DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application is being examined under the pre-AIA first to invent provisions.
Continued Examination Under 37 CFR 1.114
A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114. Applicant's submission filed on 05 May 2026 has been entered.
Formal Matters
Applicant’s claim amendments and arguments filed on 05 May 2026 are acknowledged and have been fully considered due to the entered request for continued examination. Claims 1, 8-16, and 21-31 are pending. Claims 1, 8-15, 21, and newly added claims 22-30 are under consideration in the instant office action. Claims 16 and 31 are withdrawn from further consideration pursuant to 37 CFR 1.142(b) as being drawn to a nonelected invention, there being no allowable generic or linking claims. Claims 2-7 and 17-20 are canceled. Claims 22-31 are newly added.
Withdrawn Objections/Rejections
Rejections and/or objections not reiterated from the previous office actions are hereby withdrawn as are those rejections and/or objections expressly stated to be withdrawn.
Rejections-Maintained
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103(a) which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
(a) A patent may not be obtained through the invention is not identically disclosed or described as set forth in section 102 of this title, if the differences between the subject matter sought to be patented and the prior art are such that the subject matter as a whole would have been obvious at the time the invention was made to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which said subject matter pertains. Patentability shall not be negatived by the manner in which the invention was made.
This application currently names joint inventors. In considering patentability of the claims under 35 U.S.C. 103(a), the examiner presumes that the subject matter of the various claims was commonly owned at the time any inventions covered therein were made absent any evidence to the contrary. Applicant is advised of the obligation under 37 CFR 1.56 to point out the inventor and invention dates of each claim that was not commonly owned at the time a later invention was made in order for the examiner to consider the applicability of 35 U.S.C. 103(c) and potential 35 U.S.C. 102(e), (f) or (g) prior art under 35 U.S.C. 103(a).
The factual inquiries set forth in Graham v. John Deere Co., 383 U.S. 1, 148 USPQ 459 (1966), that are applied for establishing a background for determining obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103(a) are summarized as follows:
1. Determining the scope and contents of the prior art.
2. Ascertaining the differences between the prior art and the claims at issue.
3. Resolving the level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art.
4. Considering objective evidence present in the application indicating obviousness or nonobviousness
Claims 1, 8-15, 2, and newly added claims 22-30 are rejected under pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 103(a) as being unpatentable over LUKAS (WO 2006/045152, previously cited) in view of Ortyl et al. (US Patent No. 5,738,872, previously cited) and Miller et al. (US 4166107, previously cited).
Note: The claims are examined limiting the composition to the elected species active which is methoprene.
Applicant Claims
Applicant claims “A feed-through sustained-release insecticide composition comprising: (a) an active ingredient, which is from about 0.1% to about 5% methoprene, (b) a wax-like agent, which is from about 5% to about 30% hydrogenated vegetable oil; and (c) a spheronizing agent, which is from about 5% to about 30% microcrystalline cellulose; wherein the feed-through insecticide composition is in the form of pellets dried and heated at a temperature exceeding the melting point of the wax-like agent and is sustained release for a prolonged duration, which duration is selected from the group consisting of 1, 2, and 3 days, wherein the composition is combined with animal feed.” Dependent claims thereof recite further limitations describing different features. Claim 22 recites “A feed-through sustained-release insecticide composition comprising: (a) an active ingredient, which is from about 0.1% to about 5% methoprene; (b) a wax-like agent, which is from about 5% to about 30% hydrogenated vegetable oil; and (c) a spheronizing agent, which is from about 5% to about 30% microcrystalline cellulose; wherein a ratio of the wax-like agent to the spheronizing agent is from about 3:1 to about 1:1 by weight, wherein the feed-through insecticide composition is in the form of pellets and is sustained release for a prolonged duration, which duration is selected from the group consisting of 1, 2, and 3 days, wherein the spheronizing agent is homogeneously distributed throughout the pellets, and wherein the composition is combined with animal feed.” Dependent claims thereof recite further limitations describing different features.
Determination of the Scope and Content of the Prior Art (MPEP §2141.01)
LUKAS teaches a process for producing a compressed solid dosage form containing an active ingredient. The process includes a step of preparing core elements containing the active ingredient. Optionally the core elements are coated with a pharmaceutically acceptable coating layer to form coated pellets. The core elements or pellets are treated with an anti-static agent and compressed with suitable excipients to form the compressed solid dosage form. Preferred anti-static agents are starch, microcrystalline cellulose, kaolin, bentonite, silicates, silicon dioxide, cellulose, stearic acid, sodium stearyl fumarate and glyceryl behenate (see abstract). The present invention is primarily concerned with compressed solid dosage forms such as tablets. A build up of static charge is a significant problem during tablet formation using the processes just described. The build up of static charge during core element or pellet formation can interfere with handling and processing of the core elements or pellets. For example, it is generally necessary to remove both over and under size pellets by sieving, and a build up of static charge can interfere with the flowability of the core elements or pellets being sieved. It is also important that the flow of core elements or pellets between a hopper containing the core elements or pellets and a tablet press is uniform and predictable and a build up of static charge can interfere with that flow (see pages 1-2). The present invention provides processes for producing core elements and pellets that can be used to form tablets but which reduce problems associated with a build up of static charge during core element and pellet formation and subsequent processing. The processes of the invention do not adversely affect tablet formation (see page 2). A process for producing a compressed solid dosage form containing an active ingredient, the process including:
- preparing core elements containing the active ingredient,
- optionally coating the core elements with a pharmaceutically acceptable coating layer to form coated pellets,
- treating the core elements or pellets with an anti-static agent, and
- compressing the treated core elements or pellets with suitable excipients to form the compressed solid dosage form, wherein the hardness of the compressed solid dosage form is greater for a given compression force than an equivalent solid dosage form in which the core elements or pellets have been treated with talc (see claim 1). In a preferred form of the invention, the anti-static agent is admixed with the core elements or pellets in particulate form. Most preferably, the anti-static agent is in powdered form. The anti-static agent may be added manually or it may be added in an air stream. In the case of a powdered anti-static agent, the step of treating the core elements or pellets with the anti-static agent may also be referred to as dusting the core elements or pellets (see page 4). The anti-static agent used in the process of the present invention may be any inorganic or organic solid that reduces static but still allows cohesion between core elements or pellets and excipients in the solid dosage form in order for it to retain strength and structure. Materials having anti-static properties may be in a powdered form (i.e. a particle size less than about 250 microns) and be pharmaceutically acceptable. Examples of suitable materials may include, but not be limited to, polysaccharides, minerals, clays, organic acids, silicates, silicon dioxide, stearates, fumarates, and glyceryl esters. Preferably, the anti-static agent is selected from the list including starch, microcrystalline cellulose, kaolin, bentonite, magnesium trisilicate, aluminium trisilicate, silicon dioxide, cellulose, stearic acid, sodium stearyl fumarate, and glyceryl behenate (see page 4). The term "active ingredient" will be widely understood and denotes a compound having a beneficial effect when introduced into a system such as a biological system. For example, the active ingredient may be a biologically active compound for introduction into a human, animal, plant, water body or soil strata. Examples of biologically active compounds for this purpose include pharmaceutically active ingredients and agrochemicals. Exemplary agrochemicals include fertilisers, nutrients, pesticides, fungicides and algaecides. Pharmaceutically active ingredients include any compound that provides prophylactic and/or therapeutic properties when administered to, for example, humans. Examples include, but are not limited to, pharmaceutical actives, therapeutic actives, veterinarial actives, nutraceuticals, and growth regulators. Reference in this specification to a specific active ingredient is also to be understood to include the active ingredient in the form of acid addition salts, solvates, hydrates and the like (see pages 6-7). As used herein, the term "core element" will be understood to mean un-coated particles containing a mixture of one or more active ingredients and excipients. These may be produced by, for example, granulation or spray drying of mixtures of active ingredients and excipients, or by applying a layer of the active ingredient over inert cores. The term "pellets" as used herein will be understood to mean coated core elements. Typically, the coating will be a modified release coating. It will be appreciated that the process of the present invention may be applied to core elements and/or pellets (see page 7). As described previously, the present invention provides a process for producing compressed solid dosage forms containing an active ingredient. To produce compressed solid dosage forms, such as tablets, a mixture containing an active ingredient (eg. a drug) and excipients may be granulated to form core elements. The granulation process may be a "wet granulation" process which means that water or other solvent is used in the granulation step. An alternative process for producing a core element is to apply a layer of active ingredient over inert cores. The layer of active ingredient may be applied by spraying a solution of the active ingredient onto the inert cores. A drying step may be used to remove some or all of the solvent from the core element (see page 8). The core elements formed by either of these processes may be incorporated directly into a solid dosage form or they may first be coated with a pharmaceutically acceptable coating layer to form pellets. This coating step may be performed to confer controlled release or other properties onto the pellets. Thus, the core elements to be coated may be suspended in an air stream while a coating material (usually dissolved or suspended in a suitable liquid vehicle or solvent) is atomised onto the core elements to form the coated pellets. A drying step may be used to remove some or all of the solvent from the pellets (the examiner notes that since the pellets remain viable and intact the drying step did not damage the wax-like agent or the active). One of ordinary skill in the art would easily understand that a temperature which is used for drying is not higher than the melting point of the active agent or other ingredients used in the formulation process because the pellets were clearly found to be useful for the intended purpose of delivering insecticides. The core elements or pellets thus formed are then incorporated into the solid dosage form. In the case of a tablet, they may be blended with tablet excipients and then pressed into the form of a tablet. The core elements or pellets are preferably treated with an anti-static agent at or after a drying step to reduce accumulated static charge or to prevent or reduce accumulation of static charge (see page 8). The first step in the process of the present invention is the preparation of core elements containing the active ingredient. In a preferred embodiment, this involves a process of granulation, extrusion, and marumerisation using the active ingredient and suitable excipients to form a plurality of core elements containing the active ingredient. An alternative is to apply a layer of the active ingredient onto inert cores to form core elements containing the active ingredient. To form the core elements consecutive steps of wet granulation, extrusion and marumerisation are described herein (see Example 1 ). However, the person skilled in the art will appreciate that any of a number of techniques may be used, such as spheronisation onto seed cores, or rotogranulation (see page 9). The active ingredient may be present in the core element in any suitable amount, and for instance may be provided in an amount from 5 to 95% by weight, preferably from 20 to 80% by weight, based on the total weight of the core element. The active ingredient may be embodied within and through the core element, combined with or without the normal excipients, additives and fillers. Preferably, the core elements each have a diameter in the range of 50 microns to 1700 microns. In one particularly preferred form of the invention the core elements each have a diameter in the range of 500 microns to 1000 microns. The core elements may contain any suitable or required additives, such as excipients, fillers or other ingredients. For example, modified release core elements may be formed by granulating the active ingredient with insoluble materials such as waxes or insoluble polymers (see page 10). The core elements may be coated with a coating to form pellets. A coating may be applied for a number of reasons, such as, masking a bitter taste, or altering the rate of release (dissolution) of the active ingredient. Preferably, the core elements are coated to provide a modified release profile. The modified release coating may be any suitable coating material, or combination of coating materials, that will provide a desired modified release profile. For example, coatings such as enteric coatings, semi-enteric coatings, delayed release coatings or pulsed release coatings may be desired. A mixture of enteric polymers may be used to produce a modified release coating. It is possible to use a mixture of enteric polymer with a water permeable, water swellable or water-soluble material such as polyvinylpyrrolidone, hydroxypropyl cellulose, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose, polyethylene glycol having a molecular weight of from 1700 to 20,000, or a mixture thereof. The coating could also be a water- insoluble material, such as ethylcellulose, and/or enteric polymers such as cellulose acetate phthlate, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose phthalate (HPMCP), polyvinyl acetate phthalate, methacrylic acid copolymer, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose acetate succinate, shellac, cellulose acetate trimellitate, or a mixture thereof. In particular, materials such as hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose, hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose phthalate of varying grades and also as an aqueous dispersion, Eudragit® L100-55, Eudragit® L30D, and hydroxypropylmethyl cellulose acetate succinate may be used to form the modified release coating. The coating may also contain plasticisers such as triethyl citrate, diethyl phthalate or dibutyl sebacate (see page 11). Either during or directly after either of the aforementioned drying steps, the core elements or pellets are treated with an anti-static agent, such as starch or magnesium trisilicate, to reduce accumulated static charge or to prevent or reduce accumulation of static charge during processing and handling of the core elements or pellets. The anti-static agent is an organic or inorganic solid that reduces static without substantially affecting compressibility of a blend containing core elements or pellets to which it has been added. Preferably, the anti-static agent is selected from the list including starch, microcrystalline cellulose, kaolin, bentonite, silicates (such as magnesium trisilicate and aluminium trisilicate), silicon dioxide, cellulose, stearic acid, sodium stearyl fumarate, and glyceryl behenate (see page 12). After formation and treatment with an anti-static agent, the core elements or pellets are passed through sieves to obtain core elements or pellets of defined size range. A relatively narrow size range is desirable when a uniform rate of drug release is desirable. It depends on the individual situation, but generally, coated pellets in the range 50 microns to 2000 microns, preferably 500 to 1180 microns are desired (see page 13). Suitable tabletting excipients will be known to a person skilled in the art. The person skilled in the art will also appreciate that the proper formulation of a tablet involves balancing the need for content uniformity (i.e. making sure the same number of core elements or pellets is present in each tablet and therefore the same amount of active ingredient is present in each tablet) and the friability of any tablet that is formed as well as protection of coated pellets from fracture of the coating during the tabletting step. In this respect, if the weight ratio of core elements or pellets to excipients is too low, there will be problems with content uniformity, while if the weight ratio of core elements or pellets is too high there will not be enough tabletting excipients to cushion the core elements or pellets during compression into a tablet and the structural integrity of the core elements or pellets could be compromised. Also, if the amount of excipients is low the core elements or pellets are more likely to be damaged during compression and the tablets will also be weak and friable because they will not have sufficient binder to hold them together. Therefore the percentage of core elements or pellets in each tablet is ideally in the range of 20 to 50% (more preferably 25 to 35%, but most preferably about 30%) by weight of the total dosage weight (see pages 14-15). It will also be appreciated that the tablets may include a range of traditional additives such as disintegrants, diluents, fillers, lubricants, glidants, colourants and flavours in addition to the anti-static agent used in the treating step. For example, suitable disintegrants may be those that have a large coefficient of expansion, and examples may include crosslinked polymers such as crospovidone (crosslinked polyvinylpyrrolidone) and croscarmellose (crosslinked sodium carboxymethylcellulose). Also, it will be appreciated that it may be advantageous to add to a dosage form an inert substance such as a diluent or filler. A variety of materials may be used as diluents or fillers, and examples may be lactose, starch, sucrose, dextrose, mannitol, sorbitol, microcrystalline cellulose, and others known in the art, and mixtures thereof. Lubricants and glidants may be employed in the manufacture of certain dosage forms, and will usually be employed when producing tablets. Examples of lubricants and glidants are hydrogenated vegetable oils, magnesium stearate, stearic acid, sodium lauryl sulfate, magnesium lauryl sulfate, colloidal silica, talc, mixtures thereof, and others known in the art. Additives such as colouring agents and pigments may also be added to dosage forms in accordance with the present invention, and suitable colouring agents and pigments may include titanium dioxide and dyes suitable for food. The strength of the tablet of the present invention (measurement with a tablet hardness tester) is usually about 1 to 20 kiloponds (kp), preferably about 5 to 15 kp, more preferably 7 to 15 kp, although it will be appreciated that these hardness values are dependent to some extent on the physical dimensions of the tablet (see pages 15-16).
Ascertainment of the Difference between Scope the Prior Art and the Claims
(MPEP §2141.012)
LUKAS does not explicitly teach pregelatinized starch and its amounts; the amounts of microcrystalline cellulose ; and the incorporation of hydrogenated vegetable oil and its amounts. These deficiencies are cured by the teachings of Ortyl et al.
Ortyl et al. teach a pharmaceutical composition in solid unit dosage form, comprising, a) a therapeutically effective amount of a piperidinoalkanol compound or a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof; and, b) at least one inert ingredient (see abstract). Efforts have focused on improving the bioavailability of various piperidinoalkanol compounds in order to improve their therapeutic efficiency. The present invention relates to pharmaceutical compositions and pharmaceutical compositions in solid unit dosage form wherein the piperidinoalkanol compound, or a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof, is in combination with inert ingredients (column 1, lines 45-52). As used herein the term "inert ingredient" refers to those therapeutically inert ingredients that are well known in the art of pharmaceutical science which can be used singly or in various combinations, and include, for example, binders, diluents, lubricants, glidants, sweetening agents, disintegrants, coloring agents, flavoring agents, antioxidants, solubilizing agents, coating agents and the like, as are disclosed in The United States Pharmacopeia, XXII, 1990, (1989 The United States Pharmacopeial Convention, Inc.), pages 1857-1859, which is incorporated herein by reference. For example, the following inert ingredients can be utilized singly or in various combinations; binders such as gelatin, polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), pregelatinized starch, povidone, cellulose derivatives including methyl cellulose, carboxymethyl cellulose, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC), hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC), sucrose and the like; diluents such as calcium carbonate, lactose, starch, microcrystalline cellulose, and the like; lubricants such as magnesium stearate, calcium stearate, zinc stearate, stearic acid, talc, hydrogenated vegetable oil and the like; glidants such as silicon dioxide, talc and the like; disintegrants such as alginic acid, methacrylic acid DVB, cross-linked PVP, microcrystalline cellulose, croscarmellose sodium, crospovidone, polacrilin potassium, sodium starch glycolate, starch, pregelatinized starch and the like; preferred disintegrants are croscarmellose sodium, starch, pregelatinized starch and sodium starch glycolate with croscarmellose sodium being the most preferred disintegrant; sweetening agents; coloring agents; flavoring agents; antioxidants; and the like. The above inert ingredients can be present in amounts up to about 95% of the total composition weight (column 13, lines 15-46).
A suitable combination of inert ingredients comprises microcrystalline cellulose, pregelatinized starch, gelatin, magnesium stearate, calcium carbonate and sodium starch glycolate, in amounts of from about 20% to about 85%, 5% to about 50%, 1% to about 15%, 0.05% to about 3%, 5% to about 50%, and 1% to about 15%. A preferred combination of inert ingredients is microcrystalline cellulose, pregelatinized starch, calcium carbonate, magnesium stearate and sodium starch glycolate in amounts of from about 20% to about 85%, 5% to about 50%, 5% to about 50%, 0.05% to about 3%, and 1% to about 15%. Another preferred combination of inert ingredients comprises: microcrystalline cellulose, pregelatinized starch, magnesium stearate, and croscarmellose sodium in amounts of from about, 20% to about 85%, 5% to about 50%, 0.05 to about 3%, 1% to about 10%. The most preferred combination of inert ingredients is croscarmellose sodium, microcrystalline cellulose, lactose, pregelatinized starch and gelatin, in amounts of from about 1% to about 10%, 20% to about 85%, 20% to about 85%, 1% to about 30% and 1% to about 15% respectively. The most especially preferred combination of inert ingredients is croscarmellose sodium, microcrystalline cellulose, lactose, pregelatinized starch, gelatin and magnesium stearate, in amounts of from about 1% to about 10%, 20% to about 85%, 20% to about 85%, 1% to about 30%, 1% to about 15% and 0.05% to about 3% respectively. The following entries 1 through 7 in Table 5, provide the most preferred amounts of the respective inert ingredients which can be utilized in preparation of the tablet or capsule dosage forms (column 13, lines 47-67 and column 14, lines 1-8).
LUKAS and Ortyl et al. do not specifically teach Methoprene as the active ingredient and its amounts and the composition being combined with animal feed. These deficiencies are cured by Miller et al.
Miller et al. teach compositions of insect regulators comprising monostearin, carnuba wax, barium sulfate, methoprene, and diflubenzuron are selectively formulated into a sustained-release bolus and orally administered to livestock to control the larvacidal activity of arthropods in the manure of the livestock (see abstract). A sustained release bolus formulation for the control of arthropods in cattle manure, said formulation comprising the following composition: about 4-17 parts monostearin, about 4-10 parts carnuba wax, about 70-75 parts Barium Sulfate, and about 1-15 parts Methoprene (claim 1). Repeated treatment of livestock is expensive in terms of both labor and insecticide. To compensate for rapid degradation of the pesticides on animals, the producer must apply larger quantities than are necessary for control of the immediate population if toxic levels are to be maintained for any length of time. Such a practice is wasteful of insecticide, results in greater contamination to the environment, and increases the probability of toxicity to animals and of residues in animal products. Therefore, one of the objectives of studies conducted at the U.S. Livestock Insects Laboratory, Kerrville, Tex., is to develop techniques that will make it possible to maintain the minimum effective level of toxicant on livestock over an extended period and thereby to increase the efficacy, efficiency, and safety of livestock pest control. This report deals with our efforts to use controlled-release technology against horn flies, Haematobia irritans (L.), common cattle grubs, Hypoderma lineatum (De Villers), and face fly, Musca autumnalis (DeGeer). Boluses have been used in veterinary medicine to provide nutritional and therapeutic substances to animals for predetermined periods. But, for several reasons the technique has not been used in the control of livestock pests: (1) the effective dose of most conventional insecticides is usually too large for the bolus form to be practical; (2) many insecticides are degraded by the digestive processes of the animal and by the environment; and (3) conventional insecticides can accumulate in animal tissues and thereby produce objectionable residues. However, insect growth regulators (IGR's) are chemicals of another type and might be more acceptable in a bolus than conventional insecticides. Insect growth regulators have been used successfully in the control of dung breeding pests of cattle for several years. Complete inhibition of development in manure has been achieved by administering insect growth regulators (IGR) to cattle in ground feed (Harris et al, 1973), in mineral blocks (Harris et al, 1974) and in drinking water (Beadles et al, 1975; Miller et al, 1976, 1977). Free-choice consumption and the resultant variations in dosage are inherent problems in the practical application of any of these techniques. Additionally, in some areas, animals will not consume supplemental minerals since their mineral requirements are amply met by the natural diet. The presence of untreatable sources of water (streams, rainfall) can interfere with the use of a water treatment. The use of sustained-release bolus formulations is another approach to supplying animals with small daily dosages of materials. Boluses have been used in animal husbandry to provide nutritional and therapeutic substances such as trace elements, antibiotics, anthelmintics, animal hormones, and growth stimulants over predetermined periods of time. The prior art for these dosages forms is adequately described in patent literature such as, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 3,056,724 (Marston 1962), U.S. Pat. No. 3,507,952 (Rednick and Tucker 1970) and U.S. Pat. No. 3,535,419 (Siegrist and Katz 1970). However, bolus dosage forms have not been used in the control of livestock arthropods because the effective dosage of most conventional insecticides is usually too large to make the bolus form practical, many insecticides are destroyed by digestive process and environment, and conventional insecticides are often accumulated in animal tissues and, thereby produce undesirable residues. The use of sustained-release bolus formulations to administer insect growth regulators for the control of livestock pests overcomes many of the aforementioned problems associated with ad lib treatments. Additionally, the efficacy and relative safety to insect growth regulators enables the use of the bolus treatment for long-lasting control measures (see entire column 1 and 2).
Finding of Prima Facie Obviousness Rationale and Motivation
(MPEP §2142-2143)
It would have been prima facie obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the time the claimed invention was made to modify the teachings of LUKAS via incorporating pregelatinized starch, microcrystalline cellulose, and hydrogenated vegetable oil in amounts as recited respectively because Ortyl et al. teach a pharmaceutical composition in solid unit dosage form, comprising, a) a therapeutically effective amount of a piperidinoalkanol compound or a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof; and, b) at least one inert ingredient (see abstract). Efforts have focused on improving the bioavailability of various piperidinoalkanol compounds in order to improve their therapeutic efficiency. The present invention relates to pharmaceutical compositions and pharmaceutical compositions in solid unit dosage form wherein the piperidinoalkanol compound, or a pharmaceutically acceptable salt thereof, is in combination with inert ingredients (column 1, lines 45-52). As used herein the term "inert ingredient" refers to those therapeutically inert ingredients that are well known in the art of pharmaceutical science which can be used singly or in various combinations, and include, for example, binders, diluents, lubricants, glidants, sweetening agents, disintegrants, coloring agents, flavoring agents, antioxidants, solubilizing agents, coating agents and the like, as are disclosed in The United States Pharmacopeia, XXII, 1990, (1989 The United States Pharmacopeial Convention, Inc.), pages 1857-1859, which is incorporated herein by reference. For example, the following inert ingredients can be utilized singly or in various combinations; binders such as gelatin, polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP), pregelatinized starch, povidone, cellulose derivatives including methyl cellulose, carboxymethyl cellulose, hydroxypropyl methylcellulose (HPMC), hydroxypropyl cellulose (HPC), sucrose and the like; diluents such as calcium carbonate, lactose, starch, microcrystalline cellulose, and the like; lubricants such as magnesium stearate, calcium stearate, zinc stearate, stearic acid, talc, hydrogenated vegetable oil and the like; glidants such as silicon dioxide, talc and the like; disintegrants such as alginic acid, methacrylic acid DVB, cross-linked PVP, microcrystalline cellulose, croscarmellose sodium, crospovidone, polacrilin potassium, sodium starch glycolate, starch, pregelatinized starch and the like; preferred disintegrants are croscarmellose sodium, starch, pregelatinized starch and sodium starch glycolate with croscarmellose sodium being the most preferred disintegrant; sweetening agents; coloring agents; flavoring agents; antioxidants; and the like. The above inert ingredients can be present in amounts up to about 95% of the total composition weight (column 13, lines 15-46). One of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to do so because Ortyl et al. teach that a suitable combination of inert ingredients comprises microcrystalline cellulose, pregelatinized starch, gelatin, magnesium stearate, calcium carbonate and sodium starch glycolate, in amounts of from about 20% to about 85%, 5% to about 50%, 1% to about 15%, 0.05% to about 3%, 5% to about 50%, and 1% to about 15%. A preferred combination of inert ingredients is microcrystalline cellulose, pregelatinized starch, calcium carbonate, magnesium stearate and sodium starch glycolate in amounts of from about 20% to about 85%, 5% to about 50%, 5% to about 50%, 0.05% to about 3%, and 1% to about 15%. Another preferred combination of inert ingredients comprises: microcrystalline cellulose, pregelatinized starch, magnesium stearate, and croscarmellose sodium in amounts of from about, 20% to about 85%, 5% to about 50%, 0.05 to about 3%, 1% to about 10%. The most preferred combination of inert ingredients is croscarmellose sodium, microcrystalline cellulose, lactose, pregelatinized starch and gelatin, in amounts of from about 1% to about 10%, 20% to about 85%, 20% to about 85%, 1% to about 30% and 1% to about 15% respectively. The most especially preferred combination of inert ingredients is croscarmellose sodium, microcrystalline cellulose, lactose, pregelatinized starch, gelatin and magnesium stearate, in amounts of from about 1% to about 10%, 20% to about 85%, 20% to about 85%, 1% to about 30%, 1% to about 15% and 0.05% to about 3% respectively. The following entries 1 through 7 in Table 5, provide the most preferred amounts of the respective inert ingredients which can be utilized in preparation of the tablet or capsule dosage forms (column 13, lines 47-67 and column 14, lines 1-8). It should be noticed that these are conventionally known inert pharmaceutical ingredients that are useful to all classes of actives taught by LUKAS. The selection of a known material based on its suitability for its intended use supported a prima facie obviousness determination in Sinclair & Carroll Co. v. Interchemical Corp., 325 U.S. 327, 65 USPQ 297 (1945) (Claims to a printing ink comprising a solvent having the vapor pressure characteristics of butyl carbitol so that the ink would not dry at room temperature but would dry quickly upon heating were held invalid over a reference teaching a printing ink made with a different solvent that was nonvolatile at room temperature but highly volatile when heated in view of an article which taught the desired boiling point and vapor pressure characteristics of a solvent for printing inks and a catalog teaching the boiling point and vapor pressure characteristics of butyl carbitol. "Reading a list and selecting a known compound to meet known requirements is no more ingenious than selecting the last piece to put in the last opening in a jig-saw puzzle." 325 U.S. at 335, 65 USPQ at 301.). Furthermore, in the case where the claimed ranges for amount of ingredients and active and also particle sizes “overlap or lie inside ranges disclosed by the prior art” a prima facie case of obviousness exists. In re Wertheim, 541 F.2d 257, 191 USPQ 90 (CCPA 1976); In re Woodruff, 919 F.2d 1575, 16 USPQ2d 1934 (Fed. Cir. 1990). Additionally, differences in concentration will not support the patentability of subject matter encompassed by the prior art unless there is evidence indicating such concentration is critical. “[W]here the general conditions of a claim are disclosed in the prior art, it is not inventive to discover the optimum or workable ranges by routine experimentation.” In re Aller, 220 F.2d 454, 456, 105 USPQ 233, 235 (CCPA 1955). Similarly, a prima facie case of obviousness exists where the claimed ranges or amounts do not overlap with the prior art but are merely close. Titanium Metals Corp. of America v. Banner, 778 F.2d 775, 783, 227 USPQ 773, 779 (Fed. Cir. 1985). The skilled artisan would have had a reasonable chance of expectation of success in combining the teachings of LUKAS and Ortyl et al. because both references teach sustained or controlled release delivery of actives through solid dosage forms.
It would have been prima facie obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the time the claimed invention was made to modify the sustained (controlled) release dosage form of LUKAS and Ortyl et al. for the delivery of Methoprene because Miller et al. teach compositions of insect regulators comprising monostearin, carnuba wax, barium sulfate, methoprene, and diflubenzuron are selectively formulated into a sustained-release bolus and orally administered to livestock to control the larvacidal activity of arthropods in the manure of the livestock (see abstract). A sustained release bolus formulation for the control of arthropods in cattle manure, said formulation comprising the following composition: about 4-17 parts monostearin, about 4-10 parts carnuba wax, about 70-75 parts Barium Sulfate, and about 1-15 parts Methoprene (claim 1). One of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated to do so because first LUKAS teach that its formulation is useful to deliver a compound having a beneficial effect when introduced into a system such as a biological system. For example, the active ingredient may be a biologically active compound for introduction into a human, animal, plant, water body or soil strata. Examples of biologically active compounds for this purpose include pharmaceutically active ingredients and agrochemicals. Exemplary agrochemicals include fertilisers, nutrients, pesticides, fungicides and algaecides. Pharmaceutically active ingredients include any compound that provides prophylactic and/or therapeutic properties when administered to, for example, humans. Examples include, but are not limited to, pharmaceutical actives, therapeutic actives, veterinarial actives, nutraceuticals, and growth regulators. Reference in this specification to a specific active ingredient is also to be understood to include the active ingredient in the form of acid addition salts, solvates, hydrates and the like (see pages 6-7). Furthermore, Miller et al. teach that repeated treatment of livestock is expensive in terms of both labor and insecticide. To compensate for rapid degradation of the pesticides on animals, the producer must apply larger quantities than are necessary for control of the immediate population if toxic levels are to be maintained for any length of time. Such a practice is wasteful of insecticide, results in greater contamination to the environment, and increases the probability of toxicity to animals and of residues in animal products. Therefore, one of the objectives of studies conducted at the U.S. Livestock Insects Laboratory, Kerrville, Tex., is to develop techniques that will make it possible to maintain the minimum effective level of toxicant on livestock over an extended period and thereby to increase the efficacy, efficiency, and safety of livestock pest control. This report deals with our efforts to use controlled-release technology against horn flies, Haematobia irritans (L.), common cattle grubs, Hypoderma lineatum (De Villers), and face fly, Musca autumnalis (DeGeer). Boluses have been used in veterinary medicine to provide nutritional and therapeutic substances to animals for predetermined periods. But, for several reasons the technique has not been used in the control of livestock pests: (1) the effective dose of most conventional insecticides is usually too large for the bolus form to be practical; (2) many insecticides are degraded by the digestive processes of the animal and by the environment; and (3) conventional insecticides can accumulate in animal tissues and thereby produce objectionable residues. However, insect growth regulators (IGR's) are chemicals of another type and might be more acceptable in a bolus than conventional insecticides. Insect growth regulators have been used successfully in the control of dung breeding pests of cattle for several years. Complete inhibition of development in manure has been achieved by administering insect growth regulators (IGR) to cattle in ground feed (Harris et al, 1973), in mineral blocks (Harris et al, 1974) and in drinking water (Beadles et al, 1975; Miller et al, 1976, 1977). Free-choice consumption and the resultant variations in dosage are inherent problems in the practical application of any of these techniques. Additionally, in some areas, animals will not consume supplemental minerals since their mineral requirements are amply met by the natural diet. The presence of untreatable sources of water (streams, rainfall) can interfere with the use of a water treatment. The use of sustained-release bolus formulations is another approach to supplying animals with small daily dosages of materials. Boluses have been used in animal husbandry to provide nutritional and therapeutic substances such as trace elements, antibiotics, anthelmintics, animal hormones, and growth stimulants over predetermined periods of time. The prior art for these dosages forms is adequately described in patent literature such as, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 3,056,724 (Marston 1962), U.S. Pat. No. 3,507,952 (Rednick and Tucker 1970) and U.S. Pat. No. 3,535,419 (Siegrist and Katz 1970). However, bolus dosage forms have not been used in the control of livestock arthropods because the effective dosage of most conventional insecticides is usually too large to make the bolus form practical, many insecticides are destroyed by digestive process and environment, and conventional insecticides are often accumulated in animal tissues and, thereby produce undesirable residues. The use of sustained-release bolus formulations to administer insect growth regulators for the control of livestock pests overcomes many of the aforementioned problems associated with ad lib treatments. Additionally, the efficacy and relative safety to insect growth regulators enables the use of the bolus treatment for long-lasting control measures (see entire column 1 and 2). Furthermore, in the case where the claimed ranges for amount of ingredients and active and also particle sizes “overlap or lie inside ranges disclosed by the prior art” a prima facie case of obviousness exists. In re Wertheim, 541 F.2d 257, 191 USPQ 90 (CCPA 1976); In re Woodruff, 919 F.2d 1575, 16 USPQ2d 1934 (Fed. Cir. 1990). Additionally, differences in concentration will not support the patentability of subject matter encompassed by the prior art unless there is evidence indicating such concentration is critical. “[W]here the general conditions of a claim are disclosed in the prior art, it is not inventive to discover the optimum or workable ranges by routine experimentation.” In re Aller, 220 F.2d 454, 456, 105 USPQ 233, 235 (CCPA 1955). Similarly, a prima facie case of obviousness exists where the claimed ranges or amounts do not overlap with the prior art but are merely close. Titanium Metals Corp. of America v. Banner, 778 F.2d 775, 783, 227 USPQ 773, 779 (Fed. Cir. 1985). The skilled artisan would have had a reasonable chance of expectation of success in combining the teachings of LUKAS, Ortyl et al., and Miller et al. because all of the references teach sustained or controlled release delivery of actives through solid dosage forms.
With regard to the limitation reciting “…, which duration is selected from the group consisting of 1, 2, or 3 days.”, it should be noticed that both LUKAS and Miller et al. are drawn to controlled or sustained release formulations. Furthermore, the combination teachings of LUKAS, Ortyl et al., and Miller et al. met the claimed composition. Hence, all pharmacokinetic or pharmacodynamic profiles Applicant recites would necessarily be there. “[I]nherency may supply a missing claim limitation in an obviousness analysis." PAR, 773 F.3d at 1194-1195 ; see also Endo Pharms. Sols., Inc. v. Custopharm Inc., 894 F.3d 1374 , 1381 , 127 U.S.P.Q.2D (BNA) 1409 (Fed. Cir. 2018) ("An inherent characteristic of a formulation can be part of the prior art in an obviousness analysis even if the inherent characteristic was unrecognized or unappreciated by a skilled artisan."). It is long settled that in the context of obviousness, the "mere recitation of a newly discovered function or property, inherently possessed by things in the prior art, does not distinguish a claim drawn to those things from the prior art." In re Oelrich, 666 F.2d 578 , 581 (C.C.P.A. 1981). The Supreme Court explained long ago that "[i]t is not invention to perceive that the product which others had discovered had qualities they failed to detect." Gen. Elec. Co. v. Jewel Incandescent Lamp Co., 326 U.S. 242 , 249 , 66 S. Ct. 81 , 90 L. Ed. 43 , 1946 Dec. Comm'r Pat. 611 (1945). We too have previously explained that "an obvious formulation cannot become nonobvious simply by administering it to a patient and claiming the resulting serum concentrations," because "[t]o hold otherwise would allow any formulation—no matter how obvious—to become patentable merely by testing and claiming an inherent property." Santarus, Inc. v. Par Pharm., Inc., 694 F.3d 1344 , 1354 (Fed. Cir. 2012). In In re Kao, we found that the claimed controlled-release oxymorphone formulation was obvious because an inherent pharmacokinetic property of oxymorphone that was present in controlled-release oxymorphone "add[ed] nothing of patentable consequence." In re Huai-Hung Kao, 639 F.3d 1057 , 1070 , 98 U.S.P.Q.2D (BNA) 1799 (Fed. Cir. 2011). In In re Kubin, we found an inherent property obvious, explaining that "[e]ven if no prior art of record explicitly discusses the [limitation], the . . . application itself instructs that [the limitation] is not an additional requirement imposed by the claims on the [claimed protein], but rather a property necessarily present in [the claimed protein]." In re Kubin, 561 F.3d 1351 , 1357 , 90 U.S.P.Q.2D (BNA) 1417 (Fed. Cir. 2009). Our predecessor court similarly concluded that it "is not the law" that "a structure suggested by the prior art, and, hence, potentially in the possession of the public, is patentable . . . because it also possesses an [i]nherent, but hitherto unknown, function which [the patentees] claim to have discovered." In re [*1191] Wiseman, 596 F.2d 1019 , 1023 (C.C.P.A. 1979). Inherency, however, is a "high standard," that is "carefully circumscribed in the context of obviousness." PAR, 773 F.3d at 1195 . Inherency "may not be established by probabilities or possibilities," and "[t]he mere fact that a certain thing may result from a given set of circumstances is not sufficient." Oelrich, 666 F.2d at 581 (emphasis added) (quoting Hansgirg v. Kemmer, 102 F.2d 212 , 214 , 26 C.C.P.A. 937 , 1939 Dec. Comm'r Pat. 327 (C.C.P.A. 1939); see also In re Rijckaert, 9 F.3d 1531 , 1533-1534 (Fed. Cir. 1993). Rather, inherency renders a claimed limitation obvious only if the limitation is "necessarily present," or is "the natural result of the combination of elements explicitly disclosed by the prior art." PAR, 773 F.3d at 119511 -96; see also Alcon Research, Ltd. v. Apotex Inc., 687 F.3d 1362 , 1369 (Fed. Cir. 2012) (relying on inherency where the claims recited "a property that is necessarily present" in the prior art). "If . . . the disclosure is sufficient to show that the natural result flowing from the operation as taught would result in the performance of the questioned function, it seems to be well settled that the disclosure should be regarded as sufficient" to render the function inherent. Oelrich, 666 F.2d at 581 (quoting Hansgirg v. Kemmer, 102 F.2d 212 , 214 , 26 C.C.P.A. 937 , 1939 Dec. Comm'r Pat. 327 (C.C.P.A. 1939)). On appeal, Persion contends that the district court erred in applying the inherency doctrine in its obviousness analysis because Devane does not teach administering its hydrocodone-only formulation to patients with mild or moderate hepatic impairment. Thus, Persion asserts, "'the natural result flowing from the operation as taught' in Devane cannot be the claimed [pharmacokinetic] values for [hepatically impaired] patients." Appellant's Br. 37 (quoting Oelrich, 666 F.2d at 581 ); Reply Br. 19. To the extent Persion contends that inherency can only satisfy a claim limitation when all other limitations are taught in a single reference, that position is contrary to our prior recognition that "inherency may supply a missing claim limitation in an obviousness analysis" where the limitation at issue is "the natural result of the combination of prior art elements." PAR, 773 F.3d at 1194-1195 (emphasis added, internal quotations omitted). Here, the district court specifically found that Devane, together with Jain, the state of the prior art at the time of invention, and the Vicodin and Lortab labels, taught the combination of elements that inherently result in the claimed pharmacokinetic parameters. The district court found that a person of ordinary skill in the art would have been motivated, with reasonable expectation of success, to administer an unadjusted dose of the Devane formulation to hepatically impaired patients. There was also no dispute that the Devane formulation, which was identical to the Zohydro ER formulation described in the patents in suit, necessarily exhibited the claimed parameters under these conditions. Pernix, 323 F. Supp. 3d at 607 , 610 . In this context, the district court did not err by finding that the pharmacokinetic limitations of the asserted claims were inherent and added no patentable weight to the pharmacokinetic claims.
With regard to the preamble recitation “A feed-through sustained-release insecticide composition” it is an intended use limitation. A recitation of the intended use of the claimed invention must result in a structural difference between the claimed invention and the prior art in order to patentably distinguish the claimed invention from the prior art. If the prior art structure is capable of performing the intended use, then it meets the claim.
In light of the forgoing discussion, one of ordinary skill in the art would have concluded that the subject matter defined by the instant claims would have been obvious within the meaning of 35 USC 103(a). Therefore, the invention as a whole was prima facie obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the time the invention was made, as evidenced by the references, especially in the absence of evidence to the contrary.
Response to Arguments
Applicant's arguments filed on 05 May 2026 have been fully considered but they are not persuasive.
Applicant argues the instant specification demonstrates with clear evidence that heating the pellets to a temperature exceeding the melting point of the wax-like agent results in a specific structural transformation, which, in combination with the specifically claimed composition, enables the 1, 2, or 3-day duration. See Application as-filed, 46:14-47:5. This structural transformation is the result of "the second stage of drying, which resembles thermal annealing treatment, [and] is believed to cause a partial melting of wax-like sustained release agent in the pellets to allow for more intimate incorporation and embedment of the active ingredient." Application as-filed, 46:26-30. The transformation results in specific physical properties, i.e., "[t]he melting and congealing of the wax-like sustained release agent may also help sealing the pores in the pellets due to the removal of water and thus reduce the surface area of the pellets." Application as-filed, 46:30-47:3. Thus, the claimed duration is not inherent to the components, as "[p]ellets prepared by the same method described herein but without the second drying step exhibited significantly faster drug release (see, Example 17)." Application as-filed, 47:3-5. This structural annealing of a pre-formed pellet, and resulting release profile, distinguishes claim 1 from the cited art, which provides no teaching or suggestion of a pre-formed pellet that has been heated to achieve a release duration of 1, 2, or 3 days. Lukas modifies the release profile of the active ingredient by applying a "rate controlling membrane to the core elements" to achieve "a desired modified release profile." Lukas, 5:21 and 10:28-29. Miller relies on a singular dense body that is melted, then "poured into a preheated mold," and cast into a "rounded mass as a large pill" (bolus) designed to "have a specific gravity >1.5 in order that it might be retained in the reticulum of the cattle" for a "13-24-week period." Miller, 3:48-50, 2:66, 3:7-9. Ortyl describes standard tableting wherein the tablets are designed such that "not less than 75%" of the tablet is "dissolved in 45 minutes." Ortyl, 16:16-17 and 40-41. Thus, the cited art focuses on coated tablets (Lukas), melting components before casting a bolus with a significantly longer release profile (Miller) or a significantly shorter release profile (Ortyl), and fails to teach or suggest the structural annealed properties of a pre-formed solid pellet required to achieve the claimed release profile.
The above assertions are not found persuasive because Miller et al. teach in example 1 for example Boluses were made according to formulation A above. The monostearin and carnuba wax were melted at 100-120 °C and thoroughly blended. The methoprene was then blended into the molten mixture. Next, the barium sulfate was added and blended until a creamy mixture was obtained. The resultant molten material was poured into a preheated (100-120° C.) mold. The mold was set on a vibrating device to allow air bubbles to migrate out of the mixture. The mixture was allowed to cool at room temperature. The resultant boluses, approximately 2.3 cm. dia×7.6 cm length, were then removed from the mold. Each bolus was domed at both ends and the weight adjusted to 80 g. Miller et al. teach compositions of insect regulators comprising monostearin, carnuba wax, barium sulfate, methoprene, and diflubenzuron are selectively formulated into a sustained-release bolus and orally administered to livestock to control the larvacidal activity of arthropods in the manure of the livestock (see abstract). A sustained release bolus formulation for the control of arthropods in cattle manure, said formulation comprising the following composition: about 4-17 parts monostearin, about 4-10 parts carnuba wax, about 70-75 parts Barium Sulfate, and about 1-15 parts Methoprene (claim 1). Repeated treatment of livestock is expensive in terms of both labor and insecticide. To compensate for rapid degradation of the pesticides on animals, the producer must apply larger quantities than are necessary for control of the immediate population if toxic levels are to be maintained for any length of time. Such a practice is wasteful of insecticide, results in greater contamination to the environment, and increases the probability of toxicity to animals and of residues in animal products. Therefore, one of the objectives of studies conducted at the U.S. Livestock Insects Laboratory, Kerrville, Tex., is to develop techniques that will make it possible to maintain the minimum effective level of toxicant on livestock over an extended period and thereby to increase the efficacy, efficiency, and safety of livestock pest control. This report deals with our efforts to use controlled-release technology against horn flies, Haematobia irritans (L.), common cattle grubs, Hypoderma lineatum (De Villers), and face fly, Musca autumnalis (DeGeer). Boluses have been used in veterinary medicine to provide nutritional and therapeutic substances to animals for predetermined periods. But, for several reasons the technique has not been used in the control of livestock pests: (1) the effective dose of most conventional insecticides is usually too large for the bolus form to be practical; (2) many insecticides are degraded by the digestive processes of the animal and by the environment; and (3) conventional insecticides can accumulate in animal tissues and thereby produce objectionable residues. However, insect growth regulators (IGR's) are chemicals of another type and might be more acceptable in a bolus than conventional insecticides. Insect growth regulators have been used successfully in the control of dung breeding pests of cattle for several years. Complete inhibition of development in manure has been achieved by administering insect growth regulators (IGR) to cattle in ground feed (Harris et al, 1973), in mineral blocks (Harris et al, 1974) and in drinking water (Beadles et al, 1975; Miller et al, 1976, 1977). Free-choice consumption and the resultant variations in dosage are inherent problems in the practical application of any of these techniques. Additionally, in some areas, animals will not consume supplemental minerals since their mineral requirements are amply met by the natural diet. The presence of untreatable sources of water (streams, rainfall) can interfere with the use of a water treatment. The use of sustained-release bolus formulations is another approach to supplying animals with small daily dosages of materials. Boluses have been used in animal husbandry to provide nutritional and therapeutic substances such as trace elements, antibiotics, anthelmintics, animal hormones, and growth stimulants over predetermined periods of time. The prior art for these dosages forms is adequately described in patent literature such as, for example, U.S. Pat. No. 3,056,724 (Marston 1962), U.S. Pat. No. 3,507,952 (Rednick and Tucker 1970) and U.S. Pat. No. 3,535,419 (Siegrist and Katz 1970). However, bolus dosage forms have not been used in the control of livestock arthropods because the effective dosage of most conventional insecticides is usually too large to make the bolus form practical, many insecticides are destroyed by digestive process and environment, and conventional insecticides are often accumulated in animal tissues and, thereby produce undesirable residues. The use of sustained-release bolus formulations to administer insect growth regulators for the control of livestock pests overcomes many of the aforementioned problems associated with ad lib treatments. Additionally, the efficacy and relative safety to insect growth regulators enables the use of the bolus treatment for long-lasting control measures (see entire column 1 and 2). Miller et al involve preparation process melting the wax like agents at 100-120 C (well above the melting points of the wax like agent thoroughly blending the molten wax with Methoprene, adding filler, and casting into mold or cooling/grinding/compressing. This melting step creates an integrated, erosion controlled matrix that provides sustained release of the IGR into the digestive tract over an extended period. Release is tunable by wax ratios; higher monostearin speeds release; higher carnauba slows it. The bolus is orally administered and erodes in the reticulum, metering the active-precisely the feed through mechanism claimed. The transformation is innate result of for instance Miller et al’s process. Miller et al. teach melting wax like agents with Methoprene and then solidifying to form a sustained release matrix. Whether done before casting bolus or after pellet formation, the physical outcome is expected to be the same, the low melting hydrogenated vegetables oils flows around the active and MCC particles and resolidifies on cooling into a fused erosion resistant structure that controls release. Lukas further teaches that pellets cores can incorporate insoluble wax like materials or coatings for rate control. Heating pellets containing solid hydrogenated vegetable oils is an obvious way to ensure uniform matrix formation in situ. In response to applicant's arguments against the references individually, one cannot show nonobviousness by attacking references individually where the rejections are based on combinations of references. See In re Keller, 642 F.2d 413, 208 USPQ 871 (CCPA 1981); In re Merck & Co., 800 F.2d 1091, 231 USPQ 375 (Fed. Cir. 1986). Second, the examiner also reminds Applicant that a prior art reference must be considered in its entirety, i.e., as a whole, including portions that would lead away from the claimed invention. W.L. Gore & Assoc., Inc. v. Garlock, Inc., 721 F.2d 1540, 220 USPQ 303 (Fed. Cir. 1983), cert. denied, 469 U.S. 851 (1984).
Conclusion
No claims are allowed.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to TIGABU KASSA whose telephone number is (571)270-5867. The examiner can normally be reached 8 AM-5 PM.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, David Blanchard can be reached on 571-272-0827. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/TIGABU KASSA/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 1619