DETAILED ACTION
1. The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
2. The following office action is a Final Office Action in response to the communications received on 06/24/2026.
Claims 1, 2, 7, 8, 10 and 11 have been amended; claims 3-6, 9 and 12-16 have been canceled. Therefore, claims 1, 2, 7, 8, 10 and 11 are currently pending in this application.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
3. Non-Statutory (Directed to a Judicial Exception without an Inventive Concept/Significantly More)
35 U.S.C.101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
● Claims 1, 2, 7, 8, 10 and 11 are rejected under 35 U.S.C.101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea without significantly more.
Step 1
The current claims fall within one of the four statutory categories of invention (MPEP 2106.03).
Step 2A [Wingdings font/0xE0] Prong One:
The claim(s) recite a judicial exception, namely an abstract idea, as shown below:
— Considering claim 1 as the representative claim, the following claimed limitations recite an abstract idea:
[collect] reference experiment information from a plurality of previously performed experiments, wherein each reference experiment information comprises reagent identification and time-indexed internal environment information that was recorded during a respective previously performed experiment;
receive user location information and user experiment information, wherein the user experiment information includes identification of one or more reagents to be used in a current experiment;
determine whether the user is located in a laboratory based on the user location information;
receive location information of [a] laboratory equipment and internal environment information of the laboratory, wherein the internal environment information includes at least one or ac concentration of harmful gas, a temperature information;
retrieve reference experiment information corresponding to previously performed experiments that used the same reagent as identified in the user experiment information, wherein the reference experiment information is accumulated as experiments are continuously performed;
generate a time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information of the laboratory for each of a plurality of sequential time periods during the current experiment by a closed-loop prediction comprising:
analyzing a similarity between reagent information included in the user experiment information and reagent information included in the retrieved reference experiment information to produce a similarity coefficient,
apply the similarity coefficient to the time-indexed internal environment information of the laboratory related to the retrieved reference experiment information by scaling the measurement recorded at the corresponding time interval in the retrieved reference experiment information by the similarity coefficient to generate predicted internal environment values for each of the plurality of sequential time periods,
iii. correct the predicted internal environment values for each sequential time period with the [current] internal environment information of the laboratory as the [current] internal environment information is received during the current experiment, wherein correcting comprises computing, for each time period, a deviation between the predicted internal environment value and the corresponding [actual] measurement received during that time period, and applying the computed deviation to update the predicted internal environment values for subsequent sequential time periods;
[provide] experiment guide information to the user based on the user location information, the user experiment information, the location information of the laboratory equipment, and the time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information, wherein the experiment guide information includes:
a material safety data sheet for the one or more reagents identified in the user experiment information,
an instruction to perform the current experiment in a fume hood when it is determined, based on the time-period-specific prediction, a high-risk group harmful gas during the current experiment, and
the internal environment information of the laboratory and the time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information for the plurality of sequential time periods during the current experiment; and
[provide] access [to] the user based the user experiment information related to the reagents to be used by the user for the current experiment.
Thus, the limitations identified above recite an abstract idea since the limitations correspond to certain methods of organizing human activity, and/or mental processes, which are part of the enumerated groupings of abstract ideas identified according to the current eligibility standard (see MPEP 2106.04(a)).
For instance, the current claims correspond to managing personal behavior, such as teaching, wherein a user is provided with experiment guide information based on one or more conditions—such as: the user’s current experiment information, the user’s location, the location of a laboratory equipment, a reference experiment information, current and/or predicted internal environment information of the laboratory, etc., and furthermore, based on the analysis of the conditions above and the state of the current experiment that the user is conducting, one or more adjustments are made, including allowing—or denying—the user access to one or more materials needed for the experiment, etc.
Similarly, given the limitations that recite the process of: collecting and/or storing reference experiment information from a plurality of previously performed experiments, wherein each reference experiment information comprises reagent identification and time-indexed internal environment information that was recorded during a respective previously performed experiment; retrieving reference experiment information corresponding to previously performed experiments that used the same reagent as identified in the user experiment information; predicting a time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information of the laboratory for each of a plurality of sequential time periods during the current experiment, etc., the current claims also correspond to a mental process—i.e., a concept that can be performed in the human mind and/or using a pen and paper (e.g., an observation, an evaluation, a judgment, etc.).
Step 2A [Wingdings font/0xE0] Prong Two:
The claim(s) recite additional elements, wherein a user terminal, a laboratory equipment, a communication network, a display, (a smart table), a plurality of sensors, etc., are utilized to facilitate one or more of the recited steps regarding: storing information (e.g., “a memory storing instructions and accumulated reference experiment information from a plurality of previously performed experiments . . . information that was recorded during a respective previously performed experiment”); collecting information regarding the a user, equipment and/or environment (e.g., “receiving user location information and user experiment information from a user terminal, wherein the user experiment information includes identification of one or more reagents to be used in a current experiment; receiving, from one or more sensors, location information of laboratory equipment and real-time internal environment information of a laboratory, wherein the real-time internal environment information includes at least one of: a concentration of a harmful gas . . . and temperature information”; “retrieving, from the memory, reference experiment information corresponding to previously performed experiments that used the same reagent as identified in the user experiment information, wherein the reference experiment information is accumulated as experiments are continuously performed”); determining the user’s location based on collected information (“determining whether a user is located in the laboratory based on the user location information”); processing or analyzing collected information to generate one or more results (“generating a time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information of the laboratory for each of a plurality of sequential time periods during the current experiment by executing a closed-loop prediction process comprising: (i) analyzing a similarity between reagent information . . . (ii) applying the similarity coefficient to the time-indexed internal environment information of the laboratory related to the retrieved reference experiment information . . . (iii) correcting the predicted internal environment values for each sequential time period with the real-time internal environment information of the laboratory received from the plurality of sensors . . . and applying the computed deviation to update the predicted internal environment values for subsequent sequential time periods”); providing guidance based on the analysis result(s) of the collected information (“causing the display to generate experiment guide information to the user based on the user location information, the user experiment information, the location information of the laboratory equipment, and the time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information, wherein the experiment guide information includes a material safety data sheet for the one or more reagents identified in the user experiment information, an instruction to perform the current experiment in a fume hood when it is determined, based on the time-period-specific prediction, that a high-risk group harmful gas will be generated . . . sequential time periods during the current experiment”); controlling one or more devices (“automatically controlling operation of the laboratory equipment based on the time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information by: (a) actuating a locking device of a reagent cabinet in the laboratory to adjust an access region of the user in the reagent cabinet . . . (b) controlling at least one of a harmful gas purification device, the fume hood, and conditioning equipment to adjust air quality in the laboratory . . . and the conditioning equipment during a sequential time period preceding the identified future sequential time period . . . wherein the laboratory equipment includes the reagent cabinet, a smart table . . . wherein the automatically controlling of operation of the laboratory equipment based on the time-period-specific prediction enables preemptive adjustment of laboratory conditions . . . wherein the deviation computed in step (iii) for each sequential time period determines the sequential time period during which actuation of the laboratory equipment is initiated . . . adjust the laboratory conditions at a time that a controller actuating in response to a current real-time measurement of the internal environment cannot achieve”), etc.
However, the claimed additional elements fail to integrate the abstract idea into a practical application since the additional elements are utilized merely as a tool to facilitate the abstract idea. Thus, when each claim is considered as a whole, the additional elements fail to integrate the abstract idea into a practical application since they fail to impose meaningful limits on practicing the abstract idea. For instance, when each of the claims is considered as a whole, none of the claims provides an improvement over the relevant existing technology.
Although the claims recite one or more sensors, the sensors are utilized merely for data gathering purpose while they are expressed in high level of generality. Accordingly, such implementation is directed to insignificant extra-solution activity.
The observations above confirm that the claims are indeed directed to an abstract idea.
Step 2B
Accordingly, when the claim(s) is considered as a whole (i.e., considering all claim elements both individually and in combination), the claimed additional elements do not provide meaningful limitations to transform the abstract idea into a patent eligible application of the abstract idea such that the claim(s) amounts to “significantly more” than the abstract idea itself (also see MPEP 2106). The claimed additional elements are directed to conventional computer elements, which are serving merely to perform conventional computer functions.
Accordingly, when each of the current claims is considered as a whole (e.g., see the discussion under Prong Two above regarding such consideration of the claim as a whole), none of the claims recites an element—or a combination of elements—directed to an inventive concept.
Note also that the use of the conventional computer/network technology to facilitate the delivery of pertinent information (e.g. experiment guide, etc.) to the user, based on the analysis collected data (e.g. collected data regarding the user, the task the user is performing, the device/equipment being used to perform the task, etc.), including the process of controlling one or more of the devices utilized to perform the task, etc., is already directed to a well-understood, routine or conventional activity in the art (e.g. see US 2016/0357765; KR 10-1746515, etc.).
The above observation confirms that the current claimed invention fails to amount to “significantly more” than an abstract idea.
It is worth noting that the above analysis already encompasses each of the current dependent claims (i.e., claims 2, 7, 8, 10 and 11). Particularly, each of the dependent claims also fails to amount to “significantly more” than the abstract idea since each dependent claim is directed to a further abstract idea, and/or a further conventional computer element/function utilized to facilitate the abstract idea.
Accordingly, none of the claims, when considered as a whole, is implementing an element—or a combination of elements—directed to an inventive concept (e.g., none of the claims implements an element—or a combination of elements—that provides a technological improvement over the conventional computer/network technology).
► Applicant’s argument directed to section §101 have been fully considered (the arguments filed on 06/24/2026). However, the arguments are not persuasive at least for the following reasons:
Firstly, while attempting to summarize the limitations recited per current claim 1, Applicant has attempted to list some paragraphs ([0042], [0050] to [0053] and [0060] to [0069]), which are assumed to provide support regarding the current claimed features. However, as already pointed out below under section §112(a), the original specification as a whole does not provide sufficient support regarding the specific limitations currently claimed (e.g., see the findings presented under section §112(a) below). Thus, Applicant’s attempt to substantiate an alleged support, while simply listing a number of paragraphs that merely provide generic description, fails to negate the Office’s new matter findings. Consequently, Applicant’s conclusory assertion is not persuasive.
Note also that Applicant’s perspective regarding the interview, which was conducted on June 4, 2026 (see pages 8 and 9 of the current argument), does not address the core issue of the eligibility analysis. Instead, it appears to be Applicant’s attempt to shift Applicant’s previous argument, which was substantially relying on the machine-or-transformation test, to a new theory—namely, a technological improvement. For instance, Applicant asserts, “Much of the Office Action's reasoning rests on the proposition that, because no article is transformed, no improvement exists. Respectfully, that conflates two distinct inquiries: a claim may improve a technical field without transforming an article” (emphasis added).
However, besides mischaracterizing the Office’s previous analysis, Applicant also appears to fail to appreciate the correlation between the machine-or-transformation test and a technological improvement. As an initial matter, the Office’s previous analysis regarding the machine-or-transformation test was intended to demonstrate the flaws in Applicant’s previous argument. Applicant previously argued, “[t]he amended claims are patent-eligible under the framework established by the Supreme Court in Diamond v. Diehr, 450 U.S. 175 (1981) . . . The present invention operates on precisely the same principle . . . The result in Diehr was improved rubber manufacturing; the result here is improved laboratory safety through prevention of hazardous conditions before they develop” (see Applicant’s previous argument; namely, the second and third pages, which are labeled as pages “9” and “10” respectively, emphasis added). Of course, Applicant has also attempted to show the alleged patent-eligible transformation as follows (see the fourth page—labeled as page “11”—of Applicants argument filed on 02/09/2026, emphasis added),
“. . . physical control of equipment based on computational predictions of future states . . . Paragraphs [0042]-[0044] describe controlling ‘the harmful gas purification device, the fume hood, and the conditioning equipment’ to ‘adjust the air quality in the laboratory and the temperature of the laboratory,’ which causes physical changes to air composition, air flow patterns, and temperature. These are tangible physical transformations of the laboratory environment . . .”
Accordingly, as evident from the excerpt above, Applicant is erroneously correlating the change in the air quality and/or temperature in the room with the machine-or-transformation test. This is despite the fact that Applicant’s disclosed system is simply using off-the-shelf devices (e.g., an air purification device that others made for the desired purpose). For instance, Applicant’s disclosed system does not even contemplate, much less actually implement, any new—or advanced—air purification device. Instead, it is using existing off-the-shelf air purification device, which is already designed to purify the air in a room where the device is installed. Despite this reality, Applicant is relying on such alleged “tangible physical transformations” to substantiate the alleged eligibility of the claimed system. Of course, when responding to Applicant’s arguments, the Office demonstrated the reason why Applicant’s arguments fail to comply with the machine-or-transformation test (e.g., see the office action dated 03/26/2026: pages 17 to 18 and also page 22).
The observation above does confirm the Office’s position. In contrast, once realizing the failure of the previous argument directed to the machine-or-transformation test, Applicant appears to be now shifting to a new narrative while attempting to shield the fallout from the previous argument. Nevertheless, the prosecution history already shows Applicant’s attempt to rely on the machine-or-transformation test in order to substantiate the alleged eligibility of the claimed system.
Secondly, regarding Prong One of Step 2A, Applicant argues, “[t]he claimed closed-loop process is not a mental process . . . claim 1 requires continuous receipt of real-time sensor data during the current experiment, computation for each sequential time period of a deviation between a time-period-specific predicted value and the corresponding real-time sensor measurement . . . all in real time as the experiment proceeds and quickly enough to actuate before the predicted value reaches the threshold . . . The recited closed-loop deviation feedback, operating continuously across sequential time periods to govern the timing of physical actuation, cannot practically be performed mentally” (emphasis added).
However, once again Applicant appears to be mistaking the computer elements for an abstract idea. It is again worth nothing that Prong One of Step 2A does not require one to consider any of the claimed computer elements, which includes the alleged closed-loop process that the computer performs in order to actuate a physical device based on the analysis of data gathered from sensors in real-time, etc. In fact, even the office action acknowledges that such computer elements are not abstract idea. This is because the claimed computer elements are part of the additional elements, which are considered under Prong Two of Step 2A and Step 2B. In contrast, Prong One requires one to identify merely the limitations that recite a judicial exception—such as, an abstract idea; see MPEP 2106.07(a). In this regard, the Office’s analysis does not consider any of the additional elements as part of the abstract idea (also see above the findings presented under Prong One of Step 2A). Instead, while excluding the claimed computer elements, the Office is identifying merely the limitations that recite an abstract idea. The Office presents the following simple example for illustration purpose. For instance, claim 1 recites, among other things, the following limitations:
“ a processor configured for . . . receiving user location information and user experiment information from the user terminal, wherein the user experiment information includes identification of one or more reagents to be used in a current experiment; determining whether a user is located in the laboratory based on the user location information” (emphasis added),
Thus, when properly applying Prong One of Step 2A, one determines whether any one or more of the limitations above can practically be performed in the human mind (and/or using a pen and paper). In this regard, it is evident that a human can determine, based on collected location information of the user (e.g., the address of the laboratory where the user is currently present), whether the user is in the laboratory or not. Of course, a human can also analyze information (e.g., text and/or pictorial data) that describe reagents to be used in the current experiment, etc. Accordingly, while excluding the computer elements, one concludes that the following limitations recite an abstract idea; namely, a mental process (e.g., an observation, evaluation, and/or judgment),
receiving user location information and user experiment information, wherein the user experiment information includes identification of one or more reagents to be used in a current experiment;
determining whether a user is located in the laboratory based on the user location information;
In this regard, the processor may be more efficient than a human when performing one or more of the tasks above; however, this does not necessarily mean that such tasks cannot practically be performed in the human mind. Similarly, the claim may recite limitations that are not abstract idea—such as, the processor receiving signals from one or more sensors; however, this also does not necessarily mean that the claim is not reciting any other limitation that can practically be performed in the human mind. Note also that the same type of analysis applies to the rest of the limitations that recite the abstract idea. Consequently, Applicant’s attempt to challenge the Office’s finding under Prong One, while relying on the computer elements, is not persuasive.
Applicant further asserts, “[t]he amended claims do not direct, instruct, or modify human behavior as their focal point. Their focal point is the automatic actuation of physical equipment—the reagent cabinet locking device, the harmful gas purification device, the fume hood, and the conditioning equipment—in a time period determined by the computed deviation. Whether or not a downstream consequence is improved user safety, that does not convert closed-loop physical control into the management of human conduct” (emphasis added).
However, here also Applicant appears to fail to properly apply the inquiry under Prong One of Step 2A. In particular, Applicant is once again relying on the clamed additional elements (e.g., the automatic actuation of the cabinet locking device, or the harmful gas purification device, etc.) in order to challenge the Office’s findings under Prong One. However, once again Prong One does not require one to consider any of the claimed additional elements. Instead, Prong One requires one to consider only the limitations that recite the abstract idea—such as, the subgrouping managing personal behavior, under the group certain method of organizing human activity. The Office presents the following example for illustration purpose. Again claim 1 recites, among other things, the following limitations:
“ causing the display to generate experiment guide information to the user based on the user location information, the user experiment information, the location information of the laboratory equipment, and the time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information, wherein the experiment guide information includes: a material safety data sheet for the one or more reagents identified in the user experiment information, an instruction to perform the current experiment in a fume hood when it is determined, based on the time-period-specific prediction, that a high-risk group harmful gas will be generated during the current experiment” (emphasis added),
Accordingly, as evident from the excerpt above, the user is presented with experiment guide based on the consideration of various factors, including: the experiment that the user is performing, the laboratory equipment, etc., and the experiment guide includes: a material safety data sheet for the one or more reagents identified in the user experiment, an instruction to perform the current experiment in a fume hood when it is determined that a high-risk group harmful gas will be generated during the current experiment, etc. Thus, the experiment guide is essentially teaching the user not only about the materials—such as one or more reagents—that are needed for the current experiment, but also one or more safety procedures that the user is required to follow in order to safely conduct the experiment. Of course, once recognizing the fact above, the limitations that recite the abstract idea are identified as follows while excluding any of the additional elements:
[present] experiment guide information to the user based on the user location information, the user experiment information, the location information of the laboratory equipment, and the time-period-specific prediction of internal environment information, wherein the experiment guide information includes:
a material safety data sheet for the one or more reagents identified in the user experiment information,
an instruction to perform the current experiment in a fume hood when it is determined, based on the time-period-specific prediction, that a high-risk group harmful gas will be generated during the current experiment
Accordingly, the observation above confirms that the current claims do recite certain methods of organizing human activity—such as, managing personal behavior, even if the claims also recite limitations—such as additional elements—that do not recite an abstract idea. Consequently, here also Applicant’s attempt to challenge the Office’s finding under Prong One, while repeatedly relying on the additional elements, is not persuasive.
Thirdly, regarding Prong Two, Applicant asserts, “[t]he asserted improvement is the preemptive control result, not the accuracy of the prediction . . . The claimed improvement is a control result, not a computational one. The amended claim uses the per-time-period deviation to determine a sequential time period — one that precedes the time period in which the predicted internal environment value is predicted to exceed a threshold — in which the physical equipment is actuated, so that air quality and temperature are physically adjusted before the predicted value reaches the threshold level. As the claim expressly recites, this is a result that a controller actuating in response to a current real-time measurement cannot achieve. The improvement therefore does not reside in how accurately the processor calculates a value, and Applicant's position does not depend on characterizing the processor's internal operation as improved; the improvement resides in when, and on what basis, the physical equipment is actuated relative to a developing hazard. That is a control-architecture improvement of the kind recognized in Thales Visionix and in the Diehr line” (emphasis added).
However, besides being irrelevant to demonstrate any technological improvement, Applicant’s theory appears to suffer from a fundamental logical flaw. This is because Applicant appears to downplay the need for accuracy when making the predictions. However, if the accuracy of the prediction is poor, the system may not even preemptively control a hazardous condition from occurring. For instance, if it fails to accurately predict when a harmful gas is going to be released, it may not activate the air purification device ahead of the expected release of the gas. Of course, if it fails to do that, it also means that it fails to preemptively control the harmful gas.
Nevertheless, even assuming arguendo that the prediction is accurate, so that the system activates the air purification device before the harmful gas is released, such operation still does not demonstrate a technological improvement. This is because the claimed—and the disclosed—system is still performing the functions of the existing computer/network technology. In contrast, a technological improvement is referring to the implementation of a structural and/or a functional feature(s) that is an advance over the relevant existing technology. In particular, given the computer and/or network features implemented per the claimed (and the disclosed) system, one has to show a feature (if any)—or a combination of features (if any)—that is an advance over the existing computer/network technology. So far, except for the attempt made to portray the features of the existing technology as the alleged technological improvement, Applicant fails to show any feature—or any combination of features—that is an advance over the existing computer/network technology. This is because Applicant’s alleged technological improvement is the system’s functionality to operate, based on the analysis of collected data, a device in the room—such as air purifying device. In contrast, as already discussed in the previous office action, the process of analyzing collected and/or stored data, and subsequently automatically operating a device (e.g., a space heater; or an air purifying device, etc.) based on the result of the analysis, is already part of the existing computer/network technology, regardless of whether the data analysis above is a predictive analysis. It is further worth noting that the process of predicting one or more possible outcomes, based on the analysis of collected and/or prestored data (e.g., comparing one or more calculated values against one or more predetermined thresholds in order to make one or more predictive results), is already an abstract idea. Accordingly, even if one assumes that the above data analysis is a new concept, this does not necessarily mean a technological improvement. This is again because the core technology—namely, the process of automatically activating a given device (e.g., an air condition device, or air purifying device, etc.), based on the analysis of collected data (e.g., room temperature, air quality, a threshold, etc.), is already part of the existing computer/network technology. Accordingly, if anything, Applicant is utilizing the existing computer/network technology to facilitate a new abstract idea.
The finding above confirms that Applicant’s theories regarding the alleged technological improvement, “the physical equipment is actuated, so that air quality and temperature are physically adjusted before the predicted value reaches the threshold level . . . this is a result that a controller actuating in response to a current real-time measurement cannot achieve . . . “the improvement resides in when, and on what basis, the physical equipment is actuated relative to a developing hazard” (emphasis added), are all not persuasive. In fact, Applicant appears to confirm the existing technology that the claimed system is implementing. For instance, a healthy individual may be able to cope with a 50% deterioration in air quality; and accordingly, this individual may set a desired threshold—such as 45%, so that the air purifying device is automatically triggered when the deterioration of the air quality reaches 45%. Accordingly, based on the analysis of collected data (e.g., sensed air quality data), the device is automatically actuated even before the hazardous condition (i.e., the 50% deterioration of air quality) develops. Of course, if the individual has some health issues, such as respiratory issues, the individual may set even a lower threshold—such as, a 10% threshold. In any of the above cases, the system is constantly gathering and analyzing data; and thus, when it predicts—based on the analysis results—the potential of a hazardous condition, it automatically actuates the air purifying device.
The exemplary scenario above also confirms that Applicant claimed and disclosed system is directed merely to the existing computer/network technology. Consequently, Applicant’s alleged “control-architecture improvement” does not appear to exist.
Applicant further asserts, “[t]he claims reflect an improvement to a technical field (laboratory environmental-control systems) . . . The technical improvement here is a control-timing architecture in the field of laboratory environmental-control and safety systems. A conventional environmental controller actuates equipment in response to a current measurement that has already crossed a threshold —by which time the hazardous condition has begun to develop. The amended claims, by contrast, identify a future sequential time period in which the predicted value is predicted to exceed a threshold and initiate actuation during a time period preceding that future period, with the actuation time period being set by the per-period deviation between prediction and real-time measurement. This yields a result a reactive controller architecturally cannot produce: physical adjustment of air quality and temperature before the predicted value reaches the threshold” (emphasis added).
However, Applicant appears to be mistaking the field of use (or the technological environment) for the alleged technological improvement. It is again worth noting that the claimed/disclosed laboratory is merely signifying the field of use or environment where the existing technology is being used. Thus, triggering an air purifying device inside the laboratory, based on results calculated using sensor data and prestored laboratory information, does not constitute a technological improvement regardless of whether the results above are assumed to be predictive results.
Moreover, Applicant’s current claimed system is also relying on sensor measurements (e.g., sensor data collected regarding: temperature, air quality), including one or more predetermined thresholds, in order to determining the potential of a hazardous condition. Accordingly, except for the prestored data it analyzes in order to calculate the predictions, the crux of the controlling scheme that the claimed system is implementing is essentially the same as that of existing household air conditioning systems and/or common household air purifying devices, etc. Thus, Applicant fails to demonstrate an advanced technological feature (if any) that the claimed system is implementing when compared to the “conventional environmental controller” that Applicant is alleging. Of course, the claimed system includes additional information that relate to a laboratory (e.g., reference experiment information from a plurality of previously performed experiments, etc.). However, adding such additional information, which the system uses to calculate one or more predictive results, does not constitute a technological improvement. Accordingly, Applicant’s alleged technological improvement, the so-called “a control-timing architecture in the field of laboratory environmental-control and safety systems”, is certainly not persuasive. This is true even assuming that the calculation steps that Applicant is asserting are new (e.g., the process of “identify[ing] a future sequential time period in which the predicted value is predicted to exceed a threshold and initiate actuation during a time period preceding that future period, with the actuation time period being set by the per period deviation between prediction and real-time measurement”). In particular, except for adding a new abstract idea, the claimed calculation steps, alone or in any ordered combination with the rest of the claimed features, do provide any technological improvement over the relevant existing technology. Consequently, unlike Applicant’s assertion, neither the case of Thales Visionix nor the case of Diamond v. Diehr is analogous to any of the current claims.
Applicant has also attempted to challenge the Office’s analysis presented in the previous office action. Applicant asserts, “a household air purifier that activates when current sensor data show air quality dwindling . . . each actuates in response to a current measurement crossing a threshold. None of them (i) maintains a reference database of prior experiments indexed by reagent and time, (ii) scales a time-indexed reference measurement by a computed similarity coefficient to generate time-period-specific predictions, (iii) computes a per-time-period deviation between prediction and real-time measurement and propagates it to update later predictions, or (iv) actuates in a time period preceding the predicted threshold-crossing, with the timing of that actuation determined by the computed deviation . . . the claimed result is, by its terms, one that a current-measurement controller cannot achieve, the cited reactive analogies confirm the distinction rather than negate it. And because eligibility here rests on improvement rather than transformation, the absence of a transformed article is not dispositive” (emphasis added)
However, it is immaterial whether Applicant assumes that the Office’s exemplary scenarios are different from the claimed system. This is because the claimed system is merely adding additional information to be analyzed—namely, calculations to be performed based on prestored information that relate to previous experiments. Thus, regardless of whether such prestored information is used to calculate the alleged predictions, this has nothing to do with a technological improvement. This is again because the claim is merely evaluating additional information in order to estimate some possible outcomes. If anything, the claimed system is simply importing the scheme that existing meteorological or early-warning systems are normally implementing. In particular, besides gathering and analyzing (using one or more sensors) current weather attributes that relate to a given environment, existing meteorological or early-warning systems also analyze prestored or historical weather patterns of that environment in order to predict one or more possible outcomes. Of course, when the analysis result indicates a potentially hazardous condition, these systems activate one or more devices in order to alert users to take appropriate measures.
The observation above confirms that the current claimed system is indeed simply importing, into a laboratory environment, the schemes that existing meteorological or early-warning systems are normally implementing. Thus, Applicant is applying, perhaps inadvertently, the “field of use” argument in order to substantiate the alleged technological improvement. See Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Capital One Bank (USA), N.A.,792 F.3d 1363, 1366, 115 USPQ2d 1636, 1639 (Fed.Cir. 2015) (“An abstract idea does not become nonabstract by limiting the invention to a particular field of use or technological environment . . .”). Also see MPEP 2106.05(h) for additional insight. Thus, neither the four steps that Applicant listed above, nor the alleged “distinction” that Applicant is attempting to portray regarding the claimed system, demonstrates any technological improvement.
Applicant further asserts, “Applicant addresses that equipment only at the integration inquiry of Prong Two, where it belongs. So evaluated, the equipment is integral and not merely a generic tool: the very point of the claim is the actuation of these specific devices in a particular sequential time period fixed by the computed deviation. The claim does not recite generic computer functions performing an abstract idea; it recites a determinate physical actuation governed by a closed-loop timing computation” (emphasis added).
However, Applicant appears to fail to properly apply the inquiry established under Prong Two of Step 2A. It is once again worth noting that Prong Two is evaluating whether the recited abstract idea—but not the recited equipment (if any)—is integrated into a patent-eligible practical application. In the instant case, Applicant has already declared that “The Amended Claims Do Not Recite an Abstract Idea” (see page 9 of the current argument). Thus, if Applicant assumes that the current claims are not reciting a judicial exception—such as, an abstract idea, then what is being integrated into a patent-eligible practical application? Applicant appears to fail to address the above critical inquiry under Prong Two. Instead, Applicant appears to resort to a new theory by declaring that “the equipment is integral”; and accordingly, the above does not constitute a proper analysis under Prong Two.
Of course, the same is true regarding Applicant’s alleged “very point” of the claim—namely, the actuation of “specific devices in a particular sequential time period fixed by the computed deviation . . . a determinate physical actuation governed by a closed-loop timing computation”. This is because Applicant is simply repeating the same conclusory assertion that fails to demonstrate a technological improvement (if any) that the claimed system is implementing (see the Office’s analysis above).
Applicant also appears to fail to appreciate the basic principle that governs insignificant extra-solution activity. Applicant asserts, “[a]s amended, the real-time sensor measurements are not gathered for their own sake; they are inputs to the closed-loop deviation computation that determines, during the current experiment, the specific time period in which physical equipment is actuated. The deviation between the predicted value and the corresponding real-time sensor measurement is what sets the actuation timing; without the sensors operating in this specific closed-loop manner, the claimed preemptive timing is impossible. Data gathering that is integral to, rather than merely incident to, the operation of the claimed process is not insignificant extra-solution activity” (emphasis added).
However, the claims do not even specify any particular structural and/or functional feature(s) that relate to the sensors, much less a structural and/or functional feature (if any) that signifies an advanced sensor technology. In particular, given the very high-level of generality of the terms in the claims, the claims are relying merely on existing—i.e., off-the-shelf—sensors, which are used for basic data gathering purpose only. Accordingly, regardless the functions that the claimed system is performing based on the data gathered from the sensors, the claimed implementation of the sensors is directed merely to insignificant extra-solution activity. Thus, Applicant’s arguments in this regard are also not persuasive.
Fourthly, regarding Step 2B, Applicant argues, “[e]ven assuming, arguendo, that Step 2A is not dispositive, the claims recite significantly more. The ordered combination of (i) accumulating reference experiment information indexed by reagent identification and time, (ii) scaling time-indexed reference measurements by a computed similarity coefficient to generate time-period specific predictions, (iii) closed-loop deviation correction using continuous real-time sensor input, and (iv) preemptive actuation of specific physical equipment in a sequential time period preceding a predicted threshold-crossing, with the actuation timing determined by the computed deviation, is not well-understood, routine, or conventional . . . The Office Action relies on US 2016/0357765 and KR 10-1746515, and on the household air purifier and fire-suppression analogies reiterated during the interview. As set out above and in the prior response, US 2016/0357765 is directed to environmental monitoring and control of buildings for energy efficiency and occupant comfort and does not disclose time-period-specific prediction from accumulated reagent-indexed experiment data, similarity-coefficient scaling, closed-loop deviation-based correction, or deviation-determined preemptive actuation in a preceding time period; and the reactive analogies . . . nothing of record supplies the deviation-determined preemptive-timing architecture of the amended combination, and respectfully requests that, to maintain the rejection, the Office identify (a) where in the record the deviation based timing of actuation in a preceding time period is shown to be conventional, and (b) the factual basis under MPEP § 2106.0S(d)” (emphasis added).
However, here also Applicant fails to properly apply the inquiry under Step 2B. It is worth noting that Step 2B does not evaluate whether the abstract idea, which the claim is reciting, is a conventional one or not. Instead, while considering the claim as a whole, Step 2B is evaluating the technology that the claim is implementing. In particular, while considering the claim as a whole, Step 2B determines whether the claim is directed to a non-generic and non-conventional arrangement of the claimed additional elements. In the instant case, except for the new abstract idea that requires the consideration of additional information (i.e., prestored data related to previous experiments) to calculate one or more predictions, the claimed system is still relying on the conventional computer/network technology. This confirms that the current claims are directed to the conventional and generic arrangement of the claimed additional elements. Accordingly, it is immaterial whether Applicant asserts that the exemplary references, which are cited as part of the Step 2B analysis, do not teach the new abstract idea that Applicant is alleging—namely: “time-period-specific prediction from accumulated reagent-indexed experiment data”, “similarity-coefficient scaling”, “closed-loop deviation-based correction”, etc. This is again because the cited references are intended to demonstrate only the conventional nature of the claimed system, but not the new abstract idea that the claims are reciting. It is also worth noting that the references are exemplary only; and therefore, they are not intended to limit the scope of the conventional technology. In fact, as already discussed above, existing meteorological or early-warning systems also signify the conventional technology that not only predicts one or more hazardous conditions based on the analysis of current sensor data and prestored/historical data, but also activates one or more devices in order to help users avert imminent hazardous condition. Nevertheless, Applicant still fails to demonstrate whether the current claimed system is beyond the conventional technology.
Moreover, unlike Applicant’s theory, the Office is not necessarily required to provide any reference that teaches the new abstract idea that the current claims are reciting. This is because Step 2B requires one to provide evidence regarding the conventional technology—but not the new abstract idea—that that the claim is reciting. In contrast, while mistaking the new abstract idea for an alleged technological improvement, Applicant appears to demand a reference that teaches the claimed new abstract idea. Consequently, Applicant’s assertion is not even valid, much less persuasive.
Applicant further asserts that “Eligibility is asserted on two independent grounds: at Step 2A Prong Two, the claims integrate any exception into a practical application through the control-timing improvement described above; and at Step 2B, the combination is nonconventional as a factual matter under Berkheimer. Both inquiries are distinct from novelty. The point is not that a new abstract idea is patentable, but that the claims are not directed to an abstract idea in the first instance and, in any event, recite a nonconventional ordered combination embodying a technical improvement” (emphasis added).
However, given the originally disclosed and currently claimed system, a practical integration (if any) of a judicial exception into a patent-eligible practical application is shown if any of the claims is implementing a feature—or a combination of features—that provides a technological improvement over the relevant existing technology (per the inquiry under Prong Two of Step 2A). In this regard, Applicant’s alleged “control-timing improvement” does not constitute a technological improvement (see the rationale discussed above). Similarly, an inventive concept (if any) is demonstrated if any of the claims is directed to a non-generic and non-conventional arrangement of the claimed additional elements (per the inquiry under Step 2B). In the instant case, the discussion above already confirms that the claims are directed merely to the conventional and generic arrangement of the additional elements. Thus, except for presenting repetitive arguments, Applicant fails demonstrate whether any of the current claims complies with Prong Two of Step 2A and/or Step 2B.
Applicant further asserts that “[a] human instructor cannot, in real time during the current experiment, compute for each sequential time period a numerical deviation between a time-period-specific predicted value and a continuously arriving sensor measurement, propagate that deviation to update the predictions for all subsequent time periods, and use that deviation to initiate equipment actuation in a specific time period preceding the predicted threshold-crossing – quickly and continuously enough to actuate before the predicted value reaches the threshold. It is the deviation-determined preemptive timing, not the general notion of guiding an experiment, that the claims require, and that timing capability is what a reactive human or a reactive controller cannot achieve” (emphasis added).
However, here also Applicant appears to fail to properly apply the test regarding mental processes. Note that the test does not necessarily require performing each and every claimed step in the human mind (or using a pen and paper). Instead, the test requires one to determine the limitations that can practically be performed in the human mind and/or using a pen and paper. Thus, the test does not check whether a human can mimic the claimed sensor/signal or whether a human can be faster than the claimed computer. Instead, the test notes that a human—such as an instructor—can gather and analyze information regarding one or more previous experiments (i.e., “reference experiment information from a plurality of previously performed experiments, wherein each reference experiment information comprises reagent identification and time-indexed internal environment information that was recorded during a respective previously performed experiment”). Similarly, the instructor can also recognize a task or an experiment that the user is going to perform based on data gathered regarding the user and the current experiment (i.e., “receiving user location information and user experiment information”, “the user experiment information includes identification of one or more reagents to be used in a current experiment”, “determining whether a user is located in the laboratory based on the user location information”), etc.
Thus, regardless of the type and/or number of the computer elements currently recited, the fact above is sufficient to confirm that the claims do recite limitations that can practically be performed in the human mind and/or using a pen and paper. Of course, depending on the information that the instructor is gathering and analyzing, the instructor may also perform one or more preemptive actions; such as:
(a) locking a cabinet that stores a particular reagent if the past record shows that the user improperly used that reagent, or caused a serios accident when using that reagent,
(b) manually activating an air purifying device if the instructor observed similar pattern of the user’s activity, which caused the buildup of harmful gas in the past, etc.
Accordingly, unlike Applicant’s theory, the instructor is achieving the same end result, namely preemptively preventing a hazardous condition before it develops, even without performing the lengthy calculations that the current claim is reciting.
Nevertheless, regardless of whether the instructor decides to do those actions manually, or whether the instructor decides to automate such manual tasks using the existing computer/network technology, the main fact remains the same. In particular, neither the claimed system nor the disclosed system, when considered as a whole, provides an inventive concept that amounts to “significantly more” than an abstract idea. Consequently, Applicant’s arguments are not persuasive.
Note that Applicant has also attempted to summarize the features that each of the dependent claims is adding to claim 1. However, no additional argument is presented to show whether any these features, when considered individually or in combination with the features of claim 1, are providing (i) any technological improvement (Prong Two of Step 2A) or (ii) an inventive concept (Step 2B). Thus, the analysis presented above applies to each of the current claims.
Accordingly, at least for the reasons discussed above, none of the current claims, when considered as a whole, implements an inventive concept that amounts to “significantly more” than an abstract idea.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
4. The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C.112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C.112:
The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention.
● Claims 1, 2, 7, 8, 10 and 11 are rejected under 35 U.S.C.112(a) or 35 U.S.C.112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for pre-AIA the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention.
(a) Current claim 1 recites, “. . . executing a closed-loop prediction process comprising . . . (i) analyzing a similarity between reagent information included in the user experiment information and reagent information included in the retrieved reference experiment information to produce a similarity coefficient, (ii) applying the similarity coefficient to the time-indexed internal environment information of the laboratory related to the retrieved reference experiment information by scaling the measurement recorded at the corresponding time interval in the retrieved reference experiment information by the similarity coefficient to generate predicted internal environment values for each of the plurality of sequential time periods . . . (iii) correcting the predicted internal environment values for each sequential time period with the real-time internal environment information . . . computing, for each time period, a deviation between the predicted internal environment value and the corresponding real-time sensor measurement received during that time period, and applying the computed deviation to update the predicted internal environment values for subsequent sequential time periods” (emphasis added).
However, the original disclosure does not have sufficient written description regarding the so-called “closed-loop prediction process” currently claimed, which is assumed to not only “produce a similarity coefficient” and “apply[] the similarity coefficient to the time-indexed internal environment information of the laboratory related to the retrieved reference experiment information by scaling the measurement recorded at the corresponding time interval in the retrieved reference experiment information by the similarity coefficient to generate predicted internal environment values for each of the plurality of sequential time periods”, but also “correct[] the predicted internal environment values” by “computing, for each time
period, a deviation between the predicted internal environment value and the
corresponding real-time sensor measurement received during that time period, and
applying the computed deviation to update the predicted internal environment values for subsequent sequential time periods” (emphasis added).
Instead, the original disclosure is merely providing generic description regarding analyzing similarity (e.g., see page 17 of the original specification, emphasis added),
“. . . the system for providing a user-optimized laboratory environment may analyze a similarity between the reference experiment information and the user experiment information and calculate and provide the internal environment information of the laboratory predicted for each time period during the experiment on the basis of the previous environment internal information of the laboratory related to the reference experiment information and the real-time internal environment information of the laboratory. In an embodiment, the internal environment information of the laboratory predicted for each time period during the experiment may be derived by analyzing a similarity between reagent information included in the user experiment information and reagent information included in the reference experiment information, applying the similarity to the previous environment internal information of the laboratory related to the reference experiment information, and then correcting the internal environment information of the laboratory with the real-time internal environment information of the laboratory”
Thus, it is evident from the excerpt above that the original specification, which relies merely on a generic description, does not provide sufficient support regarding the current claims.
(b) Claim 1 further recites, “controlling at least one of a harmful gas purification device”, wherein “said controlling comprises (1) identifying, from the predicted internal environment values as updated by the deviation computed in step (iii), a future sequential time period in which a predicted internal environment value is predicted to exceed a threshold level, and (2) initiating actuation . . . wherein the deviation computed in step (iii) for each sequential time period determines the sequential time period during which actuation of the laboratory equipment is initiated, such that the air quality and the temperature of the laboratory are physically adjusted before the predicted internal environment value reaches the threshold level, thereby controlling the laboratory equipment to adjust the laboratory conditions at a time that a controller actuating in response to a current real-time measurement of the internal environment cannot achieve” (emphasis added).
However, here also the original disclosure does not have sufficient description regarding the above specific limitations. Instead, the specification is once again providing merely generic description regarding the controlling process (e.g., see pages 15-16 of the original specification)
Thus, at least for the reasons discussed above in parts (a) and (b), the current claims involve new subject matter.
Note that, when an amendment is filed in reply to an objection or rejection based on 35 U.S.C. 112(a), or first paragraph (pre-AIA ), a study of the entire application is often necessary to determine whether or not "new matter" is involved. Applicant should therefore specifically point out the support for any amendments made to the disclosure (see MPEP 2163.06).
5. The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C.112(b):
(b) CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C.112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
● Claims 1, 2, 7, 8, 10 and 11 are rejected under 35 U.S.C.112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor, or for pre-AIA the applicant regards as the invention.
Current claim 1 recites, “. . . such that the air quality and the temperature of the laboratory are physically adjusted before the predicted internal environment value reaches the threshold level, thereby controlling the laboratory equipment to adjust the laboratory conditions at a time that a controller actuating in response to a current real-time measurement of the internal environment cannot achieve” (emphasis added).
However, it is unclear whether the limitation above is an attempt to signify the deficiency of the claimed system, or an attempt to recite a negative limitation. Thus, at least for the reason above, the current claims are ambiguous or indefinite.
Applicant is further advised to evaluate each of the current claims and make appropriate corrections if additional discrepancies are discovered.
Prior Art
6. Considering current claim 1 as a whole (including each of the dependent claims), the prior art does not teach or suggest the current claimed system (regarding the state of the prior art, see the office-action dated 06/21/2024).
Conclusion
Applicant’s amendment necessitated the new grounds of rejection presented in this final office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filled within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any extension fee pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to BRUK A GEBREMICHAEL whose telephone number is (571) 270-3079. The examiner can normally be reached from 7:00 AM - 3:00 PM.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, PETER VASAT can be reached on (571) 270-7625. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from the Patent Application Information Retrieval (PAIR) system. Status information for published applications may be obtained from either Private PAIR or Public PAIR. Status information for unpublished applications is available through Private PAIR only. For more information about the PAIR system, see http://pair-direct.uspto.gov. Should you have questions on access to the Private PAIR system, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative or access to the automated information system, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/BRUK A GEBREMICHAEL/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3715