DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Continued Examination Under 37 CFR 1.114
A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114.
Status of Claims
The amendments and remarks filed on 06JUL2026 have been entered and considered.
Claims 1 & 13 have been amended.
Claims 13-15, 17, & 19-23 are under examination.
New matter has been added to claims 1 & 13.
The remarks filed on 06JUL2026 points to Paragraphs 38, 50-53, 66, 68, 70-72, 87-89, & 90 of the Specification. The Specification filed on 30NOV2021 does not provide paragraph numbers .
Information Disclosure Statement
The information disclosure statement (IDS) submitted on 18MAY2026 was filed in compliance with the provisions of 37 CFR 1.97. Accordingly, the information disclosure statement is being considered by the examiner.
Response to Arguments
Applicant's arguments filed 06JUL2026 regarding the rejections under 35 U.S.C 101 have been fully considered but are not persuasive. Parts deemed not persuasive discussed below:
Initially, the Applicant argues (Pages 10-12 of the Remarks):
Applicant's amended claim 13 is not so generic. The amended claim does not merely recite estimating atrial remodeling or analyzing data. Instead, amended claim 13 recites a particular electrophysiological apparatus and signal-processing workflow in which: (i) a processor receives catheter configuration information for a catheter having multiple spines and closely spaced electrodes configured to contact heart tissue undergoing atrial fibrillation; (ii) the processor causes sets of signals to be acquired from each of the electrodes over a period of time while the electrodes are in contact with the heart tissue during atrial fibrillation; (iii) the processor determines plural LATs for each signal received from the electrodes; (iv) the processor determines, from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs, mutual information metrics between the multiple pairs of electrodes; (v) the processor generates a graph with the electrodes as nodes and edges as connections for which the mutual information metrics exceed a selected mutual information metric threshold; (vi) the processor determines local efficiency metrics based on shortest path lengths between connected nodes; (vii) the processor determines a resultant local efficiency for the selected threshold; (viii) the processor repeats the graph/local- efficiency analysis while incrementing the selected threshold until a maximum value is reached and stores ordered pairs of resultant local efficiency and corresponding threshold; (ix) theprocessor analyzes the ordered pairs to estimate a percentage amount of remodeling of the atrium; and (x) the processor presents, in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium, remodeling-classification content for use in selecting an ablation strategy, where the remodeling- classification content is based, at least in part, on the estimated percentage amount of remodeling of the atrium.
Applicant's specification explains the technical significance of this claimed workflow. The disclosure states that, for atrial fibrillation, it is important not only to locate the driver of AF, but also to classify AF to identify an optimal RF, IRE, or PF ablation strategy. See Specification at I [0038]. Areas with significant remodeling may be important in AF maintenance mechanisms, and knowing whether an atrium has been remodeled leads to improvement in the mapping and ablation strategy. See id. The specification further describes a processor acquiring signals from electrodes contacting heart tissue undergoing atrial fibrillation, calculating mutual information metrics between electrode pairs, generating a graph whose nodes correspond to electrodes and whose edges correspond to threshold-satisfying mutual information relationships, calculating local efficiency metrics, and iteratively generating ordered pairs of resultant local efficiency and mutual information threshold to classify atrial fibrillation. See id. at ЧЕЧ [0040]-[0044]. The disclosure also describes tracking electrode locations, associating electrophysiological signals with locations at which the signals were acquired, and overlaying a probe icon on a pre-acquired atrial map presented on a screen. See id. at 9191 [0050]-[0053]. Amended claim 13 reflects that disclosed technical workflow by claiming the specific catheter-signal acquisition, LAT determination, mutual-information graph generation from LATs determined for signals received from multiple electrode pairs, shortest-path local-efficiency analysis, iterative thresholding, remodelingestimation, and map-associated presentation of remodeling-classification content for use in selecting an ablation strategy.
The Advisory Action's criticism that unamended claim 13 did not recite sufficient processing detail is no longer applicable. Amended claim 13 now expressly recites that the mutual information metrics are determined from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs, thereby identifying the data used for the mutual-information processing and tying the mutual-information metrics to the acquired electrode signals. Amended claim 13 also expressly recites the electrodes, rather than electrode pairs, as the graph nodes, and further recites that the local efficiency metric is based on shortest path lengths between connected nodes. These amendments align the claim with the specification's regional information graph and local-efficiency processing. See Specification at II [0054]-[0064], [0066]-[0072]. Amended claim 13 also replaces the prior display step with a technically integrated recitation requiring the processor to present, in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium, remodeling- classification content for use in selecting an ablation strategy. This amendment ties the estimated remodeling to the disclosed electrophysiological mapping and ablation-strategy context. See id. at Я [0038], [0050]-[0053], [0087]-[0089].
However, the arguments are not persuasive. Although claim 13 recites a specific catheter configuration and a specific process for acquiring and analyzing electrophysiological signals, the claimed process still amounts to collecting information and performing mathematical analysis on that information. Determining LAT and mutual information metrics, generating a graph, determining local efficiency based on shortest path length, iteratively changing the threshold, and analyzing the resulting values to estimate atrial remodeling are calculations performed on the acquired data. The catheter and electrodes provide the data used in the analysis, and the resulting remodeling estimate is used to assist in selecting an ablation strategy but claim 13 does not require a particular ablation procedure or otherwise recite an improvement to the operation of the catheter, electrodes, or electrophysiological mapping technology. Even when the recited steps are considered together the claimed combination merely provides a particular manner of analyzing the electrophysiological data to obtain the claimed remodeling estimate. Therefore, the claims are not patent eligible.
Applicant further argues (Page 13 of the Remarks):
Here, amended claim 13 reflects a specific improvement to electrophysiological mapping and ablation-strategy selection by using a particular graph-theoretic processing workflow applied to catheter-acquired intracardiac signals during atrial fibrillation to estimate atrial remodeling and present remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy. See Specification at III [0038], [0040]-[0044], [0050]-[0053].
The December 5, 2025 USPTO memorandum addressing Ex parte Desjardins further explains that software-based logical structures and processes may provide technological improvements, and that eligibility may turn on whether the claim is directed to an improvement in computer functionality or another technology or technical field. See USPTO Memorandum dated December 5, 2025, Advance notice of change to the MPEP in light of Ex parte Desjardins, Appeal No. 2024-000567 (PTAB Sept. 26, 2025) (precedential). According to the Desjardins memorandum, when the specification identifies a technological improvement, the claim should be evaluated as a whole to determine whether the claim reflects that improvement. See id. Amended claim 13 reflects the improvement described in Applicant's disclosure, i.e., classifying atrial fibrillation and estimating atrial remodeling from catheter-acquired intracardiac signals using LAT-based mutual-information and local-efficiency graph analysis so that remodeling- classification content is presented in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy. See Specification at II [0038], [0040]-[0044], [0087]-[0089].
However, the argument is not persuasive because the claimed steps use signals to perform calculations and estimate atrial remodeling. The resulting information is then used to assist in selecting an ablation strategy, but the claim does not require an ablation or change how the components operate. Considering the claim does not change this result. Further, the claims as compared to ex parte Desjardins are moot because the present claims do not improve the operation of underlying technology. Therefore, the claims are patent ineligible.
Regarding Step 2A Prong one, Applicant argues (Pages 13-16 of the Remarks):
The Office Action and Advisory Action characterize claim 13 as reciting mental processes and mathematical/data-analysis steps. See, e.g., Office Action at 2-3. Applicant respectfully disagrees with that characterization. Amended claim 13 is not commensurate with a clinician merely observing, evaluating, or judging whether atrial remodeling is present. Rather, amended claim 13 recites an apparatus in which a processor executes a particular EP signal-processing workflow on signals acquired over time from multiple closely spaced catheter electrodes contacting heart tissue during atrial fibrillation.
Amended claim 13 recites limitations that cannot practically be performed in the human mind. The claim requires, among other things, determining plural LATs for each electrode signal acquired over time during atrial fibrillation, determining mutual information metrics from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs, generating a thresholded graph in which electrodes are nodes and threshold-satisfying mutual-information relationships are edges, determining node-level local efficiency metrics based on shortest path lengths, determining resultant local efficiency values, iteratively repeating the graph/local- efficiency process while incrementing a mutual-information threshold until a maximum value is reached, storing ordered pairs of resultant local efficiency and corresponding threshold, and analyzing those ordered pairs to estimate a percentage amount of remodeling of the atrium. See Specification at III [0054]-[0064], [0066]-[0078]. These recitations do not merely invoke a generic processor to automate a clinician's mental judgment. They define a specific, interdependent sequence of computational operations applied to catheter-acquired intracardiac signals in an EP mapping context.
The Advisory Action asserts that unamended claim 13 did not define meaningful details about the limitations of the nodes, efficiencies, path lengths, analysis, or threshold limitations. See Advisory Action at 3-4. Amended claim 13 addresses these points. First, the mutual-information limitation now expressly recites that the mutual information metrics are determined from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs. Thus, the claim identifies the data used for the mutual-information metrics and ties those metrics to the acquired electrode signals. Second, the graph limitation now expressly recites that the electrodes are the graph nodes and that the edges are the connections for which the respective mutual information metrics exceed a selected mutual information metric threshold. Third, the local- efficiency limitation expressly recites that the local efficiency metric indicates an efficiency of information exchange between a node and other nodes connected to the node based on shortest path lengths between connected nodes. Fourth, the iteration limitation recites repeating the graph/local-efficiency steps while incrementing the selected mutual information metric threshold until a maximum value is reached and storing each resultant local efficiency and corresponding selected threshold as an ordered pair. These limitations provide a concrete claimed processing architecture, not a generic instruction to analyze data.
The Office Action's assertion that the claim remains a mental process because a clinician could use Excel, other programs, or pen and paper given sufficient time is inconsistent with the required "practical" inquiry. See Office Action at 3-4. The mental-process grouping is limited to limitations that can practically be performed in the human mind or with pen and paper. The fact that a clinician might use separate software tools to perform LAT-based mutual-information calculations, graph generation, shortest-path analysis, iterative thresholding, and ordered-pair analysis does not establish that the claimed limitations can practically be performed in the human mind. Amended claim 13 requires more than a clinician "watching data" or "plotting" values; it requires a particular graph-theoretic and iterative threshold-processing architecture for estimating atrial remodeling from intracardiac AF signals and presenting remodeling-classification content with an electroanatomical map for ablation-strategy selection.
The conclusion that amended claim 13 cannot properly be reduced to a mental process is consistent with USPTO Example 48. In Example 48, the USPTO recognized that certain speech- signal operations, including generating a new mixed speech signal that excludes a target speech source, are not processes that can practically be performed in the human mind. Amended claim 13 is similarly directed to technical signal processing of physiological signals acquired by a catheter during atrial fibrillation. Although mathematical relationships are used, the claim as a whole recites a particular EP apparatus workflow for acquiring intracardiac signals, determining LATs from the signals, determining mutual-information metrics from the LATs, generating and processing mutual-information graphs over incremented thresholds, estimating atrial remodeling, and presenting remodeling-classification content with an electroanatomical atrial map for ablation- strategy selection.
Accordingly, amended claim 13, as well as the claims depending therefrom, is not properly characterized as merely a mental process.
However, the arguments are not persuasive. The applicant argues that claim 13 is not a mental process because it requires a specific catheter configuration and a detailed sequence of electrophysiological and graph-based calculations that would be difficult to perform mentally. The claim still requires determining LATs, determining mutual information metrics, determining local efficiency, evaluating shortest path lengths, changing a threshold, and analyzing the resulting values to estimate atrial remodeling. These steps involve evaluating and analyzing information. The fact that the steps may be performed more efficiently using software does not change the nature of the claimed steps. Further, the inclusion of the catheter, electrodes, signals, and graph-based analysis does not remove the analysis and evaluations from the claim. The applicant’s reliance on Example 48 is not persuasive because the present claim does not recite an improvement to the underlying signal processing technology. Therefore, the claims are patent ineligible.
Regarding Step 2A Prong Two, Applicant argues (Pages 16-17 of the Remarks):
Even assuming, without conceding, that amended claim 13 recites a judicial exception, the claim integrates any alleged exception into a practical application. Amended claim 13 does not merely recite collecting data, performing mathematical analysis, and displaying a result. Instead, the claim applies the alleged calculations in a specific electrophysiological mapping and ablation- strategy environment by processing catheter-acquired intracardiac signals from closely spaced electrodes contacting heart tissue during atrial fibrillation, estimating a percentage amount of atrial remodeling through a particular LAT-based mutual-information/local-efficiency graph workflow, and presenting remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium for use in selecting an ablation strategy.
This claimed implementation is a meaningful limitation on the alleged abstract idea. The claim does not merely recite "apply data analysis on a computer" or "display the result." The amended claim requires a specific technical workflow tied to an electroanatomical map of the atrium. The processor determines LATs for acquired signals, determines mutual information metrics from the LATs for signals received from multiple electrode pairs, generates a graph with electrodes as nodes and threshold-satisfying mutual-information relationships as edges, determines local efficiency metrics based on shortest path lengths, determines resultant local efficiencies, repeats the analysis while incrementing the mutual-information threshold, stores ordered pairs of resultant local efficiency and corresponding threshold, analyzes those ordered pairs to estimate a percentage amount of atrial remodeling, and presents remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy. See Specification at III [0040]-[0044], [0054]-[0064], [0066]-[0078], [0087]-[0089].
Applicant's specification describes the EP-specific problem addressed by the claimed apparatus. The disclosure explains that, for AF, it is important to classify the atrial fibrillation to identify an optimal ablation strategy, and that areas with significant remodeling may be important in atrial fibrillation maintenance mechanisms. See id. at I [0038]. The disclosure further explains that knowing whether an atrium has been remodeled leads to improvement in mapping and ablation strategy. See id. Amended claim 13 reflects that technical solution by reciting the particular signal-acquisition and graph-processing workflow used to estimate the percentage amount of remodeling and by further requiring presentation of remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy.
However, the arguments are not persuasive. The claimed catheter and electrodes are used to acquire the electrophysiological signals, and the process uses the signals to perform the claimed LAT, mutual information, graph, local efficiency, threshold, and remodeling calculations. The resulting information is further displayed with an EP map for use in selecting an ablation strategy. These limitations do not change the operation of the catheter, electrodes, or mapping system. They further do not perform an ablation or otherwise improve the underlying technology. Instead, the claimed analysis is applied to a particular type of field of use and medical data. Considering the additional elements individually and in combination does not change this result. The combination still amounts to performing analysis and presenting the resulting information.
Applicant argues (Pages 17-19 of the Remarks):
The Advisory Action criticizes unamended claim 13 as lacking the processing detail found in eligible USPTO Example 3. See Advisory Action at 3-4. While Applicant respectfullydisagrees with the Advisory Action's characterization, amended claim 13 is now even more analogous to Example 3. In Example 3, the claim was eligible because the mathematical operations were not claimed in isolation. The operations were integrated into a particular digital- image-processing workflow that generated a blue-noise mask, compared pixels to threshold numbers, produced a binary image array, and converted the array to a halftoned image. Amended claim 13 likewise does not claim mathematics in isolation. It recites a particular cardiac- electrophysiology processing workflow in which signals acquired from catheter electrodes during atrial fibrillation are processed to determine LATs, mutual information metrics are determined from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs, a graph is generated with electrodes as nodes and threshold-satisfying mutual-information relationships as edges, local efficiency metrics are determined based on shortest path lengths, resultant local efficiencies are iteratively generated and stored with corresponding thresholds as ordered pairs, and those ordered pairs are analyzed to estimate atrial remodeling. The claim then applies that result in the EP mapping environment by presenting remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy.
Amended claim 13 is also analogous to eligible Claims 2 and 3 of USPTO Example 48. In Example 48, the ineligible claim stopped at using a deep neural network to determine separated speech embedding vectors. By contrast, eligible Claims 2 and 3 carried the processing through to technical results: converting processed representations into separate speech waveforms and, in Claim 3, using a separated speech signal in a speech-to-text process. The USPTO explained that those additional steps reflected the technical improvement described in the disclosure and were not insignificant extra-solution activity, mere instructions to apply an exception, or mere field-of- use limitations. Amended claim 13 follows the same eligible pattern. The claim does not stop at calculating mutual information metrics, generating graph data, or estimating a remodeling amount. It carries the result of that processing through to an EP mapping and ablation-strategy application by presenting remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium for use in selecting an ablation strategy. See Specification at II [0038], [0050]-[0053], [0087]-[0089].
However, the arguments are not persuasive. The applicant compares claim 13 to USPTO Example 3 and argues that the claimed calculations are integrated into a specific electrophysiological mapping workflow. Unlike Example 3, where the claimed image processing steps produced a particular technical image processing result, claim 13 uses the acquired electrophysiological signals to calculate and analyze information, estimate atrial remodeling, and present the resulting classification information. The limitations merely define how the information is processed and does not change the i=operation of the underlying technology. Presenting a remodeling classification with a electroanatomical map for use in selecting an ablation strategy does not require the system to perform an ablation or otherwise produce a technical change. Applicants’ reliance on Example 48 is also not persuasive because the examples included additional processing tied to the claimed technical result. Claim 13 comparatively only provides the result of its analysis for use in medical decisions. Therefore, the limitations do not integrate the claims into practical application.
Applicant argues (Pages 19-20 of the Remarks):
Amended claim 13 is also analogous to eligible Claim 3 of USPTO Example 47. In Example 47, a claim that merely detected anomalies was ineligible, while Claim 3 was eligible because the claim used the anomaly-detection output to improve the technical field of network intrusion detection by taking specific network-security actions. Amended claim 13 likewise does not merely produce an uncontextualized classification. The claim uses the remodeling estimate in the EP technical environment by presenting remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy. Amended claim 13 integrates the alleged abstract analysis into a practical EP mapping and ablation-strategy application, consistent with the disclosed improvement in mapping and ablation strategy. See Specification at I [0038].
Federal Circuit precedent supports Applicant's position. In Core Wireless Licensing S.A.R.L. V. LG Electronics, Inc., the Federal Circuit held that claims directed to an improved user interface were patent eligible because they recited a particular manner of summarizing and presenting information, rather than merely displaying a generic index on a computer. See Core Wireless, 880 F.3d 1356, 1362-63 (Fed. Cir. 2018). The court explained that the claims restrained the type of data displayed, required the information to be displayed in a particular state, and provided a specific improvement over prior user interfaces. See id. Amended claim 13 is analogous. The claim does not merely display generic information on a computer. Instead, itrecites a particular manner of presenting EP mapping information: remodeling-classification content based on a processor-estimated percentage amount of atrial remodeling is presented in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium for use in selecting an ablation strategy. This claimed presentation is tied to the disclosed EP mapping and ablation-strategy problem, namely that knowing whether an atrium has been remodeled improves mapping and ablation strategy. See Specification at I [0038].
The Desjardins guidance further supports this conclusion. The relevant improvement here is an improvement to another technology or technical field: electrophysiological mapping and ablation-strategy selection for atrial fibrillation. Under Desjardins, the Office should consider whether the claim as a whole reflects such a technological improvement, rather than dismissing the recited processor, catheter, electrodes, LAT determination, LAT-based mutual-information processing, graph generation, local-efficiency analysis, and map-associated presentation as generic computer implementation or insignificant extra-solution activity. Amended claim 13 requires the alleged mathematical concepts to be implemented through a particular EP workflow in which catheter-acquired intracardiac signals during atrial fibrillation are processed by determining LATs, determining mutual-information metrics from the LATs, generating thresholded electrode graphs, determining shortest-path local-efficiency metrics, iteratively thresholding and storing ordered pairs, and estimating atrial remodeling, and in which the resulting remodeling-classification content is presented in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for ablation-strategy selection. See Specification at III [0038], [0040]-[0044], [0050]-[0053], [0064]-[0078], [0087]- [0089]. That claimed implementation integrates any alleged abstract idea into a practical application.
However, the arguments are not persuasive. The applicant argues that claim 13 is analogous to USPTO Example 47 and 48 and Core Wireless because the claimed remodeling information is used in electrophysiological mapping and ablation strategy, and Desjardins requires the claim to be considered as a whole. Even when considered as a whole, claim 13 processes acquired signals to determine LATS, mutual information, graph and local efficiency values, and atrial remodeling. It additionally presents the results for use in selecting an ablation strategy. The claim does not require the information to control an ablation, improve the operation of the mapping system, or otherwise change the underlying technology and therefore are not similar to the cited examples nor are they patent eligible.
Regarding Step 2B, Applicant argues (Pages 21-23 of the Remarks):
Even if the Examiner were to maintain that amended claim 13 is directed to an abstract idea, the claim elements, considered as an ordered combination, provide significantly more than the alleged abstract idea. Amended claim 13 recites more than merely receiving data, evaluating the data, and displaying a result. Considered as a whole, the claim recites an apparatus in which a processor causes sets of signals to be acquired from closely spaced electrodes of a multi-spine catheter while in contact with heart tissue during atrial fibrillation, determines LATs for the acquired signals, determines mutual information metrics from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs, generates a graph with electrodes as nodes and threshold-satisfying mutual-information relationships as edges, determines local efficiency metrics based on shortest path lengths, determines resultant local efficiency values, iteratively repeats the graph/local-efficiency analysis while incrementing the selected mutual-information threshold until a maximum value is reached, stores ordered pairs in memory, analyzes the ordered pairs to estimate a percentage amount of atrial remodeling, and presents remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium for use in selecting an ablation strategy.
The Advisory Action criticizes unamended claim 13 as reciting general ideas of data processing with no defined details about the data used for the mutual information metrics or about nodes, efficiencies, path lengths, analysis of data, or threshold limitations. See Advisory Action at 3-4. While Applicant respectfully disagrees with the Advisory Action's characterization, amended claim 13 addresses those criticisms by reciting, as an ordered combination, mutual information metrics determined from the plurality of LATs determined for signals received from multiple electrode pairs, electrodes as graph nodes, edges defined by mutual information metrics exceeding a selected mutual information metric threshold, local efficiency metrics based on shortest path lengths between connected nodes, resultant local efficiency values for the selected threshold, iterative thresholding until a maximum value is reached, ordered-pair storage, remodeling-percentage estimation, and presentation of remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical map for use in selecting an ablation strategy.
The Office Action and Advisory Action also characterize the processor, catheter, electrodes, memory, display, signal acquisition, ordered-pair storage, and output of remodeling information as generic implementation or insignificant extra-solution activity. But that characterization does not establish that the claimed ordered combination was well-understood, routine, and conventional. The relevant ordered combination is not merely the use of a processor, memory, catheter, electrodes, or display. Rather, the relevant ordered combination includes the particular sequence of catheter-based intracardiac signal acquisition, LAT determination, LAT- based mutual-information graph construction, local-efficiency calculation based on shortest path lengths, iterative thresholding, ordered-pair storage, remodeling-percentage estimation, and presentation of remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy. See Specification at ЧЕЧ [0038], [0040]-[0044], [0054]-[0064], [0066]-[0078], [0087]-[0089].
The Office Action and Advisory Action have not shown that this claimed ordered combination was well-understood, routine, and conventional. Nor have they shown that presenting remodeling-classification content in association with an electroanatomical atrial map for use in selecting an ablation strategy is merely insignificant post-solution activity. To the contrary, that recitation is the claimed technical output through which the graph-theoretic atrial-remodelinganalysis is applied in the EP mapping and ablation-strategy environment. See Specification at III [0038], [0050]-[0053], [0087]-[0089].
Accordingly, even if any portion of amended claim 13 were considered to recite an abstract idea, the ordered combination of limitations recited in amended claim 13 amounts to significantly more than the alleged abstract idea.
However, the arguments are not persuasive. The applicant argues that the ordered combination of steps recited in claim 13 provides significantly more than the abstract idea. However, these steps are directed at performing the claimed analysis and do not provide an additional inventive concept beyond that analysis. The processor, memory, catheter, electrodes, and display perform their respective functions in carrying out the claim process. The presentation of remodeling information for use in selecting a*n ablation strategy does not by itself perform an ablation or change the system operation. Therefore, the claims do not present an element or combination of elements that provide significantly more than the abstract idea.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112:
The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention.
Claims 1-3, 5-11, 13-15, 17, & 19-23 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention.
Regarding Claims 1 & 13:
The claims recite “determining, from the plurality of LATs determined for the signals received from multiple electrode pairs mutual information metrics between the multiple electrode pairs”. The specification does not provide support for portion “determine from a plurality of LATs”. The Specification discusses mutual information metrics between electrode pairs but does not provide that they are determined from a plurality of LATs. Therefore, the claim limitation lacks written description.
Claims 2-3 & 5-11 are rejected for depending upon the rejected claim 1.
Claims 14-15, 17, & 19-23 are rejected for depending upon the rejected claim 13.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 13-15, 17, & 19-23 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101. MPEP 2106(III) outlines steps for determining whether a claim is directed to statutory subject matter. The stepwise analysis for the instant claim is provided here.
Step 1: Statutory Categories
Claim 13 is directed to an apparatus (i.e. machine) and thus meets the step 1 requirements.
Step 2A: Prong 1; Judicial Exception
Regarding claim 13 the following claim limitation is an abstract idea: “estimating how much remodeling is present in a fibrillating atrium”, “determine a plurality of local activation times (LATs) for each signal received from the plurality of electrodes in contact with the heart tissue of the patient during atrial fibrillation”; “determine, from the plurality of LATS determined for signals received from multiple electrode pairs, mutual information metrics between the multiple pairs of electrodes”, “analyze each of the ordered pairs of resultant local efficiency and the corresponding selected mutual information metric threshold to estimate a percentage amount of remodeling of the atrium”, “generate, a graph with electrodes as nodes, and edges as connections therebetween for which the respective mutual information metrics exceed a selected mutual information metric threshold”, “determine, a resultant local efficiency for the selected mutual information metric threshold, wherein the determination comprises averaging the respective local efficiency metrics of the nodes” and “determine, a respective local efficiency metric for each node, indicatin g an efficiency of information exchange between the node and other nodes connected to the node, based on shortest path lengths between the connected nodes”, “repeat, iteratively by the processor” which are mental processes when given its broadest reasonable interpretation. As discussed in MPEP 2106.04(a)(2)(II), the mental process grouping includes observations, evaluations, judgements, and opinions. In this case, a human could analyze (i.e. evaluate) a local efficiency on the electrical measurement.
Step 2A: Prong 2; Additional Elements to Integrate J.E. Into A Practical Application
Regarding claim 13, the abstract idea is not integrated into a practical application.
The following claim elements do not add any meaningful limitation to the abstract idea: “plurality of electrodes”, a “non-transitory computer readable medium storing a plurality of instructions”, “catheter having a plurality of spines, each spine comprising a plurality of electrodes configured to contact heart tissue undergoing atrial fibrillation wherein each electrode is separated from a nearest-neighbor electrode by three millimeters or less”, “display”,” receive, from catheter configuration information for a catheter” and “a processor” are recited at a high level of generality and are generic cardiac ablation components amounting to insignificant extra-solution activity in that they are merely objects on which the functional limitations operate [MPEP 2106.05(b)]. “mutual information metric” is data that is necessary to implement the abstract idea on a computer [MPEP 2106.05(g)].
Step 2B: Significantly More/Inventive Concept
The additional elements of claim 13, when considered separately and in combination, do not add significantly more (i.e. an inventive concept) to the abstract idea. As discussed above with respect to the integration of the abstract idea into a practical application, the recited, plurality of electrodes, non-transitory computer readable medium, catheter, receive, from catheter configuration information for a catheter, and a processor, along with their associated estimations and related calculations are recited at a high level of generality and simply amount to implementing the abstract idea on a computer. The additional elements of “cause sets of signals to be acquired from each of the plurality of electrodes of the catheter over a period of time when in contact with the heart tissue of a patient during atrial fibrillation”, “iteratively while incrementing the selected mutual information metric threshold until a maximum value is reached and storing each resultant local efficiency and corresponding selected mutual information threshold as an ordered pair in a memory of a computing system” and ” present, in association with an electroanatomical map of the atrium, remodeling- classification content for use in selecting an ablation strategy, the remodeling- classification content being based, at least in part, on the estimated percentage amount of remodeling of the atrium” are insignificant extra-solution activity and do not amount to more than what is well- understood, routine, and conventional.
Dependent claims 14-15, 17, & 19-23 do not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application and do not add significantly more to the abstract idea of claim 13. The dependent claim limitations are
directed to calculating from the signal’s respective mutual information metrics between all pairs of the electrodes (claims 15, 20-21), signal analysis/plotting (Claim 14), plotting (Claim 17), structure (Claim 19), and to analyzing the set of ordered pairs generated from the mutual information metric threshold (claims 22-23), which are insignificant extra-solution activity and do not amount to more than what is well understood, routine, and conventional.
In summary, claims 13-15, 17, & 19-23 are directed to an abstract idea without significantly more and, therefore, are patent ineligible. Conclusion
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to Megan Fedorky whose telephone number is 571-272-2117. The examiner can normally be reached 3PM-11PM ET Mon-Fri.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Jennifer McDonald can be reached on Mon-Fri 9AM-5PM ET. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/MEGAN T FEDORKY/Examiner, Art Unit 3796
/LYNSEY C Eiseman/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3796