Prosecution Insights
Last updated: November 04, 2026
Application No. 17/902,832

Systems and Methods for Analysis and Simulation of Subsurface Hydraulic Fracture Geometries with Three-Dimensional Rock Discontinuities

Final Rejection §103§112
Filed
Sep 04, 2022
Examiner
SHALABY, AHMAD HUSSAM
Art Unit
2187
Tech Center
2100 — Computer Architecture & Software
Assignee
BJ Karst Science & Technology Ltd.
OA Round
2 (Final)
33%
Grant Probability
At Risk
3-4
OA Rounds
0m
Est. Remaining
99%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants only 33% of cases
33%
Career Allowance Rate
1 granted / 3 resolved
-21.7% vs TC avg
Strong +100% interview lift
Without
With
+100.0%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
4y 0m
Avg Prosecution
25 currently pending
Career history
39
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
29.9%
-10.1% vs TC avg
§103
42.5%
+2.5% vs TC avg
§102
4.7%
-35.3% vs TC avg
§112
22.1%
-17.9% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 3 resolved cases

Office Action

§103 §112
DETAILED ACTION Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Responsive to communications on 06/20/2026 Claims 1-4, and 6-20 pending Claims 2-4, 6-9, 11, 13-17 and 19 original Claims 1, 10, 12, 18, and 20 amended Claim 5 canceled Claims 1-4, and 6-20 rejected Final Action Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a). A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action. Begin Response to Arguments Response to Claim Objections Claims 5, 10, 12, 18, and 20 were previously objected to for informalities. The claims have been amended to correct the informalities. Previous objections are withdrawn. Response to Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112 Claim 5 was previously rejected for being indefinite. Applicant has canceled dependent claim 5. Previous rejection is withdrawn. Response to Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103 Claims 1-20 were previously rejected as being unpatentable over “Development of an Efficient Embedded Discrete Fracture Model for 3D Compositional Reservoir Simulation in Fractured Reservoirs” by Ali Moinfar (Moinfar_2013) and further in view of “4. EDFM Demo Mauricio EDFM workshop video 4” by Sim Tech LLC (Sim_2021). Issue: Neither Moinfar 2013 nor Sim_2021, alone or in combination, teach or suggest the recitations of amended claims 1, 12, and 20. Specifically the claims have been amended to recite “3D subterranean modeling requiring data implementing multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults,” “the 3D modeling entailing non-planar hydraulic fractures wherein the hydraulic fracture digital data comprises a non-planar surface represented by a sequence of connected polygonal segments, each polygonal segment sharing at least two vertices with an adjacent polygonal segment, and wherein orientation changes between consecutive polygonal segments.” The claims further specify and clarify the three separate simulator modules. Rule: MPEP 2145 (IV) states “One cannot show nonobviousness by attacking references individually where the rejections are based on combinations of references.” Analysis: These issues are brought up in more detail in the arguments below. Examiner agrees Moinfar does not expressly recite the newly added limitations of “3D subterranean modeling requiring data implementing multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults,” and “the 3D modeling entailing non-planar hydraulic fractures wherein the hydraulic fracture digital data comprises a non-planar surface represented by a sequence of connected polygonal segments, each polygonal segment sharing at least two vertices with an adjacent polygonal segment, and wherein orientation changes between consecutive polygonal segments.” Since the amendments propose new subject matter, new prior art references are introduced. The prior art of Lei has been introduced to make obvious the 3D modeling including bedding layers and faults. And the prior art of Sepehrnoori has been introduced to make obvious the polygonal modeling of non-planar fractures. Conclusion: As the scope of the claim has been amended, new prior art may be introduced for amended claim limitations. New prior arts of Seperhrnoori and Lei have been introduced which make obvious the newly added limitations. Issue: Applicant clarifies Moinfar_2013 invention as discussing natural fractures and hydraulic fractures. With Chapter 8 describing large hydraulic fractures explicitly and numerous small natural fractures with a dual-continuum approach. Applicant argues invention applies three-dimensional discontinuities, incorporating multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults in the same domain which Moinfar_2013 does not recite. Rule: MPEP 2145 (IV) states “One cannot show nonobviousness by attacking references individually where the rejections are based on combinations of references.” Analysis: Examiner confirms prior art of Moinfar_2013 discusses the modeling of large hydraulic fractures explicitly (with EDFM) and numerous small natural fractures with a dual-continuum approach. Examiner points out that Moinfar_2013 does make obvious modeling both with EDFM see page 201 section 8.6 “Comparison of the results using the coupled dual continuum and EDFM approach with that of using the EDFM approach to represent all natural and hydraulic fractures explicitly shows that reasonably accurate results can be obtained at much lower computational time by using the coupled approach with moderate grid refinements.” Regarding the newly amended limitations which include “incorporating multiple discontinuity classes” from the DFN model, appendix A includes reference to a “Fault block” but it is unclear if it references faults in a software engineering or petroleum engineering sense, or if these faults refer specifically to the DFN. The prior art of Moinfar_2013 does reference layers, page 110 “The fractures are extended through different layers.” But this seems to reference the numeric layers of the EDFM model rather than the bedding layers as claimed. Therefore, a new reference was needed for the newly added claim limitations. Specifically, Lei has been introduced, which discusses the usage of faults and bedding layers for DFN modeling. Conclusion: Examiner confirms Moinfair_2013 does not contain the newly amended claim limitations. New prior art Lei has been introduced which makes obvious the newly added limitation. Issue: Applicant clarifies Moinfar_2013 invention as handling arbitrary-oriented fractures and inclined fracture planes using polygons that are primarily intersection polygons created when a fracture plane cuts a matrix gridblock - triangles, quadrilaterals, pentagons, or hexagons which the applicant argues are not input objects representing non-planar faults or hydraulic-fracture surfaces. Applicant argues the newly added limitations, which include “a non-planar surface represented by a sequence of connected polygonal segments, each polygonal segment sharing at least two vertices with an adjacent polygonal segment, and wherein orientation changes between consecutive polygonal segments” provides superior modeling that supports non-planar hydraulic fractures built from consecutive polygons, which is not found in Moinfar 2013. Rule: MPEP 2145 (IV) states “One cannot show nonobviousness by attacking references individually where the rejections are based on combinations of references.” Analysis: Examiner confirms Moinfar_2013 polygon fracture planes are caused by intersections. Page 56 shows this PNG media_image1.png 395 730 media_image1.png Greyscale Examiner also confirms Moinfar_2013 fractures to be angled slants rather than polygons which are connected to each other in a non-planar fashion as claimed. Page 196 shows this PNG media_image2.png 554 742 media_image2.png Greyscale Therefore, a new reference was needed for the newly added claim limitations. Sepehrnoori has been introduced, which discusses the modeling of complex and nonplanar geometries. Conclusion: Examiner confirms Moinfair_2013 does not contain the newly amended claim limitations. New prior art Sepehrnoori has been introduced which makes obvious the newly added limitation. Issue: Applicant argues the workflows of the present application and Moinfar_2013 differ. Applicant argues that Moinfar 2013 proposes a preprocessor that takes a reservoir description, fracture network, wells, matrix grid, aperture, permeability, porosity, etc., and prepares data for GPAS. That is not the same as a workflow that applies separate DFN software output+ separate hydraulic-fracture propagation software output + conversion into a third conventional reservoir simulator. Applicant clarifies invention as entailing three separate simulator modules. Rule: MPEP 2145 (IV) states “One cannot show nonobviousness by attacking references individually where the rejections are based on combinations of references.” Analysis: Under BRI, the examiner previously did not interpret a first and second simulator module to explicitly mean two separate software outputs which the data is received from. That is because the language of “module” under BRI led the examiner to associate it as a “part” of a whole. Applicant has clarified the language of the claim to include that the second simulator module is “separate” from the first simulator module. However, the examiner still understands these to still be allowed to be the same part of a whole simulation, as long as the parts are received or computed separately under BRI. Examiner notes that previous rejection incorporated Sim_2021 as including the different models, where “integrating explicit hydraulic fractures” was interpreted as the inclusion two simulator modules for DFN and HF data. Examiner has introduced prior art reference Rodriguez which makes clear the usage of a separate first DFN and second HF to be input into a third separate model. Conclusion: Examiner confirms Moinfair_2013 does not contain the newly amended claim limitations. New prior art Rodriguez has been introduced which makes obvious the newly added limitation. End Response to Arguments Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103 The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action: A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made. “Claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Moinfar_2013 “Development of an Efficient Embedded Discrete Fracture Model for 3D Compositional Reservoir Simulation in Fractured Reservoirs,” Rodriguez_2018 (US 20180230784 A1) , Sepehrnoori_2020 (US 20200200929 A1), and Lei_2017 (“The use of discrete fracture networks for modelling coupled Geomechanical and hydrological behaviour of fractured rocks”) Claim 1:Moinfar makes obvious A system for simulating a subterranean region having fracture geometries, comprising: (page viii par 1: “We developed an embedded discrete fracture model (EDFM) for an in-house fully-implicit compositional reservoir simulator.”)at least one processor configured with non-transitory instructions, which when executed cause the processor to perform functions including to: (par 31: “The EOS and chemical compositional modules of GPAS are developed under this framework and thus, multi-processor simulations are feasible using GPAS”). obtain module, page 60: “We have developed a pre-processing code to provide the required data for fluid flow simulations in GPAS. The input of the pre-processing code is the description of the model reservoir including the reservoir dimensions, fracture network, location of wells, structured grid for the matrix domain, aperture and permeability of fractures, and porosity and permeability of matrix. The following calculations are carried out in the preprocessing code:” page 96 par 3: “To evaluate the impact of grid resolution on accuracy of the EDFM approach, we also performed a mesh sensitivity study for the case in the absence of capillary pressure contrasts. Retaining the same fracture network, we examined three additional EDFM simulations that use uniform 40×40×1, 50×50×1, and 80×80×1 matrix grids, respectively, to check the convergence of the method as the grid is refined.” Examiner note: this passage indicates that a fracture network digital data is used for EDFM simulations. Where the same fracture network being used in different matrix grids shows that this is an independent fracture network from the EDFM simulation module. Page 110 par 1: “In most simulation studies performed in the past, natural fractures were assumed to be vertical in the subsurface. However, the new implementation of the EDFM approach presented in this research provides an effective and reliable environment to model obliquely dipping fractures. Hence, the third example examines water-flooding into a 3D model reservoir shown in Figure 6.14, comprising 13 inclined fractures. The fractures are extended through different layers. We also investigate the effect of fracture inclination in this example. The dip angle of fractures ranges from 55 to 90 degrees. The matrix grid is 20×20×4, with cell dimensions of 25×25×20 ft in the x, y, and z directions, respectively.” Examiner note: This passage specifies the use of a 3D model PNG media_image3.png 543 834 media_image3.png Greyscale Examiner note: Where figure 8.13 makes obvious the information received contains both hydraulic and natural fractures. Where this is the model input which gets simulated. Page 195:” Here, we simulate natural gas production from a synthetic 3D tight reservoir model shown in Figure 8.13.” obtain page 60: “We have developed a pre-processing code to provide the required data for fluid flow simulations in GPAS. The input of the pre-processing code is the description of the model reservoir including the reservoir dimensions, fracture network, location of wells, structured grid for the matrix domain, aperture and permeability of fractures, and porosity and permeability of matrix. The following calculations are carried out in the preprocessing code:” page 96 par 3: “To evaluate the impact of grid resolution on accuracy of the EDFM approach, we also performed a mesh sensitivity study for the case in the absence of capillary pressure contrasts. Retaining the same fracture network, we examined three additional EDFM simulations that use uniform 40×40×1, 50×50×1, and 80×80×1 matrix grids, respectively, to check the convergence of the method as the grid is refined.” Examiner note: this passage indicates that a fracture network digital data is used for EDFM simulations. Where the same fracture network being used in different matrix grids shows that this is an independent fracture network from the EDFM simulation module. Page 110 par 1: “In most simulation studies performed in the past, natural fractures were assumed to be vertical in the subsurface. However, the new implementation of the EDFM approach presented in this research provides an effective and reliable environment to model obliquely dipping fractures. Hence, the third example examines water-flooding into a 3D model reservoir shown in Figure 6.14, comprising 13 inclined fractures. The fractures are extended through different layers. We also investigate the effect of fracture inclination in this example. The dip angle of fractures ranges from 55 to 90 degrees. The matrix grid is 20×20×4, with cell dimensions of 25×25×20 ft in the x, y, and z directions, respectively.” Examiner note: This passage specifies the use of a 3D model PNG media_image3.png 543 834 media_image3.png Greyscale Examiner note: Where figure 8.13 makes obvious the information received contains both hydraulic and natural fractures. Where this is the model input which gets simulated. Page 195: ”Here, we simulate natural gas production from a synthetic 3D tight reservoir model shown in Figure 8.13.” convert the digital data page 43: “The implementation of EDFM includes two parts: [Symbol font/0xB7] Pre-processing of a fracture network with any geometry over an arbitrary grid to provide the required data for reservoir simulation” Examiner note: Where this pre-processing of a fracture network is a conversion of the fracture network into EDFM format. d) produce a computational domain separate from the first digital simulator module and the second digital simulator module; page 50 par 1: “Figure 4.4 specifies all gridblocks containing a segment of a fracture for both layers. Cells containing a segment of the black fracture are marked with black circles and those containing a segment of the red fracture are marked with red squares. In contrast to vertical fractures that cross similar gridblocks in different computational layers, inclined fractures may cross a different number of gridblocks in each layer, as shown in Figure 4.4. For the example under consideration, the black fracture penetrates 14 cells in the top computational layer while penetrating only 9 cells in the bottom one. Unlike the black fracture, the red fracture crosses more gridblocks in the bottom computational layer than in the top one.” (Examiner note: Based on the examiners understanding, figures 4.4 and 4.5 depict a computational domain/layer separate from the first or second digital “physical” simulators) e) input the converted digital EDFM format data from step (c) into the computational domain to produce output data; (page 60 par 3: “We have developed a pre-processing code to provide the required data (Examiners note: output data) for fluid-flow simulations in GPAS. The input of the pre-processing code is the description of the model reservoir including the reservoir dimensions, fracture network, location of wells, structured grid for the matrix domain, aperture and permeability of fractures, and porosity and permeability of matrix (Examiners note: this input as described is the digital EDFM format data). The following calculations are carried out in the pre-processing code:”) Examiners note: Where these calculations are output data. See also table 4.2 in page 66 which outlines an example step of the methodology. As shown, this produces data such as “fracture porosity” and other data. Examiner note: The examiner would like to make a note to remove confusion from understanding and mapping. Previously, the examiner states that the preprocessing was a conversion of the fracture network into EDFM format. Then the examiner stated that the preprocessing is a conversion of the EDFM format data into output data. As the examiner understands, this pre-processing does do both functions. The pre-processing takes in the fracture network and layers into onto an arbitrary grid (converts to EDFM format) and also produces output data to be simulated. f) input the output data of step (e) into a third digital simulator module page 60 par 3: “We have developed a pre-processing code to provide the required data (Examiner note: the required data in this context is the output data of step (e).) for fluid-flow simulations in GPAS (Examiners note: This is the third digital simulator module). … page 62 par 1: “The entire model, including the matrix grid and fracture control volumes, (Examiner note: this is the output of step (e)) is entered into a reservoir simulator, which allows for non-neighboring connections and transmissibility modifiers” g) generate a simulation of the subterranean region with the third digital simulator module. page 62 par 1: “The entire model, including the matrix grid and fracture control volumes, is entered into a reservoir simulator, which allows for non-neighboring connections and transmissibility modifiers” … page 114 gives an example of a simulation “Figure 6.18 shows the pressure profiles after 150 days of production, computed by the EDFM approach. Pressure profiles in all three numerical layers are presented in Figure 6.18, depicting different pressure depletion patterns in various layers because of the presence of randomly-generated fractures. Also, Figure 6.19 shows the oil production rate and average reservoir pressure over two years of production. The computational time of the simulation (Examiner note: this is the third simulation that uses the fracture network information as well as the information computed by the EDFM approach/ format data) was 3.31 hours.” Moinfar does not expressly recite wherein the model comprises multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults; separate from the first digital simulator module, wherein the hydraulic fracture digital data comprises anon-planar surface represented by a sequence of connected polygonal segments, each polygonal segment sharing at least two vertices with an adjacent polygonal segment, and wherein orientation changes between consecutive polygonal segments; separate from the first and second digital simulator modules; and Rodriguez however makes obvious par 85: “Par 85: “As shown, a zone set/structure grid 552 includes Young's modulus (YME), Poisson's ratio (PR), pore pressure (Pp), and in situ stresses (St). This grid is input into the fracture simulator 554.1 of the fracture simulator 556 to simulate a hydraulic fracture network 558.1 the hydraulic fracture network 558.1 and a discrete fracture network 559 are coupled to the finite element simulator 560.”) Par 85: “As shown, a zone set/structure grid 552 includes Young's modulus (YME), Poisson's ratio (PR), pore pressure (Pp), and in situ stresses (St). This grid is input into the fracture simulator 554.1 of the fracture simulator 556 to simulate a hydraulic fracture network 558.1 the hydraulic fracture network 558.1 and a discrete fracture network 559 are coupled to the finite element simulator 560. separate from the first digital simulator module, PNG media_image4.png 393 655 media_image4.png Greyscale Par 85: “As shown, a zone set/structure grid 552 includes Young's modulus (YME), Poisson's ratio (PR), pore pressure (Pp), and in situ stresses (St). This grid is input into the fracture simulator 554.1 of the fracture simulator 556 to simulate a hydraulic fracture network 558.1 the hydraulic fracture network 558.1 and a discrete fracture network 559 are coupled to the finite element simulator 560. Examiner note: See figure 5 above, where the hydraulic fracture network 558.1 is separate from the discrete fracture network 559. PNG media_image4.png 393 655 media_image4.png Greyscale Examiner note: Where figure 5 shows the outputs from both steps being used as inputs to a third step. separate from the first and second digital simulator modules; and Par 85: “As shown, a zone set/structure grid 552 includes Young's modulus (YME), Poisson's ratio (PR), pore pressure (Pp), and in situ stresses (St). This grid is input into the fracture simulator 554.1 of the fracture simulator 556 to simulate a hydraulic fracture network 558.1 the hydraulic fracture network 558.1 and a discrete fracture network 559 are coupled to the finite element simulator 560. Examiner note: See figure 5 above, where the hydraulic fracture network 558.1 is separate from the discrete fracture network 559 which is separate from the third model 560. Moinfar and Rodriguez are analogous art to the claimed invention because they are from the same field of endeavor called reservoir modeling. Before the effective filing date, it would have been obvious to a person ordinarily skilled in the art to combine Moinfar and Rodriguez. The rational for doing so would have been applying a known technique to a known device (method, or product) ready for improvement to yield predictable results The prior art of Moinfar is a base device which Takes information from a model and uses it to simulate natural gas production using an EDFM approach. See for example section 8.4.2 page 195: “Hydraulic fracture planes are not always vertical, especially when fracturing fluid opens up non-vertical natural fractures during stimulation treatment. Here, we simulate natural gas production from a synthetic 3D tight reservoir model shown in Figure 8.13. The reservoir dimensions are 2000×1000×100 ft. The model contains three hydraulic fractures, represented by blue planes in Figure 8.13, with 500-ft spacing. … Furthermore, the reservoir comprises 1892 small-scale natural fractures, presented by red planes in Figure 8.13” The prior art of Rodriquez has a known technique applicable to the base device. While using separate DFN and Hydraulic fracture data. Rodriguez states par 32: “The methods use geomechanical parameters, such as microseismic events, formation stresses, and reactive fracture displacement, based on fracture wellsite parameters (e.g., temperature, pressure, and fracture geometry) and reservoir wellsite parameters (e.g., pressure, flow rate, and permeability) to determine production parameters (e.g., pressure, production flow rate, and permeability). The methods and systems may be performed by coupling various simulators, such as a fracture simulator (e.g., UFM®, MANGROVE™), a reservoir simulator (e.g., INTERSECT™ or ECLIPSE™), a geomechanic simulator (e.g., VISAGE™), and/or other simulators (e.g., MANGROVE™ and/or PETREL™), to generate fracture parameters (e.g., microseismic events, stress planes of a natural fracture network) resulting from stress changes at the wellsite. Modeling software and/or simulators that may be used, such as UFM™, INTERSECT™, ECLIPSE™, VISAGE™, MANGROVE™, and PETREL™, are commercially available from SCHLUMBERGER TECHNOLOGY CORPORATION™ at www.slb.com.” One ordinarily skilled in the art would have recognized this technique applicable to the base device of Moinfar. Moinfar states page 68: “The EDFM approach is compatible with reservoir simulators that allow for NNCs and transmissibility modifiers (such as commercial reservoir simulators).” Therefore it would have been obvious to apply the known technique of utilizing separate sources for the DFN and HF by coupling different commercial sources and simulators from Rodriguez to the EDFM workflow of Moinfar which is comparable with commercial reservoir simulators, and would require the data to be gathered in production when using the workflow which would allow the EDFM approach to be used for modeling gas production to obtain the invention as specified in the claims. Moinfar and Rodriguez do not expressly recite wherein the model comprises multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults; wherein the hydraulic fracture digital data comprises anon-planar surface represented by a sequence of connected polygonal segments, each polygonal segment sharing at least two vertices with an adjacent polygonal segment, and wherein orientation changes between consecutive polygonal segments; Sepehrnoori however makes obvious wherein the hydraulic fracture digital data comprises anon-planar surface (par 7 :” Transient flow around hydraulic fractures has long been an important topic in tight reservoirs. During hydraulic fracturing, complex fracture networks may be generated due to a stress shadow effect or pre-existing natural fractures” … par 66: “Through non-neighboring connections (NNCs), an embedded discrete fracture modeling (EDFM) formulation is applied to data representing a subterranean region to accurately model or simulate formations with complex geometries such as fracture networks and nonplanar fractures (Examiner note: Where this data received incorporates hydraulic fractures).” represented by a sequence of connected polygonal segments, each polygonal segment sharing at least two vertices with an adjacent polygonal segment, and wherein orientation changes between consecutive polygonal segments; PNG media_image5.png 285 471 media_image5.png Greyscale Par 45: “FIG. 14, in accordance with some embodiments of the present disclosure, depicts a schematic of the modeling of a nonplanar fracture;” Moinfar, Rodriguez, and Sepehrnoori are analogous art to the claimed invention because they are from the same field of endeavor called reservoir modeling. Before the effective filing date, it would have been obvious to a person ordinarily skilled in the art to combine Moinfar, Rodriguez, and Sepehrnoori. The rational for doing so would have been to follow a teaching proposed in the prior art. Moinfar states par 170: “Another substantial challenge for unconventional reservoir simulations is the presence of complex hydraulic fracture geometry. Warpinski et al. (1993) and Fast et al. (1994) presented observations of multi-stranded fracture propagation in cores drilled across expected hydraulic fracture planes and challenged the conventional assumption of single, planar hydraulic fracture propagation.” As outlined above, Moinfar outlines the challenges of modeling complex hydraulic fracture geometry using EDFM simulations. Sepehrnoori provides a methofology for modeling complex hydraulic fracture geometry using EDFM simulations in particular through modeling with connected polynomial sections using the same EDFM workflow as Moinfar. Therefore it would have been obvious to combine the nonplanar hydraulic fracture geometry of Sepehrnoori with the modeling workflow of Moinfar for the benefit of tacking the problem of complex geometry in unconventional reservoir simulations to obtain the invention as specified in the claims. Moinfar, Rodriguez and Sepehrnoori do not expressly recite wherein the [dfn] model comprises multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults; Lei however makes obvious wherein the [dfn] model comprises multiple discontinuity classes including bedding layers and faults; (page 152 col 2 par 2: “A ‘‘discrete fracture network” (DFN) refers to a computational model that explicitly represents the geometrical properties of each individual fracture (e.g. orientation, size, position, shape and aperture), and the topological relationships between individual fractures and fracture sets. Unlike the conventional definition of DFNs that corresponds to stochastic fracture networks, the term DFN here represents a much broader concept of any explicit fracture network model. A DFN can be generated from geological map ping, stochastic realisation or geomechanical simulation to represent different types of rock fractures including joints, faults, veins and bedding planes.”) Moinfar and Lei are analogous art to the claimed invention because they are from the same field of endeavor called reservoir modeling. Before the effective filing date, it would have been obvious to a person ordinarily skilled in the art to combine Moinfar and lei. The rational for doing so would have been to follow a teaching proposed in the prior art. Moinfar models fractures but does not expressly recite the specific presence of bedding layers and faults in the modeled fracture network. Lei states introduction par 1: “Fractures such as joints, faults, veins and bedding planes are ubiquitous in crustal rocks. These naturally occurring discontinuities often comprise complex networks and dominate the geomechanical and hydrological behaviour of subsurface rocks [1]. Understanding of the nontrivial effect of fractures is a challenging issue which is relevant to many engineering applications such as underground construction, enhanced geothermal systems, unconventional shale gas production (fracking), groundwater management and radioactive waste disposal [2–4]. The importance of the presence of natural fractures, which can result in heterogeneous stress fields [5] and channelized fluid flow pathways [6] in highly disordered geological formations, has promoted the development of robust fracture network models for numerical simulation of fractured rocks” Moinfar also discusses modeling of these natural fractures for shale gas specifically, see page 170 par 2 :” Many shale gas units and tight sandstones contain numerous embedded natural fractures, making the numerical simulation of these unconventional reservoirs more challenging.” Therefore it would have been obvious to combine the EDFM modeling workflow of Moinfar which takes in a 3D fracture model with the presence of faults and bedding layers of Lei in the received DFN for the benefit of simulating non-trivial fracture discontinuities which are relevant in shale gas modeling to obtain the invention as specified in the claims. Claim 2: The system of claim 1 wherein: Moinfar_2013 makes obvious the function of step (d) includes to produce a matrix grid in the produced computational domain; (page 50 par 1: “Figure 4.4 specifies all gridblocks containing a segment of a fracture for both layers. Cells containing a segment of the black fracture are marked with black circles and those containing a segment of the red fracture are marked with red squares. In contrast to vertical fractures that cross similar gridblocks in different computational layers, inclined fractures may cross a different number of gridblocks in each layer, as shown in Figure 4.4. For the example under consideration, the black fracture penetrates 14 cells in the top computational layer while penetrating only 9 cells in the bottom one. Unlike the black fracture, the red fracture crosses more gridblocks in the bottom computational layer than in the top one.” (Examiner note: Where “cells” are the cells of the matrix grid) the function of step (e) includes to identify geometric relationships between the converted digital EDFM format data and matrix cells in the matrix grid. (page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Check the intersection of each fracture plane (Examiner note: EDFM format data) with all matrix gridblocks and determine the exact specification of intersections.” ) Claim 3:The system of claim 2 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein the function of step (e) includes to create at least one new rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell in the computational domain (par 44: “The model uses a structured grid to represent the matrix, and introduces additional fracture control volumes by computing the intersection of fractures with the matrix grid” (Examiner note: see claim interpretation, this process as outlined is the creation of a “new” cell ))and identify a geometric relationship between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid. (page 60 under pre-processing step: “Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock (Examiner note: cell in matrix grid) containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 4:The system of claim 3 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein the function of step (e) includes to identify a non- neighboring connection between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid. (Page 51 fig. 4.5 description: Arrangement of fracture cells in the fracture domain for (a) layer 1, and (b) layer 2 of the model shown in Figure 4.3. Fracture cells are marked and numbered in this figure, which correspond to those in Figure 4.4. The blue dashed lines represent non-neighboring connections (NNC) for the intersection of two fractures. Also, the green dashed line represents only one example of NNC between two cells of an individual fracture. … page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Calculate the number of NNCs for each computational gridblock either in the matrix domain or in the fracture domain”) Claim 6: The system of claim 3 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein the function to identify a geometric relationship between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid comprises identification of a connection between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a matrix grid cell corresponding to one or more subsurface rock discontinuities or hydraulic fractures. (page 60 under pre-processing steps: “Check the intersection of each fracture plane with all matrix gridblocks and determine the exact specification of intersections. • Check if any two fracture planes intersect and identify the gridblocks in which the intersection lies. • Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 7:The system of claim 3 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein the function of step (e) includes to calculate a fluid flow transmissibility factor between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid. (page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Calculate the transmissibility factors in the x, y, and z directions for the fracture control volumes in the fracture domain.” … page 64 explains some of the pre-processing steps: “The fourth column presents the transmissibility of NNCs between corresponding matrix and fracture cells.”) Claim 8: The system of claim 7 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein the function of step (g) includes to generate the simulation of the subterranean region using the calculated fluid flow transmissibility factor. (Page 62: “The entire model, including the matrix grid and fracture control volumes, is entered into a reservoir simulator, which allows for non-neighboring connections and transmissibility modifiers. The governing equations for fracture control volumes are similar to those described for the matrix medium, implying that Darcy’s law is used in the fracture domain. In order to implement the EDFM approach in GPAS, we have added the NNC term to the mass balance equations, as previously described in Equations 4.2 and 4.3. In doing so, the residual vector and the Jacobian matrix (see Chapter 3) are augmented with additional terms associated with NNCs. Other modifications to GPAS have also been implemented to properly include the parameters calculated in the pre-processing code. These parameters include porosity, permeability, and depth of fracture control volumes, transmissibility factors between NNCs, transmissibility factors between adjacent fracture cells, and well indices for the fractures intercepted by a well. Also, we have made necessary changes to bypass all calculations carried out for the dead blocks in the fracture domain.” Claim 9: The system of claim 2 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein the function of step (e) includes to create a plurality of new rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells in the computational domain (page 44: “The model uses a structured grid to represent the matrix, and introduces additional fracture control volumes by computing the intersection of fractures with the matrix grid” (Examiner note: see claim interpretation, this process as outlined is the creation of a “new” cell )) and identify geometric relationships between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells. (page 60 under pre-processing step: “Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock (Examiner note: cell in matrix grid) containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 10: The system of claim 9 Moinfar makes obvious wherein the function to identify geometric relationships between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells comprises identification of connections between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells corresponding to one or more subsurface rock discontinuities or hydraulic fractures. (page 60 under pre-processing steps: “Check the intersection of each fracture plane with all matrix gridblocks and determine the exact specification of intersections. [Symbol font/0xB7] Check if any two fracture planes intersect and identify the gridblocks in which the intersection lies. [Symbol font/0xB7] Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 11:The system of claim 9 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein: the function of step (e) includes to calculate fluid flow transmissibility factors between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells; (page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Calculate the transmissibility factors in the x, y, and z directions for the fracture control volumes in the fracture domain.”) the function of step (g) includes to generate the simulation of the subterranean region using the calculated fluid flow transmissibility factors. (Page 62: “The entire model, including the matrix grid and fracture control volumes, is entered into a reservoir simulator, which allows for non-neighboring connections and transmissibility modifiers. The governing equations for fracture control volumes are similar to those described for the matrix medium, implying that Darcy’s law is used in the fracture domain. In order to implement the EDFM approach in GPAS, we have added the NNC term to the mass balance equations, as previously described in Equations 4.2 and 4.3. In doing so, the residual vector and the Jacobian matrix (see Chapter 3) are augmented with additional terms associated with NNCs. Other modifications to GPAS have also been implemented to properly include the parameters calculated in the pre-processing code. These parameters include porosity, permeability, and depth of fracture control volumes, transmissibility factors between NNCs, transmissibility factors between adjacent fracture cells, and well indices for the fractures intercepted by a well. Also, we have made necessary changes to bypass all calculations carried out for the dead blocks in the fracture domain.”) Claim 12:Claim 12 is substantially similar to claim 1, except that it pertains to A method (Moinfar page 171 col 1: “Hence, we have developed a coupled dual continuum and discrete fracture method to simulate production from unconventional reservoirs. Large-scale hydraulic fractures (macrofractures are modeled explicitly using EDFM and numerous small-scale natural fractures (micro-fractures) are modeled using a dual continuum approach.”) Therefore claim 12 is rejected under a similar rational to claim 1. Claim 13: The method of claim 12 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein: producing a computational domain comprises producing a matrix grid in the computational domain; (page 50 par 1: “Figure 4.4 specifies all gridblocks containing a segment of a fracture for both layers. Cells containing a segment of the black fracture are marked with black circles and those containing a segment of the red fracture are marked with red squares. In contrast to vertical fractures that cross similar gridblocks in different computational layers, inclined fractures may cross a different number of gridblocks in each layer, as shown in Figure 4.4. For the example under consideration, the black fracture penetrates 14 cells in the top computational layer while penetrating only 9 cells in the bottom one. Unlike the black fracture, the red fracture crosses more gridblocks in the bottom computational layer than in the top one.” (Examiner note: Where “cells” are the cells of the matrix grid) inputting the converted digital EDFM format data into the computational domain comprises identifying geometric relationships between the EDFM format data and matrix cells in the matrix grid. (page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Check the intersection of each fracture plane (Examiner note: EDFM format data) with all matrix gridblocks and determine the exact specification of intersections.” ) Claim 14:The method of claim 13 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein inputting the converted digital EDFM format data into the computational domain comprises creating at least one new rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell in the computational domain (par 44: “The model uses a structured grid to represent the matrix, and introduces additional fracture control volumes by computing the intersection of fractures with the matrix grid” (Examiner note: see claim interpretation, this process as outlined is the creation of a “new” cell )) and identifying a geometric relationship between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid. (page 60 under pre-processing step: “Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock (Examiner note: cell in matrix grid) containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 15:The method of claim 14 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein inputting the converted digital EDFM format data into the computational domain comprises identifying a non-neighboring connection between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid. (Page 51 fig. 4.5 description: Arrangement of fracture cells in the fracture domain for (a) layer 1, and (b) layer 2 of the model shown in Figure 4.3. Fracture cells are marked and numbered in this figure, which correspond to those in Figure 4.4. The blue dashed lines represent non-neighboring connections (NNC) for the intersection of two fractures. Also, the green dashed line represents only one example of NNC between two cells of an individual fracture. … page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Calculate the number of NNCs for each computational gridblock either in the matrix domain or in the fracture domain”) Claim 16:The method of claim 14 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein identifying a geometric relationship between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a cell in the matrix grid comprises identifying a connection between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and a matrix grid cell corresponding to one or more subsurface rock discontinuities or hydraulic fractures. (page 60 under pre-processing steps: “Check the intersection of each fracture plane with all matrix gridblocks and determine the exact specification of intersections. • Check if any two fracture planes intersect and identify the gridblocks in which the intersection lies. • Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 17: The method of claim 14 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein inputting the converted digital EDFM format data into the computational domain comprises calculating a fluid flow transmissibility factor between the at least one new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cell and the cell in the matrix grid; (page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Calculate the transmissibility factors in the x, y, and z directions for the fracture control volumes in the fracture domain.” … page 64 explains some of the pre-processing steps: “The fourth column presents the transmissibility of NNCs between corresponding matrix and fracture cells.”) and generating the simulation of the subterranean region comprises generating the simulation using the calculated fluid flow transmissibility factor. (Page 62: “The entire model, including the matrix grid and fracture control volumes, is entered into a reservoir simulator, which allows for non-neighboring connections and transmissibility modifiers. The governing equations for fracture control volumes are similar to those described for the matrix medium, implying that Darcy’s law is used in the fracture domain. In order to implement the EDFM approach in GPAS, we have added the NNC term to the mass balance equations, as previously described in Equations 4.2 and 4.3. In doing so, the residual vector and the Jacobian matrix (see Chapter 3) are augmented with additional terms associated with NNCs. Other modifications to GPAS have also been implemented to properly include the parameters calculated in the pre-processing code. These parameters include porosity, permeability, and depth of fracture control volumes, transmissibility factors between NNCs, transmissibility factors between adjacent fracture cells, and well indices for the fractures intercepted by a well. Also, we have made necessary changes to bypass all calculations carried out for the dead blocks in the fracture domain.” Claim 18: The method of claim 13 Moinfar_2013 makes obvious wherein inputting the converted digital EDFM format data into the computational domain comprises creating a plurality of new rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells in the computational domain (page 44: “The model uses a structured grid to represent the matrix, and introduces additional fracture control volumes by computing the intersection of fractures with the matrix grid” (Examiner note: see claim interpretation, this process as outlined is the creation of a “new” cell )) and identifying geometric relationships between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells by identifying connections between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells corresponding to one or more subsurface rock discontinuities or hydraulic fractures. (page 60 under pre-processing steps: “Check the intersection of each fracture plane with all matrix gridblocks and determine the exact specification of intersections. [Symbol font/0xB7] Check if any two fracture planes intersect and identify the gridblocks in which the intersection lies. [Symbol font/0xB7] Determine the arrangement of fracture control volumes in the fracture domain. Corresponding to each gridblock containing a segment of a fracture, a fracture 61 control volume should be defined in the fracture domain. Figure 4.5 presented an example of fracture arrangement for a simple 3D model reservoir. Furthermore, arrangement of fracture cells leads to the identification of dead blocks”) Claim 19:The method of claim 18 wherein: Moinfar_2013 makes obvious inputting the converted digital EDFM format data into the computational domain comprises calculating fluid flow transmissibility factors between the new created rock discontinuity or hydraulic fracture cells; (page 60 under pre-processing code which is interpreted as the function of step (e), outlines processes including: “Calculate the transmissibility factors in the x, y, and z directions for the fracture control volumes in the fracture domain.”) generating the simulation of the subterranean region comprises using the calculated fluid flow transmissibility factors. (Page 62: “The entire model, including the matrix grid and fracture control volumes, is entered into a reservoir simulator, which allows for non-neighboring connections and transmissibility modifiers. The governing equations for fracture control volumes are similar to those described for the matrix medium, implying that Darcy’s law is used in the fracture domain. In order to implement the EDFM approach in GPAS, we have added the NNC term to the mass balance equations, as previously described in Equations 4.2 and 4.3. In doing so, the residual vector and the Jacobian matrix (see Chapter 3) are augmented with additional terms associated with NNCs. Other modifications to GPAS have also been implemented to properly include the parameters calculated in the pre-processing code. These parameters include porosity, permeability, and depth of fracture control volumes, transmissibility factors between NNCs, transmissibility factors between adjacent fracture cells, and well indices for the fractures intercepted by a well. Also, we have made necessary changes to bypass all calculations carried out for the dead blocks in the fracture domain.”) Claim 20:Claim 20 is substantially similar to claim 1, except that it pertains to A non-transitory computer-readable medium, embodying instructions for simulating a subterranean region having fracture geometries which when executed by a computer cause the computer to perform a plurality of functions, including functions to: (Moinfar page viii par 1: “We developed an embedded discrete fracture model (EDFM) for an in-house fully-implicit compositional reservoir simulator.” … par 31: “The EOS and chemical compositional modules of GPAS are developed under this framework and thus, multi-processor simulations are feasible using GPAS”). Therefore claim 20 is rejected under a similar rational to claim 1. Conclusion The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure. Xu_2017 (“Discrete-Fracture Modeling of Complex Hydraulic-Fracture Geometries in Reservoir Simulators”) discusses EDFM modeling with complex hydraulic fracture geometries using segments. Sepehrnoori_2021 (US 10914140 B2) incorporated by reference in this application. Discusses many of the EDFM modeling simulation steps. Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to AHMAD HUSSAM SHALABY whose telephone number is (571)272-7414. The examiner can normally be reached Mon-Fri 7:30am - 5pm. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Emerson Puente can be reached at 5712723652. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /A.H.S./Examiner, Art Unit 2187 /EMERSON C PUENTE/Supervisory Patent Examiner, Art Unit 2187
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Sep 04, 2022
Application Filed
Jan 21, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §103, §112
Jun 20, 2026
Response Filed
Sep 14, 2026
Final Rejection mailed — §103, §112 (current)

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

3-4
Expected OA Rounds
33%
Grant Probability
99%
With Interview (+100.0%)
4y 0m (~0m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
Moderate
PTA Risk
Based on 3 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month