DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Continued Examination Under 37 CFR 1.114
A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114. Applicant's submission filed on 09 September 2026 has been entered.
Status of Claims
An amendment filed 09/09/2026 is acknowledged.
Claims 1-12, and 21-28 are pending.
Claim 13-20 have been canceled.
Claims 1, 21, and 28 have been amended, however, amendment finds support in the paragraph [0074] and [0083] of the instant specification of the discloser, therefore, no new matter is presented.
Therefore, claims claim 1-12 and 21-28 are under examination on the merits for this office action.
Status of Previous Rejections
The previous 35 USC § 112(b) second paragraph rejections of the claims have been withdrawn.
The previous 35 USC § 102 and 35 USC § 103 rejections of the claims have been withdrawn, due to amendment of the claim 1, 24 and 28.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis (i.e., changing from AIA to pre-AIA ) for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made.
The factual inquiries for establishing a background for determining obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103 are summarized as follows:
1. Determining the scope and contents of the prior art.
2. Ascertaining the differences between the prior art and the claims at issue.
3. Resolving the level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art.
4. Considering objective evidence present in the application indicating obviousness or nonobviousness.
This application currently names joint inventors. In considering patentability of the claims the examiner presumes that the subject matter of the various claims was commonly owned as of the effective filing date of the claimed invention(s) absent any evidence to the contrary. Applicant is advised of the obligation under 37 CFR 1.56 to point out the inventor and effective filing dates of each claim that was not commonly owned as of the effective filing date of the later invention in order for the examiner to consider the applicability of 35 U.S.C. 102(b)(2)(C) for any potential 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(2) prior art against the later invention.
Claim 1 and 8-10 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] and in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter).
Regarding Claim 1, Liu discloses a full cycle regeneration process method of waste lead acid batteries [Col. 13, line 64-67] includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (smashing the waste lead acid battery in a mixture of grid lead, lead mud (equivalent to lead paste) and waste electrolyte, i.e., the diluted sulfuric acid) [Col. 14, line 1-4].
agitating the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-16]. Vibration is a synonym for agitation, and the paragraph [00121] of the instant specification of the disclosure also defines “the term “agitating” as used herein is intended to have a broad meaning that includes both hammering and/or vibrating as these terms are disclosed or utilized herein”.
Liu then discloses, removing the lead alloy from the mixture to form slurry (less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen, this part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor. Grid lead is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen) [Liu’s Step (1) Col. 14, line 16-22] and the diachylon is a mixture consisting of lead sulfate (PbSO4), lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead monoxide (PbO) [Col. 14, line 35-42], therefore, diachylon is the lead based paste (according to the instant specification of the disclosure, "Background Section" and in the paragraph [0002], grid lead is defined as a lead alloy and lead-based paste typically comprises lead oxides and lead sulfates coated over the exposed surfaces of the lead-alloy grid).
performing solid-state electrolysis on the slurry to recover pure elemental lead (Liu’s Step (2): the lead mud obtained from Step (1) is filter pressed to separate the solid from the liquid, and the separated solid is diachylon, a mixture consisting of lead sulfate (PbSO4), lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead monoxide (PbO) [Col. 14, line 35-42] and then in Liu’s Step (3): desulphurization and deoxidation of diachylon are performed under airtight condition, wherein lead sulfate and the lead dioxide react to obtain lead monoxide (PbO) and sulfur trioxide (SO3) and then the obtained lead monoxide is reduced by solid phase electrolysis so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead [Col. 14, line 50-67, and Col. 15, line 19-58]. It is to be further noted, Liu’s process as described in [Col. 15, line 19-58] is same as the Solid-state electrolysis process as described in the paragraph [0067] of the instant specification of the disclosure.
But Liu is silent about utilizing an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode.
However, Nishio discloses an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode (a cathode liquor into a cathode compartment formed between a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode plate of gas-liquid impermeability, with which the membrane is wetted, then a mixed stream of the cathode liquor and cathode gas being removed from the cathode compartment, see Nishio’s Abstract).
Nishio then teaches a horizontal type electrolytic cell provided with an anode compartment located on a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode compartment under said membrane, it is characterized in that a gas-liquid impermeable cathode plate is placed in close proximity to or in contact with the cation exchange membrane, a cathode liquor stream is formed which flows in a space of the cathode compartment formed between the cation exchange membrane and the cathode plate, while the lower side of the membrane being wetted with the cathode liquor stream, a caustic alkali and hydrogen gas is enfolded in the cathode liquor stream immediately when prepared in the space of the cathode compartment and then removed from the cathode compartment. Cathode compartment being surrounded by a cathode plate having gas-liquid impermeability, side walls so as to enclose the cathode plate and the lower side of the membrane and provided with an inlet of cathode liquor and an outlet of a mixed stream of the cathode gas and the cathode liquor (see Nishio’s col. 2, line 30-67) These cation exchange membranes exhibit very small water permeability while hindering the passage of hydraulic flow (see Nishio’s col. 4, line 25-30).
Nishio is directed to electrolysis and therefore analogous to the instant claim and Liu.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Nishio’s teaching of using electrolyzer with horizontal cathode to modify Liu’s process of solid phase electrolysis step so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead while hindering the passage of any hydraulic flow of gas and liquid for efficient separation of the battery material.
Regarding Claim 8, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 8, wherein, Liu discloses the agitating comprises vibrating a container within which the mixture is contained (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-16]. Liu further anticipates said vibration sufficient to cause material movement within the mixture, as Liu discloses separating out of the materials within the mixture using the vibration screen (less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen. This part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor and Grid lead which is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen [Col. 14, line 16-22].
Regarding Claim 9, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 and 8 are applicable to claim 9, wherein, Liu discloses the container comprises a sieve through which the solution and the lead paste may pass but through which the lead alloy may not pass (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen and less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen. This part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor and Grid lead which is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-22].
Regarding Claim 10, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 and 9 are applicable to claim 10, in addition, Liu discloses the vibrating of the container at least in part facilitates passage of the solution and the lead paste through the sieve (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen and less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen. This part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor and Grid lead which is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-22].
Claim 2-6, and 12 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter) as applied to claim 1 and further in view of Albert E. La Point et.al. [US4018567].
Regarding Claim 2 and 3, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 2, wherein Liu teaches smashed and crushed waste battery is passes through a vibration screen (agitating) [Col. 14, line 14-16].
But both Liu and Nishio are silent about the agitating comprises rotational hammering of the mixture.
However, Albert discloses separating the constituents of lead-acid batteries having grid plates of antimonial lead, other lower grade alloy parts, active material consisting of lead, lead oxide, and lead sulfate, and organic material consisting of the battery case and separators [Col.3, line 20 – 24]. Albert’s disclosed process includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (shredded lead-acid batteries, sodium carbonate and water are fed into a rotating drum separator) [Col. 3, line 26-28].
agitating the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy (Agitation of the mixture, by internal drum features serves (a) to further fracture and degrade the battery fragments; (b) to form a bath or slurry in which fine particles of active material create a pseudo-heavy density liquid adapted to float the organic material there on and to permit the remaining battery fragments to sink; ( c) to transpose the finer lead sulfate particles into lead carbonate; and (d) to neutralize any battery acid which contaminates the slurry [Col. 3, line 28-37], and means for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68]).
Albert further discloses, removing the lead alloy from the mixture (The remaining sinkable fragments, consisting mainly of grid metal, are concentrated and discharged from a separate drum opening onto a second screen for further segregation by size) [Col. 3, line 41-44].
With respect to the term “hammering” in agitating step, as defined by the paragraph [00122] of the instant specification of the disclosure, “to create a hammering effect on the mass mixture ("hammering") to promote the physical detachment of the lead paste from the broken lead alloy grid components within the mixture” and claim 3 recites “the rotational hammering is achieved at least in part through use of a rotating drum”, as Albert discloses, a rotating drum [Col. 3, line 65-68] and the physical detachment of the lead paste from the broken lead alloy grid components within the mixture using drum velocity, controlling movements of battery fragments and efficient breakup by the grinding balls[Col. 4, line 3-8]. Therefore, Albert’s rotating drum is creating rotational hammering effect.
Albert is in the field of separating materials and therefore analogous to instant claim as well as Liu and Nishio.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 4, all the above discussions regarding claim 1-3 are applicable to claim 4, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the rotating drum comprises internal baffles that at least in part contribute to the rotational hammering.
However, Albert further teaches the rotating drum comprises internal baffles that at least in part contribute to the rotational hammering, (a helical scroll on the internal drum surface, aided by longitudinal lifter bars, advances sinkable battery fragments toward the second or opposite end of the drum until obstructed by a transverse baffle plate (internal baffles) which restricts further passage to all material larger than predetermined size. The larger fragments are therefore concentrated for efficient breakup by the grinding balls while means are provided for lifting the smaller fragments) [Col. 4, line 3-8].
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 5, all the above discussions regarding claim 1-4 are applicable to claim 5, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the rate of rotation of the rotating drum is maintained to achieve the rotational hammering of the mixture.
However, Albert further teaches a rate of rotation of the rotating drum is maintained to achieve the rotational hammering of the mixture (means are provided for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68] and the motion of the rotating drum both cleans and fractures the grid metal. The battery grids quickly loose most of their attached active material by the combined action of the water and the tumbling and shearing motion brought about by the drum rotation. The speed of rotation of the drum must be sufficient to maintain finer active material in suspension but not so great so to create centrifuging of solid fragments [Col. 7, line 1-9]).
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and clean separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 6, all the above discussions regarding claim 1-5 are applicable to claim 6, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the range is the rate of rotation at which the portions of the mass in the drum are lifted above a medial axis of the drum and subsequently fall back below the medial axis.
However, Albert further discloses the range is the rate of rotation at which the portions of the mass in the drum are lifted above a medial axis of the drum and subsequently fall back below the medial axis, (means are provided for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68]. Albert further teaches the longitudinal lifter bars raise both the grinding balls and the larger sinkable battery fragments, consisting mainly of grid metal and other lower grade lead alloy parts, out of the bath to a height dependent on drum speed and diameter [Col. 6, line 64-68], from which they fall back into the pulp or suspension. This motion both cleans and fractures the grid metal. The battery grids quickly loose most of their attached active material by the combined action of the water and the tumbling and shearing motion brought about by the drum rotation. The speed of rotation of the drum 10 must be sufficient to maintain finer active material in suspension but not so great so to create centrifuging of solid fragments [Col. 7, line 1-9].
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and clean separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 12, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 12, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the solution comprises at least one supplemental chemical that at least in part diminishes adherence of the lead paste to the lead alloy.
However, Albert discloses the solution comprises at least one supplemental chemical that at least in part diminishes adherence of the lead paste to the lead alloy (shredded lead-acid batteries, together with sodium carbonate and water are fed into a rotating drum separator, to transpose the finer lead sulfate particles into lead carbonate and to neutralize any battery acid which contaminates the slurry) [Col. 3, line 26-37].
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of supplemental chemical to modify Liu’s process for efficient separation of the battery materials and neutralizing the slurry to avoid contamination in the recycling operation.
Claims 21-24 and 26-28 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] and in view of Albert E. La Point et.al. [US4018567] and further in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter).
Regarding Claim 21, Liu discloses a full cycle regeneration process method of waste lead acid batteries [Col. 13, line 64-67] includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (smashing the waste lead acid battery in a mixture of grid lead, lead mud (equivalent to lead paste) and waste electrolyte, i.e., the diluted sulfuric acid) [Col. 14, line 1-4].
agitating the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-16]. Vibration is a synonym for agitation, and the paragraph [00121] of the instant specification of the disclosure also defines “the term “agitating” as used herein is intended to have a broad meaning that includes both hammering and/or vibrating as these terms are disclosed or utilized herein”.
Liu then discloses, removing the lead alloy from the mixture (less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen, this part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor. Grid lead is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen) [Liu’s Step (1) Col. 14, line 16-22] and the diachylon is a mixture consisting of lead sulfate (PbSO4), lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead monoxide (PbO) [Col. 14, line 35-42], therefore, diachylon is the lead based paste (according to the instant specification of the disclosure, "Background Section" and in the paragraph [0002], grid lead is defined as a lead alloy and lead-based paste typically comprises lead oxides and lead sulfates coated over the exposed surfaces of the lead-alloy grid).
performing solid-state electrolysis on the mixture to recover pure elemental lead (Liu’s Step (2): the lead mud obtained from Step (1) is filter pressed to separate the solid from the liquid, and the separated solid is diachylon, a mixture consisting of lead sulfate (PbSO4), lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead monoxide (PbO) [Col. 14, line 35-42] and then in Liu’s Step (3): desulphurization and deoxidation of diachylon are performed under airtight condition, wherein lead sulfate and the lead dioxide react to obtain lead monoxide (PbO) and sulfur trioxide (SO3) and then the obtained lead monoxide is reduced by solid phase electrolysis so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead [Col. 14, line 50-67, and Col. 15, line 19-58].
But Liu is silent about the rotational hammering of the mixture and an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode.
However, Albert discloses separating the constituents of lead-acid batteries having grid plates of antimonial lead, other lower grade alloy parts, active material consisting of lead, lead oxide, and lead sulfate, and organic material consisting of the battery case and separators [Col.3, line 20 – 24]. Albert’s disclosed process includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (shredded lead-acid batteries, sodium carbonate and water are fed into a rotating drum separator) [Col. 3, line 26-28].
agitating the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy (Agitation of the mixture, by internal drum features serves (a) to further fracture and degrade the battery fragments; (b) to form a bath or slurry in which fine particles of active material create a pseudo-heavy density liquid adapted to float the organic material there on and to permit the remaining battery fragments to sink; ( c) to transpose the finer lead sulfate particles into lead carbonate; and (d) to neutralize any battery acid which contaminates the slurry [Col. 3, line 28-37], and means for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68]).
Albert further discloses, removing the lead alloy from the mixture (The remaining sinkable fragments, consisting mainly of grid metal, are concentrated and discharged from a separate drum opening onto a second screen for further segregation by size) [Col. 3, line 41-44].
With respect to the term “hammering” in agitating step, as defined by the paragraph [00122] of the instant specification of the disclosure, “to create a hammering effect on the mass mixture ("hammering") to promote the physical detachment of the lead paste from the broken lead alloy grid components within the mixture” and claim 3 recites “the rotational hammering is achieved at least in part through use of a rotating drum”, as Albert discloses, a rotating drum [Col. 3, line 65-68] and the physical detachment of the lead paste from the broken lead alloy grid components within the mixture using drum velocity, controlling movements of battery fragments and efficient breakup by the grinding balls[Col. 4, line 3-8]. Therefore, Albert’s rotating drum is creating rotational hammering effect.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
But Albert is also silent about utilizing an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode.
However, Nishio discloses an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode (a cathode liquor into a cathode compartment formed between a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode plate of gas-liquid impermeability, with which the membrane is wetted, then a mixed stream of the cathode liquor and cathode gas being removed from the cathode compartment, see Nishio’s Abstract).
Nishio then teaches a horizontal type electrolytic cell provided with an anode compartment located on a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode compartment under said membrane, it is characterized in that a gas-liquid impermeable cathode plate is placed in close proximity to or in contact with the cation exchange membrane, a cathode liquor stream is formed which flows in a space of the cathode compartment formed between the cation exchange membrane and the cathode plate, while the lower side of the membrane being wetted with the cathode liquor stream, a caustic alkali and hydrogen gas is enfolded in the cathode liquor stream immediately when prepared in the space of the cathode compartment and then removed from the cathode compartment. Cathode compartment being surrounded by a cathode plate having gas-liquid impermeability, side walls so as to enclose the cathode plate and the lower side of the membrane, and provided with an inlet of cathode liquor and an outlet of a mixed stream of the cathode gas and the cathode liquor (see Nishio’s col. 2, line 30-67) These cation exchange membranes exhibit very small water permeability while hindering the passage of hydraulic flow (see Nishio’s col. 4, line 25-30).
Nishio is directed to electrolysis to separate materials and therefore analogous to the instant claim as well as Liu and Albert.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Nishio’s teaching of electrolyzer with horizontal cathode to modify Liu’s process of solid phase electrolysis step in view of Albert, so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead while hindering the passage of any hydraulic flow of gas and liquid for efficient separation of the battery material.
Regarding Claim 22, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 2, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the agitating comprises rotational hammering of the mixture.
However, Albert discloses the rotational hammering is achieved at least in part through use of a rotating drum (means for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries [Col. 3, line 65-68]).
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 23, all the above discussions regarding claim 1-3 are applicable to claim 4, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the rotating drum comprises internal baffles that at least in part contribute to the rotational hammering.
However, Albert further teaches the rotating drum comprises internal baffles that at least in part contribute to the rotational hammering, (a helical scroll on the internal drum surface, aided by longitudinal lifter bars, advances sinkable battery fragments toward the second or opposite end of the drum until obstructed by a transverse baffle plate (internal baffles) which restricts further passage to all material larger than predetermined size. The larger fragments are therefore concentrated for efficient breakup by the grinding balls while means are provided for lifting the smaller fragments) [Col. 4, line 3-8].
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of internal baffles to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 24, all the above discussions regarding claim 1-4 are applicable to claim 5, but both Liu and Nishio are silent about the rate of rotation of the rotating drum is maintained to achieve the rotational hammering of the mixture.
However, Albert further teaches a rate of rotation of the rotating drum is maintained to achieve the rotational hammering of the mixture (means are provided for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68] and the motion of the rotating drum both cleans and fractures the grid metal. The battery grids quickly loose most of their attached active material by the combined action of the water and the tumbling and shearing motion brought about by the drum rotation. The speed of rotation of the drum must be sufficient to maintain finer active material in suspension but not so great so to create centrifuging of solid fragments [Col. 7, line 1-9]).
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rate of rotation of rotating drum to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and clean separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
Regarding Claim 26, all the above discussions regarding claim 21 are applicable to claim 26, in addition, Liu discloses vibrating a container within which the mixture is contained (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-16]. As Liu’s process separated the materials from the mixture (less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen. This part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor and Grid lead which is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen [Col. 14, line 16-22], therefore, Liu’s vibration would have been sufficient to cause material movement within the mixture.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention, to combine Liu’s vibration screen and Albert’s rotational hammering effect for separating the battery materials effectively.
Regarding Claim 27, all the above discussions regarding claim 21 and 26 are applicable to claim 27, in addition, Liu discloses utilizing a sieve through which the solution and the lead paste may pass but through which the lead alloy may not pass; and vibrating the sieve to at least in part facilitates passage of the solution and the lead paste through said sieve (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen and less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen. This part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor and Grid lead which is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen [Col. 14, line 14-22].
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention, to combine Liu’s vibration screen modify Albert and Albert’s rotational hammering effect for separating the battery materials effectively.
Regarding Claim 28, Liu discloses a full cycle regeneration process method of waste lead acid batteries [Col. 13, line 64-67] includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (smashing the waste lead acid battery in a mixture of grid lead, lead mud (equivalent to lead paste) and waste electrolyte, i.e., the diluted sulfuric acid) [Col. 14, line 1-4];
vibrating the mixture sufficient to cause material movement within the mixture (the waste battery is smashed in a crusher and the material then passes a vibration screen) [Col. 14, line 14-16];
removing the lead alloy from the mixture (less than 1 mm diachylon is separated out by the vibration screen, this part of diachylon is formed into lead mud with electrolysis acid liquor. Grid lead is larger than 1 mm and remains on the upper surface of the vibration screen) [Liu’s Step (1) Col. 14, line 16-22] and the diachylon is a mixture consisting of lead sulfate (PbSO4), lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead monoxide (PbO) [Col. 14, line 35-42], therefore, diachylon is the lead based paste (according to the instant specification of the disclosure, "Background Section" and in the paragraph [0002], grid lead is defined as a lead alloy and lead-based paste typically comprises lead oxides and lead sulfates coated over the exposed surfaces of the lead-alloy grid);
performing solid-state electrolysis on the mixture to recover pure elemental lead (Liu’s Step (2): the lead mud obtained from Step (1) is filter pressed to separate the solid from the liquid, and the separated solid is diachylon, a mixture consisting of lead sulfate (PbSO4), lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead monoxide (PbO) [Col. 14, line 35-42] and then in Liu’s Step (3): desulphurization and deoxidation of diachylon are performed under airtight condition, wherein lead sulfate and the lead dioxide react to obtain lead monoxide (PbO) and sulfur trioxide (SO3) and then the obtained lead monoxide is reduced by solid phase electrolysis so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead [Col. 14, line 50-67, and Col. 15, line 19-58].
But Liu is silent about the rotational hammering of the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy, the rotational hammering being achieved at least in part through use of a rotating drum comprises internal baffles. Liu is also silent about an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode.
However, Albert discloses separating the constituents of lead-acid batteries having grid plates of antimonial lead, other lower grade alloy parts, active material consisting of lead, lead oxide, and lead sulfate, and organic material consisting of the battery case and separators [Col.3, line 20 – 24]. Albert’s disclosed process includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (shredded lead-acid batteries, sodium carbonate and water are fed into a rotating drum separator) [Col. 3, line 26-28].
agitating the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy (Agitation of the mixture, by internal drum features serves (a) to further fracture and degrade the battery fragments; (b) to form a bath or slurry in which fine particles of active material create a pseudo-heavy density liquid adapted to float the organic material there on and to permit the remaining battery fragments to sink; ( c) to transpose the finer lead sulfate particles into lead carbonate; and (d) to neutralize any battery acid which contaminates the slurry [Col. 3, line 28-37], and means for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68]).
Albert further discloses, removing the lead alloy from the mixture (The remaining sinkable fragments, consisting mainly of grid metal, are concentrated and discharged from a separate drum opening onto a second screen for further segregation by size) [Col. 3, line 41-44].
With respect to the term “hammering” in agitating step, as defined by the paragraph [00122] of the instant specification of the disclosure, “to create a hammering effect on the mass mixture ("hammering") to promote the physical detachment of the lead paste from the broken lead alloy grid components within the mixture” and claim 3 recites “the rotational hammering is achieved at least in part through use of a rotating drum comprises internal baffles”, as Albert discloses, a rotating drum [Col. 3, line 65-68] and a helical scroll on the internal drum surface, aided by longitudinal lifter bars, advances sinkable battery fragments toward the second or opposite end of the drum until obstructed by a transverse baffle plate (internal baffles) which restricts further passage to all material larger than predetermined size. The larger fragments are therefore concentrated for efficient breakup by the grinding balls while means are provided for lifting the smaller fragments) [Col. 4, line 3-8]. Therefore, Albert’s rotating drum comprises internal baffles would have created rotational hammering effect.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Albert’s teaching of rotational hammering to modify Liu’s process for efficient breakup of the battery fragment and separation of the battery material in the recycling operation.
But Albert is also silent about utilizing an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode.
However, Nishio discloses an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode (a cathode liquor into a cathode compartment formed between a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode plate of gas-liquid impermeability, with which the membrane is wetted, then a mixed stream of the cathode liquor and cathode gas being removed from the cathode compartment, see Nishio’s Abstract).
Nishio then teaches a horizontal type electrolytic cell provided with an anode compartment located on a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode compartment under said membrane, it is characterized in that a gas-liquid impermeable cathode plate is placed in close proximity to or in contact with the cation exchange membrane, a cathode liquor stream is formed which flows in a space of the cathode compartment formed between the cation exchange membrane and the cathode plate, while the lower side of the membrane being wetted with the cathode liquor stream, a caustic alkali and hydrogen gas is enfolded in the cathode liquor stream immediately when prepared in the space of the cathode compartment and then removed from the cathode compartment. Cathode compartment being surrounded by a cathode plate having gas-liquid impermeability, side walls so as to enclose the cathode plate and the lower side of the membrane, and provided with an inlet of cathode liquor and an outlet of a mixed stream of the cathode gas and the cathode liquor (see Nishio’s col. 2, line 30-67) These cation exchange membranes exhibit very small water permeability while hindering the passage of hydraulic flow (see Nishio’s col. 4, line 25-30).
Nishio is directed to electrolysis to separate materials and therefore analogous to the instant claim as well as Liu and Albert.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Nishio’s teaching of electrolyzer with horizontal cathode to modify Liu’s process of solid phase electrolysis step in view of Albert, so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead while hindering the passage of any hydraulic flow of gas and liquid for efficient separation of the battery material.
Claim 7 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] and in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter) as applied to claim 1 and further in view of Takashi Hottori et.al. [US7132195B2].
Regarding Claim 7, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 7, in addition Liu discloses, in the separating process of waste lead acid battery, the smashed and crushed waste battery material passes a vibration screen and grid lead and plastic on the upper surface of the vibration screen. According to the difference of specific gravity, plastic and grid lead are separated out. The last plastic part is further separated in a plastic separating system according to the difference of plastic specific gravity to separate out polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP) and polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The known technology is adopted to treat the separated plastic, for reusing polypropylene in production of plastic battery enclosures and reusing other plastic products [Col. 14, line 15-36].
Although Liu is silent about the mixture further comprises cloth adhering to the lead paste, however, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, that if the waste battery would contain any cloth adhering to the lead paste with Liu’s process of agitating would cause the cloth to no longer adhere to the lead paste or to the lead alloy as Liu discloses separating everything in the battery material including all the plastic materials. Nishio is silent about the cloth adhering to the lead paste.
However, Hottori discloses a lead-acid battery, and particularly to a separator thereof which prevents an internal short-circuit and thereby realizes a longer-life battery. In general, a discharge reaction of the lead-acid battery produces lead sulfate (PbSO4) through electrochemical reduction and oxidation of lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead (Pb) in sulfuric acid (H2SO4) electrolyte solution; where PbO2 and Pb are active materials of positive and negative electrodes. The produced PbSO4 on the positive and negative electrodes is electrochemically reduced as well as oxidized by charging, thereby not only producing PbO2 and Pb, but also revitalizing H2SO4 [Col. 1, line 12-29]. Hottori discloses a battery separator made from hydrophilic treated synthetic fiber non-woven and thermoplastic cloth to avoid short circuit [Col. 3, line 63-65, Col. 4 line 1-3]. Hottori’s separator 4 may be hydrophilic treated non-woven cloth made from a mixture of (a) polyethylene (PE) fiber and (b) polypropylene (PP) fiber [Col. 4, line 29-33]. Hottori’s cloth is made of plastics and organic material.
Hottori is in the field of separation of material and therefore, similar as Liu, Nishio, and the instant claim.
Hottori’s battery comprises cloth separator, and cloth is a mixture of (a) polyethylene (PE) fiber and (b) polypropylene (PP) fiber [ Hottori, Col. 4, line 29-33] are similar material as disclosed by Liu (separating out of polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP) [Liu’ Col. 14, line 15-36]) and are also similar to Albert’s separator (separator consisting of (organic materials) and the plastics those are no longer adhere to the lead paste or to the lead alloy [Col. 6, Line 11 – 60]).
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to combine Hottori’s teaching with Liu’s process, for recycling of the lead-acid batteries comprising a cloth separator.
Claim 11 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] and in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter) as applied to claim 1 and further in view of Tyagi, Vipin [WO2016130675A1].
Regarding Claim 11, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 11, Liu discloses in Step (1) of the separation process, the grid lead is put into a melting pod for melting and refining and then casting the molten lead into a mold to cast an alloy lead ingot and the obtained alloy lead ingot will be used in the manufacture of the battery pole plate [Col.14, Line 8-14].
But Liu and Nishio are silent about the pressing the lead alloy into a pressed form.
However, Tyagi discloses a recycling process of lead waste battery, in step C the grid obtained in step A undergoes further treatment to remove the paste on it. The grid can directly be melted to obtain lead metal or lead alloy. To improve the recovery and decrease the amount of dross formation during the melting process, (a) the grid lead is washed with the basic electrolyte (optionally with agitation); (b) the cleaned grid metal obtained in can be pressed into ingots or melted [Section 0047].
Tyagi is in the field of separation of material and therefore, analogous to the instant claim as well as Liu and Nishio.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was invented to have Tyagi’s teaching to modify Liu’s process for separating lead alloy and to be pressed into ingots for further manufacturing the battery or any other application.
Claim 25 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] in view of Albert E. La Point et.al. [US4018567] and Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter), as applied to claim 21 and further in view of Takashi Hottori et.al. [US7132195B2].
Regarding Claim 25, all the above discussions regarding claim 21 are applicable to claim 25, in addition Liu discloses, in the separating process of waste lead acid battery, the smashed and crushed waste battery material passes a vibration screen and grid lead and plastic on the upper surface of the vibration screen. According to the difference of specific gravity, plastic and grid lead are separated out. The last plastic part is further separated in a plastic separating system according to the difference of plastic specific gravity to separate out polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP) and polyvinyl chloride (PVC). The known technology is adopted to treat the separated plastic, for reusing polypropylene in production of plastic battery enclosures and reusing other plastic products [Col. 14, line 15-36].
Although Liu is silent about the mixture further comprises cloth adhering to the lead paste, however, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, that if the waste battery would contain any cloth adhering to the lead paste with Liu’s process of agitating would cause the cloth to no longer adhere to the lead paste or to the lead alloy as Liu discloses separating everything in the battery material including all the plastic materials.
Albert also discloses in the process of separating the constituents of lead-acid batteries of the type having grid plates of antimonial lead, other lower grade alloy parts, active material consisting of lead, lead oxide, and lead sulfate, and organic material consisting of the battery case and separators [Col.3, line 20 – 24]. Albert teaches once the drum starts to rotate, the organic material, made up of plastic battery housings and separators will float immediately upon release from other inorganic battery parts and the finely divided active material is mixed with water and agitated by the drum rotation forms a pseudo-heavy density liquid or "heavy media" suspension whose density is higher than that of the organic material. As the organic material is advanced over the second set of screens 38-38 by the action of the screw 49, it is sprayed with water from a separately supported spray nozzle 50 which extends longitudinally within the trommel 15. This will remove any remaining active material clinging to the organic material and deposit it in the hopper 28. The organic material is then pushed out through the open end of the trommel 16 [Col. 6, Line 11 – 60]. Therefore, Albert’s mixture comprises the separator and plastic materials adhering to the lead paste, and wherein the agitating causes the separator and the plastics to no longer adhere to the lead paste or to the lead alloy.
But Albert and Nishio are also silent about the cloth.
However, Hottori discloses a lead-acid battery, and particularly to a separator thereof which prevents an internal short-circuit and thereby realizes a longer-life battery. In general, a discharge reaction of the lead-acid battery produces lead sulfate (PbSO4) through electrochemical reduction and oxidation of lead dioxide (PbO2) and lead (Pb) in sulfuric acid (H2SO4) electrolyte solution; where PbO2 and Pb are active materials of positive and negative electrodes. The produced PbSO4 on the positive and negative electrodes is electrochemically reduced as well as oxidized by charging, thereby not only producing PbO2 and Pb, but also revitalizing H2SO4 [Col. 1, line 12-29]. Hottori discloses a battery separator made from hydrophilic treated synthetic fiber non-woven and thermoplastic cloth to avoid short circuit [Col. 3, line 63-65, Col. 4 line 1-3]. Hottori’s separator 4 may be hydrophilic treated non-woven cloth made from a mixture of (a) polyethylene (PE) fiber and (b) polypropylene (PP) fiber [Col. 4, line 29-33]. Hottori’s cloth is made of plastics and organic material.
Hottori is in the field of separation of material and therefore, similar as Liu, Albert, Nishio and the instant claim.
Hottori’s battery comprises cloth separator, and cloth is a mixture of (a) polyethylene (PE) fiber and (b) polypropylene (PP) fiber [ Hottori, Col. 4, line 29-33] are similar material as disclosed by Liu (separating out of polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP) [Liu’ Col. 14, line 15-36]) and are also similar to Albert’s separator (separator consisting of (organic materials) and the plastics those are no longer adhere to the lead paste or to the lead alloy [Col. 6, Line 11 – 60]).
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to combine Hottori’s teaching with Liu and Albert’s process, for recycling of the lead-acid batteries comprising a cloth separator.
Claim 1-6, 8-12, 21-24, and 26 are alternately rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Albert E. La Point et.al. [US4018567], and in view of Tyagi, Vipin [WO2016130675A1] and further in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter).
Claim 1-6, 8-10, 12, 21-24, and 26 Albert discloses separating the constituents of lead-acid batteries having grid plates of antimonial lead, other lower grade alloy parts, active material consisting of lead, lead oxide, and lead sulfate, and organic material consisting of the battery case and separators [Col.3, line 20 – 24]. Albert’s disclosed process includes the following steps
mixing the lead paste and lead alloy with a solution to form a mixture (shredded lead-acid batteries, sodium carbonate and water are fed into a rotating drum separator) [Col. 3, line 26-28].
agitating the mixture in a manner sufficient to cause the lead paste to no longer physically adhere to the lead alloy (Agitation of the mixture, by internal drum features serves (a) to further fracture and degrade the battery fragments; (b) to form a bath or slurry in which fine particles of active material create a pseudo-heavy density liquid adapted to float the organic material there on and to permit the remaining battery fragments to sink; ( c) to transpose the finer lead sulfate particles into lead carbonate; and (d) to neutralize any battery acid which contaminates the slurry [Col. 3, line 28-37], and means for rotating the drum with a range of velocity for proper fragmentation of the batteries and avoidance of centrifuging [Col. 3, line 65-68]).
Albert further discloses, removing the lead alloy from the mixture (The remaining sinkable fragments, consisting mainly of grid metal, are concentrated and discharged from a separate drum opening onto a second screen for further segregation by size) [Col. 3, line 41-44].
With respect to the term “hammering” in agitating step, as defined by the paragraph [00122] of the instant specification of the disclosure, “to create a hammering effect on the mass mixture ("hammering") to promote the physical detachment of the lead paste from the broken lead alloy grid components within the mixture” and claim 3 recites “the rotational hammering is achieved at least in part through use of a rotating drum”, as Albert discloses, a rotating drum [Col. 3, line 65-68] and a helical scroll on the internal drum surface, aided by longitudinal lifter bars, advances sinkable battery fragments toward the second or opposite end of the drum until obstructed by a transverse baffle plate (internal baffles) which restricts further passage to all material larger than predetermined size. The larger fragments are therefore concentrated for efficient breakup by the grinding balls while means are provided for lifting the smaller fragments) [Col. 4, line 3-8]. Therefore, Albert’s rotating drum is creating rotational hammering effect and rotating drum comprises internal baffles would have created rotational hammering effect.
Albert further teaches the longitudinal lifter bars raise both the grinding balls and the larger sinkable battery fragments, consisting mainly of grid metal and other lower grade lead alloy parts, out of the bath to a height dependent on drum speed and diameter [Col. 6, line 64-68], from which they fall back into the pulp or suspension. This motion both cleans and fractures the grid metal. The battery grids quickly loose most of their attached active material by the combined action of the water and the tumbling and shearing motion brought about by the drum rotation. The speed of rotation of the drum 10 must be sufficient to maintain finer active material in suspension but not so great so to create centrifuging of solid fragments [Col. 7, line 1-9].
But Albert is silent about performing solid-state electrolysis on the mixture to recover pure elemental lead.
However, Tyagi teaches a method for recovery of near-pure lead from an impure lead container metal from a used lead-acid battery, the method comprising: desulfurizing the impure metal material, combining the impure lead with a sodium hydroxide electrolyte to form a slurry, thus a slurry that is a mixture of the impute material and the electrolyte such that the electrolyte does not dissolve the target metal in the impure metal material, performing solid state electrolysis on the slurry to form lead deposits and residual components, and mechanically separating the lead from the electrolyte and the residual components (Paragraphs 0027-0031, 0035-0038 and 0044-0045). The similar Solid-state electrolysis process as described in the paragraph [0067] of the instant specification of the disclosure including the desulfurization and using NaOH for making slurry same as Tyagi.
Tyagi is analogous to Albert and instant claim as Tyagi is in the field of recycling of lead-acid batteries.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Tyagi’s teaching of performing solid state electrolysis to modify Albert’s process for separation of pure elemental lead from the battery recycling operation.
But both Albert and Tyagi are silent about utilizing an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode.
However, Nishio discloses an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode (a cathode liquor into a cathode compartment formed between a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode plate of gas-liquid impermeability, with which the membrane is wetted, then a mixed stream of the cathode liquor and cathode gas being removed from the cathode compartment, see Nishio’s Abstract).
Nishio then teaches a horizontal type electrolytic cell provided with an anode compartment located on a cation exchange membrane positioned substantially horizontal and a cathode compartment under said membrane, it is characterized in that a gas-liquid impermeable cathode plate is placed in close proximity to or in contact with the cation exchange membrane, a cathode liquor stream is formed which flows in a space of the cathode compartment formed between the cation exchange membrane and the cathode plate, while the lower side of the membrane being wetted with the cathode liquor stream, a caustic alkali and hydrogen gas is enfolded in the cathode liquor stream immediately when prepared in the space of the cathode compartment and then removed from the cathode compartment. Cathode compartment being surrounded by a cathode plate having gas-liquid impermeability, side walls so as to enclose the cathode plate and the lower side of the membrane, and provided with an inlet of cathode liquor and an outlet of a mixed stream of the cathode gas and the cathode liquor (see Nishio’s col. 2, line 30-67) These cation exchange membranes exhibit very small water permeability while hindering the passage of hydraulic flow (see Nishio’s col. 4, line 25-30).
Nishio is directed to electrolysis to separate materials and therefore analogous to the instant claim as well as Liu and Albert.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was made, to have Nishio’s teaching of electrolyzer with horizontal cathode to modify Tyagi’s solid phase electrolysis step to incorporate the process of Albert, so that the lead monoxide is reduced into sponge lead while hindering the passage of any hydraulic flow of gas and liquid for efficient separation of the battery material.
Regarding Claim 11, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable to claim 11, Albert is silent about the pressing the lead alloy into a pressed form.
However, Tyagi discloses a recycling process of lead waste battery, in step C the grid obtained in step A undergoes further treatment to remove the paste on it. The grid can directly be melted to obtain lead metal or lead alloy. To improve the recovery and decrease the amount of dross formation during the melting process, (a) the grid lead is washed with the basic electrolyte (optionally with agitation); (b) the cleaned grid metal obtained in can be pressed into ingots or melted [Section 0047].
Tyagi is in the field of recycling process of waste lead-acid batteries and therefore, analogous to Liu and the instant claim.
Therefore, it would have been further obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention was invented to have Tyagi’s teaching to modify Albert’s process for separating lead alloy and to be pressed into ingots for further manufacturing the battery or any other application.
Claim 2-6, are alternately rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Zhiqiang Liu, et.al. [US9257731B2] and in view of Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter) as applied to claim 1 and further in view of Hong Seong Ho [KR20040005770A] (machine translation is being used for the text and original is being used for the Figures).
Regarding Claim 2-6, all the above discussions regarding claim 1 are applicable, but Liu and Nishio are silent about the rotational hammering.
However, Hong teaches a process and device for a waste battery recycling, wherein the process includes after separating the plastic, using a crusher for crushing lead plates [Section 34]. Hong’s lead plate crusher is a hammer crusher, and a rotating shaft is installed inside the case of the hammer crusher, and both ends of the rotating shaft are installed on both sides of the case so that rotation is supported by bearings, and two fixed shafts are installed symmetrically in parallel with the rotating shaft, so that when the lead plate, is fed into the case through the inlet of the crusher, it is crushed by the rotating hammer [Section 35]. Hong teaches the lead plate is made up of a lead grid (lead alloy) and a paste applied to the lead grid (lead paste) [Section 55]. Hong’s lead plate is fed through the inlet of the shredder inside the case, where it is crushed by a rotating hammer. When a pair of hammers collide with each other due to rotational force and centrifugal force, the lead is pulverized into powder between them or between the hammers and the lining of the case. Or it can be crushed into powder by being directly hit by a hammer. The hammer crusher is powered by an electric motor, and a stepper motor can be used to adjust the forward and reverse rotation and rotation speed. The case is manufactured in two parts, upper and lower, for easy maintenance [Section 62 and 63].
Hong is in the field of separation of material and therefore, analogous to Liu, Nishio and the instant claim.
Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filling date of the present invention, to have Hong’s rotating hammer crusher for utilizing rotational force and centrifugal force, to pulverize lead plate to modify Liu’s process to have an effective and easy maintained rotating hammer for separating all the battery materials from the waste lead acid batteries.
Response to Arguments
Applicant’s arguments with respect to claims 1, 21 and 28 filed 09/09/2026 have been fully considered and Applicant’s argument regarding the previously cited prior art does not teach the new amended limitations of “an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode”, seems persuasive, therefore, all the previous rejections have been withdrawn.
However, a new prior art, Tsutomu Nishio et.al. [US4596639] (Nishio hereafter) teaches the limitation “an electrolyzer comprising a horizontal cathode”, therefore, a new 35 USC § 103 rejections of the claim 1, 21 and 28 and other dependent claims have been associated with this office action (please check the section of the 35U.S.C. 103 rejection associated with this office action for further details).
Conclusion
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to NAZMUN NAHAR SHAMS whose telephone number is (571)272-5421. The examiner can normally be reached M-F 11:00 AM-7:30PM (EST).
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Merkling Sally can be reached on (571)2726297. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/NAZMUN NAHAR SHAMS/Examiner, Art Unit 1738
/DANIELLE M. CARDA/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 1738