Prosecution Insights
Last updated: November 04, 2026
Application No. 18/112,321

SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR REMOTE REAL ESTATE INSPECTIONS AND VALUATIONS

Final Rejection §101
Filed
Feb 21, 2023
Priority
Jul 11, 2017 — provisional 62/531,172 +2 more
Examiner
MONAGHAN, MICHAEL J
Art Unit
3629
Tech Center
3600 — Transportation & Electronic Commerce
Assignee
Accurate Group LLC
OA Round
4 (Final)
34%
Grant Probability
At Risk
5-6
OA Rounds
0m
Est. Remaining
87%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants only 34% of cases
34%
Career Allowance Rate
49 granted / 144 resolved
-18.0% vs TC avg
Strong +53% interview lift
Without
With
+52.9%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
3y 2m
Avg Prosecution
19 currently pending
Career history
176
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
38.1%
-1.9% vs TC avg
§103
34.5%
-5.5% vs TC avg
§102
11.3%
-28.7% vs TC avg
§112
13.7%
-26.3% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 144 resolved cases

Office Action

§101
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101 35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows: Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title. Claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea without significantly more. Step 1: Claims 1-20 recite a method and therefore fall into a statutory category. Step 2A – Prong 1 (Is a Judicial Exception Recited?): Referring to claims 1-20, the claims cover concepts reciting a manner of generating a valuation for a property based on the analysis of collected information, which under its broadest reasonable interpretation covers concepts covered under the Mental Processes and Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity groupings of abstract ideas. The abstract idea portion of the claims is as follows: A method of generating a valuation for real estate property comprising: assigning a quantitative score representing an assessed condition or desirability of a first property for which a valuation is to be generated; assigning a comparative score representing an assessed condition or desirability of each of a plurality of other properties, wherein the comparative score represents the assessed condition if the quantitative score represents the assessed condition, and wherein the comparative score represents the assessed desirability if the quantitative score represents the assessed desirability; automatically comparing, [without human intervention by a controller in a computing device], the quantitative score of the first property with the comparative score of the plurality of other properties; automatically determining a first subset of the plurality of other properties refined from the plurality of other properties based on the comparison of the quantitative score and the comparative score; upon determining the first subset of the plurality of other properties based on the comparison, automatically comparing, [without human intervention by the controller], visual characteristics of one or more images of the first property with visual characteristics of one or more images of each other property in the first subset [using an image recognition algorithm]; in response to comparing the visual characteristics, determining, [without human intervention by the controller], a second subset of the plurality of other properties refined from the first subset of other properties based on the image recognition; and automatically using, [without human intervention by the controller], the second subset of other properties to generate a valuation for the first property. Where the portions not bracketed recite the abstract idea. Here the claims recite concepts capable of being performed in the human mind and/or via pen and paper (including an observation, evaluation, judgement, opinion) but for the recitation of generic computer components. In the present application concepts directed to generating a valuation for a property based on the analysis of collected information. (See paragraphs 2, 5, 11, and 17). Further the claims recite concepts performed as part of fundamental economic principles or practices or managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (following rules or instructions). In the present application concepts reciting manner of generating a valuation for a property. (See paragraphs 2, 5, 11, and 17). If a claim limitation, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, covers concepts capable of being performed in the human mind and/or via pen and paper, it falls under the Mental Processes grouping of abstract ideas. See MPEP 2106.04. Further if a claim limitation, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, covers concepts capable of being performed in either fundamental economic principles or practices or managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people, it falls under the Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity. Id. Step 2A-Prong 2 (Is the Exception Integrated into a Practical Application?): The examiner views the following as the additional elements: A controller. (See paragraph 59) A computing device. (See paragraph 59) An image recognition algorithm. (See paragraph 19) These additional elements are recited at a high-level of generality such that they act to merely “apply” the abstract idea using generic computing components and do not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application. (See MPEP 2106.05 (f)) The combination of these additional elements and/or results oriented steps are no more than mere instructions to apply the exception using generic computing components. (See Id.) Accordingly, even in combination these additional elements do not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application because they do not impose any meaningful limits on practicing the abstract idea. Therefore, the claim is directed to an abstract idea. Step 2B (Does the claim recite additional elements that amount to Significantly More than the Judicial Exception?): As noted above, the claims as a whole merely describes a method that generally “apply” the concepts discussed in prong 1 above. (See MPEP 2106.05 f (II)) In particular applicant has recited the computing components at a high-level of generality such that it amounts to no more than mere instructions to apply the exception using generic computer components. As the court stated in TLI Communications v. LLC v. AV Automotive LLC, 823 F.3d 607, 613 (Fed. Cir. 2016) merely invoking generic computing components or machinery that perform their functions in their ordinary capacity to facilitate the abstract idea are mere instructions to implement the abstract idea within a computing environment and does not add significantly more to the abstract idea. Accordingly, these additional computer components do not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application because it does not impose any meaningful limits on practicing the abstract idea. Therefore, even when viewed as a whole, nothing in the claim adds significantly more (i.e. an inventive concept) to the abstract idea and as a result the claim is not patent eligible. Dependent claims 2-3, 6-15, and 20 further define the abstract idea as identified. Therefore claims 2-3, 6-15 and 20 are considered to be patent ineligible. Dependent claim 4 further defines the abstract idea as identified. Additionally, the claim recites the generic controller (See paragraph 59) and computing device (See paragraph 59) for merely implementing the abstract idea using generic computing components which does not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application or adds significantly more. Therefore claim 4 is considered to be patent ineligible. Dependent claim 5 further defines the abstract idea as identified. Additionally, the claim recites the generic controller (See paragraph 59), computing device (See paragraph 59), and text mining algorithm (See paragraph 19) for merely implementing the abstract idea using generic computing components which does not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application or adds significantly more. Therefore claim 5 is considered to be patent ineligible. Dependent claim 16-18 further defines the abstract idea as identified. Additionally, the claim recites the generic image recognition algorithm (See paragraph 19), computing device (See paragraph 59), and text mining algorithm (See paragraph 19) for merely implementing the abstract idea using generic computing components which does not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application or adds significantly more. Therefore claims 16-18 are considered to be patent ineligible. Dependent claim 19 further defines the abstract idea as identified. Additionally, the claim recites the existing image databases (See paragraph 21) for merely implementing the abstract idea using generic computing components which does not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application or adds significantly more. Therefore claim 19 is considered to be patent ineligible. In conclusion the claims do not provide an inventive concept, because the claims do not recite additional elements or a combination of elements that amount to significantly more than the judicial exception of the claims. There is no indication that the combination of elements improves the functioning of a computer or improves any other technology, and the collective functions merely provide conventional computer implementation. Therefore, whether taken individually or as an order combination, the claims are nonetheless rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 as being directed to non-statutory subject matter. Response to Arguments Applicant's arguments filed August 17, 2026 have been fully considered but they are not persuasive. Applicant’s arguments, on pages 6-25 of the Remarks, regarding the 101 rejection, the Examiner finds unpersuasive. Applicant argues under Step 2A Prong 2 that the claims provide for an ordered combination of additional elements that integrates the abstract idea into a practical application. Applicant contends the claims reflect this through: the first stage of "automatically compar[es], without human intervention by a controller in a computing device, the quantitative score of the first property with the comparative score of the plurality of other properties" and "automatically determin[es] a first subset of the plurality of other properties refined from the plurality of other properties based on the comparison of the quantitative score and the comparative score" and in the second stage, and only "upon determining the first subset," the claim "automatically compar[es], without human intervention by the controller, visual characteristics of one or more images of the first property with visual characteristics of one or more images of each other property in the first subset using an image recognition algorithm," and "in response to comparing the visual characteristics, determin[es], without human intervention by the controller, a second subset of the plurality of other properties refined from the first subset of other properties based on the image recognition." The claim then requires "automatically using, without human intervention by the controller, the second subset of other properties to generate a valuation for the first property." Applicant concludes the claims are analogous and supported by the conclusion provided Examples 47-49 through improving the technical functioning of an automated-image-recognition-based property valuation system. Applicant argues that a combination of steps cannot simultaneously be absent from the prior art architecture and also be a mere restatement of the same architecture. According to Applicant, Examples 47-48 confirm that where the specification discloses a specific technical benefit (i.e. less subjective, faster and more scalable valuations than a human appraiser, automatically responsive to changing trends), and the claims recite the specific ordered steps that produce that benefit, the claim reflects a change in how the underlying system processes information, not merely a change in the abstract idea being automated. See MPEP 2106.04(d)(1); 2106.05(a). The Examiner respectfully disagrees. The limitations proffered by Applicant the Examiner maintains recite steps of the identified abstract idea that are merely applied using generic computing components as discussed in the prior Non-Final Rejection. (See page 6) Specifically, paragraph 23 discusses how the current conditions for valuating a property include a professional appraiser that evaluates the condition and appearance of a property to determine the value illustrating that an individual can in fact perform the tasks of determining the attributes and the PCR scores for the condition and location score are discussed in paragraph 64. Applicant does not explain why an individual such as an appraiser could not determine a subset of the plurality of other properties refined from the plurality of other properties based on comparison of the quantitative score and the comparative score as claimed. The Examiner notes there is no limit on the size of the dataset processed to suggest otherwise that an individual could not perform this determination as claimed. Further the Examiner views that an individual can upon determining the subset compare visual characteristics for determining a second subset of the plurality of other properties refined from the first subset of other properties given the claim’s broadest reasonable interpretation. Applicant’s attempt at suggesting the “combination of steps cannot simultaneously be absent from the prior art architecture and also be a mere restatement of the same architecture” the Examiner views that the lack of prior art for performing the identified functions of the abstract idea does not change the analysis but rather supports the determination that a novel abstract idea as in the instance case is still abstract despite the lack of prior art “As made clear by the courts, the “‘novelty’ of any element or steps in a process, or even of the process itself, is of no relevance in determining whether the subject matter of a claim falls within the § 101 categories of possibly patentable subject matter.” Intellectual Ventures I v. Symantec Corp., 838 F.3d 1307, 1315 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (quoting Diamond v. Diehr, 450 U.S. at 188–89). See also Synopsys, Inc. v. Mentor Graphics Corp., 839 F.3d 1138, 1151 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (“a claim for a new abstract idea is still an abstract idea. The search for a § 101 inventive concept is thus distinct from demonstrating § 102 novelty.”)” Specifically, lack of novelty under 35 U.S.C. 102 or obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103 of a claimed invention does not necessarily indicate that additional elements are well-understood, routine, conventional elements. Because they are separate and distinct requirements from eligibility, patentability of the claimed invention under 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 with respect to the prior art is neither required for, nor a guarantee of, patent eligibility under 35 U.S.C. 101. Applicant’s purported novelty as identified relates to steps of the abstract idea not additional elements. The Examiner views the proffered benefits asserted reflect an improved valuation as claimed rather than constituting a technical solution as provided in Examples 47 and 48 or Example 49 as further discussed below in response to Applicant’s specific arguments for each Example. Applicant’s asserted limitations are not reflective of any of the eligible claims in either Example 47 or 48 because the identified abstract idea is merely applied using generic computing components as claimed. The Examiner does not view the claims are directed to improving the technical functioning of an automated-image-recognition-based property valuation system but rather directed to improving the valuation process that as claimed is an improvement to a commercial or business problem rather than a technical solution or the other considerations as enumerated under MPEP 2106.05 (d). Applicant argues claim 1 analogous to Example 47 claim 3 because claim 3 of Example 47 uses the output of an abstract determination (anomaly detection) as the trigger for a further, ordered technical operation (source-address detection, packet dropping, and traffic blocking) that reflects a disclosed improvement, claim 1 here uses the output of the first (quantitative/comparative score) filtering operation as the express predicate for a second, technically distinct filtering operation using an image recognition algorithm, the output of which is in turn used to generate the property valuation. According to Applicant, the particular ordered combination of steps (which no prior art is applied), in particular, this ordered, conditional relationship between the two filtering stages mirrors the ordered relationship in Example 47's eligible claim 3, where the mental/mathematical determination (anomaly detection) is integrated into a practical application precisely because it triggers and directs a further, non- mental technical sequence that reflects the specification's disclosed improvement, replacing the subjective judgment of a human appraiser with a two-stage, image-recognition-driven refinement process that the specification explains is less subjective, is scalable to national and international scale, and can be updated automatically to track quickly changing market trends, thereby improving the accuracy, consistency, and efficiency of automated property valuation as a technology. Applicant contends as the Example 47 panel found that steps (d)-(f) do more than merely instruct the reader to apply the abstract idea because they recite a specific, ordered technical sequence tied to the disclosed improvement (rather than a generic outcome), the second- stage image-recognition filtering step of claim 1 does more than instruct the reader to apply an abstract idea using a generic computer because it recites a specific, conditional, ordered operation, triggered only after and based upon the results of the first-stage numerical filtering, that uses image recognition of visual characteristics to further refine the candidate set, an operation that the Examiner concedes is novel over the cited prior art of record. The Examiner respectfully disagrees, viewing none of limitations asserted reflect a particular remedial action as in steps e and f of Example 47 claim 3, but rather only provide for an generating a property valuation. Further unlike step d, where the detection is claimed such that it is viewed as a computer function further illustrated by the Specification that discusses performing the detection by a tracing operation or by using a software tool, Applicant’s steps can be performed as part of the mental processes or certain methods of organizing activity as illustrated by the Specification as discussed above. Rather each of the limitations referenced by Applicant are similar to step b, where the step does not provide any details about how the trained ANN is used or how the detection is made, such that “detecting one or more anomalies in network traffic” is viewed as reciting a mental process. In the instant claims the steps do not provide details about how the controller in a computing device and image recognition automatically perform the steps as claimed or how the steps are performed to suggest they do not recite abstract ideas as discussed prior in light of the Specification. Applicant argues claim 1 is unlike claim 2 of example 47 because claim 1 does not stop at outputting a score or a filtered list, but instead, the output of the first-stage numerical filtering becomes the express, conditional input that triggers a second, technically distinct filtering operation (image recognition-based comparison of visual characteristics), the output of which is itself used to generate a property valuation. Each stage does more than recite a bare outcome; the claim specifies the sequence, the trigger relationship between stages, and the particular technique (image recognition applied to visual characteristics) used at the second stage, where this ordered, conditional, multi-technique architecture is precisely what was missing from ineligible claim 2 of Example 47 and what rendered eligible claim 3 of Example 47 patent eligible. The Examiner respectfully disagrees reiterating that each of the steps identified by Applicant constitute a part of the identified abstract idea as claimed that is merely applied using generic computing components as previously addressed and in view of the discussion of claim 3 of Example 47 above. Applicant argues claim 1 is analogous with Example 48 claim 2 because even if that the initial score-comparison step reflects a concept that could be performed mentally, the claim as a whole does not stop there but proceeds, in a specific ordered sequence, to apply an image recognition algorithm to a data-driven subset generated by the first step, and then generates a property valuation from the output of that second step. As in Example 48's eligible claim 2, the later steps of claim 1 are not insignificant extra-solution activity or a bare instruction to "apply" an abstract idea. According to Applicant, the additional claim steps reflect the specific, disclosed improvement of the invention: an automated, two-stage refinement architecture that is less subjective than a human appraiser, is quickly scalable to national or international scale, and can be updated automatically to reflect fast-changing market trends, thereby reducing the incidence of human bias, where the second-stage image-recognition filtering and subsequent valuation-generation steps of claim 1 reflect the claimed improvement in automated property-valuation technology by changing how the underlying architecture processes information, not merely automating what a human previously did by hand. The Examiner respectfully disagrees viewing the additional elements are similar to the DNN as claimed in claim 1 step 3 of Example 48 where the claim does not include details about the DNN or how it operates. In the instant claims there are no details about the additional elements identified or how they operate. Rather they amount to mere instructions to apply the identified abstract idea discussed prior (encompassing the “two-stage refinement architecture) using generic computing components. The Examiner views automating the task of appraising as claimed is not sufficient to show an improvement in computer-functionality citing to MPEP 2106.05 (a) “mere automation of manual processes, such as using a generic computer to process an application for financing a purchase,” Credit Acceptance Corp. v. Westlake Services, 859 F.3d 1044, 1055, 123 USPQ2d 1100, 1108-09 (Fed. Cir. 2017) Applicant argues claim 1 is distinct from claim 1 of Example 48 because the instant claim does not terminate after the first-stage score comparison but instead, the result of the comparison is used, in an express, conditional manner ("upon determining the first subset ... based on the comparison"), to trigger and bound a further image-recognition-based operation, the output of which is then used to generate a property valuation. According to Applicant, unlike ineligible claim 1 of Example 48, which stopped at a bare mathematical output with no further application, Applicant's claim 1 carries the output of the first stage through additional, specific technical processing (image recognition) to a concrete result (a property valuation) that is the type of downstream integration that distinguished eligible claim 2 from ineligible claim 1 in Example 48. The Examiner respectfully disagrees viewing that the conditional logic, two-stage process, and generation of a valuation is part of the identified abstract idea as a user may upon determining the subset perform the visual analysis to use this information in determining a valuation as discussed previously. The Examiner views the image recognition is mere instructions to apply the abstract idea using generic computing components as further evidenced by the Specification (See paragraph 19) rather than constituting additional elements that integrate the abstract idea into a practical application. Applicant argues that the instant claim is distinguishable from claim 1 of Example 49 and analogous to claim 2 of Example 49 because claim 1 here recites a specific, ordered second filtering operation, using image recognition to compare visual characteristics of a data-driven subset of properties, that is itself narrowly defined by, and conditioned on, the output of the first filtering step, and whose own output is what is actually used to generate the valuation. According to Applicant, Claim 1 does not, like ineligible claim 1 of Example 49, leave the downstream use of the abstract determination open-ended or generic; it specifies precisely how the output of the first stage is used (as the exclusive input pool for a defined image-recognition comparison) and precisely how the output of that second stage is used (as the exclusive basis for the valuation) that is the same type of meaningful, non- generic limitation on the abstract idea that rendered Example 49's claim 2 eligible, and it is absent from Example 49's ineligible claim 1. The Examiner respectfully disagrees reiterating their findings that the ordered combination proffered by Applicant constitutes steps of the identified abstract idea that is merely applied using generic computing components as discussed above. Applicant argues the prior art of record does not teach or suggest the specifically claimed ordered, two-step filtering process, in which a less resource- intensive numerical filtering operation is performed first to narrow the largest data set, and a more resource-intensive image-recognition-based filtering operation is performed second, on the resulting narrowed subset, to arrive at the final comparison set used to generate the valuation that in view of Examples 47 and 48, this type of ordered, conditional relationship between an initial abstract determination and a further, specifically recited technical operation whose output is itself used to produce a concrete result is precisely what integrates an abstract idea into a practical application at Step 2A, Prong Two. According to Applicant, this ordered combination also reflects an improvement to the functioning of the computer system itself, not merely to the abstract idea of valuation, because it changes how the underlying system allocates computational resources as the claimed process first applies a less resource-intensive numerical filtering operation to the largest data set, and only thereafter applies a more resource-intensive image-recognition operation, and only to the smaller, already-refined first subset, where this sequencing is not merely a matter of the order in which a human would choose to think about the problem; it is a specific technical architecture that reduces the volume of image data that must be processed by the computationally expensive image recognition algorithm, thereby improving the efficiency of the computing device performing the valuation as compared to a system that ran image recognition across the entire, unfiltered data set of other properties. Applicant contends an improvement of this kind, namely a claimed architecture that reduces the computational burden on a technology by conditionally sequencing operations of different computational cost, is the type of improvement to the functioning of a computer that Step 2A, Prong Two and MPEP 2106.05(a) recognize as integrating an abstract idea into a practical application, independent of the additional improvements to accuracy, consistency, and scalability discussed above. According to Applicant, the claimed architecture is not merely an improvement to the abstract idea of "valuating properties" untethered from any technology, but rather, consistent with the reasoning applied to eligible claim 3 of Example 47 and eligible claim 2 of Example 48, the claimed ordered combination reflects a specific technical improvement to the technology of automated property valuation: a two-stage, conditionally- triggered architecture that uses image recognition to refine a numerically pre-filtered candidate set, achieving valuation results that are less subjective than human appraisal, that scale efficiently from local to national or international markets, and that can be updated automatically and quickly to reflect changing market conditions where these advantages cannot be replicated by a human appraiser with comparable consistency or speed. The Examiner respectfully disagrees, viewing that the concept of the ordered combination is steps of the identified abstract idea that is merely applied using generic computing components as previously addressed. There is no specific technical operation recited whose output is a concrete result that integrates the abstract idea practical but rather generation of the valuation. Applicant’s remarks pertaining to the reduced computational resources is predicated on steps of the abstract idea (i.e. the two-stage filter) rather than the additional elements as claimed. Instead, the additional elements are generic computing components merely applied for performing the abstract idea. The Examiner reiterates they do not view the claims to be analogous to the eligible claims of Examples 47 and 48 as discussed above and that the purported achievements pertaining to valuations is an improvement to a commercial or business endeavor rather than one of the considerations enumerated under MPEP 2106.04 (d). Applicant argues the ordered combination recited in Applicant's claim 1 tracks, limitation by limitation, the analytical pattern the USPTO's own Examples 47-49 identify as sufficient to integrate an abstract idea into a practical application under Step 2A, Prong Two, because like the eligible claims in Examples 47 and 48, claim 1 does not merely output the result of an abstract determination; it uses that result as an express, conditional trigger for a further, specifically recited technical operation, the output of which is itself carried forward to produce a concrete result, here, a property valuation, and, as demonstrated above, claim 1 is affirmatively distinguishable from each of the ineligible claims in Examples 47, 48, and 49 precisely because it does not terminate in a generic output (unlike Example 47's ineligible claim 2), does not stop at a bare mathematical calculation with no further application (unlike Example 48's ineligible claim 1), and does not leave the downstream use of the abstract determination open-ended or unspecified (unlike Example 49's ineligible claim 1). According to Applicant, considered as a whole, and in light of the Examiner's own finding that this specific ordered combination is absent from the prior art of record, the claims reflect a specific improvement to the technology of automated real estate valuation, not a mere instruction to implement an abstract idea using generic computer components. The Examiner respectfully disagrees reiterating their analysis above with respect to Applicant’s arguments for Examples 47-49 addressed prior. Further what the prior art lacks in teaching are the steps of the abstract idea including steps of the two stage filter process that is merely applied using the generic computing components identified as additional elements as claimed and therefore do not amount to a practical application. Applicant argues under Step 2B that the Examiner's own factual finding that the specific ordered combination of ordered combination of first determining a first subset of properties based on a comparison of quantitative and comparative scores, and then, upon determining the first subset, further comparing visual characteristics of images using an image recognition algorithm to determine a second, further-refined subset that is then used to generate the valuation is absent from the prior art of record is directly relevant evidence at Step 2B, because it confirms that the combination of the claimed first-stage numerical filtering and second-stage image- recognition filtering, triggered and bounded exactly as recited, is not well-understood, routine, or conventional activity previously known in the field of automated real estate valuation. See MPEP 2106.05(d) (evidence that a combination of elements is not routine or conventional supports a finding of an inventive concept). According to Applicant, unlike Example 47's ineligible claim 2, in which the recited computer components perform only long-established, generic functions such as receiving data, discretizing it, and outputting a generic result, and unlike Example 49's ineligible claim 1, in which the data- gathering steps of sample collection and genotyping are expressly identified as routine, long standing laboratory techniques, with respect to Applicant's claims, the Examiner has not found any comparable art establishing that this particular two-stage, conditionally sequenced filtering architecture was previously known, let alone routine or conventional. Rather, Applicant relies on the Examiner's novelty finding as evidence bearing on the separate, narrower factual question posed at Step 2B: whether the specific ordered combination of additional elements was well-understood, routine, or conventional activity in the field, a question the MPEP expressly directs be informed by whether the combination (as opposed to the underlying abstract idea) was previously known. See MPEP 2106.05(d). Applicant contends Symantec and Synopsys hold that a novel abstract idea is still an abstract idea; they do not hold that evidence a specific combination of additional elements was absent from the art is irrelevant to whether that combination was conventional. The Examiner respectfully disagrees because the Examiner views Applicant’s purported additional elements to be made up of the abstract idea that is merely applied using generic computing components and does not add significantly more to the abstract idea. That is what the prior art lacks in teaching are the steps of the abstract idea including the steps of two stage filter process, and the generic computing components identified as additional elements as claimed, therefore both Symantec and Synopsys are relevant. The Examiner reiterates they view the generation of the valuation to be part of the recited abstract idea rather than an additional element that could integrate the abstract idea into a practical application. Applicant argues even if the individual generic components identified by the Examiner, namely a controller, a computing device, and an image recognition algorithm, were each independently well known, the inventive concept inquiry "requires more than recognizing that each claim element, by itself, was known in the art," because "an inventive concept can be found in the non-conventional and non-generic arrangement of known, conventional pieces." BASCOM Global Internet Servs., Inc. v. AT&T Mobility LLC, 827 F.3d 1341, 1350 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (quoted in the Office Action). According to Applicant, the Office Action only address the additional elements in isolation it does not address whether the specific ordered, conditional arrangement of those elements, namely a first, less resource-intensive numerical filtering pass that determines the very pool of candidates subjected to a second, more resource-intensive image-recognition pass, is itself conventional, where the Examiner's own novelty finding over the cited prior art confirms that this specific ordered, conditional arrangement of those elements, as claimed, is not conventional. Applicant contends this is the same analytical distinction drawn in Example 47, where eligible claim 3 was found to recite an inventive concept (in the alternative analysis under Step 2B principles incorporated into Step 2A, Prong Two) not because the underlying trained neural network or computer hardware was itself unconventional, but because the specific, ordered arrangement of detection followed by real-time source-address identification, automatic dropping of malicious packets, and blocking of future traffic reflected a non-conventional technical solution to network intrusion, as confirmed by the disclosed improvement over prior art systems that required a human network administrator to react. Applicant argues the individual steps of detecting anomalies, identifying source addresses, and blocking network traffic might each be performed using known techniques, but the claimed ordered combination of those steps, triggered and sequenced as recited, was what rendered the claim eligible, where the same reasoning applies to Applicant's claims. According to Applicant, even crediting the Examiner's premise that a controller, a computing device, and an image recognition algorithm are each individually generic, the claimed ordered combination, in which the output of a numerical score comparison determines the candidate pool later subjected to image-recognition analysis, and the output of that second analysis is what is used to generate the valuation, is the non-conventional, non-generic arrangement that supplies the inventive concept required to make Applicant's claims eligible subject matter. The Examiner respectfully disagrees, first regarding Examiner’s supposed lack of consideration of the additional elements in combination the Examiner notes the Step 2B Analysis of the Non-final rejection, in particular on page 5, that states: “In conclusion the claims do not provide an inventive concept, because the claims do not recite additional elements or a combination of elements that amount to significantly more than the judicial exception of the claims. There is no indication that the combination of elements improves the functioning of a computer or improves any other technology, and the collective functions merely provide conventional computer implementation. Therefore, whether taken individually or as an order combination, the claims are nonetheless rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 as being directed to non-statutory subject matter.” The Examiner again does not view the first and second passes as additional elements but part of the abstract idea that is merely applied using generic computing components. The Examiner views “the claimed ordered combination, in which the output of a numerical score comparison determines the candidate pool later subjected to image-recognition analysis, and the output of that second analysis is what is used to generate the valuation, is the non-conventional, non-generic arrangement that supplies the inventive concept required to make Applicant's claims eligible subject matter” as part of the abstract idea rather than additional elements. Applicant argues the previously cited TLI Communications LLC v. AV Automotive, LLC, 823 F.3d 607, 613 (Fed. Cir. 2016), for the proposition that invoking generic computing components that perform their functions in their ordinary capacity does not add significantly more to an abstract idea does not control here because, as explained above, the claims do not merely invoke a controller, a computing device, and an image recognition algorithm to perform their functions in their ordinary, generic capacity, but rather instead, the claims recite a specific, conditional sequence in which those components are deployed, a sequence that the Examiner has already found to be absent from the prior art that distinguishes the claims from those in TLI, or Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Capital One Bank (USA), 792 F.3d 1363 (Fed. Cir. 2015), cited in the Office Action, in which the claims at issue recited no more than the application of an abstract idea using computer components performing only their basic, well-known functions with no claimed technical arrangement analogous to the two-stage, conditionally triggered filtering architecture recited here. The Examiner respectfully disagrees viewing the specific conditional sequence is steps of the identified abstract idea as discussed prior and the additional elements identified are mere instructions to apply the abstract idea using generic computing components. Applicant argues the specification discloses the claimed system is less subjective than work done by a human appraiser, is quickly scalable from a single neighborhood to national or international scale, can be updated automatically to account for quickly changing home-buying trends faster than is humanly possible, and greatly reduces the incidence of human bias, where these are not benefits that flow merely from performing a pre- existing manual process faster on a generic computer, of the type found insufficient in Intellectual Ventures I v. Capital One Bank. According to Applicant, instead the benefits flow specifically from the claimed ordered combination, in which a first-stage numerical filter narrows an arbitrarily large data set before a second-stage image-recognition filter is applied to the resulting, more computationally tractable subset, where it is this specific architecture, and not merely the abstract idea of valuing property or the generic recitation of a controller, computing device, and image recognition algorithm, that enables the disclosed scalability and consistency advantages and because these benefits are tied to the particular, non-conventional ordered combination rather than to the abstract idea itself or to routine computer automation of that idea, the claims recite significantly more than the judicial exception. The Examiner respectfully disagrees viewing the improvement over a human appraiser relates to the improvement to an administrative or business process (automated accurate valuations on a large scale and accounting for home buying trends) rather than constituting a technical improvement. As discussed previously the Examiner views each step of the two-stage filter process is a step of the recited abstract idea as claimed that is merely applied using generic computing components that does not add significantly more. Applicant argues the closest prior art of record does not teach or suggest the claimed ordered, two-stage filtering combination is itself evidence that the combination is not well-understood, routine, or conventional activity in the field of automated real estate valuation and under BASCOM, the relevant inquiry is not whether the controller, computing device, and image recognition algorithm are individually generic, but whether their specific, ordered, conditional arrangement is conventional, and the Examiner has identified no prior art suggesting that it is. According to Applicant, unlike the generic, unbounded computer implementations at issue in TLI Communications and Intellectual Ventures I v. Capital One Bank, the claims here recite a specific technical sequence in which the output of one stage expressly determines and bounds the operation of the next, a sequence that produces the very benefits described in paragraph 24 of the specification, namely reduced subjectivity, national and international scalability, automatic responsiveness to changing market trends, and reduced human bias, benefits that are tied to the particular ordered architecture rather than to the abstract idea of property valuation itself or to routine automation of that idea. The Examiner respectfully disagrees reiterating that the steps of the two stage filtering combination are steps of the recited abstract that is merely applied using generic components. The inventive concept as discussed and claimed in the Bascom patent at issue “is the installation of a filtering tool at a specific location, remote from the end-users, with customizable filtering features specific to each end user. This design gives the filtering tool both the benefits of a filter on a local computer and the benefits of a filter on the ISP server. BASCOM explains that the inventive concept rests on taking advantage of the ability of at least some ISPs to identify individual accounts that communicate with the ISP server, and to associate a request for Internet content with a specific individual account.” Bascom at 1350. The Examiner does not view the benefits to be technical benefits as illustrated by Bascom, but rather as supported by paragraphs 24 or 64 are improvements to a business or commercial process i.e. a faster and reduced human bias in valuating a property. Therefore, the Examiner has maintained the 101 rejection. Conclusion The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure. Humphries et al. (US Patent No. 10,198,735) – directed to determining a market rental rate index for homes THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a). A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action. Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to MICHAEL J MONAGHAN whose telephone number is (571)270-5523. The examiner can normally be reached on Monday- Friday 8:30 am - 5:30 pm. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Sarah Monfeldt can be reached on (571) 270-1833. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /Michael J. Monaghan/Examiner, Art Unit 3629
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Show 3 earlier events
Feb 07, 2025
Examiner Interview Summary
Mar 19, 2025
Response Filed
Jun 24, 2025
Final Rejection mailed — §101
Jan 08, 2026
Request for Continued Examination
Feb 13, 2026
Response after Non-Final Action
Apr 07, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §101
Aug 17, 2026
Response Filed
Oct 15, 2026
Final Rejection mailed — §101 (current)

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12770206
SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR CONTRACT NEGOTIATION AND DRAFTING
1y 5m to grant Granted Oct 20, 2026
Patent 12749049
APPARATUS AND METHOD FOR PROCESSING WORK ACTIVITY BASED ON WORK OBJECT
2y 9m to grant Granted Sep 29, 2026
Patent 12748893
Method and Apparatus for Data Verification
2y 9m to grant Granted Sep 29, 2026
Patent 12626154
APPARATUS AND A METHOD FOR THE GENERATION OF A JUDGMENT SCORE
2y 7m to grant Granted May 12, 2026
Patent 12619954
SYSTEMS AND METHODS TO GENERATE RECORDS WITHIN A COLLABORATION ENVIRONMENT BASED ON A MACHINE LEARNING MODEL TRAINED FROM A TEXT CORPUS
1y 9m to grant Granted May 05, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 5 most recent grants.

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

5-6
Expected OA Rounds
34%
Grant Probability
87%
With Interview (+52.9%)
3y 2m (~0m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
High
PTA Risk
Based on 144 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month