Prosecution Insights
Last updated: November 11, 2026
Application No. 18/227,204

PROFICIENCY PROFILE MANAGEMENT AND RECOMMENDATION SYSTEM

Non-Final OA §101§103§112
Filed
Jul 27, 2023
Priority
Jul 29, 2022 — provisional 63/393,510
Examiner
HATCH, ANGELA MAIDA
Art Unit
3626
Tech Center
3600 — Transportation & Electronic Commerce
Assignee
Mcgraw Hill LLC
OA Round
3 (Non-Final)
0%
Grant Probability
At Risk
3-4
OA Rounds
0m
Est. Remaining
0%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants only 0% of cases
0%
Career Allowance Rate
0 granted / 17 resolved
-52.0% vs TC avg
Minimal +0% lift
Without
With
+0.0%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
2y 11m
Avg Prosecution
14 currently pending
Career history
38
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
36.5%
-3.5% vs TC avg
§103
30.9%
-9.1% vs TC avg
§102
16.0%
-24.0% vs TC avg
§112
14.9%
-25.1% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 17 resolved cases

Office Action

§101 §103 §112
DETAILED ACTION Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Status of Claims The office action is being examined in response to the Request for Continued Evaluation (RCE), filed by the applicant on 5 May 2026. Claims 1-6, 8-13, and 15-20 are pending, claims 7 and 14 are cancelled, and the removed weighting assignment limitations from claim 20 are incorporated into claims 1, 8, and 15. The pending claims have been examined. This action is made NON-FINAL. Continued Examination Under 37 CFR 1.114 A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114. Applicants’ submission filed on 5 May 2026 has been entered. Response to Arguments 35 U.S.C. § 101 Arguments Applicant's arguments filed 5 May 2026 with regards to 35 U.S.C. § 101 have been fully considered but they are not persuasive. Applicants’ arguments, on pages 13-18, summarily asserting, on pages 13, 15, and 17, that the claims are not directed to abstract ideas, but if they were, the claims integrate any such exception into a practical application and amount to significantly more, are not persuasive. Applicants’ arguments, on pages 13-14, asserting that the claims produce a transformation of data into formatted data, such that this is indicative of a practical application, is neither probative, nor persuasive. The root of the chosen section, i.e. MPEP 2106.05(c), is that the claims must set forth at least one additional element that effects a transformation or reduction of a particular article to a different state or thing. In this case, the asserted transformation is merely a formatting data, i.e. the data that is returned, must have a particular format, one that is not disclosed in the specification nor in the claims as a different thing or state of a thing, e.g. data is merely formatted data, which is still merely data. Therefore, said transformation of data into formatted data, is not a transformation as described under MPEP 2106.05(c) in the claims, and subsequently, the asserted practical application is not persuasive. Further, throughout the arguments on pages 13-15, making assertions of a practical application, the applicant does not address which elements are abstract ideas or which elements are additional. The applicants’ arguments assert that functions of receiving data by a model that returns formatted data, cannot be performed in the human mind, however, the claims merely recite that the models are applied to the received data, i.e. apply it, after finding parameters and training the models to become trained models, differing only by the training parameters. The data that is output is still data. The claims do not recite the manner of defining data or training with the data to generate the models, nor do the claims assert how the data is returned, beyond merely applying the data to particular product specific data based on the specific product that the model was trained on. That is, the models are merely applied as tools. The defining, 6 generating, training, applying, transforming, and 3 determining, are recited without limits to how the defining, 6 generating, training, applying, transforming, and 3 determining steps occurs, such that the claims do not clearly depict steps that may not be performed as a mental process, based on the rules outlined in the MPEP. In fact, all of these functions are abstract ideas, and the applicant does not present any analyses that overcomes this finding. The only additional elements in the claims are those identified in the 35 U.S.C. § 101 rejections, updated below. These are not persuasive because data cannot be transformed into data and fulfill the requirements of MPEP 2106.05(c), where the transformation must transform or reduce a particular article into another different state or thing. In the case of the instant invention, the data is input as characterized performance data and is returned by the model as skill mastery probability data. One specific specification ¶ disclosing that the probabilities are merely data is [0026] “the farther the probability is away from 0.5,” such that the Examiner agrees that any probability data produced, is merely numerical data. The combined estimate is merely the combination of two numerical data values. Considering the claims as a whole for a moment, the Examiner disagrees with the applicant’s assertion that the claims cannot be performed in the human mind. The Applicant asserts that the invention is able to evaluate student achievement across disparate products – this is not unlike what teachers traditionally do when evaluating student achievement and taking into consideration a variety of “products” i.e. exams, homework, in-class exercises, textbook questions, hand-outs, individual projects, group projects, class presentations etc. All such educational pedagogy are disparately evaluated with unique rubrics – and a student may have high achievement in any one product and lower in another. Teachers traditionally evaluate all of the students’ achievements and arrive at an overall assessment of the student’s mastery. It is appreciated that the claims require a computer to accomplish this task, and the mechanism the computer follows involves modeling which itself is not something a human could easily execute – nevertheless, ultimately the computer is merely emulating a traditionally manual human process. As we have indicated in recent interviews, the claims merely catalog intended results rather than articulate a technical advancement underlying the asserted abstract idea. The applicants’ further assertions, that the amended claims do not recite abstract ideas in the categories of mathematical concepts, certain methods of organizing human activity, and mental processes, on page 14, are not persuasive. On page 15, merely recategorizing the limitations into a pipeline that transforms data into data, does not remove the mathematical nature of the claims as declared in the prior and the updated 35 U.S.C. § 101 analyses below. The arguments present no rules or analyses to support the conclusory statements. The arguments do not discuss the certain methods of organizing human activity category as it pertains to the 35 U.S.C. § 101 rejection. The applicants’ assertions that the amended claims are not mental processes, are constrained to the same issue, merely asserting that the limitations cannot be reduced to mental observations, evaluations, or judgements, without pointing to the rules or an overriding analysis, is merely commentary stating a conclusion without the evidence to support said conclusory assertions. In both cases, the applicants’ arguments support the finding that the models are applied to perform the functions of the claims, i.e. apply it. The amended claims incorporate some specific sets of verbiage that are not discussed elsewhere. In the limitations of defining model parameters, the reflecting limitations through the end of the clause, are intended results. The same occurs in the training model parameters limitations, such that the “based on” limitation, through the “to produce” limitation and to the end of the clause, are also intended results. That is, the positively recited clause is training a first/second set of model parameters. In the applying the first model to first performance data limitations, the limitation, to transform, and through the end of the clause is also an intended result. The applying second model to second performance data, alternately recites “transforming,” but this is not enough to alter the meaning of the claim and the transforming clause through the end of the clause is an intended result. That is, the claim positively recites applying the first/second product specific model to the first/second performance data associated with the first/second instructional product. In the generating limitation, the claim positively recites generating a combined estimate of skill proficiency relating to the first skill. The “based on” portion is intended results. The four limitations recited to perform the generating, three of determining and one of applying, are also comprised of intended results. The first, determining a first and second signal strength are comprised of corresponding to clauses that define where the data comes from. The determining first/second timepoint data are comprised of associated with clauses that define where the data comes from. The determining first and second weights for the first and second estimates of skill proficiencies include “based on” clauses that define where the data comes from. The wherein clause positively recites, determining each weight comprises applying a temporal decay function, but the remaining claim language, “that decreases the respective weight based on elapsed time since the corresponding observations were generated” is an intended result as well. Similarly, the applying a weighting function that assigns the first/second weight to the first/second estimate of skill proficiency are positively recited, but the wherein clause is an intended result. Therefore, the intended results features do not carry patentable weight for the purposes of either this 35 U.S.C. § 101 or the below 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) rejections. The additional elements in the claims are the model, trained and calibrated into 2 trained versions of the same model, merely characterized by data, a third model, and the general-purpose computing structures, as depicted in the full analysis, below. The steps of the claim that are sending, receiving, or displaying data, are not abstract ideas. The remaining elements are abstract ideas. The additional elements are applied as tools to perform the abstract ideas. The applicant’s assertion, on pages 11, 12, and 13, that the processing pipelines are implemented by a computing system, the defined, trained, and calibrated model is applied, and the weighting is implemented by applying the third model, support the findings that the claims are adding the words “apply it” with the abstract ideas, i.e. using the general-purpose computing structures and the models as tools implemented to perform the abstract ideas. The claims are focused on the nature of the data being manipulated via the performance of generic business functions recited in the abstract ideas in the claims. The claims recite implementations of the abstract ideas via the additional, non-abstract elements, that attempt to cover any solution to the problem with no restriction on how the results are accomplished and no description of the mechanisms for accomplishing the results. The models and functions are generated, trained, defined, and applied, without detailing the scope of the models or functions. Therefore, the claims recite the intended use of the models/functions to perform characterized tasks like generating by training and calibrating the models and applying the models and function, recited in terms of the intended results of applying the models to return characterized data. The claims generally link these abstract ideas to computing structures and to the model in the technical fields of mathematical/statistical models, academic/research models, and/or machine learning models. The specification does not reveal that the core of the invention is related to advances in any of these characterized models or to the functioning of the general-purpose computing structures. Since these abstract ideas are not performed in a meaningful way beyond the general linkage to the additional elements, the claims, as a whole, are a drafting effort designed to monopolize the exception. The arguments by the applicant, on pages 15-18, asserting that amended claim 1, if comprised of abstract ideas, are integrated into a practical application due to comparison and being synonymous with the eligible claim 2, distinguished from ineligible claim 1 from the USPTO subject matter eligibility guidance, Example 42, are not persuasive. The inferences made in the applicants’ arguments are incorrect because Example 42 does not disclose the elements asserted by the applicant as the basis of dismissing the rejection. The Examiner cannot reach the applicants’ associated conclusions on the basis of the applicants’ arguments. Please find the updated 35 U.S.C. § 101 analysis below reflecting the amendments. The arguments are not persuasive and the 35 U.S.C. § 101 is Maintained. 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) Arguments Applicant's arguments filed 5 May 2026 with regards to 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) have been fully considered but they are not persuasive. With regards to the Applicant’s arguments, on pages 20-23, the assertions that Gal differs from the instant application because Gal does not anticipate each element of the claim limitations, are not persuasive. The applicant argues a lack of obviousness by referring to only three of the numerous citation paragraphs presented in the prior art rejection. Applicants’ arguments do not comply with 37 CFR 1.111(c) because they do not clearly point out the patentable novelty which he or she thinks the claims present in view of the state of the art disclosed by the references cited or the objections made. Further, they do not show how the amendments avoid such references or objections. The applicants’ arguments, in pages 20-21, asserting that Gal is only directed to a single learning product, are not persuasive. The applicant bases the argument on only two of numerous paragraphs cited in the rejection and one citation that is both taken out of context and was not presented in the office action. The applicants’ arguments, that Gal’s “copies” of the Bayesian network are copies of the “same model,” are also not persuasive. The arguments, based on excerpts only from paragraphs [0004], [0016], and [0017] do not reflect the full scope or breadth of previous rejection, even when applied to the amended claim limitations. In response to the claim amendments, the claims have been re-examined, and the rejection has been updated to address these new limitations. The applicants’ arguments, on page 21, that Gal does not disclose generating product specific models, are not persuasive. When the full breadth of the citations for Gal are considered, [0076] discloses a system that also receives third-party content, such that the single network and single product arguments are not probative. With regards to the applicants’ arguments, on page 21, asserting that Gal does not teach or disclose pragmatically comparable data that is produced through formatting, are not persuasive. The full rejection to the new limitation of data formatting is disclosed below in the full rejection based on Gal. The applicant’s further assertions, on page 21, that gal has no concept of product specific characteristics, e.g. question type, assessment type, or relative difficulty, are not persuasive. These limitations are disclosed in at least Gal [0089, 0072, 0103] as is found in the full updated 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) below. The applicants’ assertions, on page 22, that the Examiner asserted in the interview from April 22, 2026, are not persuasive. As indicated in the interview summary, no agreements were reached, and no agreements were made. The applicant’s assertions characterize the facts and therefore are not persuasive as indicated in the interview. The applicants’ assertions, in the same ¶, that the full breadth of the prior art reference citations presented by the Examiner only comprises mapping the weighting function of the instant claims to Gal [0029], are not persuasive. Since the applicant does not address the full scope of the rejection as applied to the existing or new limitations, the claim limitations are addressed, and the full rejection is found below. The applicants’ arguments, on page 22, asserting that Gal [0029] does not read on the instant claims because Gal only weights possible values of hidden variables within a single Bayesian network “without determining signal strengths, timepoint data, or applying a temporal decay function that decreases weights based on an elapsed time since observations,” are also not probative nor persuasive. The applicants’ arguments are based on assertions of only one of the numerous citations implemented to show obviousness of the . Therefore, the arguments do not assert either the full scope of the rejection nor the full scope of the the facts of the rejection, the statements are not persuasive. For the purposes of compact prosecution, the Examiner has updated the prior art rejection to a 35 U.S.C. § 103 rejection, incorporating prior art that more clearly is obvious over a temporal decay function. While Gal does disclose weighting based on time decay of student performance, the new art, found below in the alteration of the 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) rejection to a 35 U.S.C. § 103 rejection was necessitated by amendments. Please find the updated 35 U.S.C. § 103 rejection below reflecting the amendments. While the arguments are not persuasive and the 35 U.S.C. § 102(a)(1) would have been Maintained, the additional art for a temporal decay function necessitated the change to the 35 U.S.C. § 103 rejection to more clearly shows obviousness. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112 The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a): (a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention. The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112: The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention. Claims 1-6, 8-13, and 15-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention. Claims 1, 8, and 15 recite the limitations determining a first/second signal strength, determining a first/second weight for the first/second estimates of skill proficiency based on the first/second signal strength and first/second timepoint data, and “determining each weight comprises applying a temporal decay function.” The specification does not disclose determine signal strengths for instructional products. In fact, signal strength is disclosed in [0033] “the initialization process determines the characteristics that contribute to the strength of the question's signals about proficiency,” without disclosing what the signal strengths are or how they are determined. The specification discloses in [0036] that the strength of signals are considered in determining the weights, but further fails to disclose how the signal strengths are determined or considered in determining the weights. In fact, neither of these paragraphs discloses any definitions of the signal strengths. The specification discloses in [0038] that a student signal strength for a product is based on the number and recency of student responses to questions in that product. Since [0032] discloses said characteristics that contribute to signal strength are ” relative difficulty, question type (e.g., multiple-choice or open-ended), assessment type (e.g., low-stakes practice assignment with multiple tries or high-stakes assessment), etc.,” it does not seem reasonable that the signal strength for the product is merely based on the number and recency of student question responses. Therefore, the specification does not disclose how the signal strengths are determined, and further, fails to define what said signal strength is at all. The specification does not disclose determining signal strengths in a manner that conveys possession of to a person having ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date. Since determining the weights is based on said signal strengths and timepoint data points, the weights are not disclosed in the specification with written description support, either. The specification also does not disclose that the particular signal strength implemented in determining the weights are merely the number and recency of student question responses, but also does not disclose what said signal strengths are or how they are determined. The specification does not disclose how determining the weights is performed, or how said determination is based on signal strengths and timepoint data. Therefore, determining the weights based on the signal strengths and timepoint data are not supported by the specification in a manner that conveys possession to a person having ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date. Lastly, determining the weights are also comprised of applying a temporal decay function. The specification does not disclose a temporal decay function that decreases the respective weight based on elapsed time since the observations were generated. The specification does not disclose the terms temporal or decay at all. The specification’s disclosure of time-based functions are not disclosed in a manner that supports the claim language. Therefore, the temporal decay function limitation is not disclosed in the specification in a manner that conveys to a person having ordinary skill in the art that the applicant was in possession of the invention before the effective filing date. Claims 2-6, 9-13, and 16-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 112(a) based on the dependency to the independent claims, 1, 8, and 15. The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112(b): (b) CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention. The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph: The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention. Claims 1-6, 8-13, and 15-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor (or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the applicant), regards as the invention. The terms determining a first/second signal strength, determining a first/second weight for the first/second estimates of skill proficiency based on the first/second signal strength and first/second timepoint data, and “determining each weight comprises applying a temporal decay function.” in claims 1, 8, and 15 are relative terms which render the claims indefinite. The term determining a first/second signal strength, determining a first/second weight for the first/second estimates of skill proficiency based on the first/second signal strength and first/second timepoint data, and “determining each weight comprises applying a temporal decay function,” are not defined by the claim, the specification does not provide a standard for ascertaining the requisite degree, and one of ordinary skill in the art would not be reasonably apprised of the scope of the invention. As discussed above, these terms are recited in the claims without providing metes and bounds, i.e. the claims do not provide for a standard metric, measurement, or objective baseline for what constitutes the first or second signal strength, how they are determined, or how a weight is derived from the signal strengths and timepoint data. The relationship between the signal strength, the timepoint data, and the resulting weight is expressed in purely functional terms without providing the structural or mathematical boundaries required for determining weights. The specification does not disclose a temporal decay function. Further, the specification fails to disclose the equation, boundary conditions, rate, or direction of decay. A person of ordinary skill in the art would not be apprised of how elapsed time quantitatively decreases the respective weights due to a lack of boundary conditions. The specification does not provide an objective standard or guideline for ascertaining the requisite degree or scope of these terms, such that a person of ordinary skill in the art would not be apprised of the full scope of the claimed invention. Claims 2-6, 9-13, and 16-20 are rejected according to 35 U.S.C. § 112(b) based on the dependency to the independent claims, 1, 8, and 15. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101 35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows: Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefore, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title. Claims 1-6, 8-13, and 15-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea without significantly more. Independent Claims: Regarding Claims 1, 8 and 15, the claims recite generating a first and second function, each by defining and training a base function with data, applying the first and second function to generate proficiency data, generating a combined proficiency data by: determining first and second weights by applying a temporal decay function that decreases weight according to elapsed time since observations, and applying the weighting functions to first and second estimates to generate a combined skill proficiency, which are abstract ideas in the category of mathematical concepts, more specifically, mathematical calculations and relationships because the claims present relationships between different data to return the final data at each step and the functions perform calculations to return the solution. Regarding Claims 1, 8 and 15 recite the abstract idea of “certain methods of organizing human activity,” more specifically, “managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people" include social activities, teaching, and following rules or instructions.” These claims perform four generate data functions, a define parameters function, two determine signal strength for products, two determine timepoint data for performance data, and a generate profile function. The functions are recited to map student data from two different academic products to a set of skills in an academic, grade-level-based ontology, to estimate skill proficiency for students for these ontological skills based on the data, and to combine the skill proficiency estimates from each product to form a combined student profile. Therefore, these claims manage teaching and learning behavior for students and the assessors that evaluates each students’ educational performance data, where the data may drive what students are perceived to understand from the curriculum at a grade, which drives learning strategies chosen by educators and student’s placement within the educational structure (MPEP 2105.04(a)(2)(II)). These same functions recited above, the two generating a function limitations by defining parameters and training each function, applying the two functions, applying the weighting function, four generate data functions, a define parameters function, two determine signal strength for products, two determine timepoint data for performance data, a generate profile function, and generate a display interface function, are additionally abstract ideas in the category of “Mental Processes,” or processes that can be performed in the human mind, including observations, evaluations, judgments, and opinions. These limitations are merely collecting data, sorting and filtering data in to skill groups, estimating skill proficiency, finding, grouping, and combining the proficiency data into one single skill group from data across two products, and generating a display showing the results (mental processes could comprise drawing a graph on paper), all of which can be performed in the human mind or with the aid of pen and paper and comprise observations, evaluations, judgements, and opinions about student data (MPEP 2105.04(a)(2)(III)). Further, there is nothing in the claims that precludes these limitations from being performed using pen and paper, from being performed in the mind, or being performed with the aid of a computing structure used as a tool. The claimed functions are recited at a high level of generality. In fact, the claims do not place any meaningful limits on how these limitations are performed, but for the models and computing structures applied as tools. Further, the claims place no meaningful limits on the models or computing structures used to apply the limitations, i.e. any model or computing structure may be implemented to “apply it,” e.g. the claims are mere instructions to implement the abstract ideas using tools, applying them on any computing structure and with any model. Step 2A Prong 2: The claims also recite data or groups of data, all characterizations of data or characterized groups of data that amount to non-functional descriptive information limitations. They are not abstract ideas, nor limitations that can be relied on to integrate the abstract idea into a practical application because they do not positively recite any additional functions that limit the claims or the structures of the claims. Insofar as the claims 1, 8, and 15 recite in the preambles and claims, for claim 8, A system comprising: a memory to store instructions; and a processing device, operatively coupled to the memory, to execute the instructions to perform operations comprising, and for claim 15, A non-transitory computer-readable storage medium having instructions that, when executed by a processing device, cause the processing device to perform operations. The claims and the applicant’s specification at paragraphs [0061]-[0067] are simply reciting/disclosing general-purpose computing structures at a high level of generality. The specification does not reveal that the core of the invention relates to advances or improvements to the computing structures themselves. The claims amount to “apply it,” mere instructions to apply the Judicial Exceptions using generally linked, general-purpose computing structures. Claims 1, 8, and 15 recite a base model, trained, and calibrated to become the first and second models, and third model for performing a weighting function. Models are disclosed in the specification ¶ [0024] as any statistical models or machine learning tools to create model pipelines, ¶ [0028] as a psychometrics model like Diagnostic Classification Models (DCM), Cognitive Diagnosis Models (CDM), or a Deterministic Inputs, Noisy "And" gate model (DINA) model, and ¶ [0031] as a Bayesian framework. Since the base model is trained and calibrated to become the first and second functions, the model is being applied as a tool to produce the generated models by training and calibrating the base model with data. The first and second models are implemented as tools to generate data. The third model is implemented as a tool to perform the weighting function. Therefore, the models are tools user to perform the abstract ideas, i.e. adding the words “apply it” with the abstract ideas. The claims recite automation of generic business processes that were historically performed by hand like manipulating, combining, generating, and displaying data that include a final universal profile, recommendations, proficiencies, skill/ontology mappings, probabilities of mastery, various weightings, and combined estimates of skill proficiencies. The claims recite general purpose model frameworks that attempt to cover any solution to the problem with no restriction on how the result is accomplished and no description of the mechanism for accomplishing the results. The specification does not reveal that the core of the invention relates to advances in statistical methods, mathematical functions, academia or research-based modeling frameworks, i.e. psychometric modeling, or machine learning models. The claims generally link the use of the abstract ideas to the technological environments of statistical methods, mathematical functions, models, data models, or machine learning models. Insofar as the use of abstract ideas are generally linked to the technological fields of statistical methods, mathematical functions, modeling, machine learning methods, data models, training, calibration, application, and weighting through the use of models, graphic user interfaces, and general-purpose computing structures. The claims do not add meaningful functions or limitations, or reveal improvements upon the technologies or technical fields. The claims are focused on the nature of the data being manipulated – i.e., the descriptive nature of the data without detailing an inventive concept beyond the abstract ideas., the claims do not apply or use the abstract ideas in some other meaningful way beyond the general linkage to the technological environments. Therefore, the claims, as a whole, while looking at the additional elements, are no more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the recited judicial exceptions. The claims recite: receive first and second data, train the models (receiving, at the model, data sent to the model), calibrate the models (receiving, at the model, collected data sent to the model), display data, and generate a graphical user interface. The specification does not reveal that the core of the invention relates to advances to the technologies of sending and receiving data, training models (feeding, i.e. sending data), calibrating models (feeding, i.e. sending data), displaying data, or generating or using graphical user interfaces. The claims as a whole, while looking at additional elements individually and in combination, do not integrate the judicial exceptions into a practical application. Step 2B: The analysis above for Step 2A is commensurate with the analysis for this Step 2B, such that the claims, as a whole, do not include additional elements that are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception when taken individually and in combination (MPEP 2106.05). Dependent Claims: Claims 2, 9, and 16 further limit the display of the profile, adding a description of a proficiency. This limitation is not an abstract idea as it is merely further limiting the non-functional descriptive information presented, or merely displaying further data characterizations. The specification does not disclose that the invention makes advances to display graphical user interface (GUI) architecture or methods, where displaying data and the GUI are disclosed at a high level of generality, focusing on the descriptive nature of the data being displayed. These limitations cannot be relied upon to integrate the claims as a whole, while looking at additional elements individually and in combination, into a practical application or significantly more. Claims 3, 10, and 17 further limit the recommendations generated in claim by characterizing the data comprised in the recommendations, which is non-functional descriptive information that carries no patentable weight. These claims recite no additional elements, such that they cannot be integrated into a practical application or amount to significantly more. Claims 4, 11, and 18, add a new function, monitor a growth metric, associated with the first skill over a time period. The monitor function recites an abstract idea in the same categories as the independent claim, "Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity" for “managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people" which “include social activities, teaching, and following rules or instructions.” The claim uses skill determinations from a student’s academic data to evaluate their academic growth in a skill, further impacting behavioral management of a student according to their academic data. This function is also in the abstract idea category of “Mental Processes” for implementing observations, evaluations, judgments, and opinions” where a growth metric, skill, and time can be monitored in the mind or with pen and paper. The claimed functions are recited at a high level of generality. The claims are focused on the nature of the data being manipulated – i.e., the descriptive nature of the data without detailing an inventive concept beyond the abstract ideas. Generally linking the Judicial Exception to a technological fields of using student skill determinations from student academic data to evaluate each students’ academic growth in the skill over time, without exhibiting some other meaningful approach such that the claims as a whole are not more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the exception is not indicative of integration into a practical application (MPEP 2016.05(e) and (h)). For the same reason the claims do not integrate the abstract ideas into a practical application above, the claims, as a whole, do not include additional elements sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception, when taken individually and in combination. Claims 5, 12, and 19 add a new function, generate a first prediction, associated with performance in the first skill. The ‘generate a prediction’ function recites an abstract idea in the same categories as the independent claim. This function is in the abstract idea category of "Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity" for “managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people" which “include social activities, teaching, and following rules or instructions” because it generates a prediction that corresponds to the first skill associated with student performance, all based on student academic data, further impacting behavioral management of a student according to their academic data. This function is also in the abstract idea category of “Mental Processes” for implementing observations, evaluations, judgments, and opinions” where the prediction of student performance in a skill can be performed in the mind or with pen and paper. The claimed functions are recited at a high level of generality. The claims are focused on the nature of the data being manipulated – i.e., the descriptive nature of the data without detailing an inventive concept beyond the abstract ideas. They are simply applying the Judicial Exception to the technological field of the prediction of student performance in a skill based on student academic data, without adding meaningful functions or limitations. such that the claims as a whole are not more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the exception is not indicative of integration into a practical application of the claims as a whole, while looking at additional elements individually and in combination (MPEP 2016.05(e) and (h)). For the same reason the claims do not integrate the abstract ideas into a practical application above, the claims, as a whole, do not include additional elements sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception, when taken individually and in combination. Claims 6, 13 and 20 add a new function, generate an update to the combined estimate of skill proficiency relating to the first skill based on updated first and second performance data over time. The ‘generate an update’ function recites an abstract idea in the same categories as the independent claim. This function is in the abstract idea category of "Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity" for “managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people" which “include social activities, teaching, and following rules or instructions” because it generates an updated combined estimate of skill proficiency in a skill based on updated data over time for a student, all based on student academic data, further impacting behavioral management of a student according to their academic data. This function is also in the abstract idea category of “Mental Processes” for implementing observations, evaluations, judgments, and opinions” where the update generation can be performed in the mind or with pen and paper. The claimed functions are recited at a high level of generality. The claims are focused on the nature of the data being manipulated – i.e., the descriptive nature of the data without detailing an inventive concept beyond the abstract ideas. They are simply applying the Judicial Exception to the technological field of the updating skill proficiency of student’s skill based on student academic data, without adding meaningful functions or limitations. such that the claims as a whole are not more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the exception is not indicative of integration into a practical application of the claims as a whole, while looking at additional elements individually and in combination (MPEP 2016.05(e) and (h)). For the same reason the claims do not integrate the abstract ideas into a practical application above, the claims, as a whole, do not include additional elements sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception, when taken individually and in combination. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103 The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action: A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made. The factual inquiries for establishing a background for determining obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103 are summarized as follows: 1. Determining the scope and contents of the prior art. 2. Ascertaining the differences between the prior art and the claims at issue. 3. Resolving the level of ordinary skill in the pertinent art. 4. Considering objective evidence present in the application indicating obviousness or nonobviousness. Claims 1-6, 8-13, and 15-20 are rejected under U.S.C. § 103 as being obvious over Gal, US20100190142A1, in view of Cormode, "Forward Decay: A Practical Time Decay Model for Streaming Systems," 2009 IEEE 25th International Conference on Data Engineering, Shanghai, China, 2009, pp. 138-149, doi: 10.1109/ICDE.2009.65. Regarding claims 1, 8, and 15: Gal discloses: receiving, by a processing device, first data associated with a first instructional product and second data associated with a second instructional product; [0057] (receiving, by a processing device, completion of a learning activity and completion of a learning object), [0060] (receive, by a processing device personalized learning activities, “access remotely-stored educational content (e.g., through the Internet, an Intranet, or other types of networks) which may be stored on external and/or remote server(s),” [0102] “information imported from other assessment systems (e.g., a third-party or external test generator or electronic testing system),” [0070] (learning activities data is monitored, recorded, mined, and stored, i.e. received), [0084] (receives multiple types of inputs); generating a first plurality of skill-mapped items based on a mapping of at least a portion of first data associated with a first instructional product to a first skill in an ontology; [0083] (activity data from instructional products are concept tagged, mapping between the various learning objects or learning entities to the ontology concepts reflecting the pedagogic values); wherein the ontology comprises a set of skills corresponding to a grade level in a first academic subject; [0090] (ontology is used in the same manner, based on grade level, pedagogy, subject, and finer granularity of skills, where skill mapping is also referred to as concept-tagging, and outcome concepts are academic subjects); generating a second plurality of skill-mapped items based on a mapping of at least a portion of second data associated with a second instructional product to the first skill in the ontology; [0083] (activity data from instructional products are concept tagged, mapping between the various learning objects or learning entities to the ontology concepts reflecting the pedagogic values); generating a first product-specific model associated with the first instructional product, wherein the generating comprises: [0053] (a plurality of models may be implemented), [0016] “an algorithm which creates one or more statistically evolving models based on relational concept mapping,” (i.e. a main model that is defined and trained into product specific domain versions of the model based on the product specific training data), [0089] (domain models: a specification of required or desired knowledge and capabilities within a given domain, i.e. a product specific model); defining a first set of model parameters reflecting a first set of characteristics of an assessment environment and questions associated with the first instructional product; [0081] (computer aided assessment of performance of students and of pedagogic parameters related to assessments of said students), [0082] (ontological data, i.e. product specific student data, reflecting the explicit and implicit knowledge present within the collected data for each product), [0084] (for each product, parameters are defined based on “information about the activities of the student (e.g., answers to questions, the difficulty level of each question, the time it took to complete various tasks, the location where different tasks were performed,” i.e. the parameters for each product are defined); training the first set of model parameters based on a first set of representative student responses to the questions mapped to the set of skills in the first instructional product, to produce the first product-specific model configured to output a first set of probabilities of mastery for the set of skills [0016] “an algorithm which creates one or more statistically evolving models based on relational concept mapping”, (i.e. training a model), [0089] (training the model on the first set of parameters, where the model “may receive as input multiple types of data: the required or desired knowledge map; mapping of tasks performed by the student to knowledge and capabilities represented in the knowledge map; information about the performed tasks, for example, task parameters (e.g., type, difficulty level) and performance metrics (e.g., correct or incorrect answer, number of attempts, time spent on task).” generating a second product-specific model associated with the second instructional product, wherein the generating comprises: [0053] (a plurality of models may be implemented), [0016] “an algorithm which creates one or more statistically evolving models based on relational concept mapping,” (i.e. a main model that is defined and trained into product specific versions of the model based on the product specific training data), [0089] (generate domain models: a specification of required or desired knowledge and capabilities within a given domain, i.e. a product specific model); defining a second set of model parameters reflecting a second set of characteristics of an assessment environment and questions associated with the second instructional product; [0081] (computer aided assessment of performance of students and of pedagogic parameters related to assessments of said students), [0082] (ontological data, i.e. product specific student data, reflecting the explicit and implicit knowledge present within the collected data for each product), [0084] (for each product, parameters are defined based on “information about the activities of the student (e.g., answers to questions, the difficulty level of each question, the time it took to complete various tasks, the location where different tasks were performed,” i.e. the parameters for each product are defined); training the second set of model parameters based on a second set of representative student responses to the questions mapped to the set of skills in the second instructional product, to produce the second product-specific model configured to output a second set of probabilities of mastery for the set of skills; [0016] “an algorithm which creates one or more statistically evolving models based on relational concept mapping”, (i.e. training a model),[0089] (training the model on the first set of parameters, where the model “may receive as input multiple types of data: the required or desired knowledge map; mapping of tasks performed by the student to knowledge and capabilities represented in the knowledge map; information about the performed tasks, for example, task parameters (e.g., type, difficulty level) and performance metrics (e.g., correct or incorrect answer, number of attempts, time spent on task).”); applying the first product-specific model to first performance data associated with the first instructional product, to transform the first performance data into a first estimate of skill proficiency expressed as a first skill mastery probability, corresponding to the first plurality of skill-mapped items and the first instructional product, wherein the first skill mastery probability is output in a common probability-of-mastery format; [0090] (applying the specific domain model using data mining algorithms to allow a comprehensive view of individual product specific activities, i.e. the system drills down to a detailed view to produce product specific data based on the particular instructional product), [0093] (applying the first domain model to determine a first estimate of skill proficiency, specifically estimating a skill proficiency for calculation capability using student solved problems, expressed in common comparable output formats, i.e. calculation capabilities and solving numerical problems); applying the second product-specific model to second performance data associated with the second instructional product, transforming the second performance data into a second estimate of skill proficiency expressed as a second skill mastery probability, corresponding to the second plurality of skill-mapped items and the second instructional product, wherein the second skill mastery probability is output in the common probability-of-mastery format such that the first skill mastery probability and the second skill mastery probability are combinable by the third model; [0090] (applying the specific domain model using data mining algorithms to allow a comprehensive view of individual product specific activities, i.e. the system drills down to a detailed view to produce product specific data based on the enumerated instructional product), [0093] (applying the second domain model to determine a second estimate of skill proficiency in solving verbal mathematical problems involving estimates of skill proficiencies, i.e. calculation capabilities, solving numerical problems, solving verbal math problems, and reading comprehension, expressed in common comparable output formats, in this case, showing an overlap between calculation capabilities and solving numerical problems from product 1 to product 2, but with two new estimates of skill proficiencies that combine into one main skill, reading capability, in addition to the first skill of calculation capability); generating, by a third model, based on the first estimate of skill proficiency and the second estimate of skill proficiency, a combined estimate of skill proficiency relating to the first skill, by: [0096-0097] (generating a combined estimate of skill proficiency that combines the first and second estimates of proficiencies for at least a first skill, in this case, the first skill is calculation capabilities and the second skill is reading comprehension capabilities), [0126-0128] (generate, by a an algorithmic model, based on skill estimates of proficiency, a combined estimate of skill proficiencies based on student performance data in order to continuously track skill mastery as related to proficiency combinations for each of the skills), [0130] that ties the required knowledge to the acquired skills); determining a first signal strength corresponding to the first instructional product and a second signal strength corresponding to the second instructional product; [0108-0109] (data points, i.e. performance metrics that are collected and logged during the collection and logging of student performance data for individual tasks that signify signal strengths of a student per observation, per subject, per question, per product, each mapped to the ontology of skills), [0103] “For a given learning task, the parameters of the task determine how to modify the estimate regarding the variables that are directly related to this task. For example, if a student fails in a task, it would have a negative effect on the estimation of the value of a parent variable that is important for fulfilling that task. However, this negative effect may be smaller if the task is classified as a difficult task than if the task is classified as an easy task. Similarly, success in a difficult task may have a larger impact in strengthening the estimation that the student masters a capability that this task depends on,” i.e. strength of signals coming from for each of the first or second products may be gauged based on the strength of the signals), [0127] “the CAA is used in conjunction with adaptive learning, in which the system programs itself by adjusting …. strengths for producing the appropriate output” (such that the adjusting strengths produces at least a first and a second signal strength corresponding to the associated first and second products); determining first timepoint data associated with first observations of the first performance data and second timepoint data associated with second observations of the second performance data; [0004 and 0005] “creating a log of interactions of a student with one or more learning activities, wherein the learning activities are concept-tagged based on said ontology; one or more observable task performance items reflected in the log of interactions,” [0017] “student data at a plurality of time points;” determining a first weight for the first estimate of skill proficiency based on the first signal strength and the first timepoint data, and a second weight for the second estimate of skill proficiency based on the second signal strength and the second timepoint data; [0127] “summative assessment, which takes place after a period of instruction, and is used in order to prove that students gained knowledge over a certain time and/or to compare capabilities of students or student groups; and formative assessment, which is integrated throughout the learning process and in which evidence is used to adapt teaching to meet students' needs….the system programs itself by adjusting content, weights or strengths for producing the appropriate outputs,” (i.e. weights are based on time and strengths of data); applying a weighting function that assigns the first weight to the first estimate of skill proficiency and the second weight to the second estimate of skill proficiency to generate the combined estimate of skill proficiency; [0028] “modify at least one of the probabilities of the possible values of the set of one or more conditional distribution functions,” [0029] (the module, i.e. a model, determines a weighted pedagogic score, where the weighted scores are used to determine the combined proficiency and the strength that each individual proficiency plays in the combined proficiency; and therefore, a weighted pedagogic score is the cumulation of weighted individual scores, combined into one single pedagogic score, such that the individual proficiency categories of a plurality of at least two skills are weighted based on their signal strengths), [0096] (probability function that combines all estimates of proficiencies related to the first skill), [0105-0107] (applying a weighting function that assigns weights to each of the skill proficiencies, to return a combined proficiency); generating a universal profile comprising at least the combined estimate of skill proficiency relating to the first skill, wherein the combined estimate of skill proficiency is expressed in the common probability-of-mastery format; [0070] (data is formatted similarly to allow subsequent system processing), [0084] “the mappings between the activities performed by the student and the knowledge elements that these activities contribute to; and a model (e.g., a “required knowledge map”) of the knowledge elements and capabilities that the student is expected to master within a given learning unit, including the possible relationships between such elements. The knowledge map engine 173 utilizes these inputs to establish an “acquired knowledge map” estimating, at any given point in time, the degree to which the student mastered each of the required knowledge elements or capabilities. The knowledge map engine 173 may use graphical models of belief propagation to build a model of the knowledge map of the student, and may update this model over time, as information about more activities performed by the student becomes available,” [0126] (generation of a universal profile, combining the product specific results for a student based on ontological objectives of mastery); generating an interactive graphical interface comprising a display of at least a portion of the universal profile and one or more recommendations relating to the first instructional product and the second instructional product. [0072 and 0118] (interactive display interface for tracking data and results, including the universal profile as disclosed in [0084] above), [0058] (i.e. assignment of particular recommended learning activities or objects, from recommended learning products), [0073] (automatic analysis of student competencies in skills used to adaptively assign content recommendations) to accommodate the identified strengths and weaknesses of each Student for each skill), [0076] (“dynamic personalization” of content, i.e. adaptive assignments from the system and third party systems), [0117] (ongoing assessment to support dynamic adaptive activity assignments). Where Gal does not disclose, Cormode teaches: wherein determining each weight comprises applying a temporal decay function that decreases the respective weight based on elapsed time since the corresponding observations were generated; [Abstract] “the decayed weight of a tuple is based on its age, measured backward from the current time,” [Page 1 Introduction] “In processing data with timestamp information, it is common to down weight tuples which correspond to older data.” It would have been obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date, to apply the further known techniques of applying temporal decay function to down weight older data and apply a higher weight to the data that occurs most closely to the current time as the time decay functions of Gan were ready for improvement to yield predictable results. Gan discloses a base disclosure upon which the disclosure of Cormode can be seen as an improvement. The prior art contained a known technique of applying weights based on time, in the base device, such that the further descriptions of Cormode discloses the known technique that improves upon the prior art to provide a combined prior art disclosure that is obvious over the instant invention. A person having ordinary skill in the art would have recognized that applying the known technique would have yielded predictable results and resulted in an improved disclosure. Regarding Claims 2, 9, and 16: Gal discloses & Cormode teaches: The method of claim 1, Gal discloses: wherein the display of the at least the portion of the universal profile comprises a description of a proficiency associated with the first skill. [0073] (the display interface displays the detailed descriptions of the proficiencies of the first skill in the profile), [0079] (display interface further details what may be comprised within the different areas of the display including “explanations related to topics,” where topics can include descriptions of proficiencies from [0073] and [0079]). Regarding Claims 3, 10, and 17: Gal discloses and Cormode teaches: The method of claim 1, System of claim 10 or Non-transitory CRM of claim 15: Gal discloses: further comprising wherein the one or more recommendations comprise at least one of a first skill-mapped assignment associated with the first instructional product or a second skill-mapped assignment associated with the second instructional product. [0073]” (analysis of student competencies in skills used to adaptively assign content recommendations to accommodate identified strengths and weaknesses of particular students,” [0076] (“dynamic personalization” of content, i.e. adaptive assignments from the system and third-party systems), [0117] (adaptive activity assignments supported through ongoing assessment.) Regarding Claims 4, 11, and 18: Gal discloses and Cormode teaches: The method of claim 1, System of claim 10 or Non-transitory CRM of claim 15, Gal discloses: further comprising monitoring a growth metric associated with the first skill over a time period. [0113] “monitoring students' progress in their level of understanding of different assessed variables;” [0123] (student information is tracked and the “gained knowledge” is measured and mapped, where this paragraph discloses monitoring growth over time). Regarding Claims 5, 12, and 19: Gal discloses and Cormode teaches: The method of claim 1, System of claim 10 or Non-transitory CRM of claim 15, Gal discloses: further comprising generating a first prediction associated with performance corresponding to the first skill. [0173] (predicted future performance, where the prior art discloses “testing the accuracy of predicting test results”, it would be obvious to a person having ordinary skill in the art to predict performance corresponding to the first skill as the system in the prior art evidences actions surrounding the skills themselves and a test could be easily replaced with skill to perform the same function as it does in the disclosure of the prior art.). Regarding Claims 6, 13, and 20: Gal discloses and Cormode teaches: The method of claim 1, System of claim 10 or Non-transitory CRM of claim 15, Gal discloses: further comprising generating an update to the combined estimate of skill proficiency relating to the first skill based at least in part on updated performance first data and updated second performance data collected over a period of time. [0124] (updating the combined estimates of skill proficiencies includes the ongoing monitoring and assessment of student performance data, i.e. at least first and second performance data, collected over time). Conclusion Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to ANGELA HATCH whose telephone number is (571)270-1393. The examiner can normally be reached 10:00-6:00. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Nathan Uber can be reached at (571)270-3923. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. ANGELA HATCH Examiner Art Unit 3626 /ANGELA HATCH/Examiner, Art Unit 3626 /KIERSTEN V SUMMERS/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3626
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Show 4 earlier events
Nov 05, 2025
Response Filed
Feb 20, 2026
Final Rejection mailed — §101, §103, §112
Apr 15, 2026
Interview Requested
Apr 22, 2026
Applicant Interview (Telephonic)
Apr 22, 2026
Examiner Interview Summary
May 20, 2026
Request for Continued Examination
May 26, 2026
Response after Non-Final Action
Sep 01, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §101, §103, §112 (current)

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

3-4
Expected OA Rounds
0%
Grant Probability
0%
With Interview (+0.0%)
2y 11m (~0m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
High
PTA Risk
Based on 17 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month