NON-FINAL OFFICE ACTION
This Non-final office action addresses U.S. Application No. 18/399,069, which is a reissue application of U.S. Application No. 16/503,485 (the “485 Application”), entitled “MULTI QUANTIZED DIGITALLY CONTROLLED POWER SUPPLY VOLTAGE FOR MULTI AMPLIFIER STAGES”, which issued as U.S. Patent No. 11,211,900 (the “900 Patent") on December 28, 2021.
BRIEF SUMMARY OF THE PROCEEDING
Broadening: The instant application is filed within two years of issue of the 900 Patent.
Patent Term: Based upon an updated review of the file record Examiners find that the Patent term has not expired.
Litigation: Base upon Examiners review of the file itself, Examiners find that the 900 Patent is not involved in litigation.
AMENDMENT
Applicant filed a preliminary amendment on 12/28/2023 (the “2023 Preliminary Amendment”). The 2023 Preliminary Amendment has been considered and entered. This action is in response to the 2023 Preliminary Amendment.
STATUS OF CLAIMS
The 388 Patent issued with claims 1-20.
As of the date of this Office Action, the status of the claims is:
Patent claims 1-20 were amended.
New claims 21-34 were added.
Accordingly, claims 1-34 are subject to the examination of this present reissue application. Of these, claims 1, 9, 25 and 30 are independent claims.
PRIORITY
Examiners acknowledge that the instant application is a reissue of the 900 Patent that was issued from the 485 Application, filed July 4, 2019. Examiners also find that the 900 Patent does not claim foreign priority.
CLAIM INTERPRETATION
During examination, claims are given the broadest reasonable interpretation consistent with the specification and limitations in the specification are not read into the claims. See MPEP §2111, MPEP §2111.01 and In re Yamamoto et al., 222 USPQ 934 (Fed. Cir. 1984). Under a broadest reasonable interpretation, words of the claim must be given their plain meaning, unless such meaning is inconsistent with the specification. See MPEP §2111.01(I). It is further noted that it is improper to import claim limitations from the specification, i.e., a particular embodiment appearing in the written description may not be read into a claim when the claim language is broader than the embodiment. See MPEP §2111.01(II). Therefore, unless one of the exceptions applies below, Examiners will interpret the limitations of the pending and examined claims using the broadest reasonable interpretation.
A. Lexicographic Definitions
A first exception to the prohibition of reading limitations from the specification into the claims is when the Applicant for patent has provided a lexicographic definition for the term. See MPEP §2111.01(IV). Following an independent review of the claims in view of the specification herein, Examiners find that Patent Owner has not provided any lexicographic definitions related to claim terms with any reasonable clarity, deliberateness and precision.
B. Claim Interpretation Under 35 U.S.C. §112(f)
A second exception to the prohibition of reading limitations from the specification into the claims is when the claimed feature is written as a means-plus-function or a step-plus-function. See 35 U.S.C. §112(f) and MPEP §2181-2183. As noted in MPEP §2181, a three prong test is used to determine the scope of a means-plus-function or step-plus-function limitation in a claim:
(A) the claim limitation uses the term “means” or “step” or a term used as a substitute for “means” that is a generic placeholder (also called a nonce term or a non-structural term having no specific structural meaning) for performing the claimed function
(B) the term “means” or “step” or the generic placeholder is modified by functional language, typically, but not always linked by the transition word “for” (e.g., “means for”) or another linking word or phrase, such as "configured to" or "so that"
(C) the term “means” or “step” or the generic placeholder is not modified by sufficient structure, material, or acts for performing the claimed function.
Examiners find herein that claims 9-20, 23-24, 30-34 include one or more claim limitations that do not use the word “means,” but are nonetheless being interpreted under 35 U.S.C. §112(f) because the claim limitations uses a generic placeholder that is coupled with functional language without reciting sufficient structure to perform the recited function and the generic placeholder is not preceded by a structural modifier. Each such limitation will be discussed in turn as follows:
B1. FL #1: “a sampling circuitry” (Claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24)
A first means-plus-function phrase is recited in claim 9 (and included in each of dependent claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24), which recites “a sampling circuitry” or hereinafter FL #1. Examiners determine herein that FL #1 meets the three-prong test and thus will be interpreted as a means-plus-function limitation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
Examiners find that FL #1 in claim 9 recites:
“a sampling circuitry operable to sample the input signal carrying the information in accordance with a certain sampling rate to generate samples of the input signal carrying the information”
(B1)(a) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (A)
FL #1 meets invocation prong (A) because "means ... for" type language is recited. Examiners find that “circuitry” is a generic placeholder or nonce term equivalent to “means” because the term “circuitry” does not convey any particular structure. Examiners further note that the specification of the 900 Patent does not define “circuitry” and thus the specification of the 900 Patent does not impart or disclose any structure for the phrase. Examiners also find that “sampling” merely defines the functionality of the circuitry without implying any specific structure.
Furthermore, there is no disclosure or suggestion from the prior art or the 900 Patent that a “sampling circuitry" is a sufficient structure to perform the functions recited in FL #1. Outside of the patent claims, Examiners finds that the 900 Patent does not use the entire term “sampling circuitry”. Specifically, there is no suggestion that any known sampling circuitry of a prior art can perform the function as recited in FL #1 of claim 1.
Accordingly, Examiners find nothing in the specification, prosecution history or the prior art to construe “sampling circuitry” in FL #1 as the name of a sufficiently definite structure for performing the functions recited in FL #1 so as to take the overall claim limitation out of the ambit of §112(f). See Williamson v. Citrix Online, L.L.C., 115 USPQ2d 1105, 1112 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
In light of the above, the Examiners conclude that the term “sampling circuitry” is a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith. Because “sampling circuitry” is merely a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith, the Examiners conclude that FL #1 meets invocation Prong (A).
(B1)(b) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (B)
FL #1 meets invocation prong (B) because it recites the function: “to sample the input signal carrying the information in accordance with a certain sampling rate to generate samples of the input signal carrying the information”
(B1)(c) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (C)
FL #1 meets invocation prong (C) because FL #1 does not recite sufficient structure for performing the claimed function. Based upon a review of claims 9-12, 14-20, 23-24, particularly claim 9 itself, the Examiners find that FL #1 recites very little structure, if any, for performing the functions as set forth of FL #1.
In view of the Examiners findings above that FL #1 meets invocation prongs (A)-(C), the Examiners conclude FL #1 invokes interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
(B1)(d) Corresponding Structure
After a claimed phrase has been shown to invoke 35 U.S.C. §112(f), as found above, the next step is to determine the corresponding structure or material as described in the specification for performing the recited function. See MPEP §2181(II).
With regard to the hardware for the sampling circuitry of FL #1, Examiners are unable to find specific support. As shown in FIG. 5 of the 900 Patent, the sampling circuitry is shown as no more than a blank box 503. Examiners do not find a disclosure from the specification of the 900 Patent what structures are within the blank box 503. Nevertheless, Examiners do recognize that the sampling circuitry recited in claim 13 is implemented by discrete electronic components, digital signal processors or by software in field programmable gate arrays (FPGA). Examiners also do recognize that col. 19, line 63 - col. 20, line 3 discloses step 106 includes sampling the input signal in accordance with the sampling rate is implemented by a sampling circuit or a sample and hold (S/FI) circuit or with multicarrier signals, or step 106 can be implemented by a fast Fourier transform (FFT) with a higher time resolution to fulfill the sampling rate requirement.
Accordingly, based on these disclosures, Examiners find the corresponding hardware structures for sampling circuitry to be the sample and hold (S/FI) circuit, the fast Fourier transform (FFT) with the higher time resolution, the discrete electronic components, the digital signal processors or by software structure in the field programmable gate arrays (FPGA) having instructions thereon to perform specific sampling functions: i.e., the disclosure at column 19, lines 48 - col. 20, line 3 includes description of Fig. 1, steps 103, 106 contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #1. Or the disclosure at column 25, lines 49 - col. 26, line 3 includes description of Fig. 3, Steps 303, 306 contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #1.
PNG
media_image1.png
275
432
media_image1.png
Greyscale
PNG
media_image2.png
475
459
media_image2.png
Greyscale
PNG
media_image3.png
443
454
media_image3.png
Greyscale
FIGs. 1, 3 and 5 of the 900 Patent.
Accordingly, as required by 35 U.S.C. §112(f) Examiners find FL #1 will be limited to these corresponding hardware and software instructions record therein and equivalents thereof.
Regarding dependent claims 10-12, 14-20 and 23-24, Examiner find that FL #1 in these claims would have the same corresponding structures as discussed above for claim 9.
Claim 13 recites some structure for the sampling circuitry, thus, would not invoke interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
B2. FL #2: “a quantizer circuitry (Claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24)
A further means-plus-function phrase is recited in claim 9 (and dependent claims 10-12, 14-20 and 23-24), which recites “a quantizer circuitry” or hereinafter FL #2. Examiners determine herein that FL #2 meets the three prong test and thus will be interpreted as a means-plus-function limitation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
Examiners find that FL #2 in claim 9 recites:
“a quantizer circuitry operable to quantize the in-phase and quadrature-phase components to generate Nbq quantization bits that correspond to a quantized value of the in phase component and Nbq quantization bits that correspond to a quantized value of the quadrature-phase component”
(B2)(a) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (A)
FL #2 meets invocation prong (A) because "means ... for" type language is recited. Examiners find that “circuitry” is a generic placeholder or nonce term equivalent to “means” because the term “circuitry” does not convey any particular structure. Examiners further note that the specification of the 900 Patent does not define “circuitry” and thus the specification of the 900 Patent does not impart or disclose any structure for the phrase. Examiners also find that “quantizer” merely defines the functionality of the circuitry without implying any specific structure.
Furthermore, there is no disclosure or suggestion from the prior art or the 900 Patent that a “quantizer circuitry" is a sufficient structure to perform the functions recited in FL #2. Outside of the patent claims, Examiners finds that the 900 Patent does not use the entire term “quantizer circuitry”. Specifically, there is no suggestion that any known quantizer circuitry of a prior art can perform the functions as recited in FL #2 of claim 9.
Accordingly, Examiners find nothing in the specification, prosecution history or the prior art to construe “quantizer circuitry” in FL #2 as the name of a sufficiently definite structure for performing the functions recited in FL #2 so as to take the overall claim limitation out of the ambit of §112(f). See Williamson v. Citrix Online, L.L.C., 115 USPQ2d 1105, 1112 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
In light of the above, the Examiners conclude that the term “quantizer circuitry” is a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith. Because “quantizer circuitry” is merely a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith, the Examiners conclude that FL #2 meets invocation Prong (A).
(B2)(b) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (B)
FL #2 meets invocation prong (B) because it recites the function: “operable to quantize the in-phase and quadrature-phase components to generate Nbq quantization bits that correspond to a quantized value of the in phase component and Nbq quantization bits that correspond to a quantized value of the quadrature-phase component”
(B2)(c) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (C)
FL #2 meets invocation prong (C) because FL #2 does not recite sufficient structure for performing the claimed function. Based upon a review of claims 9-12, 14-20, 23-24, particularly claim 9 itself, Examiners find that FL #2 recites very little structure, if any, for performing the functions as set forth of FL #2.
In view of the Examiners findings above that FL #2 meets invocation prongs (A)-(C), the Examiners conclude FL #2 invokes interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
(B2)(d) Corresponding Structure
After a claimed phrase has been shown to invoke 35 U.S.C. §112(f), as found above, the next step is to determine the corresponding structure or material as described in the specification for performing the recited function. See MPEP §2181(II).
With regard to the hardware for the quantizer circuitry of FL #2, Examiners are unable to find specific support. As shown in FIG. 5 of the 900 Patent, the quantizer circuitry is shown as no more than a blank box 508. Examiners do not find a disclosure from the specification of the 900 Patent what structures are within the blank box 508. Nevertheless, Examiners do recognize that the quantizer circuitry recited in claim 13 is implemented by discrete electronic components, digital signal processors or by software in field programmable gate arrays (FPGA). Examiners also do recognize that col. 20, lines 17-19, 32-34 discloses instruction step 108 (or step 308, col. 26, lines 15-17, 30-33) includes processing in the quantizer which can be performed by a comparator and a LUT (look up table).
Accordingly, based on these disclosures, Examiners find the corresponding hardware structures for quantizer circuitry to be the comparator and the LUT, the discrete electronic components, the digital signal processors or by software structure in the field programmable gate arrays (FPGA) having instructions thereon to perform specific quantizer functions: the disclosure at column 20, lines 3-19 includes description of Fig. 1, steps 107-108 contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #2. Or the disclosure at column 26, lines 4-17 includes description of Fig. 3, steps 307-308 contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #2.
Accordingly, as required by 35 U.S.C. §112(f) Examiners find FL #2 will be limited to these corresponding hardware and software instructions record therein and equivalents thereof.
Regarding dependent claims 10-12, 14-20, and 23-24, Examiner find that FL #2 in these claims would have the same corresponding structures as discussed above for claim 9.
Claim 13 recites some structure for the sampling circuitry, thus, would not invoke interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
B3. FL #3: “a digital mapper circuitry” (Claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24)
A further means-plus-function phrase is recited in claim 9 (and included in dependent claims 10-12, 14-20, 23-24), which recites “a digital mapper circuitry” or hereinafter FL #3. Examiners determine herein that FL #3 meets the three prong test and thus will be interpreted as a means-plus-function limitation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
The Examiners find that FL #3 in claim 9 recites:
“a digital mapper circuitry operable to map the Nbq quantization bits that correspond to the quantized value of the in-phase component and the Nbq quantization bits that correspond to a quantized value of the quadrature-phase component to obtain an amplitude and a phase of a polar representation of each quantization bit, wherein the amplitude associated with the polar representation of each quantization bit is defined according to a decomposition of the quantized value into polar components with amplitudes given by the sets with Nbq amplitudes |Cl,i| and Nbq amplitudes |Cq,i| for the in-phase and quadrature-phase components, respectively;”
(B3)(a) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (A)
FL #3 meets invocation prong (A) because "means ... for" type language is recited. Examiners find that “circuitry” is a generic placeholder or nonce term equivalent to “means” because the term “circuitry” does not convey any particular structure. Examiners further note that the specification of the 900 Patent does not define “circuitry” and thus the specification of the 900 Patent does not impart or disclose any structure for the phrase. Examiners find that “digital mapper” merely defines the functionality of the circuitry without implying any specific structure.
Furthermore, there is no disclosure or suggestion from the prior art or the 900 Patent that a “digital mapper circuitry" is a sufficient structure to perform the functions recited in FL #3. Outside of the patent claims, Examiners finds that the 900 Patent does not use the entire term “digital mapper circuitry”. Specifically, there is no suggestion that any known digital mapper circuitry of a prior art can perform all the functions as recited in FL #3 of claim 9.
Accordingly, Examiners find nothing in the specification, prosecution history or the prior art to construe “the digital mapper circuitry” in FL #3 as the name of a sufficiently definite structure for performing the functions recited in FL #3 so as to take the overall claim limitation out of the ambit of §112(f). See Williamson v. Citrix Online, L.L.C., 115 USPQ2d 1105, 1112 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
In light of the above, the Examiners conclude that the term “digital mapper circuitry” is a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith. Because “digital mapper circuitry” is merely a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith, the Examiners conclude that FL #3 meets invocation Prong (A).
(B3)(b) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (B)
FL #3 meets invocation prong (B) because it recites the functions: “operable to map the Nbq quantization bits that correspond to the quantized value of the in-phase component and the Nbq quantization bits that correspond to a quantized value of the quadrature-phase component to obtain an amplitude and a phase of a polar representation of each quantization bit, wherein the amplitude associated with the polar representation of each quantization bit is defined according to a decomposition of the quantized value into polar components with amplitudes given by the sets with Nbq amplitudes |Cl,i| and Nbq amplitudes |Cq,i| for the in-phase and quadrature-phase components, respectively”.
(B3)(c) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (C)
FL #3 meets invocation prong (C) because FL #3 does not recite sufficient structure for performing the claimed function. Based upon a review of claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24, particularly claim 9 itself, the Examiners find that FL #3 recites very little structure, if any, for performing the functions as set forth of FL #3.
In view of the Examiners findings above that FL #3 meets invocation prongs (A)-(C), the Examiners conclude FL #3 invokes interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
(B3)(d) Corresponding Structure
After a claimed phrase has been shown to invoke 35 U.S.C. §112(f), as found above, the next step is to determine the corresponding structure or material as described in the specification for performing the recited function. See MPEP §2181(II).
With regard to the hardware for the digital mapper circuitry of FL #3, as shown in FIG. 5 of the 900 Patent, the digital mapper circuitry is shown as no more than a blank box 513. However, Examiners do recognize that col. 31, lines 33-35 disclose the digital mapper circuitry may include a FPGA and a LUT (look up table). Examiners also do recognize that the digital mapper circuitry recited in claim 13 is implemented by discrete electronic components, digital signal processors or by software in field programmable gate arrays (FPGA).
Regarding the software, the disclosure at column 20, lines 20-39 includes description of Fig. 1 contains an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #3: i.e., Step 109.
Accordingly, based on these disclosures, Examiners find the corresponding hardware structures for digital mapper circuitry to be the FPGA and the LUT (look up table), the discrete electronic components, the digital signal processors or by software structure in the field programmable gate arrays (FPGA) having instructions thereon to perform specific digital mapper functions: the disclosure at column 20, lines 20-39 includes description of Fig. 1, step 109 contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #3.
Accordingly, as required by 35 U.S.C. §112(f) Examiners find FL #3 will be limited to these corresponding hardware and software instructions record therein and equivalents thereof.
Regarding dependent claims 10-12, 14-17, 19-20, and 23-24, Examiners find that FL #3 in these claims would have the same corresponding structures as discussed above for claim 9.
Claim 13 recites some structure for the sampling circuitry, thus, would not invoke interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
Regarding dependent claim 18, even assuming “digital mapper circuitry comprises one or more look up tables (LUTs)” connotes some structure, however, the “one or more look up tables (LUTs)” itself impart insufficient structure for performing the entire claimed functions for the digital mapper circuitry of claim 9. Thus, claim 18 still invoke interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f) for the same reasons as discussed for claim 9.
B4. FL #4: “a Vdd voltage mapper circuitry” (Claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24)
A further means-plus-function phrase is recited in claim 9 (and included in dependent claims 10-12, 14-20, 23-24), which recites “a Vdd voltage mapper circuitry” or hereinafter FL #4. Examiners determine herein that FL #4 meets the three prong test and thus will be interpreted as a means-plus-function limitation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
The Examiners find that FL #4 in claim 9 recites:
“a Vdd voltage mapper circuitry that uses the signals provided by the digital mapper circuitry to generate a set of Nbq control signals used to select the Nbq supply voltage values Vdd to be applied to the amplifiers of an amplification stage circuitry with Nbq power amplifiers, according to power control information”.
(B4)(a) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (A)
FL #4 meets invocation prong (A) because "means ... for" type language is recited. Examiners find that “circuitry” is a generic placeholder or nonce term equivalent to “means” because the term “circuitry” does not convey any particular structure. Examiners note that the specification of the 900 Patent does not define “circuitry” and thus the specification of the 900 Patent does not impart or disclose any structure for the phrase. Examiners find that “Vdd voltage mapper” merely defines the functionality of the circuitry without implying any specific structure.
Furthermore, there is no disclosure or suggestion from the prior art or the 900 Patent that a “Vdd voltage mapper circuitry" is a sufficient structure to perform the functions recited in FL #4. Outside of the patent claims, Examiners finds that the 900 Patent does not use the entire term “Vdd voltage mapper circuitry”. Specifically, there is no suggestion that any known Vdd voltage mapper circuitry of a prior art can perform all the functions as recited in FL #4 of claim 9.
Accordingly, Examiners find nothing in the specification, prosecution history or the prior art to construe “the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry” in FL #4 as the name of a sufficiently definite structure for performing the functions recited in FL #4 so as to take the overall claim limitation out of the ambit of §112(f). See Williamson v. Citrix Online, L.L.C., 115 USPQ2d 1105, 1112 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
In light of the above, the Examiners conclude that the term “Vdd voltage mapper circuitry” is a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith. Because “Vdd voltage mapper circuitry” is merely a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith, the Examiners conclude that FL #4 meets invocation Prong (A).
(B4)(b) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (B)
FL #4 meets invocation prong (B) because it recites the function: “uses the signals provided by the digital mapper circuitry to generate a set of Nbq control signals used to select the Nbq supply voltage values Vdd to be applied to the amplifiers of an amplification stage circuitry with Nbq power amplifiers, according to power control information”.
(B4)(c) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (C)
FL #4 meets invocation prong (C) because FL #4 does not recite sufficient structure for performing the claimed function. Based upon a review of claims 9-12, 14-20 and 23-24, particularly claim 9 itself, the Examiners find that FL #4 recites very little structure, if any, for performing the functions as set forth of FL #4.
In view of the Examiners findings above that FL #4 meets invocation prongs (A)-(C), the Examiners conclude FL #4 invokes interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
(B4)(d) Corresponding Structure
After a claimed phrase has been shown to invoke 35 U.S.C. §112(f), as found above, the next step is to determine the corresponding structure or material as described in the specification for performing the recited function. See MPEP §2181(II).
With regard to the hardware for the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry of FL #4, Examiners are unable to find specific support. As shown in FIG. 5 of the 900 Patent, the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry is shown as no more than a blank box 517. Examiners do not find a disclosure from the specification of the 900 Patent what structures are within the blank box 517. Nevertheless, Examiners do recognize that the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry recited in claim 13 is implemented by discrete electronic components, digital signal processors or by software in field programmable gate arrays (FPGA).
Regarding the software, the disclosure at column 20, lines 40-53, col. 26, lines 18-38 includes description of Figs. 1 and 3, step 110 or 309 contains an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #4.
Accordingly, based on these disclosures, Examiners find the corresponding hardware structures for Vdd voltage mapper circuitry to be the discrete electronic components, the digital signal processors or by software structure in the field programmable gate arrays (FPGA) having instructions thereon to perform specific voltage mapper functions: the disclosure at column 20, lines 40-53 or col. 26, lines 18-38 includes description of Fig. 1, step 110 or Fig. 3, step 309 contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #4.
Accordingly, as required by 35 U.S.C. §112(f) Examiners find FL #4 will be limited to these corresponding hardware and software instructions record therein and equivalents thereof.
Regarding dependent claims 10-12, 14-20, and 23-24, Examiner find that FL #4 in these claims would have the same corresponding structures as discussed above for claim 9.
Claim 13 recites some structure for the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry, thus, would not invoke interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
B5. FL #5: “a mapper circuit” (Claims 30-34)
A further means-plus-function phrase is recited in claim 30 (and included in dependent claims 31-34), which recites “a mapper circuit” or hereinafter FL #5. Examiners determine herein that FL #5 meets the three prong test and thus will be interpreted as a means-plus-function limitation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
The Examiners find that FL #5 in claim 30 recites:
“a mapper circuit operable to map a first set of quantized bits that represents an in-phase rectangular domain component of an input signal to obtain an in-phase polar domain representation of each quantized bit of the first set of quantized bits and to map a second set of quantized bits that represents a quadrature-phase rectangular domain component of the input signal to obtain a quadrature-phase polar domain representation of each quantized bit of the second set of quantized bits, with the first and second sets of quantized bits having a same number of quantization bits and each quantization bit of the first and second sets of quantized bits corresponding to a certain magnitude”.
(B5)(a) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (A)
FL #5 meets invocation prong (A) because "means ... for" type language is recited. Examiners find that “circuit” is a generic placeholder or nonce term equivalent to “means” because the term “circuit” does not convey any particular structure. Examiners note that the specification of the 900 Patent does not define “circuit” and thus the specification of the 900 Patent does not impart or disclose any structure for the phrase. Examiners find that “mapper” merely defines the functionality of the circuit without implying any specific structure.
Furthermore, there is no disclosure or suggestion from the prior art or the 900 Patent that a “mapper circuit" is a sufficient structure to perform the functions recited in FL #5. Outside of the patent claims, Examiners finds that the 900 Patent does not use the entire term “mapper circuit”. Specifically, there is no suggestion that any known mapper circuit of a prior art can perform all the functions as recited in FL #5 of claim 30.
Accordingly, Examiners find nothing in the specification, prosecution history or the prior art to construe “the mapper circuit” in FL #5 as the name of a sufficiently definite structure for performing the functions recited in FL #5 so as to take the overall claim limitation out of the ambit of §112(f). See Williamson v. Citrix Online, L.L.C., 115 USPQ2d 1105, 1112 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
In light of the above, the Examiners conclude that the term “mapper circuit” is a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith. Because “mapper circuit” is merely a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith, the Examiners conclude that FL #5 meets invocation Prong (A).
(B5)(b) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (B)
FL #5 meets invocation prong (B) because it recites the functions: “operable to map a first set of quantized bits that represents an in-phase rectangular domain component of an input signal to obtain an in-phase polar domain representation of each quantized bit of the first set of quantized bits and to map a second set of quantized bits that represents a quadrature-phase rectangular domain component of the input signal to obtain a quadrature-phase polar domain representation of each quantized bit of the second set of quantized bits, with the first and second sets of quantized bits having a same number of quantization bits and each quantization bit of the first and second sets of quantized bits corresponding to a certain magnitude”.
(B5)(c) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (C)
FL #5 meets invocation prong (C) because FL #5 does not recite sufficient structure for performing the claimed function. Based upon a review of claims 30-34, particularly claim 30 itself, the Examiners find that FL #5 recites very little structure, if any, for performing the functions as set forth of FL #5.
In view of the Examiners findings above that FL #5 meets invocation prongs (A)-(C), the Examiners conclude FL #5 invokes interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
(B5)(d) Corresponding Structure
After a claimed phrase has been shown to invoke 35 U.S.C. §112(f), as found above, the next step is to determine the corresponding structure or material as described in the specification for performing the recited function. See MPEP §2181(II).
With regard to the hardware for the mapper circuit of FL #5, Examiners are unable to find specific support. There is no “magnitude” limitation disclose in the specification of the 900 Patent. However, the 900 Patent does disclose “amplitude” (col. 14, line 29, col. 16, lines 9, 11, col. 17, line 54 …). If considered as “amplitude” aspect, as shown in Figs. 2A, 2B, 4A, 4B, and 5 of the 900 Patent, the mapper circuit is shown as no more than blank box 205 (Figs. 2A-2B), or blank box 405 (Figs. 4A-4B). Examiners further do not find a disclosure from the specification of the 900 Patent what structures are within these blank boxes 205 or 405. In addition, the details of the mapper block 205 or 405 are disclosed in Fig. 5. Examiners also do not find a disclosure from the specification of the 900 Patent what structures are within these blank boxes, sampling block 503, phase shifter block 505, quantizer block 508, digital mapper block 513 and Vdd voltage mapper block 517. Nevertheless, Examiners do recognize that the sampling circuitry, digital mapper circuitry, the quantizer circuitry and the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry recited in claim 13 are implemented by discrete electronic components, digital signal processors or by software in field programmable gate arrays (FPGA). Examiners also do recognize that col. 31, lines 33-35 discloses the digital mapper block may include a FPGA and lookup tables.
PNG
media_image1.png
275
432
media_image1.png
Greyscale
PNG
media_image4.png
465
592
media_image4.png
Greyscale
Figs. 2A and 5 of the 900 Patent.
Regarding the software, the disclosure at column 19, line 63 - col. 20, line 53, col. 26, lines 4-38 includes description of steps 107-110 (Fig. 1) or steps 307-309 (Fig. 3) contains an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #5 (if considered as “amplitude” aspect).
PNG
media_image2.png
475
459
media_image2.png
Greyscale
PNG
media_image3.png
443
454
media_image3.png
Greyscale
Figs. 1 and 3 of the 900 Patent.
Accordingly, based on these disclosures, Examiners find the corresponding hardware structures for mapper circuit to be the sampling, the phase shifter, the quantizer, the amplitude mapper, the voltage mapper as shown in Fig. 5, whereas each of these components are implemented by the discrete electronic components, the digital signal processors or by software structure in the field programmable gate arrays (FPGA) having instructions thereon to perform specific functions, i.e. steps 107-110 (Fig. 1) or steps 307-309 (Fig. 3) contain an algorithm that achieves the Function of FL #5 (if considered as amplitude aspect).
Accordingly, as required by 35 U.S.C. §112(f) Examiners find FL #5 will be limited to these corresponding hardware and software instructions record therein and equivalents thereof.
Regarding dependent claims 31-34, Examiners find that FL #5 in these claims would have the same corresponding structures as discussed above for claim 30.
B6. FL #6: “a combiner circuit” (Claims 30-34)
A further means-plus-function phrase is recited in claim 30 (and included in dependent claims 31-34), which recites “a combiner circuit” or hereinafter FL #6. Examiners determine herein that FL #6 meets the three prong test and thus will be interpreted as a means-plus-function limitation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
The Examiners find that FL #6 in claim 30 recites:
“a combiner circuit operable to combine, for each quantization bit, the in-phase and quadrature-phase polar domain representations to obtain a set of polar domain signals, with each polar domain signal corresponding to a certain quantization bit, with a number of the set of polar domain signals corresponding to a number of quantization bits and a combination of the set of polar domain signals corresponding to the input signal”.
(B6)(a) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (A)
FL #6 meets invocation prong (A) because "means ... for" type language is recited. Examiners find that “circuit” is a generic placeholder or nonce term equivalent to “means” because the term “circuit” does not convey any particular structure. Examiners further note that the specification of the 900 Patent does not define “circuit” and thus the specification of the 900 Patent does not impart or disclose any structure for the phrase. Examiners find that “combiner” merely defines the functionality of the circuit without implying any specific structure.
Furthermore, there is no disclosure or suggestion from the prior art or the 900 Patent that a “combiner circuit" is a sufficient structure to perform the functions recited in FL #6. Outside of the patent claims, Examiners finds that the 900 Patent does not use the entire term “combiner circuit”. Specifically, there is no suggestion that any known combiner circuit of a prior art can perform all the functions as recited in FL #6 of claim 30.
Accordingly, Examiners find nothing in the specification, prosecution history or the prior art to construe “the combiner circuit” in FL #6 as the name of a sufficiently definite structure for performing the functions recited in FL #6 so as to take the overall claim limitation out of the ambit of §112(f). See Williamson v. Citrix Online, L.L.C., 115 USPQ2d 1105, 1112 (Fed. Cir. 2015).
In light of the above, the Examiners conclude that the term “combiner circuit” is a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith. Because “combiner circuit” is merely a generic placeholder having no specific structure associated therewith, the Examiners conclude that FL #6 meets invocation Prong (A).
(B6)(b) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (B)
FL #6 meets invocation prong (B) because it recites the function: “operable to combine, for each quantization bit, the in-phase and quadrature-phase polar domain representations to obtain a set of polar domain signals, with each polar domain signal corresponding to a certain quantization bit, with a number of the set of polar domain signals corresponding to a number of quantization bits and a combination of the set of polar domain signals corresponding to the input signal”.
(B6)(c) 3-Prong Analysis: Prong (C)
FL #6 meets invocation prong (C) because FL #6 does not recite sufficient structure for performing the claimed function. Based upon a review of claims 30-34, particularly claim 30 itself, the Examiners find that FL #6 recites very little structure, if any, for performing the functions as set forth of FL #6.
In view of the Examiners findings above that FL #6 meets invocation prongs (A)-(C), the Examiners conclude FL #6 invokes interpretation under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
(B6)(d) Corresponding Structure
After a claimed phrase has been shown to invoke 35 U.S.C. §112(f), as found above, the next step is to determine the corresponding structure or material as described in the specification for performing the recited function. See MPEP §2181(II).
With regard to the hardware for the combiner circuit of FL #6, Examiners are unable to find specific support. As shown in Figs. 2A, 2B, 4A, 4B of the 900 Patent, the combiner circuit is shown as no more than blank box 233 (Figs. 2A-2B), or blank box 429 (Figs. 4A-4B). Examiners further do not find a disclosure from the specification of the 900 Patent what structures are within these blank boxes 233 or 429. Nevertheless, Examiners do recognize that col. 22, lines 59-62, col. 28, lines 29-32 disclose that the combiner box 233 or 429 using well known combining techniques such as active combiners or other techniques such as Wilkinson, hybrid or transformers.
PNG
media_image5.png
602
726
media_image5.png
Greyscale
PNG
media_image6.png
580
715
media_image6.png
Greyscale
Figs. 2A and 4A of the 900 Patent.
Thus, based on these disclosures, Examiners find the corresponding hardware structures for combiner circuit to be active combiners or other techniques such as Wilkinson, hybrid or transformers.
Accordingly, as required by 35 U.S.C. §112(f) Examiners find FL #6 will be limited to this corresponding hardware therein and equivalents thereof.
Regarding dependent claims 31-34, Examiner find that FL #6 in these claims would have the same corresponding structures as discussed above for claim 30.
If applicant does not intend to have these limitations, Fl#1-FL#6 interpreted under 35 U.S.C. §112(f) applicant may: (1) amend the claim limitation(s) to avoid it/them being interpreted under 35 U.S.C. §112(f) (e.g., by reciting sufficient structure to perform the claimed function); or (2) present a sufficient showing that the claim limitation recites sufficient structure to perform the claimed function so as to avoid it/them being interpreted under 35 U.S.C. §112(f).
C. Conclusion of Claim Interpretation
In view of the forgoing, Examiners will interpret FL #1 – FL #6 under 35 U.S.C. §112(f). Because the remaining limitations are not lexicographically defined and need no special interpretation, the remaining limitations will be interpreted using the broadest reasonable interpretation.
OBJECTION TO AMENDMENT
37 C.F.R. 1.173 Reissue specification, drawings, and amendments.
(c) Status of claims and support for claim changes. Whenever there is an amendment to the claims pursuant to paragraph (b) of this section, there must also be supplied, on pages separate from the pages containing the changes, the status (i.e., pending or canceled), as of the date of the amendment, of all patent claims and of all added claims, and an explanation of the support in the disclosure of the patent for the changes made to the claims.
(d) Changes shown by markings. Any changes relative to the patent being reissued that are made to the specification, including the claims but excluding "Large Tables" (§ 1.58(c) ), a "Computer Program Listing Appendix" (§ 1.96(c) ), a "Sequence Listing" (§ 1.821(c) ), and a "Sequence Listing XML" (§ 1.831(a) ) upon filing or by an amendment paper in the reissue application, must include the following markings:
(1) The matter to be omitted by reissue must be enclosed in brackets; and
(2) The matter to be added by reissue must be underlined.
(g) Amendments made relative to the patent. All amendments must be made relative to the patent specification, including the claims, and drawings, which are in effect as of the date of filing of the reissue application.
The claim amendments in the 2023 Preliminary Amendment are objected to because Applicant has not provided a proper explanation of support for the claim changes as required above. On page 20 of the 2023 Preliminary Amendment, Examiners find that Applicant has merely provided a citation of support, not an explanation of support for the changes. Specifically, Applicant must identify how the patent claims have been amended to arrive at the pending claims and further the support for the deletions and the additions to the claims. Such an explanation goes to the merits of written description and original patent requirements. Appropriate correction is required in response to this Office action.
REJECTIONS – 35 U.S.C. §112
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112:
The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112(b):
(b) CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
Claims 9, 12 and 22 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor (or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the applicant), regards as the invention.
Claim 9 recites the limitation "the in-phase" in line 15. There is insufficient antecedent basis for this limitation in the claim.
Regarding claim 12, it is unclear as to whether “a quantizer circuitry” recited in line 14 is additional limitation “a quantizer circuitry” as previously cited in claim 9, line 15.
Regarding claim 33, it is unclear as to whether “a combiner circuit” recited in line 2 is additional limitation “a combiner circuit” as previously cited in claim 30, line 11.
Claims 25-34 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention.
Regarding new claim 25: Claim 25 has been added to recite: “mapping a first set of quantized bits … and each quantization bit of the first and second sets of quantized bits corresponding to a certain magnitude” (lines 2-9). However, following a careful review of the 900 Patent, Examiners does not find support for such a new limitation “corresponding to a certain magnitude” and thus is new matter herein. Examiners recognize that the 900 Patent does disclose step 109 includes processing individually the quantization bits of the quantized in-phase component to generate the corresponding amplitude and phase of polar representation of each quantization bit and processing individually the quantization bits of the quantized quadrature component to generate the corresponding amplitude and phase of polar representation of each quantization bit. The amplitude associated to each quantization bit is defined according to the decomposition of the quantized value into polar components with amplitudes given by the sets with Nbq amplitudes |cI,i| and Nbq amplitudes |cq,i| for the in-phase and quadrature component. And step 110 includes processing the sets with Nbq amplitudes |cI,i| and Nbq amplitudes |c q,I| for the in-phase and quadrature component, to generate the control information that selects the corresponding set of Nbq values of Vdd to be applied to the Nbq amplifiers. Still, it is silent upon “the corresponding of a certain magnitude”. Insofar as understood, amplitude and
magnitude are both terms used to describe properties of quantities. However, the main difference between amplitude and magnitude is that amplitude refers to the furthest values that a quantity can take from 0, whereas
magnitude refer to the size of a quantity regardless of direction. Amplitude indicates the strength or intensity of a wave and amplitude can be positive or negative depending on the direction of displacement. While magnitude, on the other hand, describes the size or quantity of a physical variable regardless of direction. Magnitude is always a positive value and can describe quantities like distance, speed, force or energy. Accordingly, Examiners find “the corresponding of a certain magnitude” recited in new claim 25 lacks any direction, support or disclosure in the 900 Patent. Thus, Examiners find claim 25 contains new matter.
Because claims 26-29 depend on claim 26, Examiners conclude these claims contain new matter for the same reasons as for claim 25.
New claim 30 recites “a mapper circuit … and each quantization bit of the first and second sets of quantized bits corresponding to a certain magnitude”. Similarly, as new claim 25, Examiners find “the corresponding of a certain magnitude” recited in new claim 30 lacks any direction, support or disclosure in the 900 Patent. Thus, Examiners find claim 30 contains new matter for similar reasons as claim 25.
Because claims 31-34 depend on claim 30, Examiners conclude these claims contain new matter for the same reasons as for claim 30.
REISSUE OATH/DECLARATION
37 C.F.R. §1.175 Reissue oath or declaration (in part).
(a) The inventor’s oath or declaration for a reissue application, in addition to complying with the requirements of § 1.63, § 1.64, or § 1.67, must also specifically identify at least one error pursuant to 35 U.S.C. 251 being relied upon as the basis for reissue and state that the applicant believes the original patent to be wholly or partly inoperative or invalid by reason of a defective specification or drawing, or by reason of the patentee claiming more or less than the patentee had the right to claim in the patent.
(b) If the reissue application seeks to enlarge the scope of the claims of the patent (a basis for the reissue is the patentee claiming less than the patentee had the right to claim in the patent), the inventor's oath or declaration for a reissue application must identify a claim that the application seeks to broaden. A claim is a broadened claim if the claim is broadened in any respect.
The reissue declarations filed along with the filing of the present application (hereinafter the “2023 Reissue Declaration”) is acknowledged. However, Examiners object to the 2023 Reissue Declaration on the basis that Examiners find that it fails to state a proper error in the claims on which to base this reissue.
There is no error statement provided in the 2023 Reissue Declaration. A proper error statement must identify a single word, phrase, or expression in the specification or in an original claim in the underlying patent, i.e., the 900 Patent, and how it renders the original patent wholly or partly inoperative or invalid. See MPEP §1414(II).
Thus, Applicant is required to provide a new declaration with a statement of error with respect to 900 Patent identifying “a single word, phrase, or expression” from the claims of the 900 Patent that rendered the 900 Patent invalid or inoperative.
37 CFR §3.73(c) STATEMENT
This application is objected to under 37 CFR 1.172(a) as the assignee has not established its ownership interest in the patent for which reissue is being requested. An assignee must establish its ownership interest in order to support the consent to a reissue application required by 37 CFR 1.172(a). The assignee’s ownership interest is established by:
(a) filing in the reissue application evidence of a chain of title from the original owner to the assignee, or
(b) specifying in the record of the reissue application where such evidence is recorded in the Office (e.g., reel and frame number, etc.).
The submission with respect to (a) and (b) to establish ownership must be signed by a party authorized to act on behalf of the assignee. See MPEP § 1410.01.
An appropriate paper satisfying the requirements of 37 CFR 3.73 must be submitted in reply to this Office action.
In this case, Patent Assignment cover sheet filed on March 27, 2025 (hereinafter “2025 Patent Assignment”) is objected to because: After reviewing the present reissue application, Examiners find that the 2025 Patent Assignment does not identify Reel/Frame Number of the assignment record. The Applicant showing ownership must be in compliance with 37 CFR 1.172. See MPEP §1410.01. The below Assignment: Reel/Frame 70918/0026 is missing from the 2025 Patent Assignment. Applicant is required to provide a new statement under 37 C.F.R. §3.73(c) properly identifying the assignment records.
PNG
media_image7.png
756
1210
media_image7.png
Greyscale
Form PTO/AIA /96 should be use, signed by, or on behalf of, the assignee pursuant to 37 CFR 3.73(c)(2)-(d)(3). See MPEP 1410.02.
CONSENT
Since Applicant is the Owner of the 900 Patent as of the filling date of this reissue, thus, a written consent of the assignee in compliance with 37 C.F.R. §1.172 is not needed. However, where no assignee exists, Applicant should affirmatively state that fact. This can be done by simply checking the "NO" box of item 8 of Form PTO/AIA /50, which may be signed by the inventors or by a registered practitioner. See MPEP 1410.02.
REJECTIONS – 35 U.S.C. §251
35 U.S.C. §251 Reissue of defective patents.
(a) IN GENERAL.—Whenever any patent is, through error, deemed wholly or partly inoperative or invalid, by reason of a defective specification or drawing, or by reason of the patentee claiming more or less than he had a right to claim in the patent, the Director shall, on the surrender of such patent and the payment of the fee required by law, reissue the patent for the invention disclosed in the original patent, and in accordance with a new and amended application, for the unexpired part of the term of the original patent. No new matter shall be introduced into the application for reissue.
Rejection Based on Defective Declaration
Claims 1-34 and this application as a whole are rejected under 35 U.S.C. §251 as being based upon a defective reissue oath/declaration as set forth above. See 37 C.F.R. §1.175. The nature of the defects in the 2023 Reissue Declaration is set forth in the discussion above in this Office action.
Rejection Based on New Matter
Claims 25-34 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 251 as being based upon new matter added to the patent for which reissue is sought. The new added material “a mapper circuit … and each quantization bit of the first and second sets of quantized bits corresponding to a certain magnitude”, which is not supported by the 900 Patent, is set forth in the discussion above.
REJECTIONS UNDER 35 U.S.C. §251 – ORIGINAL PATENT REQUIREMENT
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. §251(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—Whenever any patent is, through error, deemed wholly or partly inoperative or invalid, by reason of a defective specification or drawing, or by reason of the patentee claiming more or less than he had a right to claim in the patent, the Director shall, on the surrender of such patent and the payment of the fee required by law, reissue the patent for the invention disclosed in the original patent, and in accordance with a new and amended application, for the unexpired part of the term of the original patent. No new matter shall be introduced into the application for reissue.
MPEP §1412.01 states that the reissue claims must be for the same invention as that disclosed as being the invention of the original patent. MPEP §1412.01 further provides guidelines for determining whether the reissue claims are “for the invention disclosed in the original patent” as:
(A) the claims presented in the reissue application are described in the original patent specification and enabled by the original patent specification such that 35 U.S.C. 112, first paragraph is satisfied;
PNG
media_image8.png
18
19
media_image8.png
Greyscale
(B) nothing in the original patent specification indicates an intent not to claim the subject matter of the claims presented in the reissue application; and
PNG
media_image8.png
18
19
media_image8.png
Greyscale
(C) the newly claimed invention is clearly and unequivocally disclosed in the specification as a separate invention with the claimed combination of features.
The Fed. Cir. addressed the “original patent” requirement in Antares Pharma, Inc. v. Medac Pharma Inc., 112 USPQ2d 1865 (Fed. Cir. 2014). The court stated that “a reissue claim is for the ‘same invention’ if the original patent specification fully describes the claimed inventions, but not if the broader claims ‘are [] merely suggested or indicated in the original specification.” Antares, 112 USPQ2d at 1868 (citing U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in U.S. Industrial Chemicals). Further, the court stated “‘it is not enough that an invention might have been claimed in the original patent because it was suggested or indicated in the specification.’ Rather, the specification must clearly and unequivocally disclose the newly claimed invention as a separate invention.” Antares, 112 USPQ2d at 1871 (citing U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in U.S. Industrial Chemicals) (citation omitted), or that “the exact embodiment claimed on reissue [be] expressly disclosed in the specification.” Id.
Recently, the Fed. Cir. stated:
Thus, for broadening reissue claims, the specification of the original patent must do more than merely suggest or indicate the invention recited in reissue claims; “[I]t must appear from the face of the instrument that what is covered by the reissue was intended to have been covered and secured by the original.” Indus Chems, 315 US at 676 (emphasis in Forum US). Stated differently, the original patent “must clearly and unequivocally disclose the newly claimed invention as a separate invention.” Antares, 771 F.3d at 1362.1
Claims 1-20 and 25-34 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. §251 because they are not for the same invention as that disclosed as being the invention in the original patent.
Initially, Examiners find that each of the patent claims of the 900 Patent have been broadened by the deletion of the following features:
In patent claim 9:
an input circuitry that receives a clock signal with a value set according to a signal frequency of the input signal.
an input circuitry that receives a clock signal with a value set according to a desired sampling rate of the input signal;
an input circuitry that receives a clock signal in accordance with a desired output signal frequency of a desired output signal.
an input circuitry that receives a slow and fast power control information.
a circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, that generates the phase rotations associated to the polar representation of each quantization bit and adjust delays between the polar signals associated to the quantization bits.
a circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal according to the in- phase amplitude coefficients |C₁,i| to generate Nbq in-phase constituent signals and a circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each quadrature polar signal according with the quadrature amplitude coefficients to generate Nbq quadrature constituent signals.
a bank of filters with the same impulsive response, that receives the in-phase and quadrature constituent signals and filters them to assure a desired spectral shape.
circuitry that combines pairs of in-phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals to generate a set of Nbq constituent signals with quasi or constant envelope.
a circuitry that receives the Nbq constituent signals with quasi or constant envelope and up-convert them by multiplying each one by a periodic signal, with the desired output signal frequency.
an amplification stage circuitry with Nbq power amplifiers in parallel, that receives said constituent signals with quasi or constant, comprising at least Nbq active power amplification branches with different power output levels controlled by a set of supply voltage values Vdd provided by the digital mapper circuitry, wherein each one of the said constituent signals with quasi or constant envelope-is amplified by the power amplifier of his branch;
a combiner circuitry coupled to the Nbq branches of said amplification stage circuitry that combines the outputs of the branches of said amplification stage circuitry according to the control signals of V voltage mapper circuitry.
Rather the presentation of claim 9 (and its dependent claims 10-20) in the 2023 Preliminary Amendment only require “sampling circuitry”, “a quantizer circuitry”, “a digital mapper circuitry” and “Vdd voltage mapper circuitry” with no requirement of “first -third clock signals, a slow and fast power control information to control an output power of an amplification stage, a circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, a circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, a bank of filters, a circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, a multiplying circuitry, an amplification stage circuitry and a combiner circuitry”.
Similarly, regarding claims 1-8, Examiners find these claims also fail the original patent requirement for the same reasons regarding the method for power amplification with multi quantized digitally controlled power supply voltage on amplifier stages as for claims 9-20 based on their similar limitations, albeit encompassed in method limitations. For example, the deletion limitation of claim 1:
(1) receiving a first clock signal with a value set according to a signal frequency of the input signal.
(2) receiving a second clock signal with a value set according to a desired sampling rate of the input signal.
(3) receiving a third clock signal in accordance with a desired output signal frequency of a desired output signal.
(4) receiving a slow and fast power control information to control an output power of an amplification stage with Nbq power amplifiers, where Nbq denotes the number of power amplifiers, by selecting different sets of Nbq supply voltage values Vdd to be applied to the Nbq power amplifiers over different information blocks or over each data block of the input signal carrying the information;
(5) processing the polar components of in-phase component by multiplying by a pulse signal with a desired spectral shape and processing the polar components of quadrature component by multiplying by a pulse signal with a desired spectral shape.
(6) processing the in-phase signals and quadrature signals by summing pairs of signals with a same amplitude to generate a set of Nbq constituent signals with constant envelope and a sum equal to the quantized version of the signal carrying the information;
(7) multiplying the resulting set of Nbq constituent signals with constant envelope by a periodic signal with the frequency of a radio frequency (RF) signal;
(8) biasing the Nbq power amplifiers of the amplification stage with a set of Nbq supply voltage values Vdd, and/or drive currents, according to the decomposition of the quantized values into polar components and the slow and fast power control information;
(9) amplifying each one of the Nbq constituent signals in one of Nbq power amplifiers of said amplification stage and summing in a combiner the amplified constituent signals to create the desired output signal.
Similar with new claims 25-34, these claims only require “a mapper circuit” and “a combiner circuit” with no requirement of “the first -third clock signals, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the circuitry that receives the Nbq constituent signals, and the amplification stage circuitry” as called for in the original claims 1-20 of the 900 Patent.
The new invention now being claimed in claims 1-20 and 25-34 is directed to an apparatus/method that do not require the first -third clock signals, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of an amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry and the amplification stage circuitry. Specifically, Examiners find the claims cover a new and broader class of the apparatus for power amplification with multi-quantized digitally controlled power supply voltage on amplifier stages that only require the sampling circuitry, the quantizer circuitry, the digital mapper circuitry and the Vdd voltage mapper (claims 1-20) or only require the mapper circuit and a combiner circuit (claims 25-34). Examiners find that Applicant has broadened the claims to such an extent that the claims now cover a new and broader invention than patented in the 900 Patent.
Examiners do not find an unequivocal disclosure in the 900 Patent for this new and broader invention as a separate invention, i.e., an apparatus that does not require first - third clock signals, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry. First for example, such a requirement of the above limitations was patented in all the claims 1-20 of the 900 Patent. Second, Examiners find the 900 Patent shows in Figs. 1-4A show the apparatus that involve first -third clock signals, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry for performing multi quantized digitally controlled power supply voltage for multi amplifier stages, and the 900 Patent states that: “Step 102 includes receiving a clock signal set according to the signal frequency of the input signal.
Step 103 includes receiving a clock signal set according to a desired sample rate of the input signal. It is important to mention that, as understood by N person skilled in the art, the sampling rate may vary according to the bandwidth of the input signal and the desired time resolution of the sampling process.
Step 104 includes receiving a clock signal in accordance with the frequency of the desired output RF signal.
Step 105 includes receiving slow and fast power control information to control the power output level after the amplification stage, by selecting different sets of V values and amplifiers' source currents over different information blocks. or selecting different sets of Vₐ values and amplifiers' source currents for the different samples of the envelope of the input signal carrying the information to be sent.
Step 111A includes processing the polar in-phase components by multiplying by a pulse signal with the desired spectral shape.
Step 111B includes processing the polar quadrature components by multiplying by a pulse signal with the desired spectral shape.
Step 112 is optional and includes multiplying the resulting signals of steps 111A and 111B by a periodic signal with the frequency of the IF signal.
Step 113 includes processing the in-phase signals and quadrature signals by summing pairs of signals with same amplitude to generate a set of Nₕₐ signals with constant envelope and a sum equal to the quantized version of the envelope.
Step 114 includes multiplying the resulting signals of step 113 by a periodic signal with the frequency of the RF signal.
Step 115 includes the biasing of the Nbq amplifiers with the corresponding set of Nbq values of Vdd defined in steps 105 and 109 according the mapping rule of the decomposition of the quantized values.
Step 116 includes individually amplifying each one of the constituent signals and summing the amplified signals to generate the desired output signal.”
(col. 19, lines 46-62, col. 20, line 54 - col. 21, line 9)
The embodiment of invention contemplated in the 900 Patent requires steps 102-105, 111A-116 of Fig. 1 (or steps 302-305, 310A-315 of Fig. 3 disclose in cols. 25-26). Furthermore, both the drawings, Figs. 1-7 and the detailed description of the invention explained in col. 21, line 10 – col. 25, line 33; col. 27, line 1- col. 30, line 38 explicitly state the invention includes the first - third clock signal, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry. Examiners are unable to find any unequivocal support for a disclosure of the apparatus that does not require the first - third clock signals, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry. Rather every embodiment disclosed and contemplated in the 900 Patent explicitly requires such the first - third clock signal, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry.
Examiners find such the first - third clock signals, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry critical to the invention disclosed in the 900 Patent. See the drawings, Figs. 1-4B (for example) and disclosure of the 900 Patent.
As noted above, the original patent requirement puts a limit on the manner to which reissue applicants can broaden the patent claims in reissue. Specifically, claims that are broadened in reissue that cover a new scope/class of invention must have an unequivocal disclosure on the face of the original patent for that new class of invention as a separate invention. Following a careful review of claims 1-20 and 25-34 in this reissue application with respect to the claims as patented in the 900 Patent, Examiners find the new scope of claims 1-20 and 25-34 covers a new and broader invention that is not unequivocally disclosed on the face the 900 Patent as a separate invention. Specifically, Examiners do not find an unequivocal disclosure or a discussion of the new invention of providing an apparatus that does not require the first -third clock signal, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the circuitry with phase shifters and polar converters, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry. Rather Examiners find that the above limitations are critical and/or important and required features of every embodiment of the invention in the 900 Patent. Thus, Examiners conclude claims 1-20 and 25-34 presented in this reissue application fail the original patent requirement and thus are rejected under 35 U.S.C. §251.
This situation is also analogous to the recent Federal Circuit decision in Forum US, Inc. v. Flow Valve, LLC, 926 F.3d 1346 (Fed. Cir. 2019). In Forum US, the original patent claims were drawn to a workpiece having a body member and a plurality of arbors (arbors circled):
PNG
media_image9.png
267
600
media_image9.png
Greyscale
Forum US, 926 F.3d at 1348-49.
In reissue, patentee broadened the claims to remove the requirement as to arbors. Id. at 1349. The Federal Circuit determined that the new claims did not comply with the original patent requirement of section 251 because the face of the patent did not disclose any arbor-less embodiment, and the abstract, summary of invention, and all disclosed embodiments including arbors. Id. at 1352. The Court concluded that the specification did not clearly and unequivocally disclose an embodiment without arbors, thus the original patent requirement was violated by broadening the claims to no longer require arbors. Id.
In the present reissue, Examiners similarly find original claims 1-20 of the 900 Patent and the disclosure of the 900 Patent as a whole are focused on the power amplification apparatus including the multiple clock signals, the sampling circuitry, the quantizer circuitry, the digital mapper circuitry, the Vdd voltage mapper circuitry, phase shifters and polar converters circuitry, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in-phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, the amplification stage circuitry, the combiner circuitry. Examiners find Applicant in the presentation of claims 1-20 and 25-34 provided in the 2023 Preliminary Amendment has completely deleted various features from the 900 Patent claims to arrive at a new and broader invention that does not require the above limitations (i.e., the first -third clock signal, the slow and fast power control information to control the output power of the amplification stage, the phase shifters and polar converters circuitry, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the bank of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, and the amplification stage circuitry). Examiners do not find an unequivocal disclosure for this new and broadened invention as now claimed in claims 1-20 and 25-34. Accordingly, Examiners conclude that claims 1-20 and 25-34 in this reissue application do not have unequivocal support in the 900 Patent as a separate invention and thus are not proper claims in reissue under the original patent requirement following the same reasoning as held in Forum US.
Examiners find that the Applicant has broadened and amended the original patent claims via claims 1-20 and 25-34 herein so much these new claims cover the power amplification apparatus not disclosed or discussed or even conceivable in the 900 Patent, which is improper in reissue. Thus, Examiners conclude claims 1-20 and 25-34 of the 900 Patent fail the original patent requirement and thus are rejected under 35 U.S.C. §251.
It is noted that claims 21-24 include first-third clocks, the phase shifters and polar converters circuitry, the circuitry that adjusts the amplitude of each in-phase polar signal, the set of filters, the circuitry that combines pairs of in phase constituent and quadrature constituent signals, the multiplying circuitry, the amplification stage circuitry, the combiner circuitry. Thus, these claims are not rejected under 35 U.S.C. §251.
INFORMATION DISCLOSURE STATEMENT
The Information Disclosure Statements filed December 28, 2023 has been considered. In accordance with MPEP § 1406, Examiners have reviewed and considered the prior art of record in the original prosecution of the 900 Patent. Applicant(s) are reminded that a listing of the information of record in the original prosecution of the 900 Patent need not be resubmitted in this reissue application unless Applicant(s) desire the information to be printed on a patent issuing from this reissue application.
PRIOR OR CONCURRENT PROCEEDINGS
Applicant is reminded of the obligation to apprise the Office of any prior or concurrent proceedings in which the 900 Patent is or was involved, such as interferences or trials before the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, reissues, reexaminations, or litigations and the results of such proceedings.
INFORMATION MATERIAL TO PATENTABILITY
Applicant(s) are reminded that they “have a continuing duty under 37 CFR §1.56 to timely apprise the Office of any information which is material to the patentability of the claims under consideration in the reissue application. See MPEP §1418.” - MPEP § 1406.
CONCLUSION
Claims 1-34 are rejected.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the Examiner should be directed MY TRANG TON whose telephone number is (571) 272-1754. The Examiner can normally be reached on 7AM -6PM Monday – Thursday.
If attempts to reach the Examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the Examiner’s supervisor, ANDREW J. FISCHER, SPE Art Unit 3992, can be reached at (571) 272-6779. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-9900.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at (866) 217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call (800) 786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or (571) 272-1000.
Signed:
/MY TRANG TON/ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3992
Conferees:
/KENNETH WHITTINGTON/ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3992
/ANDREW J. FISCHER/ Supervisory Patent Examiner, Art Unit 3992
1 Forum US Inc. v. Flow Valve LLC, 926 F.3d 1346 (Fed. Cir. 2019).