Prosecution Insights
Last updated: April 19, 2026
Application No. 18/432,971

Resource Selection for Sidelink Inter-User Equipment Coordination

Non-Final OA §102
Filed
Feb 05, 2024
Examiner
GHAFOERKHAN, FAIYAZKHAN
Art Unit
2476
Tech Center
2400 — Computer Networks
Assignee
Ofinno LLC
OA Round
1 (Non-Final)
87%
Grant Probability
Favorable
1-2
OA Rounds
2y 10m
To Grant
95%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants 87% — above average
87%
Career Allow Rate
486 granted / 560 resolved
+28.8% vs TC avg
Moderate +8% lift
Without
With
+8.2%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
2y 10m
Avg Prosecution
20 currently pending
Career history
580
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
5.2%
-34.8% vs TC avg
§103
41.6%
+1.6% vs TC avg
§102
29.7%
-10.3% vs TC avg
§112
15.0%
-25.0% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 560 resolved cases

Office Action

§102
DETAILED ACTION Claims 1-20 have been examined. Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 102 In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis (i.e., changing from AIA to pre-AIA ) for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status. The following is a quotation of the appropriate paragraphs of 35 U.S.C. 102 that form the basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action: A person shall be entitled to a patent unless – (a)(2) the claimed invention was described in a patent issued under section 151, or in an application for patent published or deemed published under section 122(b), in which the patent or application, as the case may be, names another inventor and was effectively filed before the effective filing date of the claimed invention. Claim(s) 1-3, 5-13, and 15-20 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(2) as being anticipated by US 2022/0225297 A1 to Wang et al. (hereinafter “Wang”). As per claim 1, Wang discloses a method comprising: receiving, by a first wireless device, sidelink control information (SCI) indicating: a resource reservation of first resources (Wang Fig. 2 and [0196] In some aspects, the second wireless device 205-b may determine a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a which may be used by the first wireless device 205-a, the second wireless device 205-b, or both. The second wireless device 205-b may determine the set of resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a based on monitoring the sidelink communication link 215-a. In this regard, the second wireless device 205-b may determine the set of resources as part of the Mode 2 operation of the sidelink communication link 215-a. When determining sets of sidelink resources in Mode 2 operation, the second wireless device 205-b may be said to “reserve” the set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a. Therefore, it is noted herein that the second wireless device 205-b may be configured to determine a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a which may be used via the control message 220 received from the base station 105-a (Mode 1 operation), by monitoring and determining the set of sidelink resources at of the sidelink communication link 215-a, (Mode 2 operation), or both. [0197] In some aspects, the second wireless device 205-b may transmit an indication of a set of sidelink resources 225 to the first wireless device 205-a. In some aspects, the set of sidelink resources 225 may be usable by the first wireless device 205-a to transmit an uplink transmission 240 (e.g., S-UCI) to the second wireless device 205-b. The indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 may be indicated via a sidelink communication link 215-a between the first wireless device 205-a and the second wireless device 205-b. Additionally, the indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 may be indicated via control signaling (e.g., RRC signaling, DCI signaling, SCI signaling). The second wireless device 205-b may transmit the indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 based on receiving the control message 220 from the base station 205-a, monitoring the sidelink communication link 215-a, determining a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a, or any combination thereof.); and an identifier (ID) indicating that a second wireless device is an intended receiver of a sidelink transmission by a third wireless device (Wang [0291] In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be transmitted and/or addressed to multiple wireless devices. For example, the downlink transmission 850 may include a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., GC-PSCCH) which is transmitted by the second wireless device to a set of wireless devices including the first wireless device. For instance, the second wireless device may transmit a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., common S-DCI) to a group of wireless devices to indicate SFIs for the respective wireless devices. In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be addressed to different wireless devices and transmitted (e.g., multiplexed) using multiple OCCs. For example, in some cases, the downlink transmission 850 may be associated with a set of OCCs, where at least one OCC of the set of OCCs is associated with the first wireless device. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof. [0349] At 1040, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In some aspects, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link based on receiving the RRC at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, determining the identifier at 1035, or any combination thereof. [0350] For example, in some cases, the control message (e.g., SCI) may indicate a set of resources for receiving a downlink transmission (e.g., S-DCI) from the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may schedule a downlink transmission from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a. In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the set of resources indicated in the control message. By way of another example, the control message may indicate a format for a set of TTIs of the sidelink communication link. For instance, the control message may indicate a set of TTIs which are configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format). In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the sidelink communication link based on (e.g., in accordance with) the indicated formats. In particular, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor TTIs which are associated with a downlink format. (also see [0356])); and transmitting, to the third wireless device, coordination information indicating second resources for the sidelink transmission (Wang Fig. 9, 10, and [0345] In some aspects, the control message may allocate a set of resources for a set of transmissions between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may serve as a configured grant (e.g., CG-2) and/or semi-persistent scheduling for transmissions between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. For example, the control message may allocate a set of resources usable by the first wireless device 1005-a to transmit CSI reports, sounding reference signals, inter-UE coordination messages, PSSCH transmissions, S-UCI transmissions, or any combination thereof. Similarly, by way of another example, the control message may allocate a set of resources usable by the second wireless device 1005-b to transmit PSSCH transmissions, S-DCI transmissions, or both. [0346] Additionally, or alternatively, the control message may indicate a format (e.g., SFI) associated with one or more TTIs of the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. For example, the control message may indicate that a first TTI (e.g., first slot) is configured for uplink transmissions (e.g., uplink format) from the first wireless device 1005-a to the second wireless device 1005-b, a second TTI (e.g., second slot) is configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format) from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a, and a third TTI (e.g., third slot) is configured for uplink and downlink transmissions (e.g., flexible format) between the wireless devices 1005. By indicating a format for TTIs of the sidelink communication link, techniques described herein may reduce a quantity of blind decoding which is performed by the respective wireless devices 1005.), wherein the second resources are selected for the coordination information based on the second wireless device being the intended receiver of the sidelink transmission (Wang [0291] In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be transmitted and/or addressed to multiple wireless devices. For example, the downlink transmission 850 may include a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., GC-PSCCH) which is transmitted by the second wireless device to a set of wireless devices including the first wireless device. For instance, the second wireless device may transmit a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., common S-DCI) to a group of wireless devices to indicate SFIs for the respective wireless devices. In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be addressed to different wireless devices and transmitted (e.g., multiplexed) using multiple OCCs. For example, in some cases, the downlink transmission 850 may be associated with a set of OCCs, where at least one OCC of the set of OCCs is associated with the first wireless device. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof. [0349] At 1040, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In some aspects, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link based on receiving the RRC at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, determining the identifier at 1035, or any combination thereof. [0350] For example, in some cases, the control message (e.g., SCI) may indicate a set of resources for receiving a downlink transmission (e.g., S-DCI) from the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may schedule a downlink transmission from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a. In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the set of resources indicated in the control message. By way of another example, the control message may indicate a format for a set of TTIs of the sidelink communication link. For instance, the control message may indicate a set of TTIs which are configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format). In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the sidelink communication link based on (e.g., in accordance with) the indicated formats. In particular, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor TTIs which are associated with a downlink format. (also see [0345-0346,0356])). As per claim 2, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, wherein the SCI comprises: a first stage of the SCI comprising one or more fields indicating the resource reservation of the first resources (Wang Fig. 9 and [0305] At 925, the second wireless device 905-b may transmit an indication of a set of sidelink resources to the first wireless device 905-a. In some aspects, the set of sidelink resources may be usable by the first wireless device 905-a to transmit an uplink transmission (e.g., S-UCI) to the second wireless device 905-b. The indication of the set of sidelink resources may be indicated via a sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 905-a and the second wireless device 905-b. Additionally, the indication of the set of sidelink resources may be indicated via control signaling (e.g., RRC signaling, DCI signaling, SCI signaling). The second wireless device 905-b may transmit the indication of the set of sidelink resources based on receiving the control message at 910, monitoring the sidelink communication link at 915, determining a set of sidelink resources at 920, or any combination thereof.); and a second stage of the SCI comprising the ID of the second wireless device (Wang Fig. 9 and [0307] At 930, the first wireless device 905-a may receive an RRC message from the second wireless device 905-b, the third wireless device 905-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. In some aspects, the first wireless device 905-a may receive the RRC message at 930 based on receiving a control message at 910, receiving an indication of a set of sidelink resources at 925, or both. In some aspects, the RRC message may include information for configuring communications between the first wireless device 905-a and the second wireless device 905-b via the sidelink communication link between the respective devices. Data which may be indicated via the RRC message may include, but is not limited to, sets of sidelink resources for transmissions between the first and second wireless devices 905-a, 905-b, relationships between sets of sidelink resources which are used to schedule transmissions between the respective devices and the sets of sidelink resources used for the scheduled transmission, parameters associated with scheduled transmissions between the respective devices, or any combination thereof. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof.). As per claim 3, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, further comprising triggering a resource selection procedure to select the second resources (Wang [0342-0345,0349-0350]). As per claim 5, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, wherein the SCI comprises a reservation interval indicating the resource reservation of the first resources (Wang [0342-0344,0358]). As per claim 6, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, further comprises selecting the second resources from a candidate resource set after excluding the first resources from the candidate resource set (Wang [0357]). As per claim 7, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, wherein the second resources and the first resources are in different time slots (Wang Figs. 3 and 4). As per claim 8, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, further comprising receiving a radio resource control (RRC) message comprising one or more IDs of the second wireless device, wherein the one or more IDs comprise the ID of the second wireless device (Wang [0348-0349,0352,0360]). As per claim 9, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, wherein the first wireless device receives the SCI from the second wireless device (Wang Fig. 9). As per claim 10, Wang discloses the method of claim 1, wherein the first wireless device is a coordinating wireless device for a sidelink inter user equipment (UE) coordination between the second wireless device and the third wireless device (Wang Fig. 9 [0223,0282,0345,0362]). As per claim 11, Wang discloses a first wireless device (Wang Fig. 14) comprising: one or more processors (Wang Fig. 14); and memory storing instructions that, when executed by the one or more processors (Wang Fig. 14), cause the first wireless device to: receive sidelink control information (SCI) indicating: a resource reservation of first resources (Wang Fig. 2 and [0196] In some aspects, the second wireless device 205-b may determine a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a which may be used by the first wireless device 205-a, the second wireless device 205-b, or both. The second wireless device 205-b may determine the set of resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a based on monitoring the sidelink communication link 215-a. In this regard, the second wireless device 205-b may determine the set of resources as part of the Mode 2 operation of the sidelink communication link 215-a. When determining sets of sidelink resources in Mode 2 operation, the second wireless device 205-b may be said to “reserve” the set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a. Therefore, it is noted herein that the second wireless device 205-b may be configured to determine a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a which may be used via the control message 220 received from the base station 105-a (Mode 1 operation), by monitoring and determining the set of sidelink resources at of the sidelink communication link 215-a, (Mode 2 operation), or both. [0197] In some aspects, the second wireless device 205-b may transmit an indication of a set of sidelink resources 225 to the first wireless device 205-a. In some aspects, the set of sidelink resources 225 may be usable by the first wireless device 205-a to transmit an uplink transmission 240 (e.g., S-UCI) to the second wireless device 205-b. The indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 may be indicated via a sidelink communication link 215-a between the first wireless device 205-a and the second wireless device 205-b. Additionally, the indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 may be indicated via control signaling (e.g., RRC signaling, DCI signaling, SCI signaling). The second wireless device 205-b may transmit the indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 based on receiving the control message 220 from the base station 205-a, monitoring the sidelink communication link 215-a, determining a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a, or any combination thereof.); and an identifier (ID) indicating that a second wireless device is an intended receiver of a sidelink transmission by a third wireless device (Wang [0291] In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be transmitted and/or addressed to multiple wireless devices. For example, the downlink transmission 850 may include a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., GC-PSCCH) which is transmitted by the second wireless device to a set of wireless devices including the first wireless device. For instance, the second wireless device may transmit a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., common S-DCI) to a group of wireless devices to indicate SFIs for the respective wireless devices. In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be addressed to different wireless devices and transmitted (e.g., multiplexed) using multiple OCCs. For example, in some cases, the downlink transmission 850 may be associated with a set of OCCs, where at least one OCC of the set of OCCs is associated with the first wireless device. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof. [0349] At 1040, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In some aspects, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link based on receiving the RRC at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, determining the identifier at 1035, or any combination thereof. [0350] For example, in some cases, the control message (e.g., SCI) may indicate a set of resources for receiving a downlink transmission (e.g., S-DCI) from the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may schedule a downlink transmission from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a. In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the set of resources indicated in the control message. By way of another example, the control message may indicate a format for a set of TTIs of the sidelink communication link. For instance, the control message may indicate a set of TTIs which are configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format). In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the sidelink communication link based on (e.g., in accordance with) the indicated formats. In particular, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor TTIs which are associated with a downlink format. (also see [0356])); and transmit, to the third wireless device, coordination information indicating second resources for the sidelink transmission (Wang Fig. 9, 10, and [0345] In some aspects, the control message may allocate a set of resources for a set of transmissions between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may serve as a configured grant (e.g., CG-2) and/or semi-persistent scheduling for transmissions between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. For example, the control message may allocate a set of resources usable by the first wireless device 1005-a to transmit CSI reports, sounding reference signals, inter-UE coordination messages, PSSCH transmissions, S-UCI transmissions, or any combination thereof. Similarly, by way of another example, the control message may allocate a set of resources usable by the second wireless device 1005-b to transmit PSSCH transmissions, S-DCI transmissions, or both. [0346] Additionally, or alternatively, the control message may indicate a format (e.g., SFI) associated with one or more TTIs of the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. For example, the control message may indicate that a first TTI (e.g., first slot) is configured for uplink transmissions (e.g., uplink format) from the first wireless device 1005-a to the second wireless device 1005-b, a second TTI (e.g., second slot) is configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format) from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a, and a third TTI (e.g., third slot) is configured for uplink and downlink transmissions (e.g., flexible format) between the wireless devices 1005. By indicating a format for TTIs of the sidelink communication link, techniques described herein may reduce a quantity of blind decoding which is performed by the respective wireless devices 1005.), wherein the second resources are selected for the coordination information based on the second wireless device being the intended receiver of the sidelink transmission (Wang [0291] In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be transmitted and/or addressed to multiple wireless devices. For example, the downlink transmission 850 may include a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., GC-PSCCH) which is transmitted by the second wireless device to a set of wireless devices including the first wireless device. For instance, the second wireless device may transmit a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., common S-DCI) to a group of wireless devices to indicate SFIs for the respective wireless devices. In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be addressed to different wireless devices and transmitted (e.g., multiplexed) using multiple OCCs. For example, in some cases, the downlink transmission 850 may be associated with a set of OCCs, where at least one OCC of the set of OCCs is associated with the first wireless device. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof. [0349] At 1040, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In some aspects, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link based on receiving the RRC at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, determining the identifier at 1035, or any combination thereof. [0350] For example, in some cases, the control message (e.g., SCI) may indicate a set of resources for receiving a downlink transmission (e.g., S-DCI) from the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may schedule a downlink transmission from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a. In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the set of resources indicated in the control message. By way of another example, the control message may indicate a format for a set of TTIs of the sidelink communication link. For instance, the control message may indicate a set of TTIs which are configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format). In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the sidelink communication link based on (e.g., in accordance with) the indicated formats. In particular, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor TTIs which are associated with a downlink format. (also see [0345-0346,0356])). As per claim 12, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the SCI comprises: a first stage of the SCI comprising one or more fields indicating the resource reservation of the first resources (Wang Fig. 9 and [0305] At 925, the second wireless device 905-b may transmit an indication of a set of sidelink resources to the first wireless device 905-a. In some aspects, the set of sidelink resources may be usable by the first wireless device 905-a to transmit an uplink transmission (e.g., S-UCI) to the second wireless device 905-b. The indication of the set of sidelink resources may be indicated via a sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 905-a and the second wireless device 905-b. Additionally, the indication of the set of sidelink resources may be indicated via control signaling (e.g., RRC signaling, DCI signaling, SCI signaling). The second wireless device 905-b may transmit the indication of the set of sidelink resources based on receiving the control message at 910, monitoring the sidelink communication link at 915, determining a set of sidelink resources at 920, or any combination thereof.); and a second stage of the SCI comprising the ID of the second wireless device (Wang Fig. 9 and [0307] At 930, the first wireless device 905-a may receive an RRC message from the second wireless device 905-b, the third wireless device 905-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. In some aspects, the first wireless device 905-a may receive the RRC message at 930 based on receiving a control message at 910, receiving an indication of a set of sidelink resources at 925, or both. In some aspects, the RRC message may include information for configuring communications between the first wireless device 905-a and the second wireless device 905-b via the sidelink communication link between the respective devices. Data which may be indicated via the RRC message may include, but is not limited to, sets of sidelink resources for transmissions between the first and second wireless devices 905-a, 905-b, relationships between sets of sidelink resources which are used to schedule transmissions between the respective devices and the sets of sidelink resources used for the scheduled transmission, parameters associated with scheduled transmissions between the respective devices, or any combination thereof. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof.). As per claim 13, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the instructions further cause the first wireless device to trigger a resource selection procedure to select the second resources (Wang [0342-0345,0349-0350]). As per claim 15, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the SCI comprises a reservation interval indicating the resource reservation of the first resources (Wang [0342-0344,0358]). As per claim 16, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the instructions further cause the first wireless device to select the second resources from a candidate resource set after excluding the first resources from the candidate resource set (Wang [0357]). As per claim 17, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the second resources and the first resources are in different time slots (Wang Figs. 3 and 4). As per claim 18, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the instructions further cause the first wireless device to receive a radio resource control (RRC) message comprising one or more IDs of the second wireless device, wherein the one or more IDs comprise the ID of the second wireless device (Wang [0348-0349,0352,0360]). As per claim 19, Wang discloses the first wireless device of claim 11, wherein the first wireless device receives the SCI from the second wireless device (Wang Fig. 9). As per claim 20, Wang discloses a non-transitory computer-readable medium comprising instructions that, when executed by one or more processors of a first wireless device (Wang Fig. 14), cause the first wireless device to: receive sidelink control information (SCI) indicating: a resource reservation of first resources (Wang Fig. 2 and [0196] In some aspects, the second wireless device 205-b may determine a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a which may be used by the first wireless device 205-a, the second wireless device 205-b, or both. The second wireless device 205-b may determine the set of resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a based on monitoring the sidelink communication link 215-a. In this regard, the second wireless device 205-b may determine the set of resources as part of the Mode 2 operation of the sidelink communication link 215-a. When determining sets of sidelink resources in Mode 2 operation, the second wireless device 205-b may be said to “reserve” the set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a. Therefore, it is noted herein that the second wireless device 205-b may be configured to determine a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a which may be used via the control message 220 received from the base station 105-a (Mode 1 operation), by monitoring and determining the set of sidelink resources at of the sidelink communication link 215-a, (Mode 2 operation), or both. [0197] In some aspects, the second wireless device 205-b may transmit an indication of a set of sidelink resources 225 to the first wireless device 205-a. In some aspects, the set of sidelink resources 225 may be usable by the first wireless device 205-a to transmit an uplink transmission 240 (e.g., S-UCI) to the second wireless device 205-b. The indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 may be indicated via a sidelink communication link 215-a between the first wireless device 205-a and the second wireless device 205-b. Additionally, the indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 may be indicated via control signaling (e.g., RRC signaling, DCI signaling, SCI signaling). The second wireless device 205-b may transmit the indication of the set of sidelink resources 225 based on receiving the control message 220 from the base station 205-a, monitoring the sidelink communication link 215-a, determining a set of sidelink resources of the sidelink communication link 215-a, or any combination thereof.); and an identifier (ID) indicating that a second wireless device is an intended receiver of a sidelink transmission by a third wireless device (Wang [0291] In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be transmitted and/or addressed to multiple wireless devices. For example, the downlink transmission 850 may include a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., GC-PSCCH) which is transmitted by the second wireless device to a set of wireless devices including the first wireless device. For instance, the second wireless device may transmit a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., common S-DCI) to a group of wireless devices to indicate SFIs for the respective wireless devices. In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be addressed to different wireless devices and transmitted (e.g., multiplexed) using multiple OCCs. For example, in some cases, the downlink transmission 850 may be associated with a set of OCCs, where at least one OCC of the set of OCCs is associated with the first wireless device. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof. [0349] At 1040, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In some aspects, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link based on receiving the RRC at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, determining the identifier at 1035, or any combination thereof. [0350] For example, in some cases, the control message (e.g., SCI) may indicate a set of resources for receiving a downlink transmission (e.g., S-DCI) from the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may schedule a downlink transmission from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a. In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the set of resources indicated in the control message. By way of another example, the control message may indicate a format for a set of TTIs of the sidelink communication link. For instance, the control message may indicate a set of TTIs which are configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format). In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the sidelink communication link based on (e.g., in accordance with) the indicated formats. In particular, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor TTIs which are associated with a downlink format. (also see [0356])); and transmit, to the third wireless device, coordination information indicating second resources for the sidelink transmission (Wang Fig. 9, 10, and [0345] In some aspects, the control message may allocate a set of resources for a set of transmissions between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may serve as a configured grant (e.g., CG-2) and/or semi-persistent scheduling for transmissions between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. For example, the control message may allocate a set of resources usable by the first wireless device 1005-a to transmit CSI reports, sounding reference signals, inter-UE coordination messages, PSSCH transmissions, S-UCI transmissions, or any combination thereof. Similarly, by way of another example, the control message may allocate a set of resources usable by the second wireless device 1005-b to transmit PSSCH transmissions, S-DCI transmissions, or both. [0346] Additionally, or alternatively, the control message may indicate a format (e.g., SFI) associated with one or more TTIs of the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. For example, the control message may indicate that a first TTI (e.g., first slot) is configured for uplink transmissions (e.g., uplink format) from the first wireless device 1005-a to the second wireless device 1005-b, a second TTI (e.g., second slot) is configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format) from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a, and a third TTI (e.g., third slot) is configured for uplink and downlink transmissions (e.g., flexible format) between the wireless devices 1005. By indicating a format for TTIs of the sidelink communication link, techniques described herein may reduce a quantity of blind decoding which is performed by the respective wireless devices 1005.), wherein the second resources are selected for the coordination information based on the second wireless device being the intended receiver of the sidelink transmission (Wang [0291] In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be transmitted and/or addressed to multiple wireless devices. For example, the downlink transmission 850 may include a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., GC-PSCCH) which is transmitted by the second wireless device to a set of wireless devices including the first wireless device. For instance, the second wireless device may transmit a common downlink transmission 850 (e.g., common S-DCI) to a group of wireless devices to indicate SFIs for the respective wireless devices. In some cases, the downlink transmission 850 (e.g., S-DCI) may be addressed to different wireless devices and transmitted (e.g., multiplexed) using multiple OCCs. For example, in some cases, the downlink transmission 850 may be associated with a set of OCCs, where at least one OCC of the set of OCCs is associated with the first wireless device. [0348] In some cases, the RRC message and/or control message received at 1025 and 1030 may indicate the identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a. In this regard, the first wireless device 1005-a may determine an identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a based on receiving the RRC message at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, or both. The identifier associated with the first wireless device 1005-a may include a sidelink reception identifier (e.g., sidelink Rx-ID). Additionally or alternatively, the identifier may be assigned to the first wireless device 1005-a (e.g., UE-assigned identifier) by the second wireless device 1005-b (e.g., PLC), the third wireless device 1005-c (e.g., base station 105), or both. monitoring the sidelink communication link at 1035, receiving the downlink transmission at 1040, or any combination thereof. [0349] At 1040, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link between the first wireless device 1005-a and the second wireless device 1005-b. In some aspects, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor the sidelink communication link based on receiving the RRC at 1025, receiving the control message at 1030, determining the identifier at 1035, or any combination thereof. [0350] For example, in some cases, the control message (e.g., SCI) may indicate a set of resources for receiving a downlink transmission (e.g., S-DCI) from the second wireless device 1005-b. In this regard, the control message may schedule a downlink transmission from the second wireless device 1005-b to the first wireless device 1005-a. In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the set of resources indicated in the control message. By way of another example, the control message may indicate a format for a set of TTIs of the sidelink communication link. For instance, the control message may indicate a set of TTIs which are configured for downlink transmissions (e.g., downlink format). In this example, the first wireless device may monitor the sidelink communication link based on (e.g., in accordance with) the indicated formats. In particular, the first wireless device 1005-a may monitor TTIs which are associated with a downlink format. (also see [0345-0346,0356])). Allowable Subject Matter Claims 4 and 14 are objected to as being dependent upon a rejected base claim, but would be allowable if rewritten in independent form including all of the limitations of the base claim and any intervening claims. Conclusion Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to FAIYAZKHAN GHAFOERKHAN whose telephone number is (571)270-7161. The examiner can normally be reached Flex. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Ayaz R Sheikh can be reached at (571) 272-3795. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. FAIYAZKHAN GHAFOERKHAN Primary Examiner Art Unit 2476 /FAIYAZKHAN GHAFOERKHAN/ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2476
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Feb 05, 2024
Application Filed
Mar 20, 2026
Non-Final Rejection — §102 (current)

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12598578
METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR PERFORMING RANDOM ACCESS
2y 5m to grant Granted Apr 07, 2026
Patent 12598650
PRIORITIZATION OF R-TWT TIDS IN R-TWT SPS
2y 5m to grant Granted Apr 07, 2026
Patent 12593354
METHOD FOR WIRELESS COMMUNICATION, TERMINAL, BASE STATION, COMMUNICATION DEVICE, AND STORAGE MEDIUM
2y 5m to grant Granted Mar 31, 2026
Patent 12592787
MOBILE STATION AND RECEPTION QUALITY MEASUREMENT METHOD
2y 5m to grant Granted Mar 31, 2026
Patent 12568028
LOW LATENCY SOFTWARE DEFINED NETWORKING
2y 5m to grant Granted Mar 03, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 5 most recent grants.

AI Strategy Recommendation

Get an AI-powered prosecution strategy using examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Powered by AI — typically takes 5-10 seconds

Prosecution Projections

1-2
Expected OA Rounds
87%
Grant Probability
95%
With Interview (+8.2%)
2y 10m
Median Time to Grant
Low
PTA Risk
Based on 560 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allow rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month