DETAILED ACTIONS
This action is a non-final First Office Action.
Claims 1-9 are currently presented for examination.
This action is in response to communications filed on 08/14/2023.
This nonprovisional application is filed with foreign priority in regards to parent Application No. JP2022-158830 filed on 09/30/2022.
Claims 1-9 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 as being directed to a non-statutory matter, a judicial exception, an abstract idea (mental process and mathematical concept) without significantly more.
Claims 1-2, 6-9 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) as being anticipated by Johnson et al. “Operations Optimization Assignment Control System With Coupled Subsystem Models and Digital Twins (US-20210350294-A1).
Claim 3 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Johnson in view of Kapteyn et al. “From Physics-Based Models to Predictive Digital Twins via Interpretable Machine Learning”.
Claim 4 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Johnson in view of Wang et al. “BIM Information Integration Based VR Modeling in Digital Twins in Industry 5.0”.
Claim 5 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Johnson in view of Davis et al. “Method and System For Using Response-Surface Methodologies To Determine Optimal Tuning Parameters For Complex Simulators” (US-6381564-B1).
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Priority
Acknowledgment is made of applicant’s claim for foreign priority under 35 U.S.C. 119 (a)-(d). The certified copy has been filed in parent Application No. JP2022-158830, filed on 09/30/2022.
Information Disclosure Statement
The information disclosure statement (IDS) filed on 08/14/2023 has been considered by the Examiner.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 1-9 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to a judicial exception (i.e. abstract idea) without anything significantly more.
Step 1: Claims 1-8 are directed to a system, which is a process, which is a statutory category of invention. Claim 9 is directed to a method, which is a process, which is a statutory category of invention. Therefore, claims 1-9 are directed to patent eligible categories of invention.
Step 2A, Prong 1: Claims 1 and 9 recite the abstract idea of picking the best scenario model for a digital twin simulator, constituting an abstract idea based on Mathematical Concepts based on mathematical relationships, mathematical formulas/equations, and mathematical calculations, and based on Mental Processes based on concepts performed in the human mind, both with the aid of pencil and paper.
In regard to claim 1, the limitation of an interface apparatus that receives physical asset data that is data related to a physical asset;. This limitation does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of a storage apparatus that stores the physical asset data; and does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of a processor connected to the interface apparatus and the storage apparatus, wherein does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of the processor determines a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor, covers mathematical concepts including mathematical calculations used to calculate the value and threshold of each model factor.
Additionally, the limitation of the processor receives from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics, covers mathematical concepts including mathematical calculations used to calculate the range of a value of each model outcome using heuristics.
Additionally, the limitation of the processor prepares, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class, and does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of the processor selects an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes. does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
In regard to claim 9, the limitation of determining, by a processor, a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor; covers mathematical concepts including mathematical calculations used to calculate the value and threshold of each model factor.
Additionally, the limitation of receiving, by the processor, from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics; covers mathematical concepts including mathematical calculations used to calculate the range of a value of each model outcome using heuristics.
Additionally, the limitation of preparing, by the processor, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class; and does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, the limitation of selecting, by the processor, an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Thus, the claims recite the abstract idea of picking the best scenario model for a digital twin simulator.
Dependent claims 2-8 further narrow the abstract ideas, identified in the independent claims.
Step 2A, Prong 2: The judicial exception is not integrated into a practical application. In claim 1, the limitations of an interface apparatus that receives physical asset data that is data related to a physical asset; a storage apparatus that stores the physical asset data; and a processor connected to the interface apparatus and the storage apparatus, wherein amounts to mere instructions, where it invokes computers or other machinery merely as a tool to perform an existing process. The interface apparatus, storage apparatus, and processor are all generic computer components and thus fall under this category. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(2).
Also, the limitation of the processor determines a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites the idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how the processor chooses model classes or how a model class is related to a scenario model. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and amounts to insignificant extra-solution activity of receiving data, i.e. pre-solution activity for gathering data for use in the claimed process. See MPEP 2106.05(g).
Additionally, the limitation of a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor, amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how it is comparing the value and threshold for each model factor. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of the processor receives from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics, amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how heuristics are applied to each model outcome. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of the processor prepares, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class, and amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Additionally, the limitation of the processor selects an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
In claim 9, the limitation of determining, by a processor, a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites the idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how the processor chooses model classes or how a model class is related to a scenario model. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and amounts to insignificant extra-solution activity of receiving data, i.e. pre-solution activity for gathering data for use in the claimed process. See MPEP 2106.05(g).
Additionally, the limitation of a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor; amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how it is comparing the value and threshold for each model factor. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of receiving, by the processor, from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics; amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how heuristics are applied to each model outcome. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of preparing, by the processor, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class; and amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Additionally, the limitation of selecting, by the processor, an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Dependent claims 2-8 further narrow the abstract ideas, identified in the independent claims, and do not introduce further additional elements for consideration beyond those addressed above.
Step 2B: In claim 1, the limitations of an interface apparatus that receives physical asset data that is data related to a physical asset; a storage apparatus that stores the physical asset data; and a processor connected to the interface apparatus and the storage apparatus, wherein amounts to mere instructions, where it invokes computers or other machinery merely as a tool to perform an existing process. The interface apparatus, storage apparatus, and processor are all generic computer components and thus fall under this category. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(2).
Also, the limitation of the processor determines a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites the idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how the processor chooses model classes or how a model class is related to a scenario model. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and is shown to reflect the court decisions of Versata Dev. Group, Inc. v SAP Am., Inc. iv. Storing and retrieving information in memory, shown in MPEP 2106.05(d)(II).
Additionally, the limitation of a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor, amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how it is comparing the value and threshold for each model factor. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of the processor receives from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics, amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how heuristics are applied to each model outcome. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of the processor prepares, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class, and amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Additionally, the limitation of the processor selects an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
In claim 9, the limitation of determining, by a processor, a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites the idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how the processor chooses model classes or how a model class is related to a scenario model. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and is shown to reflect the court decisions of Versata Dev. Group, Inc. v SAP Am., Inc. iv. Storing and retrieving information in memory, shown in MPEP 2106.05(d)(II).
Additionally, the limitation of a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor; amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how it is comparing the value and threshold for each model factor. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of receiving, by the processor, from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics; amounts to mere instructions to apply an exception, where it recites an idea of a solution. The limitation does not indicate how heuristics are applied to each model outcome. See MPEP 2106.05(f)(1).
Additionally, the limitation of preparing, by the processor, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class; and amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Additionally, the limitation of selecting, by the processor, an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes amounts to generally linking the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Dependent claim 2 recites wherein the one or more model factors include at least one of a processor load, a status of asset, scarcity of data point, and a type of input data, and the one or more model outcomes include at least one of accuracy, an execution speed, a building requirement time, and a signal-to-noise ratio. This limitation amounts to insignificant extra-solution activity of receiving and outputting data i.e. pre-solution activity of gathering data and post-solution activity of selecting particular data sources for use in the claimed process. See MPEP 2106.05(g).
Dependent claim 3 recites wherein the processor generates a decision tree in which each of the plurality of model classes is a leaf node, a root node or an intermediate node is a comparison between a value obtained for the model factor corresponding to the node and a threshold corresponding to the model factor, and a next node is determined depending on a result of the comparison. This limitation does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, dependent claim 3 recites the processor monitors a value for each of the plurality of model factors, and the optimal scenario model is a scenario model determined by following the decision tree, based on the monitored value and the threshold for each model factor. This limitation does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Dependent claim 4 recites wherein the optimal scenario model is a scenario model having a largest query hit rate. This limitation does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Dependent claim 5 recites wherein each scenario model is a response surface methodology (RSM) model. This limitation is nothing more than generally linking the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Dependent claim 6 recites wherein each scenario model is a model generated based on a scenario set including a plurality of scenarios that are each a combination of an objective variable value and one or more values of explanatory variables. This limitation amounts to insignificant extra-solution activity of receiving data, i.e. pre-solution activity for gathering data for use in the claimed process. See MPEP 2106.05(g).
Additionally, claim 6 recites the processor generates digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data and is input to the digital twin simulator, by inputting the physical asset data to an asset model for each viewpoint, and. This limitation amounts to insignificant extra-solution activity of receiving data, i.e. pre-solution activity for gathering data for use in the claimed process. See MPEP 2106.05(g).
Additionally, claim 6 recites the processor builds the scenario model by specifying a value range for each variable, based on the digital asset data. This limitation does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Dependent claim 7 recites wherein the objective variable value is an output value as a calculation result of the digital twin simulation, and. This limitation is calculating the objective variable value as a calculation result of the digital twin simulation. Therefore, under MPEP 2106.04(a)(2), this limitation covers a mathematical concept, which falls in the “Mathematical Concept” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, claim 7 recites the one or more explanatory variables are one or more features specified from data that is input to the digital twin simulation. This limitation amounts to insignificant extra-solution activity of receiving data, i.e. pre-solution activity for gathering data for use in the claimed process. See MPEP 2106.05(g).
Dependent claim 8 recites wherein the plurality of model classes are a plurality of model clusters based on one or more designated criteria, and. This limitation does not distinguish itself from being able to be conducted in the human mind or with pencil and paper. Therefore, under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the limitation is a process step that covers performance in the human mind or with the aid of pencil and paper. Therefore, this limitation falls within the “Mental Process” grouping of abstract ideas.
Additionally, claim 8 recites each of the plurality of model clusters may be a set of one or more scenario models. This limitation is nothing more than generally linking the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP 2106.05(h).
Claims 1-9 are therefore not drawn to eligible subject matter as they are directed to an abstract idea without significantly more.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 102
In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis (i.e., changing from AIA to pre-AIA ) for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status.
The following is a quotation of the appropriate paragraphs of 35 U.S.C. 102 that form the basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action:
A person shall be entitled to a patent unless –(a)(1) the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention.
Claims 1-2, 6-9 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) as being anticipated by Johnson et al. “Operations Optimization Assignment Control System With Coupled Subsystem Models and Digital Twins (US-20210350294-A1).
Regarding claim 1, Johnson anticipates an interface apparatus that receives physical asset data that is data related to a physical asset; (Paragraph [0030], “The user computing device 102 may include a display 102a, a processing unit 102b and an input device 102c, each of which may be communicatively coupled together and/or to the network 100. The user computing device 102 may be used to interface with a user who may manipulate and/or configure a DT model, a business model, an optimization process or the like.”)
a storage apparatus that stores the physical asset data; and (Paragraph [0033], “As also illustrated in FIG. 1B, the computing device 103 may include a processor 130, input/output hard-ware 132, network interface hardware 134, a data storage component 136, and a memory component 140.”)
a processor connected to the interface apparatus and the storage apparatus, (Figure 1B and Paragraph [0033], “As also illustrated in FIG. 1B, the computing device 103 may include a processor 130, input/output hardware 132, network interface hardware 134, a data storage component 136, and a memory component 140.”, Figure 1B shows the processor in conjunction with input/output hardware.)
wherein the processor determines a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: (Paragraph [0042], “An asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) may be implemented to generate optimization parameters for the asset, thereby optimizing the asset for an intended or desired function or operation. For example, a user may desire an asset that is capable of having low offline maintenance time and high long flight fuel efficiency for carrying cargo. The asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) may be configured with these requirements and optimize an asset, generating optimization parameters that define the components and/or subsystems of the asset as well as operating conditions such as anticipated maintenance. The one or more DTs defining the asset may further be configured to receive real-time information, such as sensor data from operations of the asset, that enables the asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) to provide optimization parameters for a predefined time period (e.g., one that is defined by a user) or for a projection of time into the future to determine future economics and/or operations of the asset such as when maintenance may be required.”
Examiner’s Note: The examiner interprets the phrase “model class” as a specific set of parameters derived from the simulated object, and scenario model as based on the overall number of parameters gathered from the simulated object. This interpretation comes from the Specification and from the examiner’s research into digital twins.)
one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and (Paragraph [0026], “In the current time context, DTs, like simulations, can help provide an understanding of what may happen in the real world as time unfolds. However, DTs also provide an understanding of what is physically happening, that is how the asset or business unit is behaving in the real-world and causal understanding, for example, by reconciling physical dynamics which may not be directly measurable but inferred or computed as being the only possible internal dynamic given that the physical system is mimic modeled and compared to real time signals. This is accomplished through a continuous influx of information that is provided to a DT and reconciliation between its computed physical state and the empirically observed physical state to estimate what the missing internal value(s) must be.”)
a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor, (Paragraph [0026], “The present embodiments utilize this feature and go several steps farther by integrating multiple DTs, and optionally other types of models, together in a system hierarchy where optimization processes are implemented at various levels in the hierarchy to achieve real-time or almost real-time optimization parameters (as an output of an optimization of a level) and/or operation protocols and/or insights to physical constraints which manifest themselves as operational limits. Operation protocols include the events, activities, and/or threshold ranges that should be implemented or maintained to achieve a desired objective, for example of reaching and/or maintaining the operation of a system in an optimized state.”)
the processor receives from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics, (Paragraph [0075], “A given DT approach may include many model types. In example embodiments, first principle, statistical, machine learning, historical observation, rules and/or heuristics define DT model types 725, 730, 735, 740. Should an operational scenario include a future forecast component such as would be the case if a current operations action were desired to be taken in current time, t0, 710 that would effect a future time period,
t
+
n
, 720, thus four candidate models, as depicted in FIG. 7, could be selected. DT models 725, 730 and 735 overlap in their time horizons. Each DT model may have a certain strength over their cohort of other models such as compute time or precision or ability to explain system dynamics with respect to a varying input assumption.”)
the processor prepares, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class, and (Paragraph [0076], “DTs are invoked to achieve the computational goals and limits and may ultimately form a compilation of model activation to complete the trajectory through time, for example from current time, t0, 710 to future time, t+m 720. For example, but without limitation, DTl 725 in FIG. 7 is the only viable DT model for any reason (compute speed, accuracy, forecast interval, and etc.) available from a start time to time 745, at which interval only DT3 735 is viable up to time 760 where two DTs 730 and 735 have candidacy. DTK is selected according to the one or more objectives or constraints.”)
the processor selects an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes. (Paragraph [0076], “DTl 725 may be optimally used from a starting time 710 to 745 where, for example DT3 735 is called for interval spanning 745 to 760, upon which time DT2 is utilized from 760 to 765 and DT4 may be utilized from 765 to 770.”)
Regarding claim 2, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson also anticipates wherein the one or more model factors include at least one of a processor load, a status of asset, scarcity of data point, and a type of input data, and (Paragraph [0050], “Data in the computer data store 410 might include, for example, information about the twinned physical asset or system 420, such as historic engine sensor information about a number of different aircraft engines and prior aircraft flights (e.g., external temperatures, exhaust gas temperatures, engine model numbers, takeoff and landing airports, etc.”
Examiner’s Note: The examiner is interpreting the historic engine sensor information to be an example of a type of input data, as well as data present within the computer data store be a broader example of a type of input data.)
Johnson also anticipates the one or more model outcomes include at least one of accuracy, an execution speed, a building requirement time, and a signal-to-noise ratio. (Paragraph [0072], “In instances where a certain assurance of computational variance, for example expressed through Equation 1 below is required in a certain time interval 790, the system may call certain ones of the DTs 725, 730, 735, 740 based upon their computation speed on an absolute basis or according to a ratio of a DT's contribution to variance 775 per unit time as computed by Equation 2.”
Examiner’s Note: The examiner is interpreting the computation speed of each example digital twin to be an example of execution speed, as digital twin performance is directly linked to computation speed and execution speed.)
Regarding claim 4, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson also anticipates wherein the optimal scenario model is a scenario model having a largest query hit rate (Paragraph [0078], “A predetermined duration of compute time may be defined for a combination of DTs and then the combination of DTs yielding the rate of learning or variation level that meets the compute time constraint or the learning threshold.”
Examiner’s Note: While not explicitly stated, query hit rate in regards to digital twin models refers to how well the model is able to compute the necessary parameters and other computations in relation to what is being simulated. With this in mind, a POSITA would be able to understand that a digital twin model having the largest query hit rate would be the same as being able to meet the compute time restraint or learning threshold in the shortest possible time.)
Regarding claim 6, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson also anticipates wherein each scenario model is a model generated based on a scenario set including a plurality of scenarios that are each a combination of an objective variable value and one or more values of explanatory variables, (Paragraph [0026], “In the current time context, DTs, like simulations, can help provide an understanding of what may happen in the real world as time unfolds. However, DTs also provide an understanding of what is physically happening, that is how the asset or business unit is behaving in the real-world and causal understanding, for example, by reconciling physical dynamics which may not be directly measurable but inferred or computed as being the only possible internal dynamic given that the physical system is mimic modeled and compared to real time signals. This is accomplished through a continuous influx of information that is provided to a DT and reconciliation between its computed physical state and the empirically observed physical state to estimate what the missing internal value(s) must be. The present embodiments utilize this feature and go several steps farther by integrating multiple DTs, and optionally other types of models, together in a system hierarchy where optimization processes are implemented at various levels in the hierarchy to achieve real-time or almost real-time optimization parameters (as an output of an optimization of a level) and/or operation protocols and/or insights to physical constraints which manifest themselves as operational limits. Operation protocols include the events, activities, and/or threshold ranges that should be implemented or maintained to achieve a desired objective, for example of reaching and/or maintaining the operation of a system in an optimized state. Hidden constraints may include the internal physical dynamics of a complicated engineered asset, such as a turbine, whose internal pressure or temperature or flow signals may not be directly measurable by a physical sensor, and are or should be limited in their operation. For example, a firing temperature should be limited so that it does not exceed the material properties of an engine, which may have reduced thermal properties as a result of wear through prior operations.”)
Johnson also anticipates the processor generates digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data and is input to the digital twin simulator, by inputting the physical asset data to an asset model for each viewpoint, and (Paragraph [0043], “Each of the DTs may be interconnected with each other by way of the asset optimizer 320. The asset optimizer 320 implements the asset optimizer module 144a so that the asset may be optimized and optimization parameters may be generated. The asset optimizer 320 effectively creates a network of DTs for the aircraft so that adjustments to one DT may be implemented within the other connected DTs as they would in a real-world aircraft. FIG. 3A”)
Johnson also anticipates the processor builds the scenario model by specifying a value range for each variable, based on the digital asset data. (Paragraph [0045], “The operation protocols 250 include the events, activities, and/or threshold ranges that should be implemented or maintained to achieve a desired objective, for example of reaching and/or maintaining the operation of a system in an optimized state. The optimization status 260 may include tracking of critical elements that provide an indication as to how optimized the system is or whether certain optimization parameters are near their desired limits. For example, if a financial business unit includes a range defining the desired revenue or expenses and the optimization manages to obtain a result within the range, but near one of the extremes, the status may indicate the same. In some embodiments, the aforementioned range may be identified by a user as a critical element for tracking purposes and thus be displayed on a display device (for example, display device 102a, FIG. lA) for tracking purposes.”)
Regarding claim 7, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 6. Johnson also anticipates wherein the objective variable value is an output value as a calculation result of the digital twin simulation, and (Paragraph [0064], “The DT 550 may also include output economic data and modeling results 580. The eco-nomic data and/or modeling results 580 may be optimization parameters 138c (FIG. 1B) that are used as inputs to subsequent DTs and models of the optimization system. In particular, for example, the economic data and modeling results maybe include considerations such as inspection scheduling, related logistics, assessment and mitigation of financial risk, or the like for a particular asset such as an aircraft engine.”)
Johnson also anticipates the one or more explanatory variables are one or more features specified from data that is input to the digital twin simulation. (Paragraph [0042], “The one or more DTs defining the asset may further be configured to receive real-time information, such as sensor data from operations of the asset, that enables the asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) to provide optimization parameters for a predefined time period (e.g., one that is defined by a user) or for a projection of time into the future to determine future economics and/or operations of the asset such as when maintenance may be required.”)
Regarding claim 8, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson also anticipates wherein the plurality of model classes are a plurality of model clusters based on one or more designated criteria, and (Paragraph [0069], “In some embodiments, the utilization of a plurality of physical asset DTs through a time horizon as orchestrated to interact and compute key process indicators which account for desired system of systems behavior may include the utilization of a simulation. The simulation may be in continuous time or discrete time simulation. The entities being simulated may be directed to act by a central analytical reasoner or may have autonomous behavioral responses computed by each physical asset with system dynamics emerging with agent behavior. The time horizon may be historical (e.g., based on past sensor readings, events, and/or outcomes), current, or future. Entities in the system simulation may be physical, informational, or economic in nature. Simulation scenarios may be deterministic or probabilistic and traverse in a directed or undirected graph pattern through time.”)
Johnson also anticipates each of the plurality of model clusters may be a set of one or more scenario models. (Paragraph [0069], “Where the simulation is configured to explore
probabilistic paths, replications are made through definable time horizons which may be controlled by the disclosed system, comprised of a plurality of DTs which may be
optimally called to describe elements of the system.”)
Regarding claim 9, Johnson anticipates determining, by a processor, a plurality of model classes that are each a model class of a scenario model, based on: (Paragraph [0042], “An asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) may be implemented to generate optimization parameters for the asset, thereby optimizing the asset for an intended or desired function or operation. For example, a user may desire an asset that is capable of having low oflline maintenance time and high long flight fuel efficiency for carrying cargo. The asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) may be configured with these requirements and optimize an asset, generating optimization parameters that define the components and/or subsystems of the asset as well as operating conditions such as anticipated maintenance. The one or more DTs defining the asset may further be configured to receive real-time information, such as sensor data from operations of the asset, that enables the asset optimizer module 144a (FIG. 1B) to provide optimization parameters for a predefined time period (e.g., one that is defined by a user) or for a projection of time into the future to determine future economics and/or operations of the asset such as when maintenance may be required.”)
one or more model factors that are one or more different factors with respect to the scenario model for a digital twin simulator, the one or more model factors being specified from the physical asset data or digital asset data corresponding to the physical asset data, and (Paragraph [0050], “The system 400 includes a computer data store 410 (e.g., a data store of the user computing device 102, the computing device 103, and/or the administrator computing device 104 as depicted in FIG. lA) that provides information to a DT 450 of a twinned physical asset or system 420. Data in the computer data store 410 might include, for example, information about the twinned physical asset or system 420, such as historic engine sensor information about a number of different aircraft engines and prior aircraft flights (e.g., external temperatures, exhaust gas temperatures, engine model numbers, takeoff and landing airports, etc.).”)
a result of comparison, for each model factor of the one or more model factors, between a value for the each model factor and a threshold of the each model factor; (Paragraph [0026], “The present embodiments utilize this feature and go several steps farther by integrating multiple DTs, and optionally other types of models, together in a system hierarchy where optimization processes are implemented at various levels in the hierarchy to achieve real-time or almost real-time optimization parameters (as an output of an optimization of a level) and/or operation protocols and/or insights to physical constraints which manifest themselves as operational limits. Operation protocols include the events, activities, and/or threshold ranges that should be implemented or maintained to achieve a desired objective, for example of reaching and/or maintaining the operation of a system in an optimized state.”)
receiving, by the processor, from a user, for each of the plurality of model classes and for each model outcome of one or more model outcomes that are one or more different outcomes with respect to the scenario model, an outcome value range that is a range of a value of the each model outcome and is a range of a value based on heuristics; (Paragraph [0075], “A given DT approach may include many model types. In example embodiments, first principle, statistical, machine learning, historical observation, rules and/or heuristics define DT model types 725, 730, 735, 740. Should an operational scenario include a future forecast component such as would be the case if a current operations action were desired to be taken in current time, t0, 710 that would effect a future time period,
t
+
n
, 720, thus four candidate models, as depicted in FIG. 7, could be selected. DT models 725, 730 and 735 overlap in their time horizons. Each DT model may have a certain strength over their cohort of other models such as compute time or precision or ability to explain system dynamics with respect to a varying input assumption.”)
preparing, by the processor, for each model class of the plurality of model classes, a scenario model having an outcome value belonging to the outcome value range received for the each model class; and (Paragraph [0076], “DTs are invoked to achieve the computational goals and limits and may ultimately form a compilation of model activation to complete the trajectory through time, for example from current time, t0, 710 to future time, t+m 720. For example, but without limitation, DTl 725 in FIG. 7 is the only viable DT model for any reason (compute speed, accuracy, forecast interval, and etc.) available from a start time to time 745, at which interval only DT3 735 is viable up to time 760 where two DTs 730 and 735 have candidacy. DTK is selected according to the one or more objectives or constraints.”)
selecting, by the processor, an optimal scenario model from among the scenario models prepared for respective ones of the model classes. (Paragraph [0076], “DTl 725 may be optimally used from a starting time 710 to 745 where, for example DT3 735 is called for interval spanning 745 to 760, upon which time DT2 is utilized from 760 to 765 and DT4 may be utilized from 765 to 770.”)
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis (i.e., changing from AIA to pre-AIA ) for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made.
Claim 3 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Johnson in view of Kapteyn et al. “From Physics-Based Models to Predictive Digital Twins via Interpretable Machine Learning”.
Regarding claim 3, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson does not explicitly recite wherein the processor generates a decision tree in which each of the plurality of model classes is a leaf node, a root node or an intermediate node is a comparison between a value obtained for the model factor corresponding to the node and a threshold corresponding to the model factor, and a next node is determined depending on a result of the comparison, the processor monitors a value for each of the plurality of model factors, and the optimal scenario model is a scenario model determined by following the decision tree, based on the monitored value and the threshold for each model factor.
Kapteyn does teach wherein the processor generates a decision tree in which each of the plurality of model classes is a leaf node, (Section 3B, “predict outcomes for new, previously unseen feature vectors. When a test observation, x˜t , is obtained at some timestep t, evaluation begins at the root node of the tree. At each branching node in the tree, a decision is made depending on the observed feature values, until the test observation reaches a leaf node, at which point a predicted output is assigned.”)
a root node or an intermediate node is a comparison between a value obtained for the model factor corresponding to the node and a threshold corresponding to the model factor, and a next node is determined depending on a result of the comparison, (Figure 1 and Section 3B, “We also show the decision trees corresponding to each partitioning. Once a classification tree has been generated it can be used to predict outcomes for new, previously unseen feature vectors. When a test observation, x˜t , is obtained at some timestep t, evaluation begins at the root node of the tree.”)
the processor monitors a value for each of the plurality of model factors, and (Section 3B, “Recall that in our context, each of these features would be a piece of observational data, for example a sensor measurement or the result of an inspection. We then show examples of using either axis-aligned or hyperplane splits to partition the feature space.”
Examiner’s Note: While not directly referring a processor, the use of decision trees implies the use of computers and computer related components, to which a POSITA would reasonably assume a processor is a key component.)
the optimal scenario model is a scenario model determined by following the decision tree, based on the monitored value and the threshold for each model factor. (Figure 1, Section 4B, “In practice we could compare different optimal solutions in this way as a post-processing step, or we could modify the optimization problem to reward the appearance of critical labels higher up in the tree. This example serves to highlight how the optimal decision trees can be used to reveal accurate sparse sensing strategies, and can prioritize critical and/or cost effective classifications.”)
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date, to combine the teachings of Johnson with Kapteyn as the references deal with utilizing machine learning techniques to develop digital twin simulation-based models. Kapteyn would modify Johnson by further defining the use of decision trees and their role in deciding the most optimal configurations for the digital twin models. The benefit of doing so would allow the syste to more easily find the most optimal configuration to allow for the smoothest operation of the digital twin model, saving time and resources better spent elsewhere. (Kapteyn Section II)
Claim 4 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Johnson in view of Wang et al. “BIM Information Integration Based VR Modeling in Digital Twins in Industry 5.0”.
Regarding claim 4, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson does not explicitly recite wherein the optimal scenario model is a scenario model having a largest query hit rate.
Wang teaches wherein the optimal scenario model is a scenario model having a largest query hit rate. (Figure 10, “Fig. 10 illustrates the system delay results of different models in various scenarios. The real-time capability of the model is positively correlated with the number of queries processed per second. The more data processing queries, the higher the latency performance of the model. In the Identity scenario, the latency of both frameworks is within 100 milliseconds. Such results suggest that the model proposed and the model in the latest literature have lower data latency performance. The delay of Storm is about 5 times that of Flink in the Sleep scenario, which further shows that the proposed model shows obvious advantages in system delay.”
Examiner’s Note: While Wang does not outright say that the model with the lowest delay is the most optimal model, a POSITA would be able to make the connection that the model framework with the lowest delay would be the most optimal digital twin model.)
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date, to combine the teachings of Johnson with Wang as the references deal with modeling digital twin simulations in order to find the most optimal model for the situation. Wang would modify Johnson by utilizing delay time as a factor in deciding the most optimal model. The benefit of doing so would allow digital twin models with the least possible latency out of the entire group to be a considering factor in determining the most optimal model configuration, speeding up the simulation process and saving computing time. (Wang Section 1).
Claim 5 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Johnson in view of Davis et al. “Method and System For Using Response-Surface Methodologies To Determine Optimal Tuning Parameters For Complex Simulators” (US-6381564-B1).
Regarding claim 5, Johnson anticipates the limitations of claim 1. Johnson does not explicitly recite wherein each scenario model is a response surface methodology (RSM) model.
Davis teaches wherein each scenario model is a response surface methodology (RSM) model. (Section 3 Paragraph 2, “The initial phase is to build an RSM model, this including designing an experiment wherein there are provided the points at which to tune and the ranges for the parameter settings. A simulation experiment is then run and relevant information is extracted from the simulated experiment.”)
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date, to combine the teachings of Johnson with Davis as the references deal with simulations of real-world data and objects in order to simulate certain effects or events on said data. Davis would modify Johnson by explicitly defining response surface methodology (RSM) models as usable within the digital twin simulation process. The benefit of doing so further defines the use cases of the optimal digital twin simulation process, allowing for a more streamlined simulation process, optimizing the simulation process and potentially making it more efficient. (Davis Section 1).
Conclusion
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant’s disclosure.
Goldfarb et al. “Feature Selection and Feature Synthesis Methods for Predictive Modeling in a Twinned Physical System” (US-20180137219-A1): Also teaches the optimization of the factors in a digital twin model.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to ALEXANDER JOSEPH MEKOVSKY whose telephone number is (571)272-0428. The examiner can normally be reached 7:30am-5pm M-F.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Ryan Pitaro can be reached at (571) 272-4071. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/ALEXANDER JOSEPH MEKOVSKY/Examiner, Art Unit 2188
/RYAN F PITARO/Supervisory Patent Examiner, Art Unit 2188