Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Response to Amendment / Status of the Claims
Applicant is thanked for their 8/28/26 response to the Office Action dated 4/29/26. The amendment has been entered and, accordingly:
Claim 1 is amended.
Claims 2-7 are cancelled.
Claims 8-17 are withdrawn.
Claims 1 and 8-17 are pending.
NOTE: If the claims being examined are ever in condition for allowance, it’s noted that the withdrawn claims must be cancelled or eligible for rejoinder before the application is in a state for allowance. See MPEP 821. Examiner notes that at least some of the withdrawn claims, such as claim 8, are directed to species that were not elected in the Response to Restriction filed 4/6/26 and therefore must be cancelled before the case can be allowed.
Response to Remarks
Applicant’s arguments filed 4/29/26, with respect to the rejection of claim 1 of Massey in view of Surawski and Richardson, have been fully considered and are persuasive. The 103 rejection of claim 1 has been withdrawn.
Claim Objections
Claim 1 is objected to because of the following informalities:
Regarding Claim 1, line 25, “the the ASM” should read “the . Appropriate correction is required
Claim Interpretation
Independent claim 1 recites “A system for supplying source air to an air separation membrane (ASM) of an inerting system of an aircraft” (lines 1-2), which suggests the claimed system and ASM are independent systems. However, claim 1 also recites, “a third flow-path, fluidly coupled between the second compressor, a fuel tank and the ASM” (lines 14-15), which suggests the ASM is a feature of the claimed system. In light of Figure 1 and Par. 0029 of the as-filed disclosure, it’s the Examiner’s understanding that the ASM is a feature of the claimed system.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
Claim 1 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention.
Regarding claim 1, the motor-generator is claimed to operate in a motor mode “when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold” and operate in a generator mode “when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold”. However, neither the figures nor the as-filed specification explicitly disclose a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure. Par. 0031 of the as-filed specification discloses the motor-generator operates in a motor mode “When the aircraft 70 is not in flight or is at low altitude and the cabin 180 is not pressurized” and a generator mode “when pressure in the first flow-path, due to pressure in the cabin 180, is above a threshold. For example, during flight conditions, when the cabin is pressurized to around 11 PSIA, pressure in the first flow-path 170 will also increase to thereby drive the turbine 140”. Although the claimed limitations and as-filed specification are related, the claimed limitations are directed to a differential threshold based on the difference between a cabin and an atmospheric pressure while the as-filed specification is directed to a threshold based on a cabin pressure that has different values at different altitudes.
In light of the above discrepancy between the claim language and what the specification discloses, it is the examiner's decision that the written description lacks sufficient support for the motor-generator operating in a motor mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold and operating in a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold. In other words, at the time of filing, it appears that the applicant' s invention only conceived of the motor-generator operating in a motor mode or a generator mode based on the pressure of the cabin at different altitudes, and therefore the applicant did not have possession of the claimed invention as recited in claim 1.
NOTE: Examiner suggests claim 1 be amended to better align with what is disclosed in the as-filed specification, such as “wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure in the cabin in the cabin
Allowable Subject Matter
Claim 1 is objected to because of a corresponding claim objection and 112a rejection, but would be allowable if the claim objection is amended as suggested and the 112a rejection is overcome. Note amendments made to overcome the 112a rejection may change the scope of the claim and require further search and/or consideration.
Prior art references Massey (US 20160236792 A1, as cited in the Applicant’s 5/16/25 IDS), Surawski et al. (US 20100064886 A1, hereafter Surawski, as cited in the Applicant’s 5/16/25 IDS), Richardson et al. (CA 3058732 A1, hereafter Richardson), Liu et al. (CN 111071465 A, hereafter Liu), and Cerney (CN 106864754 A) represent the closest prior art of record to the Applicant’s claimed invention as recited in claim 1.
Reference is made to the Chinese to English machine translation of Cerney ‘754.
Regarding claim 1, Massey discloses a system for supplying source air to an air separation membrane (ASM) (Fig. 3, air separator module 24) of an inerting system of an aircraft, the system comprising:
a first compressor (Fig. 3, positive displacement compressor 20);
a turbine (Fig. 3, energy recovery turbine 12), operationally coupled to the first compressor (Fig. 3);
a motor-generator (Fig. , motor 30, turbine generator 26), operationally coupled to the first compressor and the turbine (Fig. 3);
wherein the first compressor, the turbine, the second compressor and the motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts;
a first flow-path extending from a cabin of the aircraft (Fig. 3, cabin air supply) and configured to receive cabin air from a cabin of the aircraft (Fig. 3, cabin air supply), the first flow-path having: a first branch, fluidly coupled to the first compressor (Fig. 3, left branch from cabin air supply); and a second branch, fluidly coupled to the turbine (Fig. 3, right branch from cabin air supply), wherein the motor-generator operates in a generator mode (¶ 0032-0033), wherein the first and second branches diverge from each other at a junction (Fig. 3, where cabin air supply meets cruise);
a third flow-path, fluidly coupled between a fuel tank (Fig. 3, fuel tank) and the ASM (Fig. 3, air separator module 24); and
a first heat exchanger (Fig. 3, heat exchanger 22), operationally coupled to the second branch of the first flow-path to heat flow through the second branch before it is provided to the turbine (Fig. 3 and ¶ 0033, “however, the portion of cabin air to be supplied to the turbine is initially passed through the heat exchanger 22”),
wherein turbine outflow is exhausted overboard via an exhaust flow-path (Fig. 3, over board),
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor (Par. 0017, “In a motor-driven configuration, an electric motor may be drivably connected to said positive displacement compressor, which conveniently receives electrical energy from said generator or an energy storage arrangement associated therewith”); and a generator mode such that cabin pressure drives the turbine (Par. 0033, “As previously, cabin air is used to drive an energy recovery turbine 12 which drives the generator 26 which supplies electrical power to the controller 28.”).
However, Massey does not disclose a unitary motor-generator,
wherein the first compressor, the turbine, the second compressor and the motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts;
a second compressor, operationally coupled to the turbine and configured to be fluidly coupled to the air separation membrane;
the motor-generator operates in a generator mode when pressure in the first flow-path is above a threshold;
a second flow-path, fluidly coupled between the first compressor and the second compressor;
a third flow-path, fluidly coupled between the second compressor, a fuel tank and the ASM;
a first heat exchanger…configured to receive bleed airflow from an aircraft component;
a second heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the second flow-path between the first compressor and the second compressor to cool the flow through the second flow-path with ram air,
a third heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the third flow-path, between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM, to cool the flow through the third flow-path with ram air, wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold; and a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold such that cabin pressure drives the turbine.
Surawski discloses an inert gas generation system providing air to an air separation module (Abstract) similar to the present invention and Surawski further discloses it is known to have a second compressor (Fig. 1, second compressor 24) configured to be fluidly coupled to the air separation membrane (Fig. 1, air separation module 30);
a second flow-path (Fig. 1, 16b, 24a), fluidly coupled between a first compressor (Fig. 1, first compressor 16) and the second compressor (Fig. 1, second compressor 24);
a third flow-path (Fig. 1, 24b, 26, 31), fluidly coupled between the second compressor (Fig. 1, second compressor 24), a fuel tank (Fig. 1, fuel tank 36) and the ASM (Fig. 1, air separation module 30); and
a heat exchanger (Fig. 1, heat exchanger assembly 20), operationally coupled to the second flow-path between the first compressor and the second compressor to cool the flow through the second flow-path (Fig. 1 and ¶ 0003, “A heat exchanger is typically arranged in a ram air duct in fluid communication between the compressors and the air separation module to cool the non-enriched air”).
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to have modified the system of Massey to include 1) a second compressor and 2) a second heat exchanger as taught by Surawski in order to have a second compressor configured to be fluidly coupled to the air separation membrane; a second flow-path, fluidly coupled between the first compressor and the second compressor; a third flow-path, fluidly coupled between the second compressor, a fuel tank and the ASM; and a second heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the second flow-path between the first compressor and the second compressor to cool the flow through the second flow-path and thereby 1) increase the pressure of the air (As suggested by ¶ 0010 of Surawski: “The second compressor 24 provides further compressed air to the heat exchanger assembly 20. The further compressed air, which has been cooled by the heat exchanger assembly 20, is provided to a filter 28 through a duct 26. Non-enriched air flows through the filter 28 to an air separation module 30.”) for more reliable operation of the ASM and 2) increase the effectiveness of the system (As suggested by ¶ 0003 of Surawski: “It is desirable to provide the non-enriched air to the air separation module within a desired operating temperature range to produce the nitrogen enriched air. A heat exchanger is typically arranged in a ram air duct in fluid communication between the compressors and the air separation module to cool the non-enriched air. The non-enriched air is cooled when ram air flows through the heat exchanger, thus maintaining the non-enriched air within the desired operating temperature range”).
However, Massey, as modified above, does not disclose a unitary motor-generator,
wherein the first compressor, the turbine, the second compressor and the motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts;
a second compressor operationally coupled to a turbine; and
a first heat exchanger…configured to receive bleed airflow from an aircraft component;
the motor-generator operates in a generator mode when pressure in the first flow-path is above a threshold,
a second heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the second flow-path between the first compressor and the second compressor to cool the flow through the second flow-path with ram air,
a third heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the third flow-path, between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM, to cool the flow through the third flow-path with ram air, wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold; and a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold such that cabin pressure drives the turbine.
Richardson discloses an air system for an aircraft (Abstract) similar to the present invention and Richardson further discloses it is known for a compressor (‘Background’, line 24, compressor) to be operationally coupled to a turbine (‘Background’, line 24, “The turbine, the compressor, and a fan are mechanically connected via shaft.”);
a first flow-path configured to receive cabin air from a cabin of the aircraft (Fig. 2, flow-path from ‘cabin supply air’ to ‘atmosphere’); and
the motor-generator (Fig. 2, fan 214, motor 215, battery 216, and generator 232; ‘Detailed Description’, Pg. 10, lines 15-24, “The turbine 221 is coupled to the generator 232 to drive the generator 232 to generate power. In turn, the generator 232 produces a load on the turbine 221. In some examples, the power provided by the generator 232 is stored in the battery 216 of the aircraft 100. Additionally or alternatively, the power may be supplied directly to one or more electrical device(s) of the aircraft (100), such as the electric motor 215 for the fan 214.”; ‘Detailed Description’ Pg. 17, lines 8-20, “In some examples, the fan 214 is operable in two modes: a first mode of operation in which the fan 214 is driven by the electric motor 215 to direct the cabin exhaust air to the atmosphere, and a second mode of operation in which the fan 214 is driven by the cabin exhaust air and the fan 214 drives the electric motor 215 to generate power.”) operates in a generator mode (Fig. 3 and ‘Detailed Description’, Pg. 17, lines 8-20, generator mode) when pressure in the first flow-path is above a threshold (‘Detailed Description’, Pg. 17, lines 8-20, “For example, in some instances, the pressure drop between the cabin 108 and the atmosphere is large enough such that when the valve 218 is opened, the cabin exhaust air flows from the cabin 108 and through the heat exchanger 205 to the atmosphere. In such an example, the fan 214 is not needed to move the cabin exhaust air through the passageways 212, 213. Instead, the fan 214 can be used as a generator to generate additional electrical power. For example, the fan instrument controller 274 may switch the electric motor 215 into a generator mode. The cabin exhaust air flowing through the passageway 213 drives the fan 214, which drives the electric motor 215 to produce power.”),
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode (‘Detailed Description’ Pg. 17, lines 8-20, “In some examples, the fan 214 is operable in two modes: a first mode of operation in which the fan 214 is driven by the electric motor 215 to direct the cabin exhaust air to the atmosphere) when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold (One of ordinary skill in the art would understand this must necessarily be the case in light of Detailed Description’, Pg. 17, lines 8-20, as quoted below, which discloses the generator mode occurs when a pressure drop between the cabin air and atmosphere is large enough. To elaborate, given the fan 214, motor 215, battery 216, and generator 232 switch to the generator mode when a pressure drop between the cabin air and atmosphere is large enough and Richardson also discloses the fan 214, motor 215, battery 216, and generator 232 have a motor mode where the fan 214 is driven by electric motor 215, the motor mode must necessarily occur when the pressure drop between the cabin air and atmosphere is low); and a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold (Detailed Description’, Pg. 17, lines 8-20, “For example, in some instances, the pressure drop between the cabin 108 and the atmosphere is large enough such that when the valve 218 is opened, the cabin exhaust air flows from the cabin 108 and through the heat exchanger 205 to the atmosphere. In such an example, the fan 214 is not needed to move the cabin exhaust air through the passageways 212, 213. Instead, the fan 214 can be used as a generator to generate additional electrical power. For example, the fan instrument controller 274 may switch the electric motor 215 into a generator mode. The cabin exhaust air flowing through the passageway 213 drives the fan 214, which drives the electric motor 215 to produce power.”).
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to have modified the system of Massey with the 1) compressor and 2) motor-generator of Richardson in order to have the second compressor operationally coupled to a turbine and a motor-generator that operates in a generator mode when pressure in the first flow-path is above a threshold and thereby 1) make the system more compact and lightweight and 2) (As suggested by ‘Detailed Description’, Pg. 17, lines 20-23 of Richardson: “The power produced by the electric motor 215 can be stored in the battery 216 and/or used directly by one or more electric devices of the aircraft 100.”).
NOTE: It is the Examiner’s position that modified Massey would result in a motor-generator that is configured to operate in a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold such that cabin pressure drives the turbine as claimed. To elaborate, Massey discloses a motor-generator that is configured to operate in a generator mode such that cabin pressure drives the turbine and Richardson discloses a motor-generator operates in a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold, so the motor-generator must necessarily be configured to operate in a generator mode when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is above a threshold such that cabin pressure drives the turbine in modified Massey.
However, Massey, as modified above, does not disclose a unitary motor-generator,
wherein the first compressor, the turbine, the second compressor and the motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts;
a first heat exchanger…configured to receive bleed airflow from an aircraft component;
a second heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the second flow-path between the first compressor and the second compressor to cool the flow through the second flow-path with ram air,
a third heat exchanger, operationally coupled to the third flow-path, between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM, to cool the flow through the third flow-path with ram air, wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold.
Liu discloses an inerting system (Abstract) similar to the present invention and Liu further discloses it is known to have a first heat exchanger (Fig. 1, first heat exchanger 2) configured to receive bleed airflow from an aircraft component (¶ 0028, “Air filter 1 is connected to the bleed air of the aircraft engine at its inlet. The hot side channel of the first heat exchanger 2 is connected to the air filter 1”);
a second heat exchanger (Fig. 1, second heat exchanger 3) cool the flow through the second flow-path with ram air (¶ 0028, “the second heat exchanger 3, while the cold side channel is circulated with ram air”),
a third heat exchanger (Fig. 1, third heat exchanger 4), operationally coupled to a third flow-path (Fig. 1, path from first shut-off valve 8 to aircraft fuel tank 201) to cool the flow through the third flow-path (¶ 0031, “cooled by low temperature ram air in the third heat exchanger 4”) with ram air (¶ 0028, “The hot side channel of the third heat exchanger 4…while the cold side channel is circulated with ram air and discharged to the outside environment”), wherein an air separation column (¶ 0031, “The air is frozen into liquid and enters the distillation column 9 for distillation. Nitrogen is first separated from the liquid air to form nitrogen-rich gas, and then condensed in the distillation column 9 to form nitrogen-rich liquid. The nitrogen-rich liquid enters the nitrogen-rich liquid storage tank 102, and after passing through the fifth shut-off valve 101 and the hot side channel of the fourth heat exchanger 6, it enters the gas phase space of the aircraft fuel tank 201, where oxygen is converted and discharged to the external environment.”) is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank (Fig. 1, aircraft fuel tank 201).
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to have modified the system of Massey with the first heat exchanger configured to receive bleed airflow from an aircraft component, the second heat exchanger that cools the flow through the second flow-path with ram air, and a third heat exchanger as taught by Liu in order to 1) better ensure flight safety under extreme conditions (As suggested by Par. 0031 of Liu: “The system's operating method can meet the aircraft's fuel tank inerting requirements across the entire flight envelope and under extreme conditions, reduce the impact on engine bleed air, ensure flight safety, and provide a large amount of oxygen-enriched gas for aircraft cabin pressurization and oxygen supply.”) and 2) increase the cooling capacity of the system (As suggested by Par. 0020 of Liu: “This invention utilizes a first heat exchanger, a second heat exchanger, a third heat exchanger, and a fourth heat exchanger to perform multiple induced draft cooling processes”) and thereby mitigate the impact that failure of the first and/or second heat exchanger would have on the system.
However, Massey, as modified above, does not disclose a unitary motor-generator,
wherein the first compressor, the turbine, the second compressor and the motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts;
a third heat exchanger…between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM…wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold.
Cerney discloses an aircraft integrated power and thermal management system (Abstract) similar to the present invention and Cerney further discloses it is known to have a unitary motor-generator (Fig. 2, motor-generator 212) and
wherein a first compressor (Fig. 2, compressor 206), a turbine (Fig. 2, cooling turbine 208), and a motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts (Fig. 2, main shaft 214).
It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to have modified the device of Massey, as modified above, to include the unitary motor-generator and shaft as taught by Cerney in order to decrease part count which reduces costs and is often correlated with increased reliability.
However, Massey, as modified above, does not disclose the first compressor, the turbine, the second compressor and the motor-generator are rotationally coupled to each other via one or more shafts;
a third heat exchanger…between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM…wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold.
It would have been an obvious matter of design choice to add the second compressor to the same shaft as the first compressor, turbine, and second compressor, since it has been held that the configuration of the claimed element was a matter of choice which a person of ordinary skill in the art would have found obvious absent persuasive evidence that the particular configuration of the claimed shaft was significant. MPEP 2144.04 VI-C. Please note that in the instant application, the Applicant has not disclosed any criticality for the claimed limitation. One could have expected the compressors, turbine, and motor-generator to perform substantially equally well, whether on the same shaft or in their original positions.
However, Massey, as modified above, does not disclose a third heat exchanger…between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM…wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold.
At the time of this writing, Examiner hasn’t found a prior art teaching that has a third heat exchanger…between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM…wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank and wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold. In addition, any design choice rejection regarding the location of the third heat exchanger in lieu of a prior art teaching would result in an unreasonable hindsight rejection and reconstruction of the Applicant’s claimed invention. This is at least partly because Par. 0035 of the PGPUB discloses the location of the third heat exchanger in the third flow-path serves the critical purpose of reducing energy to the fuel tank in supply air from the system, “thereby reducing pressure in the supply air and the risk of related complications” and Par. 0036 of the PGPUB discloses the motor-generator driving the first compressor, the second compressor, and the turbine serves the critical purpose of recovering available energy from the cabin air. In addition, five references have already been used to teach the other limitations of claim 1, so adding more references to the rejection would further result in an unreasonable hindsight rejection and reconstruction of the Applicant’s claimed invention. Therefore, the limitations “a third heat exchanger…between the second compressor and the the ASM, and directly upstream of the ASM…wherein the ASM is disposed in the third flow-path, between the third heat exchanger and the fuel tank, and
wherein the motor-generator is configured to operate in: a motor mode to drive the first compressor, the second compressor and the turbine when a pressure differential between atmospheric pressure and cabin pressure is below a threshold” (emphasis added), when combined with the other limitations of the claim, distinguishes the claim from the prior art.
Conclusion
Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to Elizabeth A Laughlin whose telephone number is (703)756-5924. The examiner can normally be reached Monday - Friday 8:30-6:00 ET.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Michael Hoang can be reached on (571) 272-6460. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/E.A.L./Examiner, Art Unit 3762 /MICHAEL G HOANG/Supervisory Patent Examiner, Art Unit 3762