DETAILED ACTION
Claim Status
Claim(s) 1, 3-13 is/are pending.
Claim(s) 1, 3-13 is/are rejected.
Claim(s) 2 is/are rejected.
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112:
The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention.
Claim(s) 1, 3-13 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, because the specification, while being enabling for: (A) a limited range of heat-shrinkable polyester film compositions; does not reasonably provide enablement for the entire encompassed compositional range of the polyester film. The specification does not enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make the invention commensurate in scope with these claims.
The propriety of a rejection based upon the scope of a claim relative to the scope of the enablement concerns (1) how broad the claim is with respect to the disclosure and (2) whether one skilled in the art could make and use the entire scope of the claimed invention without undue experimentation. See MPEP 2164.08. The disclosure as originally filed does not enable one of ordinary skill in the art to make the claimed heat-shrinkable polyester films exhibiting:
the recited properties (claim 1):
(a) E1-E2 between 23.5-50 MPa; and
(b) transverse direction (TD) shrinkage A1 under the specified conditions at 98°C; and
(c1) E1 of 40-70 MPa; and
(c2) E2 of 15-45 MPa;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 3):
(d) TD shrinkage A2 under the specified conditions at 80°C;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 4):
(e) TD shrinkage A3 under the specified conditions at 70°C;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 5):
(f) tensile modulus of elasticity C;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 6):
(g) b* value;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 8):
(i) haze value;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 9):
(d) TD shrinkage A2 under the specified conditions at 80°C;
(e) TD shrinkage A3 under the specified conditions at 70°C;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 10):
(d) TD shrinkage A2 under the specified conditions at 80°C;
(f) tensile modulus of elasticity C;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 11):
(d) TD shrinkage A2 under the specified conditions at 80°C;
(g) b* value;
optionally with the additional recited properties (claim 13):
(d) TD shrinkage A2 under the specified conditions at 80°C;
(i) haze value;
over the entire scope of the present claims.
MPEP 2164.01(a) Undue Experimentation Factors [R-08.2012]
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
There are many factors to be considered when determining whether there is sufficient evidence to support a determination that a disclosure does not satisfy the enablement requirement and whether any necessary experimentation is "undue." These factors include, but are not limited to:
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(A) The breadth of the claims;
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(B) The nature of the invention;
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(C) The state of the prior art;
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(D) The level of one of ordinary skill;
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(E) The level of predictability in the art;
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(F) The amount of direction provided by the inventor;
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(G) The existence of working examples; and
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
(H) The quantity of experimentation needed to make or use the invention based on the
content of the disclosure.
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
In re Wands, 858 F.2d 731, 737, 8 USPQ2d 1400, 1404 (Fed. Cir. 1988) (reversing the PTO’s determination that claims directed to methods for detection of hepatitis B surface antigens did not satisfy the enablement requirement). In Wands, the court noted that there was no disagreement as to the facts, but merely a disagreement as to the interpretation of the data and the conclusion to be made from the facts. In re Wands, 858 F.2d at 736-40, 8 USPQ2d at 1403-07. The Court held that the specification was enabling with respect to the claims at issue and found that "there was considerable direction and guidance" in the specification; there was "a high level of skill in the art at the time the application was filed;" and "all of the methods needed to practice the invention were well known." 858 F.2d at 740, 8 USPQ2d at 1406. After considering all the factors related to the enablement issue, the court concluded that "it would not require undue experimentation to obtain antibodies needed to practice the claimed invention." Id., 8 USPQ2d at 1407.
In particular, with respect to Wand factor (A) the claims are very broad -- for example, but not limited to:
• the claims do not contain any limitations as to the composition of the crystalline polyester resin;
• the claims do not contain any limitations as to the composition of the non-crystalline polyester resin;
• the claims only contain minimal limitations as to the composition of the polyester resin composition as a whole (except for the required amounts of crystalline polyester resin and non-crystalline polyester resin);
• the claims only contain minimal limitations as to the composition of the heat-shrinkable polyester film as a whole (except for the required presence of the recited “polyester resin composition”);
• the claims do not contain any restrictions on the type(s) and amount(s) of other components (e.g., other types of polyesters; other thermoplastic and/or thermosetting resins; non-polymeric components such as various organic or inorganic compounds, such as fillers, pigments, and/or other additives; etc.) in the heat-shrinkable polyester film as a whole, as long as: (i) the recited “polyester resin composition” are present;
• the claims do not contain any limitations on the orientation conditions (e.g., MD and TD stretching temperatures; MD and TD stretch ratios; post-stretching heat treatment; etc.) of the heat-shrinkable polyester film;
etc.
With respect to Wand factor (B), the present claims require the claimed heat-shrinkable polyester film to simultaneously satisfy the recited combination of properties (a)-(c2) of claim 1, and optionally additional properties (d)-(g) or (i).
With respect to Wand factor (C), the prior art does not specifically disclose or suggest how to produce polyester films capable of simultaneously satisfying the recited combination of properties (a)-(c2) of claim 1, and optionally (d)-(g) or (i) to produce heat-shrinkable films.
With respect to Wand factor (D), in view of the evidence in the specification with that the recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i) can vary significantly -- and in some cases, unpredictably (e.g., non-linearly) -- with differences in the heat-shrinkable polyester film composition and polyester resin composition, it is the Examiner’s position that the disclosure as originally filed does not provide adequate guidance that permits one of ordinary skill in the art to produce heat-shrinkable polyester films capable of simultaneously satisfy the recited combination of properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), using film compositions which satisfy the broad compositional limitations on the claimed heat-shrinkable film and polyester resin composition, but which differ substantially from Applicant’s working Examples, with mere routine experimentation.
With respect to Wand factor (E), the Examples in the specification provide evidence that changes in the heat-shrinkable polyester film composition will result in films with significant -- and in some cases, unpredictable -- variations in recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), and it is not readily apparent or predictable how differences in polyester film composition will affect a film’s ability to simultaneously satisfy recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i).
With respect to Wand factor (F)-(G), the disclosure as originally filed only provides guidance how to produce a film capable of satisfying simultaneously satisfying recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), using: (1) a relatively limited range of crystalline polyester resins; (2) a relatively limited range of non-crystalline polyester resins; and (3) a limited range of heat-shrinkable polyester film compositions as a whole, combined with specific film-forming conditions.
With respect to Wand factor (H), in view of the evidence provided by the Examples in the specification with respect to the effect of: (1) different crystalline polyester resins; and/or (2) heat-shrinkable polyester film compositions as a whole; on recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), it is the Examiner’s position that undue experimentation would be required to produce a heat-shrinkable polyester film capable of simultaneously satisfying recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), using crystalline polyester resins and/or non-crystalline polyester resins and/or polyester resin compositions and/or heat-shrinkable polyester film compositions which are encompassed by the present claims, but are materially different from those used in the working Examples in the specification.
The disclosure as originally filed only discloses producing films capable of simultaneously satisfying recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), using heat shrinkable polyester films formed effectively entirely (about 99 wt%) from:
(1) blends containing:
• 10-70 pbw of polyethylene terephthalate (PET) homopolymer;
• 90-30 pbw of copolyester PETG1 derived from:
• an acid component of 100 mol% terephthalic acid;
• a diol component of:
• 63 mol% ethylene glycol
• 13 mol% diethylene glycol
• 24 mol% 1,4-cyclohexanedimethanol (CHDM),
(2) a blend containing:
• 25 pbw of PET homopolymer;
• 10 pbw of polybutylene terephthalate (PBT) homopolymer;
• 65 pbw of copolyester PETG3 derived from:
• an acid component of 100 mol% terephthalic acid;
• a diol component of:
• 70 mol% ethylene glycol;
• 2 mol% diethylene glycol;
• 28 mol% neopentyl glycol (NPG);
In view of the working and comparative Examples in the specification, the Examiner has reason to believe that the recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), are substantially affected by: (1) the type of crystalline polyester; and (2) the type of non-crystalline polyester; and (3) the film composition as a whole; in view of the working Examples in the specification. Applicant has not provided persuasive evidence that recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), can be simultaneously satisfied using heat-shrinkable polyester films only partially composed of polyester resin compositions:
(i) which contain crystalline polyester resins which differs significantly from the crystalline PET homopolymer and/or PBT homopolymer used in the working Examples in the specification; and/or
(ii) which contain non-crystalline polyester resins which differs significantly from the non-crystalline PETG-type copolyesters used in the working Examples in the specification; and/or
(iii) in which the combined total of crystalline polyester resin and additional amorphous PETG-type copolymer constitute less than the effective entirety (about 99 wt%) of the film composition as a whole; and/or
(iv) which contain non-trivial amounts of other polymeric components (e.g., additional crystalline polyester resins; additional amorphous non-PETG-type copolyesters; other thermoplastic polymers; etc.) and/or non-polymeric components (e.g., inorganic or organic fillers or fibers, colorants,plasticizers, etc.).
For example, the compositional limitations of the present claims allow for heat-shrinkable polyester films such as, but are not limited to:
---------------------------------------------------
(1) a heat-shrinkable film containing a polyester resin composition, wherein the polyester resin composition contains:
• 10-70 wt% of a crystallizable (co)polyester resin;
• 30-90 wt% of an amorphous copolyester derived from;
• a polycarboxylic acid component comprising:
• 1-50 mol% terephthalic acid;
• 50-100 mol% one or more other polycarboxylic acids (e.g., aromatic dicarboxylic acids such as isophthalic acid, etc.; aliphatic or cycloaliphatic dicarboxylic acids such as adipic acid, succinic acid, cyclohexane dicarboxylic acid, etc.; polycarboxylic acids with functionalities of three or more; etc.);
• a polyalcohol component comprising:
• 0-50 mol% ethylene glycol;
• 50-100 mol% one or more other polyalcohols (e.g., CHDM, NPG; 1,4-butanediol; 1,6-hexanediol; etc.);
(2) a heat-shrinkable film containing a polyester resin composition, wherein the polyester resin composition contains:
• 10-70 wt% of a first crystallizable polyester resin (A) derived from:
• a polycarboxylic acid component comprising:
• 0-10 mol% terephthalic acid;
• 90-100 mol% one or more other polycarboxylic acids (e.g., aromatic dicarboxylic acids such as isophthalic acid, 2,6-napthalenedicarboxylic acid, etc.; aliphatic or cycloaliphatic dicarboxylic acids such as adipic acid, succinic acid, cyclohexane dicarboxylic acid, etc.; polycarboxylic acids with functionalities of three or more; etc.);
• a polyalcohol component comprising:
• 0-10 mol% ethylene glycol;
• 90-100 mol% one or more other polyalcohols (e.g., CHDM, NPG; 1,4-butanediol; 1,6-hexanediol; etc.);
• 30-90 wt% of an amorphous polyester;
(3) a heat-shrinkable film containing a polyester resin composition, wherein the polyester resin composition contains:
• 10-70 wt% of a crystalline polyester resin (e.g., crystalline polylactic acid; crystalline polyhydroxyalkanoate; polycaprolactone etc.);
• 30-90 wt% of amorphous polyester resin (e.g., amorphous polylactic acid; amorphous polyhydroxyalkanoate; etc.);
(4) a heat-shrinkable film containing:
• less than 99 wt% (e.g., 90 wt% or 80 wt% or 60 wt% or 50 wt% or 20 wt% or 10 wt%, etc.) of the recited polyester resin composition;
• more than 1 wt% (e.g., 90 wt% or 80 wt% or 50 wt% or 60 wt% or 20 wt% or 10 wt%, etc.) of other components (e.g., polymeric; non-polymeric organic; inorganic; etc.);
---------------------------------------------------
However, the disclosure as originally filed fails to provide any teachings or guidance as to how to simultaneously satisfy recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), with illustrative films (1)-(5) as described above, and there is insufficient evidence that one of ordinary skill in the art would be able to simultaneously satisfy recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), with illustrative film compositions (1)-(5) as described above using mere routine experimentation, particularly in view of the evidence in the specification with respect to potentially unpredictable effect of different film compositions on recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i).
---------------------------------------------------
The present claims use the term “produced from” with respect to the composition of the heat-shrinkable polyester film as a whole, which is interpreted as equivalent to the open term “comprising” or “comprises”, which allows for nearly any amount(s) of other material(s) (e.g., polymeric; non-polymeric organic; inorganic; etc.) in the heat-shrinkable polyester film as a whole, as long as the recited “polyester resin composition” is present in the heat shrinkable polyester film in the specified amount.
Similarly, the present claims use the term “includes” with respect to the “polyester resin composition” as a whole, which is interpreted as equivalent to the open term “comprising” or “comprises”, which allows for nearly any amount(s) of other material(s) (e.g., polymeric; non-polymeric organic; inorganic; etc.) in the “polyester resin composition” as a whole, as long as the recited “crystalline polyester resin” is present in the “polyester resin composition” in the specified amount.
The Examiner has reason to believe: (1) a minimal amount of crystalline polyester resin; and (2) a minimal amount of non-crystalline polyester resin; and (3) a minimal amount of the polyester resin composition; need to be present in the heat-shrinkable polyester film as a whole in order to produce a heat-shrinkable polyester film capable of simultaneously satisfying recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i).
Furthermore, the Examiner has reason to believe the recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), of a heat-shrinkable polyester film would be materially affected by presence of non-trivial amounts of other components (e.g., other polymers; other non-polymeric compounds or additives; etc.) in the heat-shrinkable polyester film as a whole or the polyester resin composition as a whole.
Applicant has not provided adequate guidance to one of ordinary skill in the art as to how to produce a heat-shrinkable polyester film capable of simultaneously satisfying recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i) without undue experimentation using:
(i) heat-shrinkable polyester film compositions in which the combined amount of specific crystalline polyester resin and specific types of non-crystalline polyester resin represents less than the effective entirety (about 99 wt%) of the heat-shrinkable polyester film composition as a whole;
and/or
(ii) polyester resin compositions containing crystalline polyester resin which differs materially from the specific crystalline polyester resins utilized in the working Examples in the specification;
and/or
(iii) polyester resin compositions containing non-crystalline polyester resins which differs materially from the specific non-crystalline PETG-type copolyesters utilized in the working Examples in the specification.
----------------------------------------------
Therefore, in view of the above, the disclosure as originally filed does not enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make the invention commensurate in scope with the present claims without undue experimentation, especially in view of the evidence in the specification which indicates the ability to simultaneously satisfying recited properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), is materially (and in some cases, unpredictably) affected by: (i) the heat-shrinkable polyester film composition as a whole; and/or (ii) the type and amount of crystalline polyester resin in the heat-shrinkable polyester film; particularly when the film orientation and post-stretching treatments for biaxially oriented polyester films materially affect the crystallinity of said polyester films, which in turn, can significantly impact the stress-strain curves for said polyester film.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112(b):
(b) CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
Claim(s) 1, 3-13 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor, or for pre-AIA the applicant regards as the invention.
Claim 1 is vague and indefinite because the phrase “a total resin amount (100% by weight) of the polyester resin” fails to clearly set forth the basis of the percentage (e.g., the total combined amount of crystalline polyester resin and non-crystalline polyester resin? the total amount of all polyester resins in the “polyester resin composition”? the total amount of all polyester resins in the heat-shrinkable film as a whole? ).
Claims 3-13 are dependent on one or more of the above claims and therefore incorporate the above-described indefinite subject matter.
Response to Arguments
Applicant's arguments filed 07/07/2026 have been fully considered but they are not persuasive.
(A) Applicant argues that the amended language in claim 1 (e.g., 10% to 70% by weight of crystalline polyester resin and 30% to 90% by weight of non-crystalline polyester resin; incorporation of features from claim 2) fully addresses the present rejections under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph (scope of enablement) in the previous Office Action mailed 04/08/2026. However, the Claim Amendments filed 07/07/2026 fail to fully address the outstanding issues of scope of enablement for the reasons discussed in detail in the rejections under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph (scope of enablement) in the present Office Action.
(B) Applicant argues that “the specification as filed sufficiently explains the correlation between the crystalline polyester loading and b* in the chromaticity coordinates (b*). It is explained further in paragraph [0038] that the numerical value associated with relational expression 1 (E1 - E2) can be controlled if b* 0.15.” Applicant further argues that “the numerical value associated with relational expression 1 (E1 - E2) can be controlled if b* 0.15.”
In response to applicant's argument that the references fail to show certain features of the invention, it is noted that the features upon which applicant relies (i.e., b* in chromaticity coordinates) are not recited in the majority of the rejected claim(s). Although the claims are interpreted in light of the specification, limitations from the specification are not read into the claims. See In re Van Geuns, 988 F.2d 1181, 26 USPQ2d 1057 (Fed. Cir. 1993). If the b* value is somehow critical to obtaining the recited (E1-E2) value, then the b* value should be present in the independent claim.
Regarding claims 6, 11, the linear correlation between crystalline polyester resin content and *b value in Figure 2 is only derived from the inventive Examples 1-5, which utilize a relatively narrow range of heat-shrinkable polyester film compositions. There is no objective evidence that a comparably easily derived linear correlation would exist using film compositions containing: (1) types and/or amounts of crystalline polyester resin which materially differ from those used in the inventive Examples in the Specification; (2) types and/or amounts of non-crystalline polyester resin which materially differ from those used in the inventive Examples in the Specification; (3) non-trivial amounts of other polymers and/or non-polymer components are not present in the inventive Examples in the Specification.
Similarly, the relationship between (E1-E2) and b* value is only derived from the inventive Examples 1-5, and it is unclear whether the relationship between (E1-E2) and b* value can be readily predicted (e.g., via a linear correlation, etc.) for film compositions containing: (1) types and/or amounts of crystalline polyester resin which materially differ from those used in the inventive Examples in the Specification; (2) types and/or amounts of non-crystalline polyester resin which materially differ from those used in the inventive Examples in the Specification; (3) non-trivial amounts of other polymers and/or non-polymer components are not present in the inventive Examples in the Specification. For example, differences in miscibility and/or unpredictable molecular interactions between the crystalline and non-crystalline polyester resins in the polyester resin composition can result in non-linear and/or difficult to quantify relationships between the amount of crystalline polyester resin and the *b value.
(C) Applicant argues that “an ordinary artisan is enabled to produce the claimed polyester film through the teachings of the specification and known elements of the art as of the effective filing date. Applicant further argues that “An ordinary artisan could simply choose a crystalline polyester resin loading within the claimed range to predictably satisfy the remainder of the claimed elements without undue experimentation.”
However, the basis for the present rejections under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, in the present Office Action is not a lack of enablement per se (i.e., the specification does enable one of ordinary skill in the art to make a heat shrinkable polyester film which exhibits the recited above physical properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i).
Instead, the basis for the present rejection under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, in the present Office Action is the insufficient scope of enablement provided by the disclosure as originally filed (i.e., that the disclosure as originally filed does not enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make the invention commensurate in scope with the present claims without undue experimentation -- i.e., while the disclosure as originally filed is enabling for a limited range of heat shrinkable film compositions, the specification does not reasonably provide adequate enablement for the entire scope of the present claims (as represented by the entire compositional range of film compositions as a whole which are encompassed by the present claims). As discussed in detail above in the present rejections under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, the scope of the present claims is substantially broader than the guidance provided by the disclosure as originally filed.
Regarding “scope of enablement” rejections, the issue is not whether one of ordinary skill in the art can, for a given heat shrinkable film composition, can determine if said compound falls inside or outside the present claims. Instead, the relevant inquiry is whether the specification provide adequate guidance or direction for experimentation that would enable one of ordinary skill to produce heat shrinkable polyester film which exhibits the recited above physical properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i) using film compositions which fall within the scope of the present claims, but are non-trivially different from the types of film compositions used in the working Examples.
The courts have repeatedly held that "the specification must teach those skilled in the art how to make and use the full scope of the claimed invention without ‘undue experimentation’" or that any experimentation must be "reasonable". See Amgen Inc. et al. v. Sanofi et al., 598 U.S. 594, 2023 USPQ2d 602 (2023); McRO, Inc. v. Bandai Namco Games Am. Inc., 959 F.3d 1091, 2020 USPQ2d 10550 (Fed. Cir. 2020); Wyeth & Cordis Corp. v. Abbott Laboratories, 720 F.3d 1380, 107 USPQ2d 1273 (Fed. Cir. 2013); Enzo Life Sciences, Inc. v. Roche Molecular Systems, Inc., 928 F.3d 1340 (Fed. Cir. 2019); and Idenix Pharmaceuticals LLC v. Gilead Sciences Inc., 941 F.3d 1149, 2019 USPQ2d 415844 (Fed. Cir. 2019). See also In re Wright, 999 F.2d 1557, 1561, 27 USPQ2d 1510, 1513 (Fed. Cir. 1993). See MPEP 2164.08.
While even a considerable amount of experimentation may be permissible when the specification provide adequate guidance or direction for experimentation for one of ordinary skill in the art, it is the Examiner’s position that in the present instance, the disclosure as originally filed does not provide adequate guidance or direction for such experimentation, and therefore one skilled in the art would be left to blindly select or adjust multiple parameters (e.g., the type(s) and/or amount(s) of various components, etc.) of a film composition in an attempt to produce a heat-shrinkable film exhibiting the required combination of physical properties, which constitutes “undue experimentation” when the film compositions contain: (1) types and/or amounts of crystalline polyester resin which materially differ from those used in the inventive Examples in the Specification; (2) types and/or amounts of non-crystalline polyester resin which materially differ from those used in the inventive Examples in the Specification; (3) non-trivial amounts of other polymers and/or non-polymer components are not present in the inventive Examples in the Specification; particularly when the present claims encompasses film compositions containing a very broad range of crystalline polyester resins and a very broad range of non-crystalline polyester resins and a very broad range of film compositions as a whole.
Therefore, Applicant has not provided persuasive arguments that the disclosure as originally filed provides enablement over the entire scope of the present claims (particularly with respect to the range of film compositions encompassed by the present claims), particularly in view of: (1) the relative broadness of the present claims; (2) the very limited number of working Examples; and (3) the absence of adequate guidance or teachings in the Specification which would provide one of ordinary skill in the art with reasonable directions for experimentation or modification when attempting to produce heat shrinkable films which simultaneously exhibit the required multiple physical properties, but which deviate materially from the film compositions of the inventive Examples in the specification.
(D) Applicant argues that while “the Office indicates that the claims do not contain any restrictions on the types and amounts of other components in the heat- shrinkable polyester film. Applicant emphasizes that these elements are not critical components, but they may be included in optional embodiments of the invention. A skilled person is able to select suitable additives and incorporate them in appropriate amounts through appropriate means.” However, the Examiner is not asserting that these other component are critical, but rather that the present claims are sufficiently broad in scope as to allow for the presence of non-trivial amounts of other components in the heat-shrinkable film composition as a whole and the polyester resin composition as a whole. It is reasonable to assume that the presence of these other component can materially -- and potentially unpredictably -- affect one or more of the recited physical properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), particularly in view of the inventive Examples, which provide evidence that the above physical properties can vary significantly depending on the film composition used, and the disclosure as originally filed does not provide adequate guidance regarding what types of modifications and/or adjustments would be necessary to produce heat-shrinkable polyester films which exhibit the recited physical properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), from film compositions containing non-trivial amounts of other additional components.
(E) Applicant argues that while “the Office indicates that the claims should define stretch ratios and conditions. Paragraphs [0050] and [0053] describe the stretch ratios together with an explanation thereof. In addition, particular attention should be paid to Table 1, which provides sufficient information regarding the stretch ratios and conditions at issue. At least based on the above, a skilled person would readily be enabled to appropriately select, adjust, and control the stretch ratios without undue experimentation. As such, a skilled person is able to ascertain the spirit of the invention without recitation of these features within the claims.”
However, as discussed in detail above, the guidance provided by the Specification, in particular the inventive Examples, is effectively limited to the relatively narrow range of film compositions used in said inventive Examples. Since it is well known that mechanical properties (e.g., yield point, tensile modulus, etc.) and heat-shrinkable characteristics (e.g., shrinkage at various temperatures and various directions) of polyester films are strongly dependent on the orientation conditions (e.g., shrink ratio, heat-setting temperature, relaxation steps, etc.) for the heat shrinkable film, it is reasonable to assume that the film orientation conditions of the claimed heat-shrinkable films would materially -- and potentially unpredictably -- affect one or more of the recited physical properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), and the disclosure as originally filed does not provide adequate guidance regarding what types of modifications and/or adjustments to film orientation would be necessary to produce heat-shrinkable polyester films which exhibit the recited physical properties (a)-(c2), and optionally (d)-(g) or (i), from film compositions which are materially different from those utilized in the inventive Examples in the Specification.
(F) Applicant argues that “The tight correlations of the working examples presented in Figs. 2-10 demonstrate that the required properties are predictable based upon the crystalline resin loading relative to the non-crystalline resin loading within the respective claimed ranges. As such, a skilled artisan would be enabled to practice the invention through the teachings of the
specification.”
However, as discussed in detail above, the “tight correlations” are based on the inventive Examples which utilize a range of film compositions as a whole which is substantially narrower in scope compared to the range of film compositions encompassed by the present claims. Therefore, while a skilled artisan is enabled to practice the invention for a limited range of film compositions, a skilled artisan is not enabled to practice the claimed invention over the entire scope of the present claims without undue experimentation.
(G) Applicant argue that the Claim Amendments filed 07/07/2026 fully address the outstanding rejections under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) in the previous Office Action mailed 04/08/2026. However, Applicant’s arguments are not persuasive for the reasons stated in the rejections under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) in the present Office Action.
Conclusion
Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to Vivian Chen (Vivian.chen@uspto.gov) whose telephone number is (571) 272-1506. The examiner can normally be reached on Monday through Thursday from 8:30 AM to 6 PM. The examiner can also be reached on alternate Fridays.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner's supervisor, Callie Shosho, can be reached on (571) 272-1123. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is (571) 273-8300.
The General Information telephone number for Technology Center 1700 is (571) 272-1700.
Information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from Patent Center. Status information for published applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Status information for unpublished applications is available through Patent Center for authorized users only. Should you have questions about access to Patent Center, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free).
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) Form at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/uspto-automated- interview-request-air-form.
September 28, 2026
/VIVIAN CHEN/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 1787