Prosecution Insights
Last updated: July 17, 2026
Application No. 18/726,308

TERMINAL, RADIO COMMUNICATION METHOD, AND BASE STATION

Non-Final OA §102
Filed
Jul 02, 2024
Priority
Jan 07, 2022 — nonprovisional of PCTJP2022000414
Examiner
BAIG, ADNAN
Art Unit
Tech Center
Assignee
Nippon Telegraph and Telephone Corporation
OA Round
1 (Non-Final)
69%
Grant Probability
Favorable
1-2
OA Rounds
1y 4m
Est. Remaining
94%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants 69% — above average
69%
Career Allowance Rate
387 granted / 563 resolved
+8.7% vs TC avg
Strong +25% interview lift
Without
With
+25.3%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
3y 4m
Avg Prosecution
36 currently pending
Career history
622
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
0.8%
-39.2% vs TC avg
§103
92.5%
+52.5% vs TC avg
§102
2.6%
-37.4% vs TC avg
§112
2.4%
-37.6% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 563 resolved cases

Office Action

§102
DETAILED ACTION Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 102 The following is a quotation of the appropriate paragraphs of 35 U.S.C. 102 that form the basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action: A person shall be entitled to a patent unless – (a)(2) the claimed invention was described in a patent issued under section 151, or in an application for patent published or deemed published under section 122(b), in which the patent or application, as the case may be, names another inventor and was effectively filed before the effective filing date of the claimed invention. Claims 7-10 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(2) as being anticipated by Yuan et al. US (2024/0214172). Regarding Claim 7, Yuan discloses a terminal (see Fig. 2 i.e., UE 115-a & Fig. 7) comprising: a receiver (see Fig. 7 i.e., transceiver 715) that receives a Medium Access Control Control Element (MAC CE) (see Figures 4-5 i.e., MAC CE) indicating activation of a plurality of Transmission Configuration Indication (TCI) states applicable to a plurality of types of channels; (see Figures 4-5 & Para’s [0075] i.e., The UE 115-a may receive a MAC-CE from the BS 105-a associated with the configuration of TCI states, where the MAC-CE may activate a subset of configured TCI states for the TCI codepoint in DCI, [0076] i.e., TCI states applicable to downlink channel types such as PDCCH, PDSCH and uplink channel types such as PUSCH, PUCCH, [0092] i.e., The TRP may transmit the MAC-CE 400 indicating activated TCI states and TCI state types, [0096] & [0099-0102] i.e., MAC-CE 500 including bitmap 505 and the bitmap 510 indicate which TCI states (e.g., such as downlink TCI states and uplink TCI states) are activated & [0106] i.e., At 610, the BS 105-b may transmit a MAC-CE message to the UE 115-b indicating which TCI states, as indicated by the RRC message at 605, are activated) and a processor (see Fig. 7 i.e., processor 740 & Para’s [0115-0118]) that determines, based on a first field (see Fig. 5 i.e., first bitmap 505 may be interpreted as the claimed “first field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., C0 field 420 may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “first field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0096] i.e., For example, a field 420 may include a first bit (C0, C1, up to Cn). The bit in a field 420 may indicate whether a second octet including a second TCI state or a pair of TCI states is present in the MAC-CE 400…In some implementations, the field 420 in the codepoint 435 may indicate a pair of TCI states. That is, the codepoint 435 may identify a first TCI state and a corresponding first TCI state type, and a second TCI state and a corresponding second TCI state type & [0099-0103] i.e., The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510) and a second field that are included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., second bitmap 510 may be interpreted as the claimed “second field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., the entire D/U field (e.g., 425, 440) may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “second field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., 1 bit in field 425 and 1 bit in field 440 (e.g., D/U field) indicate which list TCI state ID01 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) and which list TCI state ID02 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”)) a number of Downlink (DL) TCI states mapped to a codepoint (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of DL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 DL TCI state ID1 or 1 DL TCI state ID4) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 505 for DL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) of a TCI field indicated by Downlink Control Information (DCI) (see Para’s [0075] i.e., the UE may receive a DCI with a TCI codepoint (i.e., “TCI field”) selecting TCI states from the activated TCI states , [0090], [0098] i.e., the UE may then receive a DCI selecting one or more of the activated TCI states, & [0104] i.e., upon receiving a DCI indicating one of the activated TCI states), a number of Uplink (UL) TCI states mapped to the codepoint, (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of UL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 UL TCI state ID4 or 1 UL TCI state ID14) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 510 for UL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) and order of one or more TCI state ID fields included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., UE determines based on the MAC-CE, an order of one or more TCI state ID fields such as DL TCI state ID1, UL TCI state ID4 mapped to TCI codepoint 0 based on order of TCI types (e.g., in order of downlink and uplink TCI states) & [0096] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint may be mapped in a default order of TCI types. For example, when the field 420 for the TCI codepoint 435 is set to 1, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint 435 may be mapped to DL TCI state and UL TCI state, respectively & [0103]) Regarding Claim 8, Yuan discloses a radio communication method for a terminal (see Fig. 2 i.e., UE 115-a & Fig. 7), comprising: receiving a Medium Access Control Control Element (MAC CE) (see Figures 4-5 i.e., MAC CE) indicating activation of a plurality of Transmission Configuration Indication (TCI) states applicable to a plurality of types of channels; (see Figures 4-5 & Para’s [0075] i.e., The UE 115-a may receive a MAC-CE from the BS 105-a associated with the configuration of TCI states, where the MAC-CE may activate a subset of configured TCI states for the TCI codepoint in DCI, [0076] i.e., TCI states applicable to downlink channel types such as PDCCH, PDSCH and uplink channel types such as PUSCH, PUCCH, [0092] i.e., The TRP may transmit the MAC-CE 400 indicating activated TCI states and TCI state types, [0096] & [0099-0102] i.e., MAC-CE 500 including bitmap 505 and the bitmap 510 indicate which TCI states (e.g., such as downlink TCI states and uplink TCI states) are activated & [0106] i.e., At 610, the BS 105-b may transmit a MAC-CE message to the UE 115-b indicating which TCI states, as indicated by the RRC message at 605, are activated) And determining, based on a first field (see Fig. 5 i.e., first bitmap 505 may be interpreted as the claimed “first field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., C0 field 420 may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “first field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0096] i.e., For example, a field 420 may include a first bit (C0, C1, up to Cn). The bit in a field 420 may indicate whether a second octet including a second TCI state or a pair of TCI states is present in the MAC-CE 400…In some implementations, the field 420 in the codepoint 435 may indicate a pair of TCI states. That is, the codepoint 435 may identify a first TCI state and a corresponding first TCI state type, and a second TCI state and a corresponding second TCI state type & [0099-0103] i.e., The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510) and a second field that are included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., second bitmap 510 may be interpreted as the claimed “second field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., the entire D/U field (e.g., 425, 440) may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “second field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., 1 bit in field 425 and 1 bit in field 440 (e.g., D/U field) indicate which list TCI state ID01 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) and which list TCI state ID02 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”)) a number of Downlink (DL) TCI states mapped to a codepoint (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of DL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 DL TCI state ID1 or 1 DL TCI state ID4) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 505 for DL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) of a TCI field indicated by Downlink Control Information (DCI) (see Para’s [0075] i.e., the UE may receive a DCI with a TCI codepoint (i.e., “TCI field”) selecting TCI states from the activated TCI states , [0090], [0098] i.e., the UE may then receive a DCI selecting one or more of the activated TCI states, & [0104] i.e., upon receiving a DCI indicating one of the activated TCI states), a number of Uplink (UL) TCI states mapped to the codepoint, (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of UL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 UL TCI state ID4 or 1 UL TCI state ID14) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 510 for UL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) and order of one or more TCI state ID fields included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., UE determines based on the MAC-CE, an order of one or more TCI state ID fields such as DL TCI state ID1, UL TCI state ID4 mapped to TCI codepoint 0 based on order of TCI types (e.g., in order of downlink and uplink TCI states) & [0096] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint may be mapped in a default order of TCI types. For example, when the field 420 for the TCI codepoint 435 is set to 1, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint 435 may be mapped to DL TCI state and UL TCI state, respectively & [0103]) Regarding Claim 9, Yuan discloses a base station (see Fig. 2 i.e., base station 105-a & Fig. 8 & Para’s [0074-0075] & [0125]) comprising: a transmitter (see Fig. 8 i.e., transceiver 815 & Para’s [0121] & [0125-0126]) that transmits a Medium Access Control Control Element (MAC CE) (see Figures 4-5 i.e., MAC CE) indicating activation of a plurality of Transmission Configuration Indication (TCI) states applicable to a plurality of types of channels, (see Figures 4-5 & Para’s [0075] i.e., The UE 115-a may receive a MAC-CE from the BS 105-a associated with the configuration of TCI states, where the MAC-CE may activate a subset of configured TCI states for the TCI codepoint in DCI, [0076] i.e., TCI states applicable to downlink channel types such as PDCCH, PDSCH and uplink channel types such as PUSCH, PUCCH, [0092] i.e., The TRP may transmit the MAC-CE 400 indicating activated TCI states and TCI state types, [0096] & [0099-0102] i.e., MAC-CE 500 including bitmap 505 and the bitmap 510 indicate which TCI states (e.g., such as downlink TCI states and uplink TCI states) are activated, [0106] i.e., At 610, the BS 105-b may transmit a MAC-CE message to the UE 115-b indicating which TCI states, as indicated by the RRC message at 605, are activated & [0125]) and a processor (see Fig. 8 i.e., processor 840 & Para’s [0122-0123] & [0126]) that indicates, using a first field (see Fig. 5 i.e., first bitmap 505 may be interpreted as the claimed “first field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., C0 field 420 may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “first field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0096] i.e., For example, a field 420 may include a first bit (C0, C1, up to Cn). The bit in a field 420 may indicate whether a second octet including a second TCI state or a pair of TCI states is present in the MAC-CE 400…In some implementations, the field 420 in the codepoint 435 may indicate a pair of TCI states. That is, the codepoint 435 may identify a first TCI state and a corresponding first TCI state type, and a second TCI state and a corresponding second TCI state type & [0099-0103] i.e., The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510) and a second field that are included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., second bitmap 510 may be interpreted as the claimed “second field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., the entire D/U field (e.g., 425, 440) may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “second field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., 1 bit in field 425 and 1 bit in field 440 (e.g., D/U field) indicate which list TCI state ID01 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) and which list TCI state ID02 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”)) a number of Downlink (DL) TCI states mapped to a codepoint (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of DL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 DL TCI state ID1 or 1 DL TCI state ID4) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 505 for DL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) of a TCI field indicated by Downlink Control Information (DCI), (see Para’s [0075] i.e., the UE may receive a DCI with a TCI codepoint (i.e., “TCI field”) selecting TCI states from the activated TCI states, [0090], [0098] i.e., the UE may then receive a DCI selecting one or more of the activated TCI states, & [0104] i.e., upon receiving a DCI indicating one of the activated TCI states), a number of Uplink (UL) TCI states mapped to the codepoint, (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of UL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 UL TCI state ID4 or 1 UL TCI state ID14) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 510 for UL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) and order of one or more TCI state ID fields included in the MAC CE. (see Fig. 5 i.e., UE determines based on the MAC-CE, an order of one or more TCI state ID fields such as DL TCI state ID1, UL TCI state ID4 mapped to TCI codepoint 0 based on order of TCI types (e.g., in order of downlink and uplink TCI states) & [0096] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint may be mapped in a default order of TCI types. For example, when the field 420 for the TCI codepoint 435 is set to 1, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint 435 may be mapped to DL TCI state and UL TCI state, respectively & [0103]) Regarding Claim 10, Yuan discloses a system (see Figures 1-2 & Para’s [0030] & [0074]) comprising a terminal (see Fig. 2 i.e., UE 115-a & Fig. 7) and a base station (see Fig. 2 i.e., base station 105-a & Fig. 8 & Para’s [0074-0075] & [0125]), wherein the terminal comprises: a receiver (see Fig. 7 i.e., transceiver 715) that receives a Medium Access Control Control Element (MAC CE) (see Figures 4-5 i.e., MAC CE) indicating activation of a plurality of Transmission Configuration Indication (TCI) states applicable to a plurality of types of channels; (see Figures 4-5 & Para’s [0075] i.e., The UE 115-a may receive a MAC-CE from the BS 105-a associated with the configuration of TCI states, where the MAC-CE may activate a subset of configured TCI states for the TCI codepoint in DCI, [0076] i.e., TCI states applicable to downlink channel types such as PDCCH, PDSCH and uplink channel types such as PUSCH, PUCCH, [0092] i.e., The TRP may transmit the MAC-CE 400 indicating activated TCI states and TCI state types, [0096] & [0099-0102] i.e., MAC-CE 500 including bitmap 505 and the bitmap 510 indicate which TCI states (e.g., such as downlink TCI states and uplink TCI states) are activated & [0106] i.e., At 610, the BS 105-b may transmit a MAC-CE message to the UE 115-b indicating which TCI states, as indicated by the RRC message at 605, are activated) and a processor (see Fig. 7 i.e., processor 740 & Para’s [0115-0118]) that determines, based on a first field (see Fig. 5 i.e., first bitmap 505 may be interpreted as the claimed “first field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., C0 field 420 may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “first field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0096] i.e., For example, a field 420 may include a first bit (C0, C1, up to Cn). The bit in a field 420 may indicate whether a second octet including a second TCI state or a pair of TCI states is present in the MAC-CE 400…In some implementations, the field 420 in the codepoint 435 may indicate a pair of TCI states. That is, the codepoint 435 may identify a first TCI state and a corresponding first TCI state type, and a second TCI state and a corresponding second TCI state type & [0099-0103] i.e., The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510) and a second field that are included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., second bitmap 510 may be interpreted as the claimed “second field” included in the MAC-CE & Fig. 4 i.e., the entire D/U field (e.g., 425, 440) may also be interpreted alternatively as the claimed “second field” in the MAC-CE & Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., 1 bit in field 425 and 1 bit in field 440 (e.g., D/U field) indicate which list TCI state ID01 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) and which list TCI state ID02 corresponds to (i.e., determines uplink or downlink TCI state type) & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”)) a number of Downlink (DL) TCI states mapped to a codepoint (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of DL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 DL TCI state ID1 or 1 DL TCI state ID4) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 505 for DL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) of a TCI field indicated by Downlink Control Information (DCI) (see Para’s [0075] i.e., the UE may receive a DCI with a TCI codepoint (i.e., “TCI field”) selecting TCI states from the activated TCI states , [0090], [0098] i.e., the UE may then receive a DCI selecting one or more of the activated TCI states, & [0104] i.e., upon receiving a DCI indicating one of the activated TCI states), a number of Uplink (UL) TCI states mapped to the codepoint, (see Fig. 5 i.e., the UE may determine a number of UL TCI states (e.g., such as 1 UL TCI state ID4 or 1 UL TCI state ID14) mapped to either TCI codepoint 0 or TCI codepoint 1 based on the bitmap 510 for UL TCI states, Para’s [0093-0097] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE & [0099-0103] i.e., That is, the first bitmap 505 may correspond to a first subset of TCI states, which may correspond to downlink TCI states, while the second bitmap 510 may correspond to a second subset of TCI states, which may correspond to uplink TCI states… The base station may transmit MAC-CE 500 to the UE. The MAC-CE 500 may include the bitmap 505 (i.e., “first field”) and the bitmap 510 (i.e., “second field”))…Each codepoint may include one or two bits, mapped from the activated bits in order. For example, the first activated bit in ascending order for the first bitmap 505 (such as T1) and the first activated bit in ascending order for the second bitmap 510 (such as T4) may be included in TCI codepoint 0. Thus, TCI codepoint 0 may include bits T1 of the first bitmap 505 and T4 of the second bitmap 510. TCI codepoint 0 may therefore indicate DL TCI state ID 1 (from the first list) and UL TCI state ID4 (from the second list)) and order of one or more TCI state ID fields included in the MAC CE, (see Fig. 5 i.e., UE determines based on the MAC-CE, an order of one or more TCI state ID fields such as DL TCI state ID1, UL TCI state ID4 mapped to TCI codepoint 0 based on order of TCI types (e.g., in order of downlink and uplink TCI states) & [0096] i.e., if there are a pair of DL and UL TCI states activated in a TCI codepoint by the MAC-CE, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint may be mapped in a default order of TCI types. For example, when the field 420 for the TCI codepoint 435 is set to 1, the first octet and the second octet for the TCI codepoint 435 may be mapped to DL TCI state and UL TCI state, respectively & [0103]) and the base station comprises: a transmitter (see Fig. 8 i.e., transceiver 815 & Para’s [0121] & [0125-0126]) that transmits the MAC CE, (see Figures 4-5 i.e., MAC CE & Para’s [0075], [0106] & [0125]) Conclusion Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to ADNAN A BAIG whose telephone number is (571)270-7511. The examiner can normally be reached M-F 9:00am-5:00pm. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Huy Vu can be reached at 571-272-3155. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /ADNAN BAIG/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2461
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Jul 02, 2024
Application Filed
Jul 09, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §102 (current)

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12666466
REDUCED CONTROL CHANNEL MONITORING FOR RANDOM ACCESS PROCEDURES
3y 1m to grant Granted Jun 23, 2026
Patent 12647748
METHODS, APPARATUSES AND SYSTEMS DIRECTED TO QUALITY OF EXPERIENCE DATA ANALYTICS FOR MULTIPLE WIRELESS TRANSMIT AND RECEIVE UNITS
4y 2m to grant Granted Jun 02, 2026
Patent 12634752
ENHANCED BLOCK FLOATING POINT COMPRESSION FOR OPEN RADIO ACCESS NETWORK FRONTHAUL
3y 6m to grant Granted May 19, 2026
Patent 12633975
METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR PERFORMING MULTIPLE-USER MULTIPLE-INPUT MULTIPLE-OUTPUT COMMUNICATION, AND NON-TRANSITORY COMPUTER READABLE STORAGE MEDIUM
3y 0m to grant Granted May 19, 2026
Patent 12627331
GAIN ADAPTATION FOR DOWNSTREAM VECTORING SYSTEMS
4y 4m to grant Granted May 12, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 5 most recent grants.

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

1-2
Expected OA Rounds
69%
Grant Probability
94%
With Interview (+25.3%)
3y 4m (~1y 4m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
Low
PTA Risk
Based on 563 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month