DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Continued Examination Under 37 CFR 1.114
A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114. Applicant's submission filed on August 17, 2026 has been entered.
Status of Claims
This office action is in response to arguments and amendments entered on August 17, 2026 for the patent application 18/767,799 originally filed on July 9, 2024. Claims 1, 2, 4, 11-13, 19 and 20 are amended. Claims 1-20 are pending. The first office action of March 10, 2026 and the second office action of May 15, 2026 are fully incorporated by reference into this Final Office Action.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
Claims rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 112(a)
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
Claims 12-18 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention.
Claim 18 recites the following limitations: “first logic,” “second logic,” and “third logic.” Specifically, these limitations are not adequately described in the specification as originally filed and forms the basis of the rejection. As such, the limitations are reasonably rejected under a theory of new matter. Therefore, claim 18 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 112(a), as failing to comply with the written description requirement.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. § 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 101 because the claimed invention is directed to a judicial exception (i.e., a law of nature, a natural phenomenon, or an abstract idea) without significantly more.
Step 1 – “Statutory Category Identification”
Claim 1 is directed to “a method” (i.e. a process), claim 12 is directed to “an automated online proctoring system” (i.e. a machine), and claim 19 is directed to “a computer program product” (i.e. a machine), hence the claims are directed to one of the four statutory categories (i.e. process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter). In other words, Step 1 of the subject-matter eligibility analysis is “Yes.”
Step 2A, Prong 1 “Abstract Idea Identification”
However, the claims are drawn to an abstract idea of “online proctoring,” in the form of “certain methods of organizing human activity,” in terms of managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (including social activities, teaching and following rules or instructions), or reasonably in the form of “mental processes,” in terms of processes that can be performed in the human mind (including an observation, evaluation, judgement or opinion). Regardless, the claims are reasonably understood as either “certain methods of organizing human activity” or “mental processes,” which require the following limitations:
Per claim 1:
“training one or more AI models using predefined training data;
receiving inputs corresponding to a student typing on a keyboard and/or manipulating a computer mouse;
receiving eye-tracking information corresponding to movements of the student's eyes;
using the one or more AI models in an AI system to evaluate the received inputs and eye-tracking information, and calculate a trust score indicative of academic integrity; and
using the AI system to automatically generate and display output containing real time guidance on a computer screen during a test for improving a submission input by the student during the test.”
Per claim 12:
“a facial recognition module configured to identify a human student by analyzing an image of the student captured by a camera coupled to a computer being used by the student, and comparing the image to a stored photograph of the student;
a lockdown test monitor module configured to, in response to initiation of a test, prevent the student from viewing material on a computer screen that is outside of a test display being displayed on the computer screen by locking at least some output to the computer screen while the test is being administered; and
an AI system configured to:
train one or more AI models using predefined training data, receive inputs corresponding to the student typing on a keyboard and/or manipulating a computer mouse integrated with the computer screen,
receive eye-tracking information corresponding to movements of the student's eyes,
evaluate the received inputs and eye-tracking information,
calculate a trust score that characterizes an authenticity and originality of a submission by the student during the test, and
automatically generate and display output containing real time guidance on a computer screen during the test for improving a submission input by the student during the test.”
Per claim 19:
“training one or more AI models using predefined training data;
receiving inputs corresponding to a student typing on a keyboard and/or manipulating a computer mouse;
receiving eye-tracking information corresponding to movements of the student's eyes;
using an AI system to evaluate the received inputs and eye-tracking information, and calculate a trust score indicative of academic integrity; and
using the AI system to automatically generate and display output containing real time guidance on a computer screen during a test for improving a submission input by the student during the test.”
These limitations simply describe a process of data gathering and manipulation, which is partially analogous to “collecting information, analyzing it, and displaying certain results of the collection analysis” (i.e. Electric Power Group, LLC, v. Alstom, 830 F.3d 1350, 119 U.S.P.Q.2d 1739 (Fed. Cir. 2016)). Hence, these limitations are akin to an abstract idea which has been identified among non-limiting examples to be an abstract idea. In other words, Step 2A, Prong 1 of the subject-matter eligibility analysis is “Yes.”
Step 2A, Prong 2 – “Practical Application”
Furthermore, the claims do not include additional elements that either alone or in combination are sufficient to claim a practical application because to the extent that, e.g., “one or more AI models,” “an AI system,” “a computer,” “a keyboard,” “a computer mouse,” “a computer screen,” and “a camera,” are claimed, as these are merely claimed to generally link the use of a judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use. In other words, the claimed “online proctoring,” is not providing a practical application, thus Step 2A, Prong 2 of the subject-matter eligibility analysis is “No.”
Step 2B – “Significantly More”
Likewise, the claims do not include additional elements that either alone or in combination are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception because to the extent that, e.g. “one or more AI models,” “an AI system,” “a computer,” “a keyboard,” “a computer mouse,” “a computer screen,” and “a camera,” are claimed, these are generic, well-known, and conventional elements. As evidence that these are generic, well-known, and a conventional elements (or an equivalent term), as a commercially available product, or in a manner that indicates that the additional elements are sufficiently well-known, the Applicant’s specification discloses these in a manner that indicates that the additional elements are sufficiently well-known that the specification does not need to describe the particulars of such additional elements to satisfy 35 U.S.C. § 112(a), per MPEP § 2106.07(a) III (a). As such, this satisfies the Examiner’s evidentiary burden requirement per the Berkheimer memo.
Moreover, the element of “one or more AI models,” is described in paras. [0025], [0029] and [0064] as follows:
“[0025] Each AI model used in various approaches may be trained on predefined training data according to known training techniques to enable the AI model to provide the corresponding functionality. The AI training data may be any data suitable for training the corresponding AI model for its intended purpose, as would become apparent to one skilled in the art after reading the present disclosure.”
“[0029] Machine learning models undergo rigorous development, testing, and validation phases to ensure accuracy and reliability in detecting academic misconduct. Training data, labeled by educators, are used to refine and improve the models continuously. The integration of AI models, such as GPT-4 or the like, further enhances the system's capabilities in providing personalized assistance and feedback to students. Various exemplary embodiments will now be described.”
“[0064] AI Assistance: The system incorporates AI assistance powered by advanced, publicly available, large language models (LLM), typically based on the Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) AI methodology, such as Open AI's GPT-4 or Anthropic's Claude Opus, to offer personalized feedback and support to students. Through an intuitive interface, students can engage in a dialogue with the AI, receiving guidance and suggestions without compromising academic autonomy.”
These elements are reasonably interpreted as known software techniques as part of a generic computer which provides no details of anything beyond ubiquitous standard off-the-shelf equipment utilizing commercially available software.
Likewise, the elements of “an AI system,” “a computer,” “a keyboard,” “a computer mouse,” “a computer screen,” and “a camera,” are described in paras. [0021], [0023], [0024] [0064] and [0082] as follows:
“[0023] The AI system may have at least one AI model trained to perform a respective portion or all of the functionality disclosed herein. The AI system may also include hardware components, such as a computer for running the AI modules such as a server, network server, etc., and/or particular hardware and/or software modules of said computer; a computer on which the test is taken and/or particular hardware and/or software modules of said computer; etc. See, e.g., FIGS. 2-3, which are described in more detail below. Accordingly, an AI system may have multiple AI modules that provide independent, overlapping, cooperating, and/or pipelined functionality. For example, one AI model may be used to perform a particular function, such as eye movement tracking, while another AI model performs the functions to generate the guidance. Moreover, an AI system may include a computer that runs the AI model(s), where said computer is in communication with the computer on which the test is being taken, e.g., via a network.”
“[0024] Any known AI platform or set of platforms may be used, and integrated to create the automated online proctoring system that implements the method 100.”
“[0064] AI Assistance: The system incorporates AI assistance powered by advanced, publicly available, large language models (LLM), typically based on the Generative Pretrained Transformer (GPT) AI methodology, such as Open AI's GPT-4 or Anthropic's Claude Opus, to offer personalized feedback and support to students. Through an intuitive interface, students can engage in a dialogue with the AI, receiving guidance and suggestions without compromising academic autonomy.”
“[0082] The workstation shown in FIG. 3 includes a Random Access Memory (RAM) 314, Read Only Memory (ROM) 316, and I/O adapter 318 for connecting peripheral devices such as disk storage units 320 to the bus 312, a user interface adapter 322 for connecting a keyboard 324, a mouse 326, a speaker 328, a microphone 332, and/or other user interface devices such as a touch screen and a digital camera (not shown) to the bus 312, communication adapter 334 for connecting the workstation to a communication network 335 (e.g., a data processing network) and a display adapter 336 for connecting the bus 312 to a display device 338.”
These elements are reasonably interpreted as part of a generic computer having generic computer components which provides no details of anything beyond ubiquitous standard off-the-shelf equipment utilizing commercially available software.
Therefore, the Applicant’s own specification discloses ubiquitous standard equipment that is (1) generic, routine, conventional, and/or commercially available; and (2) does not provide anything significantly more. Thus, Step 2B, of the subject-matter eligibility analysis is “No.”
In addition, dependent claims 2-11, 13-18 and 20 do not provide a practical application and are insufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception. As such, dependent claims 2-11, 13-18 and 20 are also rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 101, based on their respective dependencies to claim 1, 12 or 19. Therefore, claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 101 as being directed to non-statutory subject matter.
Response to Arguments
The Applicant’s arguments filed on August 17, 2026 related to claims 1-20 are fully considered, but are not persuasive.
Claim Interpretation
The Applicant’s arguments are moot in view of the amendments entered. Therefore, the argument is persuasive and the 35 U.S.C. §112(f) invocation is withdrawn.
Rejections under 35 U.S.C. § 112
The Applicant’s arguments with regard to claim 12 are moot in view of the amendments entered. Therefore, the 35 U.S.C. §112(a) rejection of claim 12 is withdrawn.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Finally, regarding the allegation that the "logic" of claim 18 is new matter, Applicant respectfully disagrees and refers to 0074 and 0087 of the present application, which provides a more-than-adequate description of what the logic can be.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. Claim 18 recites the following limitations: “first logic,” “second logic,” and “third logic.” Paras. [0074] and [0087] do not disclose “first logic,” “second logic,” or “third logic.” In fact, the word “logic” is not found in paras. [0074] and [0087]. At best, para. [0084] describes “hardware logic” and “software logic.” Even if these forms of logic equate to “first logic,” and “second logic,” the claimed “third logic” remains as subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention. As such, the argument is not persuasive. Therefore, the 35 U.S.C. §112(a) rejection of claim 18 is not withdrawn.
Rejections under 35 U.S.C. § 101
The Applicant respectfully argues “As in Ex parte Desjardins, the embodiments claimed in the present application do in fact improve the functioning of a computer. Reference is first made to 0003-0004 of the present application, which state:
"The digital transformation of the educational sector, though being a significant boon to universal access to education, has simultaneously posed notable challenges. Among these, ensuring academic integrity and the legitimacy of students' work in remote learning environments has become paramount. Contemporary online proctoring solutions offer limited efficacy, thereby underscoring the necessity for an evolved, comprehensive system that amalgamates robust verification of academic honesty with facilitating a conducive learning environment.
Moreover, in the rapidly evolving landscape of digital education, traditional online proctoring solutions often fall short in providing comprehensive support to students who struggle with initiating and structuring their written work, which can inadvertently drive them towards academic dishonesty."
The embodiments claimed remedy this problem, meet this need, for improved operational capabilities of a computer. 0005 of the present application notes that:
"A method for automated online proctoring, in accordance with one embodiment, includes using an AI system to consider monitored aspects of activities of a student taking a test to calculate a trust score indicative of academic integrity, the aspects including at least user interaction with one or more input devices, and eye movements of the student. The AI system is used to provide guidance to the student during the test for improving a submission input by the student during the test."
See also 0022 and 0026 of the present application. Moreover, the methodology of claim 1 trains and implements AI models specifically to fuse hardware inputs into an integrated algorithmic output (the trust score), representing a distinct software architecture improvement.
Following Director Squires' lead, Applicant respectfully requests that the Examiner not use section 101 as a blunt instrument to exclude entire technological fields, but rather consider how the claimed embodiments improve the functioning of a computer.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. The Applicant’s argument points to a human element of education. No advancement in the functioning of a computer is present. As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Applicant also notes that the thrust of the rejections under 35 USC 101 revolve around "mental processes."
Under MPEP § 2106, a method of organizing human activity involves fundamental economic practices, commercial interactions, or basic human behaviors that can be performed via mental steps or pen and paper. Claim 1 does not recite any such abstract concept.
Instead, Claim 1 recites a highly technical process requiring the integration of real-time computer hardware signals. Specifically, the method requires "receiving inputs corresponding to a student typing on a keyboard and/or manipulating a computer mouse" and "receiving eye-tracking information corresponding to movements of the student's eyes." A human proctor cannot intercept low-level hardware interrupt signals from an input device, nor can a human physically map and track the coordinate vectors of a student's pupils in real-time. Because these steps require specialized hardware capture and sub-second digital processing, they cannot be performed "in the human mind," removing them from the category of abstract human activities.
To further elaborate, the claims cannot be practically performed in the human mind. According to USPTO guidance, claim limitations that cannot practically be executed in a human mind fall completely outside the "mental process" category of abstract ideas. See the USPTO's August 2025 memorandum² on patent subject matter eligibility.
Claim 1, as exemplary and particularly as amended, requires "training one or more AI models using predefined training data." However, training an AI model cannot practically be performed in the human mind because it requires specialized machine-based calculations over massive datasets.
It is a practical impossibility for a human mind to train an AI model, especially for the purposes recited in the claim. Illustrative training requires multi-dimensional matrix multiplications across millions or billions of parameters simultaneously. The human mind simply cannot perform all of the calculations necessary to train one or more AI models.
In addition, training at least one AI model is not a generic thinking step; it is an operation that requires physical computer hardware to function. For instance, training relies on processing vast streams of data, such as real-time pattern recognition across huge digital datasets.
Moreover, claim 1 is directed to a specialized, automated computer-vision and physical-interface monitoring paradigm. It cannot be performed "in the human mind" or with "pen and paper" because it requires the real-time collection, synchronization, and algorithmic processing of continuous, machine-generated digital data streams (keyboard/mouse hardware interrupts and physical eye-tracking sensor data).
Furthermore, the system provides automated feedback to modify an ongoing submission during a test, a real-time responsive mechanism that is practically impossible for human cognitive faculties to perform. The claim requires "receiving inputs corresponding to a student typing on a keyboard and/or manipulating a computer mouse" and "receiving eye-tracking information". A human mind cannot receive or parse electrical hardware interrupts from a computer peripheral, nor can a human mind natively capture and digitize eye-tracking telemetry, much less in a manner usable as real-time input to an AI system that is providing guidance back to the student”.
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. With respect to mental processes, actual mental performance of the abstract idea is not required. Further, the MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(III)(C) states that “claims can recite a mental process even if they are claimed as being performed on a computer” and that “examiners should review the specification to determine if the claimed invention is described as a concept that is performed in the human mind and Applicant is merely claiming that concept performed 1) on a generic computer, or 2) in a computer environment, or 3) is merely using a computer as a tool to perform the concept. In these situations, the claim is considered to recite “a mental process.” In the present case, the claim limitations perform steps that are performed on a generic computer and/or computer environment, and merely uses a computer as a tool to perform the concept of “proctoring,” which has been done in the analog by teachers, professors and instructors for decades if not centuries. As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Applicant also respectfully submits that the claims do not recite a judicial exception, and therefore should be deemed as eligible subject matter, e.g., as outlined by Example 39 of "July 2024 Subject Matter Eligibility Examples" (referred to herein as the "Subject Matter Eligibility Examples"). There, Example 39 pertains to a method of training a model to perform facial detection, and provides valuable guidance on how claims, like claims 1, 12, and 19, should be evaluated with respect to subject matter eligibility. More specifically, Applicant submits that the limitations recited in claims 1, 12, and 19 are eligible "because [they do] not recite a judicial exception." See Step 2A-Prong 1 as shown on p. 9 of the Subject Matter Eligibility Examples.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. Although “the examples” consist of hypothetical cases that may parallel Supreme Court decisions and Federal Circuit decisions, the examples are not considered precedential and are not fully considered as binding precedent on the USPTO. That being said, the Applicant’s argument with regard to “Example 39” does not super cede the Examiner’s subject-matter eligibility analysis using precedential Supreme Court decisions and Federal Circuit decisions. As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Following the reasoning provided in Example 39, Applicant notes that the present claims 1, 12, and 19 do not recite any mathematical relationships, formulas, or calculations. For instance, Example 39 explains that "[w]hile some of the limitations may be based on mathematical concepts, the mathematical concepts are not recited in the claims." Applicant respectfully submits that the same is true here. Looking to claims 1, 12, and 19, some of the limitations recited therein involve obtaining the digital form of physical movements that are made by a student, evaluating the digital information using an AI system, and then using the evaluated digital information to calculate a trust score. Claim 11 (which depends from claim 1) has also been amended to include limitations therein that involve updating training data based on feedback received from educators, and using the updated training data to re-train the AI system. While some of these points may arguably be based on mathematical concepts, the mathematical concepts themselves are not recited in the claims. It follows that the claims do not recite any mathematical judicial exceptions.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. The 35 U.S.C. §101 rejection never mentions any mathematical judicial exceptions. However, the rejection cites the following judicial exceptions: “certain methods of organizing human activity,” in terms of managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (including social activities, teaching and following rules or instructions), and/or “mental processes,” in terms of processes that can be performed in the human mind (including an observation, evaluation, judgement or opinion). As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Furthermore, while the rejection has alleged that the claims are "directed to an abstract idea without significantly more," Applicant respectfully submits that the claims as presently presented overcome any subject matter eligibility based rejections, for reasons similar to why Example 39 of the Subject Matter Eligibility Examples includes subject matter eligible claims.
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. The Applicant’s claims do not include additional elements that either alone or in combination are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception because to the extent that, e.g. “one or more AI models,” “an AI system,” “a computer,” “a keyboard,” “a computer mouse,” “a computer screen,” and “a camera,” are claimed, these are generic, well-known, and conventional elements, as previously discussed above in the rejection. Therefore, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully continues to argue “Again, the limitations recited in each of claims 1, 12, and 19 involve obtaining the digital form of physical movements that are made by a student, evaluating the digital information using an AI system, and then using the evaluated digital information to calculate a trust score. The claims thereby include similar functionality to that of the allowable claims in Example 39. There, the USPTO provides that "Applicant's invention addresses this issue by using a combination of features to more robustly detect human faces. The first feature is the use of an expanded training set of facial images to train the neural network. This expanded training set is developed by applying mathematical transformation functions on an acquired set of facial images. These transformations can include affine transformations, for example, rotating, shifting, or mirroring or filtering transformations, for example, smoothing or contrast reduction. The neural networks are then trained with this expanded training set using stochastic learning with backpropagation which is a type of machine learning algorithm that uses the gradient of a mathematical loss function to adjust the weights of the network." (Excerpt from Example 39, emphasis added).”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. The arguments with regard to Example 39 have been asked, answered and continue to be unpersuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Applicant thereby submits that claims 1, 12, and 19 do not recite a mental process and cannot be considered "abstract ideas" either. As outlined in Example 39 of the Subject Matter Eligibility Examples, evaluating digital data is not something that can be performed "in the human mind", much less using the evaluated digital data to train a model. In other words, the steps recited in the claims have been explicitly classified in the Subject Matter Eligibility Examples as not including abstract ideas. Returning again to Example 39, the USPTO explains that the sample "claim does not recite a mental process because the steps are not practically performed in the human mind." (emphasis added) For instance, the limitations recited in the sample claim of Example 39 include creating information used to train a model (i.e., "creating a first training set" and "creating a second training set"), as well as actually training the model (i.e., "training the [model] in a first stage using the first training set" and "training the [model] in a second stage using the second training set").
In view of the foregoing arguments, it is apparent that claims 1, 12, and 19 "does not recite a mental process because the steps are not practically performed in the human mind." (emphasis added) Again, it is unreasonable to assert that claims 1, 12, and 19 can reasonably be performed in the human mind or done using pen/paper as alleged, because they simply cannot.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. Once again, with respect to mental processes, actual mental performance of the abstract idea is not required, Further, the MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(III)(C) states that “claims can recite a mental process even if they are claimed as being performed on a computer” and that “examiners should review the specification to determine if the claimed invention is described as a concept that is performed in the human mind and Appellant is merely claiming that concept performed 1) on a generic computer, or 2) in a computer environment, or 3) is merely using a computer as a tool to perform the concept. In these situations, the claim is considered to recite a mental process.” In the present case, the claim limitations perform steps that are performed on a generic computer and/or computer environment, and merely uses a computer as a tool to perform the concept. As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Further still, it can be concluded that claims 1, 12, and 19 do not involve organizing human activity. Returning again to Example 39, the USPTO explains that the sample "claim does not recite any method of organizing human activity such as a fundamental economic concept or managing interactions between people." (emphasis added) The same is true looking to the limitations recited in each of claims 1, 12, and 19.
Moreover, claim 1 as exemplary recites "using the AI system to automatically generate and display output containing real time guidance to the student during a test for improving a submission input by the student during the test." Thus the "human" element has been removed from the claim limitation, which is now directed to a pure machine-to- user software architecture interface.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. It is true the Applicant’s claims do not consist of “a fundamental economic concept,” which is listed as an example of “certain methods of organizing human activity.” Instead, the Applicant’s claims have been identified in terms of managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (including social activities, teaching and following rules or instructions). Specifically, “proctoring exams” is clearly on point with managing personal behavior (including teaching and following rules or instructions). The fact that the Applicant is trying to automate the process using generic computers fails to overcome the subject-eligibility analysis. As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “Finally, even if the claim touches upon the concept of exam supervision, it is patent-eligible because it is integrated into a specific "practical application" under USPTO Step 2A (Prong II).”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. First, the argument is conclusory. Second, the Applicant’s argument is misguided as to the proper analysis of a “Practical Application” as required under Step 2A, Prong 2. Specifically, the Applicant’s argument appears to describe claimed utility, which is not the test. Instead, the Applicant’s claims are not considered a “Practical Application,” because the claims do not provide any of the following:
An improvement in the functioning of a computer, or an improvement to other technology or technical field, as discussed in MPEP §§ 2106.04(d)(1) and 2106.05(a);
Applying or using a judicial exception to effect a particular treatment or prophylaxis for a disease or medical condition, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.04(d)(2);
Implementing a judicial exception with, or using a judicial exception in conjunction with, a particular machine or manufacture that is integral to the claim, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(b);
Effecting a transformation or reduction of a particular article to a different state or thing, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(c); and
Applying or using the judicial exception in some other meaningful way beyond generally linking the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment, such that the claim as a whole is more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the exception, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(e).
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
Furthermore, there are also several factors that reasonably explain that the Applicant’s claims are not indicative of integration into a practical application, which include:
Merely reciting the words "apply it" (or an equivalent) with the judicial exception, or merely including instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer, or merely using a computer as a tool to perform an abstract idea, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(f);
Adding insignificant extra-solution activity to the judicial exception, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g); and
Generally linking the use of a judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(h).
PNG
media_image1.png
18
19
media_image1.png
Greyscale
Here, the Applicant’s claims are not providing any technological advancement as described in the first five bulleted factors and, as described above in the rejection, the Applicant’s claims are merely claimed to use a computer as a tool to perform an abstract idea and to generally link the use of a judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use. As such, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “In accordance with the precedential decision in Ex parte Desjardins (Appeal No. 24-000567), claims that combine trained AI models to process complex data sets and improve system feedback loops represent patent-eligible practical applications. Claim 1 specifies:
1. Training one or more AI models using predefined training data;
2. Fusing separate physical data streams (typing, mouse manipulation, and eye-
tracking vectors);
3. Mathematically calculating a real-time "trust score indicative of academic
integrity"; and
4. Dynamically modifying the execution of the test environment by "providing
guidance to the student during a test for improving a submission input."
This is not a passive recording or a set of human administrative rules. It is an active, automated software feedback loop that allows the AI system to dynamically interact with the computer's test-taking application based on biometric telemetry. The combination of these components provides a concrete technological improvement over conventional, passive computer testing environments.
Accordingly, Claim 1 is not directed to an abstract idea and is patent-eligible under 35 U.S.C. § 101. The other pending claims are likewise not directed to an abstract idea for similar reasons.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees. In Ex Parte Desjardins, Appeal No. 2024-000567 (PTAB September 26, 2025, Appeals Review Panel Decision) (precedential), the claimed invention was a method of training a machine learning model on a series of tasks.
In Step 2A Prong Two, the ARP then determined that the specification identified improvements as to how the machine learning model itself operates, including training a machine learning model to learn new tasks while protecting knowledge about previous tasks to overcome the problem of “catastrophic forgetting” encountered in continual learning systems. Importantly, the ARP evaluated the claims as a whole in discerning at least the limitation “adjust the first values of the plurality of parameters to optimize performance of the machine learning model on the second machine learning task while protecting performance of the machine learning model on the first machine learning task” reflected the improvement disclosed in the specification. Accordingly, the claims as a whole integrated what would otherwise be a judicial exception instead into a practical application at Step 2A Prong Two, and therefore the claims were deemed to be outside any specific, enumerated judicial exception (Step 2A: NO).
The courts have not provided an explicit test for this consideration, but have instead illustrated how it is evaluated in numerous decisions. These decisions, and a detailed explanation of how examiners should evaluate this consideration are provided in MPEP § 2106.05(a). In short, first the specification should be evaluated to determine if the disclosure provides sufficient details such that one of ordinary skill in the art would recognize the claimed invention as providing an improvement in the functioning of a computer, or an improvement to other technology or a technical field. The specification need not explicitly set forth the improvement, but it must describe the invention such that the improvement would be apparent to one of ordinary skill in the art. Conversely, if the specification explicitly sets forth an improvement but only in a conclusory manner (i.e., a bare assertion of an improvement without the detail necessary to be apparent to a person of ordinary skill in the art), the examiner should not determine that the claim improves technology or a technical field.
In the present case, the Applicant’s statement “Training one or more AI models using predefined training data,” is set forth in a conclusory manner. In fact, the limitation is at best, poorly described at para. [0025] which provides the following:
“[0025] Each AI model used in various approaches may be trained on predefined training data according to known training techniques to enable the AI model to provide the corresponding functionality. The AI training data may be any data suitable for training the corresponding AI model for its intended purpose, as would become apparent to one skilled in the art after reading the present disclosure.”
As such, the Applicant’s written description is a bare assertion of an improvement without the detail necessary to be apparent to a person of ordinary skill in the art, which fails to improve technology or a technical field. Therefore, the argument is not persuasive.
The Applicant respectfully argues “In conclusion, Applicant respectfully submits that the claims are patent eligible because they do not recite a judicial exception. As discussed above, the present claims do not involve any (i) mathematical relationships, (ii) abstract ideas, or (iii) organizing human activity. Accordingly, Applicant respectfully requests withdrawal of the rejection of claims 1-20 under 35 U.S.C. § 101.”
The Examiner respectfully disagrees, as discussed here and above in the rejection. As such, the argument is not persuasive. Therefore, the rejections under 35 U.S.C. §101 are not withdrawn.
Conclusion
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to ROBERT P. BULLINGTON whose telephone number is (313) 446-4841. The examiner can normally be reached on Monday through Friday from 8 A.M. to 4 P.M. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner's supervisor, Peter Vasat, can be reached on (571) 270-7625. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is (571) 273-8300.
Information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from the Patent Application Information Retrieval (PAIR) system. Status information for published applications may be obtained from either Private PAIR or Public PAIR. Status information for unpublished applications is available through Private PAIR only. For more information about the PAIR system, see http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal. Should you have questions on access to the Private PAIR system, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at (866) 217-9197 (toll-free).
/Robert P Bullington, Esq./ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3715