Prosecution Insights
Last updated: November 13, 2026
Application No. 18/778,323

IMMERSION COOLING SYSTEM

Non-Final OA §103
Filed
Jul 19, 2024
Priority
Jul 27, 2023 — provisional 63/529,194
Examiner
ALVARE, PAUL
Art Unit
3763
Tech Center
3700 — Mechanical Engineering & Manufacturing
Assignee
Modine LLC
OA Round
3 (Non-Final)
58%
Grant Probability
Moderate
3-4
OA Rounds
95%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants 58% of resolved cases
58%
Career Allowance Rate
362 granted / 625 resolved
-12.1% vs TC avg
Strong +37% interview lift
Without
With
+36.7%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
Avg Prosecution
44 currently pending
Career history
675
Total Applications
across all art units

Office Action

§103
DETAILED ACTION Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status: The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Continued Examination Under 37 CFR 1.114 A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114. Applicant's submission filed on 07/21/2026 has been entered. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103 In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status. The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action: A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102 of this title, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made. Claims 1-5 and 21 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Titel et al. (USP 11534703B2), hereinafter referred to as Enright and Titel, respectively. Regarding Claim 1, Enright discloses a cooling system comprising: a sump area (523) configured to hold a dielectric fluid (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300); a bath area configured to receive a computer component (“The tank can include a bath area and a sump area, and the computing device can be immersed in a dielectric fluid in the bath area of the tank”, ¶273), the bath area configured to hold the dielectric fluid (see annotation above); a first filter (see annotation below, referring to a first filter of the parallel filters); a second filter (“The first stage may be a large particle filter located within the bottom of the vessel. The purpose of this filter is to prevent particles which are too large to be handled by the later stages from entering the rest of the system. The second stage may be a medium particulate filter which sits in-line in the piping system between the first and third stage. This second stage medium particulate filter may use a small barrel style filter to remove particulates that were too small to be removed by the first stage filter but still too large to be handled by the third stage filter. The third stage filter may consist of one or more parallel filters with support for various kinds of filter configurations”, underline for emphasis, ¶39); and a pump configured to draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area, pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and the second filter, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300). Although Enright discloses multiple filters being situated in parallel within an immersion cooled system, Enright fails to disclose a pressure sensor configured to determine a pressure-drop across the first filter; and a filter controller including an electronic processor and a memory, wherein the filter controller is configured to compare the pressure-drop received from the pressure sensor to a threshold, wherein in response to the filter controller determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter without user intervention, and wherein in response to the filter controller determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter without user intervention. Titel, also drawn to filter system for a cooler (“Filter systems for food processing systems filter fluid that is used to cook, clean, cool and/or transport food products” (col. 5 ll. 44-45)), teaches a pressure sensor (126-127) configured to determine a pressure-drop across the first filter (“System 100 also includes pressure sensors 126 and 127 (FIGS. 1 and 4-7) to monitor the pressure across filters 107 and 114” (col. 8 ll. 56-58)); and a filter controller (122) including an electronic processor and a memory (“A controller can be located on one or more boards, and can be analog, digital, or both. In the preferred embodiment the controller is a digital controller, such as a PLC, programmed to have the described modules. Digital controller, as used herein, refers to a controller that includes digital logic, including a PLC, and includes the software used by the digital logic” (col. 8 ll.5-12)), wherein the filter controller is configured to compare the pressure-drop received from the pressure sensor to a threshold (805, see figure 8), wherein in response to the filter controller determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter (107) is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the fluid through the first filter (“when module 803 returns a NO, meaning it is not time to purge, module 805 compares the pressure differential to the user set threshold. If the threshold is not crossed, there is no need to purge and the process returns to decision 801”, col. 11 ll. 15-18) and bypass the second filter (114, “The operation of system 100 has been described above with filter 107 being active and filter 114 being off. When filter 114 is active and filter 107 is off system 100 operates in a like fashion. Controller 122 monitors, time, pressures, number of purges, and how purges are triggered, and controls filter 114 and valves 116, 120 and 118 so that filter 114 enters the modes described above (with respect to filter 107)”, col. 9 ll. 67-col. 10 ll. 2) without user intervention (shown in figure 8), and wherein in response to the filter controller determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold (shown in figure 8 being the “Yes” indication of module 805), the filter controller is configured to direct the fluid through the second filter (shown in figure 8 being the modules 806, 808, 810, 812 and 814) and bypass the first filter without user intervention (“At decision point 810 controller 122 determines &filter 114 is available. If filter 114 is available an off module 812 turns off valves 109 and 113”, col. 11 ll. 48-50). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a pressure sensor configured to determine a pressure-drop across the first filter; and a filter controller including an electronic processor and a memory, wherein the filter controller is configured to compare the pressure-drop received from the pressure sensor to a threshold, wherein in response to the filter controller determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter without user intervention, and wherein in response to the filter controller determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter without user intervention, as taught by Titel, the motivation being to provide a “filter system that has the advantages of purging (such as ease of use) and the advantages OF changing to a new filter (robust operation), without the disadvantages of each”, thereby mitigating degradation or failure of systems that require the filtered fluid due to clogging or excessive system pressure. Regarding Claim 2, Enright further discloses the first filter and the second filter (the two parallel filters are previously taught by Titel in the rejection of Claim 1) are positioned in the sump area (shown in figure 10C of Enright, further Enright states “A filter lid can be mounted on top of the sump area. The filter lid can be installed next to other lids which provide access to the bath area”, ¶307). Regarding Claim 3, Enright further discloses a pH sensor fluidly connected to the second filter, wherein the pH sensor is configured to indicate a pH of the dielectric fluid flowing through the second filter (“the filter can include a stripe for testing acidity of the dielectric fluid. The stripe can be a PH indicator, litmus paper or other indicator”, ¶306). It is noted that Enright discloses any of the filters may be equipped with a PH indicator to monitor the purity of the working fluid. [AltContent: textbox (Spout)] [AltContent: arrow][AltContent: arrow] [AltContent: textbox (Housing)][AltContent: arrow][AltContent: arrow] PNG media_image1.png 302 530 media_image1.png Greyscale Titel Figure 5 Regarding Claim 4, although Enright discloses the pump (522) is configured to deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area (see ¶300), Enright fails to disclose the first filter includes a first housing and a first spout extending from the first housing, the second filter includes a second housing and a second spout extending from the second housing. Titel, also drawn to filter system for a cooler, teaches the first filter (107) includes a first housing (shown in annotated figure 5) and a first spout (shown in annotated figure 5) extending from the first housing (shown in annotated figure 5), the second filter (114) includes a second housing (shown in annotated figure 5) and a second spout extending from the second housing (shown in annotated figure 5), and the pump is (“Food processing system, as used herein, refers to a system that cooks, cools, blanches, cleans or otherwise processes food, and can include tanks, screens, fluid pumps, transfer mechanisms, etc” col. 5 ll. 16-19) configured to deliver the fluid to the first spout or the second spout (shown in figures 4 and 6). It is noted that the spouts of Titel allow for the passage of the working fluid, wherein Enright discloses the working fluid flow path. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with the first filter including a first housing and a first spout extending from the first housing, the second filter including a second housing and a second spout extending from the second housing, as taught by Titel, the motivation being to allow for the filters to be removed from the system during maintenance and to allow for said filters to be fluidly connected to the circuit in order to remove debris or other particulates harmful to the system. Regarding Claim 5, a modified Enright further teaches the pump is configured to direct the dielectric fluid through the first filter or (as taught by Titel in the rejection of Claim 1) the second filter when the computer component is placed in the bath area (“the dielectric fluid can be added to the vessel in a manner that causes liquid dielectric fluid to spill out of the rack 310 and into the sump area 523. Fluid may then be filtered, using the fluid filter 520, and pumped, using the fluid pump 522 and fluid pipe 521, to the far side of the vessel”, ¶160). Regarding Claim 21, Enright fails to disclose a first valve in fluid communication with the first filter, a first actuator configured to adjust the first valve, a second valve in fluid communication with the second filter, and a second actuator configured to adjust the second valve, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in an opened position and the second actuator to place the second valve in a closed position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in a closed position and the second actuator to place the second valve in an opened position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter. Titel, also drawn to filter system for a cooler (“Filter systems for food processing systems filter fluid that is used to cook, clean, cool and/or transport food products” (col. 5 ll. 44-45)), teaches a first valve (109) in fluid communication with the first filter (107), a first actuator configured to adjust the first valve (“Each of the valves are automatically actuated valves” col. 3 ll. 19), a second valve (116) in fluid communication with the second filter (114), and a second actuator configured to adjust the second valve (see col. 3 ll. 19), wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter (“System 100 also includes pressure sensors 126 and 127 (FIGS. 1 and 4-7) to monitor the pressure across filters 107 and 114” (col. 8 ll. 56-58)) is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller (122) is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in an opened position and the second actuator to place the second valve in a closed position (shown in figure 4, “The operation of system 100 has been described above with filter 107 being active and filter 114 being off. When filter 114 is active and filter 107 is off system 100 operates in a like fashion. Controller 122 monitors, time, pressures, number of purges, and how purges are triggered, and controls filter 114 and valves 116, 120 and 118 so that filter 114 enters the modes described above (with respect to filter 107)”, col. 9 ll. 67-col. 10 ll. 2) to pass the fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter (shown in figure 4), and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in a closed position and the second actuator to place the second valve in an opened position (shown in figure 6) to pass the fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter (“when filter 107 has entered the purge mode by crossing the pressure differential threshold more than 5 consecutive times, and filter 114 is available, controller 122 closes valves 109, 113 and 111, and opens valves 116 and 120 so that filter 107 is off and filter 114 is filtering” see col. 9 ll. 38-43, wherein the controller operates the valves to isolate a single valve for service). It is noted that the path of the dielectric fluid from the sump area to the filters and the bath area is previously taught by Enright (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300), wherein the filter controller that controls the operation of parallel filters is taught by Archibald. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a first valve in fluid communication with the first filter, a first actuator configured to adjust the first valve, a second valve in fluid communication with the second filter, and a second actuator configured to adjust the second valve, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in an opened position and the second actuator to place the second valve in a closed position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in a closed position and the second actuator to place the second valve in an opened position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter, as taught by Titel, the motivation being to provide a “filter system that has the advantages of purging (such as ease of use) and the advantages OF changing to a new filter (robust operation), without the disadvantages of each”, thereby mitigating degradation or failure of systems that require the filtered fluid due to clogging or excessive system pressure. Claim 22 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Titel et al. (USP 11534703B2)as applied in Claims 1-5 and 21 above and in further view of Wu (Translation of CN112888273A), hereinafter referred to as Wu. Regarding Claim 22, Enright fails to disclose a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and another valve in fluid communication with the second filter and an actuator configured to adjust a valve, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter. Titel, also drawn to filter system for a cooler (“Filter systems for food processing systems filter fluid that is used to cook, clean, cool and/or transport food products” (col. 5 ll. 44-45)), teaches a valve (109) in selective fluid communication with the first filter (107) and a second valve (116) in selective fluid communication with the second filter (114) and an actuator configured to adjust the valve (“Each of the valves are automatically actuated valves” col. 3 ll. 19), wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter (“System 100 also includes pressure sensors 126 and 127 (FIGS. 1 and 4-7) to monitor the pressure across filters 107 and 114” (col. 8 ll. 56-58)) is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller (122) is configured to direct the actuator to place the valve in a position to pass the fluid through the first filter (shown in figure 4, “The operation of system 100 has been described above with filter 107 being active and filter 114 being off. When filter 114 is active and filter 107 is off system 100 operates in a like fashion. Controller 122 monitors, time, pressures, number of purges, and how purges are triggered, and controls filter 114 and valves 116, 120 and 118 so that filter 114 enters the modes described above (with respect to filter 107)”, col. 9 ll. 67-col. 10 ll. 2) and bypass the second filter (shown in figure 4), and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place the valve in a position (shown in figure 6) to pass the fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter (“when filter 107 has entered the purge mode by crossing the pressure differential threshold more than 5 consecutive times, and filter 114 is available, controller 122 closes valves 109, 113 and 111, and opens valves 116 and 120 so that filter 107 is off and filter 114 is filtering” see col. 9 ll. 38-43, wherein the controller operates the valves to isolate a single valve for service). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and another valve in fluid communication with the second filter and an actuator configured to adjust the valves, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter, as taught by Titel, the motivation being to provide a “filter system that has the advantages of purging (such as ease of use) and the advantages OF changing to a new filter (robust operation), without the disadvantages of each”, thereby mitigating degradation or failure of systems that require the filtered fluid due to clogging or excessive system pressure. Although Enright discloses filters being situated in parallel for filtering coolant and a pump (522) for delivering fluid to parallel filters (see ¶39), Enright fails to disclose a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and the second filter. Wu, also drawn to a cooling system, teaches a valve (5) in fluid communication with a first filter (1, shown in figure1) and the second filter (2, shown in figure1). It is noted that Enright discloses a pump feeding the fluid to parallel filters, wherein Wu teaches parallel filters being fluidly connected by a single valve. Wu further states, “The double-filter of the invention can realize the automatic switching of the two filtering branches through the electric three-way valve; it can quickly recover the smooth of the water path when the filter is in failure”, abstract. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and the second filter, as taught by Wu, the motivation being to minimize components of the filtering system, thereby minimizing complexity and the associated costs. The rationale to support a conclusion that the claim would have been obvious is that the substitution of one known element for another yields predictable results to one of ordinary skill in the art. If any of these findings cannot be made, then this rationale cannot be used to support a conclusion that the claim would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art. Per MPEP 2143-I, a simple substitution of one known element for another, with a reasonable expectation of success supports a conclusion of obviousness. In the instant case, the simple substitution is related to substituting a single valve connected to a first and second filter with multiple valves individually connected with a first and second filter; further the prior art to Wu teaches a single valve connected to a first and second filter is known for distributing fluid within a filtering system. Therefore, since modifying the prior art to Enright with having a single valve connected to a first and second filter, can easily be made without any change in the operation of the filtering device; and in view of the teachings of the prior art to Wu there will be reasonable expectations of success, it would have been obvious to have modified the invention of Enright by having a single valve connected to a first and second filter in order to minimize components of the filtering system, thereby minimizing complexity and the associated costs. Claims 6, 9, 11 and 13-14 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2), hereinafter referred to as Enright and Archibald, respectively. Regarding Claim 6, Enright discloses a cooling system comprising: a vessel (110) including a sump area (523) and a bath area (“The tank can include a bath area and a sump area, and the computing device can be immersed in a dielectric fluid in the bath area of the tank”, ¶273), the bath area configured to receive a computer component (see ¶273), the bath area and the sump area configured to hold a dielectric fluid (see ¶273); a first filter (see annotation below, referring to a first filter of the parallel filters, ¶39); a second filter (“The first stage may be a large particle filter located within the bottom of the vessel. The purpose of this filter is to prevent particles which are too large to be handled by the later stages from entering the rest of the system. The second stage may be a medium particulate filter which sits in-line in the piping system between the first and third stage. This second stage medium particulate filter may use a small barrel style filter to remove particulates that were too small to be removed by the first stage filter but still too large to be handled by the third stage filter. The third stage filter may consist of one or more parallel filters with support for various kinds of filter configurations”, underline for emphasis, ¶39); and a pump (522) configured to move the dielectric fluid through the cooling system (shown in figure 10C, see also ¶191), wherein, the pump is controlled to draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area, pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area (“the management system can activate the timer or the counter only when the vessel is in operation, the pump is active or the dielectric fluid passes through the filter (as determined by a fluid sensor in the filter). If the management system determines that the filter has been in operation for more than a threshold time, the management system can transmit a notification to the user”, ¶311, wherein the pump passes fluid through parallel filters prior to the threshold time, one filter being the first filter), and wherein, after the threshold period of time, the pump is controlled to draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area, pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area (see annotation directly above, wherein the pump passes fluid through the parallel filters after the threshold time and transmits a notification to the user, the other filter being the second filter). Although Enright discloses multiple filters being situated in parallel within an immersion cooled system with a pump controlled to deliver cooling fluid to said system, Enright fails to disclose a filter controller including an electronic processor and a memory, wherein, in response to the filter controller determining that a threshold period of time has not elapsed, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid from the sump area, pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area, and wherein, in response to the filter controller determining that the threshold period of time has elapsed, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid from the sump area, automatically switch to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter without user intervention, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area. Archibald, also drawn to an electronic cooling system, teaches a filter controller (234) including an electronic processor (236) and a memory (244), wherein in response to the filter controller determining that a threshold period of time has not elapsed the filter controller is configured to direct the fluid through the first filter (198a, “In a single pump mode a single pump of the dual pumps is active at a given time, and provides pressure and flow to the secondary coolant loop. Further, in single pump mode, the pumps can alternate operation at regular time intervals. For example, in a first time interval, a first pump of the dual pumps can be active, and a second pump of the dual pumps can be inactive. At the expiration of the first time interval, the first pump can become inactive, and the second pump can be activated to provide flow through the secondary coolant loop, and the second pump can remain active until the expiration of a second time interval, when the first pump activates and the second pump becomes inactive”, col. 48 ll. 28-41, wherein fluid is traveling through the first pump (168a) and therefore the first filter (198a) in the single pump mode prior to the first time interval expiring) and bypass (“When the upstream shutoff valve 186a is closed, all flow of fluid in the secondary loop must flow through the pump 168b. If the CDU 100 is operating in single pump mode with pump 168a as the primary pump, fluidly isolating pump 168a by closing the upstream shutoff valve 186a can cause the CDU 100 to fail over to pump 168b, and pump 168b can resume operation from pump 168a”, col. 15 ll. 59-65, wherein the respective pump is isolated by closing the associated valve (186)) the second filter (198b) and wherein, in response to the filter controller determining that the threshold period of time has elapsed, the filter controller is configured to direct the fluid, automatically switch (“A control system could therefore operate the valves to allow flow through a bypass loop and fluidly isolate the strainer, allowing an operator to service the strainer”, col. 10 ll. 25-28, “valves upstream and downstream of pumps can be controlled automatically” col. 15 ll. 49-50 and “the controller 234 can be in operative communication with valve components 250. The valve components 250 can include any or all of the two-way valve 154, three-way valve 158, the upstream shutoff valves 186, the downstream shutoff valves 188, the egress valves 200, and any other valves of the CDU 100”, col. 27 ll. 3-8) to pass the fluid through the second filter (see previous annotation, “At the expiration of the first time interval, the first pump can become inactive, and the second pump can be activated to provide flow through the secondary coolant loop, and the second pump can remain active until the expiration of a second time interval, when the first pump activates and the second pump becomes inactive”, wherein the second pump is associated with the second filter, see at least figure 32) and bypass the first filter (see col. 15 ll. 59-65, in the single pump mode the valve (186) associated with the active pump is opened and the valve (186) associated with the inactive pump is closed, thereby isolating said inactive pump and the associated filter) without user intervention (see col. 10 ll. 25-28, col. 15 ll. 49-50 and col. 27 ll. 3-8), and deliver the fluid (shown in figure 32, wherein the activation of the pump drives the working fluid through the cooling system). It is noted that the path of the dielectric fluid from the sump area to the filters and the bath area is previously taught by Enright (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300), wherein the filter controller that controls the operation of parallel filters is taught by Archibald. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a filter controller including an electronic processor and a memory, wherein, in response to the filter controller determining that a threshold period of time has not elapsed, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid from the sump area, pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area, and wherein, in response to the filter controller determining that the threshold period of time has elapsed, the filter controller is configured to direct the dielectric fluid from the sump area, automatically switch to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter without user intervention, and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area, as taught by Archibald, the motivation being that “CDUs can be designed to continue operation even when a component of the CDU fails or requires service. Pumping systems of a CDU can thus be redundant, and redundant flow paths can be provided to allow continued flow through the system when a single pump fails. Further, elements of the CDU can facilitate servicing of components so that an operator can replace or service components with minimal tooling requirements” (col. 14 ll. 54-61), thereby allowing for replacement or repair of components without initiating system downtime. Regarding Claim 9, although Enright further discloses a pressure sensor configured to determine a pressure-drop across the first filter (“the filter can include an input pipe and an output pipe, and there can be a pressure sensor on the input pipe and a pressure sensor on the output pipe. Each pressure sensor can transmit a pressure reading to the management system. If the pressure differential between the readings of the pressure sensors exceeds a threshold pressure, the management sensor can determine that the filter is clogged”, ¶311, Enright fails to disclose when the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than a threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter, and wherein when the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter. Archibald, also drawn to an electronic cooling system, teaches when the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than a threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter (198a of Archibald, “additional pressure sensors can be provided along the secondary coolant loop, including for example, pressure sensors immediately upstream and downstream of the filters 198a, 198b to detect a pressure drop across the filters indicating a need for maintenance of one or both of the filters 198a, 198b” (col. 25 ll. 4-9), wherein the fluid is capable of passing through the first filter when there is no need for maintenance), and wherein when the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter (“as when a filter must be removed from the system for servicing, one of the redundant flow paths 181a, 181b can be fluidly isolated from the secondary coolant circuit, allowing all fluid flow of the secondary circuit to flow through the other of the redundant flow paths 181a, 181b. For example, to isolate filtration system 192a for servicing of filter 198a, the downstream shutoff valve 188a can be closed to prevent fluid flow into flow path 181a from pump 168a”, col. 16 ll. 48-56, wherein the fluid is capable of passing through the second filter and bypassing the first filter in the instance the pressure drop of the first filter indicates a need for maintenance). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with when the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than a threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter, and wherein when the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter, as taught by Archibald, the motivation being that “A control system could therefore operate the valves to allow flow through a bypass loop and fluidly isolate the strainer, allowing an operator to service the strainer” (col. 10 ll. 25-28), wherein the control system recognizes problems within the system in real time and allows for replacement or repair of components without initiating system downtime. Regarding Claim 9, MPEP 2114 II clearly states “[A]pparatus claims cover what a device is, not what a device does" and a claim having a “recitation with respect to the manner in which a claimed apparatus is intended to be employed does not differentiate the claimed apparatus from a prior art apparatus" if the prior art apparatus teaches all the structural limitations of the claim.” Because Claim 10 fails to further limit the apparatus in terms of structure, but rather only recite further functional limitations, regarding “when the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than a threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter, and wherein when the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter” limitations, the invention as taught by the combined teachings of Enright and Archibald are deemed fully capable of performing such function. Enright comprises a pump with filters and Archibald teaches parallel filters capable of being bypassed for servicing and pressure sensors that monitor when servicing should occur. Therefore, the claim limitations are met by the combination of the references put forth in this action. Regarding Claim 11, Enright further discloses a flow sensor configured to determine a flow rate across the first filter (“the filter can include a sensor which indicates that flow rate for the filter. The management system can use the flow rate to determine if the filter needs service”, ¶311) and wherein when the flow rate across the first filter is greater than a threshold, the pump passes the dielectric fluid through the first filter (“the filter can include a sensor which indicates that flow rate for the filter. The management system can use the flow rate to determine if the filter needs service”, ¶311), and wherein when the flow rate across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the pump passes the dielectric fluid through the second filter (see ¶311, wherein the fluid is passing through both of the parallel filters in the case where the flow rate measurement does not indicate servicing is required and the fluid is passing through the second filter if the flow rate of the first filter indicates servicing is required). Regarding Claim 11, MPEP 2114 II clearly states “[A]pparatus claims cover what a device is, not what a device does" and a claim having a “recitation with respect to the manner in which a claimed apparatus is intended to be employed does not differentiate the claimed apparatus from a prior art apparatus" if the prior art apparatus teaches all the structural limitations of the claim.” Because Claim 12 fails to further limit the apparatus in terms of structure, but rather only recite further functional limitations, regarding “when the flow rate across the first filter is greater than a threshold, the pump passes the dielectric fluid through the first filter, and wherein when the flow rate across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the pump passes the dielectric fluid through the second filter” limitations, the invention as taught by the combined teachings of Enright and Archibald are deemed fully capable of performing such function. Enright comprises a pump with filters and Archibald teaches parallel filters capable of being bypassed for servicing and pressure sensors that monitor when servicing should occur. Therefore, the claim limitations are met by the combination of the references put forth in this action. Regarding Claim 13, Enright further discloses a pH sensor fluidly connected to the second filter (“the filter can include a stripe for testing acidity of the dielectric fluid. The stripe can be a PH indicator, litmus paper or other indicator”, ¶306), wherein the pH sensor is configured to determine a pH of the dielectric fluid flowing through the second filter after the threshold period of time (see ¶306, wherein the pH level is tested within the filter continuously). Regarding Claim 14, Enright fails to explicitly disclose the threshold period of time is fourteen days. Enright does, however, disclose a threshold period of time exists for the system, wherein a user is notified at the termination of said threshold period (see ¶311) to replace said filter. Therefore, the amount of time that comprises the threshold period is recognized as a result-effective variable, i.e. a variable which achieves a recognized result. In this case, the recognized result is that an increased threshold time requires a more robust filter that allows for greater fluid flow prior to becoming faulty/clogged and being more convenient to a user wherein the filter is replaced less frequently over a period of time and vice versa. Therefore, since the general conditions of the claim, i.e. that the filter comprises a threshold time to designate replacement, was disclosed in the prior art by Enright, it is not inventive to discover the optimum workable range by routine experimentation, and it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the invention to provide the threshold time of Enright to be fourteen days. See MPEP 2144.05 II. Claim 23 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2) as applied in Claims 6, 9, 11 and 13-14 above and in further view of Titel et al. (USP 11534703B2). Regarding Claim 23, Enright fails to disclose a first valve in fluid communication with the first filter, a first actuator configured to adjust the first valve, a second valve in fluid communication with the second filter, and a second actuator configured to adjust the second valve, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in an opened position and the second actuator to place the second valve in a closed position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in a closed position and the second actuator to place the second valve in an opened position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter. Titel, also drawn to filter system for a cooler (“Filter systems for food processing systems filter fluid that is used to cook, clean, cool and/or transport food products” (col. 5 ll. 44-45)), teaches a first valve (109) in fluid communication with the first filter (107), a first actuator configured to adjust the first valve (“Each of the valves are automatically actuated valves” col. 3 ll. 19), a second valve (116) in fluid communication with the second filter (114), and a second actuator configured to adjust the second valve (see col. 3 ll. 19), wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter (“System 100 also includes pressure sensors 126 and 127 (FIGS. 1 and 4-7) to monitor the pressure across filters 107 and 114” (col. 8 ll. 56-58)) is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller (122) is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in an opened position and the second actuator to place the second valve in a closed position (shown in figure 4, “The operation of system 100 has been described above with filter 107 being active and filter 114 being off. When filter 114 is active and filter 107 is off system 100 operates in a like fashion. Controller 122 monitors, time, pressures, number of purges, and how purges are triggered, and controls filter 114 and valves 116, 120 and 118 so that filter 114 enters the modes described above (with respect to filter 107)”, col. 9 ll. 67-col. 10 ll. 2) to pass the fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter (shown in figure 4), and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in a closed position and the second actuator to place the second valve in an opened position (shown in figure 6) to pass the fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter (“when filter 107 has entered the purge mode by crossing the pressure differential threshold more than 5 consecutive times, and filter 114 is available, controller 122 closes valves 109, 113 and 111, and opens valves 116 and 120 so that filter 107 is off and filter 114 is filtering” see col. 9 ll. 38-43, wherein the controller operates the valves to isolate a single valve for service). It is noted that the path of the dielectric fluid from the sump area to the filters and the bath area is previously taught by Enright (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300), wherein the filter controller that controls the operation of parallel filters is taught by Archibald. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a first valve in fluid communication with the first filter, a first actuator configured to adjust the first valve, a second valve in fluid communication with the second filter, and a second actuator configured to adjust the second valve, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in an opened position and the second actuator to place the second valve in a closed position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the first actuator to place the first valve in a closed position and the second actuator to place the second valve in an opened position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter, as taught by Titel, the motivation being to provide a “filter system that has the advantages of purging (such as ease of use) and the advantages OF changing to a new filter (robust operation), without the disadvantages of each”, thereby mitigating degradation or failure of systems that require the filtered fluid due to clogging or excessive system pressure. Claim 24 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2) as applied in Claims 6, 9, 11 and 13-14 above in further view of Titel et al. (USP 11534703B2) and Wu (Translation of CN112888273A). Regarding Claim 22, Enright fails to disclose a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and another valve in fluid communication with the second filter and an actuator configured to adjust a valve, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter. Titel, also drawn to filter system for a cooler (“Filter systems for food processing systems filter fluid that is used to cook, clean, cool and/or transport food products” (col. 5 ll. 44-45)), teaches a valve (109) in selective fluid communication with the first filter (107) and a second valve (116) in selective fluid communication with the second filter (114) and an actuator configured to adjust the valve (“Each of the valves are automatically actuated valves” col. 3 ll. 19), wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter (“System 100 also includes pressure sensors 126 and 127 (FIGS. 1 and 4-7) to monitor the pressure across filters 107 and 114” (col. 8 ll. 56-58)) is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller (122) is configured to direct the actuator to place the valve in a position to pass the fluid through the first filter (shown in figure 4, “The operation of system 100 has been described above with filter 107 being active and filter 114 being off. When filter 114 is active and filter 107 is off system 100 operates in a like fashion. Controller 122 monitors, time, pressures, number of purges, and how purges are triggered, and controls filter 114 and valves 116, 120 and 118 so that filter 114 enters the modes described above (with respect to filter 107)”, col. 9 ll. 67-col. 10 ll. 2) and bypass the second filter (shown in figure 4), and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place the valve in a position (shown in figure 6) to pass the fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter (“when filter 107 has entered the purge mode by crossing the pressure differential threshold more than 5 consecutive times, and filter 114 is available, controller 122 closes valves 109, 113 and 111, and opens valves 116 and 120 so that filter 107 is off and filter 114 is filtering” see col. 9 ll. 38-43, wherein the controller operates the valves to isolate a single valve for service). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and another valve in fluid communication with the second filter and an actuator configured to adjust the valves, wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is smaller than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and bypass the second filter, and wherein, in response to the electronic processor determining that the pressure-drop across the first filter is larger than the threshold, the filter controller is configured to direct the actuator to place a valve in a position to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and bypass the first filter, as taught by Titel, the motivation being to provide a “filter system that has the advantages of purging (such as ease of use) and the advantages OF changing to a new filter (robust operation), without the disadvantages of each”, thereby mitigating degradation or failure of systems that require the filtered fluid due to clogging or excessive system pressure. Although Enright discloses filters being situated in parallel for filtering coolant and a pump (522) for delivering fluid to parallel filters (see ¶39), Enright fails to disclose a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and the second filter. Wu, also drawn to a cooling system, teaches a valve (5) in fluid communication with a first filter (1, shown in figure1) and the second filter (2, shown in figure1). It is noted that Enright discloses a pump feeding the fluid to parallel filters, wherein Wu teaches parallel filters being fluidly connected by a single valve. Wu further states, “The double-filter of the invention can realize the automatic switching of the two filtering branches through the electric three-way valve; it can quickly recover the smooth of the water path when the filter is in failure”, abstract. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with a valve in selective fluid communication with the first filter and the second filter, as taught by Wu, the motivation being to minimize components of the filtering system, thereby minimizing complexity and the associated costs. The rationale to support a conclusion that the claim would have been obvious is that the substitution of one known element for another yields predictable results to one of ordinary skill in the art. If any of these findings cannot be made, then this rationale cannot be used to support a conclusion that the claim would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art. Per MPEP 2143-I, a simple substitution of one known element for another, with a reasonable expectation of success supports a conclusion of obviousness. In the instant case, the simple substitution is related to substituting a single valve connected to a first and second filter with multiple valves individually connected with a first and second filter; further the prior art to Wu teaches a single valve connected to a first and second filter is known for distributing fluid within a filtering system. Therefore, since modifying the prior art to Enright with having a single valve connected to a first and second filter, can easily be made without any change in the operation of the filtering device; and in view of the teachings of the prior art to Wu there will be reasonable expectations of success, it would have been obvious to have modified the invention of Enright by having a single valve connected to a first and second filter in order to minimize components of the filtering system, thereby minimizing complexity and the associated costs. Claims 7-8 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2) as applied in Claims 6, 9, 11 and 13-14 above and in further view of Wu (Translation of CN112888273A), hereinafter referred to as Wu. Regarding Claim 7, although Enright discloses filters being situated in parallel for filtering coolant and a pump (522) for delivering fluid to parallel filters (see ¶39), Enright fails to disclose a valve in fluid communication with the pump, a first pipe fluidly connecting the valve and the first filter, and a second pipe fluidly connecting the valve and the second filter. Wu, also drawn to a cooling system, teaches a valve (5) in fluid communication with pressurized fluid (shown in figure 1), a first pipe fluidly connecting the valve and the first filter (1, shown in figure1), and a second pipe fluidly connecting the valve and the second filter (2, shown in figure1). It is noted that Enright discloses a pump feeding the fluid to parallel filters, wherein Wu teaches parallel filters being fluidly connected by a single valve. Wu further states, “The double-filter of the invention can realize the automatic switching of the two filtering branches through the electric three-way valve; it can quickly recover the smooth of the water path when the filter is in failure”, abstract. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with the above limitations, as taught by Wu, the motivation being to minimize downtime of the filtering device by allowing for redundant filters. Regarding Claim 8, although Enright discloses filters being situated in parallel for filtering coolant and a pump (522) for delivering fluid to parallel filters (see ¶39), Enright fails to disclose during the threshold period of time, the valve fluidly connects the pump and the first filter and fluidly isolates the pump from the second filter and wherein after the threshold period of time, the valve fluidly connects the pump and the second filter and fluidly isolates the pump (522 of Enright) from the first filter. Wu teaches, during a threshold period of time, the valve fluidly connects the pressurized fluid and the first filter (1) and fluidly isolates the pressurized fluid from the second (2) filter (during the default state wherein, “the controller the electric three-way valve 5 of the common end C end 5.1 and the A end 5.2 in the open state, the electric three-way valve 5 of the common end C end 5.1 and B end 5.3 in the off state”), and wherein after the threshold period of time, the valve fluidly connects the pressurized fluid and the second filter and fluidly isolates the pressurized fluid from the first filter (“if 1 # filter branch after a certain time 1 # pressure difference switch 3 the filter dirty block sends the fault signal; the external controller receives the signal then the electric three-way valve 5 reversing; the common end C end 5.1 and B end 5.3 of the electric three-way valve 5 is placed in the open state; the common end C end 5.3 and the B end 5.2 of the electric three-way valve 5 are in a closed state”). It is noted that Wu teaches the parallel filters operating in a default state with a single filter allowing for the flow of working fluid while the other flid is isolated, wherein after a period of time elapses a pressure measurement is taken that detects a clogged filter and redirects the fluid through the unclogged filter. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with the above limitations, as taught by Wu, the motivation being to minimize downtime of the filtering device by allowing for redundant filters. Claims 15 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2) and in further view of Tang et al. (Translation of CN109458768A), hereinafter referred to as Enright, Archibald and Tang, respectively. [AltContent: textbox (Ramp Structure)][AltContent: arrow][AltContent: arrow] PNG media_image2.png 421 525 media_image2.png Greyscale Enright Figure 16 Regarding Claim 15, Enright discloses a cooling system comprising: a vessel (110) including a sump area (523) and a bath area (“The tank can include a bath area and a sump area, and the computing device can be immersed in a dielectric fluid in the bath area of the tank”, ¶273), the bath area configured to receive a computer component (see ¶273), the bath area and the sump area configured to hold a dielectric fluid (see ¶273); an expandable bellows (905) configured to regulate an interior pressure of the vessel (“Dielectric vapor may flow from the tank 710 through piping to one or more bellows 905. In some embodiments, the vapor recovery system 900 comprises an expanding and collapsing bellows 905 configured to receive the dielectric vapor, thereby reducing or eliminating any pressure build-up in the tank 710”, ¶249); the expandable bellows including a ramp structure (shown in annotated figure 16); a door (711) selectively coupled to the vessel (shown in figures 12C, 13 and 16), a filter (520) having a housing (shown in figure 10C); and a pump (522) configured to draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area (shown in figure 10C), pass the dielectric fluid through the filter (shown in figure 10C), and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300), wherein of the expandable bellows is configured to receive the dielectric fluid in a gaseous state (see ¶249), and wherein the ramp structure of the expandable bellows is configured to direct the dielectric fluid in a liquid state into the vessel (“When the system cools or a portion of the dielectric vapor is condensed to dielectric liquid, the bellows may collapse or contract to substantially maintain a pressure equilibrium within the tank 710”, ¶249). Enright fails to disclose the first filter includes a spout extending from the housing. Archibald, also drawn to an electronic cooling system, teaches a first filter (198a) includes a spout extending from the first (196a) housing (shown at least in figure 16, being the piping attached to the filter housing (196a)). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with the first filter including a spout extending from the housing, as taught by Archibald, the motivation being to allow for the filter to be removed from the system during maintenance and to allow the filter to be fluidly connected to the circuit. Regarding Claim 15, MPEP 2114 II clearly states “[A]pparatus claims cover what a device is, not what a device does" and a claim having a “recitation with respect to the manner in which a claimed apparatus is intended to be employed does not differentiate the claimed apparatus from a prior art apparatus" if the prior art apparatus teaches all the structural limitations of the claim.” Because Claim 15 fails to further limit the apparatus in terms of structure, but rather only recite further functional limitations, regarding “an expandable bellows configured to regulate an interior pressure of the vessel… the expandable bellows is configured to receive the dielectric fluid in a gaseous state, and wherein the ramp structure of the expandable bellows is configured to direct the dielectric fluid in a liquid state into the vessel” limitations, the invention as taught by the combined teachings of Enright and Archibald are deemed fully capable of performing such function. Enright comprises bellows being fluidly connected to the tank and capable of capturing vaporized fluid and capable of condensing said fluid to be released back into the tank. Therefore, the claim limitations are met by the combination of the references put forth in this action. Although Enright further teaches a door (711) selectively coupled to the vessel (shown in figures 12C, 13 and 16), Enright fails to disclose the door provided between the vessel and the expandable bellows. Tang teaches a door (22) is provided between the vessel (1) and the bellows (21). The rationale to support a conclusion that the claim would have been obvious is that the substitution of one known element for another yields predictable results to one of ordinary skill in the art. If any of these findings cannot be made, then this rationale cannot be used to support a conclusion that the claim would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art. Per MPEP 2143-I, a simple substitution of one known element for another, with a reasonable expectation of success supports a conclusion of obviousness. In the instant case, the simple substitution is related to substituting the door being provided between the vessel and the expandable bellows with the door not being provided between the vessel and the expandable bellows; further the prior art to Tang teaches bellows being attached to a shell with a door being placed between the bellows and said shell. Therefore, since modifying the prior art to Enright with having the door being provided between the vessel and the expandable bellows, can easily be made without any change in the operation of the heat exchanger device; and in view of the teachings of the prior art to Tang there will be reasonable expectations of success, it would have been obvious to have modified the invention of Enright by having the door being provided between the vessel and the expandable bellows in order to have visual configuration of the pressure cycle within the tank. Claims 16 is rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2) and in further view of Tang et al. (Translation of CN109458768A) as applied in Claim 15 above and in further view of Chen et al. (Translation of CN109629954A), hereinafter referred to as Chen. Regarding Claim 17, although Enright further teaches a door (711) selectively coupled to the vessel (shown in figures 12C, 13 and 16), wherein the door is movable between an opened position and a closed position (“the tank 710 may have multiple doors 711, thereby limiting the exposure of the interior of the tank 710 when a single door 711 is opened for the purpose of removing, installing and/or replacing a component or chassis 400”, ¶189), wherein the door provides access to the vessel in the opened position, wherein the door seals against the vessel in the closed position (shown in figure 12C, see ¶189), Enright fails to disclose the door is coupled to the vessel by a motorized clamp that is configured to move the door between the opened position and the closed position. Chen teaches a door (2) is coupled to the vessel (1) by a motorized clamp (15, 5) that is configured to move the door between the opened position and the closed position (“The invention relates to the field of automatic door technology, specifically a mechanism can realize automatic closing”). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with the door being coupled to the vessel by a motorized clamp that is configured to move the door between the opened position and the closed position, as taught by Chen, the motivation being “controlling the locking state of the door body, and improves the practicability of the automatic door closing device”, wherein automatically closing the door mitigates unwanted debris from entering in cases where “people forget closing or does not want closing problem at night, which greatly improves the convenience of people”. Regarding Claim 20, a modified Enright teaches the filter is a first filter (“The third stage filter may consist of one or more parallel filters with support for various kinds of filter configurations”, underline for emphasis, ¶39), wherein parallel filters are utilized within the system), the housing is a first housing (see rejection of Claim 15 above), the spout is a first spout (see rejection of Claim 15 above) the cooling system further comprises a second filter (“The third stage filter may consist of one or more parallel filters with support for various kinds of filter configurations”, underline for emphasis, ¶39), the pump (522) is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the first filter and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area through the first filter (“the tank can include a sump area and a bath area. The bath area can hold the computing device immersed in the dielectric fluid. The sump area can be next to the bath area, or the sump area and can be in fluid communication with the bath area. For example, the sump area can receive an overflow of the dielectric fluid from the bath area, e.g., the dielectric fluid can flow over a wall of the bath area adjacent to the sump area. The pump can draw the dielectric fluid from the sump area and pass the fluid through a filter”, ¶300) during a threshold period of time (“the management system can activate the timer or the counter only when the vessel is in operation, the pump is active or the dielectric fluid passes through the filter (as determined by a fluid sensor in the filter). If the management system determines that the filter has been in operation for more than a threshold time, the management system can transmit a notification to the user”, ¶311, wherein the pump passes fluid through parallel filters prior to the threshold time, one filter being the first filter), and the pump is configured to pass the dielectric fluid through the second filter and deliver the dielectric fluid to the bath area through the second filter after the threshold period of time (see annotation directly above, wherein the pump passes fluid through the parallel filters after the threshold time and transmits a notification to the user, the other filter being the second filter). Enright fails to disclose the second filter having a second housing and a second spout extending from the second housing. Archibald, also drawn to an electronic cooling system, teaches a second filter (198b) having a second housing (196b) and a second spout extending from the second housing (shown at least in figure 16, being the piping attached to the filter housing (196a)). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with disclose the second filter having a second housing and a second spout extending from the second housing, as taught by Archibald, the motivation being to allow for the filter to be removed from the system during maintenance and to allow the filter to be fluidly connected to the circuit. Claims 18-19 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Enright et al. (US PG Pub. 2021/0120705A1) in view of Archibald et al. (USP 12532433B2) and in further view of Tang et al. (Translation of CN109458768A) as applied in Claim 15 above and in further view of Chen et al. (Translation of CN109629954A) as applied in Claim 16 above and in further view of Ross et al. (USP 9795062B1), hereinafter referred to as Ross. Regarding Claim 18, although Enright further discloses the vessel is positioned within a shell (“the computing system may be contained within an outer housing as shown in FIG. 14. In some embodiments, the components schematically identified in FIG. 13 and/or disclosed herein may be contained within the outer housing”, ¶220), Enright fails to disclose the vessel is positioned within a shell, and wherein a shock absorber is positioned between the shell and the vessel. Ross, also drawn to a portable electronic housing with cooling, teaches a vessel (902) is positioned within a shell (904), and wherein a shock absorber (906) is positioned between the shell and the vessel (shown in figure 9A). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art, before the effective filing date of the claimed invention, to provide Enright with the vessel being positioned within a shell, and wherein a shock absorber being positioned between the shell and the vessel, as taught by Ross, the motivation being “Without a vibration isolation platform, such vibrations and impacts may damage computing devices installed in a portable data center”. Regarding Claim 19, a modified Enright further teaches the shock absorber is an active shock absorber, and wherein a stiffness of the active shock absorber is adjusted based on a stress characteristic imposed on the vessel (“an air pressure in a vibration cushion, such as cushion 906, may be adjusted to change a natural frequency of a system that includes a vibration isolation platform coupled with the vibration cushion. For example, increasing a pressure in a vibration cushion may increase a stiffness of the cushion, whereas reducing a pressure in a vibration cushion may reduce a stiffness of the cushion”, see col. 19 ll. 45-51 of Ross). Regarding Claim 19, MPEP 2114 II clearly states “[A]pparatus claims cover what a device is, not what a device does" and a claim having a “recitation with respect to the manner in which a claimed apparatus is intended to be employed does not differentiate the claimed apparatus from a prior art apparatus" if the prior art apparatus teaches all the structural limitations of the claim.” Because Claim 19 fails to further limit the apparatus in terms of structure, but rather only recite further functional limitations, regarding “a stiffness of the active shock absorber is adjusted based on a stress characteristic imposed on the vessel”, the invention as taught by the combined teachings of Enright and Ross are deemed fully capable of performing such function. Ross comprises a vibration isolator which is capable of being adjusted for absorbing varying levels of vibration. Therefore, the claim limitations are met by the combination of the references put forth in this action. Response to Arguments Applicant’s arguments with respect to claim(s) 1 and 6 have been considered but are moot because the new ground of rejection does not rely on any reference applied in the prior rejection of record for any teaching or matter specifically challenged in the argument. On page 12 of the Arguments the Applicant states, “Archibald does not disclose an immersion cooling system. Rather, Archibald discloses a closed- loop cooling system. The redundant flow path 181a of Archibald is part of this closed-loop cooling system. Liquid flows through the redundant flow path 181 a (and thus the first housing 196a and the piping connected to the first housing 196a). However, the liquid does not exit the redundant flow path 181 a through the alleged spout (the piping attached to the first housing 196a)”. The immersion cooling flowpath is taught by Enright in the rejection of Claim 15, wherein Archibald teaches it is old and well known to attach a spout to a filter housing. “A person of ordinary skill in the art is also a person of ordinary creativity, not an automaton.” KSR, 550 U.S. at 421, 82 USPQ2d at 1397. “[I]n many cases a person of ordinary skill will be able to fit the teachings of multiple patents together like pieces of a puzzle.” Id. at 420, 82 USPQ2d at 1397. Office personnel may also take into account “the inferences and creative steps that a person of ordinary skill in the art would employ.” Id. at 418, 82 USPQ2d at 1396 Conclusion Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to PAUL ALVARE whose telephone number is (571)272-8611. The examiner can normally be reached Monday-Friday 0930-1800. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Len Tran can be reached at (571) 272-1184. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /PAUL ALVARE/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3763
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Jul 19, 2024
Application Filed
Dec 31, 2025
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §103
Mar 30, 2026
Response Filed
Apr 22, 2026
Final Rejection mailed — §103
Jul 21, 2026
Request for Continued Examination
Jul 24, 2026
Response after Non-Final Action
Oct 20, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §103 (current)

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12791259
HEAT EXCHANGE ASSEMBLY, AND VEHICLE THERMAL MANAGEMENT SYSTEM
3y 11m to grant Granted Nov 10, 2026
Patent 12795858
IMMERSION HEAT EXCHANGE SYSTEM
2y 6m to grant Granted Nov 10, 2026
Patent 12795868
DATACENTER LIQUID COOLING ARRANGEMENT FOR REDUCING ICING RISKS OF DRY COOLERS
2y 3m to grant Granted Nov 10, 2026
Patent 12782059
COMBINATION HEAT EXCHANGER
2y 7m to grant Granted Nov 03, 2026
Patent 12782065
DRY COOLER ASSEMBLY AND METHOD OF ASSEMBLING THEREOF
2y 3m to grant Granted Nov 03, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 5 most recent grants.

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

3-4
Expected OA Rounds
58%
Grant Probability
95%
With Interview (+36.7%)
High
PTA Risk
Based on 625 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month