DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Status of Claims
Claims 1-19 are examined in the office action.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112(b):
(b) CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
Claims 1-19 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor (or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the applicant), regards as the invention.
Regarding claims 1-19, claim 1 recites “reducing the lithium-containing material to base particle size using an attrition scrubber to produce base particles”. It is unclear whether the “base particles” refers to “base” as in acid or base or particles of the material that is produced upon the reduction. The claim also recites “base particle size” without either “a” or “the” preceding it or by defining it thereby making it unclear if it is referring to a specific size or not.
Claim 1 recites “(g) delivering the acid-treated slurry to a third tank in which the acid-treated slurry is cooled to near-ambient temperature and treated with a second base until the acid-treated slurry reaches a pH of approximately 7.5, thereby generating a direct lithium extracted solution and leached clay solids”. This infers that clay solids have been leached at the end of the step (g). However, instant claim does not recite the origin of the leached clay solids thereby making it unclear where how it is produced based on the recited limitations of the prior steps.
Claim 1 requires “A method for extracting lithium from a lithium-containing material” in the first line of the claim. However, the claim ends with “(i) passing the direct lithium extracted solution and the solid tailings materials through a filter that is configured to separate the direct lithium extracted solution from the solid tailings material” (emphasis added). In other words, the claim ends with the separation of “direct lithium extracted solution” rather than “lithium” thereby making it unclear whether the claim is directed to extracting lithium or a solution with lithium.
Claim 1 recites “(g) delivering the acid-treated slurry to a third tank in which the acid-treated slurry is cooled to near-ambient temperature and treated with a second base until the acid-treated slurry reaches a pH of approximately 7.5, thereby generating a direct lithium extracted solution and leached clay solids”. It is unclear what is meant by “treated with a second base” in the phrase “treated with a second base until the acid-treated slurry reaches a pH of approximately 7.5” recited in the instant claim.
Claim 1 recites the limitation "the heated slurry" in step (d). There is insufficient antecedent basis for this limitation in the claim.
Claim 1 recites the limitation "the solid tailings materials" in step (i). There is insufficient antecedent basis for this limitation in the claim. Step (h) refers to “a solid tailings material”.
Regarding claims 8 and 9, instant claims recite “The method of claim 1, wherein the slurry contains 15% to 35% solids.” and “The method of claim 8, wherein the slurry contains approximately 30% solids.” It is unclear what step of claim 1 is required to fulfill these limitations. For example, is it in step (b) upon mixing and formation of the initial slurry or in step (c) during the heating the slurry is required to have a certain amount of solids?
Claim 13 recites “The method of claim 1, wherein the step of passing the direct lithium extracted solution and the solid tailings materials through a filter that is configured to separate the direct lithium extracted solution from the solid tailings material involves the use of multiple plate and frame filters.” The claim requires “involves the use of multiple plate and frame filters” but does not specify any steps associated with the use. Since the claims do not set forth any steps involved in the method/process, it is unclear what method/process applicant is intending to encompass. A claim is indefinite where it merely recites a use without any active, positive steps delimiting how this use is actually practiced. See MPEP § 2173.05(q).
Claim 14 recites “(j) treating the direct lithium extracted solution to an adsorption process to remove alkaline earth metal impurities from the direct lithium extracted solution, thereby generating a purified lithium-bearing solution”. It is unclear what is meant by “treating the direct lithium extracted solution to an adsorption process” in the phrase “treating the direct lithium extracted solution to an adsorption process to remove alkaline earth metal impurities from the direct lithium extracted solution, thereby generating a purified lithium-bearing solution” recited in the instant claim.
Claim 15 recites “(l) precipitating lithium carbonate out of the purified lithium-bearing solution using sodium carbonate, thereby generating a spent lithium solution and a solid lithium carbonate”. The claim requires “using sodium carbonate” but does not specify any steps associated with the use. Since the claims do not set forth any steps involved in the method/process, it is unclear what method/process applicant is intending to encompass. A claim is indefinite where it merely recites a use without any active, positive steps delimiting how this use is actually practiced. See MPEP § 2173.05(q).
Claims 2-19 are dependent on claim 1, do not resolve all of the aforementioned issues and thereby also indefinite.
Conclusion
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure.
Prior art US 2020/0263277 A1 of Patwardhan (US’277) teaches {abstract, [0001]-[0003], [0016]-[0069], [0081]-[0220]} [0001] “a process for recovering valuable products from ore containing boron and lithium.” “[0011] The invention is concerned with recovering valuable products, including lithium-containing and boron-containing products, from jadarite ore.” “[0017] In more detailed, although not exclusive, terms, the invention relates to a process for recovering valuable products from jadarite ore that includes the steps of: [0018] (a) beneficiating a mined or stockpiled jadarite ore and producing a jadarite concentrate, [0019] (b) digesting the concentrate in an acid and taking boron and lithium into solution in a digestion liquor, and, [0020] (c) subsequent steps to separate valuable boron-containing and lithium-containing products from the digestion liquor. [0021] The beneficiation step (a) may include attrition scrubbing mined or stockpiled jadarite ore in an aqueous or other suitable medium under high solids concentration (typically above 50% solids by weight) such that harder minerals like jadarite preferentially slake and attrite softer gangue minerals such as clay, calcite, dolomite, ankerite etc. thereby preferentially reducing the size of the gangue minerals. [0022] The beneficiation step (a) may include a size separation step that separates the gangue minerals degraded during the attrition scrubbing step from jadarite and other harder minerals that remain during the attrition scrubbing step, thereby achieving a grade increase of jadarite in the concentrate. [0023] The digestion step (b) may include digesting the jadarite concentration in sulphuric acid. [0024] The sulphuric acid may be concentrated sulfuric acid. [0025] The subsequent steps (c) may include any suitable series of successive steps to remove valuable products from the digestion liquor.” “[0029] The subsequent steps (c) may include precipitating boron-containing and lithium-containing products successively from solution in the digestion liquor. [0030] The subsequent steps (c) may include precipitating or removing non-valuable impurities successively from solution in the digestion liquor. [0031] The subsequent steps (c) may include precipitating boric acid and lithium carbonate successively from solution in the digestion liquor.” “[0034] The subsequent steps (c) may include precipitating boric acid, lithium carbonate, and sodium sulfate successively from solution in the digestion liquor.” “[0046] The subsequent steps (c) may include a lithium carbonate crystallisation step. [0047] The lithium carbonate crystallisation step may include precipitating impurities including any one or more than one of Mg. Al, Fe, Si and other heavy metal hydroxides, gypsum and silica from the digestion liquor and separating the precipitates from the digestion liquor. [0048] The lithium carbonate crystallisation step may include evaporating water to increase the lithium concentration in the digestion liquor. [0049] The impurity precipitation step may include adding any one or more than one of calcium carbonate, calcium hydroxide, sodium carbonate and sodium hydroxide in any suitable proportion to the digestion liquor. [0050] The lithium carbonate crystallisation step may include precipitating calcium from the digestion liquor. [0051] The lithium carbonate crystallisation step may include separating calcium precipitates from the digestion liquor. [0052] The process may include purifying lithium carbonate from the lithium carbonate crystallisation step by dissolution in presence of carbon dioxide, filtration to remove insoluble impurities, ion exchange or solvent extraction to remove dissolved impurities, and re-precipitation of lithium carbonate by heating or steam stripping. [0053] The calcium precipitation step may include adding sodium carbonate and/or carbon dioxide to the digestion liquor. [0054] The lithium carbonate crystallisation step may include a solvent extraction step to strip boron from the digestion liquor. [0055] The lithium carbonate crystallisation step may include precipitating lithium carbonate from the digestion liquor by adding sodium carbonate and carbon dioxide in any suitable proportion to the digestion liquor. [0056] The process may include converting lithium carbonate from the lithium carbonate crystallisation step to lithium hydroxide by reacting lithium carbonate with calcium hydroxide or sodium hydroxide, filtration to remove insoluble contaminants and crystallization of lithium hydroxide by evaporation and cooling. [0057] The lithium hydroxide crystals may be separated from the digestion liquor, washed to remove adhering impurities and dried under a carbon dioxide free environment. [0058] The lithium hydroxide product may be produced is re-dissolved and refined using ion exchange processes to remove deleterious elements, for example, Ca, Na, B, and recrystallizing lithium hydroxide by evaporation and cooling followed by separation from the digestion liquor, washing and drying in a carbon dioxide free atmosphere.” “[0099] Beneficiation includes an attrition scrubbing step 104 in which the crushed/milled run-of-mine ore 3 is attrition scrubbed under natural conditions in a water or other suitable aqueous medium at a high, nominally 50-65% solids concentration. [0100] In the attrition scrubber, softer clays are slaked away and the harder jadarite mineral attrites the softer calcite and dolomite minerals. The beneficiation residence time is dependent on the mineralogy and can be up to 20 minutes to achieve the best balance between concentrate grade, jadarite recovery and carbonate rejection. [0101] The resultant product 4 from the attrition scrubber is screened at 210 micrometres size in classifying step 105. Alternatively, by way of example, hydraulic separation could be used to achieve a similar goal using upward current classifiers or hydrocyclones or similar options.” “[0108] Digestion, Solubilization and Pregnant Leach Solution (PLS) Production [0109] The jadarite concentrate 7 (and NaB concentrate 109—if present) from the classifying step 105 is digested with concentrated sulfuric acid 8 (i.e. >95% H.sub.2SO.sub.4) in the presence of recycled process liquors (stream 9 and mother liquor 11 in FIG. 1) and water 10 in a digestion step 111. A slurry 12 is formed. [0110] The amount of water 10 that is added is controlled to maintain a 20-25% boric acid concentration, or at 80-90% of saturation dependent on temperature in the slurry 12. [0111] Digestion of the jadarite concentrate 7 occurs in a series of stirred tank reactors which include an internal draft tube, controlled at a temperature of between 50-100° C., preferably 80-95° C. Acid addition is carefully controlled to maintain the pH of the slurry between 1-5, preferably 2.0-3.8. Acid addition is in the high mixing zone in the draft tube to allow rapid dispersion and prevent any local variations in the pH. This technique retards silica dissolution and consequent polymerization which can lead to gelling of the digestion liquors over time.” “[0117] The PLS 13 contains boron, lithium, and sodium in solution.” “[0152] The solution is then filtered to remove undissolved solids (not shown in Figure). Undesired cationic impurities such as Ca and Mg and anionic impurities such as B are removed sequentially using suitable specific ion exchange resins in step 127. The resin is regenerated using hydrochloric acid 40, sulfuric acid 41 and sodium hydroxide 42. [0153] The purified solution 43 is then heated indirectly or directly with steam 44 to remove carbon dioxide and precipitate high purity lithium carbonate product in slurry 45 in a Battery Grade (BG) lithium carbonate crystallization step 128. The liberated carbon dioxide is captured and used in the dissolution step 126. [0154] The dissolution step is preferably conducted cold and under pressure. The precipitation or carbon dioxide stripping is preferably conducted at high temperatures. [0155] The hot slurry 45 is separated from the mother liquor in peeler centrifuges in a three-stage counter-current wash circuit with intermediate repulps to produce a wet lithium carbonate cake 47 in step 144. The separated mother liquor 46 is recycled to the lithium carbonate digestion step 126 as stream 39. The wet cake is dried in rotary or flash driers in step 129—and forms a second marketable product 49.”
Prior art WO 2020/205302 A1 via its US English equivalent US 2022/0220578 A1 of Rabe (US’578) teaches {abstract, Fig. 1-5, [0001], [0006]-[0008], [0014]-[0031], claims 1-15} [0001] “extraction and subsequent concentration of lithium from sedimentary clay” “[0006] In accordance with one aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of extracting lithium from sedimentary rock to produce lithium sulfate brine. The method includes the steps of sizing sedimentary rock, suspending the sized sedimentary rock in an aqueous solution, and separating the aqueous solution into lithium bearing slurry and low lithium containing coarse gangue. The lithium bearing slurry is then treated with an acid, dissolving lithium from the sedimentary rock and forming first precipitates, and the first precipitates are separated from the lithium bearing slurry, forming an acidic lithium sulfate solution. The pH of the acidic lithium sulfate solution is then modified to a pH of between approximately 4 and approximately 8, resulting in the formation of second precipitates, which are then separated from the neutralized lithium sulfate solution. [0007] The neutralized lithium sulfate solution is then crystallized, forming magnesium sulfate crystals and magnesium-potassium sulfate crystals which are also separated, resulting in a neutralized lithium sulfate mother liquor. The neutralized lithium sulfate mother liquor is then treated with calcium hydroxide or quicklime (calcium oxide), soda ash, and oxalic acid forming third precipitates that are then separated from the liquor and recycled to the neutralization step. Finally, the resultant magnesium-free lithium sulfate mother liquor is processed through multiple resin beds to further remove contaminants via ion exchange, forming a purified lithium sulfate brine solution. The lithium sulfate brine may subsequently be processed into lithium carbonate or lithium hydroxide monohydrate. [0008] In a preferred embodiment, the aqueous sedimentary rock is separated into lithium bearing slurry and gangue through the use of an attrition scrubber. Separately, the lithium slurry is preferably treated with sulfuric acid in segmented attack tank reactors. Precipitates formed in the attack tank reactors, as well as any undissolved solids, are preferably removed via pressure filtration. It has been determined that by using the above method, lithium sulfate brine can be extracted efficiently and economically from sedimentary clays.” “[0018] Once the sedimentary rock ore 101 is appropriately sized, the material is fed to an attrition scrubber 103. An attrition scrubber is an agitated vessel whereby water 104 is added to the sized sedimentary rock ore 101, forming a slurry. A high-speed agitator causes slurry particles to impact one another, thereby creating a scrubbing effect between particles. The disclosed invention not only uses an attrition scrubber to scrub lithium bearing particles from larger non-lithium bearing particles, but it also uses an attrition scrubber for particle comminution. By exploiting differences in breakage characteristics between lithium and low lithium bearing particles, the attrition scrubber reduces lithium bearing particles to a size fraction less than approximately 100 microns, while harder low lithium bearing particles remain in a size fraction larger than approximately 100 microns. The attrition scrubber is tuned to maximize size reduction of lithium bearing particles by controlling slurry wt. % solids, retention time, and agitator tip speed, which may vary for different ore types and lithium concentrations. Slurry wt. % solids ranges from 10 wt. % to 40 wt. %, retention time ranges from 5 minutes to 30 minutes, and agitator tip speed ranges from 200 to 2,000 feet per minute. The amount of stages contained in the attrition scrubber 103 is dependent on the characteristics of the sized sedimentary rock ore 101 being processed.” “[0021] A flow chart depicting the lithium dissolution circuit 200 is shown in FIG. 2. The ore slurry 110 is first added to a series of attack tank reactors 201. An attack tank reactor is an agitated vessel designed to control a chemical reaction between concentrated sulfuric acid and lithium bearing sedimentary ore slurry with the purpose of dissolving lithium from the sedimentary ore. The attack tank reactors 201 are segmented, and the slurry is passed from one segmented section to the next. Throughout this process, sulfuric acid 203 is added to the attack tank circuit and recycled among the segments to maintain an adequate acid strength to promote dissolution of lithium while minimizing the formation of insoluble sulfates such as calcium sulfate that can encapsulate lithium bearing materials and prevent dissolution of lithium. The sulfuric acid 203 is preferably between 90 wt % to 98 wt % sulfuric acid, and more preferably 98 wt % sulfuric acid. Preferably, the sulfate concentration in the aqueous phase ranges from about 10 g/L to 50 g/L excess sulfate.” “[0025] The acidified slurry 212 is added to filter press feed tank of the pressure filtration circuit, where the slurry is heated to 82° C. if not already up to temperature as a result of processing in the lithium dissolution circuit.” “[0030] To remove trace concentrations of divalent cations, magnesium-free lithium sulfate solution 519 is passed through a series of ion exchange cation removal resin beds 520. As the liquor is processed through the resin beds, cation contaminants not completely removed by the precipitation process such as magnesium, calcium, and iron are removed by ion exchange. The process is sequential (loading, regeneration, settling), and requires multiple resin beds operating in parallel to ensure removal of the target elements, and maintain a roughly continuous flow of finished lithium sulfate brine. Preferably, ion exchange cation removal resin beds 520 are either batch or carousel systems with a lead-lag arrangement. Preferably, the resins utilize a divinyl-benzene crosslinked microporous resin with either sulfate or a chelating group. Additionally, a sodium chloride and/or sodium hydroxide solution 521 and hydrochloric acid solution 522 may be used for resin regeneration and stripping. Contaminants removed by the ion exchange resin are discarded. The amount of pressure filters 517 and ion exchange cation removal resin beds 520 utilized is dependent on the quality of the ore that is initially mined.”
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to JOPHY S. KOSHY whose telephone number is (571)272-0030. The examiner can normally be reached M-F 8:30 AM- 5:00 PM.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, KEITH HENDRICKS can be reached at (571)272-1401. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/JOPHY S. KOSHY/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 1733