DETAILED ACTION
Acknowledgments
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
This action is in reply to the RCE, amendment, and response filed on 09/24/2026.
Claims 1-3 have been amended.
Claims 5-9 have been added.
Claim 4 has been canceled.
Claims 1-3 and 5-9 are currently pending and have been examined.
Response to Arguments
Arguments and Assertions by the Applicant
Applicant’s arguments received 09/24/2026 with respect to the prior art rejections have been considered but are moot in view of the new ground(s) of rejection.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102 of this title, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made.
Claims 1-3 and 5-9 are rejected under U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Wentz (USPGP 2020/0153627 A), hereinafter WENTZ, in view of Yuan et al. (USPGP 2016/0253664 A1), hereinafter YAUN.
Claims 1, 2, 9:
WENTZ as shown below discloses the following limitations:
A system for processing certifying instances of digital data generated by a plurality of certifying systems, the system comprising one or more processors and a memory storing instructions that, when executed by the one or more processors, cause the system to process the certifying instances: (see at least Figure 1 as well as associated and related text)
a user identifier comprising a public key of a user terminal, wherein each of the certifying instances is associated with (see at least paragraphs 0053, 0060, 0080)
a storage address; (see at least paragraphs 0053, 0060, 0080, 0134)
a user terminal; (see at least paragraphs 0053, 0060, 0080, 0134)
an ordered list of elements stored on a non-repudiable ledger, each of the elements comprising: (see at least paragraphs 0055, 0126)
an attestation generated by one of the plurality of certifying systems, the attestation comprising a type of attestation, a hash of a document, a time stamp by the certifying system of the time at which the attestation was generated; (see at least paragraphs 0027, 0073, 0075, 0077, 0088)
an electronic signature of the attestation by the certifying system; (see at least paragraphs 0019, 0021)
a time stamp by the processing module of the time at which the element was added to the ordered list, (see at least paragraphs 0088)
a pointer to the document. (see at least paragraphs 0055)
WENTZ does not specifically disclose each of the above limitations within a single embodiment. In this case, each of the elements claimed are all shown by the prior art of record but not necessarily combined as claimed. However, the technical ability exists to combine the elements as claimed and the results of the combination are predictable. Therefore, when combined, the elements perform the same function as they did separately. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Consequently, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the effective filing date to combine/modify the blockchain method of WENTZ because, “Secure storage of authentication information has become an increasingly important problem. Cryptocurrency wallets and “vaults” often are nothing more than a collection of private keys or similar authentication data usable to establish a user's right to transfer value in electronic exchanges. User passwords have similarly become more multifarious and complex in response to mounting computer security concerns, resulting in a need on the part of many users to store such passwords electronically. Unfortunately, secure storage of authentication information has also been plagued with challenges; most notably, heightened security typically reduces accessibility, and makes it possible to lose the information entirely, while convenience can come at a high, and sometimes ruinous, risk of lost value or stolen identities.” (WENTZ: paragraph 0003). Additionally, there is a recognized problem or need in the art including market pressure, design need, etc., and there are a finite number of identified predictable solutions. Accordingly, those in the art could have pursued known solutions with reasonable expectation of success. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Fundamentally, in the competitive business climate, there is a profit-driven motive to maximize the profitability of goods and services that are provided or marketed to customers. Enterprises typically use business planning to make decisions in order to maximize profits.
Claim 3:
WENTZ discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. WENTZ further discloses the following limitations:
a step of verifying the integrity of a file by a user terminal, (see at least paragraph 0004)
said file being received from another user terminal, (see at least Figure 6 as well as associated and related text)
said step comprising the following steps, implemented at the user terminal: (see at least Figure 6 as well as associated and related text)
a. calculating a hash of the received file, (see at least paragraph 0022)
b. receiving, from the other user terminal, a storage address for a certifying instance, (see at least paragraphs 0021, 0053, 0060, 0080, 0134)
c. generating a certifying instance reception request from the storage address and sending it to the system for processing certifying instances of digital data, (see at least paragraphs 0021, 0053, 0060, 0080, 0134)
d. receiving, from the system for processing certifying instances of digital data, the certifying instance associated with the storage address, (see at least paragraphs 0021, 0053, 0060, 0080, 0134)
e. browsing the ordered list of elements of the certifying instance received to determine the presence or absence of a hash of an attestation that is the same as the calculated hash. (see at least paragraphs 0027, 0073, 0075, 0077, 0088)
Claim 5:
WENTZ discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. WENTZ further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors, further cause the system to: receive, from the user terminal associated with a certifying instance, an attestation generated by a certifying system of the plurality of certifying systems, an electronic signature of the attestation and the storage address of the certifying instance;
add, to the ordered list of the certifying instance associated with the storage address, a new element comprising the attestation and the electronic signature.
See at least paragraphs 0027, 0073, 0075, 0077, and 0088.
Claim 6:
WENTZ discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. WENTZ further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the attestation comprises a hash obtained from a file on the certifying system that generated the attestation.
See at least paragraphs 0022 and 0027.
Claim 7:
WENTZ discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. WENTZ further discloses the following limitations:
in response to determining the presence of a hash of an attestation that is the same as the calculated hash, sending, by the user terminal, to each of a plurality of certifying systems that generated respective attestations in the ordered list, a respective verification request comprising the respective attestation.
See at least paragraph 0027.
Claim 8:
WENTZ discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. WENTZ further discloses the following limitations:
receiving, by the user terminal, from each of the plurality of certifying systems, a respective verification response, wherein each respective verification response is positive upon a determination that a hash recalculated by the respective certifying system from a file used to generate the respective attestation matches the hash contained in the respective attestation, and negative otherwise.
See at least paragraphs 0022 and 0027.
CONCLUSION
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure.
Non-Patent Literature:
Jakob Schaerer et al. “Veritaa: A distributed public key infrastructure with signature store.” (06 September 2021). Retrieved online 12/13/2025. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1002/nem.2183
Relevancy: “Today, the integrity and authenticity of digital documents and data are often hard to verify. Existing public key infrastructures (PKIs) are capable of certifying digital identities but do not provide solutions to store signatures immutably, and the process of certification is often not transparent. We propose Veritaa, a distributed public key infrastructure with an integrated signature store (DPKISS). The central part of Veritaa is the Graph of Trust that manages identity claims and singed declarations between identity claims and document identifiers. An application-specific distributed ledger is used to store the transactions that form the Graph of Trust immutably. For the distributed certification of identity claims, a reputation system based on signed trust declarations and domain vetting is used. In this work, we have designed and implemented the proposed architecture of Veritaa, created a testbed, and performed several experiments. The experiments show the benefits and the high performance of Veritaa.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Conner Fromknecht et al. “A Decentralized Public Key Infrastructure with Identity Retention.” (November 11, 2014). Retrieved online 12/13/2025. A Decentralized Public Key Infrastructure with Identity Retention
Relevancy: “Public key infrastructures (PKIs) enable users to look up and verify one another's public keys based on identities. Current approaches to PKIs are vulnerable because they do not offer sufficiently strong guarantees of \emph{identity retention}; that is, they do not effectively prevent one user from registering a public key under another's already-registered identity. In this paper, we leverage the consistency guarantees provided by cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin and Namecoin to build a PKI that ensures identity retention. Our system, called Certcoin, has no central authority and thus requires the use of secure distributed dictionary data structures to provide efficient support for key lookup.” (Abstract/Introduction)
OMAR et al. “BLOCKCHAIN BASED FRAMEWORK FOR EDUCATIONAL CERTIFICATES VERIFICATION.” (18.01.2020). Retrieved online 12/13/2025. (PDF) BLOCKCHAIN BASED FRAMEWORK FOR EDUCATIONAL CERTIFICATES VERIFICATION
Relevancy: “Document verification is a complex domain that involves various challenging and tedious processes to authenticate. Moreover various types of documents for instance banking documents, government documents, transaction documents, educational certificates etc. might involve customized verification and authentication practices. The content for each type vary significantly, hence requires to be dealt in a distinct manner. For students, educational certificates are the most important documents issued by their universities. However, as the issuing process is not that transparent and verifiable, fake certificates can be easily created. A skilfully generated fake certificate is always hard to detect and can be treated as the original. With the increase of forged documents, credibility of both the document holder and the issuing authority is jeopardized. Blockchain technology has recently emerged as a potential mean for authenticating the document verification process and a significant tool to combat document fraud and misuse. This research aimed to enhance the document verification process using blockchain technology. In this research, authors have identified the security themes required for document verification in the blockchain. This research also identifies the gaps and loopholes in the current blockchain based educational certificate verification solutions. At the end, a blockchain based framework for verifying educational certificates focusing on themes including authentication, authorization, confidentiality, privacy and ownership is proposed using the Hyperledger Fabric Framework.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Foreign Art:
DOUGLASS et al. “Method For Verifying E.g. Video Recording Of Court Hearing, Involves Receiving Confirmation Of Approval Of Certification Requests By Blockchain, And Generating And/or Displaying Verification Confirmation On Electronic Device.” (EP 3454523 A1)
Relevancy: “The method involves creating a recording (10) using an electronic device (12) and generating an electronic recording file (102) using the electronic device, where the electronic recording file comprises information based on the recording and pieces of data associated with the recording. The electronic recording file is sent to a certification server (13) using the electronic device. Certification requests (15, 16) are generated based on a portion of the information in the electronic recording file using the certification server. The certification requests are sent to a blockchain (17). Confirmation of approval of the certification requests is received by the blockchain using the certification server. A verification confirmation (112) is generated and/or displayed on the electronic device.” (Abstract/Introduction)
BERKERMAN et al. “Method For Facilitating Tokenization Of E.g. Pharmaceutical Products, In Distributed Ledger Environment, Involves Generating Non-certified Token Being Assigned To Physical Object For Representing Object Identification Data.” (EP 3534288 A2)
Relevancy: “The method involves generating or receiving object identification data based on inspection of a physical object, where the object identification data comprises a cryptographic hash value as a collision-resistant virtual representation of the physical object. A non-certified token being assigned to the physical object is generated for representing the object identification data. A non-certified token validation request data is communicated through a token framework to multiple certification systems (4). Token certification data is received, where the token certification data represents certification of the previously non-certified token by the certification systems.” (Abstract/Introduction)
BAUCHOT et al. “Generating Method For Authenticity Certificate To Be Stored On Media Involves Transmitting Encrypted Step Certificate And Encrypted Random Key To Be Written On Media.” (WO 2007/113040 A1)
Relevancy: “The step certificate is encrypted using the generated random key. A random key, media identifier, and media key block are transmitted to clearing house. The encrypted random key is received from clearing house based upon random key, media identifier, and media key block. The encrypted step certificate and encrypted random key to be written are transmitted on media.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Any inquiry of a general nature or relating to the status of this application or concerning this communication or earlier communications from the Examiner should be directed to James A. Reagan (james.reagan@uspto.gov) whose telephone number is 571.272.6710. The Examiner can normally be reached Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the Examiner’s supervisor, John Hayes, can be reached at 571.272.6708.
Information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from the Patent Application Information Retrieval (PAIR) system. Status information for published applications may be obtained from either Private PAIR or Public PAIR. Status information for unpublished applications is available through Private PAIR only. For more information about the PAIR system, see http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair . Should you have questions on access to the Private PAIR system, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866.217.9197 (toll-free).
Any response to this action should be mailed to:
Commissioner for Patents
PO Box 1450
Alexandria, Virginia 22313-1450
or faxed to 571-273-8300.
Hand delivered responses should be brought to the United States Patent and Trademark Office Customer Service Window:
Randolph Building
401 Dulany Street
Alexandria, VA 22314.
/JAMES A REAGAN/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3697
james.reagan@uspto.gov
571.272.6710 (Office)
571.273.6710 (Desktop Fax)