Prosecution Insights
Last updated: November 20, 2026
Application No. 18/921,466

INTELLIGENT FLAGGING AND RECAP GENERATION FOR MEDIA CONTENT

Final Rejection §103
Filed
Oct 21, 2024
Examiner
TRAN, LOI H
Art Unit
2484
Tech Center
2400 — Computer Networks
Assignee
DISH Network LLC
OA Round
2 (Final)
65%
Grant Probability
Favorable
3-4
OA Rounds
8m
Est. Remaining
88%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants 65% — above average
65%
Career Allowance Rate
411 granted / 631 resolved
+7.1% vs TC avg
Strong +23% interview lift
Without
With
+23.3%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
2y 9m
Avg Prosecution
22 currently pending
Career history
668
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
8.1%
-31.9% vs TC avg
§103
66.1%
+26.1% vs TC avg
§102
9.3%
-30.7% vs TC avg
§112
14.1%
-25.9% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 631 resolved cases

Office Action

§103
DETAILED ACTION The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Response to Arguments 2. Applicant's arguments with respect to the rejections of claims 1-12 and 20 have been considered but are moot in view of new grounds of rejection. Response to Amendment Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103 3. The text of those sections of Title 35, U.S. Code not included in this section can be found in a prior Office action. 4. Claims 1-6, 8-12, and 20 are rejected under AIA 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over by Wolf et al. (US Publication 2020/0237452) in view of Gao et al. (English Translation of Chinese Publication 115630188 11-2023). Regarding claim 1, Wolf discloses an automated process for generating flags and recaps for content (Wolf, fig. 5, a process for generating markers and displaying content of a video), the automated process comprising: retrieving program data related to a selected program in response to a request for a summary of the selected program (Wolf, fig. 5, para’s 0143-0145, accessing at least one video of a surgical procedure; para’s 0114 and 0153-0166, identifying video footage locations represented as one or more pixels, voxels, bounding boxes, bounding polygons, bounding shapes, coordinates, and so forth; computer analysis may include using one or more image recognition algorithms to identify features of one or more frames of the video footage; computer analysis may include using one or more image recognition algorithms to identify features of one or more frames of the video footage. Computer analysis may include object detection algorithms, such as Viola-Jones object detection, scale-invariant feature transform (SIFT), histogram of oriented gradients (HOG) features, convolutional neural networks (CNN), or any other forms of object detection algorithms. Other example algorithms may include video tracking algorithms, motion detection algorithms, feature detection algorithms, color-based detection algorithms, texture-based detection algorithms, shape-based detection algorithms, boosting based detection algorithms, face detection algorithms, or any other suitable algorithm for analyzing video frames. In one example, a machine learning model may be trained using training examples to identify particular locations within videos, and the trained machine learning model may be used to analyze the video footage and identify the video footage location. An example of such training example may include a video clip together with a label indicating a location within a video clip, or together with a label indicating that no corresponding location is included within the video clip.; para. 0206, upon request of a user, presenting to the user an aggregate of the first group of frames of the particular surgical video footage, while omitting presentation to the user of the second group of frames); analyzing the program data using an artificial intelligence (AI) model to generate flags for scenes of interest in the selected program, wherein a second subset of the flags identifies scenes containing content relevant to later content (Wolf, para’s 0101-0102, providing for unconventional approaches that efficiently and effectively enable a surgeon to view a surgical video summary that aggregates footage of relevant surgical events “scenes of interest” while omitting other irrelevant footage. An interface may allow a surgeon to review surgical video (of their own surgeries, other's surgeries, or compilations) with a surgical timeline simultaneously displayed. The timeline may include markers keyed to activities or events that occur during a surgical procedure. These markers may allow the surgeon to skip to particular activities to thereby streamline review of the surgical procedure; para. 0114, computer analysis may be used to analyze frames of the video footage and identify markers to include at various locations in the timeline. In one example, a machine learning model may be trained using training examples to generate markers for videos, and the trained machine learning model may be used to analyze the video and generate markers for that video. Such generated markers may include locations within the video for the marker, type of the marker, properties of the marker, and so forth; para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames); and playing back the selected program with a plurality of flags comprising the second subset of the flags overlayed on a timeline of the selected program during playback of the content (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames; para. 0452, time markers may be an icon or other graphic that appears on an active or static timeline of some or all of a surgical procedure. If active, the time marker may be clickable (or otherwise selectable) to cause footage of the associated event to be presented. The marker may be caused to appear in footage, either through a textual or graphic overlay on the footage or through an identifying audio indicator embedded for playback presentation; fig. 4 also illustrates overlaid time markers on a timeline of a video presentation); aggregating the scenes of interest identified by the second subset of the flags into a recap of the content relevant to the later content (Wolf, para. 0215, fig. 10 step 1040, process 1000 may include generating a cause-effect summary of the surgical footage, wherein the cause-effect summary includes the cause set of frames and the outcome set of frames and omits the intermediate set of frames); presenting the recap to a viewer in response to the viewer initiating playback of the later content (Wolf, para. 0218, at step 1140, process 1100 may include, upon request of a user, presenting to the user an aggregate of the first group of frames of the particular surgical footage, while omitting presentation to the user of the second group of frames). Wolf does not explicitly disclose but Gao discloses: retrieve playback interaction data describing playback interactions performed by a plurality of other viewers of the selected program (Gao, para. 0045, obtain a set of positive feedback video segments, and a set of negative feedback video segments. The set of positive feedback video segments is the collection of video segments from the original sample video that the user watched in its entirety, while the set of negative feedback video segments is the collection of video segments where the user skipped the video; the samples used during model training fully consider the fine-grained interaction characteristics between the user and the entire video at the segment level, enabling the model to capture the differences in user interest in different parts of a video. This allows the trained video recommendation model to capture the user's interest in the video to be recommended from a fine-grained perspective at the video segment level. The calculation of interest is more accurate, and therefore, when recommending videos based on the interest output of the video recommendation model, it can recommend videos that better match the user's interests, thus improving the accuracy of video recommendations; para. 0055, among the various user interactions with videos, watching and skipping are the most important user feedback; para’s 0100 and 0133, the original sample videos can be obtained by collecting users' historical interaction video data. This historical interaction video data consists of the original video file data of the user's interaction videos, which carries all the information of the video and can support fine-grained segmentation processing; the sample video clips used during the training of the video recommendation model can be historical interaction videos from multiple users. This allows determining the set of positive feedback video segments and the set of negative feedback video segments from the original sample videos); analyzing the playback interaction data to generate a first subset of the flags for scenes of interest in the selected program, wherein the first subset of the flags identifies commonly rewatched or skipped segments based on the playback interaction data (Gao, para. 0074, each original video sample can be uniformly divided into 5 video segments. When a user watches the original video sample A, if they skip the second video segment of A, that second video segment can be used as a negative feedback video segment. If they watch all 5 video segments of the original video sample A, then all 5 video segments can be used as positive feedback video segments. Understandably, for any original sample video, if there are any unwatched video segments, none of the five video segments of that original sample video will be used as positive feedback video segments; for any video segment, if a skipping action occurs on that video segment, that video segment will be used as a negative feedback video segment; clearly the position of the segment that was skipped indicates a flag of the skipped segment). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to incorporate Gao’s features into Wolf’s invention for enhancing user’s playback experience by allowing user to visually select the segments of interest. It is also obvious that the combination of Wolf‘s playing back the selected program with a plurality of flags comprising the second subset of the flags overlayed on a timeline of the selected program during playback of the content and Gao’s first subset of the flags would also enable playing back the selected program with a plurality of flags comprising the first subset of the flags overlayed on a timeline of the selected program during playback of the content by allowing user to visually select the segments based on other users’ viewing history. Regarding claim 2, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, wherein the flags identify the scenes of interest as containing content relevant to later content (Wolf, para. 0340, obtaining any suitable data related to a past, present or future surgical procedure that correspondingly was previously performed, or ongoing or scheduled to be performed in the surgical operating room. Such data may include a name of a procedure, a surgeon performing the procedure, a name of a patient, any characteristic parameters related to the patient or/and medical personnel, a starting time or an estimated starting time for the procedure. This indicates the marker as disclosed is associated with a timed event relevant to later content). Regarding claim 3, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 2, further comprising aggregating the scenes of interest identified by the flags to automatically generate the recap of the content relevant to the later content (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames). Regarding claim 4, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 3, further comprising presenting the recap to a viewer in response to the viewer initiating playback of the later content (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user). Regarding claim 5, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, wherein a flag from the flags identifies a playback action taken by other users at a corresponding location on the timeline of the selected program (Wolf, para. 0145, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video, to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. The surgeon may be able to view additional information about the event or occurrence associated with the marker, which may include information from past surgical procedures. For example, the markers may be associated with an intraoperative surgical event and selecting the marker may enable the surgeon to view alternative video clips of past surgical procedures associated with the intraoperative surgical event. For example, the surgeon may be enabled to view clips from other surgeries where a similar intraoperative surgical event was handled differently, where a different technique was used, or where an outcome varied. In some embodiments, the marker may be a decision-making junction marker, representing a decision that was made during the surgical procedure. Selecting the decision-making junction marker may enable the surgeon to view information about the decision, including alternative decisions. Such information may include videos of past surgical procedures including similar decision-making junctions, a list or distribution of alternate possible decisions, estimated outcomes of the alternate possible decisions, or any other relevant information. Based on the steps described in process 500, the surgeon or other users may be able to more effectively and more efficiently review surgical videos using the timeline interface). Regarding claim 6, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 5, further comprising executing the playback action in response to a user interaction with the flag (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames). Regarding claim 8, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, wherein the selected program comprises a live event, wherein the request for a summary is generated in response to the live event ending (Wolf, para. 0021, the received video footage may be analyzed using the image-related data to determine, in real time, an existence of a surgical decision-making junction; para. 0503, aspects of disclosed embodiments may further include identifying an indication of a deviation between a specific surgical procedure and a recommended sequence of events for the surgical procedure. In some cases, identifying an indication of a deviation may include identifying an indication of a deviation during an ongoing surgical procedure, such as, for example, in real time during the surgical procedure. In various embodiments, the deviation may be identified with a small delay as measured from the ongoing time of the surgical procedure due to processing related to identifying an indication of a deviation. The delay may be a millisecond, a second, a few seconds, a few tens of seconds, a minute, a few minutes, and the like. Once the deviation is identified, disclosure embodiments may include providing a notification during the ongoing surgical procedure. (e.g., provide the notification as soon as the deviation is identified). For example, providing a notification may occur in real time during the surgical procedure) Regarding claim 9, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, wherein the selected program comprises a live event, wherein the request for a summary is generated in response to a recording of the live event completing (Wolf; para’s 0105 and 0194, surgical video footage may be recorded by an image capturing device; the footage may be recorded during the surgical procedure, i.e., live event recording). Regarding claim 10, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, wherein a flag from the flags identifies a segment of the selected program of low interest (Wolf, para. 0237, embodiments of the present disclosure may further include omitting portions of the identified specific frames, for example, to avoid redundancy, to shorten the resulting compilation, to remove less relevant or less informative portions). Regarding claim 11, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, wherein a flag from the flags identifies a segment of the selected program in response to a person of interest to the viewer appearing in the segment (Wolf, para. 0085, the cameras may capture the video/image data at a location 127 of a body of patient143 on which a surgical procedure is performed, the video/image data of a surgeon 131 performing the surgery., or the surgical team personnel, such as an anesthesiologist, nurses, surgical tech and the like located in operating room). Regarding claim 12, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1, further comprising: presenting a first flagged scene of the selected program; and skipping to a next flagged scene of the selected program in response to the first flagged scene ending (Wolf, para’s 0101-0102, when preparing for a surgical procedure, it may be beneficial for a surgeon to review video footage of surgical procedures having similar surgical events. It may be too time consuming, however, for a surgeon to view the entire video or to skip around to find relevant portions of the surgical footage. Therefore, there is a need for unconventional approaches that efficiently and effectively enable a surgeon to view a surgical video summary that aggregates footage of relevant surgical events while omitting other irrelevant footage. Aspects of this disclosure may relate to reviewing surgical video, including methods, systems, devices, and computer readable media. An interface may allow a surgeon to review surgical video (of their own surgeries, other's surgeries, or compilations) with a surgical timeline simultaneously displayed. The timeline may include markers keyed to activities or events that occur during a surgical procedure. These markers may allow the surgeon to act on selected markers and skip to particular activities to thereby streamline review of the surgical procedure). Regarding claim 20, Wolf discloses a non-transitory computer-readable medium configured to store instructions thereon that, when executed by a computer-based system, cause the computer-based system to perform operations (Wolf, para. 0220, computer readable media), the operations comprising: retrieving program data related to a selected in response to a request for a summary of the selected program (Wolf, fig. 5, para’s 0143-0145, accessing at least one video of a surgical procedure; para’s 0114 and 0153-0166, identifying video footage locations represented as one or more pixels, voxels, bounding boxes, bounding polygons, bounding shapes, coordinates, and so forth; computer analysis may include using one or more image recognition algorithms to identify features of one or more frames of the video footage; computer analysis may include using one or more image recognition algorithms to identify features of one or more frames of the video footage); analyzing the program data using an artificial intelligence (AI) model to generate flags for scenes of interest in the selected program (Wolf, para’s 0101-0102, providing for unconventional approaches that efficiently and effectively enable a surgeon to view a surgical video summary that aggregates footage of relevant surgical events “scenes of interest” while omitting other irrelevant footage. An interface may allow a surgeon to review surgical video (of their own surgeries, other's surgeries, or compilations) with a surgical timeline simultaneously displayed. The timeline may include markers keyed to activities or events that occur during a surgical procedure. These markers may allow the surgeon to skip to particular activities to thereby streamline review of the surgical procedure; para. 0114, computer analysis may be used to analyze frames of the video footage and identify markers to include at various locations in the timeline. In one example, a machine learning model may be trained using training examples to generate markers for videos, and the trained machine learning model may be used to analyze the video and generate markers for that video. Such generated markers may include locations within the video for the marker, type of the marker, properties of the marker, and so forth; para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames); and playing back the selected program with the flags overlayed on a timeline during playback of the selected program (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames; para. 0452, time markers may be an icon or other graphic that appears on an active or static timeline of some or all of a surgical procedure. If active, the time marker may be clickable (or otherwise selectable) to cause footage of the associated event to be presented. The marker may be caused to appear in footage, either through a textual or graphic overlay on the footage or through an identifying audio indicator embedded for playback presentation; fig. 4 also illustrates overlaid time markers on a timeline of a video presentation). Wolf does not explicitly disclose but Gao discloses: retrieving a viewing history of a viewer (Gao, para. 0045, obtain a set of positive feedback video segments, and a set of negative feedback video segments. The set of positive feedback video segments is the collection of video segments from the original sample video that the user watched in its entirety, while the set of negative feedback video segments is the collection of video segments where the user skipped the video; the samples used during model training fully consider the fine-grained interaction characteristics between the user and the entire video at the segment level, enabling the model to capture the differences in user interest in different parts of a video. This allows the trained video recommendation model to capture the user's interest in the video to be recommended from a fine-grained perspective at the video segment level. The calculation of interest is more accurate, and therefore, when recommending videos based on the interest output of the video recommendation model, it can recommend videos that better match the user's interests, thus improving the accuracy of video recommendations; para. 0055, among the various user interactions with videos, watching and skipping are the most important user feedback; para’s 0100 and 0133, the original sample videos can be obtained by collecting users' historical interaction video data); analyzing the viewing history of the viewer to generate flags for scenes of interest in the selected program (Gao, para. 0074, each original video sample can be uniformly divided into 5 video segments. When a user watches the original video sample A, if they skip the second video segment of A, that second video segment can be used as a negative feedback video segment. If they watch all 5 video segments of the original video sample A, then all 5 video segments can be used as positive feedback video segments. Understandably, for any original sample video, if there are any unwatched video segments, none of the five video segments of that original sample video will be used as positive feedback video segments; for any video segment, if a skipping action occurs on that video segment, that video segment will be used as a negative feedback video segment; clearly the position of the segment that was skipped indicates a flag of the skipped segment; para. 0055, among the various user interactions with videos, watching and skipping are the most important user feedback; para’s 0100 and 0133, the original sample videos can be obtained by collecting users' historical interaction video data); It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to incorporate Gao’s features into Wolf’s invention for enhancing user’s playback experience by allowing user to visually select the segments of interest. It is also obvious that the combination of Wolf‘s playing back the selected program with the flags overlayed on a timeline of the selected program during playback of the content and Gao’s generating of the flags based on the viewing history would also enable playing back the selected program with the flags based on the viewing history overlayed on a timeline during playback of the selected program. 5. Claim 7 is rejected under AIA 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Wolf-Gao, as applied to claim 1 above, in view of O’Neill (US Publication 2024/0412542). Regarding claim 7, Wolf-Gao discloses the automated process of claim 1. Wolf-Gao does not explicitly disclose but O’Neill discloses wherein the selected program comprises a sporting event, wherein a flag from the flags identifies a segment of the selected program including a scoring play (O’Neill, para’s 0087, 0092, and 0305, an important play in a sporting event obviously may include a scoring play involving one or more players). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to incorporate O’Neill’s features into Wolf-Gao’s invention for enhancing user’s playback experience by providing an edited video to include a sport scoring play. 6. Claim 13 and 15-19 are rejected under AIA 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over by Wolf et al. (US Publication 2020/0237452) in view of Kim et al. (US Publication 2023/0110006). Regarding claim 13, Wolf discloses an automated process for generating flags and recaps for content (Wolf, fig. 5, a process for generating markers and displaying content of a video), the automated process comprising: retrieving program data related to a selected program in response to a request for a summary of the selected program, wherein the viewer data comprises a viewing history of the viewer (Wolf, fig. 5, para’s 0143-0145, accessing at least one video of a surgical procedure; para’s 0114 and 0153-0166, identifying video footage locations represented as one or more pixels, voxels, bounding boxes, bounding polygons, bounding shapes, coordinates, and so forth; computer analysis may include using one or more image recognition algorithms to identify features of one or more frames of the video footage; computer analysis may include using one or more image recognition algorithms to identify features of one or more frames of the video footage. Computer analysis may include object detection algorithms, such as Viola-Jones object detection, scale-invariant feature transform (SIFT), histogram of oriented gradients (HOG) features, convolutional neural networks (CNN), or any other forms of object detection algorithms. Other example algorithms may include video tracking algorithms, motion detection algorithms, feature detection algorithms, color-based detection algorithms, texture-based detection algorithms, shape-based detection algorithms, boosting based detection algorithms, face detection algorithms, or any other suitable algorithm for analyzing video frames. In one example, a machine learning model may be trained using training examples to identify particular locations within videos, and the trained machine learning model may be used to analyze the video footage and identify the video footage location. An example of such training example may include a video clip together with a label indicating a location within a video clip, or together with a label indicating that no corresponding location is included within the video clip; para. 0206, upon request of a user, presenting to the user an aggregate of the first group of frames of the particular surgical video footage, while omitting presentation to the user of the second group of frames); analyzing the program data and the viewer data using an artificial intelligence (AI) model to generate flags for scenes of interest to the viewer in the selected program [based on the viewing history of the viewer, wherein analyzing the viewer data comprises comparing the viewing history of the viewer with viewing histories of other users having similar viewing traits to identify the scenes of interest to the viewer ] (Wolf, para’s 0101-0102, providing for unconventional approaches that efficiently and effectively enable a surgeon to view a surgical video summary that aggregates footage of relevant surgical events “scenes of interest” while omitting other irrelevant footage. An interface may allow a surgeon to review surgical video (of their own surgeries, other's surgeries, or compilations) with a surgical timeline simultaneously displayed. The timeline may include markers keyed to activities or events that occur during a surgical procedure. These markers may allow the surgeon to skip to particular activities to thereby streamline review of the surgical procedure; para. 0114, computer analysis may be used to analyze frames of the video footage and identify markers to include at various locations in the timeline. In one example, a machine learning model may be trained using training examples to generate markers for videos, and the trained machine learning model may be used to analyze the video and generate markers for that video. Such generated markers may include locations within the video for the marker, type of the marker, properties of the marker, and so forth; para. 0189, storing an event characteristic associated with the particular intraoperative surgical event. As discussed in greater detail above, the event characteristic may include an adverse outcome of the surgical event, a surgical technique, a surgeon skill level, a patient characteristic, an identity of a specific surgeon, a physiological response, a duration of the event, or any other characteristic or property associated with the event. The event characteristic may be manually determined (for example, inputted by a viewer), or may be determined automatically through artificial intelligence applied to machine vision, for example as described above. In one example, the event characteristic may include skill level (such as minimal skill level required, skill level demonstrated during the event, etc.), a machine learning model may be trained using training example to determine such skill levels from videos, and the trained machine learning model may be used to analyze the video footage to determine the skill level); aggregating the scenes of interest to the viewer into a recap, wherein the recap comprises a shorter duration than the selected program (Wolf, para’s 0101-0102, aggregates footage of relevant surgical events while omitting other irrelevant footage; para. 0124, selecting the decision marker may open a menu or otherwise display options for viewing the alternative video clips. For example, selecting the decision naming marker may pop up an alternative video menu containing depictions of the conduct in the associated alternative video clips. The alternative video clips may be presented as thumbnails, text-based descriptions, video previews (e.g., playing a smaller resolution version or shortened clip); and playing back the recap to the viewer in response to the viewer initiating playback (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames; para. 0452, time markers may be an icon or other graphic that appears on an active or static timeline of some or all of a surgical procedure. If active, the time marker may be clickable (or otherwise selectable) to cause footage of the associated event to be presented. The marker may be caused to appear in footage, either through a textual or graphic overlay on the footage or through an identifying audio indicator embedded for playback presentation; fig. 4 also illustrates overlaid time markers on a timeline of a video presentation). Wolf does not explicitly disclose but Kim discloses: wherein the viewer data comprises a viewing history of the viewer (Kim, para’s 0151, obtaining viewing history of a viewer). analyzing the viewer data to generate flags for scenes of interest to the viewer in the selected program based on the viewing history of the viewer, wherein analyzing the viewer data comprises comparing the viewing history of the viewer with viewing histories of other users having similar viewing traits to identify the scenes of interest to the viewer (Kim, para’s 0144-0145, the recommended content determination module 124-1 may mean a module that determines at least one recommended content based on prediction information for each content acquired by the prediction information generation module for each content 123-5. For example, the recommended content determination module 124-1 may determine three content items having the highest probability value from among ten predetermined content items as recommended content; identifying a particular content item(s) as recommended content implies providing indicator(s) or flag(s) for identifying the particular content item(s); para. 0152, the electronic apparatus 100 may obtain attribute information for each content by inputting the graph information to the graph neural network model 123 at operation S425. The attribute information for each content may be information related to a user's viewing pattern. The electronic apparatus 100 may identify a viewing group based on the graph information and the attribute information for each content at operation S430. The electronic apparatus 100 may determine to which viewing group a user using the terminal apparatus 200 belongs. The viewing group may be at least two predetermined groups). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to incorporate Kim’s features into Wolf’s invention for enhancing user’s playback experience by allowing user to visually select media segments that are comparable to viewing history of a plurality of viewers. Regarding claim 15, Wolf-Kim discloses the automated process of claim 13, wherein the flags identify the scenes of interest as containing content relevant to later content (Wolf, para. 0340, obtaining any suitable data related to a past, present or future surgical procedure that correspondingly was previously performed, or ongoing or scheduled to be performed in the surgical operating room. Such data may include a name of a procedure, a surgeon performing the procedure, a name of a patient, any characteristic parameters related to the patient or/and medical personnel, a starting time or an estimated starting time for the procedure. This indicates the marker as disclosed is associated with a timed event relevant to later content). Regarding claim 16, Wolf-Kim discloses the automated process of claim 13, wherein a flag from the flags identifies a playback action taken by other users at a corresponding location on the timeline of the selected program (Wolf, para. 0145, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video, to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. The surgeon may be able to view additional information about the event or occurrence associated with the marker, which may include information from past surgical procedures. For example, the markers may be associated with an intraoperative surgical event and selecting the marker may enable the surgeon to view alternative video clips of past surgical procedures associated with the intraoperative surgical event. For example, the surgeon may be enabled to view clips from other surgeries where a similar intraoperative surgical event was handled differently, where a different technique was used, or where an outcome varied. In some embodiments, the marker may be a decision-making junction marker, representing a decision that was made during the surgical procedure. Selecting the decision-making junction marker may enable the surgeon to view information about the decision, including alternative decisions. Such information may include videos of past surgical procedures including similar decision-making junctions, a list or distribution of alternate possible decisions, estimated outcomes of the alternate possible decisions, or any other relevant information. Based on the steps described in process 500, the surgeon or other users may be able to more effectively and more efficiently review surgical videos using the timeline interface). Regarding claim 17, Wolf-Kim discloses the automated process of claim 16, further comprising executing the playback action in response to a user interaction with the flag (Wolf, para. 0111, enabling a surgeon, while viewing playback of the at least one video to select one or more markers on the surgical timeline, and thereby cause a display of the video to skip to a location associated with the selected marker. As used herein, “playback” may include any presentation of a video in which one or more frames of the video are displayed to the user. Typically, playback will include sequentially displaying the images to reproduce moving images and/or sounds, however playback may also include the display of individual frames). Regarding claim 18, Wolf-Kim discloses the automated process of claim 13, wherein the selected program comprises a live event, wherein the request for a summary is generated in response to the live event being broadcast (Wolf, para. 0021, the received video footage may be analyzed using the image-related data to determine, in real time, an existence of a surgical decision-making junction; para. 0503, aspects of disclosed embodiments may further include identifying an indication of a deviation between a specific surgical procedure and a recommended sequence of events for the surgical procedure. In some cases, identifying an indication of a deviation may include identifying an indication of a deviation during an ongoing surgical procedure, such as, for example, in real time during the surgical procedure. In various embodiments, the deviation may be identified with a small delay as measured from the ongoing time of the surgical procedure due to processing related to identifying an indication of a deviation. The delay may be a millisecond, a second, a few seconds, a few tens of seconds, a minute, a few minutes, and the like. Once the deviation is identified, disclosure embodiments may include providing a notification during the ongoing surgical procedure. (e.g., provide the notification as soon as the deviation is identified). For example, providing a notification may occur in real time during the surgical procedure) Regarding claim 19, Wolf-Kim discloses the automated process of claim 18, wherein the selected program comprises a live event, wherein the request for a summary is generated in response to a recording of the live event progressing through the broadcast (Wolf; para’s 0105 and 0194, surgical video footage may be recorded by an image capturing device; the footage may be recorded during the surgical procedure, i.e., live event recording). 7. Claim 14 is rejected under AIA 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Wolf-Kim, as applied to claim 13 above, in view of O’Neill (US Publication 2024/0412542). Regarding claim 14, Wolf-Kim discloses the automated process of claim 13. Wolf-Kim does not explicitly disclose but O’Neill discloses wherein the selected program comprises a sporting event, wherein the flags identify segments of the selected program containing highlights for a selected player (O’Neill, para’s 0087, 0092, and 0305, an important play in a sporting event obviously may include a scoring play involving one or more players). It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to incorporate O’Neill’s features into Wolf-Kim’s invention for enhancing user’s playback experience by providing an edited video to include a player’s highlight in a sport match. Conclusion 8. Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a). A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action. 9. Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to LOI H TRAN whose telephone number is (571)270-5645. The examiner can normally be reached 8:00AM-5:00PM PST FIRST FRIDAY OF BIWEEK OFF. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, THAI TRAN can be reached at 571-272-7382. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /LOI H TRAN/ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2484
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Oct 21, 2024
Application Filed
Apr 23, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §103
Jul 14, 2026
Response Filed
Sep 22, 2026
Final Rejection mailed — §103
Nov 13, 2026
Interview Requested

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12795227
OBJECT TRACKING APPARATUS, METHOD OF CONTROLLING THE SAME AND STORAGE MEDIUM
1y 9m to grant Granted Nov 10, 2026
Patent 12786506
SYSTEM AND METHOD TO REVIEW ONLINE VIOLENCE AND EDUCATION
2y 4m to grant Granted Nov 03, 2026
Patent 12776201
SYSTEM FOR MONITORING EVENT RELATED DATA
1y 7m to grant Granted Oct 27, 2026
Patent 12764415
IMAGING DEVICE, IMAGING INSTRUCTION METHOD, AND IMAGING INSTRUCTION PROGRAM
1y 11m to grant Granted Oct 13, 2026
Patent 12755902
VIDEO SURVEILLANCE PLAYBACK SYSTEM WITH MULTI-TIERED STORAGE
3y 9m to grant Granted Oct 06, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 5 most recent grants.

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

3-4
Expected OA Rounds
65%
Grant Probability
88%
With Interview (+23.3%)
2y 9m (~8m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
Moderate
PTA Risk
Based on 631 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month