DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112(b):
(b) CONCLUSION.—The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor regards as the invention.
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph:
The specification shall conclude with one or more claims particularly pointing out and distinctly claiming the subject matter which the applicant regards as his invention.
Claims 1-17 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), second paragraph, as being indefinite for failing to particularly point out and distinctly claim the subject matter which the inventor or a joint inventor (or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the applicant), regards as the invention.
It is noted that the conditional step of “determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit” and “determining if further cooling is needed for the LT space” may never occur. In particular, claim 1 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange or further cooling), actually does not occurs, or is ever required to not occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 1, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 2 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange or further cooling), actually does not occurs, or is ever required to not occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 2, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 3 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 3, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “ if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 4 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 4, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit” and “determining if further cooling is needed for the LT space may never occur. In particular, claim 7 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange or further cooling), actually does not occurs, or is ever required to not occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 7, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit” and “determining if further cooling is needed for the MT space” may never occur. In particular, claim 8 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange or further cooling), actually does not occurs, or is ever required to not occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 8, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “ if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 9 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 9, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 11 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 11, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 11 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 11, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit and the LT compressor unit” and “determining if further cooling is needed for the MT space or the LT space” may never occur. In particular, claim 13 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange or further cooling), actually does not occurs, or is ever required to not occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 13, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “ if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 15 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 15, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
It is noted that the conditional step of “if heat exchange should not occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit” may never occur. In particular, claim 17 does not recite the condition precedent (i.e. heat exchange), actually does occurs, or is ever required to occur, within the broadest reasonable interpretation. Since the recited “if” conditions need not be satisfied to meet the claim, the recited steps of determining need not occur to satisfy the claim. As such, the Examiner need not present evidence establishing the obviousness of the conditional "if” step of claim 17, because it is not required to be performed under the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim.
Claims 5-6, 10, 12, 14, 16 are rejected based on dependency from a rejected claim.
Allowable Subject Matter
Claims 1-17 would be allowable if rewritten or amended to overcome the rejection(s) under 35 U.S.C. 112(b) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), 2nd paragraph, set forth in this Office action.
Reasons for Allowance
The following is an examiner’s statement of reasons for allowance:
Regarding claim 1, the subject matter which is considered to distinguish from the closest prior art of record, Cole (US 20210207851) and Sanders et al (US 20180195773). The prior art of record teaches a method of operating a refrigeration system for cooling a medium temperature (MT) space, the method comprising: cooling a refrigerant using a gas cooler; decreasing the pressure of the refrigerant from the gas cooler using an expansion valve; separating the refrigerant provided by the expansion valve into a vapor refrigerant and a liquid refrigerant using a flash tank; transferring a portion of the liquid refrigerant from the flash tank to a MT evaporator unit; cooling the MT space using the MT evaporator unit; compressing the refrigerant from the MT evaporator unit using a MT compressor unit in contrast to the claimed features of determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit; if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit: transferring heat from a portion of the refrigerant provided by the MT compressor unit to a portion of the refrigerant provided by a low temperature (LT) compressor unit using a heat exchanger to produce a heated refrigerant stream and a cooled refrigerant stream; combining the heated refrigerant stream from the heat exchanger with the vapor refrigerant stream from the flash tank; compressing the heated refrigerant stream and the vapor refrigerant stream in a parallel compressor unit; combining the refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit with the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit; transferring a portion of the combined refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit and the MT compressor unit to the gas cooler; and recycling a portion of the combined refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit and the MT compressor unit to the heat exchanger for further heat transfer; determining if further cooling is needed for the MT space; and repeating the method if further cooling is needed.
Regarding claim 7, the subject matter which is considered to distinguish from the closest prior art of record, Cole (US 20210207851) and Sanders et al (US 20180195773). The prior art of record teaches a method of operating a refrigeration system for cooling a low temperature (LT) space, the method comprising: cooling a refrigerant using a gas cooler; decreasing the pressure of the refrigerant from the gas cooler using an expansion valve; separating the refrigerant provided by the expansion valve into a vapor refrigerant and a liquid refrigerant using a flash tank; transferring a portion of the liquid refrigerant from the flash tank to a LT evaporator unit; cooling the LT space using the LT evaporator unit; compressing the refrigerant from the LT evaporator unit using a LT compressor unit in contrast to the claimed features of determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit; if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the LT compressor unit: transferring heat from a portion of the refrigerant provided by a medium temperature (MT) compressor unit to a portion of the refrigerant provided by the LT compressor unit using a heat exchanger to produce a heated refrigerant stream and a cooled refrigerant stream; combining the heated refrigerant stream from the heat exchanger with the vapor refrigerant stream from the flash tank; compressing the heated refrigerant stream and the vapor refrigerant stream in a parallel compressor unit; combining the refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit with the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit; transferring a portion of the combined refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit and the MT compressor unit to the gas cooler; and recycling a portion of the combined refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit and the MT compressor unit to the heat exchanger for further heat transfer; determining if further cooling is needed for the LT space; and repeating the method if further cooling is needed.
Regarding claim 13, the subject matter which is considered to distinguish from the closest prior art of record, Cole (US 20210207851) and Sanders et al (US 20180195773). The prior art of record teaches a method of operating a refrigeration system, the method comprising: cooling a refrigerant using a gas cooler; decreasing the pressure of the refrigerant from the gas cooler using an expansion valve; separating the refrigerant provided by the expansion valve into a vapor refrigerant and a liquid refrigerant using a flash tank; determining whether to cool a medium temperature (MT) space or a low temperature (LT) space; if cooling the MT space: transferring a portion of the liquid refrigerant from the flash tank to a MT evaporator unit; cooling the MT space using the MT evaporator unit; and compressing the refrigerant from the MT evaporator unit using a MT compressor unit in contrast to the claimed features of if cooling the LT space: transferring a portion of the liquid refrigerant from the flash tank to a LT evaporator unit; cooling the LT space using the LT evaporator unit; and compressing the refrigerant from the LT evaporator unit using a LT compressor unit; determining if heat exchange should occur for the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit and the LT compressor unit; if heat exchange should occur: transferring heat from a portion of the refrigerant provided by the MT compressor unit to a portion of the refrigerant provided by the LT compressor unit using a heat exchanger to produce a heated refrigerant stream and a cooled refrigerant stream; combining the heated refrigerant stream from the heat exchanger with the vapor refrigerant stream from the flash tank; compressing the heated refrigerant stream and the vapor refrigerant stream in a parallel compressor unit; combining the refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit with the refrigerant compressed by the MT compressor unit; transferring a portion of the combined refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit and the MT compressor unit to the gas cooler; and recycling a portion of the combined refrigerant provided by the parallel compressor unit and the MT compressor unit to the heat exchanger for further heat transfer; determining if further cooling is needed for the MT space or the LT space; and repeating the method if further cooling is needed.
Therefore, it would not be obvious to modify the technique of the prior art structures to have the apparatus as claimed without improper hindsight and independent claims 1, 7 and 13 with dependent claims therefrom are considered allowable.
Conclusion
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to ELIZABETH J MARTIN whose telephone number is (571)270-3840. The examiner can normally be reached 8:30-3:00 CT pm M-F.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Jerry-Daryl Fletcher can be reached at (571) 270-5054. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/ELIZABETH J MARTIN/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3763