DETAILED ACTION
Acknowledgments
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
This action is in reply to the application and preliminary amendment simultaneously filed on 07/09/2025.
Claims 1-9 and 26-34 have been amended.
Claims 10-19, 22-25, and 35-37 have been canceled.
Claims 1-9, 20, 21, and 26-34 are currently pending and have been examined.
Information Disclosure Statement
The Information Disclosure Statement filed on 07/09/2025 has been considered. An initialed copy of the Form 1449 is enclosed herewith.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 1-9, 20, 21, and 26-34 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to non-patent eligible subject matter because the claim(s) as a whole, considering all claim elements both individually and in combination, do not amount to significantly more than an abstract idea.
Step 1:
The claims recite a process, system, apparatus, article of manufacture, and/or a nontransitory storage medium with instructions, each of which are proper statutory categories.
Step 2A (prong 1):
Claim 1 (representative of claims 20 and 29):
The claim limitations are grouped as shown immediately following:
determine a condition to be used in authentication processing based on distribution of collation scores with respect to a master image; (Certain Methods Of Organizing Human Activity - managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people including social activities and following rules or instructions)
execute authentication processing based on an authentication target image and the master image, by using the condition. (Certain Methods Of Organizing Human Activity - managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people including social activities and following rules or instructions)
Additional dependent claims 2-9, 21, 26-28, and 30-34 do not appear remedy the deficiency.
Step 2A (prong 2):
Claim 1 (representative of claims 20 and 29):
An authentication apparatus comprising:
at least one memory storing instructions: and at least one processor configured to execute the instructions to:
…one or more computers
…a non-transitory computer-readable recording medium
These remaining claim limitations are delineated as shown immediately preceding. The abstract idea is not integrated into a practical application. There are no improvements to the functioning of a computer, other technology or technical field, a particular machine is not cited, nothing is transformed to a different state or thing, the abstract idea is not more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the abstract idea. The claim merely uses a computer as a tool to perform the abstract idea, which is generally linked to a particular field of use, in this case, marketing and advertising. Thus, these limitations are recited at a high-level of generality (i.e., as a generic processor and memory performing a generic computer function of processing and storing data) such that it amounts no more than mere instructions to apply the exception using a generic computer component – MPEP 2106.05(f). Further, receiving data, evaluating data and distributing data are data gathering and data outputting, which has no effect on technology and does no more than generally link the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use – see MPEP 2106.05(h).
Step 2B:
The claim limitations do not provide an Inventive Concept. The claim limitations do not recite additional elements that amount to significantly more that the abstract idea because the additional elements of the system comprising a computer processor, computer readable storage medium with instructions, and a memory configured to store information, each recited at a high level of generality in a computer network which only perform the universal computer functions of accessing, receiving, storing, and processing data, transmitting and presenting information. Taking the elements both individually and as an ordered combination, the function performed by the computer at each step of the process is purely orthodox. Using a computer to obtain and display data are some of the most basic functions of a computer. As shown, the individual limitations claimed are some of the most rudimentary functions of a computer. The technical solution described in this invention does not alter hardware structure or its routine, does not transform the character of the information being processed, does not identify a novel source or type of data, does not advance the functionality of a computer as a tool, and does not incorporate specific rules enabling the computer to accomplish innovative utilities. In summary, the individual step and/or component does no more than require a general computer to perform standard computer functions. As discussed above with respect to integration of the abstract idea into a practical application, the additional element of a computer devices amounts to no more than mere instructions to apply the exception using a generic computer component - requiring the use of software to tailor information and provide it to the user on a generic computer, Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Capital One Bank (USA), 792 F.3d 1363, 1370-71, 115 USPQ2d 1636, 1642 (Fed. Cir. 2015);
Claims 29-34, as recited, are directed toward a non-transitory computer-readable medium. Such logic can be interpreted as computer code, per se, which is not a statutory category and is therefore unpatentable. However, a computer program can be eligible for patent protection if it is tangibly embodied on a computer readable medium and, when executed by a computer, performs the steps of the invention. Appropriate correction is required.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action:
A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102 of this title, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made.
Claims 1-9, 20, 21, and 26-34 are rejected under U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Hyuga et al. (USPGP 2009/0175512 A1) hereinafter HYUGA, in view of Yasukawa et al. (USPGP 2007/0277198 A1), hereinafter YASUKAWA.
Claims 1:
HYUGA as shown below discloses the following limitations:
at least one memory storing instructions: (see at least paragraph 0048)
at least one processor configured to execute the instructions to: (see at least paragraph 0046)
determine a condition to be used in authentication processing based on distribution of collation scores with respect to a master image; (see at least paragraphs 0005, 0008, 0054, Figure 4a as well as associated and related text)
execute authentication processing based on an authentication target image and the master image, by using the condition. (see at least paragraphs 0005, 0008, 0054, Figure 4a as well as associated and related text)
HYUGA does not specifically disclose a condition per se. YASUKAWA, however, in at least paragraphs 0005, 0007, 0038, and 0113 discloses attributes, characteristics, time zones, and weather conditions. In this case, each of the elements claimed are all shown by the prior art of record but not combined as claimed. However, the technical ability exists to combine the elements as claimed and the results of the combination are predictable. Therefore, when combined, the elements perform the same function as they did separately. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Consequently, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the effective filing date to combine/modify the method of HYUGA with the technique of YASUKAWA because, “…when a person other than registrants is collated, as a number of registrants increases, probability that a person resembling the relevant stranger appears among the plurality of registrants becomes higher. Therefore, as the number of registrants increases, a higher score is calculated as an average. In a situation where only one threshold is set for determining whether or not the collation object person is the registrant, the above-described fluctuations in score result in fluctuations in likelihood of acceptance of the stranger (stranger acceptance rate).” (HYUGA: paragraph 0007). Additionally, there is a recognized problem or need in the art including market pressure, design need, etc., and there are a finite number of identified predictable solutions. Accordingly, those in the art could have pursued known solutions with reasonable expectation of success. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Fundamentally, in the competitive business climate, there is a profit-driven motive to maximize the profitability of goods and services that are provided or marketed to customers. Enterprises typically use business planning to make decisions in order to maximize profits.
Claims 2:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the condition is a determination threshold value of the collation score, and the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to: (see at least paragraphs 0005, 0008, 0054, Figure 4a as well as associated and related text)
determine the determination threshold value based on distribution of the collation scores for each time zone;
output an authentication result based on a result of determining whether the collation score exceeds the determination threshold value in association with authentication time.
See at least paragraphs 0005, 0006, 0008, 0054.
Claim 3:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to determine the determination threshold value based on a false rejection rate (FRR).
See at least paragraph 0017.
Claim 4:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to determine the condition based on the collation score for each time zone and a reference collation score.
See at least paragraphs 0005, 0006, 0008, 0054; Figure 4a as well as associated and related text.
Claim 5:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to determine the condition based on the collation score in a first time zone and the collation score in a second time zone.
See at least paragraphs 0005, 0006, 0008, 0054.
Claim 6:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the condition is a condition related to image processing performed on the authentication target image before the collation score is calculated, the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to:
determine a condition related to the image processing based on distribution of the collation score for each time zone;
perform the image processing on the authentication target image by using the condition related to the image processing in association with authentication time and execute authentication processing based on the authentication target image after the image processing and the master image.
See at least paragraphs 0005, 0006, 0008, 0054; Figure 4a as well as associated and related text.
Claim 7:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the condition is an imaging condition of the authentication target image, the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to:
determine the imaging condition based on distribution of the collation scores for each time zone, and execute authentication processing based on an authentication target image captured under the imaging condition in association with authentication time and the master image.
See at least paragraphs 0005, 0006, 0008, 0054; Figure 3a as well as associated and related text. YASUKAWA in at least paragraphs 0005, 0007, 0038, and 0113 discloses attributes, characteristics, time zones, and weather conditions. In this case, each of the elements claimed are all shown by the prior art of record but not combined as claimed. However, the technical ability exists to combine the elements as claimed and the results of the combination are predictable. Therefore, when combined, the elements perform the same function as they did separately. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Consequently, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the effective filing date to combine/modify the method of HYUGA with the technique of YASUKAWA because, “…when a person other than registrants is collated, as a number of registrants increases, probability that a person resembling the relevant stranger appears among the plurality of registrants becomes higher. Therefore, as the number of registrants increases, a higher score is calculated as an average. In a situation where only one threshold is set for determining whether or not the collation object person is the registrant, the above-described fluctuations in score result in fluctuations in likelihood of acceptance of the stranger (stranger acceptance rate).” (HYUGA: paragraph 0007). Additionally, there is a recognized problem or need in the art including market pressure, design need, etc., and there are a finite number of identified predictable solutions. Accordingly, those in the art could have pursued known solutions with reasonable expectation of success. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Fundamentally, in the competitive business climate, there is a profit-driven motive to maximize the profitability of goods and services that are provided or marketed to customers. Enterprises typically use business planning to make decisions in order to maximize profits.
Claim 8:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. HYUGA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to determine the condition for each place.
See at least paragraphs 0005, 0008, 0054, Figure 4a as well as associated and related text.
Claim 9:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections above. YASUKAWA further discloses the following limitations:
wherein the at least one processor is further configured to execute the instructions to:
determine the condition for at least one of weather, a season, and a month;
execute the authentication processing means executes authentication processing using the condition in association with at least one of weather, a season, and a month at authentication time.
YASUKAWA in at least paragraphs 0005, 0007, 0038, and 0113 discloses attributes, characteristics, time zones, and weather conditions. In this case, each of the elements claimed are all shown by the prior art of record but not combined as claimed. However, the technical ability exists to combine the elements as claimed and the results of the combination are predictable. Therefore, when combined, the elements perform the same function as they did separately. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Consequently, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art at the effective filing date to combine/modify the method of HYUGA with the technique of YASUKAWA because, “…when a person other than registrants is collated, as a number of registrants increases, probability that a person resembling the relevant stranger appears among the plurality of registrants becomes higher. Therefore, as the number of registrants increases, a higher score is calculated as an average. In a situation where only one threshold is set for determining whether or not the collation object person is the registrant, the above-described fluctuations in score result in fluctuations in likelihood of acceptance of the stranger (stranger acceptance rate).” (HYUGA: paragraph 0007). Additionally, there is a recognized problem or need in the art including market pressure, design need, etc., and there are a finite number of identified predictable solutions. Accordingly, those in the art could have pursued known solutions with reasonable expectation of success. (KSR v. Teleflex, 127 S. Ct. 1727 (2007)). Fundamentally, in the competitive business climate, there is a profit-driven motive to maximize the profitability of goods and services that are provided or marketed to customers. Enterprises typically use business planning to make decisions in order to maximize profits.
Claims 20, 21, and 26-34:
The combination of HYUGA/YASUKAWA discloses the limitations as shown in the rejections of the claims above. The Examiner finds that remaining claims 20, 21, and 26-34 are not patentably distinct from claims 1-9, because the inventions in the claims are directed to related, indistinct products. The related inventions would be distinct if: (1) the inventions as claimed were either not capable of use together or could have a materially different design, mode of operation, function, or effect; (2) the inventions did not overlap in scope, i.e., are mutually exclusive; and (3) the inventions as claimed were not obvious variants. See MPEP § 806.05(j). Furthermore, the inventions as claimed encompass overlapping subject matter and are obvious variants that do not produce any new, meaningful, synergetic result that would render the claims novel. Therefore, for the sake of clarity, the Examiner has grouped the rejections of claims 1-9, 20, 21, and 26-34 accordingly using the same references and citations as above.
CONCLUSION
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure.
Non-Patent Literature:
NIST. “Facial Recognition Technology (FRT).” February 6, 2020. Retrieved online 10/13/2026. https://www.nist.gov/speech-testimony/facial-recognition-technology-frt-0
Relevancy: “Chairman Thompson, Ranking Member Rogers, and Members of the Committee, I am Chuck Romine, Director of the Information Technology Laboratory (ITL) at the Department of Commerce’s National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). ITL cultivates trust in information technology and metrology through measurements, standards and testing. Thank you for the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss NIST’s role in standards and testing for facial recognition technology.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Jake Parker et al. “What Science Really Says About Facial Recognition Accuracy and Bias Concerns.” (July 23, 2022). Retrieved online 10/13/2026. What Science Really Says About Facial Recognition Accuracy and Bias Concerns - Security Industry Association
Relevancy: “Since 2020, calls to heavily restrict or ban the use of facial recognition technology have become commonplace in technology, data privacy and artificial intelligence policymaking discussions. In many cases, the sole justification offered is the claim that this face matching technology is generally inaccurate, and particularly so with respect to women and minorities.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Facial Identification Scientific Working Group. “Facial Recognition Systems Operation Assurance: Scoring Thresholds.” (2022). Retrieved online 10/13/2026. Facial Recognition Systems Operation Assurance: Scoring Thresholds - v1.1 - 2022.11.04
Relevancy: “The scope of this document is to provide a detailed process and examples of how to evaluate scoring thresholds when adjusting operational workflows. Properly executing biometric performance assessment by producing appropriate charts to inspect and review scoring thresholds can be done for many reasons. This document will focus on how this analysis can support a systematic process to determine appropriate facial scoring thresholds to support end user requirements. This document is relevant to systems that operate with automated workflows as well as investigative systems requiring a human practitioner to review a candidate list.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Foreign Art:
YOSHIO H. “Collation Apparatus Used For Camera System, Has Comparison Unit That Determines Whether Alarm Notification Is Implemented, And Collation List Update Unit For Updating Thresholds Within Collation List By User Input From Input Receiving Unit.” (WO 2011/132387 A1)
Relevancy: “The apparatus has a collation unit (36) that collates an input image and registration image managed by a collation list (34) and a comparison unit (38) compares a large value and an input image calculated in the collation unit. The comparison unit request whether an alarm notification is implemented and a collation list update unit (35) updates the thresholds within the collation list by the user input from the input receiving unit (41).” (Abstract/Introduction)
TOMITA Y. “Face Recognition Apparatus Used In Information-technology Equipment, Has Illumination Information Estimation Unit Which Estimates Information, And Authentication Precision Control Unit Which Controls Authentication Precision.” (WO 2014/084249 A1)
Relevancy: “The apparatus has imaging parameter input unit (101) which inputs imaging parameter. An illumination information estimation unit (102) estimates illumination information based on the imaging parameter. An authentication precision control unit (103) controls an authentication precision. An authentication precision control unit controls the threshold value for determining an authentication result based on the illumination information. An authentication quality-control database matches and stores the illumination information and authentication precision parameter.” (Abstract/Introduction)
IIDA et al. “Authentication Device Has Determination Unit For Determining That Authentication Is Not Performed, When There Is No Difference In Feature Values That Do Not Match In Each Of Feature Values As Result Of Comparison By Comparison Unit.” (WO 2021/157686 A1)
Relevancy: “The device has a comparison unit for comparing each feature value obtained by extracting the feature value required for authentication from the biometric information acquired multiple times from each biometric information with the feature value master data for authentication. A determination unit is provided for determining that authentication is not performed, when there is no difference in feature values that do not match in each of the feature values as a result of comparison by the comparison unit.” (Abstract/Introduction)
Any inquiry of a general nature or relating to the status of this application or concerning this communication or earlier communications from the Examiner should be directed to James A. Reagan (james.reagan@uspto.gov) whose telephone number is 571.272.6710. The Examiner can normally be reached Monday through Friday from 9 AM to 5 PM. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the Examiner’s supervisor, John Hayes, can be reached at 571.272.6708.
Information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from the Patent Application Information Retrieval (PAIR) system. Status information for published applications may be obtained from either Private PAIR or Public PAIR. Status information for unpublished applications is available through Private PAIR only. For more information about the PAIR system, see http://portal.uspto.gov/external/portal/pair . Should you have questions on access to the Private PAIR system, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866.217.9197 (toll-free).
Any response to this action should be mailed to:
Commissioner for Patents
PO Box 1450
Alexandria, Virginia 22313-1450
or faxed to 571-273-8300.
Hand delivered responses should be brought to the United States Patent and Trademark Office Customer Service Window:
Randolph Building
401 Dulany Street
Alexandria, VA 22314.
/JAMES A REAGAN/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3697
james.reagan@uspto.gov
571.272.6710 (Office)
571.273.6710 (Desktop Fax)