DETAILED ACTION
1. The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . The following FINAL office action is in response to Applicant communication filed on 08/13/2026 regarding application 19/174,326. Claims 1, 4-6, 8-10, 13, 16-17 and 20-22 have been amended. Claims 2-3 and 14-15 have been canceled. Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are pending and have been rejected.
Priority
2. The Examiner has noted the Applicants claiming Priority from Provisional Application PRO 63/631,728 filed on 04/09/2024. Therefore, the earliest effective filing date examined for this case is reflective of 04/09/2024.
Status of Claims
3. Applicant’s arguments, see page 12 of 25 filed on 08/13/2026, with respect to the Claim Objections for Claims 1, 9-10 and 21-22 have been fully considered, and are found to be persuasive. Therefore, the Claim Objections for Claims 1, 9-10 and 21-22 are withdrawn.
4. Applicant’s arguments, see page 12 of 25 filed on 07/10/2026, with respect to the Specification Objections to Abstract have been fully considered, and are found to be persuasive. Therefore, the Specification Objections to Abstract are withdrawn. Examiner Note: Examiner annotated “OK to ENTER” for the amendments to the Abstract of the Disclosure with Examiner’s initials and date for OC case submission.
5. Applicant’s arguments, see page 13 of 25 filed on 08/13/2026, with respect to the 35 U.S.C. § 112 (b) Claim Rejections for Claims 1-24 have been fully considered, and are found to be persuasive. Therefore, the 35 U.S.C. § 112 (b) Claim Rejections for Claims 1-24 are withdrawn.
6. Applicant’s arguments, see pages 18-24 of 25 filed on 08/13/2026, with respect to the 35 U.S.C. § 103 Claim Rejections for Claims 1-3, 5, 9-16 and 21-24 have been fully considered, and are found to be persuasive. Therefore, the 35 U.S.C. § 103 Claim Rejections for Claims 1-24 are withdrawn. See Examining Claims with Respect to Prior Art Section below.
Response to 35 U.S.C. § 101 Arguments
7. Applicant’s 35 U.S.C. § 101 arguments, filed with respect to Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 have been fully considered, but they are found not persuasive (see Applicant Remarks, Pages 13-18 of 25 dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees.
Argument #1:
(A). Applicant argues that Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 do not recite an abstract idea, law of nature of natural phenomenon under revised step 2a prong one of the 35 U.S.C § 101 analysis (see Applicant Remarks, Pages 13-15 of 25, dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees. These arguments have been found to be not persuasive.
Specifically, Applicant argues that the claims recite a specific technical architecture” rather than a mental process or a method of organizing human activity because a person cannot mentally process structured API data, ingest feedback from thousands of concurrent users, or train a machine learning model in real time. This argument improperly conflates the computational scale of execution with a technological change to the underlying computer functionality. The recited process remains directed to the abstract concept of collecting, analyzing and displaying user sentiment (opinions) regarding financial or event predictions. The addition of an AI/machine learning module does not change the core nature of these claims; it merely automates statistical predictive modeling on a computer.
Applicant argues that these claims do not constitute a Mental Process (see Applicant Remarks, 2nd ¶ of Page 14, dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees. This argument is not persuasive.
With respect to “Mental Processes” category, Examiner refers Applicant to MPEP § 2106.04 (a) (2) (III) (B): “If a claim recites a limitation that can practically be performed in the human mind, with or without the use of a physical aid such as pen and paper, the limitation falls within the mental processes grouping, and the claim recites an abstract idea. See, e.g., Benson, 409 U.S. at 67, 65, 175 USPQ at 674-75, 674 (noting that the claimed "conversion of [binary-coded decimal] numerals to pure binary numerals can be done mentally," i.e., "as a person would do it by head and hand."); Synopsys, 839 F.3d at 1139, 120 USPQ2d at 1474 (holding that claims to the mental process of "translating a functional description of a logic circuit into a hardware component description of the logic circuit" are directed to an abstract idea, because the claims "read on an individual performing the claimed steps mentally or with pencil and paper"). The use of a physical aid (e.g., pencil and paper or a slide rule) to help perform a mental step (e.g., a mathematical calculation) does not negate the mental nature of the limitation, but simply accounts for variations in memory capacity from one person to another.”
Moreover, with respect to “Mental Processes” category, Examiner refers Applicant to MPEP § 2106.04 (a) (2) (III) (C): “Claims can recite a mental process even if they are claimed as being performed on a computer. The Supreme Court recognized this in Benson, determining that a mathematical algorithm for converting binary coded decimal to pure binary within a computer’s shift register was an abstract idea. The Court concluded that the algorithm could be performed purely mentally even though the claimed procedures "can be carried out in existing computers long in use, no new machinery being necessary." 409 U.S at 67, 175 USPQ at 675. See also Mortgage Grader, 811 F.3d at 1324, 117 USPQ2d at 1699 (concluding that concept of "anonymous loan shopping" recited in a computer system claims are an abstract idea because it could be "performed by humans without a computer").” “For instance, the Examiner has reviewed Applicant’s Specification and determined that the claimed invention is described as concepts that are performed in the human mind and applicant is merely claiming that concept performed 1) on a generic computer (see Applicant’s Specification ¶ [0182]: “The hardware may include a general-purpose computer and/or dedicated computing device or specific computing device or particular aspect or component of a specific computing device. The processes may be realized in one or more microprocessors, microcontrollers, embedded microcontrollers, programmable digital signal processors or other programmable devices, along with internal and/or external memory.”), or 2) in a computer environment (see Applicant’s Specification ¶ [0177]: “The methods and systems described herein may be adapted for use with any kind of private, community, or hybrid cloud computing network or cloud computing environment, including those that involve features of software as a service (SaaS), platform as a service (PaaS), and/or infrastructure as a service (IaaS).”), or 3) is merely using a computer as a tool to perform these concepts.” Thus, based on these 3 factors, Examiner maintains that the claims still recite a mental process.
Applicant argues that these claims do not constitute a Certain Method of Organizing Human Activities (see Applicant Remarks, 3rd ¶ of Page 14, dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees. This argument is not persuasive.
Examiner refers Applicant to MPEP § 2106.04 (a) (2) II which states that: “the sub-groupings encompass both activity of a single person (for example, a person following a set of instructions or a person signing a contract online) and activity that involves multiple people (such as a commercial interaction), and thus, certain activity between a person and a computer may fall within the "Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities" groupings. It is noted that the number of people involved in the activity is not dispositive as to whether a claim limitation falls within this grouping. Instead, the determination should be based on whether the activity itself falls within one of the sub-groupings.”
Furthermore, Examiner notes for example Independent Claims 1 and 13 recite mathematical forecasting, calculating weights based on historical accuracy, and tallying user “likes/dislikes” constitute mathematical concepts and methods of organizing human activity (crowdsourcing market data). The Federal Circuit has repeatedly held that commercial or social interactions that are automated remain abstract ideas, regardless of the complexity or speed of the software instructions.
Here, the claim limitations for Independent Claims 1 and 13, are directed to the abstract idea of collecting, analyzing, and displaying user sentiment and customized prediction data for marketing events. This abstract idea falls squarely within the judicial exception categories of Mental Processes (as the underlying logic of assigning scores and modifying odds can be performed din the human mind) and Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities due to managing interactions, feedback and opinion tracking from users.
Receiving event market data (first predicted outcome): This is a data gathering step, often deemed part of an abstract idea, representing a commercial activity (tracking market predictions). Displaying rendered graphics of the predicted outcome: This is a routine GUI function (data presentation). Displaying prompts (like/dislike) and receiving feedback: This is a conventional method of organizing human activity (opinion polling/sentiment tracking). Assigning/storing user sentiment score: This is a mental process or mathematical calculation (arithmetic evaluation of sentiment), which is inherently abstract. Displaying the sentiment score with the prediction: This is simply displaying the results of the calculation, a routine computer output function.
Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity/Commercial Activity: The invention tracks and analyzes human sentiment (agree/disagree) on predictions, which is a form of polling or market evaluation.
Mental Processes: The process of creating a "like" or "dislike" is an evaluation or judgment that a user would typically perform mentally, merely automated by a computer.
Mathematical Concepts: The assignment and storage of a "sentiment score" is a basic calculation based on input, transforming subjective opinion into numerical data.
Therefore, in conclusion, Examiner maintains that Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are directed to abstract ideas under “Mental Processes” or “Mathematical Concepts” or “Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities” Groupings under 35 U.S.C. § 101 Step 2A Prong 1.
Argument #2:
(B). Applicant argues that Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 recite additional elements that integrate the judicial exception into a practical application under revised step 2a prong two of the 35 U.S.C. § 101 analysis (see Applicant Remarks, Pages 15-17 of 25, dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees. Examiner respectfully disagrees. These arguments have been found to be not persuasive.
Specifically, Applicant argues that the claims solve a specific technological problem – namely, that existing platforms only allow “passive engagement with pre-defined odds” – and provide a concrete technical improvement under Enfish and McRO. This argument misinterprets what constitutes a “technical improvement” under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
In response to Applicant remarks with respect to 35 U.S.C. § 101 step 2a prong 2, Examiner points out that this is a business/application improvement per se and not a technical improvement. The problem identified by the Applicant is limited user interaction and passive engagement on prediction platforms is a business, social, or user-experience problem, and not a technical defect in computer hardware or network operations. Unlike the Enfish, LLC v. Microsoft Corp., 822 F.3dd 1327 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (which improved database structural operations) or McRo, Inc. v. Bandai Namco Games A., Inc., 837 F.3d 1299 (Fed. Cir. 2018)) (which improved automated animation rules), the present claims do not make the computer run faster, use less memory, or operate more securely. Instead, the claimed invention uses standard computer elements such as (processors, displays and standard API structures) used conventionally to run a specific type of application logic. The practical application is merely the automation of a subjective feedback mechanism to create a weighted market prediction, which does not constitute an eligible technological improvement under 35 U.S.C. § 101 step 2a prong 2.
The steps (receiving data, displaying graphics, storing scores) are implemented using conventional computer components ("one or more processors," "visual display"). As discussed, simply performing standard input/output functions in a GUI does not typically transform an abstract idea into patent-eligible subject matter. The steps merely gather and display data in a known way, without providing a technical solution to a technical problem. These claims do not improve upon the operation of the computer itself. Instead, it uses existing, generic computer functionality to execute the method of tracking market sentiment and customizing odds. The computer acts merely as a tool for automation.
Moreover, with respect to Independent Claims 1 and 13, certain/particular limitations shown recite (1) mere data gathering such as (e.g., “receiving, at a computing device having one or more processors, event market data, the event market data having a first predicted outcome from the event” & “receiving, at the computing device, feedback associated with the first predicted outcome based on one of a selected like and dislike”) and (2) mere data outputting/mere data displaying such as (e.g., “displaying, as rendered graphics on a visual display of the computing device, the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, available prompt selections indicative of a like and a dislike, wherein the like represents agreement with the first predicted outcome and the dislike represents disagreement with the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, and resulting from a selected dislike user feedback, available prompt selections indicative of customizing the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, a field that receives a user new customized value that contradicts the first predicted outcome”) wherein each of these claim limitations are reminiscent of insignificant extra-solution activities under MPEP § 2106.05 (g).
Applicant’s reliance on Core Wireless Licensing SARL v. LG Electronics, 880 F.3d 1356, 1362 (Fed. Cir. 2018) has been considered, but is not persuasive. Applicant points out that in the “Core Wireless” court case required that the application summary window listed a limited set of data, “each of the data in the list being selectable to launch the respective application and enable the selected data to be seen within the respective application” and “restrained the type of data that can be displayed in the summary window”. Examiner notes that the “Core Wireless case” "disclosed a specific technical manner of displaying a limited set of information to the user, rather than using conventional user interface methods to display a generic index on a computer. The court noted that prior art systems required a user to navigate through many different layers or views to access desired data or functionality, and that that process could "seem slow, complex and difficult to learn." In contrast, the court noted that the disclosed invention improves the efficiency of using the electronic device by permitting a limited list of common functions and commonly accessed stored data to be accessed directly from a main menu. Specifically, the application summary window addressed the problems associated with the small screen size by bypassing the additional levels of navigation necessitated by the small screen size. Examiner submits that while technological improvements need not to solely stem from: phoneme to keyframe lip synchronization in facial 3D animation in “McRO” supra, solved paging problem in small screen as in “Core Wireless” – supra it is still worth noting that each of “McRO” and “Core Wireless” raised above, are relevant in providing valuable insight to ascertain what actual technology is, and most importantly, to ascertain what constitutes deliberate improvement to actual technology or the computer itself as opposed to a mere entrepreneurial improvement. In this instant case however, Applicant merely argues in favor of Applicant merely argues in favor of an entrepreneurial best business practice of a limited user interaction and passive engagement on prediction platforms which is a business, social, or user-experience problem, and not a technical defect in computer hardware or network operations. The important distinctions to note is that in the Core Wireless case, the problem statement focused on the limitations in the operation or function of prior art user interfaces caused by the small screens of certain computer devices. On the other hand, in the Trading Technologies cases, the problem statement focused on the types of information being provided to the user through the user interface. The information did not address any problem associated with a specific computer operation or characteristic, but rather a problem associated with the ability of the trader to carry out trading activities. Similarly, as in cited in the Trading Technologies case, Examiner points out that the Applicant has not addressed or pointed out any specific technical problem associated with a specific computer operation or characteristic. The claim limitations as recited in Independent Claims 1 and 13 for example of the claimed invention governed what information is displayed and the formatting of that information. These limitations do not tie back to any particular technical problem and are not related to any specific computer operation or characteristic.
Applicant’s reliance on Enfish, LLC v. Microsoft Corp, 822. F.3d 1327 (Fed. Cir. 2016) has been considered, but is not persuasive. Turning now to the “Enfish” case, Examiner reveals that the Federal Circuit did not find its claims as an eligible improvement, by simple virtue of mere allowing the computer to perform tasks not previously, but instead found a database improvement (see “Elec. Power Grp.p.1482 ¶2-¶3), further explain by configuring a memory according to a logical table that need not be stored contiguously in the computer memory, but instead appended with new columns that are available for immediate use through the creation of new column definition records, with one or more cells defined by the intersection of the rows and columns, and with the object identification number that, acting as a pointer of variable length between databases, to identify each said logical row, corresponding to a record of information (“Enfish LLC v. Microsoft Corp. , 118 USPQ2d 1684, U.S. Court of Appeals Federal Circuit, No. 2015-1244, May 12, 2016, 2016 BL 151342, 822 F.3d 1327”, hereinafter “Enfish” noting at p.1688 second to last ¶, pp. 1689-1690) providing a trifecta improvements in: increasing flexibility, providing faster search times, and smaller memory requirements (“Enfish” p.1690, second to last ¶) (emphasis added).
Indeed, as later elucidated by the Federal Circuit in “Elec. Power Grp”: “In Enfish, we applied the distinction to reject the § 101 challenge at stage one because the claims at issue focused not on asserted advances in uses to which existing computer capabilities could be put, but a particular database technique in how computers could carry out one of their basic functions of storage and retrieval of data (“Elec. Power Grp” p.1742 ¶3 last sentence citing “Enfish, 822 F.3d at 1335-36”; “Bascom, 2016 WL 3514158, at *5; cf. Alice, 134 S. Ct. at 2360”.
Whereas here, similar to “Elec. Power Grp” p.1742 ¶3 last sentence, the focus of the claims is not on such an improvement in computers as tools, but on certain independently abstract ideas that use computers as tools to allegedly allow the computer to perform the functions of collecting, analyzing, and displaying user sentiment and customized prediction data for marketing events which could be performed as certain method of organizing human activities for managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people for teachings or following rules or instructions through using a computer in a marketing environment. Examiner notes that unlike the cases of Enfish, McRO and CoreWireless, the present claims do not improve the physical operating capability of the display or the underlying computer memory architecture. The applicant’s optimization occurs entirely at the application layer – specifically modifying how user sentiment metrics are statistically weighted. Improving the predictive accuracy of an output model or creating a better user engagement application is a business or mathematical optimization, not a technological solution to a computer problem.
The Applicant asserts that “tying historical predictive accuracy to AI training weights” is a “technical feedback mechanism” that is neither a mental process nor a conventional computer function. The Examiner maintains that this mechanism is an inherent mathematical concept and a variation of a mental process. The underlying logic such as evaluating a human predictor’s historical accuracy and giving their future predictions more weight or authority based on that track record is a method of human analysis. Also tying numerical accuracy scores to weights within a machine learning process is an implementation of regression analysis or statistical weighting. Software rules that merely optimize mathematical modeling or clean/weight training data do not strip these claims of its abstract nature.
The Applicant contends that Claims 9-10 and 21-22 add “significantly more” because they recite a specific, self-reinforcing loop that calibrates an AI model based on historical user accuracy (see Applicant Remarks, last ¶ Page 16 of 25 dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees.
The Examiner maintains that the ordered combination fails to provide an inventive concept. The individual elements rely on AI training functions (gathering inputs, adjusting mathematical weights based on data flags, and retaining a model). Under Federal Circuit (such as Electric Power Group and SAP America), collecting data, analyzing it mathematically according to specific logic rules, and outputting the modified results does not supply an inventive concept. The “accuracy-calibrated prediction architecture” simply restricts the abstract idea of predictive tracking to a specific environment (AI model training). Merely automating a statistical weighting protocol on generic computing components to yield highly refined data output does not amount to “significantly more” than the abstract idea itself.
Applicant comments that that the claims requires real-time rendering of dynamic AI model output alongside live event market data and aggregated multi-user sentiment scores, with concurrent normalization of historical and contemporary datasets feeding a trained prediction model (see Applicant Remarks, 1st ¶ Page 17 of 25 dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees.
Examiner cautions Applicant that even requiring the implementation of the computer functions in real time (“Intellectual Ventures I LLC v. Capital One Bank (USA), 115 USPQ2d 1636 N.A. U.S. Court of Appeals Federal Circuit No. 2014-1506 Decided July 6, 2015 2015 BL 214690, 792 F3d 1363 page 160 last ¶ last sentence to page 1641 first ¶ first sentence”), or referring to the complexity of the implementing software or the level of detail in the Specification (see Accenture Global Servs., GmbH v. Guidewire Software, Inc. U.S. Court of Appeals Federal Circuit, 108 USPQ2d 1173No. 2011-1486, Decided September 5, 2013, 2013 BL 235751 728 F.3d 1336 page 1180 second to last ¶ - last sentence) does not transform a claim reciting only an abstract concept into a patent-eligible system or method, and even if such level of detail would be explicitly claimed, it would still remain representative of mere mental limitations reminiscent to at least the ones found ineligible in “Bilski v. Kappos, 95 USPQ2d 1001, U.S. Supreme Court No. 08-964, Decided June 28, 2010,130 SCt 3218, 561 US 593” at page 1005 ¶2, page 1012 ¶2-¶3 and page 1028 ¶4 when further referring to “Benson”. Furthermore, it is worthy to note that well before “Alice”, as early as 1972, the Supreme Court raised concerns with respect to the eligibility of patenting programs: “Direct attempts to patent programs have been rejected on the ground of nonstatutory subject matter. Indirect attempts to obtain patents and avoid the rejection, by drafting claims as a process, or a machine or components thereof programmed in a given manner, rather than as a program itself, have confused the issue further and should not be permitted (Gottschalk v. Benson 175 USPQ No. 71-485, p. 677)”.
In summary, the judicial exception is not integrated into a practical application under Step 2A, Prong Two. Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are maintained as being patent ineligible under 35 U.S.C. § 101 step 2a prong 2.
Argument #3:
(C). Applicant argues that Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 recite additional elements that amount to significantly more than the recited judicial exceptions under revised step 2B of the 35 U.S.C. § 101 analysis (see Applicant Remarks, Pages 17-18 of 25, dated 08/13/2026). Examiner respectfully disagrees.
Specifically, Applicant argues under BASCOM that the “specific ordered combination” of elements – ingesting data, mapping user-defined odds, passing data into an AI pipeline, weighting features based on historical accuracy, and displaying concurrent graphics – amounts to a non-conventional, patent – eligible system architecture. These arguments have been found to be not persuasive.
An ordered combination of conventional steps that merely automates an abstract data-processing pipeline does not supply an inventive concept. The individual steps described in the ordered combination include (e.g., receiving data – displaying prompts – storing user inputs – feeding data to a model – outputting results) represents the normal functional process of a web application or data pipeline. Applicant notes that the specific role of the AI module (training on user-defined odds and outputting concurrent predictions) provides the inventive concepts, citing Amdocs. However, using a ML model to evaluate datasets and weigh parameters based on historical performance is a tool used by data analysts. Restricting an abstract idea to a particular software framework such as an AI training pipeline or a specific application environment such as event forecasting market data does not add “significantly more” under Alice. The combination does nothing more than involve generic computer to execute the abstract algorithm at scale.
In response, Examiner refers Applicant to Examiner’s 35 U.S.C. 101 analysis section (e.g., Claim Rejections - 35 U.S.C. § 101 section shown below) shown for step 2B particularly for Independent Claims 1 and 13. The claims do not recite additional elements that amount to significantly more than the recited judicial exceptions, because they are merely directed to the particulars of the abstract idea and likewise do not add significantly more to the above-identified judicial exceptions. The limitations are directed to limitations referenced in MPEP § 2106.05I.A. that are not enough to qualify as significantly more when recited in these claims with the abstract idea which include: (1) adding the words “apply it” (or an equivalent) with the judicial exception, (2) or mere instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer and providing the results to the user on a computer, and (3) generally linking the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use.
Where a factual finding of well-understood, routine, conventional activity is necessary, that finding should be supported in accordance with MPEP § 2106.07 and the applicable evidentiary requirements. The Step 2B conclusion, however, does not depend solely upon treating every individual ML operation as conventional. The claims can also be considered as a whole to determine whether the ordered combination provides significantly more than the abstract idea. MPEP § 2106 describes Step 2B as requiring consideration of whether the additional elements, individually and in combination, amount to significantly more.
Moreover, certain/particular claim limitations recited in Independent Claims 1 and 13 recite (1) mere data gathering such as (e.g., “receiving, at a computing device having one or more processors, event market data, the event market data having a first predicted outcome from the event” & “receiving, at the computing device, feedback associated with the first predicted outcome based on one of a selected like and dislike”) and (2) mere data outputting/mere data displaying such as (e.g., “displaying, as rendered graphics on a visual display of the computing device, the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, available prompt selections indicative of a like and a dislike, wherein the like represents agreement with the first predicted outcome and the dislike represents disagreement with the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”) wherein each of these claim limitations are reminiscent of insignificant extra-solution activities under MPEP § 2106.05 (g). Furthermore, these certain/particular claim limitations as demonstrated above for Independent Claims 1 and 13 reflects Well-Understood, Routine and Conventional Activities (WURC) under MPEP § 2106.05 (d) ii: See Receiving or transmitting data over a network, e.g., using the Internet to gather data, Symantec,838 F.3d at 1321, 120 USPQ2d at 1362 (utilizing an intermediary computer to forward information); TLI Communications LLC v. AV Auto. LLC, 823 F.3d 607, 610, 118 USPQ2d 1744, 1745 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (using a telephone for image transmission); OIP Techs., Inc., v. Amazon.com, Inc., 788 F.3d 1359,1363, 115 USPQ2d 1090, 1093 (Fed. Cir. 2015) (sending messages over a network); buySAFE, Inc. v. Google, Inc., 765 F.3d 1350, 1355, 112 USPQ2d1093, 1096 (Fed. Cir. 2014) (computer receives and sends information over a network).
Furthermore, these certain/particular claim limitations as demonstrated such as (e.g., “assigning and storing, at the computing device, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback”) for Independent Claims 1 and 13 reflects Well-Understood, Routine and Conventional Activities (WURC) under MPEP § 2106.05 (d) ii: See Storing and retrieving information in memory, Versata Dev. Group, Inc. v. SAP Am., Inc.,793 F.3d 1306, 1334, 115 USPQ2d 1681, 1701 (Fed.Cir. 2015); OIP Techs., 788 F.3d at 1363, 115USPQ2d at 1092-93.
The additional elements of “artificial intelligence (AI) module” or “artificial intelligence” in general for Dependent Claims 8 and 20 do not amount to significantly more than the judicial exceptions under step 2B due to being expressly recognized as Well-Understood, Routine and Conventional (WURC) in the art.
See for example; US PG Pub (US 2019/0026786 A1) – “Platform for Managing Social Media Content Throughout an Organization”, hereinafter Khoury, et. al. Khoury at ¶ [0125]: “Such content 25a as well as a template 25b containing the same, its form, and its delivery parameters may be determined by a user of the system, or may be determined based on various algorithms run by the system, e.g., by an artificial intelligence module thereof. Particularly, as described in detail below, the system 1 may include an A/I module, which A/I module may be configured for analyzing (potential) content 25a, determining patterns and trends of recipient activity, and may further be configured for automatically generating content 250 (or suggestions thereof) and/or for determining suggested delivery patterns of communications or messaging containing that content 25.” See also Khoury at ¶ [0189]: “For instance, in one instance, as explained below, an artificial intelligence (A/I) module 54 of the system may be employed to weigh the various factors of the system, determine trends with respect thereto, and may configure the content collector 12, e.g., API or web crawler, so as to collect content 25 from across the web for inclusion into the repository 34.” See also for example; US PG Pub (US 2024/0346098 A1) – “Machine-Learning News Aggregation and Serving”, hereinafter Cicinyte, et. al. Cicinyte at ¶ [0031]: “It will be apparent to one of skill in the art that any suitable machine learning or artificial intelligence techniques may be used to train the models, including one or more of supervised, unsupervised, and/or reinforcement learning.”
Moreover, Examiner also points out that in the BSG Tech LLC v. Buyseasons Inc. decision (Aug. 15, 2018), the relevant inquiry is not whether the claimed invention as a whole is unconventional or non-routine. At step two we “search for an inventive concept” that is sufficient to ensure that the patent in practice amounts to significantly more than a patent upon the [ineligible concept] itself. But this simply restates what we have already determined is an abstract idea. At Alice step two, it is irrelevant whether considering historical usage information while inputting data may have been non-routine or unconventional as a factual matter. As a matter of law, narrowing or reformulating an abstract idea does not add “significantly more” to it. See SAP Am., Inc. V. InvestPic, LLC, No. 2017-2081, slip op. at 14 (Fed. Cir. Aug. 2, 2018). Therefore, Applicant’s suggestion that a specific limitation (or the claimed invention as a whole) must be shown to be well-understood, routine and conventional to support the conclusion of subject matter ineligibility is not persuasive.
The ordered combination of elements in the Dependent Claims (including the limitations inherited from the parent claim(s)) add nothing that is not already present as when the elements are taken individually. There is no indication that the combination of elements improves the functioning of a computer or improves any other technology. Accordingly, the subject matter encompassed by the dependent claims fails to amount to a practical application or significantly more than the abstract idea itself. Therefore, under Step 2B, Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 do not include additional elements that are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the recited judicial exceptions. Thus, Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are ineligible with respect to the 35 U.S.C. § 101 analysis. Because the claims remain directed to an abstract idea, are not integrated into a practical technological application, and contain no inventive concept beyond computer automation, the rejection under 35 U.S.C. § 101 is maintained.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
8. 35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
9. Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea without significantly more.
Step 1: Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are focused to a statutory category namely, a “process” or a “method” (Claims 1 and 4-12) and a “system” or an “apparatus” (Claims 13 and 16-24).
Step 2A Prong One: Independent Claims 1 and 13 recites limitations that set forth the abstract idea(s), namely (see in bold except where strikethrough):
“” (see Independent Claim 13);
“” (see Independent Claim 13);
“receiving, event market data, the event market data having a first predicted outcome from the event” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“displaying, the first predicted outcome” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“displaying, available prompt selections indicative of a like and a dislike, wherein the like represents agreement with the first predicted outcome and the dislike represents disagreement with the first predicted outcome” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“receiving, , feedback associated with the first predicted outcome based on one of a selected like and dislike” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“assigning and storing, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“displaying, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“displaying, , and resulting from a selected dislike user feedback, available prompt selections indicative of customizing the first predicted outcome” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“displaying, , a field that receives a user new customized value that contradicts the first predicted outcome” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13);
“wherein assigning and storing, , the user sentiment score related to the user feedback further comprises: assigning the user new customized value as user defined odds to the user sentiment score and wherein the user sentiment score includes the user defined odds” (see Independent Claims 1 and 13).
Here, the claim limitations for Independent Claims 1 and 13, are directed to the abstract idea of collecting, analyzing, and displaying user sentiment and customized prediction data for marketing events. This abstract idea falls squarely within the judicial exception categories of Mental Processes (as the underlying logic of assigning scores and modifying odds can be performed in the human mind) and Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities due to managing interactions, feedback and opinion tracking from users.
Receiving event market data (first predicted outcome): This is a data gathering step, often deemed part of an abstract idea, representing a commercial activity (tracking market predictions). Displaying rendered graphics of the predicted outcome: This is a routine GUI function (data presentation). Displaying prompts (like/dislike) and receiving feedback: This is a conventional method of organizing human activity (opinion polling/sentiment tracking). Assigning/storing user sentiment score: This is a mental process or mathematical calculation (arithmetic evaluation of sentiment), which is inherently abstract. Displaying the sentiment score with the prediction: This is simply displaying the results of the calculation, a routine computer output function.
Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activity/Commercial Activity: The invention tracks and analyzes human sentiment (agree/disagree) on predictions, which is a form of polling or market evaluation.
Mental Processes: The process of creating a "like" or "dislike" is an evaluation or judgment that a user would typically perform mentally, merely automated by a computer.
Mathematical Concepts: The assignment and storage of a "sentiment score" is a basic calculation based on input, transforming subjective opinion into numerical data.
Therefore, other than reciting (e.g., “the computing device” & “one or more processors” & “visual display” & “rendered graphics” & “non-transitory computer-readable storage medium”) nothing in the claim elements precludes the steps from being performed as “Mental Processes” which pertains to (1) concepts performed in the human mind (including observations or evaluations or judgments) or (2) using pen and paper as a physical aid and additionally or alternatively as “Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities” which pertains (3) managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (including teachings or following rules or instructions) or (4) commercial interactions (including marketing or business relations) and additionally or alternatively as “Mathematical Concepts” which pertains to (5) mathematical calculations.
Therefore, at step 2a prong 1, Yes, Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 recites an abstract idea. We proceed onto analyzing the claims at step 2a prong 2.
Step 2A Prong Two: With respect to Step 2A Prong Two of the eligibility inquiry (as explained in MPEP § 2106.04(d)), the judicial exception is not integrated into a practical application. Independent Claim 1 recites additional elements directed to: (e.g., “the computing device” & “visual display” & “rendered graphics”). Independent Claim 13 recites additional elements directed to: (e.g., “the computing device” & “one or more processors” & “visual display” & “rendered graphics” & “non-transitory computer-readable storage medium”). These additional elements have been considered individually and in combination, but fail to integrate the abstract idea into a practical application because they amount to using computing elements or instructions (software) to perform the abstract idea, similar to adding the words “apply it” (or an equivalent), which merely serves to link the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment. See MPEP § 2106.05(f) and MPEP § 2106.05(h).
The steps (receiving data, displaying graphics, storing scores) are implemented using conventional computer components ("one or more processors," "visual display"). As discussed, simply performing standard input/output functions in a GUI does not typically transform an abstract idea into patent-eligible subject matter. The steps merely gather and display data in a known way, without providing a technical solution to a technical problem. These claims do not improve upon the operation of the computer itself. Instead, it uses existing, generic computer functionality to execute the method of tracking market sentiment and customizing odds. The computer acts merely as a tool for automation.
Moreover, certain/particular claim limitations recited in Independent Claims 1 and 13 recite (1) mere data gathering such as (e.g., “receiving, at a computing device having one or more processors, event market data, the event market data having a first predicted outcome from the event” & “receiving, at the computing device, feedback associated with the first predicted outcome based on one of a selected like and dislike”) and (2) mere data outputting/mere data displaying such as (e.g., “displaying, as rendered graphics on a visual display of the computing device, the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, available prompt selections indicative of a like and a dislike, wherein the like represents agreement with the first predicted outcome and the dislike represents disagreement with the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”) wherein each of these claim limitations are reminiscent of insignificant extra-solution activities under MPEP § 2106.05 (g).
In addition, these limitations fail to provide an improvement to the functioning of a computer or to any other technology or technical field, fail to apply the exception with a particular machine, fail to apply the judicial exception to effect a particular treatment or prophylaxis for a disease or medical condition, fail to effect a transformation of a particular article to a different state or thing, and fail to apply/use the abstract idea in a meaningful way beyond generally linking the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment.
Accordingly, because the Step 2A Prong One and Prong Two analysis resulted in the conclusion that the claims are directed to an abstract idea, additional analysis under Step 2B of the eligibility inquiry must be conducted in order to determine whether any claim element or combination of elements amount to significantly more than the judicial exception. Therefore, at step 2a prong 2, Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are directed to the abstract idea and do not recite additional elements that integrate into a practical application.
Step 2B: (As explained in MPEP § 2106.05), it has been determined that the claims do not include additional elements that are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception. Independent Claim 1 recites additional elements directed to: (e.g., “the computing device” & “visual display” & “rendered graphics”). Independent Claim 13 recites additional elements directed to: (e.g., “the computing device” & “one or more processors” & “visual display” & “rendered graphics” & “non-transitory computer-readable storage medium”). These elements have been considered individually and in combination, but fail to add significantly more to the claims because they amount to using computing elements or instructions (software) to perform the abstract idea, similar to adding the words “apply it” (or an equivalent), which merely serves to link the use of the judicial exception to a particular technological environment (computing environment) and does not amount to significantly more than the abstract idea itself. See MPEP § 2106.05 (f) and MPEP § 2106.05 (h). Notably, Applicant’s Specification suggests that the claimed invention relies on nothing more than a general-purpose computer executing the instructions to implement the invention (e.g., see at Applicant’s Specification ¶ [0182]: “The hardware may include a general-purpose computer and/or dedicated computing device or specific computing device or particular aspect or component of a specific computing device. The processes may be realized in one or more microprocessors, microcontrollers, embedded microcontrollers, programmable digital signal processors or other programmable devices, along with internal and/or external memory.”). Examiner notes that receiving data (event market data), displaying information (graphics), receiving user input (like/dislike), and calculating/storing data (user sentiment score) are all routine, conventional functions performed by standard computer systems and network environments. When viewed as an ordered combination, the sequence follows the flow of data processing between data collection, user interaction, calculation and redisplay. Combining computer tasks to automate the collection and manipulation of user-defined prediction odds does not yield an inventive concept beyond the abstract idea itself.
Moreover, certain/particular claim limitations recited in Independent Claims 1 and 13 recite (1) mere data gathering such as (e.g., “receiving, at a computing device having one or more processors, event market data, the event market data having a first predicted outcome from the event” & “receiving, at the computing device, feedback associated with the first predicted outcome based on one of a selected like and dislike”) and (2) mere data outputting/mere data displaying such as (e.g., “displaying, as rendered graphics on a visual display of the computing device, the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, available prompt selections indicative of a like and a dislike, wherein the like represents agreement with the first predicted outcome and the dislike represents disagreement with the first predicted outcome” & “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”) wherein each of these claim limitations are reminiscent of insignificant extra-solution activities under MPEP § 2106.05 (g). Furthermore, these certain/particular claim limitations as demonstrated above for Independent Claims 1 and 13 reflects Well-Understood, Routine and Conventional Activities (WURC) under MPEP § 2106.05 (d) ii: See Receiving or transmitting data over a network, e.g., using the Internet to gather data, Symantec,838 F.3d at 1321, 120 USPQ2d at 1362 (utilizing an intermediary computer to forward information); TLI Communications LLC v. AV Auto. LLC, 823 F.3d 607, 610, 118 USPQ2d 1744, 1745 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (using a telephone for image transmission); OIP Techs., Inc., v. Amazon.com, Inc., 788 F.3d 1359,1363, 115 USPQ2d 1090, 1093 (Fed. Cir. 2015) (sending messages over a network); buySAFE, Inc. v. Google, Inc., 765 F.3d 1350, 1355, 112 USPQ2d1093, 1096 (Fed. Cir. 2014) (computer receives and sends information over a network).
Furthermore, these certain/particular claim limitations as demonstrated such as (e.g., “assigning and storing, at the computing device, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback”) for Independent Claims 1 and 13 reflects Well-Understood, Routine and Conventional Activities (WURC) under MPEP § 2106.05 (d) ii: See Storing and retrieving information in memory, Versata Dev. Group, Inc. v. SAP Am., Inc.,793 F.3d 1306, 1334, 115 USPQ2d 1681, 1701 (Fed.Cir. 2015); OIP Techs., 788 F.3d at 1363, 115USPQ2d at 1092-93.
In addition, when taken as an ordered combination, the ordered combination adds nothing that is not already present as when the elements are taken individually. There is no indication that the combination of elements integrates the abstract idea into a practical application. Therefore, when viewed as a whole, these additional claim elements do not provide meaningful limitations to transform the abstract idea into a practical application of the abstract idea or that, as an ordered combination, amount to significantly more than the abstract idea itself.
Dependent Claims 4-12 and 16-24 recite substantially the same or similar additional elements as addressed above and when considered individually and as an ordered combination (as a whole) with these limitations recite the same abstract idea(s) as shown in Independent Claims 1 and 13 along with further steps/details pertaining to “Mental Processes” which pertains to (1) concepts performed in the human mind (including observations or evaluations or judgments) or (2) using pen and paper as a physical aid and additionally or alternatively as “Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities” which pertains (3) managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (including teachings or following rules or instructions) or (4) commercial interactions (including marketing or business relations) and additionally or alternatively as “Mathematical Concepts” which pertains to (5) mathematical calculations.
Dependent Claims 4-7, 9-12, 16-19 and 21-24 further narrow the abstract ideas, and are therefore still ineligible for the reasons previously provided in Steps 2A Prong 2 and Step 2B for Independent Claims 1 and 13. Dependent Claims 8 and 20: With respect to reliance on (e.g., “artificial intelligence (AI) module” & “AI predictions”) as additional elements shown in Dependent Claims 8 and 20 when considered both individually and as an ordered combination (as a whole) with these recited claim limitations, these additional elements both do not provide limitations that are indicative of integration into a practical application under step 2a prong 2 and also do not amount to significantly more than the judicial exceptions under step 2B due to the following: (1) limiting a particular field of use or technological environment due to predicting an outcome from an event based on user sentiment based on historical event results and contemporary user sentiment data and the contemporary event data using a computer in a marketing environment/field of use (see MPEP § 2106.05 (h)) or (2) recites mere instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer or using a computer as a tool to “apply” the recited judicial exceptions by providing the results to the user on a computer (see MPEP § 2106.05 (f)).
The additional elements of “artificial intelligence (AI) module” or “artificial intelligence” in general for Dependent Claims 8 and 20 do not amount to significantly more than the judicial exceptions under step 2B due to being expressly recognized as Well-Understood, Routine and Conventional (WURC) in the art.
See for example; US PG Pub (US 2019/0026786 A1) – “Platform for Managing Social Media Content Throughout an Organization”, hereinafter Khoury, et. al. Khoury at ¶ [0125]: “Such content 25a as well as a template 25b containing the same, its form, and its delivery parameters may be determined by a user of the system, or may be determined based on various algorithms run by the system, e.g., by an artificial intelligence module thereof. Particularly, as described in detail below, the system 1 may include an A/I module, which A/I module may be configured for analyzing (potential) content 25a, determining patterns and trends of recipient activity, and may further be configured for automatically generating content 250 (or suggestions thereof) and/or for determining suggested delivery patterns of communications or messaging containing that content 25.” See also Khoury at ¶ [0189]: “For instance, in one instance, as explained below, an artificial intelligence (A/I) module 54 of the system may be employed to weigh the various factors of the system, determine trends with respect thereto, and may configure the content collector 12, e.g., API or web crawler, so as to collect content 25 from across the web for inclusion into the repository 34.” See also for example; US PG Pub (US 2024/0346098 A1) – “Machine-Learning News Aggregation and Serving”, hereinafter Cicinyte, et. al. Cicinyte at ¶ [0031]: “It will be apparent to one of skill in the art that any suitable machine learning or artificial intelligence techniques may be used to train the models, including one or more of supervised, unsupervised, and/or reinforcement learning.”
The ordered combination of elements in the Dependent Claims (including the limitations inherited from the parent claim(s)) add nothing that is not already present as when the elements are taken individually. There is no indication that the combination of elements improves the functioning of a computer or improves any other technology. Accordingly, the subject matter encompassed by the dependent claims fails to amount to a practical application or significantly more than the abstract idea itself. Therefore, under Step 2B, Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 do not include additional elements that are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the recited judicial exceptions. Thus, Claims 1, 4-13 and 16-24 are ineligible with respect to the 35 U.S.C. § 101 analysis.
Examining Claims with Respect to Prior Art
10. Applicant’s arguments, see pages 18-24 of 25 filed on 08/13/2026, with respect to the 35 U.S.C. § 103 Claim Rejections for Claims 1-3, 5, 9-16 and 21-24 have been fully considered, and are found to be persuasive. Therefore, the 35 U.S.C. § 103 Claim Rejections for Claims 1-24 are withdrawn. See Examining Claims with Respect to Prior Art Section below.
Regarding Independent Claims 1 and 13, there is no disclosure in the existing prior art or any new art that either teaches and/or discloses the sequence operation of features either individually or in combination relating to:
- “assigning and storing, at the computing device, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, and resulting from a selected dislike user feedback, available prompt selections indicative of customizing the first predicted outcome”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, a field that receives a user new customized value that contradicts the first predicted outcome”;
- “wherein assigning and storing, at the computing device, the user sentiment score related to the user feedback further comprises: assigning the user new customized value as user defined odds to the user sentiment score and wherein the user sentiment score includes the user defined odds”.
The closest prior arts are as follows:
US Patent # (US 8,396,777 B1) – “Prediction Market Database, Related Methods, Devices, and Systems”, hereinafter Fine, et. al;
US PG Pub (US 2014/0162241 A1) – “Determining Crowd Consensus”, hereinafter Morgia, et. al;
3) US PG Pub (US 2025/0254380 A1) – “Systems and methods for Generating a Smart Overlay for an Interactive Display” hereinafter Cockerill, et. al.
Regarding Independent Claim 1, Fine method for predicting an outcome from an event based on user sentiment teaches the following:
- receiving (see at least Fine: Fig. 2C & Figs. 8-9), at a computing device having one or more processors (see at least Fine: Fig. 1 & Fig. 4.), event market data (see at least Fine: Figs. 8-9 & Col. 2, Lns. 9-12 & Col. 2, Lns. 54-65. Fine teaches a prediction tool (used by individual users to make their predictions for one or more events supported by the relational database), and a viewing and reporting tool 119. See also Fine at Col. 2, Lns. 54-65: Box 283 presents a multi-dimensional prediction market representing past (January) and future (February, March) sales of hypothetical products 1 and J. The market to be adjusted is the forecast for product J in month February (as represented by an italic, underlined figure "42"). This prediction is effectively cascaded to a geography dimension (represented as plural boxes or "events," including forecast sales for just the US and for just Mexico, as indicate by boxes 285 and 287) as well as to higher order, related markets (e.g., forecasts for "all products", as indicated by box 291) using "roll-up" and "roll-down" functionality.), the event market data having a first predicted outcome from the event (see at least Fine: Col. 7, Lns. 20-40 & Col. 18, Lns. 1-29. Fine teaches that it was mentioned earlier that one converts user inputs to Normal distributions and then aggregates multiple Normal distributions to form a cumulative probability distribution (used to provide a "crowd-based" prediction for the event). The administrator might prior to the first wager provide an initial Normal distribution and weight the distribution to provide elasticity to support the first wager that will be received-if for example the prediction market is used to forecast "this quarter's profits", the administrator might set an initial weight of $5000 (representing $5000 in initial bets), an initial mean of $10M, and a standard deviation of $3M. The administrator should typically have an understanding of the value of a typical wager (e.g., $500 in play credits) and a somewhat accurate baseline for expected profits (e.g., last year's actual profits) for the market to offer the correct elasticity given the number and nature of wagers that will be provided, expertise that will be gained with experience. See also Fine at Col. 18, Lns. 1-29: It might be desired to permit users to make predictions on "sales for January," "sales for February," and "sales for March," and to define "first quarter sales" as a mathematical function for these month-based events. As each prediction is received, e.g., a wager on sales for March, it may be desired to "roll-up" a revised forecast for "March" such that it is also reflected in another tier ( e.g., "first quarter sales"). If a new user input expresses a prediction of significant sales for March, the new user input is combined with existing user wagers (represented by a cumulative probability distribution for "March") to obtain a revised, cumulative probability distribution for March; because, however, this change in crowd prediction for March would also imply a change in crowd predictions for the first quarter sales, a cumulative probability distribution is also revised for "first quarter sales" to combine changes for March with the (unchanged) predictions for "January" and "February," as established through the mathematical dependencies selected by the administrator.)
- displaying, as rendered graphics on a visual display of the computing device (see at least Fine: Fig. 1 & Figs. 8-9 & Col. 21, Lns. 34-43. Fine teaches that the invocation of widget functionality is represented by reference numeral 813, and three sample choices that may be offered are represented by graphics 815, 816, and 817, respectively. These graphics represent, respectively, an interactive display or display graphic that may be associated with placing a wager, viewing crowd forecast for the associated event, or viewing a listing of all wagers made the user has made in association with the particular event; as alluded, fewer functions or alternative functions may also be used. Examiner notes the computing device is shown in Fig. 1 and more rendered graphics is shown in Figs. 2B-2C and Figs. 8-9 of Fine reference.), the first predicted outcome (see at least Fine: Col. 2, Lns. 29-46 & Col. 25, Lns. 40-65 & Figs. 8-10. Fine teaches that changes at a specific tier (e.g., tier 1011) represented by a new user input (or administrator or manager modification forced modification of the crowd prediction) are presented at the affected tier by a wager entered into the bet log, and a revision of the cumulative probability distribution for the affected location. After this step is effectuated, software identifies each higher-level tier location that references the "changed" location, and a subroutine invokes the calculation engine to determine a new probability distribution based upon both unaltered and changed probability distributions at the level below the identified higher level tier location. For example, if the right-hand most box associated with numeral 1011 was modified to reflect a predicted outcome received as a new user input, software would compute a revised, cumulative distribution for the location identified by reference numeral 1013, based on the unaltered locations identified by numeral 1011 and the altered location represented by the right-hand-most box next to numeral 1011. See also Fine: Col. 2, Lns. 29-46: The object of any particular "wager" on an outcome can be expressed as a point bet (e.g., "I bet team X will win the Stanley Cup"), or a confidence range (e.g., "I bet the total points for the NCAA men’s basketball tournament final game will be between 150 and 162"), or a distribution (e.g., "I believe the correct distribution for total points of the NCAA men’s basketball tournament final game will be a Normal distribution having a mean of 157 and a standard deviation of 4"). These different types of expressions are represented by numerals 243, 245 and 247 in FIG. 2B; as indicated by corresponding graphics boxes 251, 255 and 259, a meaningful display may be provided to the user seeking to place a wager that shows exactly how a proposed wager might overlap with the "aggregate prediction" of other users (i.e., to show how the proposed wager compares to "crowd wisdom" and to provide associated odds or pricing that can be employed by the user to assess what the user stands to gain by winning the bet). See also Fine: Col. 28, Lns. 24-30: A sports information agency may use these teachings to predict the outcomes of sporting events, or sports seasons by collecting information in the form of user wagers from a blog base (whether weighted by bet amounts, provided with rewards or otherwise), to obtain probability distributions that reflect crowd wisdom. See also Fine at Figs. 2B-2C.).
However, neither Fine, et. al and the other prior art of record do not reach or render obvious the sequence of limitations directed to:
- “assigning and storing, at the computing device, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, and resulting from a selected dislike user feedback, available prompt selections indicative of customizing the first predicted outcome”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, a field that receives a user new customized value that contradicts the first predicted outcome”;
- “wherein assigning and storing, at the computing device, the user sentiment score related to the user feedback further comprises: assigning the user new customized value as user defined odds to the user sentiment score and wherein the user sentiment score includes the user defined odds”.
Regarding Independent Claim 1, Morgia method for predicting an outcome from an event based on user sentiment teaches the following:
- displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display (see at least Morgia: ¶ [0178] & ¶ [0749-0750]. Morgia notes that if the approval rate drops below a particular threshold, or trends downward in a particular manner, the question-askers may choose to deviate from the agenda and change the nature of the questions being asked. The asking, rating, and approving may continue indefinitely in this manner. The approval levels, taken as single data points or used as a trend, provide feedback to the question-askers as to whether they are asking the right questions. See also Morgia at ¶ [0178]: The collective opinion of the crowd can be collected and shown on a timeline graph. In some instances, this can be available for all to see.), available prompt selections indicative of a like and a dislike (see at least Morgia: ¶ [0164] & ¶ [0204] & Fig. 3 & Fig 98. Morgia notes that FIG. 3 shows an example of a time graph 300 for a 30 second period in which the group collectively felt positively (e.g., liked, agreed, found exciting) during seconds˜6-15 302, and then felt negatively (e.g., disliked, disagreed, found boring) during second 2-26 304. In the beginning (seconds˜2-4) and end (seconds˜25-30), the crowd was neutral. See also Morgia at Fig. 5 noting the slider showing strongly disapprove and strongly approve along with the trend/line graph shown in Morgia at Fig. 6.), wherein the like represents agreement with the first predicted outcome and the dislike represents disagreement with the first predicted outcome (see at least Morgia: ¶ [0204] & Fig. 98. Morgia teaches that FIG. 98 shows a screenshot 9800 of a presorting option that can be used by itself as a voting round or in combination with one of the examples. For instance, the participant can select one or several ideas 9802 he/she likes (or agrees with) by pressing the up arrow 9804 to the idea's left, and/or the participant can select one or several ideas 9802 he/she dislikes (or disagrees with) by pressing the down arrow 9806 to the idea's right. The “done” button 9808 can be clicked/pressed to move to the next screen. In some examples, the ideas that the participant liked could then be displayed as a list for further ranking, for instance as shown in FIGS. 73, 74, 77, 78, 80, etc. See also Morgia at ¶ [0031]: We use the term “idea” and each of the other terms in its broadest sense to include, for example, any item, entity, object, expression, indicia, icon, audio or visual item, or other thing that can be approved or ranked or ordered or discussed or joined, or any combination of those, including comments in forums, potential products or services, political candidates, memberships, possible goals, and selections of music, videos and text, among others. See also Morgia at ¶ [0294]: Once again, in many situations, it cannot be known in a real situation if the predicted winners are the best, but all the simulations have returned very high perfection ratios for voting round 2 tests (over 90%). See also Morgia at ¶ [0622]: In element 4812, the participants provide their respective responses to the question of element 4811, which may be referred to as “ideas”. Their answers may be selected from a list, as in a multiple-choice vote or a political election, or may be open-ended, with a wording and/or content initiated by each respective participant. See also Morgia at Fig. 5 noting the slider showing strongly disapprove and strongly approve along with the trend/line graph shown in Morgia at Fig. 6.)
- receiving, at the computing device (see at least Morgia: Fig. 47 & ¶ [0606]. Morgia teaches that other implementations can also be used, such as mobile computing devices, mobile communication devices, set-top box television client devices, etc.), feedback (see at least Morgia: ¶ [0022] & ¶ [0706] & ¶ [0750]. Morgia teaches that the participants arrive at a consensus idea that answers the second question, and submit approval levels for the second question. If the approval rate is too low, the question-askers may choose to deviate from the agenda to ask a third question. This third question is determined in part by the approval levels for the first and second questions. The asking, rating, and approving may continue indefinitely in this manner. The approval levels, taken as single data points or used as a trend, provide feedback to the question-askers as to whether they are asking the right questions. See also Morgia at ¶ [0022]: We use the terms “outcomes” and “goals” in their broadest possible senses to include, for example, any group decision or goal, any useful or interesting data developed or discovered within the group, or any knowledge or opinions possessed by members of a group, including the best (or worst) customer ideas or suggestions, group feedback on any project or idea, group consensus, group bargaining, experiences of group members, and a group's rankings of ideas, among others. We note here that group communication as we describe it includes, for example, true nuanced qualitative idea formation by a mass of people. See also Morgia at ¶ [0160]: All sorts of icons/edit-tools could be included that a participant could use to provide feedback, such as: Clarify, Elaborate, Too Strong, Too Wishy-washy, Too Vulgar, Tone it Down, Tone it Up, Boring, I Like This, I Don't Like This, I Think This is Wrong, I Know This is Wrong. See also Morgia at ¶ [0706]: For instance, an agenda may be written up by a group of participants, posted, and voted on by the all the participants. The full agenda or individual items may be voted on the group, in order to provide immediate feedback. Such approval voting may be accomplished in discrete steps or along a continuum, such as with a toggle switch or any suitable mechanism. This approval voting may redirect the agenda according to the overall wishes of the participants. See also Morgia at ¶ [0187].) associated with the first predicted outcome based on one of a selected like and dislike (see at least Morgia: ¶ [0164] & ¶ [0204] & Fig. 3 & Fig 98. Morgia notes that FIG. 3 shows an example of a time graph 300 for a 30 second period in which the group collectively felt positively (e.g., liked, agreed, found exciting) during seconds˜6-15 302, and then felt negatively (e.g., disliked, disagreed, found boring) during second 2-26 304. In the beginning (seconds˜2-4) and end (seconds˜25-30), the crowd was neutral. See also Morgia at Fig. 5 noting the slider showing strongly disapprove and strongly approve along with the trend/line graph shown in Morgia at Fig. 6. See also Morgia at ¶ [0187]: For each idea 6406, the participant has several options: (1) the participant can press the “best so far” button 6408 to set the idea as #1 (bumping all previous ideas down, so any existing #1 becomes #2, any existing #2 becomes #3, etc.), (2) the participant can press the “Trash it!” button 6410 to move the idea to the bottom of the list or (3) the participant can press the “Maybe it's OK” button 6412 to move the idea to just below any of the ideas that were the “Best.” A button instruction section 6414 explains the outcome of pressing each of the buttons 6408, 6410 and 6412.).
However, neither Morgia, et. al and the other prior art of record do not reach or render obvious the sequence of limitations directed to:
- “assigning and storing, at the computing device, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, and resulting from a selected dislike user feedback, available prompt selections indicative of customizing the first predicted outcome”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, a field that receives a user new customized value that contradicts the first predicted outcome”;
- “wherein assigning and storing, at the computing device, the user sentiment score related to the user feedback further comprises: assigning the user new customized value as user defined odds to the user sentiment score and wherein the user sentiment score includes the user defined odds”.
Regarding Independent Claim 1, Cockerill method for predicting an outcome from an event based on user sentiment teaches the following:
Cockerill teaches at ¶ [0016] that an overlay may be partially transparent such that a video stream is visible through the overlay. An overlay may be interactive such that a user (e.g., a user of a user device) may select the overlay or a subset of the overlay (e.g., a button, icon, etc.). Such interaction may allow a user to take an odds based action (e.g., make a market prediction, perform a fantasy sport action). The overlay may be dynamically determined based on event data and may provide an odds based option based on the event data. Cockerill teaches at ¶ [0016] at ¶ [0060] teaches that the generative artificial intelligence model may refine (e.g., retrain) its understanding using reinforcement learning or feedback loops, thereby continuously updating predictions based on new user interactions. This personalized approach may allow the generative artificial intelligence model to tailor responses, recommendations, or content generation (e.g., the generation of the one or more smart overlays) to align more closely with individual user preferences.
However, neither Cockerill, et. al and the other prior art of record do not reach or render obvious the sequence of limitations directed to:
- “assigning and storing, at the computing device, a user sentiment score related to the user feedback”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, the user sentiment score concurrently with the first predicted outcome from the event market data”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, and resulting from a selected dislike user feedback, available prompt selections indicative of customizing the first predicted outcome”;
- “displaying, as rendered graphics on the visual display, a field that receives a user new customized value that contradicts the first predicted outcome”;
- “wherein assigning and storing, at the computing device, the user sentiment score related to the user feedback further comprises: assigning the user new customized value as user defined odds to the user sentiment score and wherein the user sentiment score includes the user defined odds”.
Therefore, when taken as a whole, the claims are not rendered obvious as the available prior art does not suggest or otherwise render obvious the noted features nor do the available art suggest or otherwise render obvious further modification of the evidence at hand. Such modification would require substantial reconstruction relying solely on improper hindsight bias, and thus would not be obvious.
Conclusion
Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to DERICK HOLZMACHER whose telephone number is (571) 270-7853. The examiner can normally be reached on Monday-Friday 9:00 AM – 6:30 PM EST.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, Applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Brian Epstein can be reached on 571-270-5389. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-270-8853.
Information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from Patent Center. Status information for published applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Status information for unpublished applications is available through Patent Center for authorized users only. Should you have questions about access to Patent Center, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free).
/DERICK J HOLZMACHER/
Patent Examiner, Art Unit 3625A
/BRIAN M EPSTEIN/Supervisory Patent Examiner, Art Unit 3625