Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
Claims 1-3, 5-12, and 14-22 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to a judicial exception (i.e., a law of nature, a natural phenomenon, or an abstract idea) without significantly more.
Claim 1
Step 1, This part of the eligibility analysis evaluates whether the claim falls within any statutory category. See MPEP 2106.03. The claim recites a vehicle identification number (VIN) system comprising one or more memory devices and one or more processors that perform at least one step. Thus, the claim is a machine, which is one of the statutory categories of invention under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
Step 2A Prong 1, This part of the eligibility analysis evaluates whether the claim recites a judicial exception. As explained in MPEP 2106.04, subsection II, a claim “recites” a judicial exception when the judicial exception is “set forth” or “described” in the claim.
Limitation “calculating, by an artificial intelligence (AI) scoring model, a reliability score based on at least one of the VIN and the data associated with the VIN according to a set of standards used for the VIN for a particular type of vehicle” This limitation recites “calculating” a reliability score based on inputs and standards. It falls within the grouping of Mathematical Concepts.
Limitation “calculating, via the Al scoring model, an updated reliability score based on the user input modification” This limitation explicitly recites "calculating" an updated reliability score. It falls within the grouping of Mathematical Concepts.
Step 2a Prong 2 This part of the eligibility analysis evaluates whether the claim as a whole integrates the recited judicial exception into a practical application of the exception or whether the claim is "directed to" the judicial exception. This evaluation is performed by (1) identifying whether there are any additional elements recited in the claim beyond the judicial exception, and (2) evaluating those additional elements individually and in combination to determine whether the claim as a whole integrates the exception into a practical application. See MPEP 2106.04(d).
The additional elements:
one or more memory devices comprising a database storing, for each of a plurality of VINs, specification data for a corresponding vehicle model;
one or more processors, one or more memory devices;
receiving a VIN from a remote user device;
retrieving data associated with the VIN from the database;
sending instructions to the remote user device to display the data associated with the VIN and the reliability score;
receiving, from the remote user device, a user input modification comprising at least one of an update to the data associated with the VIN or a correction to the data associated with the VIN;
updating the database with the user input modification when the updated reliability score is above a predetermined threshold;
training the Al scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training.
MPEP 2106.05(a) Improvements to the Functioning of a Computer or to Any Other Technology or Technical Field:
The additional elements describe system architecture and data management steps. However, evaluating these additional elements individually and in combination does not integrate the exception into a practical application because there is no improvement to the functioning of a computer or other technology. The claim uses generic processors and memory devices to store and retrieve data. The “AI scoring model” is described as a tool used to perform the calculation. It merely applies standard machine learning techniques to score data. Consequently, the claim does not improve existing technology and remains directed to the abstract idea without meaningful integration.
MPEP 2106.05(b) Particular Machine:
The additional elements describe hardware components like memory devices, processors, and remote user devices. The “one or more processors” and “remote user device” do not perform any specific function that improves upon the abstract idea; they are merely used as tools to implement the calculation steps.
MPEP 2106.05(c) Particular Transformation:
The additional elements describe data management steps like updating a database and training a model. The “updating” step involves storing numerical scores and text data back into a repository based on a threshold condition, which is a conventional data storage operation. Similarly, “training” the model is based on input modifications, which does not transform a physical object in a meaningful way that integrates the abstract idea of calculating reliability scores into a practical application.
MPEP 2106.05(e) Other Meaningful Limitations:
The additional elements describe input, retrieval, output, and training steps. However, evaluating these additional elements individually and in combination does not integrate the exception into a practical application. The “set of standards used for the VIN” is a constraint that defines the data being processed rather than integrating the calculation into a practical application. Furthermore, receiving input and sending instructions are generic steps performed by standard software interfaces. These steps do not integrate the mathematical concept of calculating scores into a practical application beyond simply instructing the computer to perform the math.
MPEP 2106.05(g) Insignificant Extra-Solution Activity:
The additional elements describe data gathering, retrieval, storage, and user interaction steps. Receiving a VIN from a remote device, retrieving data from a database, receiving user input modifications, and updating a database based on a threshold are all conventional activities. These steps do not add meaningful limits to the abstract idea but rather describe how the computer system interacts with external entities (users, databases) to facilitate the.
MPEP 2106.05(h) Field of Use and Technological Environment:
The additional elements describe operations within the RV industry. The claim is directed to calculating reliability scores for vehicle identification numbers (VINs) in the recreational vehicle industry. While this specifies a field of use, it does not improve the functioning of computers or technology within that field.
Step 2B, examine the additional elements individually and as an ordered combination—to see if they provide an inventive concept that adds "significantly more" than the exception itself.
The additional steps (receiving, retrieving, sending instructions, updating database, training AI model) are well-understood, routine, and conventional practices in the relevant field of computer data processing and management. There is no unconventional use or configuration described that goes beyond standard software implementation. The claim limitations describe the steps for managing RV data. The AI scoring mode" and database updates are implemented using conventional computing techniques. The ordered combination does not describe a specific, non-generic solution that adds significantly more than the abstract idea of calculating scores based on standards. The additional elements do not provide an inventive concept that adds significantly more than the judicial exception itself. Therefore, the claim is patent ineligible under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
Claim 2 recites “wherein the user input modification further comprises an update to the VIN itself”. The claim merely recites a functional result, accepting user-submitted corrections, rather than a specific technical solution to a technical problem. The claim does not amount to significantly more than the abstract idea.
Claim 3 recites “wherein the one or more processors are further configured for: calculating a further updated reliability score based on the update to the VIN; and updating the database with the update to the VIN when the further updated reliability score is above the predetermined threshold.” The calculation serves only to validate data entry within the existing abstract framework of scoring and storing VIN information, and the conditional storage is a well-understood, routine computer function that does not amount to significantly more than the exception.
Claim 5 recites “wherein sending the instructions to the remote user device comprises sending the instructions via an application programming interface (API) or a web application.” The claim merely describes a field of use rather than a specific technical solution to a technical problem. The claim does not amount to significantly more than the abstract idea.
Claim 6 recites “wherein the reliability score is based on a quantity of characters in the VIN or use of excluded characters.” The claim does not provide an inventive concept because it simply refines how the calculation is performed rather than providing a technical improvement to computer functionality beyond the basic scoring algorithm.
Claim 7 recites “wherein the reliability score is decreased by a predetermined amount if at least one excluded character is present in the VIN.” The limitation does not integrate the exception into a practical application because it is merely an additional rule. It does not improve technology or computers.
Claim 8 recites “wherein the one or more processors are further configured for: sending instructions to the remote user device to output a warning when the at least one excluded character is present in the VIN.” The addition of a warning notification does not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application because it merely provides feedback. The claim does not amount to significantly more than the judicial exception itself.
Claim 9 recites “wherein the data associated with the VIN includes two or more of: a manufacturer, a year, a make, a model, a trim, a valuation, a weight, dimensions, axles, a capacity, standard features, floorplan images, stock photos of the vehicle, specifications of the vehicle, and AI-generated summaries of the specifications of the vehicle.” Merely including the list of data types does not integrate the abstract idea into a practical application. The claim does not amount to significantly more than the abstract idea.
Claim 21 recites “a user input database separate from the database, wherein the one or more processors is further configured for: storing the user input modification in the user input database.” While this adds structural detail to the system of Claim 1, generic computer components (separate databases) used to perform data processing steps do not integrate the judicial exception into a practical application.
Claims 10-12, 14-22 are similar to claim 1-3, 5-9, and 21. The claims 10-12, 14-22 are rejected based on the same reasons.
Response to Arguments
Section Rejections based on 35 U.S.C 101
Pg. 9-10, Applicant argues that “… Applicant submits that the claims are not directed to a mental process. Claims do not recite a mental process when they do not contain limitations that can practically be performed in the human mind, for instance, when the human mind is not equipped to perform the claim limitations. MPEP § 2106.04(a); SRIInt'l, Inc. v. Cisco Systems, Inc., 930 F.3d 1295, 1304 (Fed. Cir. 2019). Applicant submits that the claims, as amended, recite steps that cannot practically be performed in the human mind, including with pen and paper. For example, the claims, as amended, recite "training the Al scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the Al scoring model after training," where training an Al scoring model cannot practically be performed in the human mind or with pen and paper. That is, a human mind cannot train a machine-learning model, and, correspondingly, cannot alter the parameters of such model to change a future output. As such, the claimed training of the Al score model does not describe an abstract concept, or a concept similar to those found by the courts to be abstract, such as a fundamental economic practice, a method of organizing human activity, an idea itself (standing alone), or a mathematical relationship. Instead, this limitation is directed to an improvement in the functionality of the AI scoring model to calculate the reliability score by optimizing computational efficiency and reducing a margin of error in system performance. As such, the claims are not directed to an abstract idea for at least this reason…”
Applicant’s argument has been considered.
Applicant argues that the step “training the AI scoring model” cannot be performed by a human mind or with pen and paper, and therefore does not recite a mental process. The Examiner acknowledges that limitations which cannot practically be performed in the human mind do not qualify as mental processes under MPEP § 2106.04(a). However, this limitation is still considered to recite an abstract idea based on the grouping of Mathematical Concepts under MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2).
Applicant further argues that this step improves the functionality of the AI model by optimizing efficiency and reducing errors. The specification does not provide sufficient technical details to demonstrate an improvement in computer functionality. Claiming a model is “trained” fails to demonstrate actual improvements to computer or technology; it merely describes using basic computer functions for abstract mathematics. Therefore, while the limitation “training model” is not a mental process, The claim remains directed to a judicial exception (a mathematical concept) and fails to provide significantly more than the recited exception in Step 2B.
Pg. 10-11, Applicant argues that “… To further prosecution, Applicant has further amended exemplary independent claim 1 to recite:
receiving, from the remote user device, a user input modification comprising at least one of an update to the data associated with the VIN or a correction to the data associated with the VIN;
calculating, via the Al scoring model, an updated reliability score based on the user input modification;
updating the database with the user input modification when the updated reliability score is above a predetermined threshold;
Particularly, updating a reliability score based on user input and updating the database with the user input modification when the updated reliability score is above a predetermined threshold is an operation that relies upon the instructions of a computer-readable medium and on the stored, VIN database. The Examiner alleged that original claim 3 could be achieved by a user "mentally [to] re-calculate a score after corrections and update to database based comparing the re-calculated score above predefined threshold". Office Action, p. 8. However, such interpretation improperly considers updating a database as a mental process. As such, Applicant submits that the supposed abstract idea is not recited in the claims and the present invention is subject matter eligible.
Further, both calculation steps for reliability scores are now expressly performed by the AI scoring model, not by a generic processor that could arguably be described as merely applying human-readable and implemented rules. The Examiner's previous characterization that the step "encompasses the user mentally assigning a score to a VIN or retrieved data by checking it against a set of standards or rules" is now moot based on the current amendments. Office Action, p. 3. A score generated by a trained Al model, whose behavior depends on the provided user input modification, is not the product of observation, evaluation, and judgment as a mental process may be defined.
As such, Applicant submits that the supposed abstract idea is not recited in the claims and the present invention is subject matter eligible…”
Applicant’s argument has been considered.
The Applicant argues that the steps of calculating an updated reliability score and updating the database are not abstract ideas because they rely on computer-readable media and a trained AI model. Applicant further notes that in the previous Office Action, these steps were characterized as mental processes. The Examiner agrees with Applicant that the inclusion of a "trained AI scoring model" suggests these limitations may not fit within the mental process grouping. However, this does not render the claims eligible. A claim that recites a mathematical calculation will be considered as falling within the mathematical concepts grouping. The limitation in Claim 1 explicitly states: “calculating... an updated reliability score based on the user input modification.” This is a clear recitation of mathematical calculations. Further, the groupings are not mutually exclusive. A claim can fall within multiple groupings. For this rejection, it is sufficient to identify it as a Mathematical Concept.
The fact that current Claim 1 specifies “via the AI scoring model” does not change the fundamental nature of the calculation itself. It merely describes how the mathematical concept is implemented.
Pg. 11, Applicant argues that “… Applicant submits that even if the claim were directed to the alleged abstract idea, the claims integrate the alleged abstract idea into a specific, practical application. The claims are more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the alleged abstract idea; instead, the claims impose a meaningful limit on the judicial exception. For example, the claims describe a specific framework for storing, retrieving, updating, and scoring reliability of data associated with vehicle identification number (VINs). That is, one or more processors coupled to a database and a remote user device collaborate to enable, and train, an AI scoring model to calculate and further refine a reliability score based on user input…”
Applicant’s argument has been considered.
The additional elements - processors communicably coupled to a memory device containing a database, and communication with a remote user device - are generic computer components. The mere recitation of generic computer components does not integrate an abstract idea into a practical application. These are well-understood, routine, conventional activities in the field of computing. The claim does not improve the functioning of the computer itself or any other technology; it merely uses generic hardware to perform the abstract steps of receiving data, calculating scores, and updating records.
The “AI scoring model” is recited at a high level of generality without any specific technical improvement described in either the specification or the claims. The claim does not describe how the AI model improves computer technology. The claim does not describe any particular mechanism by which the AI model operates differently from conventional systems. The claim recites training an AI model based on user input modifications. The specification does not describe any specific technical improvement to the AI technology itself.
Pg. 11, Applicant argues that “… Applicant submits that the limitation reciting "training the AI scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training", integrates the purported abstract idea into a practical application. Specifically, this limitation integrates any purported abstract idea into the practical application of improving the efficiency and functioning of the AI scoring model to calculate the reliability score by optimizing computational efficiency and reducing a margin of error in system performance. Additionally, the instant specification states that the database "functions as a repository of comprehensive data and is continually updated with user inputs to foster an ever-evolving and improved dataset", enhancing data accuracy and reliability. Specification at [0023], [0026]. Accordingly, the limitations as a whole are directed to an improvement in VIN system accuracy and reliability rather than an abstract idea of a mental process. For at least this reason, Applicant respectfully requests the present § 101 rejection be withdrawn…”
Applicant argues that limitation "training the Al scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training” integrates the abstract idea into a practical application by improving efficiency and reducing error margins. Applicant relies on Specification paragraphs [0023] and [0026].
The specification describes general goals of an "ever-evolving and improved dataset" but does not disclose a particular technical solution to a technical problem inherent in the operation of the AI scoring system.
Paragraph [0023] states: "This database functions as a repository of comprehensive data and is continually updated with user inputs to foster an ever-evolving and improved dataset." This describes a general objective of maintaining current information, not a specific technical improvement to the functioning of the AI model.
Paragraph [0026] states: "In instances where a VIN is inaccurately decoded, the web application may present users with the option to input correct details to further aid in refining and improving the database." This describes user interaction rather than an improvement to the technology itself. It does not explain how the training mechanism improves computer functionality.
In Desjardins, the specification disclosed how the model was trained to learn new tasks while protecting knowledge about previous tasks to overcome "catastrophic forgetting" The claims recited specific steps that implemented this improvement: "adjust the first values of the plurality of parameters to optimize performance of the machine learning model on the second machine learning task while protecting performance of the machine learning model on the first machine learning task."
In contrast, limitation "training the Al scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training” does not recite a particular way to train the model that solves a technical problem inherent in AI systems.
The limitation recites training an AI model based on user input, which is well-understood, routine, and conventional activity in the field of machine learning. Unlike Desjardins, where the claims recited particular steps addressing catastrophic forgetting, limitation "training the Al scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training” does not reflect any disclosed technical improvement that would integrate the abstract idea into a practical application at Step 2A Prong Two.
Pg. 12-13, Applicant argues that “… Furthermore, even assuming that the claims are directed to the identified abstract idea, which point Applicant does not concede, the claims include "significantly more" than said abstract idea because they are not well-understood, routine, or conventional activity in the field. The claims as amended recite "training the AI scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training." The claims further recite "receiving, from the remote user device, a user input modification comprising at least one of an update to the data associated with the VIN or a correction to the data associated with the VIN; calculating, via the AI scoring model, an updated reliability score based on the user input modification; updating the database with the user input modification when the updated reliability score is above a predetermined threshold." These limitations improve the operation VIN system by enabling the database, and, thus, the data associated with the VINs, to be continually updated with user inputs to enhancing data accuracy and reliability. Specification at [0023], [0026].
As such, the claims recite a particular technological implementation that optimizes computational efficiency and reduces a margin of error in system performance in a manner that is not well-understood, routine, or conventional in the field of VIN decoding/vehicle data systems. As an example, Applicant submits that this concept of improving the functionality of the AI scoring model to calculate the reliability score is not present within any of the art of record. Accordingly, Applicant submits that training the AI scoring model with the user input modification provides significantly more than any purported abstract idea. Thus, for at least this reason, Applicant respectfully requests the present § 101 rejection be withdrawn…”
Applicant’s argument has been considered. The claim as a whole does not provide significantly more than the abstract idea for the following reasons:
Applicant argues that “training the AI scoring model based on the user input modification” provides an inventive concept because it improves computational efficiency and reduces error margins. However, this argument is not supported by either the specification.
Paragraph [0023] states: "This database functions as a repository of comprehensive data and is continually updated with user inputs to foster an ever-evolving and improved dataset." This describes a general objective of maintaining current information, not a specific technical improvement to the functioning of the AI model.
Paragraph [0026] states: "In instances where a VIN is inaccurately decoded, the web application may present users with the option to input correct details to further aid in refining and improving the database." This describes user interaction rather than an improvement to the technology itself. It does not explain how the training mechanism improves computer functionality. The specification does not disclose how this training improves computer functionality beyond simply producing more accurate scores.
A claim improves technology when it recites components or steps that provide the improvement described in the specification. The current claim recites: "training the AI scoring model based on the user input modification such that a subsequent reliability score calculated for a subsequently received VIN is calculated by the AI scoring model after training." This limitation merely states that the model will be trained and then used to calculate scores — which is the abstract idea itself applied with conventional computer components. The claim does not recite any particular mechanism for improving how the model functions (e.g., parameter adjustment, weight preservation, memory management, or other technical means of overcoming a specific technical problem).
The additional limitations: receiving a VIN from a remote user device; retrieving data associated with the VIN from the database; sending instructions to the remote user device to display the data associated with the VIN and the reliability score; receiving, from the remote user device, a user input modification comprising at least one of an update to the data associated with the VIN or a correction to the data associated with the VIN; updating the database with the user input modification when the updated reliability score is above a predetermined threshold taken individually and in combination with the training step, do not amount to significantly more than the abstract idea of scoring data accuracy using a model.
For these reasons, Applicant's arguments do not overcome the § 101 rejection. The claim as a whole is directed to an abstract idea and does not provide an inventive concept sufficient to render it patent-eligible subject matter under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
The § 101 rejection is maintained.
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure
CN111126042A – ZHANG YAN provides a VIN code verification method and device and a VIN code recognition method and device using confidence. The VIN code verification method using the confidence coefficient comprises the following steps: obtaining a VIN code to be verified through identification; obtaining the confidence coefficient of the VIN code to be verified, and verifying the VIN code to be verified by using a first verification method; and if the confidence coefficient of the VIN code to be verified passes confidence coefficient verification and the initial verification result of the first verification method is that verification is passed, judging that the VIN code to be verified passes the verification. According to the scheme, the verification accuracy and the recognition accuracy of the VINcode can be improved
CN111126044B - 张岩 provides a VIN code multiple verification method, a VIN code recognition method and apparatus that utilize confidence levels. The VIN code multiple verification method using confidence level includes: obtaining the VIN code to be verified by identification; obtaining the confidence level of the VIN code to be verified, and verifying the VIN code to be verified using the VIN code multiple verification method; if the confidence level of the VIN code to be verified passes the confidence level verification, and the initial verification result of the VIN code multiple verification method is that the verification is passed, it is determined that the VIN code to be verified has passed the verification. The above method can improve the accuracy of VIN code verification and recognition.
Conclusion
THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to HAU HAI HOANG whose telephone number is (571)270-5894. The examiner can normally be reached 1st biwk: Mon-Thurs 7:00 AM-5:00 PM; 2nd biwk: Mon-Thurs: 7:00 am-5:00pm, Fri: 7:00 am - 4:00pm.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Boris Gorney can be reached at 571-270-5626. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
HAU HAI. HOANG
Primary Examiner
Art Unit 2154
/HAU H HOANG/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2154