DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. § 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 1-20 rejected under 35 U.S.C. § 101 are directed to an abstract idea without significantly more.
The claims do not provide significantly more than the judicial exception under the subject matter eligibility two-part statutory analysis, as provided below.
Regarding Step 1,
Step 1 addresses whether the claims are directed to one of the four statutory categories of invention, i.e., process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter according to MPEP §2106.03. Independent claims 1, 8 and 15 recite a method (process), computing device (apparatus/machine), and a non-transitory computer readable medium (article of manufacture), thus all claims 1-20 fall within one of the four statutory categories.
Regarding Step 2A [prong 1],
The claimed invention recites an abstract idea according to MPEP §2106.04. Independent claim 1, also representative of independent claims 8 and 15 for the same abstract features, is underlined below which recite the following claim limitations, as an abstract idea.
Claims 1, 8 and 15:
receiving an input provided by a user, a request to generate the product description information for the product;
retrieving by using a product identifier included in the request, product data for the product, the product data including a corresponding product identifier and data describing one or more attributes of the product;
determining one or more user instructions indicated in the request;
retrieving one or more contextual datasets curated with information relevant to the product, wherein the one or more contextual datasets include at least one of: search engine optimization (SEO) data, brand standards data, industry or organization norms data, and target consumer preferences data;
generating the product description information for the product by providing the product data, the one or more user instructions, and the one or more contextual datasets as inputs to a data model to cause the data model to output the product description information for the product,
wherein the data model to generate the product description information in a manner that complies with product description parameters derived from the one or more contextual datasets; and
providing the product description information.
The underlined claim limitations, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, fall under “Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities” grouping of abstract ideas, and includes at least fundamental economic practice, commercial and/or legal interaction, managing personal behavior or relationships or interactions between people (including social activities, teaching, and following rules or instructions). See MPEP §2106.04(a)(2)(II).
But for the recitation of generic implementation of computer system components, the claimed invention merely recites a process for fundamental economic practice, commercial and/or legal interaction, managing personal behavior/relationships or interactions between people because the claimed steps recite steps to provide product description information. Accordingly, since the claimed invention describes a process that falls under “Certain Methods of Organizing Human Activities” grouping, the claimed invention recites an abstract idea.
Regarding Step 2A [prong 2],
The judicial exception is not integrated into a practical application according to MPEP §2106.04(d). Claims 1,8 and 15 include the following additional elements:
A computing device and non-transitory computer readable medium comprising:
a memory storing instructions; and
a processor, communicatively coupled to the memory,
wherein data model is trained using machine learning… display on a user interface of a device or application.
In particular, the additional elements cited above beyond the abstract idea are recited at a high-level of generality and simply equivalent to a generic recitation and basic functionality that amount to no more than mere instructions to apply the judicial exception using generic computer technology components.
The claimed invention merely provides an abstract-idea-based-solution implemented with generic computer processes and components recited at a high-level of generality (receiving, storing, determining, and comparing data) using computer instructions to implement the abstract idea on a computer, and merely “apply it” without any meaningful technological limits or any improvement to technology, technical field or improvement to the functioning of the computer itself.
Additionally, receiving, by a computing device and as an input provided by a user, a request, retrieving, by the computing device and by using a product identifier included in the request, product data, retrieving, by the computing device, one or more contextual datasets and providing, by the computing device, the information for display on a user interface of a device or application amounts to data gathering and selecting a particular data source or type of data to be manipulated, thus does not add any meaningful limitations, and since receiving, storing and transmitting data is considered one of the most basic functions of a computer, these additional elements are deemed as insignificant extra-solution activity to the judicial exception. The legal precedent in Electric Power Group and Ultramercial cited in MPEP 2106.05(g) indicate that selecting information, based on types of information and availability of information for collection, analysis and display, and requiring a request from a user to view an advertisement and restricting public access, are all insignificant extra-solution activity.
Therefore, the additional elements fail to integrate the recited abstract idea into any practical application since they do not impose any non-generic meaningful limits on practicing the abstract idea. Thus, the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea.
Regarding Step 2B,
The claimed invention does not include additional elements that are sufficient to amount to significantly more than the judicial exception. See MPEP §2106.05.
As discussed above, the claimed additional elements recited above amounts to no more than mere instructions to implement the abstract idea by adding the words “apply it” using generic computer components and functionality. See MPEP §2106.05(h). Mere instructions to apply the judicial exception using generic computer components are insufficient to provide an inventive concept. Furthermore, the claimed additional elements merely limit the abstract idea to be executed in a computer environment, thus do nothing more than generally linking the use of a judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use. See MPEP §2106.05(h).
Additionally, re-evaluating the insignificant extra-solution activities listed above, it is determined that they are also well-understood, routine, and conventional, as well. See MPEP 2106.05(d). The legal precedent in Ultramercial, Versata, Symantec, TLI, and OIP Techs court decisions cited in MPEP 2106.05(d)(II) indicate that storing and retrieving information in memory, as well as receipt and transmission of information over a computer network, and updating an activity log are a well-understood, routine, and conventional functions claimed in a generic manner, as is the case here. See also Trading Techs. Int’l, Inc. v. IBG LLC, 921 F.3d 1084, 1093 (Fed. Cir. 2019) (data gathering and displaying are well-understood, routine, and conventional activities) and also buySAFE, Inc. v. Google, Inc., 765 F.3d 1350, 1355 (Fed. Cir. 2014) (“That a computer receives and sends the information over a network—with no further specification—is not even arguably inventive”).
Considered as an ordered combination, the additional elements are claimed at a high-level of generality and add nothing that is not already present when the steps are considered separately. The sequence of the claimed limitations is equally generic and otherwise held to be abstract since the combination of these additional elements is no more than mere instructions to apply the judicial exception using generic computer components operating in their ordinary and generic capacities of what is typically expected of computers storing and updating data, and receiving and transmitting data between generic computer devices. The claimed invention is not patent eligible because the additional elements are merely invoked as tools to execute the abstract idea and thus are insufficient to amount to an inventive concept significantly more than the judicial exception.
As for the dependent claims, they merely further narrow and reiterate the same abstract ideas for storing and updating data, and receiving and transmitting data using generic data storage and transmittal techniques with the same additional elements as recited above which provide nothing more than applying the abstract idea using generic computer technology components. Furthermore the dependent claims comprise the following additional elements: print system, data repository. These additional elements do not provide any improvement to technology, technical field or improvement to the functioning of the computer itself, and at best simply applying the abstract idea executed in a general-purpose computer environment. Therefore the dependent claims are also directed to ineligible subject matter since they do not provide significantly more than the abstract idea itself.
Thus, after considering all claim elements in Claims 1-20 both individually and as an ordered combination, it has been determined that the claimed invention as a whole, is not enough to transform the abstract idea into a patent-eligible invention since nothing in the claim limitations provide significantly more than the abstract idea under 35 U.S.C. § 101.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 102
The following is a quotation of the appropriate paragraphs of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 that form the basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action:
A person shall be entitled to a patent unless –
(b) the invention was patented or described in a printed publication in this or a foreign country or in public use or on sale in this country, more than one year prior to the date of application for patent in the United States.
The following is a quotation of the appropriate paragraphs of 35 U.S.C. 102 that form the basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action:
A person shall be entitled to a patent unless –
(a)(1) the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention.
(a)(2) the claimed invention was described in a patent issued under section 151, or in an application for patent published or deemed published under section 122(b), in which the patent or application, as the case may be, names another inventor and was effectively filed before the effective filing date of the claimed invention.
Claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) as being anticipated by SHARPE (US 20230015090).
Regarding Claims 1, 8 and 15,
Sharpe discloses:
A method, computing device, memory, processor, and non-transitory computer readable medium for generating product description information for a product (Abstract, Summary and Figs. 1-5), comprising:
receiving, by a computing device and as an input provided by a user, a request to generate the product description information for the product; determining, by the computing device, one or more user instructions indicated in the request ([0079] receiving user request for product, manage requests, and determine incoming requests based on context of the user question, comment or advice requested for products, [0009] instructions for accessing a set of product regulation update alerts; instructions for extracting a set of product regulation updates from the set of product regulation update alerts, [0068-0069] application interface for customer entry of product data and countries of regulatory significance in order to automatically generate a product profile and querying based on product name, description and country of interest provided by user and sent to machine learning model);
retrieving, by the computing device and by using a product identifier included in the request, product data for the product, the product data including a corresponding product identifier and data describing one or more attributes of the product; retrieving, by the computing device, one or more contextual datasets curated with information relevant to the product, wherein the one or more contextual datasets include at least one of: search engine optimization (SEO) data, brand standards data, industry or organization norms data, and target consumer preferences data ([0016] FIG. 5 depicts an overview of datasets and components that access and analyze the datasets in association with the taxonomy mapping, [0106] publicly available datasets, including the WDC Product Categorization, [0068] application interface for customer entry of product data and countries of regulatory significance in order to automatically generate a product profile and attributes that are used to identify relevant product regulations, [0006] determine applicability of compliance requirements from regulations and regulation updates to products and their respective features, [0017] dynamically assessing applicability of product regulation updates to product profiles, [0069] querying based on product name, description and country of interest provided by user and inputs sent to machine learning model);
generating, by the computing device, the product description information for the product by providing the product data, the one or more user instructions, and the one or more contextual datasets as inputs to a data model to cause the data model to output the product description information for the product ([0068] application interface for customer entry of product data and countries of regulatory significance in order to automatically generate a product profile and attributes that are used to identify relevant product regulations, Claim 1: training dataset associated with a set of products, the training dataset comprising: (i) a training set of product descriptions associated with the set of products, and (ii) a training set of product classifications, in a universal knowledge graph, associated with the set of products, analyzing, by the one or more computer processors using the machine learning model, the information associated with the product; and based on the analyzing, outputting, by the machine learning model, a target classification, in the universal knowledge graph, for the product, [0120] inputs into the data model and output, the source taxonomy and the target taxonomy may be input into the DGMC model, an output of which may be the final taxonomy mappings);
wherein the data model is trained using machine learning to generate the product description information in a manner that complies with product description parameters derived from the one or more contextual datasets ([0006] utilize machine learning to analyze rules and representations of compliance requirements as they relate to products and their respective attributes, [0071] AI models to extract or predict information, align predicted or extracted entities with known entities, and/or perform other analyses, [0075] customers consistently add new product attributes, the models may be expanded to cover these attributes and the knowledge graph would include them in its ontology, [0075] integrate with governments and/or standards organizations and lobby for new bills/regulations/standards and [0102] updated machine learning model that reflects accurate regulation applicability in subsequent analyses); and
providing, by the computing device, the product description information for display on a user interface of a device or application ([0068-0069] An application interface for customer product data and automatically generate a product profile and attributes. A profile may be created and users may review and remove the predicted items and/or search for and add additional regulations, standards, customer standards, and/or requirements and product catalog).
Regarding Claims 2 and 11, further comprising: prior to receiving the request, obtaining heterogenous product data for the product from a plurality of disparate data sources; standardizing the heterogenous product data by mapping product data values to a schema and normalizing the product data values into a uniform machine-readable format; aggregating standardized product data to create the product data; and storing the product data that has been standardized and aggregated in the data repository in a manner that is retrievable for use in generating the product description information ([0059-0061] Knowledge graph that uses a graph-structured data model or topology to integrate data, where the knowledge graph may store interlinked descriptions of entities while encoding the semantics underlying the used terminology. In this regard, regulations and/or attributes may be defined and contextualized, and machine learning techniques may contribute to any enrichment of the knowledge graph. The systems and methods may use machine learning (e.g., using weak models) to train a model(s) that will automate category and attribute assignment in order to generate representations of products for automatically determining relevant standards, regulations, and requirements. Product taxonomies (or any information hierarchy) may be represented in a product profile or product protocol, or within the information systems that warehouse the descriptors which a profile or protocol may be tagged with. Machine learning-driven taxonomic mapping therefore allows user input to be disambiguated into its descriptors. Those matched descriptors can then be used in aggregate to assess whether a regulation might be relevant, given a set of matched descriptor entities, according to the structure of the requirements. Named Entity Recognition and Disambiguation Models to identify and normalize product categories, components, chemicals, materials, and product attributes, as well as a multi-label classifier model to classify products into the GS1 product taxonomy, [0018] analyze the information using any stored data model(s) and present information that indicates the potentially applicable regulation updates from a regulatory feed and their potential applicability to certain products for review, selection, and/or correction by certain users, and may represent information in an encoded machine-readable format).
Regarding Claims 3 and 10, and 20 further comprising: retrieving another contextual dataset that includes regulatory rules data that identifies at least one law or regulation relating to the product description information; and wherein generating the product description information comprises: providing the regulatory rules data as an input to the data model such that the data model generates the product description information in a manner that is compliant with the at least one law or regulation ([0060] automate category and attribute assignment in order to generate representations of products for automatically determining relevant standards, regulations, and requirements. Product taxonomies or any information hierarchy may be represented in a product profile, [0054] word embeddings, and [0025] product description, and [0025] product description).
Regarding Claim 4, further comprising: providing, while the user in inputting a prompt as part of the request, feedback on compliance of the prompt with the product description parameters derived from at least one of the brand standards data, the SEO data, and the regulatory rules data, wherein the feedback is displayed on the user interface in a manner that emphasizes non-compliant words or phrases ([0006] use machine learning to analyze rules and applicability of compliance requirements from regulations and regulation updates to products and their respective features for products, [0007] for each product profile of the set of product profiles, the content descriptive of the corresponding product to determine whether at least one product regulation update of the set of product regulation updates is potentially applicable to the product profile; and displaying, in a user interface, a result of the analyzing).
Regarding Claim 5, wherein the one or more contextual datasets include historical sales data and consumer preferences data, and wherein the data model is configured to apply weighted values to product description terms based on a frequency of consumer engagement with, or purchase of, the product ([0025] product profile may be based on estimates of market and/or consumer need, testing with target market customers and feedback relating thereto, initial sales projections, estimates of advertising and marketing expenditure to launch a product, and/or estimates of production cost, and may include product specifications, [0018] subsequent regulation update assessments and determinations. Additionally, feedback from users may be used to assess the quality of the regulatory update assessments, thus enabling contextualization to the target environment, marketplace, or audience, [0042-0048] weighted models machine learning training, [0093] the system updates the semantic knowledge graph to more heavily weigh the inclusion of terminology in analyses, and [0052]).
Regarding Claim 6, wherein the product description information comprises: a narrative description of the product and a set of feature bullet points, each generated in a format optimized for a respective e-commerce platform or product listing channel ([0060] automate category and attribute assignment in order to generate representations of products for automatically determining relevant standards, regulations, and requirements. Product taxonomies or any information hierarchy may be represented in a product profile, [0054] word embeddings, and [0025] product description).
Regarding Claim 7, providing the product description information to a print system configured to generate a physical label for the product ([0038] present content for product information and product profiles via user interface display and touchscreen, and also include output devices such as a printer, which may be connected through an output peripheral interface).
Regarding Claim 9, wherein the one or more contextual datasets are periodically updated to reflect changes to the SEO criteria, brand standards, or industry or organization norms ([0009] instructions for accessing a set of product regulation update alerts; instructions for extracting a set of product regulation updates from the set of product regulation update alerts, [0007] for each product profile of the set of product profiles, the content descriptive of the corresponding product to determine whether at least one product regulation update of the set of product regulation updates).
Regarding Claim 12, wherein the processor is further configured to generate the product description information in a plurality of formats including a long-form description, a short-form summary, and an SEO-optimized title ([0060] automate category and attribute assignment in order to generate representations of products for automatically determining relevant standards, regulations, and requirements. Product taxonomies or any information hierarchy may be represented in a product profile, [0054] word embeddings, and [0025] product description).
Regarding Claim 13, wherein the processor, when providing the product description information for display on the user interface, is configured to: cause the user interface to display a split view showing a first section with the product description information prepared in a narrative description format and a second section with the product description information prepared in a bullet point format ([0014] FIGS. 3A-3F depict example interfaces associated with reviewing product profiles and product regulation updates, [0008] each product profile of the set of product profiles comprises content descriptive of a corresponding product of the set of products for a given market(s), analyze, for each product profile of the set of product profiles, the content descriptive of the corresponding product to determine whether at least one product regulation update of the set of product regulation updates is potentially applicable to the product profile, and cause the user interface to display a result of the analyzing).
Regarding Claim 14, wherein the processor is further configured to provide, for display on the user interface, feedback of non-compliant text while the user is inputting a prompt as part of the request ([0006] use machine learning to analyze rules and applicability of compliance requirements from regulations and regulation updates to products and their respective features for products, [0007] for each product profile of the set of product profiles, the content descriptive of the corresponding product to determine whether at least one product regulation update of the set of product regulation updates is potentially applicable to the product profile; and displaying, in a user interface, a result of the analyzing, [0013] FIGS. 2A-2D depict example interfaces associated with reviewing product profiles and product regulation updates, [0014] FIGS. 3A-3F depict example interfaces associated with reviewing product profiles and product regulation updates).
Regarding Claim 16, cause the processor to: generate a set of feature bullet points by ranking product attributes according to a set of relevance scores derived from consumer engagement metrics ([0092-003] The interface 350 of FIG. 3F identifies a set of potentially applicable product regulation updates 351 and the corresponding potentially applicable product profiles 352. The interface 350 also features relevance scores 353 in order and product profile identifiers (IDs) 354 associated with each potentially applicable product regulation update 351 and determine a confidence level with respect to the applicability of any regulation update to a particular product profile. The interface 350 may display this confidence level ranked in the form of a numeric score (as shown, in reference to 353), a percentage, a confidence percentile, or any other suitable metric that the user may choose).
Regarding Claim 17, wherein retrieve category-specific norms that define attribute order or feature emphasis for a respective product category ([0005] regulatory intelligence (RI) is a set of tools and services that help product manufacturers and retailers understand their compliance requirements in the markets they intend to serve, and policy requirements in terms of vendor-neutral product categories, the adoption of vendor-neutral product taxonomies such as GS1's Global Product Classification (GPC) standard, Harmonized System (HS) Codes or the like can be useful in automatic entity alignment applications. Additionally, the representation of regulations in the context of standardized representation or identification of product features such as attributes, components, chemicals, materials, and the like may facilitate aligning regulations with products covered by them, [0044] dynamic schema may include, by way of non-limiting example, customer name, profile scope, regulation summaries, market of the profile, product category, and [0054], [0060]).
Regarding Claim 18, wherein store the product description information that has been generated to a data structure in a format suitable for downstream editing or quality assurance review ([0018] The systems and methods may analyze the information indicative of the product profiles, with reference to the product regulation update information, to determine which regulations may be applicable to the associated products and analyze the information using any stored data model(s) and information that indicates the potentially applicable regulation updates from a regulatory feed and their potential applicability to certain products for review, selection, and/or correction by certain users, and may represent information in an encoded machine-readable format).
Regarding Claim 19, wherein provide the product description information for display, further cause the processor to: provide visual feedback on the user interface in a manner that emphasizes a regulatory inconsistency or a brand guideline violation ([0075] analytics may be generated and data may be reviewed to suggest the need for standards or regulations to be generated or updated to account for customer activity/behavior. Based on customer use and addition of new data, ML/AI models may be updated and the knowledge graph may be improved with customer input and if customers consistently add new product attributes, [0068] systems and methods may support an application interface for customer entry of product data and countries of regulatory significance in order to automatically generate a product profile and attributes that are used to identify relevant product regulations in each country).
Conclusion
The relevant prior art made of record not relied upon but considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure can be found in the current and/or previous PTO-892 Notice of References Cited.
US20220253871 Multi-dimensional product information analysis, management, and application systems and methods [0430] generating a final finished good report based upon an initial submission)
US20230015090 Systems and Methods for Dynamically Classifying Products and Assessing Applicability of Product Regulations
US20220301031 Machine Learning Based Automated Product Classification
US20240281410 Multi-service business platform system having custom workflow actions systems and methods
US20250156898 System and method for ai based tailored advertising content generation
S. S. Roy, A. Kumar and R. Suresh Kumar, "Metadata and Review-Based Hybrid Apparel Recommendation System Using Cascaded Large Language Models," in IEEE Access, vol. 12, pp. 140053-140071, 2024, doi: 10.1109/ACCESS.2024.3462793.
S. J. Kalaiarasi and K. Nimala, "Enhancing E-Commerce Product Recommendations Using LLMs and Transformer-Based Deep Learning Architectures," 2024 International Conference on Innovative Computing, Intelligent Communication and Smart Electrical Systems (ICSES), Chennai, India, 2024, pp. 1-8, doi: 10.1109/ICSES63760.2024.10910646.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the Examiner should be directed to LAURA YESILDAG whose direct telephone number is (571) 270-5066 and work schedule is generally Monday-Friday, from 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM ET.
In order to receive any email communication from the Examiner, filing for official authorization for Internet Communication is required. The authorization form can be accessed at https://www.uspto.gov/sites/default/files/documents/sb0439.pdf.
Examiner interviews can be requested by telephone or are available using the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the Examiner are unsuccessful, the Examiner’s Supervisor, LYNDA JASMIN, can be reached at (571) 272-6782 for any urgent matter that needs immediate attention. Additional information regarding the status of an application may be obtained from the USPTO Patent Center. For more information about the USPTO Patent Center, please access https://patentcenter.uspto.gov/ The Patent Center is available to all users for electronic filing and management of patent applications and can be contacted for questions at 1-866-217-9197 or 571-272-4100.
/LAURA YESILDAG/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 3629