Prosecution Insights
Last updated: October 02, 2026
Application No. 19/531,100

DISPLAY APPARATUS DISPLAYING VIRTUAL INDICATOR AND CONTROLLING METHOD THEREOF

Non-Final OA §102
Filed
Feb 05, 2026
Priority
Aug 16, 2023 — RE 10-2023-0107166 +1 more
Examiner
BOLOTIN, DMITRIY
Art Unit
2623
Tech Center
2600 — Communications
Assignee
Samsung Electronics Co., Ltd.
OA Round
1 (Non-Final)
81%
Grant Probability
Favorable
1-2
OA Rounds
1y 8m
Est. Remaining
94%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants 81% — above average
81%
Career Allowance Rate
927 granted / 1143 resolved
+19.1% vs TC avg
Moderate +13% lift
Without
With
+12.9%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
2y 3m
Avg Prosecution
14 currently pending
Career history
1159
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
3.7%
-36.3% vs TC avg
§103
45.6%
+5.6% vs TC avg
§102
22.5%
-17.5% vs TC avg
§112
18.0%
-22.0% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 1143 resolved cases

Office Action

§102
DETAILED ACTION It would be of great assistance to the Office if all incoming papers pertaining to a filed application carried the following items: 1. Application number (checked for accuracy, including series code and serial no.). 2. Group art unit number (copied from most recent Office communication). 3. Filing date. 4. Name of the examiner who prepared the most recent Office action. 5. Title of invention. 6. Confirmation number (See MPEP § 503). Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Priority Acknowledgment is made of applicant's claim for foreign priority based on an application filed in Korea on 08/16/2023. It is noted, however, that applicant has not filed a certified copy of the Korean application as required by 37 CFR 1.55. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 102 The following is a quotation of the appropriate paragraphs of 35 U.S.C. 102 that form the basis for the rejections under this section made in this Office action: A person shall be entitled to a patent unless – (a)(1) the claimed invention was patented, described in a printed publication, or in public use, on sale, or otherwise available to the public before the effective filing date of the claimed invention. Claim(s) 1 – 20 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 102(a)(1) as being anticipated by Kondo et al. (US 2009/0141180). As to claim 1, Kondo discloses a display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) comprising: a display (display panel 261 of fig. 4); a communication interface (HDMI terminal 251 of figs. 2, 4 and 19) configured to communicate with a source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21); memory storing instructions (memory 272 and 273 of fig. 4); and one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: obtain coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) corresponding to a movement of an input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); move an indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) on a screen of the display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) based on the obtained coordinate information (based on received position information [0068 - 0070], [0124]); based on a control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) corresponding to a user input at the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) being received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), control the communication interface (HDMI terminal 251 of figs. 2, 4 and 19) to transmit coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21,); and based on an image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) reflecting the user input (a command corresponding to the user operation to the television receiver 250 in step ST33 [0209]) being received from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) through the communication interface (HDMI terminal 251 of figs. 2, 4 and 19), control the display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) to display the image signal (playback according to the video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10). As to claim 2 (dependent on 1), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: select a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) based on a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) received from the input device (input received from remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); based on the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) being selected, switch the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to a virtual indicator (free cursor FC over display of fig. 14C and 14D after input selection, ST6, [0208 - 0209]); move the virtual indicator (free cursor FC over display of fig. 14C and 14D after input selection, ST6, [0208 - 0209]) based on the obtained coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]); based on the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) being received, transmit (at step ST9 of fig. 10) coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the virtual indicator (free cursor FC over display of fig. 14C and 14D after input selection, ST6, [0208 - 0209]) and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21); and control the display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) to display the image signal reflecting the user input (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10). As to claim 3 (dependent on 2), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) is transmitted from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) to the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) after the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) moves the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to correspond to the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) received from the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), and performs an operation corresponding to the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0211 – 0212], [0236 - 0239]). As to claim 4 (dependent on 1), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: select a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) based on a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); based on the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) being selected, transmit (at step ST9 of fig. 10) a movement signal corresponding to the movement of the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21); and based on the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) reflecting the movement being received from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), control the display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) to display the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10). As to claim 5 (dependent on 4), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) is transmitted from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) to the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) after the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) obtains the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) based on the movement signal received from the display apparatus (at step ST9 of fig. 10), and moves the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) based on the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0208 – 0212], [0237 - 0241]). As to claim 6 (dependent on 1), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: select a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) according to a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) for the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); based on the second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) being selected according to the preset input (no input selection at ST32 [0207]), obtain the coordinate information (position information of the input select of figs.14A and 21A) based on a movement signal corresponding to the movement received from the input device (input is selected using transmitter 277 [0206 – 0207]); move the indicator (input select indicator box of figs. 14A and 21A) based on the coordinate information (the position information selected using transmitter 277 [0206 – 0207]); and based on the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) being received, control the display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) to display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) a screen reflecting the user input by performing an operation corresponding to the coordinate information and the control signal (selecting an appropriate input as shown in figs. 14A and 21A). As to claim 7 (dependent on 6), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein in the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21), the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) is controlled through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), wherein in the second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10), the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) is controlled through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), and wherein the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) is transmitted from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) based on the user input for at least one of a button or a microphone of the input device (input of the remote control transmitter 277 of fig. 1, fig. 14A, 14B or 21A and 21B). As to claim 8 (dependent on 1), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: select a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) based on a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); and based on the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) being selected, control the communication interface (HDMI terminal 251 of figs. 2, 4 and 19) to transmit (transmit at ST9 of fig. 10), to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), a movement signal corresponding to the movement and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), through a part of a bandwidth for receiving the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10 transmitted according to fig. 5). As to claim 9 (dependent on 1), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: based on a mode that controls the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) being selected through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), control the communication interface (HDMI terminal 251 of figs. 2, 4 and 19) to transmit (at ST9 of fig. 10), to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), a movement signal corresponding to the movement and the control signal (coordinate and user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) that are received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), through a part of a bandwidth for receiving the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10 transmitted according to fig. 5), and wherein in the selected mode, a size of the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) received from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) corresponds to a remainder of the bandwidth (bandwidth allocated according to fig. 5). As to claim 10 (dependent on 1), Kondo discloses the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), wherein the instructions, when executed by the one or more processors (CPU 271 of fig. 4) individually or collectively, cause the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) to: identify a content type (identify HDMI content, fig. 13A and 13B [0204]) corresponding to the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10); and based on the content type being identified as a preset type (content of the DLNA is designated by a user [0204]), select a mode that controls the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), and control the communication interface (HDMI terminal 251 of figs. 2, 4 and 19) to transmit (at step ST9 of fig. 10), to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), a movement signal corresponding to the movement and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) that are received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]). As to claim 11, Kondo discloses a method of controlling a display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), the method comprising: obtaining coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) corresponding to a movement of an input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); moving an indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) on a screen of a display (display panel 261 of fig. 4) of the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) based on the obtained coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]); based on a control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) being corresponding to a user input at the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) being received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), transmitting (at ST9 of fig. 10) the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) to a source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21); and based on an image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) reflecting the user input (a command corresponding to the user operation to the television receiver 250 in step ST33 [0209]) being received from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), displaying (via display panel 261 of fig. 4) the image signal (playback according to the video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10). As to claim 12 (dependent on 11), Kondo discloses the method, further comprising: selecting a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) according to a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]); and based on the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) being selected, switching the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to a virtual indicator (free cursor FC over display of fig. 14C and 14D after input selection, ST6, [0208 - 0209]), wherein the moving the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) comprises moving the virtual indicator (free cursor FC over display of fig. 14C and 14D after input selection, ST6, [0208 - 0209]) based on the obtained coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]), wherein the transmitting (at ST9 of fig. 10) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) comprises, based on the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) being received, transmitting the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the virtual indicator (free cursor FC over display of fig. 14C and 14D after input selection, ST6, [0208 - 0209]) and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), and wherein the displaying comprises displaying the image signal reflecting the user input (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10). As to claim 13 (dependent on 12), Kondo discloses the method, wherein the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) is transmitted from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) to the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) after the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) moves the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to correspond to the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) received from the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21), and performs an operation corresponding to the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]). As to claim 14 (dependent on 11), Kondo discloses the method, further comprising: selecting a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) based on a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), wherein the transmitting (at ST9 of fig. 10) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) comprises transmitting a movement signal corresponding to the movement received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), and wherein the displaying comprises, based on the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) reflecting the movement being received from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), displaying the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10). As to claim 15 (dependent on 14), Kondo discloses the method, wherein the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) is transmitted from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) to the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) after the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) obtains the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) based on the movement signal received from the display apparatus (at step ST9 of fig. 10), and moves the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) based on the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) of the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]). As to claim 16 (dependent on 11), Kondo discloses the method, further comprising selecting a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) based on a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) for the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), wherein the obtaining the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) comprises, based on the second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) being selected (no input selection at ST32 [0207]), obtaining the coordinate information (position information of the input select of figs.14A and 21A) based on a movement signal corresponding to the movement of the input device received from the input device (input is selected using transmitter 277 [0206 – 0207]), wherein the moving the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) comprise moving the indicator (free cursor FC [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) based on the coordinate information (the position information selected using transmitter 277 [0206 – 0207]), and wherein the displaying comprises, based on the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) being received, performing an operation corresponding to the coordinate information (the position information (coordinate information) of the free cursor [0069 - 0070] and [0237 - 0241]) and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) and displaying a screen reflecting the user input (selecting an appropriate input as shown in figs. 14A and 21A). As to claim 17 (dependent on 16), Kondo discloses the method, wherein in the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21), the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) is controlled through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), wherein in the second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10), the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) is controlled through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), and wherein the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) is transmitted from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]) to the display apparatus (Television 250 of figs. 4 and 18 - 21) based on the user input for at least one of a button or a microphone of the input device (input of the remote control transmitter 277 of fig. 1, fig. 14A, 14B or 21A and 21B). As to claim 18 (dependent on 11), Kondo discloses the method, further comprising: selecting a first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) or a second control mode (TV control mode of fig. 14A and 21A, ST5, ST6 of fig. 10) based on a preset input (input selection at ST32 [0207]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), and wherein the transmitting (at step ST9 of fig. 10) comprises, based on the first control mode (Handycam control mode of fig. 14 or PC control mode of fig. 21) being selected, transmitting, to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), a movement signal corresponding to the movement and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), through a part of a bandwidth for receiving the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10, transmitted according to fig. 5). As to claim 19 (dependent on 11), Kondo discloses the method, wherein the transmitting comprises, based on a mode for controlling the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) being selected through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), transmitting (at step ST9 of fig. 10), to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), a movement signal corresponding to the movement and the control signal (coordinate and user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), through a part of a bandwidth for receiving the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10 transmitted according to fig. 5), and wherein in the selected mode, a size of the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10) received from the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) corresponds to a remainder of the bandwidth (bandwidth allocated according to fig. 5). As to claim 20 (dependent on 11), Kondo discloses the method, further comprising: identifying a content type (identify HDMI content, fig. 13A and 13B [0204]) corresponding to the image signal (video signal after step ST25 of fig. 10); and based on the content type being identified as a preset type (content of the DLNA is designated by a user [0204]), selecting a mode for controlling the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21) through the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]), wherein the transmitting comprises transmitting (at step ST9 of fig. 10), to the source device (video camera recorder 210 of fig. 1 - 18 or personal computer 310 of figs. 19 - 21), a movement signal corresponding to the movement and the control signal (user click operation on the transmitter 277 [0067 - 0070], [0236 - 0239]) that are received from the input device (remote control transmitter 277 [0068 - 0070], [0237 - 0241]). Conclusion Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to DMITRIY BOLOTIN whose telephone number is (571)270-5873. The examiner can normally be reached M-F 9AM - 5PM. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Chanh Nguyen can be reached at (571)272-7772. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /DMITRIY BOLOTIN/ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2623
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Feb 05, 2026
Application Filed
Aug 11, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §102
Sep 29, 2026
Interview Requested

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12748486
INPUT AND OUTPUT HANDOFFS BETWEEN HEAD-WORN DEVICES AND WRIST-WORN DEVICES, AND SYSTEMS AND METHODS OF USE THEREOF
1y 4m to grant Granted Sep 29, 2026
Patent 12743177
FLAT PANEL DISPLAY WITH INTEGRATED TOUCH SCREEN PANEL
1y 3m to grant Granted Sep 22, 2026
Patent 12730321
REDUCING EYE STRAIN AND IMPROVING PERFORMANCE IN HEADSET DEVICE
1y 10m to grant Granted Sep 08, 2026
Patent 12722078
VIRTUAL CHARACTER DISPLAY METHOD AND APPARATUS, DEVICE, AND STORAGE MEDIUM
2y 0m to grant Granted Sep 01, 2026
Patent 12717066
UV-BLOCKING FILM FOR ARCHITECTURAL AND AUTOMOTIVE WITH 100% UV AND BLUE LIGHT BLOCKING
2y 10m to grant Granted Aug 25, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 5 most recent grants.

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

1-2
Expected OA Rounds
81%
Grant Probability
94%
With Interview (+12.9%)
2y 3m (~1y 8m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
Low
PTA Risk
Based on 1143 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month