DETAILED ACTION
A request for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, including the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e), was filed in this application after final rejection. Since this application is eligible for continued examination under 37 CFR 1.114, and the fee set forth in 37 CFR 1.17(e) has been timely paid, the finality of the previous Office action has been withdrawn pursuant to 37 CFR 1.114. Applicant's submission filed on Oct. 19th, 2026. has been entered.
This action is in response to the amendments filed on Oct. 19th, 2026 A summary of this action:
Claims 1-3, 5-6, 11-13, 15-16, 24-33 have been presented for examination.
Claims 1-3, 5-6, 11-13, 15-16, 24-33 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement
Claims 1-3, 5-6, 11-13, 15-16, 24-33 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept and mental process without significantly more.
Claims not rejected under § 102/103 – the closest prior art of record is the previously relied upon combination in the March 2026 final action, however this does not fairly teach the presently claimed combination represented by claim 1, including the “optimize, using the simulation of the input model, the at least one design parameter for the input model to generate an optimized model corresponding to the input model, wherein the optimizing is performed subject to enforcement of one or more predetermined constraints based on a constraint graph that includes vertices corresponding to patches included in the input model and edges connecting vertices corresponding to patches that are adjacent and tangential, and wherein the one or more predetermined constraints implicitly map one or more shape parameters to a set of control points of the boundary of the parameterized model and keep a number and topology of patches included in the boundary of the parameterized model fixed so that the optimized model remains manufacturable;”, even when taken in further view of newly cited Di Stefano, Paolo, Francesco Bianconi, and Luca Di Angelo. "An approach for feature semantics recognition in geometric models." Computer-Aided Design 36.10 (2004): 993-1009. Abstract, then see § 3.2 and see fig. 6-7, along with accompanying description in § 6
To clarify on the BRI of a limitation lacking § 112(a) support; MPEP § 2143.03(II): “When evaluating claims for obviousness under 35 U.S.C. 103, all the limitations of the claims must be considered and given weight, including limitations which do not find support in the specification as originally filed (i.e., new matter).”
This action is non-final
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Response to Arguments/Amendments
Regarding the § 112 Rejections
Withdrawn in view of amendment. New grounds as necessitated by amendment.
Regarding the § 101 Rejection
Maintained, updated as necessitated by amendment.
With respect to the prong 1 remarks for math concept, the claims merely set forth the math concept in textual form, rather than mathematical prose. See MPEP §2106.04(a)(2)(I): “It is important to note that a mathematical concept need not be expressed in mathematical symbols, because "[w]ords used in a claim operating on data to solve a problem can serve the same purpose as a formula." In re Grams, 888 F.2d 835, 837 and n.1, 12 USPQ2d 1824, 1826 and n.1 (Fed. Cir. 1989).” – see the subsectiosn for clarification, e.g. MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(I)(A): “A mathematical relationship is a relationship between variables or numbers. A mathematical relationship may be expressed in words or using mathematical symbols.”) and 2106.04(a)(2)(I)(C): “A mathematical calculation is a mathematical operation (such as multiplication) or an act of calculating using mathematical methods to determine a variable or number, e.g., performing an arithmetic operation such as exponentiation. There is no particular word or set of words that indicates a claim recites a mathematical calculation. That is, a claim does not have to recite the word "calculating" in order to be considered a mathematical calculation. For example, a step of "determining" a variable or number using mathematical methods or "performing" a mathematical operation may also be considered mathematical calculations when the broadest reasonable interpretation of the claim in light of the specification encompasses a mathematical calculation.”
With respect to the prong 1 remarks regarding the mental process, these remarks appear to conflate the rejection of the mental process as being a separate and independent rejection as the math concept, rather than the rationale of the rejection wherein the claims are directed to an abstract idea of both a math concept and a mental process. See MPEP § 2106.04(II)(A)(2): “RecogniCorp, LLC v. Nintendo Co., 855 F.3d 1322, 1327, 122 USPQ2d 1377 (Fed. Cir. 2017) ("Adding one abstract idea (math) to another abstract idea (encoding and decoding) does not render the claim non-abstract")” – the present claims recite a math concept with added mental process steps, wherein some of the math concept steps are recited with such generality that they may also be performed mentally (MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(I and III, including subsection (B and C) in III) for its discussion of Gottschalk v. Benson).
With respect to prong 2 remarks, MPEP 2106.04(II)(A)(2): “Genetic Techs. Ltd. v. Merial LLC, 818 F.3d 1369, 1376, 118 USPQ2d 1541, 1546 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (eligibility "cannot be furnished by the unpatentable law of nature (or natural phenomenon or abstract idea) itself.").” and MPEP § 2106.05(a): “It is important to note, the judicial exception alone cannot provide the improvement.” and MPEP § 2106.04(I): “Synopsys, Inc. v. Mentor Graphics Corp., 839 F.3d 1138, 1151, 120 USPQ2d 1473, 1483 (Fed. Cir. 2016) ("a new abstract idea is still an abstract idea") (emphasis in original).” – at issue is that the limitations pointed to for a practical application are the abstract idea itself, which cannot on their own integrate the abstract into a practical application. Rather, what is disclosed and claimed is directed to merely an allegedly new abstract idea, and the remarks allege the abstract idea alone is the practical application. To further clarify the mathematical concept of the grid embedding is a math concept in the field of geometry, i.e. embed a parametrized model (a model resulting from the parametric mapping in eq. 1, which mathematically projects a NURBs patch from one coordinate system to another), into a grid, such as a hexahedral grid (claim 6), i.e. a region/volume of space that is defined by math relationships relating the cells of the grid to the region/volume of space (dividing an area/volume into a series of smaller areas and volumes is a math operation in the mathematical field of geometry), wherein, per the claim, this produces a series of “intersections” (math relationships in geometry) between the grid and the volume of the model, thus defining a plurality of subvolumes (fig. 5B) of the parametrized model.
Furthermore, the remarks allege that remeshing is a technological problem, but see page 9: “A standard conformal Finite Element Method (FEM) discretization is poorly suited for the task at hand because, if 15 the shape of a model undergoes significant changes, remeshing is unavoidable. These uncontrolled topological changes lead to a discontinuity, and therefore to a non-differentiable simulation.” – “differentiable” being math equation(s) of which a derivative may be taken of, i.e. it’s a mathematical problem, not a technological problem, i.e. the specification does not support that the remeshing “is a burden on the computer” as alleged, but rather conveys that such remeshing creates problems for the mathematical concept itself making it “non-differentiable” – see page 1 to clarify: “…However, because shape optimization requires a differentiable simulator, and even moderate changes to design variables demand repeated conversion and remeshing, the use of CAD in combination with design optimization remains unfortunately limited in the conventional art.”
See below for clarification on the newly added limitations also being part of the abstract idea itself.
The alleged improvement in ¶¶ 69 and 94 (remarks at 18) is merely further conveying improvement in the abstract idea of the math alone.
A claim to a mathematical solution to a mathematical problem, no matter how much of a “Groundbreaking, innovative, or even brilliant discovery” it is, “does not by itself satisfy the § 101 inquiry.” (quoting Myriad, 569 U.S. at 591, 106 USPQ2d at 1979, as cited in MPEP § 2106.04(I); also see SAP America, Inc. v. InvestPic, LLC, 898 F.3d 1161, 1163, 127 USPQ2d 1597, 1599 (Fed. Cir. 2018) in MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(I)).
Thus, McRo and Enfish are also not reasonably analogous to the facts of this present claim, for in McRO it was a particular technological manner in which a previously subjective process was automated on a computer in a distinct manner (see discussion of McRo in MPEP § 2106.05(a) to clarify; further see FairWarning IP, LLC v. Iatric Sys., Inc., 839 F.3d 1089, 120 USPQ2d 1293 (Fed. Cir. 2016) for its further discussion of McRo)), similarly Enfish is not reasonably analogous because the present claims are directed to an abstract idea, not an improvement in computer technology with “claims to a self-referential table for a computer database” (MPEP § 2106.04(d)(1)). Nor is Ex Parte Desjardins, which was directed to a particular improvement in machine learning technology.
With respect to Research Corp., this is similarly not reasonably analogous – Research Corp. (MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(III)(A): “a claim to a method for rendering a halftone image of a digital image by comparing, pixel by pixel, the digital image against a blue noise mask, where the method required the manipulation of computer data structures (e.g., the pixels of a digital image and a two-dimensional array known as a mask) and the output of a modified computer data structure (a halftoned digital image), Research Corp. Techs., 627 F.3d at 868, 97 USPQ2d at 1280”) – the present claims do not recite any particular computer data structures let alone particular technological manners in which they are manipulated to output a modified computer data structure, but rather math concepts and mathematical information organized, per the specification, into mathematical prose such as matrices.
In sum, the case law pointed to in the remarks is all distinguished readily for their improvements were not in the realm of abstract ideas alone, whereas the disclosed and claimed invention merely is an allegedly new abstract idea solving mathematical problems in existing mathematical solutions.
With respect to the “model remains manufacturable” remarks (page 8, last paragraph of the disclosure, several places in the remarks); see page 9 for eq. 2 for what provides this. Also see equation 7, noting: “To prevent shape parameters from taking on values that would lead to non-manufacturable designs, an additional term is added to f that directly depends on p ( e.g., to penalize the radii of two cylinders to prevent them from overlapping), hence the direct dependence off on p.”) on pages 12-13, i.e. math concepts provide this alleged feature.
With respect to the remarks for dependent claim 5 and parallels, these claims merely further limit and add to the abstract idea itself. See the rejection below for clarification on the newly added claim.
With respect to the newly added claims and the remarks for them, see the rejection below for how these are considered under § 101. Also, see above, as the remarks alleged more improvements solely in the abstract idea itself.
Regarding the § 102/103 Rejection
Withdrawn in view of amendment.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 112
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of 35 U.S.C. 112(a):
(a) IN GENERAL.—The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor or joint inventor of carrying out the invention.
The following is a quotation of the first paragraph of pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112:
The specification shall contain a written description of the invention, and of the manner and process of making and using it, in such full, clear, concise, and exact terms as to enable any person skilled in the art to which it pertains, or with which it is most nearly connected, to make and use the same, and shall set forth the best mode contemplated by the inventor of carrying out his invention.
Claims 1-3, 5-6, 11-13, 15-16, 24-33 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 112(a) or 35 U.S.C. 112 (pre-AIA ), first paragraph, as failing to comply with the written description requirement. The claim(s) contains subject matter which was not described in the specification in such a way as to reasonably convey to one skilled in the relevant art that the inventor or a joint inventor, or for applications subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 112, the inventor(s), at the time the application was filed, had possession of the claimed invention. The dependent claims inherit the deficiencies of the claims they depend upon.
See MPEP 2163(II)(A): "For example, in Hyatt v. Dudas, 492 F.3d 1365, 1371, 83 USPQ2d 1373, 1376-1377 (Fed. Cir. 2007), the examiner made a prima facie case by clearly and specifically explaining why applicant’s specification did not support the particular claimed combination of elements, even though applicant’s specification listed each and every element in the claimed combination. The court found the "examiner was explicit that while each element may be individually described in the specification, the deficiency was lack of adequate description of their combination" and, thus, "[t]he burden was then properly shifted to [inventor] to cite to the examiner where adequate written description could be found or to make an amendment to address the deficiency.""
Also, see MPEP 2163(I) for Lockwood v. Amer. Airlines, Inc., 107 F.3d 1565, 1572, 41 USPQ2d 1961, 1966 (Fed. Cir. 1997).
Representative claim 1 recites:
optimize, using the simulation of the input model, the at least one design parameter for the input model to generate an optimized model corresponding to the input model, wherein the optimizing is performed subject to enforcement of one or more predetermined constraints based on a constraint graph that includes vertices corresponding to patches included in the input model and edges connecting vertices corresponding to patches that are adjacent and tangential, and wherein the one or more predetermined constraints implicitly map one or more shape parameters to a set of control points of the boundary of the parameterized model and keep a number and topology of patches included in the boundary of the parameterized model fixed so that the optimized model remains manufacturable;
Cf. 5, and accompanying description, for the constraint graph, as discussed on page 3: “Figure SA shows an exemplary constraint graph used to parameterize an input model,
according to one implementation;” – further see pages 16-17, including: “When a CAD file is imported, a constraint graph may be generated in which vertices correspond to patches, and in which two vertices are connected by an edge if the patches are adjacent and tangential… A list of patches that are connected to the selected parameter via the constraint graph may then be presented to user 132. User 132 may have the option of making… The constraints Cpara defined by Equation 2 above, together with the user specified parameters determine an implicit mapping from high-level shape parameters p to low-level 5 control points q.” – note that in regards to fig. 5, the letter “C” refers to “cylindrical sections”, not constraints, and rather: “the constraints are quantified as a list of equalities: ei, e2, e3”
See equation 2 on page 9:
PNG
media_image1.png
266
744
media_image1.png
Greyscale
Further, see page 17, equation 8: “The objective:… 1s minimized over the constraint manifold spanned by Cpara,”
At issue with the present claims is that the constraint graph is not clearly linked to the constraints defined by equation 2, and their associated “constraint manifold” – rather, page 17, ¶ 2 (line 3) makes clear that “constraints Cpara defined by Equation 2 above”, not the constraint graph on page 16, which has its own constraints (fig. 5A, in mathematical form as equations).
As such, the particular combination of the constraint graph and its constraints as claimed to provide the functionality of the constraints of equation 2 (i.e. cpara) is not sufficiently described, rather these are described as two distinct elements, i.e. a constraint graph at 16, and a separate and distinct element of the constraints defined by eq. 2 on page 9, as clarified on page 17, further clarified by, on page 16, the constraints of the constraint graph use the variable “e” (page 16) instead of “cpara” (further see fig. 5A which clarifies on this and the math relationships/equations of each of the “e”, noting that “c”, “p”, and “q(p)” (see equation 2, p is the shape parameters, q are the control points) are not “e”, “P”, “x”, and “r” (fig. 5A; which are “the constraints” of the constraint graph - P is for a “plane”, C for a “cylindrical section”, “r” for radius” at 16; in contrast the constraints of eq. 2). To further clarify, page 17, the “q” are “control points” – which are not part of the constraint graph as disclosed.
Examiner suggests amending the claim expressly reflect what is disclosed, i.e. there are a first set of constraints associated with a constraint graph as discussed above, and second, separate and distinct set of constraints as defined by equation 2, wherein the ones defined by eq. 2 “keep a number and topology of patches included in the boundary of the parameterized model fixed so that the optimized model remains manufacturable;” per pp. 8-9.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 1-3, 5-6, 11-13, 15-16, 24-33 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept and mental process without significantly more.
Step 1
Claim 11 is directed towards the statutory category of a process.
Claim 1 is directed towards the statutory category of an apparatus.
Claims 11, and the dependents thereof, are rejected under a similar rationale as representative claim 1, and the dependents thereof.
Step 2A – Prong 1
The claims recite an abstract idea of both a mental process and mathematical concept.
As an initial matter, the Examiner notes that the instant disclosure describes a mathematical solution to a mathematical problem, i.e. page 1, ¶¶ 1-2: “Nevertheless, and despite the advantages of boundary Io representations for manual design, strength-to-weight or rest shape optimization require the solution of a Partial Differential Equation (PDE) on the volume enclosed by the representative boundary. Although progress has been made in isogeometric analysis, where PDEs are solved on volumetric NURBS representations, the generation of volumetric NURBS for general boundary representation input continues to present challenges in the conventional art. As a result, it is still typical to solve PDEs on a volumetric mesh representation. However, because shape optimization requires a differentiable simulator, and even moderate changes to design variables demand repeated conversion and remeshing, the use of CAD in combination with design optimization remains unfortunately limited in the conventional art.” – i.e. this discovery addresses a problem in mathematics.
To further clarify, page 13, ¶¶ 2-3: “Thus, to enable shape optimization on CAD, the present novel and inventive solution introduces [i.e. provides]: 5 (1) a continuous projection of shape parameters onto the constraint manifold spanned by the user-specified parameterization [a math concept in the mathematical field of geometry], guaranteeing that the problem is well posed, and (2) a technique to efficiently compute derivatives of our hierarchical quadrature rules [a math concept of better mathematical calculations in the mathematical fields of calculus and/or numerical analysis techniques].”
As a further clarifying point on the BRI of the term “projection”, the Examiner notes that when used in its ordinary manner, as it is in this disclosure, it is a mapping (page 8 of the disclosure) from what set of coordinates to another. E.g. the well-known Mercator projection of the 3D globe to 2D maps in cartography, well before the advent of computers. The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Mercator projection". Encyclopedia Britannica, 14 Aug. 2025, www(dot)britannica(dot)com/science/Mercator-projection(dot) Accessed 26 August 2025. The Examiner is noting this in view of MPEP § 1204.04: “See, e.g., Nix v. Hedden, 149 U.S. 304, 307 (1893) (citations omitted) (admitting dictionaries to understand the ordinary meaning of terms "not as evidence, but only as aids to the memory and understanding of the court");”
See MPEP § 2106.04: “...In other claims, multiple abstract ideas, which may fall in the same or different groupings, or multiple laws of nature may be recited. In these cases, examiners should not parse the claim. For example, in a claim that includes a series of steps that recite mental steps as well as a mathematical calculation, an examiner should identify the claim as reciting both a mental process and a mathematical concept for Step 2A Prong One to make the analysis clear on the record.”
To clarify, see the USPTO 101 training examples, available at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility.
The mathematical concept recited in claim 1 is:
perform a parametric mapping of the input model based on the at least one design parameter to produce a parameterized model corresponding to the input model; - mathematical calculations/relationships in textual form. See page 8, ¶ 2 including: “…As a result, a NURBS patch with control points Qi,j E [1»3 and polynomial basis functions Bi,j: IR{2 ➔ IR{ may be considered to be a parametric mapping:” and see the equation. And page 19, last paragraph: “For accurate integration along curves C in Figure 5B the curves are parameterized with a mapping from t E [ a, b] to spatial curve points r(t),” – i.e. the parametric mapping is mapping coordinates from one domain (e.g. “u,v”) to another domain (e.g. “projective coordinates”, e.g. “x, y, z”), such as discussed on page 8 ¶ 2, by the use of mathematical relationships/equations. This is a mathematical concept in the mathematical field of “geometry”, including its various and numerous subfields (page 9, last paragraph; page 18 ¶ 2; page 1, ¶ 2: “isogeometric analysis”).
embed the parameterized model in a grid to produce a plurality of model- grid intersections defining a plurality of subvolumes of the parameterized model, wherein the grid is independent of a boundary of the parameterized model - mathematical calculations/relationships/equations in the field of geometry, i.e. this is taking a geometric CAD model (Page 8, ¶ 2: “Referring to parameterization stage 252 of process flow 200, a general form of a CAD model may be described as a closed Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline (NURBS) object, i.e., a set of NURBS patches that form a c0 surface [a mathematical technique in geometry to describe the geometry of an object using mathematical functions/relationships of “Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline”]; page 1, ¶ 1: “In modern Computer-Aided Design (CAD) systems, a boundary representation 5 composed primarily of Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline (NURBS) patches is typically used to describe solid models [describe the geometry of solid models]… require the solution of a Partial Differential Equation (PDE) on the volume enclosed by the representative boundary”), establishing new mathematical relationships which is the “parameterized model” as discussed above (i.e. mapping the mathematical representation of the geometry of an object from one set of coordinates to another set by math equations/relationships), and then embedding this mathematical representation of the geometry (the “parameterized model”) “in a grid”, wherein this grid has a plurality of “model-grid intersections defining a plurality of subvolumes…” (math relationships/calculations in geometry of finding the intersections between the grid and the model to define subvolumes), wherein this grid is independent of a boundary of the parameterized model (an exclusion of a math relationship between the geometry of the grid and the geometry of a boundary of the parameterized model), wherein the subvolume elements are cut into arbitrarily complex subvolumes (i.e. geometrical mathematical operations of dividing a volume into smaller volumes, e.g. dividing a cube into a set of smaller cubes)
To clarify on the BRI, see the above citations, then see page 19, last paragraph: “Intersections of NURBS patches with hexahedral elements form planar curves that 20 are embedded in planes parallel to one of the coordinate planes…” and page 9, last paragraph: “To mitigate this problem, the present solution includes grid embedding stage 254 prior to simulation, in which the CAD model is embedded in a simulation grid, such as a 20 three-dimensional (3D) regular hexahedral grid for example.”, and page 10, ¶ 2: “However, in contrast to standard FEM, the volume V enclosed in the CAD model is the intersection of the boundary representation of the model with the grid into which the model was embedded IO in grid embedding stage 254, and elements on the boundary are cut into arbitrarily complex subvolumes.” Also see fig. 5B, as discussed on page 16: “Figure 5B depicts an exemplary subvolume 548 of parameterized model 444, according to one implementation, which is discussed in greater detail below by reference to action 375”; page 12 last paragraph: “…parameterized volume enclosed by the CAD model…”, page 16, ¶¶ 2-4: “…Adjacent patches in CAD models often meet tangentially along edges, for example when fillets are used to remove sharp features…. The present design analysis solution enables user 132 to utilize user device 130 to 20 define a shape parameter on the surface of input model 140/240/440, e.g., the radius r2 of cylinder C2 . A list of patches that are connected to the selected parameter via the constraint graph may then be presented to user 132.” Page 26, ¶ 3: “Curve Rules: As noted above, it is in general not possible to extract an analytical parameterization for intersection curves that arise when several NURBS patches intersect 15 within a grid element, or a NURBS intersects with one of the element planes. Consequently, we represent these planar or spatial curves with sample points, and distinguish between several example cases shown by Figure 6 and discussed below.” – then on page 27, see the description of figure 6: “To this end, it is best to look at a specific examples 680 and 688 in Figure 6, where three "surfaces" intersect in a single point: if p is changed, the control points of the three patches and also the uv-coordinates in their respective parameter domain, change What uniquely defines the uv-coordinates is the constraint that they all map to the same point in 3D, formalized with an equation…for every pair…”
generate a simulation of the input model based on the plurality of model- grid intersections and the plurality of subvolumes, wherein the simulation of the input model is used to optimize one or more physical characteristics of the mechanical object;. – math calculations/relationships/equations in textual form
To clarify, Page 9, ¶ 3: “To achieve this goal, the simulation generated in subsequent
simulation stage 256 must be sufficiently smooth and differentiable”, Page 10, ¶ 1 including equation 3 and “Referring to simulation stage 256 of process flow 200, in order to determine the elastic response x E ~ 3n of a CAD model… where the material-dependent strain energy density, '-11, is integrated over points x E JR3 in the undeformed volume V.”, then see page 10, ¶ 3: “In order to loosen the coupling between grid resolution and simulation precision, the present approach represents cuts in elements explicitly with an enrichment and implements a quadrature scheme that integrates quantities such as the elastic energy Eint over complex subvolumes reliably and accurately.”, page 18, ¶ 3: “where the simulation of input model 140/240/ 440 provides a differentiable mathematical representation of input model 140/240/440 (action 375).” Page 18, last paragraph: ‘To simulate a complex CAD model on a simulation grid that is not conformal, quadrature rules are required for integration of functions [math calculations of integration of mathematical functions] over (1) subvolumes, which are part of the model interior (e.g., to accumulate elastic force density), and over (2) regions on the model surface (e.g., to aggregate surface traction).” Also see page 11, ¶ 2, which describes equation 4, and see page 12 for its equations and their accompanying descriptions including: “To support the co-optimization of such combined objectives, the present solution introduces a second type of objective that integrates standard functions over the volume defined by the boundary representation:… For example, integration of the density p(X) (times the constant 1) yields the mass of a CAD model, and can be combined with the objective described by Equation 4 above to formulate strength-to-weight ratio optimizations… The optimization performed during optimization stage 258 of process flow 200 seeks to minimize one of the objectives described by Equations 4, 5, or 6, or a weighted combination of those objectives over the parameterized volume enclosed by the CAD model”
Also see page 18, last paragraph: “To simulate a complex CAD model on a simulation grid that is not conformal, quadrature rules are required for integration of functions over (1) subvolumes…” and page 20 ¶ 3 including: “To integrate over planar areas and surfaces, a first nesting of the hierarchical integration scheme described in the present application is employed. There are two cases to consider: (1) integrals over planar areas that lie in grid planes of the simulation grid, and (2) integrals over curved surfaces, represented by NURBS patches” – see pages 20-23 for more clarification on this, and page 28, last paragraph: “The optimization techniques described above enable a wide variety of applications, ranging from combined mass distribution and strength-to-weight ratio, or rest shape optimization, to various other inverse design problems that require an accurate integration of properties or discretized PDEs over a parameterized design domain enclosed by a boundary 20 representation.”
optimize, using the simulation of the input model, the at least one design parameter for the input model to generate an optimized model corresponding to the input model; – which is mathematical calculations/equations/relationships in textual form, with a desired result specified. See the above citations, also see page 24, ¶ 2 including equation 19 to page 25 ¶ 1 including equations 20-21, also see pages 11-12 including : “The optimization performed during optimization stage 258 of process flow 200 seeks to minimize one of the objectives described by Equations 4, 5, or 6, or a weighted combination of those objectives over the parameterized volume enclosed by the CAD model”
To clarify, this does not require that it is manufactured, rather only that the desired result of the math calculations in textual form is a design of an object (i.e. the mathematical relationships/equations representing the geometry of the object; see the instant disclosure page 8-9 the paragraph split between the pages; page 9 ¶ 3 at lines 9-12; page 11 last paragraph, etc.) that is able to be manufactured (MPEP § 2111.04(I)).
wherein the optimizing is performed subject to enforcement of one or more predetermined constraints based on a constraint graph that includes vertices corresponding to patches included in the input model and edges connecting vertices corresponding to patches that are adjacent and tangential, and wherein the one or more predetermined constraints implicitly map one or more shape parameters to a set of control points of the boundary of the parameterized model and keep a number and topology of patches included in the boundary of the parameterized model fixed so that the optimized model remains manufacturable; part of the math calculations/equations/relationships in textual form. See page 9, ¶ 2 for equation 2 and its accompanying description, i.e. “During optimizations, these constraints Cpara [“Equation 2”] are enforced, keeping the number and topology of patches fixed.” In addition, see fig. 5A and accompanying description (page 16), noting that the constraints of the constraint graph as per fig. 5A are equations in mathematical prose. The constraint graph as described in the accompanying description of fig. 5A are mathematical relationships in mathematical field of geometry when read in view of fig. 5A and accompanying description.
Under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the claim recites a mathematical concept – the above limitations are steps in a mathematical concept such as mathematical relationships, mathematical formulas or equations, and mathematical calculations. If a claim, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, is directed towards a mathematical concept, then it falls within the Mathematical Concepts grouping of abstract ideas. In addition, as per MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2): “It is important to note that a mathematical concept need not be expressed in mathematical symbols, because "[w]ords used in a claim operating on data to solve a problem can serve the same purpose as a formula." In re Grams, 888 F.2d 835, 837 and n.1, 12 USPQ2d 1824, 1826 and n.1 (Fed. Cir. 1989). See, e.g., SAP America, Inc. v. InvestPic, LLC, 898 F.3d 1161, 1163, 127 USPQ2d 1597, 1599 (Fed. Cir. 2018)”
See MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2).
To clarify, see the USPTO 101 training examples, available at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility.
The mental process recited in claim 1 is:
identify at least one design parameter of the input model for automated analysis; - a mental observation/judgement, but for the mere instructions to do it on a computer/apply the abstract idea on a computer. See the instant disclosure, page 15: “Design parameter(s) for input model 140/240/440 may be provided as inputs to user device 130 by user 132 and may be received by system 100 via communication network 120 and network communication links 122” – e.g. a user, observing a shape to be optimized/designed, e.g. of a wheel, either with their own eyes (such as of a prototype, or drawings of an initial design) or by mentally visualizing the shape in their own mind, then making a mental judgement of which design parameters should be optimized, e.g. judging where the center of mass should be, and where the major axis of the moment of inertia should be. Page 11, last paragraph: “For example, 20 to optimize the strength-to-weight ratio of an asymmetric wheel design, the center of mass must lie on the axis of the wheel, and the major axis of the moment of inertia must align with this axis.” As another example, they could identify the circumference of a wheel as the design parameter by a mental judgement.
optimize, using the simulation of the input model, the at least one design parameter for the input model to generate an optimized model corresponding to the input model… – this is recited with enough generality for a person to perform such a step, e.g. using a computer as a tool to perform the math calculations of the simulation, and then the user mentally evaluating the results of the simulation such as on the display of the computer, mentally judging to adjust a design parameter so as to optimize the model, and using the computer a second time as a tool to verify that it was optimized with the adjusted parameter, such as in a trial-and-error process to optimize a design.
In addition, the Examiner notes that the differentiable mathematical representation (instant disclosure page 23, ¶ 3) is not claimed with any particularity as to what the equations are in the representation, as such a person would readily be able to use a differentiable mathematical representation in an optimization with other physical aids such as a pencil, paper, and a calculator, for a simple mathematical differentiable representation, e.g. y=mx^2.
To be clear, but for the recitation of “the input model”, and the preamble requiring the use of a computer, this feature does not even require a computer, rather it simply requires a simple differentiable equation to be used in a mental trial-and-error process to make a better design of an object.
…[generating] one or more predetermined constraints based on a constraint graph that includes vertices corresponding to patches included in the input model and edges connecting vertices corresponding to patches that are adjacent and tangential, and …- this is simple enough to be done by a mental evaluation. See fig. 5A and accompanying description at 16 – a person is readily able to mentally observe a figure such as 5A and evaluate it such as to generate such a constraint graph.
…[predetermining] wherein the one or more predetermined constraints implicitly map one or more shape parameters to a set of control points of the boundary of the parameterized model and keep a number and topology of patches included in the boundary of the parameterized model fixed so that the optimized model remains manufacturable; - a mental process, but done on a computer – page 9, ¶ 2, note that the “user 132 may be permitted to define, a priori, an implicit mapping…” – i.e. the user (a person) manually defines this mapping explicitly in the disclosure.
and design a mold for manufacturing the mechanical object using the optimized model - a mental process, but for the mere instructions to use a computer as a tool to do it (instant disclosure, page 13, ¶ 2 at lines 10-14). To clarify, this is reciting at a high level of generality (see MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2)(III)(A) for Electric Power Group v. Alstom, S.A., 830 F.3d 1350, 1353-54, 119 USPQ2d 1739, 1741-42 (Fed. Cir. 2016)) designing a mold based on a model of an object.
Such a mental process does not even require a computer. For example, an engineer is readily able to make a model of an object by mentally visualizing the object to be manufactured, and with the aid of pen and paper, and other physical aids, e.g. rulers, readily produce a mold (or a design for a mold) for the object.
E.g. blacksmiths and other metal working professionals have long used (and thus must have designed) molds to make various objects, e.g. swords, keys, artwork, etc., well before the invention of a computer.
E.g. See Bloomfield et al, “Sand Casting”, Lecture notes from Santa Rosa Junior College, Fall 2013, ENGR 45, URL: srjcstaff(dot)santarosa(dot)edu/~yataiiya/E45/PROJECTS/Sand%20Casting%20Semester%20Presentation(dot)pdf , for “A Brief History of Casting” and its “Definition” on slides 2-7, including that casting has been performed by people for thousands of years.
E.g. by the time of Diamond v. Diehr (MPEP § 2106.05(e)) rubber molding for manufacturing was a conventional process, wherein Diamond v. Diehr provided an improvement to said process. To clarify, in Diamond v. Diehr it was “a physical and chemical process for molding precision synthetic rubber products” (see the opinion) wherein the opinion clarifies: “In the first sentence of its opinion, the Court states the question presented as "whether a process for curing synthetic rubber . . . is patentable subject matter." Ante, at 177. Of course, that question was effectively answered many years ago when Charles Goodyear obtained his patent on the vulcanization process. 25” and footnote 25 clarifies it was “In an opinion written over a century ago”
E.g. Waite et al., US 7,024,342, col. 1, ln. 20-55 incl: “In manufacturing casting/molding processes, for product quality of the molded article, it is of importance to optimize the mold design and the process conditions. Conventionally, such optimization is attained after many trial and error experiments which are repeated on the basis of the rule of thumb of an expert [a person]. With the advance in computer technology, it has become possible to analyze flow behavior of a material during a casting/molding process by computer simulation. When realistically modeled, the results from 30 such simulation may be used to predict the casting behavior, thereby improving the efficiency of product and mold design, and optimization of processing conditions [by a person using a computer as a tool]…”
Under the broadest reasonable interpretation, these limitations are process steps that cover mental processes including an observation, evaluation, judgment or opinion that could be performed in the human mind or with the aid of physical aids but for the recitation of a generic computer component. If a claim, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, covers a mental process but for the recitation of generic computer components, then it falls within the "Mental Process" grouping of abstract ideas. A person would readily be able to perform this process either mentally or with the assistance of physical aids. See MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2).
To clarify, see the USPTO 101 training examples, available at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility. In particular, with respect to the physical aids, see example # 45, analysis of claim 1 under step 2A prong 1, including: “Note that even if most humans would use a physical aid (e.g., pen and paper, a slide rule, or a calculator) to help them complete the recited calculation, the use of such physical aid does not negate the mental nature of this limitation.”; also see example # 49, analysis of claim 1, under step 2A prong 1: “Moreover, the recited mathematical calculation is simple enough that it can be practically performed in the human mind. Even if most humans would use a physical aid, like a pen and paper or a calculator, to make such calculations, the use of a physical aid would not negate the mental nature of this limitation.”
As such, the claims recite an abstract idea of both a mental process and mathematical concept.
Step 2A, prong 2
The claimed invention does not recite any additional elements that integrate the judicial exception into a practical application. Refer to MPEP §2106.04(d).
The following limitations are merely reciting the words "apply it" (or an equivalent) with the judicial exception, or merely including instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer, or merely using a computer as a tool to perform an abstract idea, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(f), including the “Use of a computer or other machinery in its ordinary capacity for economic or other tasks (e.g., to receive, store, or transmit data) or simply adding a general purpose computer or computer components after the fact to an abstract idea (e.g., a fundamental economic practice or mathematical equation) does not integrate a judicial exception into a practical application or provide significantly more”:
An automated mechanical design analysis system for manufacturing a mechanical object, the system comprising: a computing platform including a hardware processor and a system memory; and a software code stored in the system memory, wherein the hardware processor is configured to execute the software code to:
Representative claim 1 (and parallel claim 11 for a similar limitation): “for manufacturing” – should this be found to positively require an act of manufacturing this would be mere instructions to “apply it”, akin to the cutting of hair with scissors of In re Brown in MPEP 2106.05(f)
Should it be found that the design of the mold is not part of the abstract idea, then it would also be mere instruction to “apply it” under a similar rationale.
The following limitations are generally linking the use of a judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(h):
and design a mold for manufacturing the mechanical object using the optimized model. – should this be found not to be abstract, this would be generally linking to a field of use/technological environment of making a mold for manufacturing, e.g. the field of Diamond v. Diehr as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(e), rather than other fields/technological environments such as “asymmetric wheel design” (page 11, last paragraph; a field discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(h): “iii. Limiting the use of the formula C = 2 (pi) r to determining the circumference of a wheel as opposed to other circular objects, because this limitation represents a mere token acquiescence to limiting the reach of the claim, Flook, 437 U.S. at 595, 198 USPQ at 199;”), wherein the instant disclosure further clarifies on this on page 28, last paragraph: “The optimization techniques described above enable a wide variety of applications”, i.e. other fields of use/technological environments; also see page 13, ¶ 3: “optimized model 160/260, can be loaded into a modeling tool for further refinement, or may be used to design a mold for manufacturing mechanical object 242 it models.”
The following limitations are adding insignificant extra-solution activity to the judicial exception, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g):
receive an input model of the mechanical object, wherein the input model comprises a Computer-Aided Design (CAD) model;- mere data gathering
and design a mold for manufacturing the mechanical object using the optimized model. – should this be found not to be abstract, this would be an insignificant extra-solution activity of an insignificant application, akin to “i. Cutting hair after first determining the hair style, In re Brown, 645 Fed. App'x 1014, 1016-1017 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (non-precedential); and ii. Printing or downloading generated menus, Ameranth, 842 F.3d at 1241-42, 120 USPQ2d at 1854-55.” As discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g)
A claim that integrates a judicial exception into a practical application will apply, rely on, or use the judicial exception in a manner that imposes a meaningful limit on the judicial exception, such that the claim is more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the judicial exception. See MPEP § 2106.04(d).
The claimed invention does not recite any additional elements that integrate the judicial exception into a practical application. Refer to MPEP §2106.04(d).
Step 2B
The claimed invention does not recite any additional elements/limitations that amount to significantly more.
The following limitations are merely reciting the words "apply it" (or an equivalent) with the judicial exception, or merely including instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer, or merely using a computer as a tool to perform an abstract idea, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(f), including the “Use of a computer or other machinery in its ordinary capacity for economic or other tasks (e.g., to receive, store, or transmit data) or simply adding a general purpose computer or computer components after the fact to an abstract idea (e.g., a fundamental economic practice or mathematical equation) does not integrate a judicial exception into a practical application or provide significantly more”:
An automated mechanical design analysis system for manufacturing a mechanical object, the system comprising: a computing platform including a hardware processor and a system memory; and a software code stored in the system memory, wherein the hardware processor is configured to execute the software code to:
Representative claim 1 (and parallel claim 11 for a similar limitation): “for manufacturing” – should this be found to positively require an act of manufacturing this would be mere instructions to “apply it”, akin to the cutting of hair with scissors of In re Brown in MPEP 2106.05(f)
Should it be found that the design of the mold is not part of the abstract idea, then it would also be mere instruction to “apply it” under a similar rationale.
The following limitations are generally linking the use of a judicial exception to a particular technological environment or field of use, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(h):
and design a mold for manufacturing the mechanical object using the optimized model. – should this be found not to be abstract, this would be generally linking to a field of use/technological environment of making a mold for manufacturing, e.g. the field of Diamond v. Diehr as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(e), rather than other fields/technological environments such as “asymmetric wheel design” (page 11, last paragraph; a field discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(h): “iii. Limiting the use of the formula C = 2 (pi) r to determining the circumference of a wheel as opposed to other circular objects, because this limitation represents a mere token acquiescence to limiting the reach of the claim, Flook, 437 U.S. at 595, 198 USPQ at 199;”), wherein the instant disclosure further clarifies on this on page 28, last paragraph: “The optimization techniques described above enable a wide variety of applications”, i.e. other fields of use/technological environments; also see page 13, ¶ 3: “optimized model 160/260, can be loaded into a modeling tool for further refinement, or may be used to design a mold for manufacturing mechanical object 242 it models.”
The following limitations are adding insignificant extra-solution activity to the judicial exception, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g):
receive an input model of the mechanical object, wherein the input model comprises a Computer-Aided Design (CAD) model;- mere data gathering
and design a mold for manufacturing the mechanical object using the optimized model. – should this be found not to be abstract, this would be an insignificant extra-solution activity of an insignificant application, akin to “i. Cutting hair after first determining the hair style, In re Brown, 645 Fed. App'x 1014, 1016-1017 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (non-precedential); and ii. Printing or downloading generated menus, Ameranth, 842 F.3d at 1241-42, 120 USPQ2d at 1854-55.” As discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g)
In addition, the above insignificant extra-solution activities are also considered as well-understood, routine, and conventional activities, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(d):
receive an input model of the mechanical object, wherein the input model comprises a Computer-Aided Design (CAD) model; - this is considered similar to the example WURC activity as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(d)(II) of: “iii. Electronic recordkeeping, Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank Int'l, 573 U.S. 208, 225, 110 USPQ2d 1984 (2014) (creating and maintaining "shadow accounts"); Ultramercial, 772 F.3d at 716, 112 USPQ2d at 1755 (updating an activity log); iv. Storing and retrieving information in memory, Versata Dev. Group, Inc. v. SAP Am., Inc., 793 F.3d 1306, 1334, 115 USPQ2d 1681, 1701 (Fed. Cir. 2015); OIP Techs., 788 F.3d at 1363, 115 USPQ2d at 1092-93;” For additional evidence, see the instant disclosure, page 1, ¶¶ 1-2; also see:
Yuan et al., “Mapped B-spline basis functions for shape design and isogeometric analysis over an arbitrary parameterization”, 2013, abstract and § 1 including: “B-spline curves and surfaces are widely used in the CAD and graphics communities. Their rational representation, known as Non-Uniform Rational B-splines (NURBS), has been the de facto industrial standard over the past decades. B-splines provide a convenient set of basis functions for a control mesh of regular topology. They have been widely used in shape design, surface reconstruction, shape deformation and animation, image processing, biomedical applications, and recently on isogeometric analysis (IGA) [6,14,18,26,28]… IGA based on B-splines has been widely discussed…”, and § 2 provides the mathematical definition of a “B-spline curve…”
and design a mold for manufacturing the mechanical object using the optimized model. and also, should it be found that the designing of the mold is not part of the abstract idea, these are considered WURC in view of Knights et al., “CAD Evolution For 3D Mold Design”, March 1st, 2008, Plastics Technology, News Article, URL: www(dot)ptonline(dot)com/articles/cad-evolution-for-3d-mold-design, see : “Specially tailored packages of 3D computer-aided design software have been available to injection mold designers for at least a decade…Today’s typical mold-design CAD package features programs or modules to build and view a full representation of the mold, which includes generating core and cavity from the part model, parting-line splits, optimization of parting surfaces, mold-base selection, and addition of shutoffs, cooling lines, runner systems, gates, slides, lifters, ejectors, columns, spacers, guides, nozzles, screws, and pins…Suppliers say such productivity advancements are critical to moldmakers today. “Injection molding part designs are becoming more complex due to parts consolidation, while at the same time the molder or customer requires the tooling sooner, so the mold has to be created and fabricated more quickly…”, also see Hafner et al., “X-CAD: Optimizing CAD Models with Extended Finite Elements”, 2019, an article on the instant invention by the instant inventors, page 2, col. 1, ¶ 3: “CAD models are often tailored for fabrication using a particular manufacturing technology. For example, if we target casting or injection molding, a model has to be undercut-free and observe a minimal draft angle constraint”; and see page 4, col. 1, ¶ 2: “or to design the mold for manufacturing by casting or modeling”, then see page 14, col. 1, ¶ 1: “To manufacture the optimized lampshade, we use MoldStar 30 rubber”
Also see Diamond v. Diehr as discussed briefly above; and Bloomfield et al, “Sand Casting”, Lecture notes from Santa Rosa Junior College, Fall 2013, ENGR 45 as discussed above
The claimed invention is directed towards an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept and a mental process without significantly more.
Regarding the dependent claims
Claims 2-4 are merely further limiting the mere data gathering in the manner discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(h): “a data gathering step that is limited to a particular data source (such as the Internet) or a particular type of data (such as power grid data or XML tags) could be considered to be both insignificant extra-solution activity and a field of use limitation”, wherein these are considered WURC in view of ¶ 3 of the instant disclosure: “In modern Computer-Aided Design (CAD) systems, a boundary representation 5 composed primarily of Non-Uniform Rational Basis Spline (NURBS) patches is typically used to describe solid models”, also see Borrmann, A.; König, M.; Koch, C.; Beetz, J. (Eds): Building Information Modeling - Technology Foundations and Industry Practice, Springer, 2018, DOI: 10.1007/978-3-319-92862-3, § 2.2.1.1: “Boundary Representation is the most common and widespread method for describing three-dimensional bodies using a computer. The basic principle involves defining a hierarchy of boundary elements. Typically, this hierarchy comprises the elements Body, Face, Edge and Vertex. Each element is described by elements from the level beneath, i.e. the body is described by its faces, each face by its edges, each edge by a start and end vertex. This system of relationships defines the topology of the modeled body, and can be described with the help of a graph (see Fig. 1.2), which is known as the vertex-edge-face graph, or … graph…”, also see § 2.4.1 including: “Freeform curves are also known as splines. These are curves that are comprised of a series of polynomials. To ensure the overall curve is smooth, the joins between the segments of the curve must satisfy given continuity conditions. There are three different stages of continuity which are termed C0-, C1- and C2 continuity (see Fig. 1.10). C0 continuity stands for point continuity and means that two curves are connected without a break between them… Freeform curves are described mathematically as parametric curves. The term “parametric” derives from the fact that the three coordinates in space are the function of common parameters (commonly termed u)… The most common types of freeform curves are Bezier curves, B-splines and NURBS. All three types are defined by a series of control points: the first and last of these lie on the curve, while those in-between are only approximated by the curve…Mathematically all three curve types are the sum of the multiplication of the control points with the basis function. These basis functions are different for each of the three curve type…” – then see page 13 for the description of “NURBS”; also see Hartmann et al., “About Isogeometric Analysis and the new NURBS-based Finite Elements in LS-DYNA”, 2011, § 2.2 including § 2.2.1-2.2.2; then see § 2.24, then see § 3.1 which describes “A typical NURBS-patch”.
Claims 12-14 are rejected under a similar rationale
For additional WURC evidence, also see previously cited Suresh et al., US 2018/ 0225871, ¶¶ 3-5; also see Cho, Maenghyo, Jinbok Choi, and Hee-Yuel Roh. "Integration of shell FEA with geometric modeling on NURBS surface representation for practical applications." 47th AIA A/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASC Structures, Structural Dynamics, and Materials Conference 14th AIA A/ASME/AHS Adaptive Structures Conference 7th. 2008. §§ 1-2, and page 31; and Hughes, Thomas JR, John A. Cottrell, and Yuri Bazilevs. "Isogeometric analysis: CAD, finite elements, NURBS, exact geometry and mesh refinement." Computer methods in applied mechanics and engineering 194.39-41 (2005): 4135-4195. § 1 including pages 4138-4139, then see § 2 including the subsections, then see § 2.6 including page 4145, and § 5.2
Claim 5 is further limiting the mathematical concept by specifying the geometry to be “3D” of the grid, and by specifying that the geometry of the grid “remains constant”, e.g. a 3D cuboidal grid comprising equally sized cubes – i.e. this would be the mathematical relationships/equations in the field geometry representing the grid for use in the math calculations in textual form (e.g. the mathematical geometrical relationships between such cubes defining the grid)
Claim 15 is rejected under a similar rationale
Claim 6 is further limiting the math concept to use a “regular hexahedral grid”, e.g. a grid of cuboidal shapes as cuboids has 6 sides in their geometry, such as a 3D grid of cubes
To clarify on the BRI of regular, while the instant disclosure does not define what the term “regular” means, the Examiner notes that POSITA would have known the meaning of this claim term by their own knowledge as this term, in this context, is a common term of art, e.g. see Yildirim et al., “PARAMETERS CORRELATION STUDY TO INVESTIGATE THE EFFECTS OF GEOMETRIC VARIABLES ON THE SAFETY OF BOLTED FLANGE CONNECTIONS”, page 2 ¶ 2: “A regular hexahedral element, also known as brick element, is presented in both Figure 3 with linear formulation and in Figure 4 with quadratic formulation” and see figures 3-4 which show this is a cube (e.g. instant figures 5B and 6)
To clarify, this point in view of Yildirim is being made in view of MPEP § 2111.01(I and III) for Phillips v. AWH, for whether a recitation is definite under § 112(b) is not in a vacuum, but rather whether POSITA would have found it to be definite, and in this particular case “regular” has a special plain meaning when interpreted by POSITA rendering it definite, e.g. see Yildirim’s usage of this and visual depictions to clarify on how POSITA would read this limitation.
Claim 16 is rejected under a similar rationale
Claims 24-25 is merely further clarifying the math concept of the optimizing. See instant disclosure eq. 4-7 to clarify, i.e. the objectives are merely math equations in textual form, and the terms of them are merely variables in the math equations (note in the equations “p” which is the variable for the shape parameters, as per page 9 ¶ 2: “shape parameters p”).
Claim 26 is reciting math relationships in geometry of curves associated with intersections in geometry (see pages 26-27), see the sample points on fig. 6 as the white dots, wherein such curves are readily also mentally evaluated/observed, such as with physical aids, on simple shapes like the ones show in fig. 6, an insignificant extra-solution activity of data storage that is WURC (MPEP § 2106.05(g); then see MPEP § 2106.05(d)(II) for WURC evidence), followed by the performance of the limitation of generating the simulation rejected under a similar rationale as discussed above for the independent claims
Claim 27 – further adding to the math concept, in view of page 25 last paragraph to 26 ¶¶ 1-2, incl.: “…With respect to increasing the efficiency of rule derivatives, it is noted that, if the transformations for volume, area, and surface integrals are kept fixed after initial rule construction, the quadrature points no longer depend on the shape parameters for volume, area, and surface rules… However, if we keep applying the initial transformation for area, surface, and volume rules, the weights, computed with the moment fitting equation, only depend on the right-hand side b of Equation 13 but not on a shape-dependent transformation” – also see eq. 10 as discussed on page 19 ¶¶ 2-4, also see pages 21-22, including: “To evaluate the integrals of basis functions over the transformed domains, we use the area and surface rules developed above, establishing a second and final layer of nesting” , also see eq. 4 on page 11 to eq. 7 on page 12, eq. 8-9 on page 17, eq. 19 on page 24, followed by pages 24-25 for eq. 20-21;
Claim 28 – repeating the limitation of the simulation and optimizing as discussed above, i.e. its rejected under a similar rationale, should this be found not to be abstract then it would be mere instructions to do it on a computer and an insignificant computer implementation and WURC in view of Bancorp Services v. Sun Life, 687 F.3d 1266, 1278, 103 USPQ2d 1425, 1433 (Fed. Cir. 2012) as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g and d(II))
Claim 29 – further adding to the math concept, in view of pages 21-22, i.e. the quadrature weights are mathematical equations/relationships used “for integration…” wherein this is over mathematical geometry of “subvolume” that are computed by “Moment fitting” (page 21 provides equations for calculation for moment fitting), wherein the bounding box is described as mathematical relationships in geometry on pages 20-21 (also note, it’s of an “integration domain” for mathematical calculation, and its mapping the bounding box, e.g. “[a,b] x [c,d]”, to a “unit cube” or “unit square”, wherein the Examiner notes a unit square is a square with a side length of 1, and a unit cube has a side length of 1 for each side, i.e. its mapping a rectangle in 2D to a square, or mapping a cuboid [e.g. a box], i.e. this is a mathematical concept in the mathematical field of geometry (mapping math equations/relationships representing a “box” to a “unit square”/”unit cube”
To further clarify, see equations 11-17, which are the mathematical prose that is recited in textual form in this claim (e.g. the mapping in eq. 11 is the mapping to the unit cube/unit square; followed by the moment fitting in the space of the isoparametric variables per the equations, followed by the mathematical transformation back to the original domain in eq. 16). Should further clarification be sought on this, the Examiner notes that the associated journal paper by the instant inventive entity, Hafner et al., “X-CAD: Optimizing CAD Models with Extended Finite Elements”, 2019, has substantially the same text as the instant description on this in § 4.2, e.g. see eq. 9-15, then see fig. 7 of Hafner which provides a visual depicton of the mapping (noting fig. 7, left-hand side is a unit square, with the “isoparametric parameters” per eq. 9 of Hafner, which is eq. 11 of the instant application.
Examiner notes, for compact prosecution, that should it be found that the mapping of the bounding box to a unit square/unit volume is not the same as the mapping act performed by equation 11, then the Examiner notes that such a finding would necessitate a § 112(a) rejection because the act of the moment fitting (page 21) is performed after the mapping with eq. 11, wherein the specification never describes a combination wherein the act of moment fitting is performed after mapping to the unit square/unit cube expressly, with the intended result as claimed. To clarify, such a finding would be that the act of mapping in eq. 11 is distinct and separate from the act of mapping to the unit square/cube, and if such a distinction is found than the particular combination recited in eq. 29 would not be sufficiently described as the moment fitting would not be clearly linked (Hyatt v. Dudas in MPEP § 2163(II)(A); also Lockwood v. American Airlines in MPEP § 2163(I)) to being after the act of the mapping, which is what the claim presently requires, including with the expressly recited intended result (the “such that…” recitation) of the act of mapping. Rather, it is the act of mapping via eq. 11 that is clearly linked in the specification to the moment fitting.
Claim 30 – the “solve…” is math calculations in textual form – see eq. 9, accompanying description, and pages 24-25; the use of the control points to minimize a potential energy is math calculations in textual form as well (pages 24-25, paragraph split between the pages; eq. 7), wherein this is to further calculate “shape derivatives” using the mathematical method of an “adjoint technique”/”adjoint method” (eq. 20-21 and accompanying description)
Claim 31 – see fig. 5A and page 16, this is a mental process of mental observations and/or evaluations of shapes such as shown in fig. 5A, as well as math relationships in geometry between parts of shapes; wherein this is to maintain a math relationship in geometry of tangency between patches (parts of the shapes; see fig. 5A; discussed on page 16) during the performing of the limitations recited in the independent claims (those limitations rejected for the rationale discussed above)
Claim 32 – further limiting the abstract idea – see the discussion of the constraint graph above
Claim 33 – steps of mere data gathering/data displaying that are WURC in view of MPEP § 2106.05(d)(II) and example 46, claim 1
The claimed invention is directed towards an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept and a mental process without significantly more.
Conclusion
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure. .
Buchegger, Florian, and Bert Jüttler. "Planar multi-patch domain parameterization via patch adjacency graphs." Computer-Aided Design 82 (2017): 2-12. Abstract, §§ 2.1-2.2
Bénière, Roseline, et al. "A comprehensive process of reverse engineering from 3D meshes to CAD models." Computer-Aided Design 45.11 (2013): 1382-1393. § 2.2 ¶ 1, §§ 3.3-3.1. Cf. 9 and accompanying description.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to DAVID A. HOPKINS whose telephone number is (571)272-0537. The examiner can normally be reached Monday to Friday, 10AM to 7 PM EST.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Ryan Pitaro can be reached at (571) 272-4071. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/David A Hopkins/ Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2188