DETAILED ACTION
This action is in response to the amendments filed on Aug. 11th, 2026. A summary of this action:
Claims 1-20 have been presented for examination.
Claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept, a mental process, and certain methods of organizing human activity without significantly more.
Claims not rejected under § 102/103. Closest reference is the previously relied upon Salter, but Salter conveys that the isolation factors include being based on both the CAC and the STC, not just the lesser of the two as expressly recited in the independent claims (i.e. “determining a limiting acoustic transmission characteristic between the pair of adjacent rooms by selecting a lesser of: (i) a ceiling acoustic class corresponding to sound traveling between the pair of adjacent rooms through the respective ceilings. and (ii) a sound transmission class corresponding to the identified wall;”)
This action is Final
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Response to Arguments/Amendments
Regarding the claim interpretation and duplicate claim warning
Interpretation is maintained, and the Examiner notes an obvious typographical mistake, in that the interpretation and duplicate claim warning was for representative claims 5-6. Remarks submit: “Whether a display outputs "poor," "fair," "good," "excellent," "highly confidential," or "total privacy" is likewise objectively ascertainable.” – but the only objective standard for these is the one that is disclosed, for the terms used in the claim are subjective. To clarify, this is akin to beauty is in the eye of the beholder, i.e. what one person judges is a beautiful object, or highly confidential levels of speech privacy, another may readily subjectively reach a different conclusion, e.g. it is of fair aesthetic value but not beautiful, or that the level of privacy is only good. Such differences may readily arise purely from their own subjective experience and opinion, e.g. a spy may conclude its only “good” from their experience and subjective opinion, whereas a carpenter may readily reach a conclusion of “total privacy” from their own experience and subjective opinion.
Thus, it is proper to import the objective standard into the claim itself, because the specification provides an objective standard for these levels, precluding a § 112(b) rejection (i.e. without importing the standard, the claim is indefinite for its use of subjective terminology). See MPEP § 2173.05(b) to clarify, e.g. “For example, in Datamize, the invention was directed to a computer interface screen with an “aesthetically pleasing look and feel.” Datamize, 417 F.3d at 1344-45, 75 USPQ2d at 1802-03. The meaning of the term “aesthetically pleasing” depended solely on the subjective opinion of the person selecting features to be included on the interface screen. Nothing in the intrinsic evidence (e.g., the specification) provided any guidance as to what design choices would result in an “aesthetically pleasing” look and feel. 417 F.3d at 1352, 75 USPQ2d at 1808. The claims were held indefinite because the interface screen may be “aesthetically pleasing” to one user but not to another. 417 F.3d at 1350, 75 USPQ2d at 1806. See also Ex parte Anderson, 21 USPQ2d 1241 (Bd. Pat. App. & Inter. 1991) (the terms “comparable” and “superior” were held to be indefinite in the context of a limitation relating the characteristics of the claimed material to other materials).”
Regarding the objections
Withdrawn in view of amendment.
Regarding the § 102/103 Rejection
Withdrawn in view of amendment.
Regarding the § 101 Rejection
Maintained, updated as necessitated by amendment.
With respect to the remarks regarding prong 1, regarding this being computer-implemented, merely doing an abstract idea on a computer does not make it eligible. See MPEP § 2106.05(f)
With respect to the remarks, regarding the additional elements at prong 2, Examiner respectfully disagrees – those steps are mere data gathering for later use in the abstract idea. E.g. see example 46, claim 1.
With respect to the remarks regarding the mental process and math concept, these remarks do not address the detailed rationale set forth in the rejection for why this claim recites both a math concept and a mental process, rather it is a mere conclusory argument regarding the prior rejection without addressing its detailed rationale.
To further clarify, the present claims follow a similar abstract idea as Electric Power Group – see MPEP § 2106.05(a)(2)(III)(A): “a claim to “collecting information, analyzing it, and displaying certain results of the collection and analysis,” where the data analysis steps are recited at a high level of generality such that they could practically be performed in the human mind, Electric Power Group v. Alstom, S.A., 830 F.3d 1350, 1353-54, 119 USPQ2d 1739, 1741-42 (Fed. Cir. 2016);”
Claim Interpretation
Representative claims 5-6 recite numerous subjective terms/relative terms, however an objective standard is provided for these levels and terms in fig. 2B, and therefore the claims are construed to be limited to the numeric levels of SPP in fig. 2B as the is the objective standard provided for POSITA to ascertain the metes and bounds of the claims. To clarify, ¶ 40: “For example, the qualitative target "good" (255) maps to a quantitative target of 70 dB. That is an SPP value of 70 or greater satisfies a qualitative target of "good."” - See MPEP § 2173.05(b) to clarify
Duplicate Claim Warning
Applicant is advised that should claim 5 be found allowable, claim 6 will be objected to under 37 CFR 1.75 as being a substantial duplicate thereof. When two claims in an application are duplicates or else are so close in content that they both cover the same thing (cf. 2B as discussed above for claim construction), despite a slight difference in wording, it is proper after allowing one claim to object to the other as being a substantial duplicate of the allowed claim. See MPEP § 608.01(m).
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 101
35 U.S.C. 101 reads as follows:
Whoever invents or discovers any new and useful process, machine, manufacture, or composition of matter, or any new and useful improvement thereof, may obtain a patent therefor, subject to the conditions and requirements of this title.
Claims 1-20 are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 101 because the claimed invention is directed to an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept, a mental process, and certain methods of organizing human activity without significantly more.
Step 1
Claim 1 is directed towards the statutory category of a process.
Claim 16 is directed towards an article of manufacture.
Claims 16, and the dependents thereof, are rejected under a similar rationale as representative claim 1, and the dependents thereof.
Step 2A – Prong 1
The claims recite an abstract idea of both a mental process and mathematical concept.
See MPEP § 2106.04: “...In other claims, multiple abstract ideas, which may fall in the same or different groupings, or multiple laws of nature may be recited. In these cases, examiners should not parse the claim. For example, in a claim that includes a series of steps that recite mental steps as well as a mathematical calculation, an examiner should identify the claim as reciting both a mental process and a mathematical concept for Step 2A Prong One to make the analysis clear on the record.”
To clarify, see the USPTO 101 training examples, available at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility.
The mathematical concept recited in claim 1 is:
determining a value for a speech privacy indicator for the pair of adjacent rooms by combining the limiting acoustic transmission characteristic with the background noise level of a receiving room of the pair of adjacent rooms, the speech privacy indicator representing a decibel level below which speech in an adjacent room becomes unintelligible. – math calculations in textual form. See ¶ 37: “SPP is a site specific, single number that is arrived by adding the level of the background noise (referred to as NC and measured in decibels: dB) to the noise isolation class (NIC).” And see fig. 5 – its merely addition of numbers in textual form.
Under the broadest reasonable interpretation, the claim recites a mathematical concept – the above limitations are steps in a mathematical concept such as mathematical relationships, mathematical formulas or equations, and mathematical calculations. If a claim, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, is directed towards a mathematical concept, then it falls within the Mathematical Concepts grouping of abstract ideas. In addition, as per MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2): “It is important to note that a mathematical concept need not be expressed in mathematical symbols, because "[w]ords used in a claim operating on data to solve a problem can serve the same purpose as a formula." In re Grams, 888 F.2d 835, 837 and n.1, 12 USPQ2d 1824, 1826 and n.1 (Fed. Cir. 1989). See, e.g., SAP America, Inc. v. InvestPic, LLC, 898 F.3d 1161, 1163, 127 USPQ2d 1597, 1599 (Fed. Cir. 2018)”
See MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2).
To clarify, see the USPTO 101 training examples, available at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility.
The mental process recited in claim 1 is:
[generating] an adjacency matrix that represents which rooms of a plurality of rooms are adjacent, - a mental process nested in a step of mere data gathering (see ¶ 8: “Implementations of the present invention can comprise systems, methods, and apparatuses configured to obtain or generate an adjacency matrix that represent which rooms are adjacent in a floor plan or a design of a building including a plurality of rooms”). Cf. 2A and accompanying description, its merely a table of what rooms are adjacent to what other rooms. See fig. 6 which shows how trivial this is mentally, e.g. 210b is adjacent to 212, 205, and 208, by a simple mental observation of the floorplan.
and assigning an identification handle indicating which wall of one or more walls separates the adjacent rooms; - see ¶ 51: “These handles can be unique alphanumeric identifiers (e.g., the numbers 1, 2, 3, etc.). For example, a user may input the wall numbers or enter wall labels in the adjacency matrix.” - this is a mental process
for each pair of adjacent rooms represented in the adjacency matrix:
identifying, using the assigned identification handle, the wall separating the pair of adjacent rooms, determining a limiting acoustic transmission characteristic between the pair of adjacent rooms by selecting a lesser of:
(i) a ceiling acoustic class corresponding to sound traveling between the pair of adjacent rooms through the respective ceilings, and(ii) a sound transmission class corresponding to the identified wall;
determining a value for a speech privacy indicator for the pair of adjacent rooms by combining the limiting acoustic transmission characteristic with the background noise level of a receiving room of the pair of adjacent rooms, the speech privacy indicator representing a decibel level below which speech in an adjacent room becomes unintelligible;
The above steps are mental process. See above cited portions of the disclosure. Then, see fig. 5, which shows the simple math involved, simple enough a person is readily able to mentally do such a calculation, such as with physical aids.
To clarify, a person simply goes through a simple list (fig. 2A) for rooms, identifies for each room the wall separating it with an adjacent room, mentally determines/selects a value of a number (e.g. the “40 dB” in fig. 5, see ¶ 50, see ¶ 37), wherein such values were already provided by a user (¶ 46), and then does a simple calculation such as purely mentally or using physical aids (e.g. pen, paper, and/or a calculator). Such is readily a mental process.
Under the broadest reasonable interpretation, these limitations are process steps that cover mental processes including an observation, evaluation, judgment or opinion that could be performed in the human mind or with the aid of physical aids but for the recitation of a generic computer component. If a claim, under its broadest reasonable interpretation, covers a mental process but for the recitation of generic computer components, then it falls within the "Mental Process" grouping of abstract ideas. A person would readily be able to perform this process either mentally or with the assistance of physical aids. See MPEP § 2106.04(a)(2).
To clarify, see the USPTO 101 training examples, available at https://www.uspto.gov/patents/laws/examination-policy/subject-matter-eligibility. In particular, with respect to the physical aids, see example # 45, analysis of claim 1 under step 2A prong 1, including: “Note that even if most humans would use a physical aid (e.g., pen and paper, a slide rule, or a calculator) to help them complete the recited calculation, the use of such physical aid does not negate the mental nature of this limitation.”; also see example # 49, analysis of claim 1, under step 2A prong 1: “Moreover, the recited mathematical calculation is simple enough that it can be practically performed in the human mind. Even if most humans would use a physical aid, like a pen and paper or a calculator, to make such calculations, the use of a physical aid would not negate the mental nature of this limitation.”
As such, the claims recite an abstract idea of both a mental process and mathematical concept.
Step 2A, prong 2
The claimed invention does not recite any additional elements that integrate the judicial exception into a practical application. Refer to MPEP §2106.04(d).
The following limitations are merely reciting the words "apply it" (or an equivalent) with the judicial exception, or merely including instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer, or merely using a computer as a tool to perform an abstract idea, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(f), including the “Use of a computer or other machinery in its ordinary capacity for economic or other tasks (e.g., to receive, store, or transmit data) or simply adding a general purpose computer or computer components after the fact to an abstract idea (e.g., a fundamental economic practice or mathematical equation) does not integrate a judicial exception into a practical application or provide significantly more”:
Preambles of the independent claims
The following limitations are adding insignificant extra-solution activity to the judicial exception, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g):
The obtaining and retrieving steps are mere data gathering.
The “outputting…” step is mere data displaying
A claim that integrates a judicial exception into a practical application will apply, rely on, or use the judicial exception in a manner that imposes a meaningful limit on the judicial exception, such that the claim is more than a drafting effort designed to monopolize the judicial exception. See MPEP § 2106.04(d).
MPEP 2106.04(II)(A)(2) “…Instead, under Prong Two, a claim that recites a judicial exception is not directed to that judicial exception, if the claim as a whole integrates the recited judicial exception into a practical application of that exception. Prong Two thus distinguishes claims that are "directed to" the recited judicial exception from claims that are not "directed to" the recited judicial exception…Because a judicial exception is not eligible subject matter, Bilski, 561 U.S. at 601, 95 USPQ2d at 1005-06 (quoting Chakrabarty, 447 U.S. at 309, 206 USPQ at 197 (1980)), if there are no additional claim elements besides the judicial exception, or if the additional claim elements merely recite another judicial exception, that is insufficient to integrate the judicial exception into a practical application. See, e.g., RecogniCorp, LLC v. Nintendo Co., 855 F.3d 1322, 1327, 122 USPQ2d 1377 (Fed. Cir. 2017) ("Adding one abstract idea (math) to another abstract idea (encoding and decoding) does not render the claim non-abstract"); Genetic Techs. Ltd. v. Merial LLC, 818 F.3d 1369, 1376, 118 USPQ2d 1541, 1546 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (eligibility "cannot be furnished by the unpatentable law of nature (or natural phenomenon or abstract idea) itself."). For a claim reciting a judicial exception to be eligible, the additional elements (if any) in the claim must "transform the nature of the claim" into a patent-eligible application of the judicial exception, Alice Corp., 573 U.S. at 217, 110 USPQ2d at 1981, either at Prong Two or in Step 2B” and MPEP § 2106(I): “Mayo, 566 U.S. at 80, 84, 101 USPQ2dat 1969, 1971 (noting that the Court in Diamond v. Diehr found “the overall process patent eligible because of the way the additional steps of the process integrated the equation into the process as a whole,”” – and see MPEP § 2106.05(e).
To further clarify, MPEP § 2106.04(II)(A)(1): “Alice Corp., 573 U.S. at 216, 110 USPQ2d at 1980 (citing Mayo, 566 US at 71, 101 USPQ2d at 1965). Yet, the Court has explained that ‘‘[a]t some level, all inventions embody, use, reflect, rest upon, or apply laws of nature, natural phenomena, or abstract ideas,’’ and has cautioned ‘‘to tread carefully in construing this exclusionary principle lest it swallow all of patent law” See also Enfish, LLC v. Microsoft Corp., 822 F.3d 1327, 1335, 118 USPQ2d 1684, 1688 (Fed. Cir. 2016) ("The ‘directed to’ inquiry, therefore, cannot simply ask whether the claims involve a patent-ineligible concept, because essentially every routinely patent-eligible claim involving physical products and actions involves a law of nature and/or natural phenomenon").”
As a point of clarity, RecogniCorp, LLC v. Nintendo Co., 855 F.3d 1322, 1327, 122 USPQ2d 1377 (Fed. Cir. 2017) ("Adding one abstract idea (math) to another abstract idea (encoding and decoding) does not render the claim non-abstract"); Genetic Techs. Ltd. v. Merial LLC, 818 F.3d 1369, 1376, 118 USPQ2d 1541, 1546 (Fed. Cir. 2016) (eligibility "cannot be furnished by the unpatentable law of nature (or natural phenomenon or abstract idea) itself." discussed in MPEP § 2106.04(II)(A)(2) as well as MPEP § 2106.04(I): “Synopsys, Inc. v. Mentor Graphics Corp., 839 F.3d 1138, 1151, 120 USPQ2d 1473, 1483 (Fed. Cir. 2016) ("a new abstract idea is still an abstract idea") (emphasis in original).
The claimed invention does not recite any additional elements that integrate the judicial exception into a practical application. Refer to MPEP §2106.04(d).
Step 2B
The claimed invention does not recite any additional elements/limitations that amount to significantly more.
The following limitations are merely reciting the words "apply it" (or an equivalent) with the judicial exception, or merely including instructions to implement an abstract idea on a computer, or merely using a computer as a tool to perform an abstract idea, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(f), including the “Use of a computer or other machinery in its ordinary capacity for economic or other tasks (e.g., to receive, store, or transmit data) or simply adding a general purpose computer or computer components after the fact to an abstract idea (e.g., a fundamental economic practice or mathematical equation) does not integrate a judicial exception into a practical application or provide significantly more”:
Preambles of the independent claims
The following limitations are adding insignificant extra-solution activity to the judicial exception, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(g):
The obtaining and retrieving steps are mere data gathering.
The “outputting…” step is mere data displaying
In addition, the above insignificant extra-solution activities are also considered as well-understood, routine, and conventional activities, as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(d):
The obtaining and retrieving steps are mere data gathering - this is considered similar to the example WURC activity as discussed in MPEP § 2106.05(d)(II) of: “iii. Electronic recordkeeping, Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank Int'l, 573 U.S. 208, 225, 110 USPQ2d 1984 (2014) (creating and maintaining "shadow accounts"); Ultramercial, 772 F.3d at 716, 112 USPQ2d at 1755 (updating an activity log); iv. Storing and retrieving information in memory, Versata Dev. Group, Inc. v. SAP Am., Inc., 793 F.3d 1306, 1334, 115 USPQ2d 1681, 1701 (Fed. Cir. 2015); OIP Techs., 788 F.3d at 1363, 115 USPQ2d at 1092-93;”
The “outputting…” step is mere data displaying that is WURC in view of MPEP § 2106.05(d)(II) as well as example 46, claim 1, see its discussion of its displaying step at 2B.
The claimed invention is directed towards an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept and a mental process without significantly more.
Regarding the dependent claims
Claim 2 recites a mental judgement/comparison of comparing two numbers; followed by a mental judgement (i.e. simply judging that should the room not have sufficient noise isolation to use a more insulative wall material, e.g. add insulation in the wall, or a more insulative ceiling; akin to judging to better insulate a drafty room), followed repeating the mere data gathering steps of claim 1 and repeating the mental and mathematical determination step of claim 1.
Claims 3- merely further limiting the mental process
Claim 4- mere data displaying
Claims 5-6 – see fig. 2B. Merely further limiting the mental judgement to use a few specific threshold values
Claim 7 – further limiting the mental judgments
Claim 8 – further limiting the abstract idea.
Claim 9 – the “use a building information model…” is merely part of the instruction to do it on a computer/in a computer environment, and generally linking this to a particular field of use. The step of the BIM application providing objects and the like is merely the mental step of a person mentally visualizing the inside of a room, e.g. visualizing the walls, ceiling and some objects in the room (e.g. furniture) such as an Examiner mentally visualizing the inside of their own office, but done in a generic computer environment (¶ 36 with “object-oriented programming”, and note the generality in ¶ 36) and generally linking to the particular technological environment of object-oriented programing. Furthermore, object-oriented programming is WURC. See Pegden, US 8,156,468 col. 1 ln. 30-col. 2 ln. 20. In view of MPEP § 2106.07: “When evaluating a claimed invention for compliance with the substantive law on eligibility, examiners should review the record as a whole (e.g., the specification, claims, the prosecution history, and any relevant case law precedent or prior art) before reaching a conclusion with regard to whether the claimed invention sets forth patent eligible subject matter” - see Simio, LLC v. FlexSim Software Prods., Inc., 983 F.3d 1353, 2020 U.S.P.Q.2d 11538 (Fed. Cir. 2020) regarding the Pegden reference. In the context of BIM, it is also WURC, see Vedvik, Richard, and Jon Mooney. "Distilling the Acoustical Model from BIM Standard Architectural, Mechanical and Structural Models-Robust Acoustical Templates, Limitations & Recommendations." Proceedings of Meetings on Acoustics. Vol. 9. No. 1. Acoustical Society of America, 2010. Page 7: “For the purpose of sharing information between the various BIM platforms, the International Alliance for Interoperability (IAI) was founded in 1995 [1]. The main objective of the IAI was to develop and maintain a specification for sharing data between the platforms and applications, called the Industry Foundation Classes (IFCs). IFC is a neutral and open data format with specifications that are based on an object-oriented data model, and written using Express data definition language [2]. The data model uses class definitions to represent the various building elements and properties that are common to commercial buildings and construction projects. There are several commercial, free, and open source programs available that allow for viewing, modifying, and translating BIM files in IFC format.”
Claim 10-12 – merely further limiting the mere data gathering that is WURC in view of evidence cited above. MPEP § 2106.05(a)(I): Examples that the courts have indicated may not be sufficient to show an improvement in computer-functionality:… vii. Providing historical usage information to users while they are inputting data, in order to improve the quality and organization of information added to a database, because "an improvement to the information stored by a database is not equivalent to an improvement in the database’s functionality," BSG Tech LLC v. Buyseasons, Inc., 899 F.3d 1281, 1287-88, 127 USPQ2d 1688, 1693-94 (Fed. Cir. 2018); and”
Claim 13 is merely generally linking to a field of use of workplace environments
Claims 14-15 is considered akin to MPEP § 2106.05(g): “v. Consulting and updating an activity log, Ultramercial, 772 F.3d at 715, 112 USPQ2d at 1754; and …” – and see MPEP § 2106.05(d) for “iii. Electronic recordkeeping, Alice Corp. Pty. Ltd. v. CLS Bank Int'l, 573 U.S. 208, 225, 110 USPQ2d 1984 (2014) (creating and maintaining "shadow accounts"); Ultramercial, 772 F.3d at 716, 112 USPQ2d at 1755 (updating an activity log);”
Claims 18-20 rejected under similar rationales as representative claims above.
The claimed invention is directed towards an abstract idea of both a mathematical concept and a mental process without significantly more.
Conclusion
THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to DAVID A. HOPKINS whose telephone number is (571)272-0537. The examiner can normally be reached Monday to Friday, 10AM to 7 PM EST.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Ryan Pitaro can be reached at (571) 272-4071. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/David A Hopkins/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 2188