DETAILED ACTION
Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status
The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA .
Election/Restrictions
Claim 23 is newly added and depends on claim withdrawn claim 12 (withdrawn Group II); therefore claim 23 is currently withdrawn from consideration.
Status of Claims
Claims 1-4, 7-11, and 21-22 are examined.
Claims 12-18, 20, and 23 are withdrawn without traverse.
Claim 5-6 and 19 is cancelled.
Claims 21-23 are newly added.
Response to Amendment
The amendments to the claims overcome the previous 35 U.S.C. 103 and 122 rejections; therefore the rejections are withdrawn.
Claim Interpretation
Claim 1 recites the limitation “the compaction pressure along a contact-interface between the roller and the ply is substantially uniformly distributed on the ply”. The term “substantially uniformly” will be interpreted in line with claim 9 and 10 and in the instant specification in ¶ [0068, 0070, 0078] as “the compaction pressure that is uniform (e.g., the variation is less than or equal to a desired threshold” and “the compaction pressure is determined as uniform when the variation in the compaction pressure along the test-contact-interface is less than 5 PSI”.
Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103
The text of those sections of Title 35, U.S. Code not included in this action can be found in a prior Office action.
Claim(s) 1-4, 7-11, and 21-22 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Maeicer (FR 3133334 A1, and English machine translation is provided in the Office Action), in view of Leise (US 2013/0158458 A1).
Regarding claim 1, Maeicer discloses method for compacting a ceramic composite material (¶ [0020] – method of manufacturing a part in composite material) comprising a ceramic reinforcement (¶ [0045] – fibers of fibrous structures 7 can be ceramic) and a ceramic matrix (claim 9, ¶ [0020] –formation of a matrix in the porosities of the fibrous preform), the method comprising steps of:
positioning a roller (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over fibrous structures) in contact with a ply-surface (¶ [0029] – on draping surface) of a ply of the ceramic composite material (¶ [0020] – a part in composite material), wherein the ply is positioned on a compaction-surface (¶ [0042] – 1 for draping fibrous structures 7 onto a draping surface S to form a fibrous preform);
applying a compaction pressure to the ply using the roller (¶ [0054] – controlling the compaction pressure P) such that the compaction pressure along a contact-interface between the roller and the ply (¶ [0054] – apply an optimal compaction pressure P adapted at each moment to the geometry of the draping surface S) is substantially uniformly distributed on the ply (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface); and
with the roller in contact with the ply-surface (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over a draping surface to deposit fibrous structures) and applying the compaction pressure (¶ [0054] – controlling the compaction pressure P), moving the roller across the ply to conform the ply of the ceramic composite material (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface) to a contour of the compaction-surface (¶ [0054] – obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties),
wherein the roller comprises a core (¶ [0032] – core 10) and a covering surrounding the core (¶ [0032] – a layer of deformable material around core 10)
wherein the covering is selected such that a variation in the compaction pressure along the contact-interface between the roller and the ply (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface; ¶ [0058] – P applied by 1 are then compared with the desired value P using a comparator 503, which transmits a corrected value P) is less than a predetermined threshold (¶ [0059] - when the compaction pressure P is less than a desired value, the comparator transmits a higher corrected value and when the compaction pressure P is greater than the desired value P, the comparator transmits a lower corrected value P) when moving the roller across the ply and accommodating for the contour of the compaction-surface (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over a draping surface to deposit fibrous structures).
Maeicer discloses external surface of deformable core 10 can be metallic or made of a polymer material, can be made mainly of a foam whose Shore A hardness is preferably between 20 and 70 (¶ [0030]) and material chosen for the deformable material layer 20 is identical to the material chosen for the interior of the undeformable core 10 (¶ [0032]). Maeicer further discloses that when the compaction pressure P is less than a desired value, the comparator transmits a higher corrected value and when the compaction pressure P is greater than the desired value P, the comparator transmits a lower corrected value P (¶ [0059]) to apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties (¶ [0054]).
Maeicer discloses all of the claim limitations as set forth above, but the reference does not explicitly disclose the roller material is selected such that the variation in the compaction pressure along the contact-interface is less than 5 PSI. As the variation of the compaction pressure (PSI) and material quality and mechanical properties is a variable that can be modified, among others, by adjusting the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure, with said variation is decreased and material quality and mechanical properties increased as the Shore A hardness is adjusted and the applied compaction pressure (PSI) is consistently corrected within the desired threshold, the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure would have been considered a result effective variable by one having ordinary skill in the art at the time the invention was made. As such, without showing unexpected results, the claimed selected material with a variation in compaction pressure less than 5 PSI cannot be considered critical. Accordingly, one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention made would have optimized, by routine experimentation, the adjustment of the Shore A hardness of the material and the applied compaction pressure in the method of Maeicer to obtain the desired variation in compaction pressure (PSI) and material quality and mechanical properties (In re Boesch, 617 F.2d. 272, 205 USPQ 215 (CCPA 1980)), since it has been held that where the general conditions of the claim are disclosed in the prior art, discovering the optimum or workable ranges involves only routine skill in the art. (In re Aller, 105 USPQ 223).
Maeicer does not disclose the covering having a Shore A hardness of between approximately 1 and 10
Leise discloses a manufacturing method, to deposit a predetermined amount and shape of adhesive and a laminating roller of predetermined firmness under a predetermined pressure provides a means of fabricating having various shapes and sizes at high rates of speed in a cost effective and energy efficient manner (¶ [0008]).
Leise further discloses the covering having a Shore A hardness of between approximately 1 and 10 (¶ [0019] – roller 25 has a firmness (hardness) of between 10 shore A and 90 shore A).
Maeicer and Leise disclose methods with the same or similar components performing the same or similar function in regards to laminating using a roller and pressure. It would have been obvious to one having ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to have applied the roller having a hardness of between 10 shore A and 90 shore A in Leise to the layer of deformable material of the roller in Maeicer to apply a predetermined pressure to deform and feather edges based on thickness (¶ [0019]) and means of fabricating having various shapes and sizes at high rates of speed in a cost effective and energy efficient manner (¶ [0008]).
Regarding claim 2, Modified Maeicer the method discloses of Claim 1, further comprising selecting a magnitude of the compaction pressure (¶ [0054] – controlling the compaction pressure P, as it is controlled, the compaction pressure is selected), wherein the magnitude of the compaction pressure is selected to conform the ceramic reinforcement of the ply to the contour of the compaction-surface (¶ [0054] – apply an optimal compaction pressure P adapted at each moment to the geometry of the draping surface S) and maintain a desired thickness of the ply while moving the roller across the ply (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties, thickness is affected by the compaction pressure, therefore a desired/optimal thickness is achieved).
Regarding claim 3, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 2, further comprising, with the roller in contact with the ply-surface, adjusting the magnitude of the compaction pressure (¶ [0054] – controlling the compaction pressure P; ¶ [0058] – P applied by 1 are then compared with the desired value P using a comparator 503, which transmits a corrected value P) using a feedback controller (¶ [0056] – closed-loop control of the compaction pressure P, adjust in real time the compaction pressure P according to asperities or irregularities).
Regarding claim 4, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 1, wherein:
the ceramic reinforcement (¶ [0045] – fibers of fibrous structures 7) comprises at least one of carbon reinforcement fibers (¶ [0045] – can be ceramic or carbon fibers), silicon carbide reinforcement fibers (¶ [0045] – can be made of silicon carbide), or alumina reinforcement fibers (¶ [0045] – alumina); and
the ceramic matrix (claim 9, ¶ [0064] – matrix) comprises at least one of a carbon matrix (¶ [0064] – composition comprising a binder and a ceramic or carbon fillers)
Regarding claim 7, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 6, further comprising a step of selecting a covering-material for the covering (¶ [0032] – deformable material 20 made of a flexible and elastically deformable material, made of elastomeric material, in particular silicone or polyurethane, or of a foam whose Shore A hardness is 20 to 70; therefore, a material is selected for the layer on the core), wherein the covering-material is selected such that the compaction pressure is uniform along the contact-interface between the roller and the ply when moving the roller across the ply (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface).
Regarding claim 8, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 7.
Maeicer discloses deformable material 20 present around the core 10 is made of a flexible and elastically deformable material, thus can be made of made of elastomeric material, in particular silicone or polyurethane, or of a foam whose Shore A hardness is 20 to 70 (¶ [0032]). Maeicer further discloses that when the compaction pressure P is less than a desired value, the comparator transmits a higher corrected value and when the compaction pressure P is greater than the desired value P, the comparator transmits a lower corrected value P (¶ [0059]) to apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties (¶ [0054]).
Maeicer discloses all of the claim limitations as set forth above, but the reference does not explicitly disclose the covering-material is selected by testing a plurality of test-covering materials and selecting one of the test-covering materials that achieves a variation in the compaction pressure along the contact-interface is less than 5 PSI. As the variation of the compaction pressure (PSI) and the material quality and mechanical properties is a variable that can be modified, among others, by adjusting the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure, with said variation is decreased and material quality and mechanical properties increased as the Shore A hardness is adjusted and the applied compaction pressure is consistently corrected within the desired threshold, the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure would have been considered a result effective variable by one having ordinary skill in the art at the time the invention was made. As such, without showing unexpected results, the claimed selected material with a variation in compaction pressure less than 5 PSI cannot be considered critical. Accordingly, one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention made would have optimized, by routine experimentation, the adjustment of the Shore A hardness of the material and the applied compaction pressure in the method of Maeicer to obtain the desired variation in compaction pressure (PSI) and material quality and mechanical properties (In re Boesch, 617 F.2d. 272, 205 USPQ 215 (CCPA 1980)), since it has been held that where the general conditions of the claim are disclosed in the prior art, discovering the optimum or workable ranges involves only routine skill in the art. (In re Aller, 105 USPQ 223).
Regarding claim 9, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 7, wherein:
the step of selecting the covering-material (¶ [0032] – deformable material 20 made of a flexible and elastically deformable material, made of elastomeric material, in particular silicone or polyurethane, or of a foam whose Shore A hardness is 20 to 70; therefore, a material is selected for the layer on the core) comprises:
providing a test-roller comprising a test-core (¶ [0032] – core 10) and a test-covering surrounding the test-core (¶ [0032] – a layer of deformable material around core 10), the test-covering comprising a test-covering-material;
positioning the test-roller (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over fibrous structures) in contact with a pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – on draping surface);
applying the compaction pressure to the pressure sensor film using the test-roller (¶ [0054] – apply an optimal compaction pressure P adapted at each moment to the geometry of the draping surface S);
with the test-roller in contact with the pressure sensor film and applying the compaction pressure, moving the test-roller across the pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over a draping surface to deposit fibrous structures);
measuring the compaction pressure while moving the test-roller across the pressure sensor film (¶ [0054] – at least one sensor 100 measures the radial distances or the variations in radial distance between the deformable outer skin 30 and the undeformable core of 10, measurements processed for the force applied so as to apply an optimal compaction pressure);
determining whether the compaction pressure is uniform along a test-contact-interface between the test-roller and the pressure sensor film (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties) when moving the test-roller across the pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over a draping surface to deposit fibrous structures); and
validating the test-covering-material when the compaction pressure is uniform along the test-contact-interface (¶ [0054] –to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties; ¶ [0058] – P applied by 1 are then compared with the desired value P using a comparator 503, which transmits a corrected value P).
Maeicer does not explicitly disclose the compaction pressure is determined as uniform when a variation in the compaction pressure along the test-contact-interface is less than 5 PSI.
However, as Maeicer discloses that when the compaction pressure P is less than a desired value, the comparator transmits a higher corrected value and when the compaction pressure P is greater than the desired value P, the comparator transmits a lower corrected value P (¶ [0059]), it would have been obvious for one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to set a range of values from the desired value as satisfactory for applying the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties (¶ [0054]). Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to set a variation or range from the desired compaction pressure to achieve the desired compaction pressure to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties (¶ [0054]).
Regarding claim 10, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 1, further comprising:
measuring the compaction pressure while moving the roller across the ply (¶ [0054] – at least one sensor 100 measures the radial distances or the variations in radial distance between the deformable outer skin 30 and the undeformable core of 10, measurements processed for the force applied so as to apply an optimal compaction pressure); and
adjusting the compaction pressure in response to the measuring (¶ [0054] – applying a compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities) when the compaction pressure is not uniform along a contact-interface between the roller and the ply (¶ [0054] – to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties; ¶ [0058] – P applied by 1 are then compared with the desired value P using a comparator 503, which transmits a corrected value P).
Regarding claim 11, Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 10, wherein:
the step of measuring the compaction pressure comprises:
positioning a pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers) in contact with the ply-surface of the ply (¶ [0029] – draping surface);;
positioning the roller (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over fibrous structures) in contact with the pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – on draping surface);
applying the compaction pressure to the pressure sensor film using the roller (¶ [0054] – apply an optimal compaction pressure P adapted at each moment to the geometry of the draping surface S);
with the roller in contact with the pressure sensor film and applying the compaction pressure, moving the roller across the pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over a draping surface to deposit fibrous structures; ¶ [0054] – measurements are processed for the force applied so as to apply an optimal compaction pressure); and
determining whether the compaction pressure is uniform along a contact-interface between the roller and the pressure sensor film (¶ [0054] – apply the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties) when moving the roller across the pressure sensor film (¶ [0029] – automatic placement of fibers, deposition roller 1 to roll over a draping surface to deposit fibrous structures).
the compaction pressure is measured while moving the roller across the pressure sensor film (¶ [0054] – at least one sensor 100 measures the radial distances or the variations in radial distance between the deformable outer skin 30 and the undeformable core of 10); and
Maeicer does not explicitly disclose the compaction pressure is determined as uniform when a variation in the compaction pressure along the test-contact-interface is less than 5 PSI.
However, as Maeicer discloses that when the compaction pressure P is less than a desired value, the comparator transmits a higher corrected value and when the compaction pressure P is greater than the desired value P, the comparator transmits a lower corrected value P (¶ [0059]), it would have been obvious for one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to set a range of values from the desired value as satisfactory for applying the desired compaction pressure, apply compaction pressure P adapted to the irregularities of the surface to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties (¶ [0054]). Therefore, it would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art to set a variation or range from the desired compaction pressure to achieve the desired compaction pressure to obtain a final part with good material quality and satisfactory mechanical properties (¶ [0054]).
Regarding claim 21, modified Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 1.
Modified Maeicer further discloses the covering comprises closed-cell foam (Maeicer ¶ [0032] - deformable material 20 present around the core 10 is made of a foam; Leise ¶ [0010] – laminating roller made of foam)
Maeicer discloses deformable material 20 present around the core 10 is made of a flexible and elastically deformable material, thus can be made of made of elastomeric material, in particular silicone or polyurethane, or of a foam whose Shore A hardness is 20 to 70 (¶ [0032]). Leise further discloses roller 25 has a firmness (hardness) of between 10 shore A and 90 shore A (¶ [0019]).
Modified Maeicer discloses all of the claim limitations as set forth above, but the reference does not explicitly disclose the covering having a Shore A hardness of between approximately 3 and 7. As the variation of the compaction pressure (PSI) and the material quality and mechanical properties is a variable that can be modified, among others, by adjusting the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure, with said variation is decreased and material quality and mechanical properties increased as the Shore A hardness is adjusted and the applied compaction pressure is consistently corrected within the desired threshold, the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure would have been considered a result effective variable by one having ordinary skill in the art at the time the invention was made. As such, without showing unexpected results, the claimed Shore A hardness cannot be considered critical. Accordingly, one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention made would have optimized, by routine experimentation, the adjustment of the Shore A hardness of the material and the applied compaction pressure in the method of Maeicer to obtain the desired variation in compaction pressure (PSI) and material quality and mechanical properties (In re Boesch, 617 F.2d. 272, 205 USPQ 215 (CCPA 1980)), since it has been held that where the general conditions of the claim are disclosed in the prior art, discovering the optimum or workable ranges involves only routine skill in the art. (In re Aller, 105 USPQ 223).
Regarding claim 22, modified Maeicer discloses the method of Claim 1.
Maeicer discloses deformable material 20 present around the core 10 is made of a flexible and elastically deformable material, thus can be made of made of elastomeric material, in particular silicone or polyurethane, or of a foam whose Shore A hardness is 20 to 70 (¶ [0032]). Leise further discloses roller 25 has a firmness (hardness) of between 10 shore A and 90 shore A (¶ [0019]).
Modified Maeicer discloses all of the claim limitations as set forth above, but the reference does not explicitly disclose the covering comprises closed-cell foam having a Shore A hardness of between approximately 5. As the variation of the compaction pressure (PSI) and the material quality and mechanical properties is a variable that can be modified, among others, by adjusting the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure, with said variation is decreased and material quality and mechanical properties increased as the Shore A hardness is adjusted and the applied compaction pressure is consistently corrected within the desired threshold, the Shore A hardness and the applied compaction pressure would have been considered a result effective variable by one having ordinary skill in the art at the time the invention was made. As such, without showing unexpected results, the claimed Shore A hardness cannot be considered critical. Accordingly, one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the claimed invention made would have optimized, by routine experimentation, the adjustment of the Shore A hardness of the material and the applied compaction pressure in the method of Maeicer to obtain the desired variation in compaction pressure (PSI) and material quality and mechanical properties (In re Boesch, 617 F.2d. 272, 205 USPQ 215 (CCPA 1980)), since it has been held that where the general conditions of the claim are disclosed in the prior art, discovering the optimum or workable ranges involves only routine skill in the art. (In re Aller, 105 USPQ 223).
Response to Arguments
Applicant argues “the covering is selected such that a variation in the compaction pressure along the contact-interface between the roller and the ply is less than a predetermined threshold corresponding to a variation of less than approximately 5 PSI when moving the roller across the ply and accommodating for the contour of the compaction-surface” is different than Mercier’s active changing in applied force based on sensor feedback as the uniform local pressure along the contact interface is achieved passively by material selection and does not rely on changing the applied force to achieve uniformity.
Examiner respectively disagrees. The limitation does limit the applied force to be constant (not changing) and therefore Mercier’s teaching of applying the desired compaction pressure adapted to the irregularities of the surface (¶ [0054]) and adjustment of the pressure to the corrected pressure (¶ [0058-0059]) meets the claimed limitation of selecting material of the roller achieving a variation of compaction pressure of less than approximately 5 PSI.
Therefore the argument is not persuasive.
Applicant’s remaining arguments with respect to claim(s) 1 have been considered but are moot because the new ground of rejection does not rely on any reference applied in the prior rejection of record for any teaching or matter specifically challenged in the argument.
Conclusion
The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure.
US 2018/0072045 A1 discloses a method for applying a transfer ply using a pressing means with an inner hardness of 10 Shore A to 50 Shore A (¶ [0033])
US 2024/0173954 A1 discloses a method for transferring a substance pattern to a substance using a pressure roller coated with a material having a hardness of approximately 10 Shore A (¶ [0066])
Applicant's amendment necessitated the new ground(s) of rejection presented in this Office action. Accordingly, THIS ACTION IS MADE FINAL. See MPEP § 706.07(a). Applicant is reminded of the extension of time policy as set forth in 37 CFR 1.136(a).
A shortened statutory period for reply to this final action is set to expire THREE MONTHS from the mailing date of this action. In the event a first reply is filed within TWO MONTHS of the mailing date of this final action and the advisory action is not mailed until after the end of the THREE-MONTH shortened statutory period, then the shortened statutory period will expire on the date the advisory action is mailed, and any nonprovisional extension fee (37 CFR 1.17(a)) pursuant to 37 CFR 1.136(a) will be calculated from the mailing date of the advisory action. In no event, however, will the statutory period for reply expire later than SIX MONTHS from the mailing date of this final action.
Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to JONATHAN B WOO whose telephone number is (571)272-5191. The examiner can normally be reached M-F 8:30 am - 5:00 pm ET.
Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice.
If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, Susan Leong can be reached at (571) 270-1487. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300.
Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000.
/JONATHAN B WOO/Examiner, Art Unit 1754
/SEYED MASOUD MALEKZADEH/Primary Examiner, Art Unit 1754