Prosecution Insights
Last updated: November 20, 2026
Application No. 19/041,902

RAPID ROCK PETROPHYSICAL QUALITY ANALYSIS WITH ELASTOMERIC SENSOR BASED IMAGES

Non-Final OA §103
Filed
Jan 30, 2025
Examiner
SOFRONIOU, MICHAEL MARIO
Art Unit
2661
Tech Center
2600 — Communications
Assignee
Halliburton Energy Services Inc.
OA Round
1 (Non-Final)
100%
Grant Probability
Favorable
1-2
OA Rounds
7m
Est. Remaining
99%
With Interview

Examiner Intelligence

Grants 100% — above average
100%
Career Allowance Rate
5 granted / 5 resolved
+38.0% vs TC avg
Minimal +0% lift
Without
With
+0.0%
Interview Lift
resolved cases with interview
Typical timeline
2y 4m
Avg Prosecution
18 currently pending
Career history
34
Total Applications
across all art units

Statute-Specific Performance

§101
7.7%
-32.3% vs TC avg
§103
44.2%
+4.2% vs TC avg
§102
12.5%
-27.5% vs TC avg
§112
32.7%
-7.3% vs TC avg
Black line = Tech Center average estimate • Based on career data from 5 resolved cases

Office Action

§103
DETAILED ACTION Notice of Pre-AIA or AIA Status The present application, filed on or after March 16, 2013, is being examined under the first inventor to file provisions of the AIA . Information Disclosure Statement The information disclosure statement(s) (IDS) submitted on 01/30/2025 & 10/24/2025 is/are in compliance with the provisions of 37 CFR 1.97. Accordingly, the information disclosure statement is being considered by the examiner. Specification The disclosure is objected to because of the following informalities: ¶0037 of the specification recites the sentence “In instances when six images are included in a set of images of the surface of the core of the sample, each of the six images may be acquired when a different LED of the elastomeric sensing device 220.” The use of the “when” (italicized for emphasis), renders this sentence incomplete. Given the context of this sentence in reference to multiple LEDs of the elastomeric sensing device 220, the examiner believes the applicant intended to recite “…with a different LED of the elastomeric sensing device 220.” ¶0048 of the specification recites the sentence “Images 410, 420, 430, and 440 may be filtered images that were generated after applying Gaussian filters or original images 415, 425, 435, and 445.” The examiner believes applicant intended the underlined “or” was intended to recite “on”. Appropriate correction is required. Claim Rejections - 35 USC § 103 In the event the determination of the status of the application as subject to AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103 (or as subject to pre-AIA 35 U.S.C. 102 and 103) is incorrect, any correction of the statutory basis (i.e., changing from AIA to pre-AIA ) for the rejection will not be considered a new ground of rejection if the prior art relied upon, and the rationale supporting the rejection, would be the same under either status. The following is a quotation of 35 U.S.C. 103 which forms the basis for all obviousness rejections set forth in this Office action: A patent for a claimed invention may not be obtained, notwithstanding that the claimed invention is not identically disclosed as set forth in section 102, if the differences between the claimed invention and the prior art are such that the claimed invention as a whole would have been obvious before the effective filing date of the claimed invention to a person having ordinary skill in the art to which the claimed invention pertains. Patentability shall not be negated by the manner in which the invention was made. Claim(s) 1, 8, 9, 16 & 17 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Dvorkin et al (US 2010/0128932 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Dvorkin”, in view of Adelson et al (US 2013/0033595 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Adelson”. Regarding claim 1, Dvorkin teach A method (methods for image segmentation [¶0037; Fig. 2] and analysis [¶0039-44; Fig. 3]) comprising: accessing image data of a surface of a sample that includes pore spaces and portions of rock matrix (at step 40, a 2D CT scan image frame is selected [¶0037; Fig. 2], this 2D image frame being from a wellbore core comprising void spaces (pore spaces) and rock grains (rock matrix) [¶0021-23]), applying one or more segmentation techniques on the image data (a region growing segmentation method is applied to the 2D image frame to classify pixels as either pore spaces or rock matrix [¶0023-24, 37]); transforming the image data into a binary image that separates the pore spaces from the portions of the rock matrix based on at least one segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques (thresholding is applied to bin pixel values below a certain threshold value as grains (i.e., rock matrix) while all other values are identified as pore spaces, resulting in a binary index image [¶0023-24; 37; Fig. 2]); and identifying one or more petrophysical properties of the sample based on the binary image that separates the pore spaces from the portions of the rock matrix (the calculated porosity of the sample (obtained from the binary index image) can be used to obtain petrophysical parameters such as permeability (step 78), resistivity (step 80), and bulk, elastic, and/or shear module (step 82) [¶0044; Fig. 3]). Dvorkin, however, utilizes CT images to segment pore and rock matrix, as opposed to images obtained by an elastomeric sensing device. Adelson, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the field of endeavor of the present application and disclose a retrographic sensor for high-resolution surface imaging. Adelson teach wherein the image data is associated with data acquired by an elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) capable of transmitting an image [¶0065; Fig. 2], this sensor enables the visualization of the surface topography of a specimen in contact with the reflective membrane [¶0079]); based on the image data being associated with the data acquired by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) capable of transmitting an image [¶0065; Fig. 2], with examples of images obtained by the retrographic sensor illustrated in Figs. 3-5, 10-13, 15-19). Adelson explain that their device fills a niche in providing an inexpensive and facile method for obtaining detailed measurements of surface topology [¶0007], which has uses in industrial surface inspection to quantify roughness or the presence of cracks, pits, and gouges [¶0004]. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present application to utilize the retrographic sensor disclosed by Adelson to image wellbore core samples. This would enable accurate measurement of pore sizes and distributions to better inform the segmentation described by Dvorkin to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Turning to claim 8, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The method of claim 1 (as described above), further comprising: comparing image data associated with the one or more segmentation techniques to data indicative of at least one of depth or location of the pore spaces of the surface of the sample (Dvorkin: during region growing segmentation, initial thresholds t1 and t2 are used to initialize clusters or "seeds" (which convey location information within the image) corresponding to pore spaces and rock grains , respectively [¶0029 & 37; steps 44 & 46 of Fig. 2]); and identifying that image data associated with a first segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques corresponds to a threshold of a segmentation rule (Dvorkin: pixels adjacent to clusters are interrogated during the region growing step, and is later allocated to a cluster if it is within a certain tolerance (i.e., a certain threshold for region growing segmentation), and this process is repeated until all pixels are allocated [¶0033-35, 37; steps 48-54 of Fig. 2]), wherein the image data is transformed into the binary image based on the image data being associated with the identification that the first segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques corresponds to the threshold of the segmentation rule (Dvorkin: all pixels are allocated to clusters of pores or rock matrix in a binary index based on the region growing segmentation [¶0023-24; Fig. 2]). As for claim 9, Dvorkin teach A non-transitory computer-related storage medium having embodied thereon instructions (computer 32, which one of ordinary skill would recognize would include at least one memory, contains program instructions to perform image analysis [¶0020; Fig. 1]) that when executed by one or more processors (computer 32, which one of ordinary skill would recognize would include at least one processor [¶0020; Fig. 1]) cause the one or more processors to: access image data of a surface of a sample that includes pore spaces and portions of rock matrix (at step 40, a 2D CT scan image frame is selected [¶0037; Fig. 2], this 2D image frame being from a wellbore core comprising void spaces (pore spaces) and rock grains (rock matrix) [¶0021-23]), apply one or more segmentation techniques on the image data (a region growing segmentation method is applied to the 2D image frame to classify pixels as either pore spaces or rock matrix [¶0023-24, 37]); transform the image data into a binary image that separates the pore spaces from the portions of the rock matrix based on at least one segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques (thresholding is applied to bin pixel values below a certain threshold value as grains (i.e., rock matrix) while all other values are identified as pore spaces, resulting in a binary index image [¶0023-24; 37; Fig. 2]); and identify one or more petrophysical properties of the sample based on the binary image that separates the pore spaces from the portions of the rock matrix (the calculated porosity of the sample (obtained from the binary index image) can be used to obtain petrophysical parameters such as permeability (step 78), resistivity (step 80), and bulk, elastic, and/or shear module (step 82) [¶0044; Fig. 3]). Dvorkin, however, utilizes CT images to segment pore and rock matrix, as opposed to images obtained by an elastomeric sensing device. Adelson, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the field of endeavor of the present application and disclose a retrographic sensor for high-resolution surface imaging. Adelson teach wherein the image data is associated with data acquired by an elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) capable of transmitting an image [¶0065; Fig. 2], this sensor enables the visualization of the surface topography of a specimen in contact with the reflective membrane [¶0079]); based on the image data being associated with the data acquired by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) capable of transmitting an image [¶0065; Fig. 2], with examples of images obtained by the retrographic sensor illustrated in Figs. 3-5, 10-13, 15-19). Adelson explain that their device fills a niche in providing an inexpensive and facile method for obtaining detailed measurements of surface topology [¶0007], which has uses in industrial surface inspection to quantify roughness or the presence of cracks, pits, and gouges [¶0004]. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present application to utilize the retrographic sensor disclosed by Adelson to image wellbore core samples. This would enable accurate measurement of pore sizes and distributions to better inform the segmentation described by Dvorkin to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Concerning claim 16, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The non-transitory computer-related storage medium of claim 9 (outlined above), wherein the one or more processors execute the instructions to: compare image data associated with the one or more segmentation techniques to data indicative of at least one of depth or location of the pore spaces of the surface of the sample (Dvorkin: during region growing segmentation, initial thresholds t1 and t2 are used to initialize clusters or "seeds" (which convey location information within the image) corresponding to pore spaces and rock grains , respectively [¶0029 & 37; steps 44 & 46 of Fig. 2]); and identify that image data associated with a first segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques corresponds to a threshold of a segmentation rule (Dvorkin: pixels adjacent to clusters are interrogated during the region growing step, and is later allocated to a cluster if it is within a certain tolerance (i.e., a certain threshold for region growing segmentation), and this process is repeated until all pixels are allocated [¶0033-35, 37; steps 48-54 of Fig. 2]), wherein the image data is transformed into the binary image based on the image data being associated with the identification that the first segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques corresponds to the threshold of the segmentation rule (Dvorkin: all pixels are allocated to clusters of pores or rock matrix in a binary index based on the region growing segmentation [¶0023-24; Fig. 2]). Regarding claim 17, Dvorkin teach A system comprising: a memory; and one or more processors that execute instructions out of the memory (computer 32, which one of ordinary skill would recognize would include at least one processor and memory, contains program instructions to perform image analysis [¶0020; Fig. 1]) to: access image data of a surface of a sample that includes pore spaces and portions of rock matrix (at step 40, a 2D CT scan image frame is selected [¶0037; Fig. 2], this 2D image frame being from a wellbore core comprising void spaces (pore spaces) and rock grains (rock matrix) [¶0021-23]), apply one or more segmentation techniques on the image data (a region growing segmentation method is applied to the 2D image frame to classify pixels as either pore spaces or rock matrix [¶0023-24, 37]); transform the image data into a binary image that separates the pore spaces from the portions of the rock matrix based on at least one segmentation technique of the one or more segmentation techniques (thresholding is applied to bin pixel values below a certain threshold value as grains (i.e., rock matrix) while all other values are identified as pore spaces, resulting in a binary index image [¶0023-24; 37; Fig. 2]); and identify one or more petrophysical properties of the sample based on the binary image that separates the pore spaces from the portions of the rock matrix (the calculated porosity of the sample (obtained from the binary index image) can be used to obtain petrophysical parameters such as permeability (step 78), resistivity (step 80), and bulk, elastic, and/or shear module (step 82) [¶0044; Fig. 3]). Dvorkin, however, utilizes CT images to segment pore and rock matrix, as opposed to images obtained by an elastomeric sensing device. Adelson, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the field of endeavor of the present application and disclose a retrographic sensor for high-resolution surface imaging. Adelson teach an elastomeric sensing apparatus (Adelson: a retrographic sensor comprising a clear elastomeric surface (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device, configured as either a bench-based [Fig. 7] or portable [Fig. 8] apparatus [¶0065; 0107-112]); wherein the image data is associated with data acquired by an elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) capable of transmitting an image [¶0065; Fig. 2], this sensor enables the visualization of the surface topography of a specimen in contact with the reflective membrane [¶0079]); based on the image data being associated with the data acquired by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) capable of transmitting an image [¶0065; Fig. 2], with examples of images obtained by the retrographic sensor illustrated in Figs. 3-5, 10-13, 15-19). Adelson explain that their device fills a niche in providing an inexpensive and facile method for obtaining detailed measurements of surface topology [¶0007], which has uses in industrial surface inspection to quantify roughness or the presence of cracks, pits, and gouges [¶0004]. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present application to utilize the retrographic sensor disclosed by Adelson to image wellbore core samples. This would enable accurate measurement of pore sizes and distributions to better inform the segmentation described by Dvorkin to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Claim(s) 2, 3, 10, 11, 18 & 19 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Dvorkin et al (US 2010/0128932 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Dvorkin”, in view of Adelson et al (US 2013/0033595 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Adelson”, further in view of Ng et al (US 9001226 B1), hereinafter referred to as “Ng”. With respect to claim 2, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The method of claim 1 (described above), further comprising: receiving data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device, wherein the sensed data includes a plurality of images of the surface of the sample and each image of the plurality of images includes light effects associated with illumination provided by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]); light effects associated with the illumination provided by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]). Dvorkin, nor Adelson describe a process for filtering the data for reducing lighting effects as a result of the illumination. Ng, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the realm of endeavor of the present application and describe a process for obtaining a plurality of images under different lighting conditions and filtering and combining them to generate a relighted image. Ng teach applying a filter function on the data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device to reduce the light effects associated with the illumination (Ng: a low-pass filter is applied to minimize variations in image brightness [col. 30, ln. 47-57; Figs. 10A-E]); and generating a combined image based on the application of the filter function that reduces the light effects associated with the illumination (Ng: relighted images (i.e., combined images) are generated by assembling various portions of captured images with different lighting conditions [col. 21, ln. 29-47] exemplified by Figs. 10A-E showing examples of relighted images with sufficient filtering [col. 30, ln. 47-57]). Ng emphasize the flexibility of their invention, being able to be implemented across a variety of contexts for subjects of varying scales and surfaces with different reflectance properties [col. 31, ln. 21-29], and that the generation of a combined image with various filters applied enables a user to sharpen or flatten the resultant image [col. 1-2, ln. 57-67, 1-4]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize the advantage of implementing Ng's filtering to generate a relighted image with the imaging system of Dvorkin in view of Adelson to account for differences in illumination conditions to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Concerning claim 3, Dvorkin in view of Adelson, further in view of Ng teach The method of claim 2 (described above), wherein the illumination of each respective image of the plurality of images is provided at a different angle relative to a reference orientation of the sample (Adelson: illumination can be provided at various angles to achieve a grazing angle, with Fig. 2B and 2C showing illumination angles either incident with or parallel to the surface [¶0083; Fig. 2]). Adelson explain that their device fills a niche in providing an inexpensive and facile method for obtaining detailed measurements of surface topology [¶0007], which has uses in industrial surface inspection to quantify roughness or the presence of cracks, pits, and gouges [¶0004]. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present application to utilize the retrographic sensor disclosed by Adelson to image wellbore core samples at varying angles of illumination. This would enable accurate measurement of pore sizes and distributions to better inform the segmentation described by Dvorkin to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Considering claim 10, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The non-transitory computer-related storage medium of claim 9 (described previously), wherein the one or more processors execute the instructions to: receive data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device, wherein the sensed data includes a plurality of images of the surface of the sample and each image of the plurality of images includes light effects associated with illumination provided by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]); light effects associated with the illumination provided by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]). Dvorkin, nor Adelson describe a process for filtering the data for reducing lighting effects as a result of the illumination. Ng, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the realm of endeavor of the present application and describe a process for obtaining a plurality of images under different lighting conditions and filtering and combining them to generate a relighted image. Ng teach apply a filter function on the data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device to reduce the light effects associated with the illumination (Ng: a low-pass filter is applied to minimize variations in image brightness [col. 30, ln. 47-57; Figs. 10A-E]); and generate a combined image based on the application of the filter function that reduces the light effects associated with the illumination (Ng: relighted images (i.e., combined images) are generated by assembling various portions of captured images with different lighting conditions [col. 21, ln. 29-47] exemplified by Figs. 10A-E showing examples of relighted images with sufficient filtering [col. 30, ln. 47-57]). Ng emphasize the flexibility of their invention, being able to be implemented across a variety of contexts for subjects of varying scales and surfaces with different reflectance properties [col. 31, ln. 21-29], and that the generation of a combined image with various filters applied enables a user to sharpen or flatten the resultant image [col. 1-2, ln. 57-67, 1-4]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize the advantage of implementing Ng's filtering to generate a relighted image with the imaging system of Dvorkin in view of Adelson to account for differences in illumination conditions to arrive at the invention of the instant application. With respect to claim 11, Dvorkin in view of Adelson, further in view of Ng teach The non-transitory computer-related storage medium of claim 10 (described above), wherein the illumination of each respective image of the plurality of images is provided at a different angle relative to a reference orientation of the sample (Adelson: illumination can be provided at various angles to achieve a grazing angle, with Fig. 2B and 2C showing illumination angles either incident with or parallel to the surface [¶0083; Fig. 2]). Adelson explain that their device fills a niche in providing an inexpensive and facile method for obtaining detailed measurements of surface topology [¶0007], which has uses in industrial surface inspection to quantify roughness or the presence of cracks, pits, and gouges [¶0004]. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present application to utilize the retrographic sensor disclosed by Adelson to image wellbore core samples at varying angles of illumination. This would enable accurate measurement of pore sizes and distributions to better inform the segmentation described by Dvorkin to arrive at the invention of the instant application. As for claim 18, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The system of claim 17 (as previously described), wherein the one or more processors execute the instructions to: receive data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device, wherein the sensed data includes a plurality of images of the surface of the sample and each image of the plurality of images includes light effects associated with illumination provided by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]); light effects associated with the illumination provided by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]). Dvorkin, nor Adelson describe a process for filtering the data for reducing lighting effects as a result of the illumination. Ng, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the realm of endeavor of the present application and describe a process for obtaining a plurality of images under different lighting conditions and filtering and combining them to generate a relighted image. Ng teach apply a filter function on the data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device to reduce the light effects associated with the illumination (Ng: a low-pass filter is applied to minimize variations in image brightness [col. 30, ln. 47-57; Figs. 10A-E]); and generate a combined image based on the application of the filter function that reduces the light effects associated with the illumination (Ng: relighted images (i.e., combined images) are generated by assembling various portions of captured images with different lighting conditions [col. 21, ln. 29-47] exemplified by Figs. 10A-E showing examples of relighted images with sufficient filtering [col. 30, ln. 47-57]). Ng emphasize the flexibility of their invention, being able to be implemented across a variety of contexts for subjects of varying scales and surfaces with different reflectance properties [col. 31, ln. 21-29], and that the generation of a combined image with various filters applied enables a user to sharpen or flatten the resultant image [col. 1-2, ln. 57-67, 1-4]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize the advantage of implementing Ng's filtering to generate a relighted image with the imaging system of Dvorkin in view of Adelson to account for differences in illumination conditions to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Regarding claim 19, Dvorkin in view of Adelson, further in view of Ng The system of claim 18 (outlined above), wherein the illumination of each respective image of the plurality of images is provided at a different angle relative to a reference orientation of the sample (Adelson: illumination can be provided at various angles to achieve a grazing angle, with Fig. 2B and 2C showing illumination angles either incident with or parallel to the surface [¶0083; Fig. 2]). Adelson explain that their device fills a niche in providing an inexpensive and facile method for obtaining detailed measurements of surface topology [¶0007], which has uses in industrial surface inspection to quantify roughness or the presence of cracks, pits, and gouges [¶0004]. It would have been obvious to one of ordinary skill in the art before the effective filing date of the present application to utilize the retrographic sensor disclosed by Adelson to image wellbore core samples at varying angles of illumination. This would enable accurate measurement of pore sizes and distributions to better inform the segmentation described by Dvorkin to arrive at the invention of the instant application. Claim(s) 6, 7, 14 & 15 is/are rejected under 35 U.S.C. 103 as being unpatentable over Dvorkin et al (US 2010/0128932 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Dvorkin”, in view of Adelson et al (US 2013/0033595 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Adelson”, further in Su et al (US 2021/0407062 A1), hereinafter referred to as “Su”. Considering claim 6, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The method of claim 1 (as described previously), further comprising: receiving data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device, wherein the sensed data includes a plurality of images of the surface of the sample (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]); and from the data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) can transmit an image [¶0065; Fig. 2]). Adelson, however, fails to disclose generating a combined image. Su, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the field of endeavor of the present application and describe a process for detecting image features (particularly product defects) by generating a multi-channel image. More particularly, Su teach generating one or more combined images (Su: multiple images or video of a product under different types of lighting conditions at different angles are acquired, and provided to an image merging module to merge the images or frames of a video to acquire a multi-channel image of the target product [¶0077-78; Figs. 3 & 4]). Su explain that their invention leverages information acquired across the plurality of image channels, as well as the correlation between image channels to improve overall defect detection accuracy [¶0049]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize that, instead of utilizing these multi-channel images for defect detection, they can instead be applied to pore detection as taught by Dvorkin in view of Adelson to leverage features from both surface and depth images for accurate pore detection. As for claim 7, Dvorkin in view of Adelson, further in view of Su teach The method of claim 6 (described above), wherein the one or more combined images includes a depth image and an image of the surface of the sample (Su: five images of the target are collected (construed as a "image of the surface of the sample" as any image of an object would convey the surface), as well a 3D information of the target conveying surface depth for a pixel in an image (i.e., a depth image) to obtain a 6-channel (i.e., combined) image [¶0069]). Su explain that their invention leverages information acquired across the plurality of image channels, as well as the correlation between image channels to improve overall defect detection accuracy [0049]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize that, instead of utilizing these multi-channel images for defect detection, they can instead be applied to pore detection as taught by Dvorkin in view of Adelson to leverage features from both surface and depth images for accurate pore detection. Turning to claim 14, Dvorkin in view of Adelson teach The non-transitory computer-related storage medium of claim 9 (described previously), wherein the one or more processors execute the instructions to: receive data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device, wherein the sensed data includes a plurality of images of the surface of the sample (Adelson: Figs 3B and 3C illustrate surface images of individual balls of a ball grid obtained by a retrographic sensor, wherein speckling (a type of light effect) can be reduced by changing the illumination pattern [¶0085]); and from the data sensed by the elastomeric sensing device (Adelson: the retrographic sensor comprises a clear elastomer (i.e., an elastomeric sensing device) can transmit an image [¶0065; Fig. 2]). Adelson, however, fails to disclose generating a combined image. Su, on the other hand, is analogous art pertinent to the field of endeavor of the present application and describe a process for detecting image features (particularly product defects) by generating a multi-channel image. More particularly, Su teach generate one or more combined images (Su: multiple images or video of a product under different types of lighting conditions at different angles are acquired, and provided to an image merging module to merge the images or frames of a video to acquire a multi-channel image of the target product [¶0077-78; Figs. 3 & 4]). Su explain that their invention leverages information acquired across the plurality of image channels, as well as the correlation between image channels to improve overall defect detection accuracy [¶0049]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize that, instead of utilizing these multi-channel images for defect detection, they can instead be applied to pore detection as taught by Dvorkin in view of Adelson to leverage features from both surface and depth images for accurate pore detection. Concerning claim 15, Dvorkin in view of Adelson, further in view of Su teach The non-transitory computer-related storage medium of claim 14 (described above), wherein the one or more combined images includes a depth image and an image of the surface of the sample (Su: five images of the target are collected (construed as a "image of the surface of the sample" as any image of an object would convey the surface), as well a 3D information of the target conveying surface depth for a pixel in an image (i.e., a depth image) to obtain a 6-channel (i.e., combined) image [¶0069]). Su explain that their invention leverages information acquired across the plurality of image channels, as well as the correlation between image channels to improve overall defect detection accuracy [0049]. One of ordinary skill in the art would recognize that, instead of utilizing these multi-channel images for defect detection, they can instead be applied to pore detection as taught by Dvorkin in view of Adelson to leverage features from both surface and depth images for accurate pore detection. Allowable Subject Matter Claims 4-5, 12-13 & 20 objected to as being dependent upon a rejected base claim, but would be allowable if rewritten in independent form including all of the limitations of the base claim and any intervening claims. Regarding claim 4, the primary reason for indication of allowable subject matter is that the prior art neither teach nor fail to suggest a process of repeatedly applying a filtering function with different values of a variable to result in a level of blur in a combined image corresponding to a filtration rule. The closest cited prior art, Ng, relied upon for teaching the application of a filtering function to reduce lighting effects and to generate a combined image, fails to disclose performing a parameter sweep of their low-pass filter to achieve a desired level of blurring. The closest art of record, Chen et al (“An Empirical Identification Method of Gaussian Blur Parameter for Image Deblurring”, 2009, IEEE) detail performing a parameter sweep to achieve an optimal blur parameter sigma, however this is only applied to a singular image, and fails to generate a combined image based on their filtering for blur removal. The same analysis outlined above can be applied to claims 12 & 20, which recite substantially identical subject matter. Claims 5 & 13 would be allowable by virtue of their dependence on claims 4 & 12, respectively, which were indicated to contain allowable subject matter. Conclusion The prior art made of record and not relied upon is considered pertinent to applicant's disclosure: Hurley et al (US 2012/0275658 A1) describe a method for analyzing petrographic images to segment images into grains and pores to determine capillary pressure Zhao et al (US 2020/0005013 A1) provide a workflow for obtaining parameters of a rock texture via clustering and watershedding to locate pore and grain sizes and distributions. Yang et al (US 2026/0044654 A1) outline a method for scanning wellbore cores via CT to generate a binary representation to simulate the pore network. Koroteev et al (US 2015/0262417 A1) provide a method for reconstructing a 3D model of a rock sample via X-ray/CT image data to resolve sample porosity. Zhang et al (“An innovative image-based workflow for quantitative pore structure characterization in reservoir rocks”, 2021, Journal of Petroleum Science and Engineering) provide a detailed method for resolving connectivity of pores in rock matrix. Han et al (“Automatic Illumination and Color Compensation Using Mean Shift and Sigma Filter”, 2009, IEEE) describe a process for correcting lighting effects using gaussian filtering. Any inquiry concerning this communication or earlier communications from the examiner should be directed to Michael M. Sofroniou whose telephone number is (571)272-0287. The examiner can normally be reached M-F: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM. Examiner interviews are available via telephone, in-person, and video conferencing using a USPTO supplied web-based collaboration tool. To schedule an interview, applicant is encouraged to use the USPTO Automated Interview Request (AIR) at http://www.uspto.gov/interviewpractice. If attempts to reach the examiner by telephone are unsuccessful, the examiner’s supervisor, John M. Villecco can be reached at (571) 272-7319. The fax phone number for the organization where this application or proceeding is assigned is 571-273-8300. Information regarding the status of published or unpublished applications may be obtained from Patent Center. Unpublished application information in Patent Center is available to registered users. To file and manage patent submissions in Patent Center, visit: https://patentcenter.uspto.gov. Visit https://www.uspto.gov/patents/apply/patent-center for more information about Patent Center and https://www.uspto.gov/patents/docx for information about filing in DOCX format. For additional questions, contact the Electronic Business Center (EBC) at 866-217-9197 (toll-free). If you would like assistance from a USPTO Customer Service Representative, call 800-786-9199 (IN USA OR CANADA) or 571-272-1000. /MICHAEL M SOFRONIOU/Examiner, Art Unit 2661 /JOHN VILLECCO/Supervisory Patent Examiner, Art Unit 2661
Read full office action

Prosecution Timeline

Jan 30, 2025
Application Filed
Sep 16, 2026
Non-Final Rejection mailed — §103
Oct 26, 2026
Applicant Interview (Telephonic)
Oct 26, 2026
Examiner Interview Summary

Precedent Cases

Applications granted by this same examiner with similar technology

Patent 12784246
INFORMATION PROCESSING APPARATUS, GENERATION METHOD, AND COMPUTER PROGRAM PRODUCT
2y 6m to grant Granted Nov 03, 2026
Patent 12711652
IMAGE PROCESSING APPARATUS, IMAGE PICKUP APPARATUS, CONTROL METHOD FOR IMAGE PROCESSING APPARATUS, AND STORAGE MEDIUM CAPABLE OF NOTIFYING USER OF BLUR INFORMATION, OR OF DISPLAYING INDICATOR
2y 8m to grant Granted Aug 18, 2026
Study what changed to get past this examiner. Based on 2 most recent grants.

Strategy Recommendation AI-generated — please review before filing

Get a prosecution strategy drawn from examiner precedents, rejection analysis, and claim mapping.
Typically takes 5-10 seconds — AI-generated, attorney review required before filing

Prosecution Projections

1-2
Expected OA Rounds
100%
Grant Probability
99%
With Interview (+0.0%)
2y 4m (~7m remaining)
Median Time to Grant
Low
PTA Risk
Based on 5 resolved cases by this examiner. Grant probability derived from career allowance rate.

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month