Prosecution Insights
Last updated: April 19, 2026

Examiner: EL-BATHY, IBRAHIM N

Tech Center 3600 • Art Units: 3628

This examiner grants 51% of resolved cases

Performance Statistics

51.3%
Allow Rate
-0.7% vs TC avg
324
Total Applications
+50.5%
Interview Lift
1179
Avg Prosecution Days
Based on 269 resolved cases, 2023–2026

Rejection Statute Breakdown

43.2%
§101 Eligibility
8.3%
§102 Novelty
37.2%
§103 Obviousness
8.6%
§112 Clarity

Currently Pending Office Actions

App #TitleStatusAssignee
18682480 CROP GROWTH ASSISTANCE APPARATUS, CROP GROWTH ASSISTANCE METHOD, AND RECORDING MEDIUM Final Rejection NEC Corporation
18566791 PROCESSING APPARATUS, PROCESSING METHOD, AND NON-TRANSITORY STORAGE MEDIUM Final Rejection NEC Corporation
18640368 INTEGRATED LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT SYSTEM AND INTEGRATED LOGISTICS MANAGEMENT METHOD Non-Final OA Samsung Display Co., Ltd.
19039441 Controlling Interactions Between Networked Devices in a Networked System Final Rejection Navan, Inc.
18744198 CONTROL SYSTEM FOR RAILWAY YARD AND RELATED METHODS Non-Final OA All Terminal Services, LLC (d/b/a ConGlobal Technologies)
18519983 METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT RECOMMENDATIONS Final Rejection STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE COMPANY
18709184 POST-SERVICE STATE VALIDATOR FOR MEDICAL DEVICES Final Rejection KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS N.V.
18723842 CONVEYING ITEMS USING A DISTRIBUTED MULTI-AGENT ALLOCAITON METHOD Final Rejection B.G. Negev Technologies and Applications Ltd.
19114423 METHOD OF PROVIDING PRODUCT PRICE PREDICTION SERVICE AND SERVER FOR PERFORMING SAME Non-Final OA NATURE MOBILITY CO., LTD.
19075952 SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR PROVIDING FREIGHT VISIBILITY Final Rejection MOTIVE TECHNOLOGIES, INC.
18557967 HIGH-LEVEL SENSOR FUSION AND MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION MAKING FOR AUTONOMOUS BIN PICKING Non-Final OA Siemens Corporation
18932230 AUTOMATICALLY MODULATING POWER USAGE OF A FACILITY TO REDUCE UTILITY DEMAND CHARGES Final Rejection Honeywell International Inc.
19029677 Real-Time, Current Utility Consumption Change Effects Isolation System Non-Final OA Mountain Vector Energy, LLC
18532787 SMART WAFER TRANSPORT CASE WITH SENSOR SYSTEM Non-Final OA Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Co., Ltd.
18643887 Utilizing Local Workgroups in a Stretched Environment Non-Final OA Dell Products L.P.
18990651 ARTICLE TRACKING SYSTEM AND METHOD Final Rejection SITA Information Networking Computing USA, Inc.
18977930 AGGREGATION AND TRANSFER OF PROPERTY DATA Final Rejection Invisible Holdings LLC
18934828 Pickup Automation System and Related Method for Orders and/or Merchandise Pickup Using Smart Locks Final Rejection QR Automation Technologies, Inc.
18935037 SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR TRACKING SHIPPING CONTAINERS Final Rejection World Commodity Freight Limited Liability Company
18566875 SERVICE VEHICLE UNIT Non-Final OA Autostore Technology AS
18906998 AUTHENTICATION KIT Final Rejection HANGING WITH THE TEAM, LLC
18754665 CARGO CARRIER SERVICING PLATFORM Non-Final OA PLM Fleet LLC
18620305 Compliance Management System And Method Using A No-Code Approach Non-Final OA LiveApplication, Inc.
18243209 MULTI-AGENT GENERATIVE AI SYSTEMS Final Rejection THE BOSTON CONSULTING GROUP, INC.
18596170 TECHNIQUES FOR REAL-TIME RESPONSE STRATEGIES IN A SUPPLY CHAIN Non-Final OA Cognosos, Inc.
18566529 Storage Systems And Pick And Place Robots Non-Final OA Nimble Robotics, Inc.
18551992 AUTOMATED GARMENT STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM Non-Final OA PLANIFORM CONVEYORS INC.
18282614 ELECTRONIC SYSTEM FOR MONITORING AND AUTOMATICALLY CONTROLLING CARGO TRANSPORTATION Final Rejection BLUME GLOBAL, INC.
17499730 SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR CONTINUOUS MODEL-BASED COST ESTIMATING Non-Final OA ACTIVE ESTIMATING INC.

Facing This Examiner?

IP Author analyzes examiner patterns and generates tailored response strategies with the highest chance of allowance.

Build Your Strategy

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month