Prosecution Insights
Last updated: July 17, 2026

Macmillan, Sobanski And Todd, LLC - First Solar

11 pending office actions • 2 clients • 7 examiners • 5 art units • 0 of 11 (0%) have an AI response strategy ready • 13 patents granted in the last 365 days

Quality Metrics (n=355 apps, methodology: how we score firms)

94.8%
Allowance Rate
n=355
+1.35σ
Allowance Rate (norm)
n=355
4.7
OAs to Allowance
n=255
+0.04σ
OAs to Allow (norm)
n=255
1101 days
Time to Allowance
n=255
-2.0pp
Interview Lift
n=355
33.1%
RCE Rate
n=355
5.2%
Appeal Rate
n=355

Rejection Performance (% of received rejections ultimately overcome)

§101 Overcome
n=2 (min 20)
90.9%
§102 Overcome
n=22
90.8%
§103 Overcome
n=217
96.0%
§112 Overcome
n=25

Specialization & Scale

H10F, Y02E, Y02P
Top CPC Subclasses
63%
Top-3 CPC Share
n=355
0
Practitioners
n=355
Apps / Practitioner
n=355 (min 20)

Portfolio Summary

11
Total Pending OAs
8
Non-Final OAs
3
Final Rejections
0
Advisory / Quayle

Response Deadline Pressure

Based on the USPTO statutory response window for each pending office action. 6 of the docket's apps have a known mailing date; the rest are excluded from the tile counts.

1
Overdue
0
Due this week
2
Due this month
2
Due in next 60 days
1
Due later

Deadline Fire Line

Every pending office action with a known statutory deadline, placed on a days-until-due axis. Dots left of Today are overdue; the further right, the more runway. Cases that share a deadline window stack vertically. 6 of the docket's apps have a known mailing date.

-30dToday30d60d90d120d
Overdue (1)Due ≤ 30 days (2)Due ≤ 60 days (2)Due later (1)

Case Difficulty Mix

Difficulty is derived from the rejection statutes on the most recent pending office action. §101-driven and multi-statute cases are graded Hard; §112-only and obviousness-type double-patenting cases are graded Easy; everything else is Medium. "Unknown" means we have not yet parsed a statute for that office action.

0
Hard (0%)
10
Medium (91%)
0
Easy (0%)
1
Unknown (9%)

Rejection Statute Mix

BucketCases
§103 only8 (73%)
§102 only1 (9%)
Double-patenting + other1 (9%)
No statute on record1 (9%)

Industry Mix

How the docket's pending cases split across USPTO tech-center bands.

11
Life Sciences
100% of docket
0
Information Tech
0% of docket
0
Communications
0% of docket
0
Semiconductors
0% of docket
0
Mechanical / Eng
0% of docket
0
Business / Other
0% of docket

Time-on-OA Estimate

Manual office-action response work runs about 10 hours per case. The time-saved bands below show what IP Author's prosecution pipeline typically delivers — a conservative 20% on the low end, 35% in the middle, 50% on the high end.

110 h
Manual time on pending OAs
22 h
Time saved (low, 20%)
38 h
Time saved (mid, 35%)
1.0 wks
FTE-weeks freed (mid)

Top Examiners on this docket

ExaminerApps on this docketAllow rateInterview lift
MOWLA, GOLAM 4 61.5% +28.8%
DINH, BACH T 2 55.2% +31.6%
KANG, TAE-SIK 1 58.0% +28.1%
TRIVISONNO, ANGELO 1 53.0% +26.6%
LAW, NGA LEUNG V 1 56.5% +20.4%
MALLEY JR., DANIEL PATRICK 1 57.0% +45.5%
WHITE, SADIE 1 49.0% +31.8%

Interview Candidates (11)

Cases in front of an examiner whose interview lift is 10 percentage points or more — i.e. interviewed cases historically resolve more favorably than non-interviewed ones. The top 8 ordered by deadline are shown.

App #TitleExaminerDue in
19030859 PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICE WITH TRANSPARENT TUNNEL JUNCTION DINH, BACH T 26d overdue
19076623 Transparent Conducting Layers and Photovoltaic Devices Including the Same MOWLA, GOLAM 15d
19023272 PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICES AND METHOD OF MAKING KANG, TAE-SIK 16d
18277153 Materials and Methods for Hole Transport Layers in Perovskite Photovoltaic Devices MALLEY JR., DANIEL PATRICK 42d
19023233 Photovoltaic Devices and Method of Making MOWLA, GOLAM 56d
19006785 Photovoltaic Devices Including An Interfacial Layer MOWLA, GOLAM 70d
19239412 Photovoltaic Devices with Textured TCO Layers, and Methods of Making TCO Stacks MOWLA, GOLAM
18828147 PHOTOVOLTAIC TOP MODULE DINH, BACH T

Client Portfolio (2 clients)

Client (Assignee)Pending OAs
First Solar 10
ALLIANCE FOR SUSTAINABLE ENERGY, LLC 1

Top Art Units

Art UnitApps
17215
17263
17281
17221
17171

Pending Office Actions

App #TitleClientExaminerArt UnitStatutesStatusDue inAIFiled
19239412 Photovoltaic Devices with Textured TCO Layers, and Methods of Making TCO Stacks First Solar, Inc. MOWLA, GOLAM 1721 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Jun 16, 2025
19076623 Transparent Conducting Layers and Photovoltaic Devices Including the Same First Solar, Inc. MOWLA, GOLAM 1721 Other Non-Final OA 15d Pending Mar 11, 2025
19030859 PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICE WITH TRANSPARENT TUNNEL JUNCTION First Solar, Inc. DINH, BACH T 1726 §103 Non-Final OA 26d overdue Pending Jan 17, 2025
19023233 Photovoltaic Devices and Method of Making First Solar, Inc. MOWLA, GOLAM 1721 §103 Non-Final OA 56d Pending Jan 15, 2025
19023272 PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICES AND METHOD OF MAKING First Solar, Inc. KANG, TAE-SIK 1728 §102 Non-Final OA 16d Pending Jan 15, 2025
19006785 Photovoltaic Devices Including An Interfacial Layer First Solar, Inc. MOWLA, GOLAM 1721 DPOther Non-Final OA 70d Pending Dec 31, 2024
18828147 PHOTOVOLTAIC TOP MODULE First Solar, Inc. DINH, BACH T 1726 §103 Final Rejection Pending Sep 09, 2024
18841928 PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICES AND METHODS OF MAKING First Solar, Inc. TRIVISONNO, ANGELO 1722 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Aug 27, 2024
18628285 SYSTEMS AND METHODS FOR VAPORIZATION AND VAPOR DISTRIBUTION First Solar, Inc. LAW, NGA LEUNG V 1717 §103 Final Rejection Pending Apr 05, 2024
18277153 Materials and Methods for Hole Transport Layers in Perovskite Photovoltaic Devices Alliance for Sustainable Energy, LLC MALLEY JR., DANIEL PATRICK 1726 §103 Final Rejection 42d Pending Aug 14, 2023
18035026 PHOTOVOLTAIC DEVICES WITH CONDUCTING LAYER INTERCONNECTS First Solar, Inc. WHITE, SADIE 1721 §103 Non-Final OA Pending May 02, 2023

Managing Macmillan, Sobanski And Todd, LLC - First Solar's Patent Prosecution?

IP Author helps law firms respond to office actions faster with AI-generated responses, examiner analytics, and prosecution intelligence.

Start Free Trial

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month