Prosecution Insights
Last updated: August 06, 2026

Intellectual Valley Law, P.C.

28 pending office actions • 5 clients • 27 examiners • 15 art units • 0 of 28 (0%) have an AI response strategy ready

Quality Metrics (n=1055 apps, methodology: how we score firms)

96.4%
Allowance Rate
n=1055
+0.59σ
Allowance Rate (norm)
n=1055
2.2
OAs to Allowance
n=825
-0.64σ
OAs to Allow (norm)
n=825
867 days
Time to Allowance
n=825
+3.5pp
Interview Lift
n=1055
12.2%
RCE Rate
n=1055
0.2%
Appeal Rate
n=1055

Rejection Performance (% of received rejections ultimately overcome)

63.2%
§101 Overcome
n=38
88.1%
§102 Overcome
n=437
88.0%
§103 Overcome
n=591
86.8%
§112 Overcome
n=258

Specialization & Scale

H10K, G09G, G06F
Top CPC Subclasses
38%
Top-3 CPC Share
n=1055
1
Practitioners
n=1055
1055.0
Apps / Practitioner
n=1055

Portfolio Summary

28
Total Pending OAs
18
Non-Final OAs
8
Final Rejections
2
Advisory / Quayle

Response Deadline Pressure

Based on the USPTO statutory response window for each pending office action. 8 of the docket's apps have a known mailing date; the rest are excluded from the tile counts.

2
Overdue
1
Due this week
2
Due this month
2
Due in next 60 days
1
Due later

Deadline Fire Line

Every pending office action with a known statutory deadline, placed on a days-until-due axis. Dots left of Today are overdue; the further right, the more runway. Cases that share a deadline window stack vertically. 8 of the docket's apps have a known mailing date.

-30dToday30d60d90d120d
Overdue (2)Due ≤ 7 days (1)Due ≤ 30 days (2)Due ≤ 60 days (2)Due later (1)

Case Difficulty Mix

Difficulty is derived from the rejection statutes on the most recent pending office action. §101-driven and multi-statute cases are graded Hard; §112-only and obviousness-type double-patenting cases are graded Easy; everything else is Medium. "Unknown" means we have not yet parsed a statute for that office action.

12
Hard (43%)
13
Medium (46%)
1
Easy (4%)
2
Unknown (7%)

Rejection Statute Mix

BucketCases
§101 + other3 (11%)
§103 only12 (43%)
§102 only1 (4%)
§112 only1 (4%)
Multi-statute (no §101)9 (32%)
No statute on record2 (7%)

Industry Mix

How the docket's pending cases split across USPTO tech-center bands.

0
Life Sciences
0% of docket
2
Information Tech
7% of docket
4
Communications
14% of docket
15
Semiconductors
54% of docket
1
Mechanical / Eng
4% of docket
6
Business / Other
21% of docket

Time-on-OA Estimate

Manual office-action response work runs about 10 hours per case. The time-saved bands below show what IP Author's prosecution pipeline typically delivers — a conservative 20% on the low end, 35% in the middle, 50% on the high end.

280 h
Manual time on pending OAs
56 h
Time saved (low, 20%)
98 h
Time saved (mid, 35%)
2.5 wks
FTE-weeks freed (mid)

Top Examiners on this docket

ExaminerApps on this docketAllow rateInterview lift
KHOO, STACY 2 81.6% +14.5%
EDUN, MUHAMMAD N 1 91.5% -4.9%
CERULLO, LILIANA P 1 74.7% +20.9%
SIDDIQUI, MD SAIFUL A 1 79.3% +15.8%
SUBEDI, DEEPROSE D 1 87.6% +13.4%
NGUYEN, VINH P 1 86.4% +16.1%
PRASAD, NANCY N 1 21.5% +18.2%
RAHMAN, MOHAMMAD A 1 86.9% +10.9%
KIM, TONG-HO 1 95.3% +0.6%
SUN, MICHAEL BRENNAN 1 100.0% +0.0%

Quick Wins (3)

Cases in front of an examiner with an allow rate of 80%+ where the difficulty is Easy or Medium. The top 3 ordered by deadline are shown.

App #TitleExaminerDue in
19323301 DISPLAY PANEL KHOO, STACY
19260692 DISPLAY APPARATUS SUBEDI, DEEPROSE D
18729123 LIGHT EMITTING DEVICE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS RAHMAN, MOHAMMAD A

Hard Cases (12)

Multi-statute / §101-driven matters, or cases in front of an examiner with an allow rate under 30%. The top 8 ordered by deadline are shown.

App #TitleExaminerDue in
18264063 DISPLAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS SENGDARA, VONGSAVANH 28d overdue
17825235 METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR DEVICE SIMULATION DRAPEAU, SIMEON PAUL 17d overdue
17828462 METHOD OF FORMING A SEMICONDUCTOR STRUCTURE INCLUDING FORMING GATE OXIDE SURROUNDING GATE ELECTRODE IN A THROUGH HOLE MAI, ANH D 14d
18261688 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS NADAV, ORI 84d
18697191 Untitled CERULLO, LILIANA P
19037123 PIXEL DRIVING CIRCUIT, DISPLAY PANEL, METHOD OF DRIVING DISPLAY PANEL KHOO, STACY
18930344 COMPUTER-IMPLEMENTED METHOD, APPARATUS FOR MANAGING PRODUCTION OF ONE OR MORE PRODUCTS, AND COMPUTER-PROGRAM PRODUCT PRASAD, NANCY N
18747462 SEMICONDUCTOR PACKAGING STRUCTURE AND METHOD FOR FORMING THE SAME KIM, TONG-HO

Interview Candidates (8)

Cases in front of an examiner whose interview lift is 10 percentage points or more — i.e. interviewed cases historically resolve more favorably than non-interviewed ones. The top 8 ordered by deadline are shown.

App #TitleExaminerDue in
18697191 Untitled CERULLO, LILIANA P
19358842 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS SIDDIQUI, MD SAIFUL A
19323301 DISPLAY PANEL KHOO, STACY
19260692 DISPLAY APPARATUS SUBEDI, DEEPROSE D
19037123 PIXEL DRIVING CIRCUIT, DISPLAY PANEL, METHOD OF DRIVING DISPLAY PANEL KHOO, STACY
19007792 DISPLAY PANEL, DISPLAY APPARATUS, AND METHOD OF DETECTING CRACK IN DISPLAY PANEL NGUYEN, VINH P
18930344 COMPUTER-IMPLEMENTED METHOD, APPARATUS FOR MANAGING PRODUCTION OF ONE OR MORE PRODUCTS, AND COMPUTER-PROGRAM PRODUCT PRASAD, NANCY N
18729123 LIGHT EMITTING DEVICE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS RAHMAN, MOHAMMAD A

Client Portfolio (5 clients)

Top Art Units

Art UnitApps
28933
28973
26242
28922
28182
26221
26261
36241
28991
28111

Pending Office Actions

App #TitleClientExaminerArt UnitStatutesStatusDue inAIFiled
19357645 Untitled BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. EDUN, MUHAMMAD N Other Non-Final OA Pending
18697191 Untitled BEIJING BOE TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT CO., LTD. CERULLO, LILIANA P 2622 §102§103 Non-Final OA Pending
19358842 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. SIDDIQUI, MD SAIFUL A 2626 §103Other Non-Final OA Pending Oct 15, 2025
19323301 DISPLAY PANEL BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. KHOO, STACY 2624 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Sep 09, 2025
19260692 DISPLAY APPARATUS BEIJING BOE TECHNOLOGY DEVELOPMENT CO., LTD. SUBEDI, DEEPROSE D §103Other Non-Final OA Pending Jul 07, 2025
19037123 PIXEL DRIVING CIRCUIT, DISPLAY PANEL, METHOD OF DRIVING DISPLAY PANEL BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. KHOO, STACY 2624 §102§103§112Other Final Rejection Pending Jan 25, 2025
19007792 DISPLAY PANEL, DISPLAY APPARATUS, AND METHOD OF DETECTING CRACK IN DISPLAY PANEL BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. NGUYEN, VINH P Other Non-Final OA Pending Jan 02, 2025
18930344 COMPUTER-IMPLEMENTED METHOD, APPARATUS FOR MANAGING PRODUCTION OF ONE OR MORE PRODUCTS, AND COMPUTER-PROGRAM PRODUCT BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. PRASAD, NANCY N 3624 §101§103§112 Final Rejection Pending Oct 29, 2024
18729123 LIGHT EMITTING DEVICE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. RAHMAN, MOHAMMAD A §103 Non-Final OA Pending Jul 15, 2024
18747462 SEMICONDUCTOR PACKAGING STRUCTURE AND METHOD FOR FORMING THE SAME Cxmt Corporation KIM, TONG-HO §102§103 Non-Final OA Pending Jun 19, 2024
18690437 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. SUN, MICHAEL BRENNAN 2892 §102§103§112 Non-Final OA Pending Mar 08, 2024
18690592 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. QUINTO, KEVIN V 2893 §102§103 Non-Final OA Pending Mar 08, 2024
18690054 DISPLAY APPARATUS AND METHOD OF FABRICATING DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. HO, TU TU V 2818 §102 Non-Final OA Pending Mar 07, 2024
18689331 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. KIM, SU C 2899 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Mar 05, 2024
18293908 COMPUTER-IMPLEMENTED METHOD, APPARATUS, COMPUTER-PROGRAM PRODUCT BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. HOANG, AMY P §103 Non-Final OA Pending Jan 31, 2024
18264484 DISPLAY PANEL AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. MALSAWMA, LALRINFAMKIM HMAR 2892 §102§112 Final Rejection Pending Aug 07, 2023
18264063 DISPLAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. SENGDARA, VONGSAVANH 2893 §102§103§112 Final Rejection 28d overdue Pending Aug 02, 2023
18261688 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. NADAV, ORI 2811 §102§103 Final Rejection 84d Pending Jul 17, 2023
18257601 LENS ASSEMBLY AND ELECTRONIC DEVICE BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. EDENFIELD, KUEI-JEN L 2872 §103 Non-Final OA 5d Pending Jun 15, 2023
17040506 A METHOD FOR MANUFACTURING A WAFER HAVING CRACK-STOPPING THROUGH-SILICON-VIAS, A WAFER HAVING CRACK-STOPPING THROUGH-SILICON-VIAS, AND A SEMICONDUCTOR DEVICE Changxin Memory Technologies, Inc. SIPLING, KENNETH MARK 2818 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Mar 27, 2023
18040775 DISPLAY PANEL AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. BLACKWELL, ASHLEY NICOLE 2897 §103 Non-Final OA 34d Pending Feb 06, 2023
17907503 METHOD OF GENERATING NEGATIVE SAMPLE SET FOR PREDICTING MACROMOLECULE-MACROMOLECULE INTERACTION, METHOD OF PREDICTING MACROMOLECULE-MACROMOLECULE INTERACTION, METHOD OF TRAINING MODEL, AND NEURAL NETWORK MODEL FOR PREDICTING MACROMOLECULE-MACROMOLECULE INTERACTION BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. SMITH, JENNIFER JOY 2124 §101§103 Non-Final OA Pending Jan 31, 2023
18152438 DISPLAY PANEL BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. AUTORE JR, MARIO ANDRES 2897 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Jan 10, 2023
18149210 PATTERNING METHOD AND METHOD OF MANUFACTURING SEMICONDUCTOR STRUCTURE Changxin Memory Technologies, Inc. PARENDO, KEVIN A 2896 §112 Final Rejection 15d Pending Jan 03, 2023
17996382 ARRAY SUBSTRATE AND DISPLAY APPARATUS BOE TECHNOLOGY GROUP CO., LTD. ABEL, GARY ROBERT 2800 §103 Non-Final OA Pending Oct 17, 2022
17933940 SEMICONDJUCTOR STRUCTURE WITHBITLINEPOSITIONEDABOVE TRANSISTOR ANT) FORMING METHOD THEREOF Changxin Memory Technologies, Inc. ZHU, SHENG-BAI 2897 §103 Final Rejection 41d Pending Sep 21, 2022
17828462 METHOD OF FORMING A SEMICONDUCTOR STRUCTURE INCLUDING FORMING GATE OXIDE SURROUNDING GATE ELECTRODE IN A THROUGH HOLE BEIJING SUPERSTRING ACADEMY OF MEMORY TECHNOLOGY MAI, ANH D 2893 §102§112 Final Rejection 14d Pending May 31, 2022
17825235 METHOD AND APPARATUS FOR DEVICE SIMULATION Changxin Memory Technologies, Inc. DRAPEAU, SIMEON PAUL 2188 §101§103§112 Non-Final OA 17d overdue Pending May 26, 2022

Managing Intellectual Valley Law, P.C.'s Patent Prosecution?

IP Author helps law firms respond to office actions faster with AI-generated responses, examiner analytics, and prosecution intelligence.

Start Free Trial

Sign in with your work email

Enter your email to receive a magic link. No password needed.

Personal email addresses (Gmail, Yahoo, etc.) are not accepted.

Free tier: 3 strategy analyses per month